AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Comprehensive Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff (Mohan Meakin Breweries Ltd.) filed a suit seeking, inter alia, to restrain the defendants (Kashmir Dreamland Distilleries) from infringing the plaintiff's copyright and from using the trade mark "MMB". As an ancillary relief the plaintiff sought an ad-interim injunction preventing the defendants from using the mark "M.B.B" on their whisky bottles pending final disposal of the suit. The plaintiffs produce bottles labelled "M.M.B" (used on one variety of their whisky) and the defendants produced bottles labelled "M.B.B". Exhibits included bottles of various sizes (750 ml, 375 ml and a quarter size).

During trial the plaintiffs obtained registration of the copyright "MMB Whisky". An issue on jurisdiction was framed on 31-10-1984. The court considered (i) whether it had jurisdiction to try the suit (in view of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 and the Copyright Act) and (ii) whether the plaintiff was entitled to ad-interim relief on the usual injunction criteria.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court had jurisdiction to try the suit given the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 (s.105) and the Copyright Act (s.62) and the definition of "District Court" under the Civil Procedure Code (1908).
  2. Whether the plaintiff had made out a prima facie case, balance of convenience and risk of irreparable injury entitling it to an ad-interim injunction restraining the defendants from using "M.B.B" or deceptively similar labels.
  3. Whether the defendants' label and mark constituted deceptive similarity/passing off (and infringement where relevant) such that purchasers of average intelligence or of imperfect recollection might be misled.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments (as presented by Mr. Chadda)

  • The defendants were contravening the Copyright Act and the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 by using a deceptively similar mark.
  • The defendants' mark "M.B.B" was similar to the plaintiffs' "M.M.B" and likely to deceive purchasers into believing the defendants' whisky was that of the plaintiff.
  • The labels, packing and overall get-up were so similar that they would cause confusion on first impression and to persons of imperfect recollection or average intelligence.
  • The defendants used "M.B.B" only to pass off their goods as those of the plaintiff, noting that the defendants' firm name is Kashmir Dreamland Distilleries (so use of "M.B.B" was assertedly senseless unless meant to deceive).
  • Evidence included physical bottles and labels of both parties (various sizes) demonstrating the alleged similarity.

Defendant's Arguments (as presented by Mr. Z. A. Shah)

  • There was no similarity between the two labels or the whiskies; the colour of the plaintiff's whisky was deeper while the defendant's was lighter.
  • The marks were distinct: the plaintiff's label had two "M"s and one "B" ("M.M.B"), while the defendant's had one "M" and two "B"s ("M.B.B").
  • A jurisdictional objection: the suit was not triable by the High Court and should have been brought before the District Court; additionally S.62 of the Copyright Act (as argued) was said to oust the High Court's jurisdiction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ruston and Hornby Ltd. v. Zamindara Engineering, AIR 1970 SC 1649 Distinction between infringement and passing off: where marks are identical the court need not enquire whether deception will result; where marks are similar, the test is likelihood of confusion, same as in passing off. The court applied this principle to hold that the same test of likelihood of confusion (as in passing off) applies to the present dispute where the marks are not identical but similar; the Court found deceptive similarity on that basis.
Saville Perfumery Ltd. v. June Perfect Ltd., (1941) 58 RPC 147 (Master of the Rolls) Where defendant's mark is identical with plaintiff's registered mark, inquiry into likelihood of deception is not required; where it is similar, the test is the same as for passing off. Used to support the proposition that similarity requires application of the passing off test; the court relied on this general principle in assessing deceptive similarity here.
Panipat Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. v. Mohan Meakin Breweries Ltd., 1978 (3) IPLR 53 (Punjab & Haryana High Court, Division Bench) In passing off the plaintiff need not prove actual deception; the court must consider whether overall visual and phonetic similarity is likely to deceive a man of imperfect recollection or average intelligence; temporary injunction principles follow from this appreciation. The court expressly stated it was in respectful agreement with this Division Bench decision and applied the described standard (average purchaser, imperfect recollection) to find that the defendants' labels were deceptively similar.
Single Bench, Allahabad High Court (reported in 1980 (4) IPLR 117) Authority where a learned single judge restrained a defendant from using a mark held to be deceptively similar to the plaintiff's mark. The court indicated agreement with that single-judge decision and treated it as supporting the grant of interim relief where deceptive similarity was shown.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court addressed jurisdiction first. It examined s.105 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958, which provides that suits relating to infringement, unregistered trade marks or passing off shall not be instituted in a court inferior to a District Court. The court observed that s.105 prevents filing in courts inferior to a District Court but does not bar filing in courts superior to a District Court. The court further explained that valuation for jurisdiction corresponds to valuation for court-fee and that where the suit valuation is Rs. 20,000 or more the High Court is the proper forum. Because the present suit was valued at more than Rs. 20,000 for jurisdiction and court-fee purposes, the suit could properly be presented in the High Court.

