Heard. The learned Additional State Public Prosecutor
is directed to take notice. At the stage of admission, the
matter is heard on merits.
2. This petition is filed seeking to quash the
proceeding in C.C.No.1387/2013 pending on the file of Prl.
Civil Judge & JMFC, Bagalkot.
3. On careful perusal of the petition averments as
well as after hearing the learned counsel for the petitioner,
the factual matrix disclose that the person by name Shrihari
Basavapattanna Ramakrishnarao submitted a F.I.R. to the
police making allegation against the petitioner herein that on
02.05.2013 at about 12.45 p.m. in the after noon, the
petitioner has used the Car bearing registration
No.KA-48/M-4053 for the purpose of election canvassing
without prior permission of the Election Commission, during
the Legislative Assembly election in Karnataka proposed to
be held on 05.05.2013. The police on being intercepted the
vehicle, seized the said vehicle and registered a case against
the petitioner for the offence punishable under Section 171H
of IPC and also under Section 133 of the Representation of
People Act, 1950.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner strenuously
contends that the above said two offences are non-cognizable
offences. Therefore, under Section 155(2) of Cr.P.C., the
police have no right or jurisdiction to investigate the matter,
without prior permission of the Magistrate, who has got
jurisdiction to try those offences. Therefore, the entire
charge sheet filed by the police is vitiated by serious
incurable defects and procedural irregularities.
5. On perusal of the FIR and also the charge sheet,
it does not disclose that there was any cognizable offence was
disclosed, so as to enable the police to investigate both the
cognizable and non- cognizable offences together and to file
the charge sheet. Therefore, he contends that the entire
charge sheet papers and on the basis of which the criminal
case is registered to be quashed.
6. The provision under Section 171H of IPC reads as
follows:
171H. Illegal payments in connection
with an election "Whoever without the general or
special authority in writing of candidate incurs or
authorises expenses on account of the holding of
any public meeting, or upon any advertisement,
circular or publication, or in any other way
whatsoever for the purpose of promoting or
procuring the election of such candidate, shall be
punished with fine which may extend to five
hundred rupees.
PROVIDED that if any person having incurred
any such expenses not exceeding the amount of
ten rupees without authority obtains within ten
days from the date on which such expenses were
incurred the approval in writing of the candidate,
he shall be deemed to have incurred such
expenses with the authority of the candidate."
7. The provision under Section 133 of
Representation of People Act 1951 reads as follows:
"If any person is guilty of any such corrupt
practice as is specified clause (5) of section 123 at
or in connection with an election, he shall be
punishable with imprisonment which may extend to
three months and with fine "
8. On perusal of the above said two provisions,
none of the offences are punishable with imprisonment for
more than 3 months Section 171H of Indian Penal Code is
punishable with a fine, which may extend to Rs.5,00/-,
wherein under Section 133 of Representation of People Act,
prescribes punishment which may extend to three months
and also with fine. Now coming to the provision of first
schedule of Cr.P.C., Section 171(H) of Indian Penal Code is
covered under the said provision which is declared as non-
cognizable and bailable offence, and triable by the Magistrate
of the First Class. Like wise classification of offence against
other laws in Cr.P.C., it also describes, if any offence under
any other law, if punishable for less than three years or with
fine which shall be considered as non-cognizable, bailable
and triable by the Magistrate of First Class.
9. On perusal of the above said provisions, it is
abundantly clear that the offence registered against the
petitioner under Section 171H of IPC and Section 133 of
Representation of the People Act, are non-cognizable in
nature. Now, coming to Section 155(2) of Cr.P.C. which
reads as follows:
"No police officer shall investigate a non-
cognizable case without the order of a Magistrate
having power to try such case or commit the case
for trial"
10. Particularly, Section 155(2) mandates the police
concerned that such police officer shall investigate the non-
cognizable offence with the permission of the Magistrate
only. This Section describes that no Police Officer shall
investigate a non-cognizable case without the order of the
Magistrate having power to try such case for trial.
11. The provision in sub Section (2) of Section 155 of
Cr.P.C., for asking permission of the Court to investigate a
non-cognizable offence is mandatory in nature. Therefore,
the investigation of non-cognizable offence by the police
without prior permission of the competent Magistrate is
illegal. Even mere accepting the charge sheet by the
Magistrate and taking the cognizance of the offence does not
validate the proceeding. Even subsequent permission by the
Magistrate also cannot cure the illegality. As could be seen
from Section 460 of Cr.P.C. these defects of non-taking
permission before investigating a non-cognizable offence is
also not curable. Though the charge sheet is filed after due
investigation without prior permission of the Court and that
the Magistrate has accepted the charge sheet and taken the
cognizance, it does not mean to show permission is granted
by the Magistrate to investigate such non-cognizable offence.
Therefore, investigation into the non-cognizable offence
without written order of the Magistrate is strictly contrary to
the provision of this Section.
12. In view of the above said facts and circumstances
of the case, the investigation done by the police in this case
is without jurisdiction and based on such invalid
investigation report, the cognizance taken by the learned
Magistrate is also illegal. Secondly, the entire proceeding
before the learned Magistrate is vitiated by serious incurable
defects.
Under the above circumstances, I have no hesitation to
quash the entire proceeding before the Magistrate. Hence,
the following order:
ORDER
The petition filed under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. is hereby
allowed.
Consequently, the proceedings pending before the
learned Prl. Civil Judge and JMFC, Bagalkot, in
C.C.No.1387/2013 and further proceedings in pursuance of
the same is hereby quashed.
SD/-
JUDGE
Rms