:
The question that arises for determination in this
revision petition is as to whether an unmarried
daughter, who is unable to maintain herself but has
attained the age of majority, is entitled to claim
maintenance in a proceeding under Section 125 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973?
2. This revision petition is by the wife, daughter and
minor son and is directed against the order dated
30.9.2010 passed by the Family Court at Mysore in
C.Mis.319/2008. By the impugned order, the Family
Court has dismissed an unmarried daughter's
(petitioner No.2 herein) claim for maintenance made
under Section 125 of the Cr.P.C on the sole ground
that she had attained the age of majority. The
reasoning of the Family Court reads as follows:
R.P.F.C. No.21 of 2011
"32. Since the 2nd petitioner is a major
unmarried daughter and she is not suffering from
any physical or mental deformity, her prayer for
maintenance in Section 125 Cr.P.C. cannot be
considered and her prayer is hereby rejected."
3. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted
that a daughter is entitled for maintenance from her
father till she gets married, notwithstanding her
attaining the age of majority. In support of his
submission, he relied on a judgment of the Supreme
Court in Noor Saba Khatoon vs. Mohd. Quasim [(1997)
6 SCC 233] and specifically referred to paras 10 & 11
thereof, which read as follows:
"10. Thus, both under the personal law
and the statutory law (Section 125 CrPC) the
obligation of a Muslim father, having sufficient
means, to maintain his minor children, unable to
maintain themselves, till they attain majority and
in case of females till they get married, is
absolute, notwithstanding the fact that the minor
children are living with the divorced wife.
11. Thus, our answer to the question posed
in the earlier part of the opinion is that the
R.P.F.C. No.21 of 2011
children of Muslim parents are entitled to claim
maintenance under Section 125 CrPC for the
period till they attain majority or are able to
maintain themselves, whichever is earlier and in
case of females, till they get married, and this
right is not restricted, affected or controlled by the
divorcee wife's right to claim maintenance for
maintaining the infant child/children in her
custody for a period of two years from the date of
birth of the child concerned under Section 3(1)(b)
of the 1986 Act. In other words Section 3(1)(b) of
the 1986 Act does not in any way affect the rights
of the minor children of divorced Muslim parents
to claim maintenance from their father under
Section 125 CrPC till they attain majority or are
able to maintain themselves, or in the case of
females, till they are married."
4. The following observations made by a three judge
Bench of the Supreme Court in Jagdish Jugtawat v.
Manju lata [(2002) 5 SCC 422] also needs to be noticed:
"3. In view of the finding recorded and the
observations made by the learned Single Judge of
the High Court, the only question that arises for
consideration is whether the order calls for
interference. A similar question came up for
consideration by this Court in the case of Noor Saba
R.P.F.C. No.21 of 2011
Khatoon v. Mohd. Quasim relating to the claim of a
Muslim divorced woman for maintenance from her
husband for herself and her minor children. This
Court while accepting the position that Section 125
CrPC does not fix liability of parents to maintain
children beyond attainment of majority, read the
said provision and Section 3(1)(b) of the Muslim
Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act together
and held that under the latter statutory provision
liability of providing maintenance extends beyond
attainment of majority of a dependent girl.
4. Applying the principle to the facts and
circumstances of the case in hand, it is manifest
that the right of a minor girl for maintenance from
parents after attaining majority till her marriage is
recognized in Section 20(3) of the Hindu Adoptions
and Maintenance Act. Therefore, no exception can
be taken to the judgment/order passed by the
learned Single judge for maintaining the order
passed by the Family Court which is based on a
combined reading of Section 125 CrPC and Section
20(3) of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act.
For the reasons aforestated we are of the view that
on facts and in the circumstances of the case no
interference with the impugned judgment/order of
the High Court is called for."
(Underlining supplied)
R.P.F.C. No.21 of 2011
In both Noor Saba Khatoon and Jagdish Jugtawat
referred to above, the Supreme Court has affirmed the
order of maintenance awarded in a proceeding under
Section 125 of the Cr.P.C to an unmarried daughter
who had attained the age of majority.
5. In the light of the three judge Bench judgment of
the Supreme Court in Jagdish Jugtawat, I am of
opinion that, an unmarried daughter who is unable to
maintain herself, is entitled to claim maintenance in a
proceeding under Section 125 of the Cr.P.C,
notwithstanding her attaining the age of majority. And
in such a proceeding, the Court has the power to grant
maintenance to her irrespective of whether she is a
Hindu or a Muslim or of any other religion, provided she
is otherwise entitled for maintenance under any other
law including personal law governing the parties. In
other words, if an applicant is not entitled for
maintenance under Section 125 of the Cr.P.C but is
entitled under any other law, the benefit of
R.P.F.C. No.21 of 2011
maintenance under the other law can be given to such
an applicant in a proceeding under Section 125 of the
Cr.P.C.
6. Coming to the facts of the present case,
admittedly petitioner No.2 is an unmarried major
daughter and is unable to maintain herself.
Accordingly, as held by the Supreme Court in Noor
Saba Khatoon, she is entitled for maintenance from her
father, as under Muslim Law, father's liability to
provide maintenance to his unmarried daughter
extends beyond her age of majority but till she gets
married. Therefore, she could be awarded maintenance
in a proceeding under Section 125 of the Cr.P.C. The
next question is as to the amount of maintenance to be
awarded? It is stated that the respondent-father owns
a workshop in Mysore city. This is evidenced by Ex.P9-
the licence issued to him by the Mysore city
Corporation to run a fabrication workshop. Petitioner
no.2 is about 25 years old and is residing in Mysore
R.P.F.C. No.21 of 2011
city. On the facts of the case, it is appropriate to
award a maintenance of Rs.4,000/- per month to
petitioner No.2. Accordingly, the respondent-father
shall pay the said maintenance to her from the date of
the petition in C.Mis.No.319/2008 till she gets
married. The revision petition stands disposed of in
the above terms in modification of the order impugned
herein.
Petition disposed of.
Sd/-
JUDGE
RV