Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Two writ petitions were filed by works contract labourers (engaged on a daily wage of Rs. 47.21) employed through contractors at Oil India Ltd. (respondent no. 2). The petitions seek (a) regularisation of their services, (b) payment of equal wages with their counterparts (as detailed in Annexure III to the writ petitions), and (c) quashing of a Government letter dated 23 November 1994 which refused to refer their dispute to the Industrial Tribunal.

The petitioners contend that, though formally engaged through contractors, they are in truth direct workmen of Oil India Ltd., having performed perennial functions for several years. They are members of the Oil India Workers Association, which pressed for their regularisation. The Association entered into an agreement with Asom Tailo Thikadari Shramik Santha and secured regularisation for its members, excluding the petitioners. The Regional Labour Commissioner (Guwahati) attempted conciliation and referred the matter to the Central Government under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947; the Central Government refused to refer the dispute to the Industrial Tribunal by letter dated 23 November 1994.

Oil India Ltd., in opposition, asserted that the petitioners are contract labour within the meaning of the Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1970, and therefore the reliefs sought under Article 226 (regularisation) are not available; instead the appropriate remedy lies under Section 10 of the 1970 Act. Oil India denied the petitioners' alleged continuous long service and membership of the Association, stated that a tripartite committee and a tripartite settlement of 14 February 1991 provided for phased regularisation of 456 workers (whose recommendations were accepted), and explained that some petitioners did not meet the criteria for inclusion.

The Central Government's letter of 23 November 1994 (quoted in the opinion) recorded that, having considered the Conciliation Report, it was of the opinion under Section 12(5) of the Industrial Disputes Act that the dispute was not fit for reference because the workmen were engaged as contract labour under the Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970, and such contract labourers are not entitled to regularisation by the principal employer.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners are direct employees of Oil India Ltd. (such that they can seek regularisation/absorption and raise an industrial dispute) or whether they are works contract labourers falling under the Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1970.
  2. Whether the Central Government's refusal (letter dated 23 November 1994) to refer the dispute to the Industrial Tribunal under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 can be legally challenged in these writ petitions.
  3. Whether relief in the form of regularisation under Article 226 can be granted to the petitioners, or whether the appropriate course is to invoke Section 10 of the Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1970 for abolition of contract labour and consequent absorption.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners asserted that, although nominally engaged through contractors, they are in reality direct workmen of Oil India Ltd., having worked continuously for several years and discharged perennial functions.
  • They claimed discriminatory treatment because members of the Oil India Workers Association were regularised under an agreement while they and other similarly situated workers were excluded.
  • They contended that the Central Government's refusal to refer the matter to the Industrial Tribunal violated Article 16 (equal treatment) of the Constitution, and thus sought relief by way of writ petitions.

