Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Article 14 and 16(i) of the Constitution
  • provisions of rule 5 of the Temporary Service Rules,
  • Civil Rule 2020 of 1992 and analoguous Civil Rules
  • Civil Rule No. 44 of 1996, 45 of 1996 and 46 of 1996
  • Civil Rule Nos. 394/95, 575/95 and 680/95, 24
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • ARTICLE 311 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • provisions of Temporary Service Rules.
  • Civil Rule Nos. 44, 45 and 46 of 1996
  • Civil Rule Nos. 1202/92, 615/94
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Article 14 and 16(i) of the Constitution
  • provisions of rule 5 of the Temporary Service Rules,
  • Civil Rule 2020 of 1992 and analoguous Civil Rules
  • Civil Rule No. 44 of 1996, 45 of 1996 and 46 of 1996
  • Civil Rule Nos. 394/95, 575/95 and 680/95, 24
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • ARTICLE 311 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • provisions of Temporary Service Rules.
  • Civil Rule Nos. 44, 45 and 46 of 1996
  • Civil Rule Nos. 1202/92, 615/94
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

These writ petitions were grouped because they raised common questions of fact and law concerning appointments to the post of Supervisors (ICDS) under the Social Welfare Department, Government of Manipur, and subsequent termination or regularisation decisions by the State.

In 1992 the Government advertised six posts of Supervisors under direct recruitment quota. A Departmental Promotion/Selection Committee (DPC) met from 18.11.92 to 21.11.92, selected six candidates for appointment and prepared a waiting panel of 27 candidates for future vacancies. The Government appointed the six recommended candidates. Later, the State appointed additional persons: some ad-hoc appointees were regularised (respondents 5–8) and three candidates from the waiting list (petitioners in Civil Rule Nos. 44/96, 45/96 and 46/96 at serial numbers 17, 18 and 19 of the panel) were also appointed on 24.7.95. The three were terminated by Government order dated 5.10.95.

Multiple writ petitions were filed under Article 226 challenging (a) termination of the three appointees from the waiting list and (b) the refusal to appoint other petitioners whose names appeared higher in the panel than some of those ultimately appointed. The State pleaded that the DPC's panel could not be acted upon for vacancies arising after the advertised vacancies and that certain regularisations were made under an office memorandum for ad-hoc regularisation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether appointments made from a waiting panel for vacancies that arose after the original advertised vacancies are constitutionally permissible, in particular under Articles 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution.
  2. Whether the termination of the three petitioners (appointed from the waiting list) was validly effected, including whether procedural protections (such as notice under Temporary Service Rules or opportunity to be heard under Article 311) were observed.
  3. Whether the State's regularisation of ad-hoc appointees (respondents 5 to 8) by invoking an office memorandum and relaxing eligibility conditions was legal and proper given that the posts were advertised and a DPC selection had been conducted.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners who were appointed from the panel (Sl. Nos. 17–19) were regular appointees and their services could not be terminated without an inquiry and an opportunity to be heard, invoking Article 311 of the Constitution.
  • There was a shortfall in the quota reserved for Scheduled Tribe (ST) candidates; as ST candidates named in the panel, petitioners claimed a right to appointment against the ST quota.
  • Other petitioners (in separate writs) argued that candidates appointed by the Government at lower serial numbers in the panel (including respondents 5–8 and 9–11) were appointed to the exclusion of persons whose names appeared higher on the panel, and thus the higher-ranked petitioners had a right to appointment.
  • Counsel for petitioners relied on case law (including a decision cited by him where the Supreme Court did not disturb appointments from reserved panels) to urge that the present Government appointments should not be disturbed.

Respondent/State's Arguments

  • The advertisement was only for six posts; the DPC recommended six candidates and those vacancies were filled. The panel prepared by the DPC was not approved by the State for subsequent vacancies, and the Government is required to issue fresh notification for new vacancies so eligible later candidates can compete.
  • The three ST candidates (Sl. Nos. 17–19) were erroneously appointed to meet an ST quota, but the State later realised those appointments were irregular and illegal because the advertised vacancies had already been filled; therefore those appointments were cancelled.
  • Respondents 5–8 were initially ad-hoc appointees whose services were regularised under a Government scheme/memorandum; their regularisation was not based solely on their presence in the panel but on the Government policy for ad-hoc regularisation.
  • The State relied on Supreme Court authorities (including Ashok Kr. and another leading decision) to contend that appointment from waiting list for subsequently arisen vacancies without fresh notification is unconstitutional (violative of Articles 14 and 16).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ashok Kr. v. Chairman, Banking Services Recruitment Board ((1996) 1 SCC 283 : AIR 1996 SC 976) Held that Article 14 read with Article 16(1) requires notification of vacant or expected vacancies so that all eligible candidates can be considered; recruitment in excess of notified vacancies by selecting waiting-list candidates without fresh notification is unconstitutional. The court relied on this decision to hold that appointments of the three petitioners from the waiting list (beyond the six advertised vacancies) were unconstitutional and liable to be terminated.
1994 Supp (3) SCC 308 : AIR 1994 SC 765 Held that a selection process conducted to fill a specific number of advertised vacancies cannot be used to fill other vacancies arising later; the merit list is exhausted once advertised vacancies are filled. The court cited this principle to conclude the DPC's selection was only for six vacancies and that no appointments could be made from the panel for subsequent vacancies created later.
Prem Singh v. Haryana State Electricity Board (Supreme Today 1996(2) Supreme 411) Examined appointments beyond advertised vacancies; held some appointments against reasonably anticipated vacancies may be sustained on equity, but appointments beyond a certain number were invalid. The court considered this case but distinguished it on facts: here six posts were advertised and later 53 posts were created; therefore appointments from the 1992 panel against posts created later were invalid.
Jammu & Kashmir Public Service Commission v. Dr. Narinder Mohan (cited in Division Bench extract) Stated that recruitment rules prescribing direct recruitment must be followed; ad-hoc appointments must be replaced by direct recruits and ad-hoc regularisation cannot substitute for recruitment according to rules. The court reproduced and relied on this principle to hold that ad-hoc appointees who failed to be recommended by the DPC cannot be regularised to the prejudice of regularly selected candidates.
State of Haryana v. Piara Singh ((1992) 4 SCC 118 : AIR 1992 SC 2130) Explained the approach to regularisation of ad-hoc/temporary employees: they may compete for regular posts, but if they fail selection they must give way to regularly selected persons; regularisation is not a substitute for regular recruitment. The court cited this authority to support the conclusion that ad-hoc appointees (respondents 5–8) who were not recommended by the DPC could not be regularised to the detriment of selected candidates.
Division Bench judgment in Civil Rule 2020 of 1992 and analogous Civil Rules Nos. 615/94 and 925/94 (High Court) Held that petitioners who appeared before the DPC for selection and failed must give way to regularly selected candidates; recruitment must follow rules and ad-hoc appointments cannot circumvent the selection process. The court relied on that Division Bench's findings to conclude that respondents 5–8, having failed selection, should not have been regularised and that such regularisation was unlawful in the circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through a factual and legal analysis applying the authorities cited by the parties and the State's own admissions:

