All these writ petitions are disposed of by this
common order.
2. The facts will be with reference to W.P.
No.1066/2012. In all these writ petitions, the
substantial prayer made by the petitioners is regarding
the definition and scope as to be found in Master
Circular -- Prudential norms on Income Recognition,
Asset Classification and Provisioning pertaining to
Advances.
3. The facts germane for disposal of these writ
petitions can be summarised as follows:
The petitioner -- company took over the existing
sick industry. The petitioner - company borrowed
substantial amounts from respondent No.1 Banking
Institution and accordingly a loan was sanctioned and
so also the additional loan to the tune of Rs.33.32
crores. This took place on 10.11.2007. The petitioner
suffered serious setback due to power shortage in
Karnataka and global economic recession resulting in
financial crisis leading to default in payment of loan
interest and loan installments to respondent No.1 --
Bank. The 1st respondent declared the loan and
securities of the petitioners as Non-performing Assets'
and accordingly, the statutory notice was issued under
I t
Section 13(2) of the Securitization and Reconstruction of
Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest
Act, 2002(for short the Acti demanding the outstanding
amount due. The 1st respondent -- Bank took symbolic
possession of few securities on 25.11.2009. A second
notice also was issued in respect of the immovables. It
appears the action of the 1st respondent was subject
matter of an appeal before the Debts Recovery Tribunal
under the Act. Suffice it to note that the petitioners
were put on certain terms but however, according to the
respondents, the said terms were not complied. Hence,
the property was brought to sale and the 3rd respondent
was the auction purchaser. Since the sale notice was
issued in respect of sale of the immovable properties,
the present proceedings are initiated by the petitioners,
who are the Directors of the Company so as to obliviate
the entire proceedings initiated under the Securitization
Act on the ground that the very basis of issuance of
notice under Section 13(2) of the Act is not on the basis
IL
of the guidelines and directions of the Reserve Bank of
India.
4. Mr.Joseph, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners In all these writ petitions. submits that
having regard to the definition and the wording of
default, non-performing asset and the secured debt, the
notice issued under Section 13(2) of the Act is not in
confirmity with the definition of Non-performlng Asset.
He further submits that the guidelines of the Reserve
Bank of India have been omitted from the definition of
default, which is to be found at Section 2(1)Q) of the
Securitization Act. The 1st respondent - Bank could not
have relied upon the guidelines as stated in the notice
under Section 13(2) of the Act. He further submits that
the definition of sale' as defined under the guidelines Is
liable to struck down on the ground that it would run
contrary to the statute under Section 2(4) of the Act. He
would press Into service the decision of the Apex Court
In the case of Transcore Vs. Union cif India and
another reported in (2008)1 8CC 125 in support of his
contention. Indeed he would attack only a part of the
circular, which would define Non-performing Asset'. In
fact that is the prayer sought for by the petitioners in all
these writ petitions.
5. Mr,Vivek Holla, learned counsel appearing for
respondent No 1 -- Bank submits that it is wholly
unnecessary for this Court to go into the validity of the
sale inasmuch as the petitioner as well as respondent
No.1 are bound under a contract, which is in the nature
of Hypothecation. He further submits that
notwithstanding the fact that it is stated in the notice
issued under Section 13(2) of the Act that it has been
issued as per the direction and guidelines of the Reserve
Bank of India, that by itself, it cannot be said that the
notice issued under Section 13(2) of the Act is bad
inasmuch as it is not in confirmity with the definition of
Default' as well as the Non-performing Asset'. He
further submits that having regard to the outstanding
amount due to the Bank, it cannot be said that the
proceedings initiated under the Act are vitiated on the
1+
premise that the 1 st respondent has imported the
definition of Non-performing Asset' as defined under
the guidelines of the Reserve Bank of India.