Respondent (Oil India Ltd.)'s Arguments

  • Oil India Ltd. contended that the petitioners are works contract labourers within the meaning of the Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970, and therefore the High Court cannot grant relief under Article 226 directing regularisation; instead, the appropriate Government may act under Section 10 of the 1970 Act.
  • The company denied that the petitioners had continuous service of 5–15 years or that they discharged perennial functions for the principal employer, and denied their claimed membership of the Oil India Workers Association.
  • To maintain industrial peace the company had agreed to a committee (management, unions representing contract labourers, and respondent 4) to identify contract labourers who fulfill the conditions in Section 10(2) of the 1970 Act; on consideration the committee's recommendations resulted in a tripartite settlement of 14 February 1991 regularising 456 workers. Some petitioners did not meet the criteria and were therefore excluded.
  • Counsel for respondents relied on a decision of this High Court (Indian Oil Corporation, Ltd. v. Presiding Officer [1998 (2) G.L.T. 67]) to argue that the dispute should be resolved under the Contract Labour Act and that the Central Government's refusal to refer to the Industrial Tribunal cannot be legally impugned unless the conditions of Section 10(2) are satisfied and the Central Government is so satisfied.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Indian Oil Corporation, Ltd. v. Presiding Officer [1998 (2) G.L.T. 67] Considered as a High Court decision addressing abolition/regularisation under Section 10 and the consequences of such abolition for contract labourers. The court treated this decision as a similar matter which took into consideration Apex Court authorities; it relied on its reasoning to support that Section 10 is the proper route and that reference to the Industrial Tribunal may frustrate the purpose where abolition/absorption is intended.
Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narayan [1975 Supp SCC 1 : A.I.R. 1975 S.C. 2299] Cited in the context of the power of judicial review and its place as part of the Constitution's basic structure. Used among authorities to support the proposition that the High Court has the constitutional duty and power of judicial review to enforce rights and to mould relief where workmen's rights under the statute are violated.
Shankar Mukherjee v. Union of India [1990 Supp SCC 668 : A.I.R. 1990 S.C. 532] Included among Apex Court decisions considered in the line of authorities relating to abolition/absorption issues. Considered by the court as part of the body of Apex Court decisions informing the proper approach where abolition under Section 10 is involved.
Gujarat Electricity Board v. Hind Mazdoor Sabha [1995 (2) L.L.N. 59] Represents an alternative scheme referenced in the authorities; its scheme was distinguished by the court. The court stated that recourse to the scheme suggested in this decision "cannot be the correct answer" where the appropriate Government intends absorption under Section 10; thus the court did not follow that scheme for the present facts.
Air India Statutory Corporation v. United Labour Union [1997 (1) L.L.N. 75] Held that on abolition of contract labour under Section 10 the intermediary ceases to exist and contractor workmen become direct employees of the principal employer; endorsed the intent that such workmen are to be absorbed. The court relied on this decision as authoritative: it was used to state the legal consequence of abolition (disappearance of the intermediary and absorption), and to emphasise the High Court's power to mould relief and enforce the law where violations occur.
Bommai [(1994) 3 SCC 1 : A.I.R. 1994 S.C. 1918] Cited as part of the chain of cases establishing judicial review as a constitutional function and part of the basic structure. Invoked to support the principle that the High Court's power of judicial review is broad and can be exercised to enforce statutory provisions and protect workmen's rights.
(1974) 1 SCC 596 : A.I.R. 1974 S.C. 960; 1995 Supp (3) SCC 579; (1994) 5 SCC 304 These authorities were relied upon by petitioners (as stated in the opinion). The court noted that these decisions, relied upon by petitioners, "do not alter the position" reached by the court in this matter and therefore did not change the direction to seek relief under Section 10 of the 1970 Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the factual allegations, the documents on record, and the submissions of counsel. It observed difficulty in concluding, on the available materials, that an employer–employee relationship existed between Oil India Ltd. and the petitioners. The Central Government's refusal (dated 23 November 1994) to refer the matter to the Industrial Tribunal was founded on the same factual conclusion: the workmen were engaged as contract labour under the Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970, and thus were not direct employees entitled to regularisation by the principal employer.

The court noted there was no documentary evidence indicating that the petitioners were paid by Oil India Ltd.; given the categorical denials by the company and the absence of documentary proof, the court concluded that any attempt to determine their employment status by adjudication in the writ proceedings would be futile. Consequently, the court stated it was unable to uphold the petitioners' claim to have the matter referred to the Industrial Tribunal.

The court turned to the statutory framework of the Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970. Relying on this statutory scheme and prior decisions (including this High Court's own decision in Indian Oil Corporation, Ltd. v. Presiding Officer and several decisions of the Supreme Court and other benches), the court explained the legal consequence of abolition under Section 10: the intermediary (contractor) ceases to exist and the contractor's workmen become direct employees of the principal employer, with absorption as a concomitant result. The court emphasized that where the appropriate Government intends abolition and absorption, the proper course is to issue a notification under Section 10 rather than to frustrate that purpose by referring the matter for adjudication under the Industrial Disputes Act.

The court also reiterated the High Court's role and power of judicial review to enforce statutory provisions and protect workmen's rights, citing authorities that treat judicial review as part of the Constitution's basic structure and as a means for courts to mould relief where statutory violations are found.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSITION: Both writ petitions are disposed of with a direction that the petitioners may take up the matter with the appropriate Government for consideration of abolition of contract labour by issuing the necessary notification under Section 10 of the Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970.