  1. The DPC process in 1992 was limited to filling six advertised vacancies and produced a panel of 27 candidates for potential future use. The court accepted the settled principle from the cited Supreme Court authorities that a selection process directed at specific advertised vacancies cannot be used to fill vacancies arising later without fresh notification, because doing so would deny other candidates (who may become eligible later) a fair opportunity and would violate Articles 14 and 16(1).
  2. Applying Ashok Kr. (1996) and the 1994 decision (1994 Supp (3) SCC 308), the court held that the appointment of the three ST candidates from serial numbers 17–19 (after the six vacancies had been filled) amounted to appointment beyond the notified vacancies and therefore was illegal and unconstitutional. The court explicitly found those appointments violative of Articles 14 and 16(1).
  3. The court accepted that the State has the authority to terminate appointments which are illegal or unconstitutional. However, it examined the procedure adopted for termination. The appointment orders for the three petitioners indicated they were temporary/probationary (appointed 24.7.95 and terminated 5.10.95). Under the Temporary Service Rules (rule 5), services of temporary appointees ordinarily require one month's notice (or pay in lieu) for termination. The court found no evidence the petitioners were given such notice or pay in lieu; thus the mode of termination was procedurally defective.
  4. Because the three petitioners were reinstated by an interim order on 19.1.96, the court addressed consequences for the period between termination and reinstatement: since the appointments were ultimately found illegal and the petitioners did not perform duties during that period (5.10.95 to reinstatement), the court applied the no-work-no-pay principle and held they were not entitled to salary for that period.
  5. On the separate question of respondents 5–8 (ad-hoc appointees later regularised), the court analysed the office memorandum under which the State sought to regularise ad-hoc appointments. The court found the memorandum did not apply where posts had been advertised and where a DPC selection process had taken place; it also noted respondents 5–8 had failed to obtain recommendation by the DPC. Additionally, the Government relaxed the memorandum's 2-year requirement to cover a shortfall of four days for respondents 5–8. The court considered these factors to be misuse of executive power and held that regularisation was unlawful.
  6. The court rejected the petitioners' reliance on a Supreme Court decision where appointments were not set aside, distinguishing that precedent because in that Supreme Court matter neither the appointment nor the appointees were properly impleaded/challenged; in the present cases the appointments themselves were directly challenged and the appointees were parties.
  7. Finally, after analysing precedent (including Prem Singh), the court reiterated the central conclusion: appointments beyond the number advertised in 1992 (the six posts) from the 1992 panel are invalid; the additional posts created in 1995 could not be filled from the 1992 panel without fresh advertisement.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court disposed of all the grouped writ petitions and issued the following operative rulings:

  • DISPOSITION: All writ petitions were disposed of in accordance with the directions set out in the judgment.
  • On the three petitioners appointed from the waiting list (C.R. Nos. 44, 45 & 46 of 1996): The court held their appointments (from Sl. Nos. 17–19 of the 1992 panel) to be illegal and unconstitutional (violative of Articles 14 and 16(1)). The State Government was directed to terminate their services. However, termination must be effected in compliance with the Temporary Service Rules: the Government was directed to give the petitioners one month's notice or terminate them forthwith after paying one month's pay in lieu of notice.
  • On salary between termination and reinstatement: The court held that because the petitioners performed no duties between the termination order (5.10.95) and their reinstatement under the interim order (19.1.96), they are not entitled to salary for that period (no work, no pay).
  • On respondents 5–8 (regularisation of ad-hoc appointees): The court quashed the order of regularisation dated 20.5.95 (Annexure-B/2) as illegal and misuse of executive power, and directed the State Government to consider termination of their services in view of their failure to obtain selection by the DPC held in 1992.
  • Costs: The court made no order as to costs.

Implications: The decision enforces the principle that selection processes directed at specific advertised vacancies cannot be used to fill subsequent vacancies without fresh notification, reaffirming the application of Articles 14 and 16(1). The judgment does not purport to create new law but applies existing Supreme Court and High Court precedents to the facts at hand. The direct effects are termination (with proper notice/pay) of the three appointees made beyond the advertised vacancies, quashing of regularisation orders for the four ad-hoc appointees, and directions to the State to proceed accordingly.

    Juliate Zimik And Five Ors. v. State Of Manipur & Ors.

    1. In all these writ petitions common question of facts and law are involved and as such these writ petitions are disposed of by this common judgment.

