Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 2 Rule 2
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order 2 Rule 2
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Deepak Jain (petitioner) filed Suit No. 12/1998 seeking a permanent prohibitory injunction against Jain Nagar Welfare Society (respondent). The primary relief sought in the first suit was to restrain the defendant and its agents from raising any construction at a site marked "Red" in the site plan and/or in front of the plot marked "A", and from interfering with the plaintiff's use of the road leading to his plot and his right of ingress and egress.

While the first suit was pending, the petitioner filed a subsequent suit claiming, inter alia, declarations that (a) the road marked "C" in the site plan is a public road and the plaintiff and his brothers have an absolute right to use it in common with other residents, and (b) that the wall marked "D" in the site plan belongs to the plaintiff and that he has the right to remove/demolish it; and seeking an injunction restraining interference with those rights.

The respondent objected to the maintainability of the second suit on the ground that it was barred by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). The trial Court (Learned 1st Additional District Judge, Jammu) framed an issue whether the suit was barred under Order 2 Rule 2 CPC and dismissed the subsequent suit on 05-02-2005, holding that the subject matter and cause of action were the same as the earlier suit and that the declaration relief in the subsequent suit could have been sought in the earlier suit. The petitioner challenged that order by filing the present revision petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the subsequent suit filed by the petitioner is barred by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  2. Whether the cause of action in the subsequent suit is separate and distinct from the cause of action in the earlier suit, such that the subsequent suit is maintainable despite overlapping reliefs.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The trial Court failed to distinguish the separate and distinct cause of action on which the subsequent suit was founded and thus erred in holding the subsequent suit not maintainable.
  • Learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon several authorities (Kunjan Nair Sivaraman Nair v. Narayanan Nair; Kewal Singh v. Lajwanti; Raman Ittiyathi v. Pappy Bhaskaran) to support the contention that the causes of action were distinct and the second suit was maintainable.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent argued that the second suit was barred by Order 2 Rule 2 CPC and relied upon authorities (Kamal Kishore Saboo v. N. Humayun Kamal Hassan Khan; Gajanan R. Salvi v. Satish Shankar Gupte & Ors; Kewal Singh v. Lajwanti) in support of the trial Court's dismissal of the subsequent suit.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kunjan Nair Sivaraman Nair v. Narayanan Nair Relied upon by the petitioner to contend that the subsequent suit was founded on a separate and distinct cause of action. The judgment was cited by petitioner; the court noted the reliance but primarily proceeded to analyze the plaints and the law relating to Order 2 Rule 2 CPC to reach its decision.
Kewal Singh v. Lajwanti Cited by both parties (petitioner and respondent) in arguments concerning the scope of Order 2 Rule 2 CPC and whether causes of action are distinct. The judgment was among those cited by counsel; the court treated it as one of several authorities referenced in submissions and evaluated the facts and legal principles independently; the court later observed some judgments cited by respondent were distinguishable.
Raman Ittiyathi v. Pappy Bhaskaran Relied upon by the petitioner in support of the contention that the subsequent suit raised a different cause of action. Cited by petitioner. The court considered the submission but based its conclusion on analysis of the plaints and governing principles of Order 2 Rule 2 CPC as discussed in the opinion.
Kamal Kishore Saboo v. N. Humayun Kamal Hassan Khan Relied upon by the respondent to support the trial Court's order that the subsequent suit was barred under Order 2 Rule 2 CPC. The court found the judgments relied upon by respondent, including this one, to be clearly distinguishable and not applicable to the facts of the present case.
Gajanan R. Salvi v. Satish Shankar Gupte & Ors Relied upon by the respondent in support of the trial Court's dismissal. The court held that this authority (cited by respondent) was distinguishable and did not apply to the facts at hand.
Mohd. Khalil Khan v. Mahbub Ali Mian ((1948) 75 Ind App 121) Used to appreciate the meaning of "cause of action" in the context of Order 2 Rule 2 CPC. The court expressly referred to this Privy Council decision to frame principles regarding what constitutes a cause of action for the purposes of Order 2 Rule 2 CPC and applied those principles in its analysis.
Moonshee Buzloor Ruheem v. Shumsoonnissa Begum ((1867) 11 Moo Ind App 551) Supports the test whether a claim in a new suit is founded on a cause of action distinct from the former suit. The court summarized and applied the test (cited from this authority) as part of the doctrinal framework for deciding whether the subsequent suit raised a distinct cause of action.
Read v. Brown ((1889) 22 QBD 128) Definition: cause of action means every fact necessary for the plaintiff to prove, if traversed, to support his right to judgment. The court reproduced and relied on this formulation when explaining how to determine whether causes of action are distinct under Order 2 Rule 2 CPC.
Brunsden v. Humphrey ((1884) 14 QBD 141) Principles: (a) if evidence to support two claims is different, causes of action are different; (b) causes may be the same if in substance identical. The court cited these principles as part of the controlling tests to determine whether the earlier and subsequent suits arose from the same cause of action.
Muss. Chand Kour v. Partap Singh ((1887-88) 15 Ind App 156 (PC)) Observation by Lord Watson that the cause of action refers to the medium upon which the plaintiff asks the court to arrive at a conclusion in his favour (in the context of the corresponding provision). The court cited this authority to emphasize that cause of action does not depend on the relief prayed for or the defence but on the factual foundation of the claim, and applied that understanding in the analysis.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the two plaints filed by the petitioner and proceeded to assess whether the subsequent suit was barred by Order 2 Rule 2 CPC. The analysis proceeded as follows:

