Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts

    State Of Mysore v. Akkamma Nainan And Another

    Venkataswami, J.:— This reference under Section 438 of Criminal Procedure Code is by the Sessions Judge, Dharwar. By an order made in Criminal Revision Petition No. 56/72, he has recommended to this court that an order made by the J.M.F.C Dharwar in Misc. Application No. 83/72 be quashed. The said application had been made by the Complainant in C.C No. 1571/71 requesting for the restoration of the complaint after setting aside the order of dismissal for default and acquitting the accused.

    The complaint was one under Section 323 I.P.C and was triable by following the procedure prescribed under Chapter 20 of Cr. P.C relating to the trial of summons cases. It would appear that on 18th January, 1972, when the case was called on for hearing, the complainant was absent. The learned Magistrate thereupon kept by the file and called the case later at about 1.20 P.M Finding that the complainant still absent, he made an order acquitting the accused. Nearly a month thereafter on 19th February, 1972 the complainant presented the Mice. Application No. 83/72 requesting for the revival of the complaint. In the said application he tried to show cause for his absence on the previous date of hearing. The learned Magistrate after hearing both the parties restored the complaint, after setting aside the order of acquittal. Aggrieved by this order the accused preferred a Criminal Revision Application No. 56/72 before the learned Sessions Judge, Dharwar. The learned Judge came to the conclusion that the order of the learned Magistrate was clearly without jurisdiction, in that he had no power to set aside the order of acquittal. He thereupon made the present reference to this court.

    It is clear from the record that the order dismissing complaint and acquitting the accused had been made purs to the provisions of Section 247 Cr. P. Code occurring in ??? 20 thereof, which deals with the procedure to be followed by Magistrate in trial of summons cases. That the learned Magistrate had no such power would be clear from the enunciation this court in Ranga Setty v. Kunna Setty(1) passage reads thus:—

    “We would, however, like to add that the discretion whether adjourn of not under Section 247 of the Code of Criminal proceedings has to be exercised with great care and caution. The statute itself tains the reason why such care should be exercised. In the first ??? the order is passed in the absence of a person who is vitally affect it; secondly, the consequences of the order are serious and ??? order is made, it is no longer in the power of the Magistrate to ??? the mischief even if he subsequently discovers that the complainant very good reasons for his absence. The order being one of ??? the complainant is prevented from taking fresh proceedings in ??? the offence complained of by him. Ordinarily, a first party in proceedings may be expected to be careful and not negligent of ??? interest. The section no doubt uses the words ‘shall acquit’. But compulsion arises after the Magistrate has exercised his discrete come to the conclusion that there are no valid grounds for ??? the case. This further emphasises the need for exercising great and examining the position very carefully before Magistrates ??? acquit the accused in private complaints under the provisions of 247 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.”

    In the light of the above enunciation, the reference by the learned Sessions Judge must be accepted. The made by the J.M.F.C, Dharwar, in Misc. Application No. ??? is hereby quashed. It follows therefore that the earlier of acquittal made in C.C No. 1571 of 1971 stands.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Mysore v. Akkamma Nainan And Another
    (Mar 27, 1973)