AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 135 of the Customs Act, 1962, hereinafter referred to as the Act
  • SECTION 178 SEA CUSTOMS ACT 1878
  • S. 135(b)(ii) of the Customs Act, 1962.
  • sub-section (1) of section 178-A
  • S. 180 of the Sea Customs Act.
  • case.3. Section 123(1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 135 of the Customs Act, 1962, hereinafter referred to as the Act
  • SECTION 178 SEA CUSTOMS ACT 1878
  • S. 135(b)(ii) of the Customs Act, 1962.
  • sub-section (1) of section 178-A
  • S. 180 of the Sea Customs Act.
  • case.3. Section 123(1)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Assistant Collector, Customs, Baroda and the State of Gujarat appealed against the acquittal of accused No. 1 (Mukbul Husain) for an offence under S. 135(b)(ii) of the Customs Act, 1962. The prosecution's case, as stated in the opinion, was that on September 28, 1963 the accused alighted from the Janta Express at Baroda and, while passing through the third-class exit gate, was stopped by a police constable because he could not give satisfactory answers and was carrying a hand-bag. The police detained him and, on searching his bag, found 50 bars of gold (each 10 tolas) with alleged foreign markings. Panchanama Ex. 12 and receipt Ex. 14 record the seizure by the Railway Police. The accused was arrested under S. 54(4), Criminal P.C.

The Railway Police delivered the accused, the seized articles (muddamal) and papers to the Customs authorities; a paper panchanama Ex. 16 was thereafter made by Mr. Dixit of the Customs. A complaint was filed after sanction and three persons (including accused No. 1) were tried under S. 135 of the Customs Act for possession, acquisition and dealing with prohibited foreign-marked gold. Accused No. 1 pleaded complete denial, stating that he had been given the bag in Bombay by one Safi to deliver to his brother in Baroda and that he did not know the contents.

The learned Magistrate convicted accused No. 1 under S. 135(b)(ii), holding that a presumption under section 123 was attracted by the Customs seizure and sentenced him to three months' rigorous imprisonment and a fine. On appeal the learned Sessions Judge acquitted accused No. 1 on the ground that the goods had been seized by the police (not by Customs under the Act) and therefore the presumption under section 123 did not arise; the Sessions Judge held that prosecution failed to prove the gold to be smuggled. The State and Customs authorities appealed to the court presided by Mehta, J.

Note: The opinion records both the date "September 28, 1963" (prosecution's account) and later references to seizures dated "28-9-1968" in the record (e.g., panchanama Ex. 12 and certain depositions). These differing dates are presented in the opinion as they appear in the record.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the presumption under section 123(1) of the Customs Act (that goods seized under the Act are smuggled unless proven otherwise) is attracted where the goods were originally seized by the police under the Criminal Procedure Code and later handed over to the Customs authorities (with a paper panchanama Ex. 16) rather than being seized by Customs from the accused's possession.
  2. Whether markings on the gold bars and reports concerning fineness (e.g., Mint Master reports Exs. 20 and 21) constitute admissible evidence to establish foreign origin or smuggling of the gold.
  3. Whether the prosecution proved the essential ingredient of the offence (that the gold was smuggled) beyond the accused's mere possession.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant / Prosecution (as presented by Mr. Mehta, Assistant Government Pleader)

  • Contended that panch witness testimony indicated that at the time of the Customs panchanama Ex. 16 the goods were seized from accused No. 1 by Customs and therefore the presumption under section 123 was attracted.
  • Relied on the foreign markings on the gold bars as indicative of foreign origin and supportive of smuggling.
  • Relied upon reports from the Mint Master (Exs. 20 and 21) indicating fineness (998.8) to argue that such fineness demonstrated foreign origin of the gold.
  • Relied on certain authorities (cases cited in the opinion) to support the contention that the presumption should apply.

