Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section (1) of Section 514 of the Criminal Procedure Code
  • S. 85(1)(2) of the Bombay Prohibition Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section (1) of Section 514 of the Criminal Procedure Code
  • S. 85(1)(2) of the Bombay Prohibition Act.
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Criminal Revision Application by Chhaganlal Kikabhai

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a Criminal Revision Application filed by Chhaganlal Kikabhai, who executed a surety bond on March 19, 1962 for one Magan (Mangan) Bhikha, arrested on March 18, 1962 under S. 85(1)(2) of the Bombay Prohibition Act. The bond obliged the accused to "attend wherever called upon" by the Billimora Police Station Officer and fixed a penalty of Rs. 200 in the event of default.

When Magan Bhikha was subsequently found to be absconding, a Judicial Magistrate issued a notice to the surety to produce him. The investigating Police Head Constable initially reported that the petitioner denied standing surety, but later deposed that the petitioner had executed the bond. The Magistrate issued a notice and, after proceedings, ordered an attachment warrant to recover Rs. 200 from the surety.

The petitioner appealed to the Sessions Judge (Criminal Appeal No. 48 of 1967, Bulsar), which allowed the appeal and remanded the matter because the Police Station Officer's evidence had not been recorded in the surety's presence. On remand the Police Station Officer was examined in the surety's presence, the petitioner was given an opportunity to cross-examine, and the Magistrate again issued an attachment warrant to recover Rs. 200. The petitioner again appealed (Criminal Appeal No. 3 of 1967, Sessions Judge, Balsar at Navsari), which was dismissed. The present revision application challenges that dismissal and the Magistrate's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Magistrate had jurisdiction under Section 514, Criminal Procedure Code (Cr.P.C.), to initiate proceedings for forfeiture and recovery where the surety bond was taken by a police officer (for appearance) rather than by a Court.
  2. Whether the surety bond was defective or void for vagueness because it did not specify the place where the accused was required to attend, thereby failing the requirement of Section 499, Cr.P.C., and rendering any forfeiture or recovery order illegal.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (Mr. Shethna)

  • The order for recovery of Rs. 200 was passed under S. 514, Cr.P.C., but that section is inapplicable because the bond was taken by a police officer and not by a Court; therefore the Magistrate lacked jurisdiction to proceed under S. 514.
  • Reliance on Rameshwar Bhatia v. State of Assam (AIR 1952 S.C. 405) to support the proposition that S. 514 applies only where the bond was taken by a Court.
  • The bond was vague and defective because it failed to specify the place where Magan Bhikha was required to attend, contrary to the requirement of S. 499, Cr.P.C.; reliance on Bhalu v. State of Punjab (AIR 1962 Punj 228) to argue that a bond obliging attendance "at the wishes of the police" is defective and makes forfeiture illegal.

The opinion does not set out a detailed, separate statement of the respondent State's opposing legal submissions; the court's analysis reflects the legal positions it considered in response to the petitioner's contentions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rameshwar Bhatia v. State of Assam, AIR 1952 S.C. 405 Held that S. 514, Cr.P.C. was inapplicable where the bond was executed in favour of a Procurement Officer (i.e., a bond to a non‑Court officer for production of property), and action under S. 514 arises only when the bond is taken by the Court. The court examined the facts of that case and distinguished it: Rameshwar Bhatia dealt with a bond given to a Procurement Officer for production of property, not a bond for the accused's personal attendance taken by a police officer. The court concluded Rameshwar Bhatia does not preclude forfeiture under S. 514 where the bond is for appearance and taken by the police for presentation before a Court; thus the precedent was held not to be helpful to the petitioner.
Bhalu v. State of Punjab, AIR 1962 Punj 228 Held that a surety bond requiring attendance "at the wishes of the police" is defective and an order for forfeiture and penalty is illegal because the bond does not specify the place required by S. 499, Cr.P.C. The court relied on this principle to conclude that the present bond—requiring attendance "wherever called upon" by the police officer and lacking a specified place—was vague and defective. On that basis the court set aside the Magistrate's order forfeiting the bond and ordering recovery.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two principal analytical stages corresponding to the petitioner's two main contentions.