    2. The petitioners in Civil Rule No. 44 of 1996, 45 of 1996 and 46 of 1996 have filed these writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenging the order of termination. It is stated in the petition that a DPC was constituted for appointment of 6(six) Supervisors (ICDS) under Social Welfare Department of the Govt. of Manipur under direct recruitment quota on regular basis. Accordingly, a DPC was constituted for selection of 6(six) candidates and the DPC recommended six candidates for appointment to the post of Supervisors (ICDS) and also prepared a panel of 27 candidates for appointment in the post of Supervisors which are likely to become vacant and kept the panel in a sealed cover. As per recommendation of the DPC 6(six) persons have been appointed by Government. Subsequently, 3(three) more candidates were appointed as Supervisor from the panel of wait list candidates. The Government appointed the three petitioners whose names appeared at Sl. Nos. 17, 18 and 19 of the panel by an order of the Director, Department of Social Welfare dated 24.7.95 at Annexure-A/1(a) of the writ petition. It is further stated that all the 3 petitioners were appointed on regular basis. Thereafter, on 5.10.95 the Director, Department of Social Welfare by his order at Annexure-A-2 of the writ petition, terminated the services of the petitioners with immediate effect without assigning any reason therefore. It is, further, averred that the said termination order was in gross violation of the principle of natural justice as well as in violation of Article 311 of the Constitution of India. The petitioners being regular employees should have been given a chance of hearing before issuing the aforesaid termination Order. There was no misconduct on the part of the petitioners for termination of their services. Having felt aggrieved by the order of termination, the petitioners filed the aforesaid three writ petitions. The contention of the respondents Government is that the advertisement was issued for filling up of six posts of Supervisors under direct recruitment quota and six persons recommended by the DPC were appointed by the Government. It is, further, averred that the panel was not acted upon by the Government. It is, however, admitted by the Govt, that these petitioners were erroneously appointed in the posts of Supervisors to fill up the back-log quota of ST candidates but, ultimately Government realised that the petitioners whose names appear at SI. Nos. 17, 18 and 19 of the panel cannot be appointed on two grounds, namely (i) the Govt, advertised for filling up of six posts of Supervisors under direct recruitment quota and since these posts have already been filled up by the candidates recommended by the DPC, there is no scope to appoint any person from the panel, and (ii) the names of the petitioners appeared at SI. Nos. 17, 18 and 19 and without making any appointment of the candidates appeared at SI. Nos. 1 to 16 of the panel, the Government cannot appoint the persons whose names appears in SI. Nos. 17 to 19. Having realised the mistake the Government has terminated the services of the petitione Rs.

    3. In Civil Rule Nos. 394/95, 575/95 and 680/95, 24 (twenty four) petitioners filed the aforesaid three writ petition under Arti. 226 of the Constitution. It is alleged in the petition that the Government advertised for filling up of six posts of Supervisors under the Social Welfare Department, Govt, of Manipur. A regular DPC was constituted by the Govt, and the DPC in its meeting dated 18.11.92 to 21.11.92 selected six candidates for appointment to the aforesaid six posts of Supervisors. The DPC also prepared a panel of 27 candidates for filling up of the future vacancies in the post of Supervisors. In the panel prepared by the DPC, the names of the petitioners appeared at different serial numbers. The names of the proforma respondents 5 to 8 appears at Sl. Nos. 23, 24, 25& 26 of the said panel and names of the proforma respondents 9 to 11 appears at SI. Nos. 17, 18 and 19. The Govt, appointed six candidates recommended by the DPC in order of merit in the post of Supervisors under the social welfare Department. But, subsequently, the Govt, appointed candidates whose names appears at Sl. Nos. 23, 24, 25 and 26 of the panel in the post of Supervisors to the exclusion of the present petitioners, though the names of the petitioners appeared above the names of the said four candidates in the panel prepared by the DPC in order of merit. On 20.5.95 the appointment-order of the proforma respondents-5, 6, 7 and 8 have been partially modified by the Director, Social Welfare Department. Thereafter, the Govt, appointed the candidates whose names appeared at SI. Nos. 17, 18 and 19 of the panel to the post of Supervisors by an order dated 24.7.95 It is, further, averred that the Government has adopted pick and choose policy while appointing the proforma respondents in the post of Supervisors. The Department of Social Welfare, Govt, of Manipur submitted a requisition to the Director Employment Exchange for filling up of 37 posts of Supervisors under direct recruitment quota. The filling up of the aforesaid 37 posts of Supervisors have been stayed by an interim order of this Court. It is averred that the petitioners should have been appointed against the aforesaid 37 vacant posts whose name appears in the panel prepared by the DPC in its meeting held from 18th to 21st Nov. 1992. Since the Govt, has appointed the candidates whose names appeared at SI. Nos. 17, 18 & 19 and from 23 to 26 of the panel the petitioners whose names appeared above the names of the aforesaid appointees should be appointed in the post of Supervisors on regular basis. It is further averred that the Govt, should not have regularised the ad-hoc appointment of respondents 5 to 8 in view of the order passed by the High Court on 13.1.95 in Civil Rule Nos. 1202/92, 615/94 and 925/94.

    4. One Smt. K. Rani, an ad-hoc appointee in the post of Supervisor, was selected by the DPC and her name was recommended for appointment to the post of Supervisor. Accordingly, Smt. K. Rani Devi has been appointed on regular basis. Since the Govt, has appointed respondents 5 to 11 who are much below in the panel, the petitioners have the right to be appointed in the post of Supervisors as their names appears above the names of the aforesaid respondents. Since the Government refused to appoint the petitioners to the posts of Supervisors the petitioners filed the present petitions.

    5. It is admitted by the respondents/Govt. that an advertisement was issued for filling up of six posts of Supervisors under direct recruitment quota and six candidates were appointed by the Government as per recommendation of the DPC. It is, further, stated that DPC should not have prepared a panel for filling up the post of Supervisors in future vacancies because for future vacancies the Government is required to issue fresh advertisement so that the persons who became qualified later on may have equal opportunity to apply for the post.

