AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These three appeals arise from a common award passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-I, Sirmaur at Nahan, dated 1.9.1993, relating to multiple claim petitions involving an accident on 26.4.1990. The truck involved, owned by Kirti Singh Pokhriyal and insured by the appellant insurance company, met with an accident at Mannal, resulting in deaths and injuries to persons being carried on the truck. The claim petitions were filed by dependants of the deceased and injured persons. The Tribunal awarded compensation, including interim compensation of Rs. 25,000/- payable by the insurance company under section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The insurance company challenged the award, contending that it should not be held liable for no fault liability under section 140 of the Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the direction of awarding interim compensation under section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 against the insurance company is legally valid.
  2. Whether the insurance company is liable to pay compensation to passengers carried gratuitously, i.e., without payment.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Member, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, 1988 ACJ 612 (Gauhati) Insurance company liable to pay interim award under section 92-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (similar to section 140 of the 1988 Act). Held that the insurance company is liable to pay interim compensation under the corresponding provision of the 1988 Act.
K. Ramulu v. Shaik Khaja, 1991 ACJ 359 (AP) Insurance company liable to pay compensation under section 92-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939; owner not solely liable. Supported the proposition that insurance companies are liable for compensation under the no fault liability provisions.
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. K. Savithri, 1990 ACJ 768 (Kerala) Insurance company vicariously liable to pay interim compensation. Confirmed the Tribunal’s decision holding the insurance company liable for interim compensation.
Babban Tiwari v. Usha Ranjan Chakraborty, 1987 ACJ 863 (Gauhati) Though section 92-A mentions "owner," insurer must indemnify owner for compensation awarded. Applied to hold insurance company liable to pay interim compensation without inquiry into defenses.
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Ghisi Devi, 1989 ACJ 728 (Rajasthan) Section 92-A provides for no fault liability; Tribunal cannot inquire into insurer’s defenses under section 95; insurer can recover from owner if ultimately not liable. Supported the principle that insurance companies must pay interim compensation and may later seek reimbursement from owners.
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sukha Devi, 1995 ACJ 796 (HP) Insurance company liable for claims in similar cases. Reinforced the liability of insurance company for compensation in the present appeals.
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Satyanath Hazarika, 1989 ACJ 685 (Gauhati) Insurance company liable to pay compensation even to gratuitous passengers based on statutory instructions of the Tariff Advisory Committee. Applied to hold insurance company liable for compensation to gratuitous passengers as well.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the provisions under Chapter X of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, particularly section 140, which imposes no fault liability on insurance companies for interim compensation. The court observed that this Chapter has overriding effect notwithstanding any other law. The court relied on established precedents from various High Courts interpreting the analogous provisions under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (sections 92-A and 95), to conclude that insurance companies are liable to pay interim compensation without inquiry into their defenses. The court examined the facts and found no evidence that the passengers were carried without the owner's or driver's authority; on the contrary, evidence showed passengers were carried for hire. Additionally, the court considered the liability of the insurance company for gratuitous passengers, relying on instructions from the Tariff Advisory Committee and relevant case law, concluding that insurance companies are liable even for such passengers unless specific policy conditions exclude such liability. Since no such conditions were shown, the insurance company was held liable. The court declined to entertain other points as none were urged before it.

Holding and Implications

The appeals are dismissed.

The court upheld the validity of awarding interim compensation under section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 against the insurance company, confirming its liability for compensation to both fare-paying and gratuitous passengers. The decision affirms the principle of no fault liability imposed on insurers for interim compensation awards and clarifies that insurers cannot avoid such liability by raising defenses at the interim stage. The direct effect is that the insurance company must pay the compensation awarded by the Tribunal. No new precedent beyond the application of existing principles was established by this judgment.

    New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Bhajnoo And Another

    S.N Phukan, C.J:— By this common judgment and order we dispose of three appeals, namely, F.A.O (MVA) No. 326 of 1993 and F.A.O (MVA) Nos. 5 and 7 of 1994 as the point involved in all the appeals is the same. The appeals have been filed by the insurance company being aggrieved by the award, by which the insurance company was saddled with no fault liability under section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’).