First, the court addressed the jurisdictional argument under S. 514, Cr.P.C. It recited sub-section (1) of Section 514 and analysed the section as dealing with two classes of bonds:

  • Bonds taken by a Court under the Code (in which case the Court that took the bond, or a Presidency Magistrate or Magistrate of the first class, may initiate proceedings under S. 514); and
  • Bonds given for appearance before a particular Court (which include bonds taken by police officers for appearance before a Court), in which case the particular Court before which appearance was required can initiate the proceedings under S. 514.

The court found that the present bond was for the accused's appearance and was taken by the Police Station Officer (i.e., the bond fell within the second class). Therefore, the learned trial Magistrate had jurisdiction under the latter part of S. 514 to entertain proceedings for forfeiture and recovery. The court rejected the petitioner's broad reading of Rameshwar Bhatia, noting that in that case the bond was to a Procurement Officer for production of property and not a bond for personal appearance before a Court; accordingly Rameshwar Bhatia did not support the petitioner's contention that S. 514 can never apply where a police officer took the bond.

Second, the court turned to the petitioner's contention that the bond was defective because it did not specify the place where the accused was to attend, as required by S. 499, Cr.P.C. The court:

  • Quoted S. 499 (the requirement that a bond be conditioned that the person "shall attend at the time and place mentioned in the bond");
  • Observed that specifying the place is an essential, mandatory requirement of S. 499 when a person is released on bail or on bond;
  • Noted the principle that penal surety bonds must be strictly construed and invoked the ordinary meaning of "mention" (to specify) to emphasise that a bond stating attendance "at the wishes of the police" does not fulfil the statutory requirement;
  • Accepted the relevance of Bhalu v. State of Punjab, which held that a bond obliging attendance "at the wishes of the police" is defective and renders forfeiture illegal.

Applying these legal principles to the present bond, which required Magan Bhikha to attend "wherever called upon" by the Billimora Police Station Officer and did not specify a place, the court concluded the bond was vague and defective under S. 499 and binding rules of strict construction for penal bonds. Consequently, although the Magistrate had jurisdiction under S. 514, the particular bond could not validly support forfeiture and recovery.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court's ultimate ruling was to allow the revision application. The court found that although the trial Magistrate had jurisdiction to proceed under S. 514 for a bond taken by a police officer for appearance, the specific surety bond in this case was defective for failing to specify the place of attendance as required by S. 499, Cr.P.C. Therefore the order forfeiting the bond and directing recovery of Rs. 200 was set aside.

DISPOSITION: The revision application is allowed; the Magistrate's order forfeiting the bond and ordering recovery of Rs. 200 from the petitioner is set aside.

Implications: The direct effect is the quashing of the attachment/forfeiture order and the discharge of liability to pay the Rs. 200 penalty under the challenged order. The opinion applies and distinguishes existing precedent (Rameshwar Bhatia) and follows the principle in Bhalu v. State of Punjab; it does not purport to create a new legal principle beyond applying statutory requirements (S. 499 and S. 514) and existing case law to the facts before it.

Order pronounced: Application allowed.

    Chhaganlal Kikabhai v. State Of Gujarat Opponent.

    1. This is a Criminal Revision Application filed by one Chhaganlal Kikabhai, who stood surety for one Mangan Bhikha who was arrested by the police head constable, Billimora Police Station on March 18, 1962, for having committed an offense under S. 85(1)(2) of the Bombay Prohibition Act. On March 19, 1962, the Police Head Constable took a surety bond, from the petitioner which is in the following terms:

    “I, Xhhaganlal Kikabbai resident of village Bhatha, Taluka Gandevi is required to give a surety bond. I therefore, bind myself that Magan Bhikha shall attend wherever called upon, and on such dates of the month and year as may be directed, by the Billimora Police Station Officer and shall continue to so attend until otherwise directed by the said police officer. In case of making a de fault in that respect, I bind myself to pay a penalty of Rs. 200/- Rupees two hundred only, to the Bharat Government.”