    6. It is stated-by respondent, State that the four per sons, respondents-5 to 8 who were appointed by an order of the Government dated 4.5.95 (Annexure: A/3) of the writ petition have not been appointed oii the basis of their names having been indicated in the panel These four candidates were appointed: on ad-hoc basis and their services were regularised by the Govt, as per scheme framed by the Government vide Memo No. 14/1/94 adhoc/DP dated 22.8.94 It is, however, admitted that the order of regularisation of the aforesaid proforma respondents were modified by an order of the Government date 20.5.95 It is, further, averred that the aforesaid four persons who are respondents 5 to 8 have been appointed not because of their names being in the panel, but because of the aforesaid Govt, policy for regularisation of ad-hoc appointment. It is also averred that Smt. Ksh. Banita Devi who was recommended by the DPC and whose name appeared at SI. No. 2 has expressed her unwillingness to accept the appointment and as such Smt. Th. Sarda Devi who was in waiting list No. 1 has been appointed out of the six posts filled up by the Government. As regards the appointment of candidates whose names appeared at SI. Nos. 17, 18 and 19 of the panel, it is stated that the aforesaid ST candidates were appointed in consideration of the fact that there were and still a shortfall in the quota reserved for ST candidates in the Grade of Supervisors. However, on realising the illegality in appointing the said 3 candidates from the panel against the vacancies that arose after the DPC of 1992, the Govt, has decided to cancel the appointment of the aforesaid three Candidates and accordingly their services were terminated. After cancelling of appointment of the 3(three) ST candidates at present there are 53 vacant post of Supervisors and the Govt, has decided to fill up 37 posts under direct recruitment quota vide Annexure-A/7 to A/9. It is further averred that the State Govt, did not give its approval to the panel prepared by the DPC for filling up the posts for future vacancies and consequently, the petitioners have no right for being considered for appointment to the posts of Supervisor that arose after the DPC in 1992. The State Government has cancelled the panel of waiting list candidates by its letter No. 29/51/89-SC (S W) dated 20.3.95 Annexure-B/4. Respondents-5 to 8 who were continuing on ad-hoc basis in the post of supervisors have been regularised in their services in pursuance, of the Office Memorandum dated 22.8.94 by condoning 4 days short fall and the aforesaid regularisation has been made in pursuance, of a common judgment and order passed on 13.1.95, in Civil Rule No. 1202 of 1992 and other analoguous Civil Rules. The services of the aforesaid proforma respondents 5 to 8 were made as per recommendation of the special DPC constituted by the Government. The appointment of any person from the waiting list beyond the number of posts advertised will be an illegality and therefore Govt, cannot be compelled to appoint the petitioners only because of their names appears in the waiting list panel.

    7. Mr. H.NK Singh, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners in Civil Rule No. 44/96, C.R No. 45/96, and C.R No. 46/96, argued that the petitioners were appointed in the post of Supervisors on regular basis as per recommendation of the DPC and their names appeared at Sl. Nos. 17, 18 and 19. The learned counsel, further, submits that there is shortfall in the quota of ST candidates in the post of Supervisors and therefore the petitioners being ST candidates have the right to be appointed against the quota reserved for ST candidates. Secondly, Mr. H.NK Singh, Id. counsel for the petitioners submits that the petitioners were appointed on regular basis and therefore their services cannot be terminated without holding any departmental inquiry and without giving them an opportunity of showing cause as required under Arti. 311 of the Constitution of India. Since the appointment of the petitioners have been terminated without making any inquiry and without giving them an opportunity of being heard, the order of termination is required to be set aside.

    8. Mr. A. Nilmani Singh, Id. counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent, State submits that the Govt, has issued the notification for filling up of 6(six) vacant posts of Supervisors under direct recruitment quota, and DPC recommended six candidates in order of merit for appointment in the said post. In addition the DPC has prepared the panel of 27 candidates for filling up of future vacancies. Mr. Nilmani Singh, further, argued that the DPC was not asked to prepare any panel for filling up of the post of Supervisors in future vacancies. Mr. Nilmani Singh, further, submits that the candidates recommended by the DPC at SI. No. 2, refused to accept the post of Supervisor arid therefore the candidate whose name appeared at SI. No. 1 of the waiting list has been appointed. Since the six posts as advertised have been filled up, the remaining panel cannot be acted upon by the Government for filling up the future vacancies specially in view of the fact that those vacancies arose after the meeting of the DPC in 1992. It is further submitted by the learned counsel that the 3 ST candidates who are the petitioners in the three writ petitions and whose names appeared in Sl. Nos. 17, 18 and 19 were initially appointed by the Govt, to fill up the quota of ST candidates, but subsequently the Govt, realised that such appointment is irregular and illegal and consequently the Govt, has terminated the services of the aforesaid three candidates. Mr. Nilmani Singh further, submits that the appointment of waiting list candidates in the vacancies arising subsequent to the notified vacancies is violative of Art. 14 of the Constitution and therefore the Government had to cancel the appointment of the three petitioners. Mr. Nilmani Singh, Id. counsel for the respondents/State relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court reported in (1996) 1 SCC 283 : AIR 1996 SC 976 (Ashok Kr. v. Chairman Banking Services Recruitment Board). In that case the Apex Court held:

    “Article 14 read with Art. 16(i) of the Constitution enshrine fundamental right to every citizen to claim consideration for appointment to post under the State. Therefore vacant post arising or expected should be notified inviting applications from all eligible candidates to be considered for their selection in accordance with their merit. The recruitment of the candidates in excess of the notified vacancies is a denial and deprivation of the constitutional right under Art. 14 read with Art. 16(1) of the Constitution. The procedure adopted, therefore, in appointing the persons kept in the waiting list by respective Board though the vacancies had arisen subsequently without being notified for recruitment, is unconstitutional.”