The court next considered the submission that s.62 of the Copyright Act ousted the High Court's jurisdiction. It concluded that "District Court" in s.62 must be read as defined in the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 — which includes courts that are principals of districts and also High Courts exercising original jurisdiction over districts — and therefore s.62 did not deprive the High Court of cognizance. Accordingly, the court held it had jurisdiction to try the suit.

Turning to the merits for interim relief, the court applied the established tripartite test for grant of interlocutory injunction: (i) prima facie case, (ii) balance of convenience, and (iii) irreparable injury if interim relief is refused. The court examined the labels and packaging exhibited in court and concluded that the labels used by the defendants and plaintiffs were so similar that a purchaser of average intelligence, or a person of imperfect recollection, was likely to mistake the defendant's product for the plaintiff's.

The court relied on the principles articulated in Ruston and Hornby Ltd. v. Zamindara Engineering and Saville Perfumery (as explained by the Supreme Court) that where an alleged infringement uses a mark similar to the registered one, the test of likelihood of confusion is the same as in passing off. The court also expressly relied on and agreed with the Division Bench decision in Panipat Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. v. Mohan Meakin Breweries Ltd. and a single-judge decision of the Allahabad High Court (1980 (4) IPLR 117), both of which endorsed assessment from the perspective of the ordinary purchaser and recognised that actual deception need not be proved to grant relief.

Applying these principles to the facts, the court found a prima facie case of deceptive similarity and passing off. It further concluded the plaintiff would suffer injury that could not be adequately quantified if the deceptive conduct were not restrained; therefore the balance of convenience lay in favour of the plaintiff.

The court made clear that its observations were provisional and "without prejudice to the rights of the defendants" and that any expression in the judgment would not be taken as a final determination on the merits of the suit.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court's primary operative direction is stated as follows:

AD-INTERIM INJUNCTION GRANTED IN FAVOUR OF THE PLAINTIFF

Specific orders and direct consequences:

  • The defendants are restrained from using the label "MBB WHISKY" or any other label that has deceptive similarity with the label used by the plaintiff ("MMB WHISKY").
  • The defendants shall not sell any whisky under such a label in the market; any whisky sold in the meantime under the offending label shall be withdrawn by the defendants.
  • The injunction is operative only until the disposal of the suit (i.e., it is an interim measure pending final determination).
  • The preliminary issue (jurisdiction) was decided against the defendants and in favour of the plaintiffs.

Broader implications: The court did not purport to lay down a new precedent; it applied existing principles (as cited) to the present facts. The opinion expressly states that the observations are without prejudice to the defendants' rights and shall not be construed as the court's final view on the merits. Thus the decision's immediate effect is to protect the plaintiff from the alleged deceptive use of labels until the suit is finally decided; no broader legal pronouncement beyond application of cited authorities and established tests was announced.

Order accordingly.

    Mohan Meakin Ltd. v. Kashmir Dreamland Distilleries

    1. Anciliary to the suit filed by the plaintiff restraining the defendants from infringing the plaintiff-company's copyright and from using their Trade mark ‘MMB’ and for some other reliefs, plaintiff has prayed for ad-interim injunction against the defendants to the effect that pending disposal of this suit, the defendants should not use the Trade mark ‘M.B.B’ on their whisky bottles of various sizes. The plaintiffs are using the trade mark ‘M.M.B’ on one of the varieties of their whisky bottles. The defendants have with a view to deceive the public labelled their whisky bottles with the trade mark ‘M.B.B’ and the purchasers are made to believe that the whisky bottles sold by the defendants are the same which are manufactured by the plaintiff under the trade mark ‘M.M.B’. As an exhibit plaintiffs have produced their own whisky bottles of different sizes with ‘M.M.B’ Label, and those of the defendants with ‘M.B.B’ mark. The bigger size is 750 ml when filled. Then there are half size bottles which are 375 ml. and there is another size which contains 1/4th of a bigger size.