Direct Effect on the Parties: The petitioners' writs were not upheld in the sense of ordering their regularisation by Oil India Ltd. The court declined to refer the dispute to the Industrial Tribunal and directed that the petitioners pursue the statutory route under Section 10. On receipt of such a request or representation, the appropriate Government is directed to dispose of it in accordance with the law, expeditiously and preferably within a period of six (6) months.

Broader Implications: The opinion applies established principles (as discussed in prior authorities) that abolition under Section 10 can lead to absorption of contractor workmen and that the proper remedy in such cases is action by the appropriate Government under the Contract Labour Act. The court did not purport to create a new precedent; instead it relied on existing lines of authority to explain that the statutory mechanism of Section 10 is the appropriate and effective route for securing absorption/regularisation where abolition of contract labour is intended. The court recorded: "No order as to costs."

    Prem Mahali And Others v. Union Of India And Others

    1. Both the writ petitions have been preferred by the works contract labourers engaged on daily wage of Rs. 47.21 by the Oil India Ltd., respondent 2 for regularisation of their services and for payment of equal wages with their counterpart as detailed in Annexure III of both the writ petitions-vis-a-vis for quashing the Government order communicated vide letter, dated 23 November, 1994, refusing to refer the matter to the Industrial Tribunal.

    2. The petitioners' case is that although they are working as works contract labourers under various contractors, in fact they are the direct workmen under the Oil India, Ltd., for all intention and purposes and working as such without any interruption for the last several years discharging various functions of perennial nature. The petitioners are also members of Oil India Workers Association and the said Association espoused the cause of the petitioners for regularisation of their services. The Oil India, Ltd., entered into an agreement with Asom Tailo Thikadari Shramik Santha and regularised the services of workers who are members of the said association to the exclusion of the petitioners and other workers similarly situated. According to the petitioners, this is a case of discrimination between the similiarly situated workers. The attempt by the Regional Labour Commissioner, Guwahati, to resolve the dispute having failed, the Regional Labour Commissioner referred the matter to the Government of India as per provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. The Union of India eventually refused to refer the dispute to the Industrial Tribunal for adjudication. The negative approach by the Oil India, Ltd., and the Union of India being violative or the provisions of Art. 16 of the Constitution, the petitioners have filed these two (2) writ petitions to vindicate their cause.

    3. The Oil India, Ltd., however, in their affidavit-in-opposition submitted that the writ-petitioners are works contract labourers within the meaning of the Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1970, and, as such, no relief can be given to them by this Court under Art. 226 of the Constitution as industrial dispute cannot be raised for regularisation of services of works contract labourers. The appropriate Government may, however, deal with the situation as per provisions of S. 10 of the Act of 1970. The respondent Oil India, Ltd. also denied that the writ-petitioners are working for about 5 to 15 years under them discharing works perennial in nature. The list of workers (Annexure 1) and their status as workmen under the Oil India, Ltd., has also been denied vis-a-vis their claim of membership with Oil India Workers Association. It is submitted that in order to maintain peace, the company agreed to constitute a committee comprising representatives of the management, the unions representing the works contract labourers and respondent 4, to identify the works contract labourers (excluding work charge labourers) who fulfill the conditions mentioned in Sub-sec. (2) of S. 10 of the Act of 1970. On proper consideration of the recommendations made by the committee, tripartite settlement was signed on 14 February, 1991, and the recomendations of the committee for regularisation of 456 workers were accepted. The Oil India Workers Association refused to become signatory to the said agreement although they had taken part in the exercise undertaken by the committee. It is contended that some of the petitioners who did not fulfill all the criteria were left out. The agreement referred to above provided for regularisation of 456 works contract labourers in a phased manner and the petitioners not being workmen are not entitled to regularisation. Therefore, no writ could be issued under Art. 226 directing their regularisation in the services of the Oil India, Ltd.