6. Mr. Sudharsan Suresh. learned counsel
appearing for the Reserve Bank of India submits that
having regard to the specific wordings of Section 2( 1)(o)
of Securitisation Act defining the Non-performing
Asset', the guidelines, as stated in the Circular of RBI
are required to be looked into. He further submits that
the RBI does have power and jurisdiction to issue such
circulars regarding the advance made by the Financial
Institutions and the Bankers. He would press into
service the definition of Section 21 of the Banking
Regulation Act, which would deal with the powers of the
RBI to issue such Circulars and direction. He would
also further press into service certain observations
made by the Apex Court in the Transcore's Case(2008)
1 SCC 125
I3
7. Mr.SaJJan Poovaiah, learned counsel appearing
for the auction purchaser supports the entire
proceedings Initiated under the Securltization Act
culminating in the sale of the property. He submits that
the auction purchasers have purchased the property
pursuant to the auction, which has taken place on
23.08.2011 and has deposited the entire amount and
the possession is to be taken. But having regard to the
fact that certain movables were in the building, which
were required to be taken away before actual possession
could be handed over to the auction purchasers. At this
stage. the present proceedings are Initiated so as to stall
the proceedings Initiated under Section 13(2) of the Act.
8.Before appreciating the rival contentions of the
learned counsel appearing for the parties, it is
necessary to look into the provisions of the Act Itself.
Undisputedly, the Act was subject matter of a series of
judicial pronouncement before the Apex Court as well
as various other High Courts. Insofar as the
(6
constitutional validity of the Securitization Act is
concerned, that fell for consideration before the Apex
Court in the case of Martha Chemicals Limited and
others V/s. Union of India and others reported in
(2004)4 SCC 311. The Apex Court while dealing with
the Constitutional Validity of the Act has opined that
except for one provision i.e Section 17 of the Act, the
other provisions cannot be said to be ultravires. Indeed
having regard to the decision rendered by the Apex
Court in the Mardia Chemicals case the Central
Government has brought about certain amendment to
Section 13 as well as Section 17 of the Act. Indeed
pursuant to the said amendment, certain provisions are
made wherein the notice issued under Section 13(2) of
the Act a reply is solicited by the borrower and such
reply being given, it is reciuired to be considered by the
Financial Institution and is to be communicated to the
borrower. These proceedings would commence under
Section 13(4) of the Act. The Apex Court was of the view
that the appeal remedy cannot be an illusion but must
be a reality. Having regard to the said observation, the
Court fee has been substantially scaled down. But for
this modification the other provisions of the Act have
remained intact. Section 13(2) of the Securitization Act
is with reference to the enforcement of security interest,
which falls under Chapter III of the Act. Section 13 of
the Act would speak about enforcement of security
interest. We are concerned in the present proceedings
with Section 13(2) of the Act, which would read as
under:
"Where arty borrower, who is under a liability
to a secured creditor under a security
agreement, makes arty default in repayment
of secured debt or any instalment thereof
and his account in respect of such debt is
classfted by the secured creditor as non-
performing asset, then, the secured creditor
may require the borrower by notice in writing
to discharge in full his liabilities to the
secured creditor within sixty days from the
date of notice falling which the secured
creditor shall be entitled to exercise all or any
of the rights under sub-section (4)."
>1
9. Indeed an endeavour was made by Mr.Joseph,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner that the
words "default", "non-performing" assets are required
to be read in tandem and jointly and conjuntively. He
submits that it is not only the default but also coupled
with Non-Performing Asset!: a notice under this
provision can be issued and the borrower can be called
upon to pay the outstanding amount. A perusal of
Section 13(2) of the Act would indicate that the
borrower, who is under a liability to a secured creditor
under a security agreement or in the nature of a
Hypothecation. makes a default in repayment of the
secured debt and any installment there of and the
account in respect of such debt is classified by the
secured creditor as Non-Performing Asset! that would
fail to generate any income and then it can be classified
as an 'Non-Performing Asset!. In such cases, the
financial institution or the secured creditor is required
to issue a notice in writing calling upon the borrower to
L
discharge in full his liabilities within 60 days from the
date of notice.
10. The definition of default is to be found in
Section 2( 1)j) of the Act, which would read as under:
"default" means non-payment of any principal
debt or interest thereon or any other amount
payable by a borrower to any secured
creditor consequent upon which the account
of such borrower is classified as non-
performing asset in the books of account of
the secured creditor.