Accused's Position (as recorded in the trial)

  • Accused No. 1 denied knowledge of the contents of the bag, asserting Safi handed him the bag in Bombay to deliver in Baroda and that he did not know it contained gold. (This was the accused's pleaded defence recorded in the opinion.)
  • General plea of complete denial as to the charge of possessing smuggled gold.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gian Chand v. State of Punjab, AIR 1962 S.C. 496 Interpreted the corresponding provision (s. 178-A of the Sea Customs Act, 1878): when goods are seized by the police the accused lose possession and the presumption attracting burden of proof arises only when goods are seized under the Customs Act from the accused's possession. The court relied on this decision as directly applicable and decisive: where police (or Magistrate under police authority) first seize goods under CrPC, their subsequent delivery to Customs does not amount to a fresh seizure under the Customs Act to attract the presumption under section 123(1).
Vasantlal v. Union of India, AIR 1967 Bom 188 Held that if goods were wrongfully seized by an officer not competent to seize, a subsequent lawful seizure by Customs could attract the presumption; used to distinguish factual situations where initial seizure was invalid. The court distinguished this case: in Vasantlal the initial seizure was wrongful (by an incompetent officer), whereas in the present case the Railway Police were competent to seize under the CrPC when arrest was made under s. 54(4); thus Vasantlal did not assist the appellant.
Deputy Supdt. Customs v. Sitaram, AIR 1968 Cal 274 Concerns delivery of goods in custody of the Magistrate to Customs authorities; addresses effect of such delivery on the legal position of seizure/possession. The court held this authority did not support the appellant: it was inapposite to the question whether goods seized by police (causing accused to lose possession) could be said to have been re-seized from the accused under the Act so as to attract s. 123(1).
Comptroller of Customs v. Western Electric Co. Ltd., 1966 AC 367 (Privy Council) Established that markings and labels indicating origin constitute hearsay and should be excluded as proof of foreign origin unless otherwise admissible. The court applied this principle to exclude reliance on the alleged foreign markings as conclusive proof of foreign origin or smuggling.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in the following steps (as stated in the opinion):

  1. Factual determination of seizure: the record shows the gold was seized by the Railway Police (panchanama Ex. 12) and a receipt Ex. 14 was issued. When Customs Officer Mr. Dixit arrived he received the accused, muddamal articles and police papers from Police Inspector Rathod as per Yadi Ex. 15 and then made panchanama Ex. 16. The court found that Ex. 16 was a "paper panchanama" documenting delivery to Customs and not a fresh seizure from the accused.
  2. Statutory interpretation of section 123(1): the court emphasized the statutory wording that the presumption arises where goods are "seized under this Act in the reasonable belief that they are smuggled goods" and that, by its terms, the burden shifts to "the person from whose possession the goods were seized." The court held that this presumption applies only if the Customs authorities effect the seizure under the Act from the accused's possession.
  3. Application of precedent (Gian Chand): relying on Gian Chand (interpreting an identical provision in s. 178-A of the Sea Customs Act), the court accepted the principle that when police seize goods, the accused lose possession and thereafter the police (or Magistrate) hold possession; a later transfer of custody to Customs under statutory provision (s. 180 in the Sea Customs Act or analogous provisions) is not a fresh seizure under the Customs Act that could attract the statutory presumption.
  4. Distinguishing contrary authorities: the court distinguished Vasantlal on the ground that there initial seizure was wrongful (by an incompetent Enforcement Department officer), which is different from the present case where the Railway Police lawfully seized under CrPC powers upon arrest. The court found Deputy Supdt. Customs v. Sitaram inapposite because that case concerned goods in custody of the Magistrate being ordered delivered to Customs, and did not support the proposition that police seizure followed by transfer could be treated as a Customs seizure from the accused's possession.
  5. On evidentiary issues the court held that markings on the gold constitute hearsay (relying on Western Electric) and cannot be taken as proof of foreign origin. The Mint Master reports (Exs. 20 and 21) could not be treated as conclusive since the Mint Master was not examined and no provision was pointed out making the reports themselves legal evidence of foreign origin. The court also noted Mr. Dixit's admission that even after prohibition, gold could be imprinted with such marks by permit of the Reserve Bank, Government or private parties.
  6. Conclusion on proof of smuggling: because the prosecution could not produce direct admissible evidence proving that the gold was smuggled (beyond possession and the hearsay markings/reports), the essential ingredient of the offence — that the gold was smuggled — was not established. Thus the presumption under s. 123(1) could not assist the prosecution, and on the merits the Sessions Judge was right to acquit.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court APPEAL DISMISSED. The appeal by the Assistant Collector Customs and the State of Gujarat fails and is dismissed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The acquittal of accused No. 1 (Mukbul Husain) is upheld — the prosecution failed to prove that the gold was smuggled and the statutory presumption under section 123(1) did not apply because the goods were originally seized by police and not by Customs from the accused's possession.
  • No broader legal finding beyond the facts: The opinion treats the decision as an application of settled principles (noting Gian Chand and distinguishing Vasantlal and other cases) and does not purport to lay down a novel precedent beyond the application of those authorities to the present facts.