    2. All the appeals have been filed against the common award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-I, Sirmaur at Nahan, dated 1.9.1993, passed in M.A.C Petition Nos. 51-N/2, 48-N/2, 47-N/2, 49-N/2 and 50-N/2 of 1990. By this judgment, the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal clubbed together all the claim petitions. Briefly stated, the facts are as follows:

    3. The truck No. UMS 8161 was owned by Kirti Singh Pokhriyal and as he did not appear, all the appeals have been taken up ex parte against him. The said truck was insured with the present appellant insurance company and Exh. R-3 is the insurance policy. On 26.4.1990 at about 11 a.m the truck met with an accident at a place, known as Mannal. The truck was carrying some persons and in the said accident the truck driver and some of the persons, who were being carried in the truck, died and some other persons, who were also travelling, suffered multiple injuries. It is alleged that some debris was lying on the road at the site of the accident and the driver got the debris removed and tried to cross that portion of the road though the persons on board the truck asked the driver not to take the risk but he did not pay any heed and as soon as the truck reached the site, ‘Danga’ gave way and it rolled down and fell about 100 feet below. The claim petitions were filed by the dependants of the deceased as well as the injured persons. By the impugned award, the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal awarded various sums in respect of the claim petitioners. In the claim petition filed by Nazro Devi and her minor children (M.A.C Petition No. 51-N/2 of 1990) in respect of the death a sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- was awarded and it was directed that a sum of Rs. 25,000/- shall be paid by the insurance company under section 140 of the Act. Similarly, in the claim petitions filed by Maina Devi (M.A.C Petition No. 47-N/2 of 1990), Bhajnoo (M.A.C Petition No. 49-N/2 of 1990) and Gurdevi (M.A.C Petition No. 50-N/2 of 1990), the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal also directed payment of Rs. 25,000/- under section 140 of the Act by the appellant. The owner was saddled with liability of the balance amount of the award in respect of the claim petitions.

    4. The short point to be decided is whether this direction of awarding interim compensation under section 140 of the Act against the insurance company is legally valid or not.

    5. Section 140 finds place in a separate Chapter, namely, Chapter X under the heading ‘Liability Without Fault In Certain Cases’, of the Act. Section 144 of the Act, which comes under the above Chapter, provides that this Chapter has the effect notwithstanding anything contained in any other provision of this Act or of any other law for the time being in force.

    6. Various decisions have been cited at the Bar, both in support and against the contention that the insurance company is not liable for this amount.

    7. Gauhati High Court speaking through Hon'ble Hansaria, J., as his Lordship then was, in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Member, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, 1988 ACJ 612 (Gauhati), considered the question as to whether insurance company by virtue of section 95 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, can claim that as per the terms of the policy the company is not liable to pay interim award under section 92-A of that Act, which is similar to section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and it was held that company is liable.

    8. The Andhra Pradesh High Court in K. Ramulu v. Shaik Khaja, 1991 ACJ 359 (AP), rejected the plea that under section 92-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, only owner is liable to pay compensation under this Act and held that the insurance company is liable to pay compensation under the above section.

    9. The Kerala High Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. K. Savithri, 1990 ACJ 768 (Kerala), held that the Claims Tribunal correctly decided that the insurance company also was vicariously liable to pay interim compensation.

    10. The single Bench of Gauhati High Court speaking through one of us (S.N Phukan, C.J) in Babban Tiwari v. Usha Ranjan Chakraborty, 1987 ACJ 863 (Gauhati), considered section 92-A and section 95 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 and held that in section 92-A, though the word ‘owner’ has been used, the insurer shall have to indemnify the owner for any amount awarded under section 92-A.