    9. In the present case also 6(six) vacancies were notified and Government has appointed six persons and therefore, as per above decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, there is no scope to appoint any further person from the panel without notifying the vacancies afresh. Consequently, the appointment of the 3 ST candidates whose names appeared at SI. Nos. 17, 18 and 19 the petitioners in the three aforesaid Civil Rules, and been made by the Government illegally and such appointment is unconstitutional and therefore their appointments are liable to be terminated. Mr. Nilmani Singh also relied on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in 1994 Supp (3) SCC 308 : AIR 1994 SC 765. In the aforesaid case advertisement was issued for appointment of 32 candidates to be appointed from the panel of 128 recommended by the Selection Committee and future vacancies may be filled up from the said panel. In that case the Apex Court held that the selection process were meant only to fill up the 32 vacancies and not to fill up other vacancies. The merit list prepared on the basis of the written test as well as Viva voice will hold good only for the purpose of filling up of those 32 vacancies and no further, because the said process of selection got exhausted and came to an end with the appointment of 32 candidates. If the same list as published for the subsisting vacancies are acted upon for the purpose of filling up of other vacancies also that would naturally amount to deprivation of rights of other candidates who would have become eligible subsequent to the said advertisement and said selection process. In the instant case also the selection process were meant only to fill up 6(six) vacancies and therefore after filling up of the six vacancies by the Government, the panel got exhausted and came to an end. Consequently, no candidate can be appointed from the panel of waiting list candidates against the future vacancies. The selection list prepared by the DPC got exhausted on completion of the selection process under advertisement. Consequently, I am of the clear view that the petitioners in the aforesaid 3 writ petitions have no right to be appointed as the Govt, has already appointed 6(six) candidates recommended by the DPC as per advertisement for filling up of 6(six) posts of Supervisors under direct recruitment quota.

    10. While it is true that when these three petitioners in Civil Rule Nos. 44, 45 and 46 of 1996 were illegally appointed by Government and their appointments are unconstitutional as such Govt, has a right to terminate their services. But the procedure adopted by the Govt, in terminating the services of the petitioners do not appear to be correct as according to Mr. H. NK. Singh Id. counsel for the petitioners, no opportunity has been given to the petitioners for showing cause before terminating their services. There is sufficient force in the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioners as from the order of appointment at Annexure-A/1(a) of the writ petition, it appears that the writ petitioners were appointed on temporary basis in the post of Supervisor (ICDS) and they were asked to be on probation for a period of 2 years. The order of appointment was issued on 24.7.95 and the services of the petitioners were terminated by an order of the Govt, dated 5.10.95 (Annexure-A/2). From the order of termination (Annexure-A/2), it does not appear that the petitioners were given one month's notice for terminating their services though they were on temporary basis and their appointment was terminated during the period of their probation. Even if the appointment of any public servant is proved to be illegal and unconstitutional, the public servant cannot be removed from service without following the procedure prescribed by law. In case of public servant who are holding the post on temporary basis, their services can be terminated after giving one month's notice as per provisions of Temporary Service Rules. Admittedly, in the present case the petitioners have not been declared either permanent or quasi-permanent in their posts and they are holding the posts temporarily. Therefore, I am of the view that termination of services of the petitioners without giving one month's notice as per provisions of rule 5 of the Temporary Service Rules, cannot be said to be proper and legal.

    11. Mr. H. NK. Singh, further, submits that in the case reported in (1996) 1 SCC 283 : AIR 1996 SC 976 the Apex Court did not interfere with the order of appointment even though the persons were appointed in the service from the reserved panel list. Consequently, the learned counsel submits that in the present case also the Govt, advertised for filling up of 6(six) vacant posts of Supervisors and as per recommendation of the DPC, six persons were appointed. But, subsequently the petitioners who are as SI. Nos. 17 to 19 of the waiting list were appointed by the Govt, and therefore following the aforesaid decision of the Apex Court the appointment of the petitioners in the present case may not be disturbed. I cannot agree with the submission of the Id. counsel for the petitioners, because in the aforesaid case the Apex Court held:

    “The procedure adopted, therefore, in appointing the persons kept in the waiting list by the respective Boards, though the vacancies has arisen subsequently without being notified for recruitment is unconstitutional. However, since the appointments have already been made and none was impleaded we are not inclined to interfere with these matters adversely affecting their appointments.”

    12. The present case is not similar to the aforesaid case decided by the Apex Court, because in the present case the appointment of these three petitioners have been challenged in C.R Nos. 394/95, 570/95 and 680/95. Since the appointment of three petitioners have been challenged in the aforesaid Civil Rules, the Court will have to examine the validity, legality or otherwise of the aforesaid appointment. In the present group of cases the appointment of the three petitioners in C.R Nos. 394, 395 and 680 of 1995 has been challenged and they are impleaded as respondents. I am of the view that the case law referred to by Mr. H. NK. Singh cannot apply in the present case.

    13. I have already discussed the case law reported in (1996) 1 SCC 283 : AIR 1996 SC 976 and 1994 Supp (3) SCC 308 : AIR 1994 SC 765 and according to the decision of the Apex Court, the appointment of the three petitioners from waiting list is illegal and unconstitutional. Following the aforesaid decision of the Apex Court, I am of the opinion that the appointment of the three petitioners of the three petitions namely, C.R Nos. 44, 45 and 46 of 1996 are illegal and violative of the provisions of Article 14 and 16(i) of the Constitution and as such their appointments are liable to be terminated.