  1. Nature of the first suit: The Court found that the first suit was founded on a cause of action arising from the threatened action of the respondent to raise an illegal construction on a public road (30' wide) immediately in front of the petitioner’s plot marked "A". The relief sought was confined to restraining that threatened construction and interference with use of the road and ingress/egress.
  2. Nature of the subsequent suit: The Court observed that the subsequent suit included a claim of absolute ownership over a brick wall marked "D" (lying between the petitioner’s 60' x 80' plot and an adjoining 48 kanals of land) and a right to remove/demolish the wall, together with a declaration about the public character of road "C". The first suit did not raise any dispute regarding ownership of the wall or a right to demolish it, nor was any injunctive relief sought in respect of that wall in the first suit.
  3. Distinctness of causes of action: Applying the legal tests summarized from Privy Council and other authorities (including Mohd. Khalil Khan; Moonshee Buzloor Ruheem; Read v. Brown; Brunsden v. Humphrey; Muss. Chand Kour), the Court concluded that the cause of action in the two suits were separate and different. The earlier suit related to the threatened obstruction by construction on the path in front of the petitioner’s plot; the subsequent suit related to ownership and the right to demolish a wall between plots — facts different from those forming the earlier suit’s foundation.
  4. Effect of overlap in reliefs: The Court noted that the mere inclusion, in the subsequent suit, of some reliefs that were earlier claimed did not render the entire suit unsustainable. Rather, where a relief is merely repeated from the earlier suit, that part may be barred by Order 2 Rule 2, but the remainder of the subsequent suit based on a distinct cause of action will not be barred.
  5. Application of Order 2 Rule 2 CPC: The Court explained the scope of Order 2 Rule 2 — it bars splitting of a single cause of action into multiple suits or omitting reliefs arising from the same cause of action, but does not require consolidation of separate and distinct causes of action into one suit. The Court reiterated that when different factual bases (and thus different evidence) are necessary to support claims, they constitute different causes of action and the bar does not apply.
  6. Disposition: On this analysis, the Court concluded that the trial Court was in error in dismissing the second suit in its entirety on the ground of Order 2 Rule 2 CPC; the trial Court had failed to take into account the distinct cause of action pleaded in the subsequent suit regarding ownership and removal of the wall marked "D".

Holding and Implications

Holding: Revision allowed and the order dated 05-02-2005 of the Learned 1st Additional District Judge, Jammu is set aside.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The trial Court's dismissal of the subsequent suit on the ground of Order 2 Rule 2 CPC was set aside and the trial Court was directed to deal with the suit in accordance with law.
  • The Court specifically held that the reliefs mentioned in paragraph No. 15 (ii) & (iii) of the plaintiff's subsequent suit (excluding the injunctive relief pertaining to the road marked "C") were not barred by Order 2 Rule 2 CPC and the suit could proceed for adjudication on those reliefs.
  • Parties through their counsel were directed to appear before the trial Court on 15th September, 2007.
  • The opinion does not articulate any broader or novel principle intended to operate as new precedent beyond applying established tests for "cause of action" under Order 2 Rule 2 CPC; the direct effect is that the petitioner’s subsequent suit may proceed on the distinct claims identified by the Court.

