ORAL:
Father of Mohd Akhter Naik (to be referred as detenue)
through the instant petition seeks quashment of the detention order
No. DMR/PSA/07/03/265-71 dated 09.07.2007 passed by District
Magistrate, Ramban (respondent No.2) whereby detaining his son
under Section 8 of the J&K Public Safety Act 1978 (for short the
Act).
Admitted position is that when the detenue was detained
under the Act on 09.07.2007, he was already in judicial confinement
in case F.I.R. No. 44/2007 registered at Police Station Banihal under
Sections 120-B/ 121-A RPC read with Sections 13 & 20 of the
Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, in which he was arrested on
12.04.2007. Other admitted position is that his co-accused namely
Farooq Ahmed Wani, who was also booked with him in the said
F.I.R. and was subsequently detained under the Act on 03.08.2007,
had challenged his detention order which stands quashed vide
judgment dated 05.03.2008 (Annexure-C).
Pursuant to notice, respondents had put in appearance but till
date no reply has been filed despite many opportunities including
the last one being granted. The right is, thus, closed, as such like
petitions should be decided at the earliest. However, Mr. Gupta has
shown me the dossier of the detenue during the course of
arguments.
Heard both the sides and record also perused.
Mr. Bali assails the impugned order of detention primarily on
the following grounds:-
(i) There were no compelling circumstances with the
District Magistrate, Ramban, for passing the
detention order; and
(ii) The detention order otherwise lacks application of
mind.
Dwelling upon his arguments, Mr. Bali submits that perusal of
grounds of detention reflects the activities of the detenue relating to
case F.I.R. No. 44/2007 registered at Police Station Banihal only and
nothing beyond that. In the said case, he was formally arrested on
12.04.2007 and sent to judicial custody. There was no extra
material supplied to respondent No.2 to come to the conclusion that
after he being detained in a substantive offence, was still indulging
in the nefarious activities prejudicial to the security of the State.
According to the learned counsel, the detenue was in custody as an
undertrial prisoner and had no even applied for bail. Therefore,
there could not be any apprehension in the mind of respondent No.2
that in the event of he being released on bail, he would indulge in
such like activities. Therefore, there were no compelling
circumstances against the detenue for passing the impugned order
of detention.
Mr. Bali then submits that not only there is aforesaid flaw in
the order of detention, it lacks complete application of mind by the
District Magistrate, Ramban, as he has just dittoed the dossier
prepared by the police without even ascertaining the true facts. He
submits that the detenue is in custody since 09.07.2007, the date of
execution of the detention order, and by now he has undergone more
than 19 months out of the total detaining period of 24 months. This
all has curtailed his constitutional liberty.
Mr. Bali lastly submits that factum of quashment of the
separate detention order of his co-accused booked in the same case
(F.I.R. No.44/2007) may also be considered in favour of the detenue.
In support of his contentions, Mr. Bali has relied upon the
following judgments:-
1. Amritlal and others v. Union Govt. through
Secy., Ministry of Finance and others (2001) 1
Supreme Court Cases 341;
2. Mohammad Yousaf Dar v. State and others
(2003) 1 S.L.J. 144 (J&K High Court); and
3. Mohammad Maqbool Beigh v. State of J&K and
others (2007) 1 S.L.J. 89 (J&K High Court).
Mr. Gupta repudiates the contentions raised by Mr. Bali on
the ground that quashment of the detention order of co-accused of
the detenue would have no bearing upon the decision of this petition
as facts of that case are entirely different. He then submits that may
be no explanation is given by the detaining authority for passing the
impugned order after three months of the arrest of the detenue in
F.I.R. No. 44/2007, but that itself would not make any difference for
the reason that the grounds of detention reflect the activities of the
detenue which can comfortably be said to be prejudicial to the
security of the State and, therefore, apparently there is no fault with
the impugned order of detention. He then submits that ordinarily
this Court should not sit in appeal over the detention order so as to
re-appreciate the matter which was made the basis of the subjective
satisfaction of the detaining authority. Therefore, the instant
petition has no merit and deserves to be dismissed.
After hearing respective contentions of the either side and
going through the record which includes the dossier of the detenue, I
am of the considered view that the detention order deserves to be
quashed as it lacks complete application of mind by the detaining
authority.
Conceded position before me is that when the order of
detention was passed on 09.07.2007, the detenue was already in
custody in F.I.R. No. 44/2007 since 12.04.2007. F.I.R. No. 44/2007
relates to substantive offences. It is also conceded that he had not
even applied for bail till then. The order of detention is passed after
few days less than three months of earlier arrest. Perusal of grounds
of detention, indicates that the basis for passing the detention order
is the involvement of the detenue for the substantive offences only.
Therefore, the detaining authority was under an obligation to explain
and disclose in the order of detention the reason of delay of about
three months in passing the order. In my view, there is no such
explanation put forth in this regard. It, on the face of it, is a serious
flaw, which speaks volume of non-application of mind by the
detaining authority and cannot be just ignored.
The matter does not rest here. Admittedly, the detenue had
not filed any application for his release from the jail, and, therefore,
it cannot be said that the detaining authority was satisfied on the
basis of the material available that there was likelihood of his being
released on bail. There is, otherwise, no reference with regard to
bail. In the absence of such satisfaction, detention order could not
be passed. In Amritlals case, relied upon by Mr. Bali, the Honble
Supreme Court while relying upon another judgment rendered in
Binod Singh v. District Magistrate, Dhanbad (1986) 4 SCC 416, has
quashed the detention order on the ground that if a person is in
custody and there is no eminent possibility of his release therefrom,
the power of detention should not ordinarily be exercised. In the
case on hand, as observed earlier (may be for the sake of repetition),
admittedly there is no reference in the grounds of detention about
the detenue being released from jail in near future. This vital
weakness is staring at the detention order.
In my view, the grounds of detention are verbatim copy of the
dossier supplied to the District Magistrate, Ramban, and he has not
considered any other material for his subjective satisfaction before
passing the impugned order. It is complete non-application of mind
on the part of District Magistrate, Ramban.
No doubt, while exercising powers of judicial review, this Court
should not ordinarily sit in appeal over the detention order so as to
re-appreciate the material, which is made the basis of subjective
satisfaction of the detaining authority. But at the same time the
Court cannot shut its eyes if it finds that there is complete nonapplication
of mind on the part of the detaining authority. Court
cannot be a silent spectator to the infringement of the constitutional
rights. Nobody can be allowed to treat them in a casual manner.
Subjective satisfaction does not mean that the District Magistrate is
supposed to ditto the dossier taking it as gospel truth. If the
detention order, on the face of it, is bad and reflects non-application
of mind, it would certainly fall within the scope of judicial review and
deserves to be quashed. The case on hand is of that nature.
I do not want to enter into a detailed discussion on any other
aspect of the present case as in my considered view the detention
order impugned herein is liable to be quashed simply on nonapplication
of mind by the District Magistrate (respondent No.2).
Resultantly, the instant petition is allowed and the detention
order No. DMR/PSA/07/03/265-71 dated 09.07.2007 impugned
herein, is, hereby quashed. The respondents are directed to release
the person of Mohd Akhter Naik S/o Sh. Abdul Rahim Naik R/o
Village Shagan, Tehsil & District Ramban, forthwith if not required
in any other case.
The detention record (Dossier of the detenue) has been
returned to Mr. Gupta.
( Virender Singh )
Judge
Jammu
18.11.2008
Narinder