    14. In the present three writ petitions, an interim order was passed by this Court on 19.1.96 In pursuance of the interim order passed by this Court on 19.1.96, the petitioners were re-instated and they are still continuing in service. In the interim order it was further directed that the period between 5.10.95 i.e the date of termination order and the date of their re-instatement in service as per the interim order of the Court will be regulated as per decision of the Court. Since the appointment of the three petitioners are illegal and unconstitutional, their appointments are to be cancelled or terminated by the Govt, and since the petitioners did not discharge any duty from 5.10.95 till the date of re-instatement as per interim order of this Court, the petitioners will not get any salary for the aforesaid period on the principle of no work no pay. The appointment of the three petitioners are found to be illegal and unconstitutional and since their appointments are challenged in Civil Rule Nos. 394/95, 570/95 and 680/95 the Government will have to terminate their services.

    15. Mr. I. Lalitkumar Singh, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners in Civil Rule Nos. 394/95, 570/95 and 680/95, argued that the respondents 5 to 8 appeared before the DPC held on 18.11.92 to 21.11.92 and their names appeared at Sl. Nos. 23 to 26 of the waiting list panel at Annexure A/1 to the writ petition. The Id. counsel consequently submits that the petitioners names appeared from serial number 2 to 22 (except SI. No. 17 to 19) of the waiting list panel and therefore the petitioners has a right of appointment in the post of Supervisors. The name of respondents 5 to 8 appears at the bottom of the merit list of the panel, therefore, the candidates who are above them are entitled to be appointed at least from the date on which respondent Nos. 5 to 8 at SI. Nos. 23 to 26 were appointed as Supervisors (ICDS). Mr. Lalit kumar also submits that the Govt, has appointed the candidates whose names appear at SI. Nos. 17 to 19 and who are made as party respondent Nos. 9 to 11 in the present case, depriving the petitioners whose names appears at SI. Nos. 2 to 16 of the waiting list. I have already discussed and found that the appointment of respondents 9 to 11 whose name appears at Sl. Nos. 17 to 19 are illegal and unconstitutional and as such the same is required to be cancelled by the Government. On the same principle the petitioners cannot claim appointment only because their names appears in the waiting list.

    16. As regards the appointment of respondents 5 to 8 whose name appears in SI. Nos. 23 to 26, Mr. A. Nilmani Singh, Id. counsel for the respondent/State submitted that these respondents were appointed by the Govt, initially on ad hoc basis and thereafter their appointments were regularised as per Scheme framed by the Govt, under Office Memorandum No. 14/1/94- adhoc/DP dated 22.8.95 at Annexure-A/3. These are not fresh appointments but regularisation of service of respondents 5 to 8 as per the aforesaid memorandum of the Govt, dated 22.8.94 at Annexure-B/1.

    17. Mr. I. Lalitkumar Singh, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners, submits that along with respondents 5 to 8 one Smt. K. Rani Devi was also appointed as Supervisor on ad hoc basis. In the DPC all the ad hoc appointees.(Respondents 5 to 8 along with K. Rani Devi) appeared and Smt. K. Rani Devi was selected on the basis of merit and the DPC recommended her name along with 5 others for appointment on regular basis against 6(six) posts advertised by the Government. It is further, submitted that respondents 5 to 8 could not get their selection by the DPC and they were placed at the bottom of the list. Mr. Lalitkumar, consequently, submits that since respondents 5 to 8 failed to get their selection in the DPC their services should not have been regularised by the Government under Office Memorandum at Annexure-B/1. The learned counsel, further submits that such back-door appointment should not be encouraged and since they have failed to get their selection in the DPC, they must give way for meritorious candidates and their ad hoc appointments should have been discontinued by the Govt. As the Govt. appointed respondents 5 to 8 whose name appears at Sl. Nos 23 to 26 the Govt, is under obligation to appoint all the persons who has better merit and who are placed above the aforesaid respondents in the reserved merit list.

    18. Mr. Lalitkumar Singh, further, argued that the Government has appointed the candidates at SI. Nos. 17 to 19 and 23 to 26 of the reserved panel list and therefore it is evident that the Govt, has acted on the reserved panel list and since the candidates at SI. Nos. 23 to 26 were appointed by the Govt, the persons above them in the merit list have a legal right to be appointed to the post of Supervisors. In support of his contention the learned counsel referred to a case law reported in ‘Supreme Today’ 1996(2) Supreme 411 (Prem Singh v. Haryana Stale Electricity Board). The relevant portion of the judgment is as follows:

    “13. In the present case, as against the 62 advertised posts the Board made appointments on 138 posts. The selection process was started for 62 clear vacancies and at that time anticipated vacancies were not taken into account. Therefore, strictly speaking the Board was not justified in more than 62 appointments pursuant to the advertisement published on 2.11.91 and the selection process which followed thereafter. But as the Board could have taken into account not only the actual vacancies but also vacancies which were likely to arise because of retirement, etc. by the time the selection process was completed it would not be just and equitable to invalidate all the appointments made on posts in excess of 62. However, the appointments which were made against future vacancies in this case on posts which were newly treated must be regarded as invalid. As stated earlier, after the selection process had started 13 posts had become vacant because of retirement and 12 because of deaths. The vacancies which were likely to arise as a result of retirement could have been reasonably anticipated by the Board. The Board through oversight had not taken them into consideration while a requisition was made for filling up 62 posts. Even with respect to the appointments made against vacancies which arose because of deaths, a lenient view can be taken and on consideration of expediency and equity they need not be quashed. Therefore, in view of the special facts and, circumstances of this case we do not think it proper to invalidate the appointments made on those 25 additional posts. But the appointments made by the Board on posts beyond 87 are held invalid. Though the High Court was right in the view it has taken we modify its order to the aforesaid extent. These appeals are allowed accordingly. No order as to costs.”