    2. In order to appreciate the controversy the labels which are fixed on the plaintiffs whisky bottles has a mark in the following manner:

    “MMB (in back and red)

    below it.

    Whisky (in red)

    Thereunder place of its bottling and blending office etc. is written”

    On the whisky bottles which are prepared by the defendants the labels are in the following manner:

    “MBB (in black and red)

    Whisky (in red)

    Thereunder the place of distilling and bottling is mentioned.”

    Plaintiffs blend and bottle their whisky in question under the name and style of ‘Mohan Meakin Breweries Ltd.’ which has its registered office at Solan. Defendants distill and bottle their whisky under the name and style of ‘Kashmir Dreamland Distilleries’ Srinagar-Kmr. On the said bottles of the defendants 25 with a knot on the right side of 5 with words UP is written on the top of the label opposite the words 750 ml. In the whisky bottles distilled by the plaintiff 25. UP is written below the words ‘Whisky’ on right side and on the left side 750 ml is written. Same is the position with regard to the bottles of smaller size.

    3. During the trial of this suit plaintiffs got their copyright registered and their copyright is, as earlier stated, ‘MMB Whisky’.

    4. Mr. Chadda appearing for the plaintiffs has submitted that the defendants are contravening the Copyright Act as also Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958. It is contended that the Trade mark used by the petitioners in the kind of whisky which is in dispute and that used by the defendants has similarity and is apt to deceive a purchaser. The defendants are passing off their goods with a view to deceive public and the public is led to believe that the whisky bottles distilled and bottled by the defendants are that of the plaintiffs company. It is contended that the whisky bottles labelled by the defendants are so similar in their labels, packing, get up etc. that they are bound to cause confusion in the minds of the purchaser and deceive him on first impression. The visual and phonetic similarity of plaintiff's bottles and defendants bottles are sure to deceive a man of imperfect collection or a man of average intelligence so as to lead him to believe that the bottles of the defendants are bottles manufactured by the plaintiff company. It is also stated that there is no sense in using the word ‘M.B.B’ when the defendant-firms name is Kashmir Dreamland Distilleries. The word ‘M.B.B’ is used by the defendants only to pass off their goods for that of the plaintiff-company.

    5. Mr. Z.A Shah appearing on other side has controverted this position and has stated that there is no similarity between the two labels or the whiskies. The colour of the two whiskies is also not the same Whisky bottled and distilled by the plaintiff is of a deeper colour and that prepared by the defendant is of a lighter colour. He contends that the word ‘M.M.B’ written on the bottles of the plaintiff-company cannot be confused with the word ‘M.B.B’ engrossed on the defendants bottles. In the plaintiffs bottles there are 2 M's and only one ‘B’ whereas in the bottles of the defendants there is one M and 2 ‘B's. His next argument was that suit was not triable by the High Court but was to be brought before the District Court.

    6. I would like to decide the main objection first i.e with regard to the jurisdiction of this court, which is covered by an issue framed on 31-10-1984.

    7. Under the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 a suit for infringement etc. is to be instituted before a District Court. S. 105 of the said Act says that no suit which relates to infringement of trade mark or relates to unregistered trade mark or for passing off arising out of the use by the defendant of any trade mark which is identical or deceptively similar to the plaintiff's trade whether registered or unregistered shall be instituted in any court, inferior to a District Court having jurisdiction to try the suit.

    8. From the perusal of this section it appears that suit brought for infringement etc. cannot be instituted in any court which is inferior to the District Court, but it does not bar filing of such a suit in any court which is superior to the District Court. Moreover suit of the present nature is essentially suit for perpetual injunction. Valuation for jurisdiction of the suit is to be the same which is valuation for the payment of court-fee. In fact it is the valuation for purposes of court-fee which will determine the valuation of the suit for purposes of jurisdiction. That would mean one and the same valuation for purposes of court-fee and jurisdiction is to be fixed and court-fee paid at ad valorem. Present suit is valued for more than Rs. 20,000/- for purposes of jurisdiction and court-fee and such a suit is necessarily to be presented before the High Court which has the jurisdiction to try it or it may transfer it for trial to District Court. Any suit valuation where of is Rs. 20,000/- or more is necessarily to be filed in the High Court. It cannot be filed before the District Judge. That is the mandate of law so far as this stage is concerned. Therefore objection of the defendant about the jurisdiction of the High Court to try the suit is not well founded.