    Deepak Jain v. Jain Nagar Welfare Society

    P. Singh, J.

    1. Deepak Jain, petitioner had filed suit No. 12/1998 for permanent prohibitory injunction against Jain Nagar Welfare Society-respondent, seeking reliefs which read thus:

    1. That the defendant, its agents and servants and all members of the defendant's society be restrained from raising any construction at the site marked Red in the site plan and/or in front of the plot of land marked "A" in the site plan directly, indirectly or otherwise and/or to interfere with the right of the plaintiff to use road leading to his plot of land and/or to interfere with the plaintiff's right of ingress or outgress and be further restrained from creating any impediment/obstruction to the plaintiff right to use the said plot of land.

    2. It was during the pendency of this suit that he filed yet another suit seeking the following reliefs:

    1. It be declared that the road marked "C" in the site plan annexed to the plaint is a public road and the plaintiff along with his brothers has absolute right to use the said road in common with other residents of Jain Nagar.

    2. It be declared that wall marked "D" in the site plan belongs to the plaintiff and he is the owner of the said wall and has every right to remove/demolish the said wall as he may deem fit.

    3. By a permanent prohibitory injunction, the defendants, their agents and servants including office bearers be restrained from interfering in the use of the road marked "C" in the site plan and in the removal/demolition or construction of the wall marked "D" by the plaintiff.

    3. The subsequent suit of Deepak Jain was based on the grounds which for facility of reference are reproduced hereunder:

    1. That the plaintiff is the owner of a plot of land measuring 60' x 80' along with his brothers and adjacent to this plot, he and his brothers purchased 48 kanals of land under Survey Nos. 531 & 532.

    2. That there is a public road towards the west of plot measuring 60' x 80' which has been constructed by Jammu Municipality and is maintained by it and defendant wanted to raise construction on this road so a suit had been filed before this Court.

    3. That there is a brick wall in between plot measuring 60' x 80' and the chunk of 48 kanals of land which the plaintiff wanted to remove, but the defendant's society lodged a protest.

    4. Objection taken by the respondent that the second suit of Deepak Jain was hit by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure resulted in the framing of an issue as to whether the suit was barred under Order 2 Rule 2 CPC?

    5. Learned 1st Additional District Judge, Jammu dismissed the second suit holding that the subject matter of litigation and cause of action was same as that of the earlier suit. It further held that relief of declaration sought in the subsequent suit, was available to the plaintiff when he had filed the earlier suit. Having omitted to sue for the relief of declaration in the earlier suit, the second suit would be barred, ruled the trial Court.

    6. Mr. Deepak Jain, petitioner has assailed the order of the trial Court dated 05-02-2005 in this revision petition.

    7. Mr. R.P. Sharma, learned Counsel for the petitioner/plaintiff while relying upon Kunjan Nair Sivaraman Nair v. Narayanan Nair reported as , Kewal singh v. Lajwanti, reported as & Raman lttiyathi v. Pappy Bhaskaran, reported as , submitted that the trial Court had failed to distinguish the separate and distinct cause of action on which the subsequent suit had been founded and had thus fallen in error in holding the subsequent suit not maintainable.

    8. Mr. L.K. Sharma, learned Counsel for the respondent Society places reliance on Kamal Kishore Saboo v. N. Humayun Kamal Hassan Khan reported as , Gajanan R. Salvi v. Satish Shankar Gupte and Ors. reported as and Kewal Singh v. Lajwanti, reported as to support the order of the trial court.

    9. I have considered the submissions of learned Counsel for the parties and gone through the two plaints which Deepak Jain, petitioner had filed against the respondent Society.

    10. The first suit which had been filed by the plaintiff/petitioner before the trial Court was based on a cause of action which had arisen to him because of the threatened action of the respondent to raise illegal construction on a public road, 30' wide, right in front of the plaintiff's plot marked "A" in the site plan.

    11. The plaintiff had not raised any dispute in this suit regarding his ownership over the wall marked "D" in the site plan and his right to remove/demolish it. No injunctive relief too had been sought for by the petitioner against the respondent Society in respect of this wall.

    12. I, therefore, find, on facts that the learned trial Court had omitted to take notice of the case pleaded by the plaintiff in the subsequent suit regarding his absolute ownership over the wall shown at point "D" in the site plan and his right to demolish/remove it as and when he so wished.