    Assistant Collector Customs, Baroda And Another v. Mukbujusein Ibrahim Pirjada .

    Mehta, J.:— The plaintiff Assistant Collector, Customs, Baroda, and the State of Gujarat have filed this appeal against the acquittal of the original accused No. 1 for the offence under S. 135(b)(ii) of the Customs Act, 1962. The case of the prosecution was that on September 28, 1963, at about 3.15 A.M, accused No. 1, Mukbul Husain alighted at Baroda from the Janta Express train coming from Bombay. While he was passing through the third class passengers' Exit gate, police constable Navalsing stopped him at the gate as the accused was not able to give satisfactory answers when he was found carrying a hand bag. The accused was detained and the police constable Jivamiya was called. The hand-bag of the accused was searched and 50 bars of gold each weighing 10 Tolas, worth about Rs. 70,000/- were found from the accused's (theli) bag inside the hand-bag. The gold bars are alleged to have foreign markings “N.M ROTHSCHILD & SONS 10 Tolas, 999-00”. Panchanama Ex. 12 was made of the seizure of the gold. The Police-station Officer Dayashanker arrested the accused-under S. 54(4), Criminal P.C Thereafter, the Circle Police Inspector Rathod informed the Customs Authorities and handed over the accused, muddamal articles for which the receipt Ex. 14 was issued and the panchanama papers to the Deputy Superintendent of Central Excise Mr. Dixit. Mr. Dixit made a fresh panchanama Ex. 16 of the seizure of these goods. After a sanction was obtained the Assistant Collector Customs, filed a complaint against the present accused and two other persons, one Mohmad Safi, who was alleged to have purchased the gold with money and sent through the accused No. 1 by one Ismail Haji accused No. 3 to whom ultimately this gold was to be delivered.; All the accused. Were put up for trial for the charge under S. 135 of the Customs Act, 1962, hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’ for possessing, acquiring and dealing with the prohibited gold of foreign marks which was liable to be confiscated under S. III of the Act. The plea of the accused was of complete denial. Accused No. 1 stated that Safi met him in Bombay and handed over to him the bag to be delivered to his brother Gulam at Baroda. He did not know the contents and put the same in his hand bag. The learned Magistrate acquitted the other two accused. The learned Magistrate held, that so far as accused No. 1 was concerned, in view of the seizure of the goods by the Customs Officers, presumption under section 123 was attracted and the burden was on the accused to show that the gold was not smuggled gold. The learned Magistrate, therefore, convicted the accused No. 1 for the offence under section 135(b)(ii) of the Act and sentenced, him to suffer R.I for three months and a fine of, Rs. 1,000, in default, rigorous imprisonment for four months. In appeal, the learned Sessions Judge has acquitted the accused on the ground that as the goods were seized by the Police, the presumption under section 123 was not attracted. The prosecution having failed to prove the gold in question to be smuggled gold, the accused No. 1 also was acquitted. Against the said order the present appeal is filed.