    4. The factual details reproduced above show that the writ-petitioners are works contract labourers working under the contractors and they are not the direct employees of the Oil India, Ltd. Sri Sarma, learned counsel for the respondents, referring to the above position argued that there being no relationship of employer and employee between the Oil India Ltd., and the writ-petitioners and the cause of the works contact labourers not having being espoused by the direct employers, the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act cannot be invoked. On this proposition, Sri Sarma further argued that the refusal by the Central Government to refer the dispute to the Industrial Tribunal cannot be legally questioned. Placing reliance on a decision of this High Court in Indian Oil Corporation, Ltd. v. Presiding Officer [1998 (2) G.L.T 67], Sri Sarma argued that the alleged dispute has to be resolved as per provisions of the Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1970, provided that the Central Government is satisfied that the writ petitioners fulfil the conditions embodied in Sub-sec. (2) of S. 10 of the above Act.

    5. Sri S.S Dey, learned counsel for the writ-petitioners, however, did not dispute the legal position as advanced by Sri Sarma But he argued at length to show that the writ-petitioners are the direct employees of the Oil India, Ltd. On careful consideration of the submission advanced on behalf of the parties and the documents on record, I am of the opinion that it would be difficult to conclude on the basis of the materials available that a relationship of employer and employee exists between the Oil India Ltd., and the writ-petitioners. The refusal by the Central Government vide letter, dated 23 November, 1994, is also based on similar consideration. The letter reads as follows:

    “No. 29012/(20/93 IR (Misc)/(Coal-I) Government of India/Barat Sarkar Ministry of Labour/Sharma Mantralaya

    New Delhi, dated 23 November, 1994

    (1) The Group General Manager, Oil India Ltd, Duliajan, P.O Duliajan, District-Dibrugarh.

    (2) The President, Oil India Workers' Association, Oil India, Ltd. Duliajan, P.O Duliajan, District-Dibrugarh.

    (3) Sri Khira Phukan, Oil India, Ltd., MES Depot, Duliajan.

    Subject: I.D Between the management of Oil India, Ltd., Duliajan and Oil India Workers' Association, Duliajan, over regularisation of WCLs at Duliajan.

    I am directed to refer to the failure of Conciliation Report No. 8(13)/94. Con, dated 24 June, 1993, received from the Regional Labour Commissioner (C), Guwahati, on the subject noted above and to say that the Central Government, having considered the said report in terms of S. 12(5) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, is of the opinion that the dispute is not fit for reference to the Industrial Tribunal for adjudication on the following grounds:

    ‘It has been reported that the workmen were engaged as contract labour under provisions of the Contract Labourers (R & A) Act, 1970. Such contract labourers are not entitled to regularisation by the Principal employer.’

    Yours faithfully,

    (Braj Mohan)

    Desk Officer

    Tel. No. 3718119

    copy forwarded to:

    (1) Regional Labour Commissioner (C), Guwahati.

    (2) Guard folder.”

    6. It would appear from the contents of the letter above that the Central Government turned down the proposal for reference of the matter to the Industrial Tribunal as the workman were engaged as contract labourers under the provisions of the Act of 1970 which obviously denotes that they are not the direct employees of the principal employer. In view of the categorical denial of the alleged relationship of employer and employees, and, especially, when there is no documentary evidence to show that they are being paid by the Oil India, any attempt to adjudge their status would be nothing short of a futile exercise. This Court is, therefore, unable to uphold the claim of the writ-petitioners in order to refer the matter to the Industrial Tribunal. The uncertainty can be dispelled and the ordeal surpassed only by resorting to the provisions of the Act of 1970, provided they fulfill the conditions mentioned in Sub-sec. (2) of S. 10.