    19. In the present case the State Government made an advertisement for filling up of six posts of Supervisors under direct recruitment quota in the year, 1992. The DPC was held from 18.11.92 to 21.11.92 At that time there were only six vacant posts against which the advertisement was made. Consequently, the Govt, cannot appoint more than 6 persons and any appointment in excess of six must be invalid and unconstitutional. It is not in dispute that additional 53 posts of Supervisors were created by the Government vide Order No. 6/4/94-S (SW) dated 15.6.95 Consequently, it is apparent that these 53 posts were created along after the aforesaid six vacancies were notified. Therefore, the Government cannot appoint any person from the reserved panel list prepared by the DPC in 1992 against these 53 posts created by the Government in 1995. In the aforesaid case the Apex Court held that appointments which are made against the newly created posts must be regarded as invalid. Consequently, I am of the opinion that the aforesaid case law of the Apex Court may not be applicable in the present case at least in favour of the petitioners. I have already discussed the decision of the Apex Court reported in (1996) 1 SCC 283 : AIR 1996 SC 976 and 1994 Supp (3) SCC 308 : AIR 1994 SC 765 and also relying on the decision cited by the learned counsel for the petitioners, Mr. I. Lalitkumar Singh, it is clear that any appointment beyond the notified 6(six) posts are invalid and unconstitutional. Consequently, I have already found that the appointments of the petitioners in Civil Rule Nos. 44, 45 and 46 of 1996 are illegal and is to be cancelled. On the same principle the present petitioners of C.R No. 394, 395 and 680 of 1995 cannot claim their appointment only because their name appears in waiting panel.

    20. Now, the only question that requires to be decided is whether the regularisation of the services of respondents 5 to 8 whose name appears at SI. Nos. 23 to 26 of the reserved panel list as per the Officer Memorandum at Annexure-B/1, is valid or not.

    21. It is admitted by the Govt, that respondents 5 to 8 along with one Smt. K. Rani Devi were initially appointed on ad hoc basis as Supervisors, (ICDS). There after, when DPC was constituted in 1992 the Selection Board recommended six candidates and amongst these six candidates, the DPC recommended the name of Smt. K. Rani Devi who was at Sl. No. 3 in the merit list. Consequently, K. Rani Devi was appointed by the Government by an order dated 6.1.92 vide Annexure A/10, but the respondents 5 to 8 could not perform well before the DPC and their names appeared at SI. Nos. 23 to 26 of the reserved waiting list. It is true that in exigency of public service, the Govt, may have to resort to ad hoc appointment, but for regular appointment the ad hoc appointees must qualify themselves before the DPC or the Selection Board. In the instant case, the ad hoc appointees, respondents 5 to 8, failed to qualify in the selection test and their names were not recommended for appointment against the six posts advertised by the Govt. The stand of the Govt, is that respondents 5 to 8 were ad hoc appointees and their services were regularised as per Scheme framed by the Govt, at Annexure B/1. It appears from the Office Memorandum at Annex-B/1 that the Govt, issued the aforesaid memorandum for regularisation of services of persons who are holding posts on ad hoc basis against direct recruitment quota. In paragraph 2(i) of the aforesaid Memorandum at Annexure-B/1 it has been specifically provided, inter alia, that all posts held on ad hoc basis against direct recruitment quota which were requisitioned to the M. P.S.C for recruitment may be frozen and withdrawn unless the MPSC had already issued advertisement. Similarly, all non gazetted posts against direct recruitment quota which are held on ad hoc basis where no advertisement had so far been issued would also be covered.

    22. On a plain reading of the aforesaid provisions it is clear that where the posts has been advertised, the scheme at Annexure-B/1 will not apply. In the present case the Government has issued an advertisement for filling up of 6 posts of Supervisors (ICDS) against direct recruitment quota in 1992. The DPC selected six candidates in 1992 itself and appointment in these six posts have also been made on 6.1.92 (Annexure-A/10). All the five ad hoc appointees in the post of Supervisors appeared before the DPC in 1992. Out of the 5(five) ad hoc appointees, only one, Smt. K. Rani Devi, was recommended by the DPC for appointment. The other 4(four) ad hoc appointees who are respondents 5 to 8 were not recommended and their names appears at SI. Nos. 23 to 26 of the reserved list. Therefore, it is obvious that the aforesaid memorandum of the Govt, at Annexure-B/1 cannot apply in the case of the respondents 5 to 8 who are ad hoc appointees in the post of Supervisors and since they have failed to get the selection in the DPC in 1992, they should have made way for those duly selected candidates. But, instead of doing so, the State Govt, continued their ad hoc appointment and subsequently regularised their services by an order of the Govt, dated 20.5.95 at Annexure-B/2. Now, it is to be examined whether the regularisation made by the Govt, is legal and proper.

    23. Mr. I. Lalitkumar Singh, Id. counsel appearing for the petitioners submitted that the question of regular appointment of the respondents 5 to 8 was decided by this Court in Civil Rule 2020 of 1992 and analoguous Civil Rules Nos. 615/94 and 925 of 1994. The findings and observation of the Division Bench of this Court in paragraphs 14 and 15 of the judgment of the aforesaid cases at Annexure-A/12 are relevant and as such the relevant portion of the judgment is reproduced below:

    “14. This apart, admittedly, the petitioners also appeared before the DPC held from 18th to 21st November, 1992 for selection to the post of Supervisors. The DPC was held in terms of the Recruitment Rules for recruitment to the post of Supervisors. It is well settled principle of law that once statutory rules have been made, the appointment shall be only in accordance with the Rules. In Jammu & Kashmir Public Service Commission, etc. Appellant v. Dr. Narinder Mohan etc. Respondent the Apex Court had held in paragraph 7 of its judgment as under:

    “7 The rule prescribes direct recruitment which would be done only by PSC or promotion committee duly constituted and by no other body. Therefore, ad hoc employee should be replaced as expeditiously as possible by Direct recruits. A little leeway to make adhoc appointment due to emergent exigencies does not clothe the executive government with power to relax the recruitment or to regularise such appointment nor to claim such appointments to be regular or in accordance with rules. Back door adhoc appointments at the behest of power sources or otherwise and recruitment according to rules are mutually antagonistic and strange bed partners. They cannot co-exist in the same sheath. The former is in negation of fair play. The latter are the products of order and regularity.”