11. A perusal of the definition of non-performing
asset is to be found in Section 2(1)(o) of the Act, which
would read as under:
"non-performing asset" means an asset or
account of a borrower, which has been
classified by a bank or financial institution as
sub-standard, doubful or loss asset, --
(a) in case such bank or financial institution is
administered or regulated by any
authority or body established. constituted
or appointed by any law for the time being
in force, in accordance with the directions
or guidelines relating to assets
calssficadons issued by such authority or
body:
(b) in any other case, in accordance with the
directions or guidelines relating to assets
classications issued by the Reserve
Bank.
12. indeed Mr.Joseph is right in submitting that
the wordings Non-Performing Asset', in accordance
with the directions or guidelines relating to assets
classifications issued by the Reserve Bank has been
omitted by act 30 of 2004 with effect from 11.11.2004.
Nevertheless, sans the definition of Non-Performing
Asset as defined under the manual of the guidelines of
the Reserve Bank of India, one is required to refer to the
definition of Non-Performing Asset as defined under
the statute.
13."Default" would necessarily mean that non
payment of a particular debt or interest thereon
inasmuch as if the amount is due on a particular date
I
>1
and if the said amount is not paid by the appointed
date, the borrower is deemed to have committed default.
14. Insofar as what is a Non-Performing Asset is
concerned, it is an asset or account of a borrower,
which has been classified by the Financial Institution as
sub-standard, doubtful or loss asset. To classify the
unit or the account as a Non-Performing Asset' the
Financial Institutions are required to rely once again on
the directions and guidelines relating to classification
issued by the Reserve Bank. This is to be found in the
definition of Non-Performing Asset' at 2( 1)(o)(a) and (b)
of the Act. Indeed whether the guidelines and the
directions as issued by the RBI are required to be
followed or not, with reference to the definition of Non
Performing Asset', need not detain us for long
inasmuch the Apex Court in the case of Tanscore has
dealt extensively with the phraseolor Non-Performing
Asset' and as to what is sub-standard. The Apex Court
with reference to the Non-Performing Asset' has
observed thus:
"Non-Performing Assets(NPA) is a cost to the
economy. When the Act was enacted in the
year 2002, the NPA stood at Rs. 1 10 lac
cr0res. This was a drag on the economy.
Basically, NPA is an account which becomes
non-viable and non-performing in terms of the
guidelines given by the RBI. As stated in the
Statement of Objects and Reasons, NPA
arises on account of mis-match between asset
and liability: The NPA account is an asset in
the hands of the Bank or Fl. It represents' an
amount receivable and realizable by the
banks or FIs. In that sense, it is an asset in
the hands Of the secured creditor. Therefore,
the NPA Act, 2002 was primarily enacted to
reduce the non-performing assets by adopting
measures not only for recovery but also for
reconstruction. Therefore, the Act provides for
setting up of asset reconstruction companies,
pcial purpose vehicles, asset management
companies etc. which are empowered to take
possession of secured assets of the borrower
including the the right to transfer bLj wati of
lease, assignment or sale."
15. It is to be noticed that the Non-Performing
Asset' proceeds on the premise that the liability of the
/f
debtor to pay has crystallized and the debt became due
since the asset of the borrower has become sub
standard and Non-Performing Asset'. Indeed the Act
has been enacted so as to regulate securitization and to
regulate reconstruction of financial assets for security
interest and for matters connected therewith. Indeed the
definition of Non-Performing Asset' as defined under
Section 2(1)(o) fell for consideration in the said decision
and the Apex Court has observed thus:
"Section 2(o) defines non-performing asset' to
mean an asset or account of a borrower
which has been classified by a bank or Fl as
sub-standard, doubtful or loss asset.'
16. It is only when these assets in the hands of
the Bank are doubtful or loss assets become classified
as a Non-Performing Asset' and it is only then, a NPA
comes into operation.
17. By a reading of Section 13(2) of the Act, it is
clear that the said sub-section proceeds on the basis
that the borrower is already under a liability and further
that his account In the books of the Bank are classified
as doubtful or loss assets and that both these
conditions are satisfied. Section 13(2) of the Act
proceeds on the basis that the debt has become due. It
proceeds on the basis that the account in the Bank is a
'Non-Performing Asset'. Hence, there is no scope for
any dispute regarding liability. Undoubtedly, there is a
difference between accrual of liabifity and liquidation of
liability. Indeed there is no inherent or Implied
inconsistency between these two remedies under two
different enactments. Indeed this is with reference to
the recovery of the amount before the Debt Recovery
Thbunal and the Securitization Act. The Apex Court In
the Tronscore's case has observed thus:
"The heart of the matter is that the NPA Act
proceeds on the basis that an Interest In the
asset pledged or mortgaged with the bank or
FT Is created Infavour of the bank/Fl; that the
borrower has become a debtor, his liability
has crystalllsed and that his account with the
hank/Fl (which is an asset with the hank/Fl
has become sub-standard.