    9. Mr. Z.A Shah then referred to Copyright Act and in his opinion S. 62 of the said Act will oust the jurisdiction of this court to try the suit. This contention also is not well founded for two reasons one, that the District Court as referred in the said section which means District Court as defined in the CPC of 1908, i.e Act No. 5 of 1908. The District Court defined under that Act is the principal court of the District as also High Court which has original jurisdiction over a District or more Districts, secondly, in a suit for perpetual injunction valuation for purposes of Jurisdiction and court-fee will determine the jurisdiction of the Court. Under S. 62 of the Copyright Act also therefore, it is held that the suit is cognizable by this Court and this Court will not lack jurisdiction in trying and deciding the suit.

    10. The main controversy which needs to be considered now is whether the plaintiff is entitled to get ad interim relief or not. For that plaintiff must establish that he has a prima facie case and balance of convenience is in his favour. He has also to proved that if ad interim unjunction is withheld he is likely to suffer irreparable injury.

    11. The labels used by the plaintiff and defendants on their bottles of whisky have been detailed out elsewhere in this judgment, the similarity between the labels used on the whisky bottles of the plaintiff and defendant is so deep that to a man of imperfect collection and average intelligence the two labels are apt to be taken as similar and label used by the defendant is to be taken by the purchaser as a label used by the plaintiff. The word ‘M.M.B’ and ‘M.B.B’ is not that distinct which is not apt to be confused with each other.

    12. The Supreme Court has drawn distinction in similarity between infringement of trade mark and passing off action. In Ruston and Hornby Ltd. v. Zamindara Engineering, AIR 1970 SC 1649, it was noted by the Supreme Court that in an action for infringement where the defendant's trade mark is identical with the plaintiff's mark the court will not enquire whether the infringement is such is likely to deceive or cause confusion. But where the alleged infringement consists of using not the exact mark on the Register, but something similar to it, the test of infringement is the same as in an action for passing off. In other words, the test as to likelihood of confusion or deception arising from similarity of marks is the same both in infringement and passing off actions.

    13. Action for infringement was held to be statutory right by the Supreme Court and it would depend upon the validity of the registration and subject to the other restrictions laid down in the various sections of the Act. On the other hand right of passing off action is that A is not entitled to represent his goods as the goods of B but it is not necessary for B to prove that A did this knowingly or with any intent to deceive. It is enough that the get-up of B's goods has become distinctive of them and there is a probability of confusion between them and the goods of A. It is not necessary to prove actual deception or actual damage. The infringement of trade mark and passing off action are similar in some respects. Relying on Saville Perfumery Ltd. v. June Perfect Ltd. (1941) 58 RPC 147 at page 161 decided by Master of the Rolls, the Supreme Court pointed out that in an action for infringement where the defendant's trade mark is identical with the plaintiffs mark, the court will not enquire whether the infringement is such, as is likely to deceive or cause confusion, but where the alleged infringement consists of using not the exact mark on the register but something similar to it, the test of infringement is the same as in an action of passing off. According to the Supreme Court the test as to likelihood of confusion or deception arising from similarity of marks is the same both in infringement and passing off action.

    14. The Supreme Court in AIR 1970 SC 1649 (supra) was considering the resemblance between the word ‘RUSTAM’ and the word ‘AUSTON’. It found that there were deceptive similarity between both and on that basis it granted a decree in favour of the plaintiff in that case, who had complained of infringement of his trade mark and brought action on the ground of passing off action.

    15. Mr. Chadda next relied on the Panipat Co-operative Sugar Mills Ltd. v. Mohan Meakin Breweries Ltd. which is said to be reported in 1978 (3) IPLR 53, A photostat copy of that judgment is placed on record by Mr. Chadda. A Division Bench of Punjab and Haryana High Court decided the case on the question of passing off. The defendant in that case had used a label on his whisky bottles which was marked as ‘BMB’ which was similar to letters ‘MMB’. In view of the similarity in the labels it was observed that the Court is not to visualise the reaction of an intelligent purchaser with a sharp menory and astute power of observation, it has to see the type of the goods and the people who commonly use it and purchase it. Commenting on the question of passing off the learned Judges constituting the Division Bench observed as under:—