    2. On the facts in the present case there can be no dispute that the gold in question was seized by the Police authorities from the accused No. 1 on 28-9-1968 as per panchanama Ex. 12 and the receipt was passed at Ex. 14 in that connection. Mr. Mehta, the learned Assistant Government Pleader vehemently argued, that the panch witness has deposed that at the time of the panchanama Ex. 16, made by the Customs authorities the goods were seized from the accused No. 1. There is no substance in this contention. The panch witness Navinchandra Thakkar can hardly be believed in this connection. The Police Inspector Mr. Rathod had in terms deposed that when Mr. Dixit the Customs officer came, to him, he made over the muddamal articles, papers and accused to him as per the Yadi Ex. 15 which in terms recites this fact. Mr. Dixit in terms deposes that on September 28, 1968, the muddamal articles seized by the Railway Police had been handed over to him as per Yadi Ex. 15. He took the custody of these articles, accused and the police papers and took them to the Customs Preventive Office before even he drew the panchanama Ex. 16. It is therefore, clear that the panchanama Ex. 16 is not of the seizure of the goods from the accused but it is only a paper panchanama of the delivery of the gootls. It is only a paper panchanama which would show that the goods which were seized by the police authorities were kept in the custody of the Customs authorities. Therefore, the goods having not been seized by the Customs authorities from the possession of the accused, the presumption under section 128 would not be attraoted in this case.

    3. Section 123(1) in terms provide that where any goods to which this section applies are seized under this Act in the reasonable-belief that they are smuggled goods, the burden of proving that they are not smuggled gold shall be on the person from whose possession the goods were seized. (2) This section shall apply to gold…..and any other class of goods which the Central Government may by notification in the Official Gazette specify. Therefore, presumption in case of gold can arise under section 123(1) and (2) provided gold is seized under the Act by the Customs authorities from the possession of the accused. In the present case gold was seized not by the Customs authorities under the Act but by the Police authorities under the provisions of Criminal Procedure Code after the accused No. 1 was arrested under section 54(4) under the panchanama Ex. 12. Therefore, the seizure was not under the Act but dehors the Act, when it was done by the police authorities. The accused having lost possession of these goods by this act of seizure by the police authorities, there was no question of the seizure of the same goods when their custody was transferred to the Customs authorities by the Police authorities. Merely making of a fresh panchanama Ex. 16 would not amount to a seizure of the goods under the Act from the possession of the accused so as to throw the burden on the accused to prove that the gold in question was not smuggled gold. The position of law in this connection is well settled after the decision of the Supreme Court in Gian Chand v. State of Punjab, AIR 1962 S.C 496, where their Lordships of the Supreme Court interpreted an identical, corresponding provision in section 178-A of the Sea Customs Act, 1878. At page 499, their Lordships of the Supreme Court observed that the last part of sub-section (1) of section 178-A lays the burden of proving that the goods are not smuggled on “the person from whose possession the goods are taken.” Assuredly when the goods are delivered to the, Customs authorities by the Magistrate, they are not taken from the possession of the persons accused in criminal case so as to throw, the burden of proof on them and it would lead to an absurdity to hold that the section contemplated “proof to the contrary” by the Magistrate under whose orders the delivery was effected. Their Lordships further pointed out that when the goods were seized by the police, they ceased to be in the possession of the accused and passed into the possession of the police, and when they were with the Magistrate it was unnecessary to consider whether the Magistrate had possession or merely eustody of the goods. Because the seizure, under the authority of law involves a deprivation of possession and not merely custody and so when the police officer seized the goods, the accused lost possession which thereafter vested in the police. When that possession was transferred by virtue of the provisions contained in S. 180 to the Customs authorities there was no fresh seizure under the Customs Act. This decision furnishes a complete answer to the present question that in order to attract the presumption under S. 123, the goods must be shown to have been seized under the Act from the possession of the accused by the Customs authorities. If the goods were originally seized by the Police authorities from the possession of the accused, the accused lost possession by seizure under the provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code and, thereafter; the possession vested in the Police authorities. It thereafter the customs authorities got the custody of these goods they could not be said to have seized under the Act so as to throw the burden on the accused to prove that the gold in question was not smuggled gold. Mr. Mehta vehemently argued that the decision of the Supreme Court was in connection with S. 180 of the Sea Customs Act. There is no substance in that contention as the decision is clearly based on the wording of the identical S. 178A. The decision in terms lays down that the burden would be thrown on the accused only when the goods are seized under the Act from the possession of the accused. If the possession of the accused is lost by the seizure of the goods by the Police authorities, the presumption under S. 128 would not arise. Mr. Mehta next relied upon the decision of the Maharashtra High Court in Vasantlal v. Union of India, AIR 1967 Bom 188, by the Division Bench consisting of Chainani C.J and Kotwal, J. That decision cannot help Mr. Mehta for the simple reason that in that case the goods were wrongfully seized by the Officer of the Enforcement Department who was not competent to do so and, therefore, it was held that when they were first lawfully seized by the Customs authorities, it was a case of seizure under the Act and it was on that ground that the decision in Gian Chands' case, AIR 1962 S.C 496 was not distinguished. That decision does not help Mr. Mehta for the simple reason that in the present case the Police Officer was entitled to seize the goods under the provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code, when the accused was arrested under S. 54(4). Mr. Mehta also relied upon the decision of Mukherji, J. in Deputy Supdt. Customs v. Sitaram, AIR 1968 Cal 274. That is a case where the goods which were in the custody of the Magistrate were ordered to be delivered to the Customs authorities. That decision can never help Mr. Mehta for contending that the goods which had been seized by the Police authorities and by which the accused losts possession could be said to have been again seized from the accused under the Act so as to throw the burden of proof under S. 123(1). Therefore, the learned Sessions Judge was right in holding that in this case the preaumption under S. 128(1) could not help the prosecution and the prosecution must prove the essential ingredient of the offence by proving that the gold in question was smuggled gold.