Value of an asset in an inflationary
economy is discounted by "time" factor. A
right created in favour of the bank/Fl involves
corresponding obligation on the part of the
borrower to see that the value of the security
does not depreciate with the passage of time
which occurs due to his failure to repay the
loan in time."
18. The very object of Section 13 of the Act is
recovery by non-adjudicatory process. The secured
asset under the NPA is an asset, which is created by
the borrower in favour of the financial institution and
on that alone the NPA secure interest on non-
adjudicatory process. Section 13(2) of the Act proceeds
on the basis of Security Interest for the Bank/Financial
Institution expeditiously without intervention that the
liability of the borrower have fallen for repayment and
the amount of the borrower in the books of the Bank
has become non-performing. Having regard to the fact
that the Apex Court in Transcore's case substantially
answers the contention of the learned counsel for the
petitioner. I am of the view that it cannot be said that
the definition as stated or definition regarding Non
Performing Asset' of sub-standard is sought to be
imported in the notice issued under Section 13(2) of the
Act. The notice issued by the 1st respondent to the
borrowers, a copy of which is produced at Annexure A'
would read as under:
"The first of you have defaulted in the
payment of irtstallments/principal/ interest
and your account has been classfied as out
of order for the various reasons mentioned in
our letter dated 15.04.2009 in response to
your letter dated 25.03.2009 and hence the
balance due from the first qf your which is a
secured debt has been classified as a Won
Performing Asset' with effect from
31/03/2009 in accordance with the
directions and guidelines of the Reserve Bank
of India.'
The usage of the words, directions and guidelines
of the Reserve Bank of India in the said notice is sought
to be pressed into service on the premise that the
guidelines and the directions as stated in the RBI has
been imported in the said notice. Assuming that it is
so, we are required to see as to what is to be classified
as a Non-Performing Asset. Non-Performing Asset in
generic terms would be an asset which certainly would
not generate any income and it has become defunct and
the unit is not at all viable, If these tests are satisfied, I
am of the view that the notice, which is issued under
Section 13(2) of the Act cannot be said to be invalid or
one without jurisdiction.
19. The contention regarding the Reserve Bank of
India having the power and jurisdiction to issue such
Circulars, it is to be noticed that the power to issue
such circular is derived from provisions of the Banking
Regulation Act. Section 21 of the Banking Regulation
Act would deal with the power of the Reserve Bank to
control advances by Banking Companies. Indeed all
Financial Institutions are governed by the guidelines
and the directions, which are issued by the RBI. Indeed
Sub-Section (2) of Section 21 would take into its core,
)727
various aspects of the directions, which are required to
be issued by the Reserve Bank of India to the Baikin
Companies either generally or to any Banking company
or Group of Banking Companies in particular with
reference to which advance may be made or may not be
made, margins to be maintained in respect of secured
advances, the maximum amount of advances or other
financial accommodation which, having regard to the
paid-up capital, reserves etc. It can also be traced to
section 35a of act which deals with the power of RBI to
give directions and also Section 36 with reference to the
other powers and functions of the Reserve Bank.
20. It is no doubt true a contention is sought to be
raised before me that the guidelines, which are issued
have been formulated without application of mind. I am
of the view that a perusal of the said guidelines does not
indicate that there is no application of mind inasmuch
as these guidelines are in force for quite some time.
I L--
/
21. This takes us to the contention raised by
Mr.Vivek Holla, learned counsel appearing for
respondent No. 1 as to whether indeed this Court is
required to go into the said question having regard to
the contract entered into between the petitioner and
respondent No. 1. Indeed the edifies with respect to the
advancement of the loan is based on a contract, which
is mutually signed by the finance institution as well as
the borrower. What is certainly sought to be enforced
by the financial institution are the terms of the contract
and one of the terms of the Hypothecation deed, which
is made available along with the statement of objections.