    11. Rajasthan High Court in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Ghisi Devi, 1989 ACJ 728 (Rajasthan), considered section 92-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 and held that this section provides for award of compensation on the basis of no fault liability and the Tribunal cannot inquire the merits of the defences available to the insurance company under section 95 of the Act. It was further held that in case the insurance company ultimately proves that it was not liable to pay any compensation then the insurance company can claim the amount from the owner of the vehicle under section 96 of the Act.

    12. From the above ratio including the ratio of the Gauhati High Court in Babban Tiwari's case, 1987 ACJ 863 (Gauhati), we hold that while giving interim compensation under section 92-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, corresponding to section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, the Tribunal is not to make an enquiry regarding the defences taken by the insurance company and the insurance company is liable to pay compensation awarded under the above section.

    13. From the evidence on record as well as from the award, we find that the persons who died or got injuries carried in the truck, there is nothing on record to show that it was so done without the authority of the owner or the driver. There is no acceptable evidence to show that the owner gave any specific instructions to the driver not to carry any passenger. On the other hand, from the evidence of Gulab Singh, PW 1(C), we find that he paid Rs. 5/- to the driver for carrying him in the truck. As most of the people were illiterate and rustic villagers who got injuries and other persons died, we accept the evidence of above witness, namely, Gulab Singh and hold that persons who were carried in the truck were carried for hire.

    14. A Division Bench of this court in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sukha Devi, 1995 ACJ 796 (HP), held that in similar cases the insurance company is liable for the claim. We see no reason to take a different view. Therefore, in these appeals on this ground also the insurance company is liable for the compensation awarded. As there are no cross-objections, we cannot decide as to whether the claimants are entitled to recover the entire awarded amount from the insurance company, but we hold that the proportionate compensation awarded against the insurance company by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal was right and legal.

    15. Let us consider as to whether gratuitous passengers were liable to get compensation. In New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Satyanath Hazarika, 1989 ACJ 685 (Gauhati), a Bench of five Judges of Gauhati High Court speaking through hon'ble Hansaria, J., as his Lordship then was, also considered the question whether the families of the deceased gratuitous passengers or such injured persons are entitled to get compensation from the insurance company and the court relying on various decisions of different High Courts including the Supreme Court and statutory instructions of the Tariff Advisory Committee, which is a statutory body, inter alia, held that the instructions of the Tariff Advisory Committee issued on 25.3.1977 would apply and as such insurance company will be liable to pay compensation even to gratuitous passengers.

    16. A copy of the part of the instructions issued by the said Committee has been made available to us and from the said instructions, we find under the heading ‘Legal Liability to Non-Fare Paying Passengers other than Statutory Liability except Fatal Accidents Act, 1855 (Commercial Vehicles only)’, it was directed, inter alia, as follows:

    “In consideration of the payment of an additional premium of Rs. … and not withstanding anything to the contrary contained in section II-I(b) and (c) it is hereby understood and agreed that the company will indemnify the insured against his legal liability other than liability under statute (except the Fatal Accidents Act, 1855) in respect of death of or bodily injury to:

    (i) Any employee of the within named insured who is not a workman within the meaning of the Workmen's Compensation Act prior to the date of this endorsement and not being carried for hire or reward.

    (ii) Any other person not being carried for hire or reward provided that the person is—

    (a) The owner or representative of the owner of the goods;

    (b) Charterer or representative of the charterer of the truck;

    (c) Any other person directly connected with the journey in one form or other being carried in or upon or entering or mounting or alighting from any motor vehicle described in the Schedule of the policy.

    Subject otherwise to the terms, exceptions, conditions and limitation of this policy.”

    17. Nothing has been placed before us to show that in the present insurance policy any condition or limitation was imposed, which is applicable to the case in hand. Therefore, in addition to what we have held, that is, the passengers who were travelling with the consent of the owner/driver on payment; even if they were gratuitous passengers, the insurance company is liable for the compensation.

    18. No other point has been urged before us.

    19. For the reasons stated above, we do not find any merit in all the three appeals and, therefore, they are dismissed. Costs on the parties.

    20. Appeals dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Bhajnoo And Another
    (Sep 7, 1995)