    7. While dealing with a similar matter, this Court in Indian Oil Corporation, Ltd. v. Presiding Officer (vide supra), took into consideration the decision rendered in Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narvana [1975 Supp SCC 1 : A.I.R 1975 S.C 2299], Shankar Mukherjee v. Union of India [1990 Supp SCC 668 : A.I.R 1990 S.C 532], Gujarat Electricity Board v. Hind Mazdoor Sabha [1995 (2) L.L.N 59], Air India Statutory Corporation v. United Labour Union [1997 (1) L.L.N 75], and held as follows:

    “11. The Apex Court clearly lays down that on abolition of the contract labour as per provisions of S. 10 of the Act, the intermediary, i.e, the contractors cease to exist and the workmen of the contractor become direct employees of the principal employer, the concomitant result being the absorption of the erstwhile workmen as regular employees under the principal employer. The Act though does not provide any express provision for such consequence on abolition of contract labour, the Apex Court, interpreting the Act, made bare the ‘intent’ of the Legislature. Therefore, recourse to the scheme as suggested in Gujarat Electricity Board [1995 (2) L.L.N 59] (vide supra), cannot be the correct answer in a case where the appropriate Government intends absorption of the workmen of the contract labourers in the establishment of principal employer. This view is manifest in Para. 69 of the judgment reported in 1997 (1) L.L.N 75] (vide supra).

    12. Keeping in mind the law as laid down by the Apex Court and having regard to the purpose of reference made in the instant case, it can be unhesitatingly said that this reference will frustrate the purpose sought to be achieved instead of ameliorating the plight of the workmen. In a case where the appropriate Government is of the opinion that the system of ‘contract labour’ prevailing in any establishment is to be abolished for permanent absorption of the workmen, the only course available for immediate relief is to issue a notification under S. 10 of the Act. Therefore, the judgment under appeal based on the ratio of Gujarat Electricity Board (vide supra), cannot be sustained as the impugned reference is contrary to law.”

    8. The provision of law as discussed above is the only answer to the problem at hand. The Supreme Court has also provided safeguard to the workmen in the event of violation of this law in the following words, in Para. 60, at page 113 of 1997 (1) L.L.N:

    “The founding fathers placed on limitation of letters on the power of the High Court under Art. 226 of the Constitution except self-imposed limitations. The arm of the Court is long enough to reach injustice wherever it is found. The Court as sentinal in the qui vive is to mete out justice in given facts. On finding that either the workmen were engaged in violation of the provisions of the Act or were continued as contract labour, despite prohibition of the contract labour under S. 10(1), the High Court has, by judicial review as the basic structure, constitutional duty to enforce the law by appropriate directions. The right to judicial review is now a basic structure of the Constitution by catena of decisions of this Court starting from Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narayan (vide supra) and Bommai case [(1994) 3 SCC 1 : A.I.R 1994 S.C 1918]. It would, therefore, be necessary that instead of leaving the workmen in the lurch the Court would properly mould the relief and grant the same in accordance with law.”1997 (1) L.L.N 75

    9. It would appear from above that in all cases, regularisation/absorption of the workmen engaged on contractual labourers has to be dealt with within the provisions of the Act. On abolition of contract labour under S. 10 of the Act, the intermediary vanishes and a direct relationship between the principal employer and the works contract labourers is established. The principal employer then is legally bound to regularise the services of the contract labourers in the establishment. The power of judicial review, in case of breach thereof, will always be available to the workmen to vindicate their cause.

    10. In the cases at hand, considering the factual background as above, it would suffice to hold that the writ-petitioners may take up the matter with the appropriate Government for consideration for abolition of contract labour by issuing necessary notification under S. 10 of the Act. The ratio laid down in (1974) 1 SCC 596 : A.I.R 1974 S.C 960, 1995 Supp (3) SCC 579 and (1994) 5 SCC 304, relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioners do not alter the position.

    11. In the result, both the writ petitions are disposed of with the direction that the petitioners may like to take up the matter with the appropriate Government for abolition of contract labour as per provisions of S. 10 of the Act. On receipt of such request/representation, the appropriate Government shall dispose of the same in accordance with the provisions of law expeditiously, preferably within a period of 6 (six) months.

    12. No order as to costs.

    13. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prem Mahali And Others v. Union Of India And Others
    (Apr 6, 1999)