The said deed would deal with taking over the
possession of the assets, if there is a default committed
by the borrower. The said document is styled as a
General Hypothecation agreement. Clause 26 would
deal with enforcement. It would read as under:
"26) ENFORcEMENT:
That in default in repaying loan amount
and/or breach of terms and conditions of the
Agreement, the Bank and its officers and
agents shall be entitled at any time as it its
absolute owners and without notice to the
borrower but at the borrower's risk and
expenses and f so required as attorneys for
and in the name of the borrower, to enter and
remain at any place where the hypothecated
goods, machinery, all other movables etc., to
take possession of: recover and receive the
same and/or appoint any officers of the Bank
or any other person as receiver(s) of the
hypothecated goods. machinery, all other
movables etc., and/or sell by public auction
or private contract or otherwise dispose off or
deal with all or any part of the hypothecated
goods, machinery, all other movables etc.,
without interventions of the Court and to
enforce, realise, settle, compromise anddeal
with any of the rights aforesaid without being
bound to exercise any of these powers,
without being liable for loss in the exercise
thereof and without prejudice to the Bank
right and remedies of suit/invocations
provisions of SARFAESI Act or under any
other legislation(s) against the Borrower
and/or assets and to apply the net proceed
such sale in or towards liquidation of the
balance due to the Bank in protanto. The
3'
Borrower hereby agrees to accept Bank
accounts of sales realisation or recoveries as
conclusive evidence of amounts realised. The
Borrower further agrees undertakes and
confirms that Borrower is Personally liable to
make good of any shortfall in realisation of
dues. The Borrower also agrees that he shall
not object/contest to the deficiency in
sale/sale price or the time of the sale for any
whatsoever.
22. A perusal of the said clause would indicate
that if the borrower defaults in payment of his dues, it
is always open for the finance institution to invoke the
provisions of the Securitization Act or any other
enactment and can take possession of the property
without intervention of the Court. In the circumstances,
it is not open for the petitioners now to contend that
the definition of the Non-Performing Asset' as defined
under the guidelines of the RBI can be faulted. I am of
the view that it hardly makes any difference inasmuch
as the twin conditions, which are required to be
satisfied i.e., notice under Section 13(2) of the Act
required to be issued as with reference to the default
and the unit to which the finance assistance is given is
not viable, which could be termed as Non-Performing
Asset. Having said so, I am of the view that the
challenge to the master guidelines issued by the RBI
insofar as declaring the amount of the Non-Performing
Asset' does not warrant any interference.
23. Indeed it is also submitted by the finance
institution as well as the auction purchaser that at no
point of time the petitioners have made any serious
effort in discharging their obligations. Be that as it
may, the challenge to the present writ petition is
confined only to the Master Circular/guidelines issued
by the RBI nothing more and nothing less. If the
petitioner has any other remedy available to him, it is
open for him to pursue the said remedy.
24. Insofar as the other companion writ petitions
are concerned, the substantive relief sought by the
petitioners is one and the same i.e., the Master Circular
guidelines Issued by the RB!. Having regard to what Is
stated in the preceding paragraphs. I am of the view
that the challenge to the said Circular In the companion
writ petitions also does not survive for consideration.
But however, if the petitioners In those writ petitions
propose to settle the matter with the financial
Institutions, liberty Is reserved to the petitioners to do
so.
25. Insofar as W.P.Nos. 12085/2009, 7248/2009,
& 7249/2009 are concerned, Mr.Joseph, learned
counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that he
does not press the other reliefs, which are sought for by
the petitioners inasmuch as one of the orders cannot be
questioned in this writ petition inasmuch as It is
required to be questioned in Chennai. Mr.Joseph,
further submits that the petitioners are in
correspondence with the financial institution for
restructuring of the loan. If it is permissible, the
financial institution shall consider the request of the
petitioners. No other contentions are urged.
26. HavIng said so, I am of the view that the
challenge to the Circular stands rejected.
It Is open for the petitioners to work out their
remedies with reference to the observations mad
e
during the course of this order.
AU linpleadlng applications stand disposed of.
Sd/it
3UDGE
Sn