    13. The cause of action in both the suits was thus separate and different, for in the earlier suit, the plaintiff had claimed his right to use the path which was existing in front of his plot whereas in the subsequent suit, claiming ownership over a brick wall existing between his plot measuring 60' x 80' and big chunk of land measuring 48 kanals of land which had been shown at point "D" in the site plan, he had claimed his right to demolish/remove it as and when he so wished and that the respondent had no right to interfere with this right of the plaintiff.

    14. Although in the subsequent suit, the plaintiff had included some of the reliefs which he had claimed in the earlier suit yet incorporation of such reliefs which had been claimed in the earlier suit, by way of additional relief, would not render whole of the suit unsustainable.

    15. All that could be said in such circumstances was that part of the relief which the plaintiff had claimed in the earlier suit and which had been repeated in the second suit, would be barred under Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure and not the whole suit as such.

    16. Law relating to the Bar enacted by the provisions of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure needs to be noticed at this stage.

    17. Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure does not require that when a transaction or right gives rise to several causes of action, they should all be combined in one suit. All what is prohibi ted by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure is that a cause of action cannot be split up to sue for one part in one suit and another part in another suit. When a cause of action gives rise only to one relief, the entire claim must be included in the suit, and, if it is not so done, the subsequent suit for the omitted or relinquished portion would be barred for ever. There may be cases in which same cause of action may give rise to several reliefs. In such cases also, all these reliefs are required to be claimed in the same suit, for omission to do so would attract the Bar of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, applicable. In such cases, the plaintiff may, however, obtain leave of the Court and reserve one or more reliefs for a separate suit.

    18. Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure would however have no application to cases where the plaintiff basis his suit on separate and distinct cause of action and chooses to relinquish one or the other of them. In such cases, it is always open to the plaintiff to file a fresh suit on the basis of a distinct cause of action which he may have so relinquished.

    19. It would be fruitful to refer to what was held in Mohd. Khalil Khan v. Mahbub Ali Mian (1948) 75 Ind App 121 by the Privy Council, to appreciate as to what would be meant by cause of action in the context of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    The principles laid down in the cases thus far discussed may be thus summarized; (1) the correct test in cases falling under Order 2 Rule 2 is "whether the claim in the new suit is, in fact, founded on a cause of action distinct from that which was the foundation for the former suit, (Moonshee Buzloor Ruheem v. Shumsoonnissa Begum (1867) 11 Moo Ind App 551 (605). (2) The cause of action means every fact which will be necessary for the plaintiff to prove, if traversed, in order to support his right to the judgment Read v. Brown (1889) 22 QBD 128, 131. (3) If the evidence to support the two claims is different then the causes of action are also different Brunsden v. Humphrey (1884) 14 QBD 141. (4) The causes of action in the two suits may be considered to be the same if in substance they are identical. Brunsden v. Humphrey. (5) The cause of action has no relation whatsoever to the defence that may be set up by the defendant, nor does it depend on the character of the relief prayed for by the plaintiff. It refers " to the media upon which the plaintiff asks the court to arrive at a conclusion in his favour." (Muss. Chand Kour v. Partap singh (1887-88) 15 Ind App 156 (PC)). (5) This observation was made by Lord Watson in a case under Section 43 of the Act of 1882 (corresponding to Order 2 Rule 2) where plaintiff made various claims in the same suit.

    20. In view of the above discussion and the law laid-down by the Privy Council in this respect, the order impugned in this revision petition cannot be upheld and needs to be set aside.

    21. Judgments cited by Mr. L.K. Sharma are clearly distinguishable and do not apply to the facts of the case in hand. For all what has been said above, I am of the view that the reliefs mentioned in paragraph No. 15 (ii) & (iii, barring the injunctive relief pertaining to road marked "C" in the site plan) of the plaintiff in the subsequent suit, were not barred by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure and. the suit could proceed for adjudicating plaintiff's suit on the aforesaid reliefs.

    22. This revision petition is, accordingly, allowed and Order dated 05-02-2005 of 1st Additional District Judge, Jammu is set aside. Learned 1st Additional District Judge, Jammu is directed to deal with the suit in accordance with law. Parties through their counsel are directed to appear before the trial Court on 15th of September, 2007.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Deepak Jain v. Jain Nagar Welfare Society
    (Aug 31, 2007)