    “In the case of ‘passing off’, the plaintiff has to allege that the goods of the defendant offered to the hands of the public are likely to be mistaken for the goods of the plaintiff, thus leading to deception. Actual deception is not necessary. The plaintiff has to prove substantial user of his goods. In order to restrain the defendant from production and marketing of goods he has to further prove that the two goods are so similar in their labels, packing, get up etc., that they are likely to cause confusion in the mind of the purchaser or to deceive him on first impression. It is to be appreciated whether the overall visual and phonetic similarity of the plaintiff's and defendant's labels, marks, get-up etc. is likely to deceive a man of imperfect recollection, or in the case of a fading memory even a man of average intelligence, so as to lead him to mistake the goods of the defendant to be the goods of the plaintiff. It is keeping in view of these well-recognised principles approved by the Courts of this country that the question of granting temporary injunction has to be examined.”

    16. Mr. Chadda has also referred to a single bench of the Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench) reported in 1980 (4) IPLR 117. He has produced a photostat copy of the said judgment and after appreciation of case law, the learned judges restrained the defendants in that case from using the trade mark which was held by him to be deceptively similar to the plaintiff's trade mark in that case.

    17. The defendants argument was that there was no infringement of trade mark committed by them because there was no similarity in the two trade marks. The plaintiffs trade mark ‘MMB’ whisky, though registered was not similar to ‘MBB’ whisky, trade mark used by the defendants though unregistered. The defendants are not using ‘MMB’ Trade mark assuming this argument to be correct, the trade mark may be not similar but this case is to be decided on the question of passing off and if the plaintiff is able to show that the label used by the defendants is deceptively similar to the label used by the plaintiff and the defendants are likely to pass on their whisky as whisky bottled and blended by the plaintiff and confuse the average purchaser, the plaintiff will be entitled to grant of ad interim relief. On a visual perusal of the whisky bottles which are presented in the court along with the labels pasted thereon, a purchaser of average intelligence who is only interested in having a whisky prepared by Mohan Meakins can be deceived and led to purchase the whisky prepared by the defendants with ‘MBB’ Label. The similarity and resemblance in the two labels is so close and near that it is likely to confuse a purchaser and whisky of defendant can be passed on as that made by the plaintiff. The purchaser would not go to the colour of the whisky or name of the company, but it will look to the bold letters written on the labels. The whisky prepared by the defendant may be passed off to a purchaser and he may be led to believe that he was purchasing the whisky prepared by the plaintiff. The element of deceitful passing off whisky prepared by the defendant for that of the plaintiff cannot be altogether ruled out. The purchaser is likely to be misled by the similarity of the labels and he is not expected to be as astatute observer to make enquiries before the purchase of the defendant's whisky. The said whisky is likely to be mistaken for the whisky prepared by the plaintiff. I am in respectful agreement with the Division Bench judgment of the Punjab and Haryana High Court reported in 1978 (3) IPLR 53 and the judgment scribed by learned single Judge of Allahabad High Court reported in 1980 (4) IPLR 117.

    18. In the present case the whisky prepared by the defendant has deceptive similarity with the whisky prepared by the plaintiff and an average man is likely to be confused and deceived by the impression used by the defendant.

    19. The plaintiff therefore has made out a prima facie case that the defendant is likely to pass off his whisky for that of the plaintiff by using deceptive labels and trade mark on his whisky. If that is not prevented, the plaintiff is likely to suffer injury which cannot be calculated at this stage. Balance of convenience is also in favour of the plaintiff because he is likely to suffer by the defendant's deceptive user of labels on his whisky.

    20. I would accordingly grant ad interim injunction in favour of the plaintiff against the defendants restraining the defendant from using the label ‘MBB WHISKY’ or any other label which has deceptive similarity with the label used by the plaintiff on his whisky as ‘MMB WHISKY’. The defendant shall not sell any whisky under this label in the market and if any whisky is sold by the defendant in the meantime, that shall be withdrawn by it. This order will enure till the disposal of the suit only.

    21. Any opinion expressed in this judgment will not be construed to be the opinion of the Court on the merits of the controversy raised in the suit which is subjudice before the Court. The observations made hereinabove are without prejudice to the rights of the defendants and shall not confer any benefit on the plaintiff in the suit.

    22. The preliminary issue is decided against the defendants and in favour of the plaintiffs.

    Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohan Meakin Ltd. v. Kashmir Dreamland Distilleries
    (Jul 22, 1988)