    4. Mr. Mehta in this connection vehemently relied on the fact that the gold in question had marks of foreign origin. It is well settled that mere markings could not be taken as proof of the fact of the foreign origin of the goods as such marking and labels would be hearsay evidence. In Comptroller of Customs v. Western Electric Co. Ltd., 1966 AC 367, their Lordships of the Privy Council in terras held at p. 809, that such marking must be excluded from consideration as being no more than hearsay.

    5. When the question arose as to the country of origin of the goods. Mr. Mehta next argued that the reports Exs. 20 and 21 from the Mint Master proved that the fineness of gold to the extent of 998.8 was such that the gold must be of foreign origin. The Mint Master has not been examined in this case and Mr. Mehta has not pointed out any provision which would make the report of the Mint Master the evidence of this fact. The evidence of the Goldsmith can hardly help this prosecution. In fact, Mr. Dixit himself admitted that even after the prohibition was issued for import of gold of the type seized, on permit of Reserve Bank, Government or any private party could imprint gold with such marks, Therefore, there is no iota of evidence in the present case to prove that the gold in question was smuggled gold. The mere fact that the accused was in possession of this gold and such possession was a conscious possession because of the various circumstances mentioned by the learned Magistrate would not prove the essential ingredient of the offence that the gold in question was smuggled gold. The learned Sessions Judge was right in acquitting the accused on that ground as the charge was not brought home to the accused No. 1.

    6. In the result this appeals fails and is dismissed.

    7. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Assistant Collector Customs, Baroda And Another v. Mukbujusein Ibrahim Pirjada .
    (Feb 7, 1969)