    In the case at hand, recruitment rules for the post of Supervisors only prescribes direct recruitment through selection. No other method has been prescribed by the Recruitment rules.

    15. It is also admitted that the petitioners also competed for the post in the DPC held from 18 to 21.11.92 If they are selected, well and good, but if they are not selected, they must give way to the regularly selected candidates. In this connection, we may refer to the decision of the Apex Court rendered in State of Haryana, Appellant v. Piara Singh, Respondent, (1992) 4 SCC 118 : AIR 1992 SC 2130. The Apex Court had held in paragraph 25 of its judgment as under:

    “25. Before parting with this case we think it appropriate to say a few words concerning the issue of regularisation of ad hoc/temporary employees in government service.

    The normal rule, of course, is regular recruitment through the prescribed agency but exigencies of administration may sometimes call for an ad hoc or temporary appointment to be made. In such a situation efforts should always be to replace such an ad hoc/temporary employees by a regularly selected employee as early as possible. Such a temporary employee may also compete along with others for such regular selection/appointment. If he gets selected, well and good, but if he does not, he must give way to the regularly selected candidate. The appointment of the regularly selected candidate cannot be withheld or kept in abeyance for the sake of such an ad hoc/temporary employee”.

    24. It appears from the aforesaid judgment that respondents 5 to 8 appeared before the Selection Board and learned Division Bench observed that if these ad hoc appointees (respondents 5 to 8) get their selection through the DPC it is well and good, but if they do not, then they must give way to the regularly selected candidates. In the DPC of 1992 it appears that out of 5 ad hoc appointees, only one has been recommended by the DPC and other four ad hoc appointees (Respondents 5 to 8) were not recommended by the DPC. Consequently, they should have given way to the regularly selected candidates for appointment to the post of Supervisors. But, instead of doing so, the Govt, has resorted for regularisation of the appointment of respondents 5 to 8 as per office memorandum of the Govt, at Annexure-B-1. The Government did not stop there. To regularise the appointment of respondents 5 to 8, the Govt, has taken recourse to its executive power to relax the shortfall of four days in regularising the appointment of the respondents 5 to 8, as is evident from the order of the Government dated 20.5.95 (Annexure-B/2) read with the order of the Govt, dated 28.3.95 1 cannot agree with the submission of the Id. counsel for the respondents, Mr. A. Nilmani Singh regarding the regularisation of respondents 5 to 8 in the post of Supervisors vide Annexure-B/1 on the following grounds.

    (a) The memorandum of the Government for regularisation of ad hoc appointees at Annexure-B/1 cannot apply in the case of the respondents 5 to 8 as post held by these respondents were already notified by the Govt, and DPC was constituted in 1992 and Selection process had already been started for appointment to the six posts of Supervisors;

    (b) as per the aforesaid memorandum of the State Govt. (Annexure-B/1) only those adhoc appointees who have completed 2 years can be regularised. The respondents 5 to 8 did not complete 2 years and the Govt, has taken recourse to its executive powers to relax the condition of 2 years so as to cover the shortfall of four days in the case of respondents 5 to 8;

    (c) the respondents 5 to 8, ad hoc appointees, appeared before the selection Board in 1992 but the Selection Committee did not recommend them for regular appointment;

    (d) 1(One) of the ad hoc appointees, Smt. K. Rani Devi, was recommended by the DPC for regular appointment. Consequently the four other ad hoc appointees, respondents 5 to 8 who failed to get their selection, must give way for the regularly selected candidates;

    (e) the Division Bench of this Court in its judgment at Annexure-A/12 has clearly held that if respondents 5 to 8 get their selection in the DPC held in 1992 that is well and good, but if they cannot get their selection, they must give way to the regularly selected candidates.

    (f) if the regularisation of service of respondents 5 to 8 are allowed to stand, this will encourage the backdoor appointment and there will be a serious complication in the matter of seniority between Smt. K. Rani Devi and respondent No. 5 to 8.

    25. Having regard to the facts and circumstances stated above, I am clearly of the view that the regularisation of respondents 5 to 8 is the misuse of executive power of the Govt, and regularisation of the respondents 5 to 8 must be held to be illegal and invalid. Accordingly, the order of regularisation of respondents 5 to 8, namely H. Mitabina Devi, N. Ruparani Devi, G. Suprabha Devi, and Teckcham Memcha Devi which were made by an order of the Govt dated 20.5.95 (Annexure-B/2) is illegal and is, therefore, quashed.

    26. The claim of the petitioners is that since there are sufficient vacancies available and their name appears in the waiting list panel, they should be appointed in the post of Supervisor. I cannot agree with the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioners in view of the law settled by Apex Court in 1996 SC 976 and 1994 SC 765. I have already, discussed aforesaid cases. In those cases the Apex Court has held that appointment from waiting list in excess of advertised post is unconstitutional and vocative of Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution. Consequently, there is no merit in the claim of the petitioners. In view of the facts and circumstances stated above, I am of the opinion that there is no merit in these writ petitions. In view of the findings made above the State Government is directed to terminate the services of the three petitioners in C.R Nos. 44, 45 and 46 of 1996 by giving them one month notice or may terminate their services forthwith after giving them one month's pay in lieu of notice. The order of regularisation of service of respondents 5 to 8 vide Annexure-B/2 is quashed. The State Govt, is directed to consider the termination of service of respondents 5 to 8 in view of the fact that they have failed to get their selection by the DPC held in 1992.

    27. With the aforesaid directions, all these writ petitions are disposed of. Having regard to the facts and circumstances stated above, I make no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Juliate Zimik And Five Ors. v. State Of Manipur & Ors.
    (Aug 26, 1996)