    2. The bond was signed by the petitioner in the presence of the Police Head Constable in charge of the Billimora Police Station. As Magan Bhikha was found absconding, a notice was issued by the Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Gandevi to the petitioner to produce him in the Court. The Police Heal Constable, Billimora submitted a report that the petitioner stated to him that he did not stand surety for the accused and he did not know him. The learned Magistrate thereafter examined the Police Head Constable on August 23, 1966 who deposed that on March 19, 1962 he was the officer in charge of the Police Station and the present petitioner had execute ed the surety bond. In view of this evidence of the Police Head Constable, the learned Magistrate issued a notice against the surety as to why the amount of Rs. 200/- should not be recovered from him. In response to this notice the surety appeared and filed an application that Magan Bhikha was serving in the Gaiyekwad Mills, Billimora and requested for time to give reply to the notice. On September 14, 1966, the petitioner filed another application stating that he did not stand surety for Magan Bhikha and the notice issued against him should be discharged. The learned Magistrate, thereafter heard the petitioner and ordered to issue an attachment warrant to recover the amount of Rs. 200/- from him. Being aggrieved by the said order, the petitioner filed a Criminal Appeal No. 48 of 1967 in the Court of Sessions Judge, Bulsar. The said appeal was allowed by the learned Sessions Judge and the order passed by the learned Magistrate was set aside and the case was remanded to the trial Court for disposal according to law. The reason for setting aside the order was that the evidence of the Police Station Officer was not recorded in the presence of the surety. On remand, the learned trial Magistrate examined the Police Station Officer in the presence of the petitioner. The petitioner was also given an opportunity to cross-examine him. The learned Magistrate thereafter considered the evidence on the record and issued attachment warrant to the Police Sub-Inspector, Billimora, to recover the sum of Be. 200/- from the surety within 7 days. Being aggrieved by the order the petitioner preferred a Criminal Appeal No. 3 of 1967 in the Court of Sessions Judge. Balsar at Navsari. The said appeal was heard by the learned Sessions Judge who was pleased to dismiss the same. It is against this order that this revision application is filed by the petitioner. Mr. Shethna appearing for the petitioner contended that the order for recovery of Rs. 200/. from the petitioner was passed under S. 514 of the Criminal Procedure Code but the said section was inapplicable to the facts of the present case. The argument of Mr. Shethna was that the bond was taken by the Police officer and not by the Court and therefore, the provisions of S. 514, Criminal Procedure Code were not applicable and that the said order passed by the learned Magistrate was without jurisdiction.

    3. Now sub-section (1) of Section 514 of the Criminal Procedure Code reads asunder:—

    “Whenever it is proved to the satisfaction of the Court by which a bond under this Code has been taken, or of the Court of Presidency Magistrate or Magistrate of the first class, or, when the bond is for appearance before a Court, to the satisfaction of such Court.

    That such bond has been forfeited, the Court shall record the grounds of such proof, and may call upon any person bound by such bond to pay the penalty thereof, or to show cause why it should not be paid.

    4. This section lays down the procedure for the forfeiture of bonds. It deals with two classes of bonds; first class is when a bond under this Code has been taken by any Court, and then it is that Court alone or the Court of the Presidency Magistrate or a Magistrate of the first class that can initiate the proceeding under the section; and the second class, is when a bond is for appearance in a particular Court and then it is only that Court which can start a proceeding for forfeiture. The bonds of the second class will include those taken by the police officer for appearance before a Court. In the present case the bond was for appearance of the accused Magan Bhikha and was taken by the Police Station Officer. The petitioner Stood surety and gave on undertaking that Magan Bhikha would attend whenever and wherever called upon by the Police Station Officer. Therefore, the present case is governed by the provisions of the latter part of S. 514 because the surety was directed to produce Magan Bhikha before the Court by the Police Station Officer and he failed to do so. It is evident, therefore, that the learned trial Magistrate had the jurisdiction to pass the impugned order under S. 514 of Criminal Procedure Code. The contention of Mr. Shethna that the provisions of S. 514 of the Criminal Procedure Code are inapplicable to the facts of this case and that the impugned order is without jurisdiction is rejected.

    5. Mr. Shethna further relied on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Rameshwar Bhatia v. State of Assam, AIR 1952 S.C 405 and particularly relied on the following observations in the said judgment:

    “The High Court was in error in thinking that S. 514, Criminal P.C, applied. Action could be taken only when the bond is taken by the Court under the provisions of the Code such as S. 91 for appearance, the several security sections or those relating to bail……. The language is perfectly dear: the power to forfeit and the imposition of the penalty provided for in the later parts of the section arise only if the preliminary conditions are satisfied”.

    6. In order to understand the said observations it is necessary to consider the facts of that case. The facts were that one Rameshwar Bhatia a shop-keeper, was in possession of food-grains in excess of the quantity permitted by the Assam Food Grains Control Order, 1947. The shop was raided and the Procurement Inspector allowed the stock of paddy with Rameshwar Bhatia under a security bond by which an undertaking was taken from Rameshwar that the seized paddy would be produced before the Court. The bond was executed in favour of the Procurement Inspector. Rameshwar was subsequently unable to produce the paddy before the Court as the whole of it was taken away by a Congress M.L.A for affording relief to those who suffered in the earthquake. Rameshwar was ordered to procure a similar quantity of paddy after taking an appropriate licence, and to make over the same to the procurement department. Against this order a reference was made to the High Court under S. 438 of the Criminal P.C, for enhancement of sentence by the District Magistrate. The reference was accepted by the High Court and the sentence was enhanced. As regards the security bond the case was remanded to the trial Court for taking action according to S. 514 of the Criminal P.C, for its forfeiture. Against the order of conviction and the order of remand an appeal was filed in the Supreme Court. Their Lordships held that the provisions of S. 514 of Criminal P.C, were inapplicable because the bond was given to the Procurement Officer. It is in light of these facts that their Lordships held that the action could be taken under the provisions of S. 514, of Criminal P.C only when the bond is taken by the Court. The only thing that was decided by the Court was that when the bond was for production of the property and executed in favour of the Procurement Officer the provisions of S. 514 of the Criminal P.C, could not apply. The Supreme Court did not purport to lay down that when a bail bond is for the appearance of the accused and is taken by a police officer under the provisions of the Criminal P.C, the bond cannot be forfeited under S. 514 of the Criminal Procedure Code. It is dear, therefore, the aforesaid observations in Rameshwar Bhatia's case AIR 1952 S.C 405 (Supra) can be of no help to Mr. Shethna. As already stated in the present case the bond was for appearance of the accused and was governed by the latter part of S. 514 of the Criminal P.C and the learned trial Magistrate bad jurisdiction to pass the order under said Section.

    7. The second contention of Mr. Shethna was that the bond was vague as it did not mention the place where Magan Bhika had ta attend whenever called upon by the Billimora Police Station Officer. The argument was that the provisions of S. 499, Criminal P.C required that it should be specifically stated in the surety bond that the accused should remain present at a particular place. In other words the place where the accused is required to be present should be specified in the bond. In the present case it is mentioned in the surety bond that Magan Bhikha had to remain present wherever Billimora Police Station Officer directed him to do so, and therefore, no specific place was mentioned in the bond as to where Magan Bhikba was required to attend. The provisions of S. 499, sub-s. (1) real as under:—

    “Before any person is released on bail or released on his own bond, a bond for such sum of money as the police officer or Court, as the case may be, thinks sufficient shall be executed by such person, and, when he is released on bail, by one or more sufficient sureties conditioned that such person shall attend at the time and place mentioned in the bond, and shall continue be to attend until otherwise directed by the police officer or Court, as the case may be”.

    8. The provisions requiring the mentioning of the place where the accused has to remain present is an essential requirement of the Section. It is again well established that a surety bond which is penal in its nature should be strictly construed. The “Shorter Oxford English Dictionary” defines the word “mention” as meaning “to specify by name or otherwise in words”. Therefore, when it is stated in the surety bond that person hag to remain present at the wishes of the police, it cannot be said to be a bond in accordance with the provisions of S. 499, Criminal P.C The provisions of S. 499 so fac as the mentioning of the place where the accused is requited to remain present are mandatory.

    9. Mr. Shethna relied on the decision in the case of Bhalu v. State of Punjab, AIR 1962 Punj 228, where it has been held that where a surety bond is for attendance of a person at the wishes of the police, the bond is defective and the order for forfeiture and for payment of penalty is illegal. The bond in the present case when it directs that Magan Bhikha has to remain present wherever called upon by the Police Station Officer is vague and defective in that respect. I, therefore, set aside the order passed by the learned Magistrate forfeiting the bond and ordering the recovery of Rs. 200/. by attachment of the property of the petitioner. The result is that the revision application is allowed. Orders accordingly.

    LGC/DVC

    10. Application allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chhaganlal Kikabhai v. State Of Gujarat Opponent.
    (Nov 15, 1967)