Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The opposite party filed a complaint petition before the Additional Deputy Commissioner (ADC), Tuensang, against the accused-petitioner Ratish Rai. The complaint alleged that both parties jointly purchased a Nissan truck from the Army at Gauhati for Rs. 23,000 and incurred repair costs of Rs. 7,090. The complainant claimed to have paid half the costs and that the vehicle was registered in the name of the accused's son, Raju Rai. It was further alleged that the accused executed a partnership deed on 4-7-82, but later denied the existence of any partnership or the execution of such a document. The complaint accused Ratish Rai of cheating and criminal breach of trust concerning the vehicle and sought an order to transfer the vehicle to the complainant upon payment of his share.

The learned ADC took cognizance of offences under Sections 406 and 420 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and issued summons to the accused. Subsequently, the complainant petitioned for attachment of the vehicle before judgment, which was granted along with a non-bailable warrant against the accused. The accused surrendered and was released on bail conditioned on producing the vehicle for attachment within 20 days. The accused then filed a revision petition seeking quashing of the proceedings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the non-examination of the complainant under Section 200 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cr. P.C.) constituted a fatal procedural defect warranting quashing of the proceedings.
  2. Whether the attachment order of the vehicle under Section 83 Cr. P.C. was valid in the absence of a proclamation under Section 82 Cr. P.C. and without proof that the accused was absconding.
  3. Whether a partner in a partnership can be held liable for criminal breach of trust under Section 406 IPC in relation to partnership assets.
  4. Whether the facts disclosed in the complaint constituted an offence under Section 420 IPC for cheating with criminal intent.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The learned ADC failed to examine the complainant under Section 200 Cr. P.C., which is an incurable procedural defect justifying quashing of the entire proceeding, relying on Dulichand Bolhra v. State, AIR 1971 Assam 14.
  • The examination under Section 200 Cr. P.C. is crucial as it tests the credibility of the complaint at the initial stage.
  • The order of attachment under Section 83 Cr. P.C. was illegal because no proclamation under Section 82 Cr. P.C. was issued and there was no material showing the accused was absconding.
  • No partner can be accused of criminal breach of trust under Section 406 IPC with respect to partnership assets, supported by precedents AIR 1964 Raj 267 and AIR 1958 Andh Pra 555.
  • The complaint lacked any clear statement or allegation of criminal intent to cheat under Section 420 IPC.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The spirit of the Criminal Procedure Code must be followed in Tuensang, where the Administration of Justice and Police Regulation applies, implying some procedural flexibility.
  • Admitted that there might not be ingredients for an offence under Section 406 IPC.
  • Asserted that facts disclose the offence under Section 420 IPC, alleging intention to cheat or deceive the complainant during the purchase and partnership.
  • Pointed out that the complainant bore 50% of the purchase and repair costs.
  • Conceded the illegality of the attachment order under Section 83 Cr. P.C.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dulichand Bolhra v. State, AIR 1971 Assam 14 (1971 Cri LJ 35) Non-observance of Section 190(1)(c) Cr. P.C. (examination of complainant) is a ground to quash proceedings. Relied upon by appellant to argue that failure to examine complainant under Section 200 Cr. P.C. invalidated the proceedings.
AIR 1964 Raj 267 (1964 (2) Cri LJ 730) Partner cannot be accused of criminal breach of trust regarding partnership assets. Supported appellant’s submission that Section 406 IPC offence was not sustainable.
AIR 1958 Andh Pra 555 (1958 Cri LJ 1114) Partner’s liability in criminal breach of trust relating to partnership property. Used to reinforce the argument that no criminal breach of trust could be attributed to the accused as a partner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the procedural and substantive aspects of the case. It noted that the learned ADC failed to examine the complainant under Section 200 Cr. P.C., which is important for assessing the credibility of the complaint. This procedural lapse was considered significant. The court also observed that the attachment order under Section 83 Cr. P.C. was illegal as no proclamation under Section 82 Cr. P.C. was issued and there was no evidence that the accused was absconding, a fact conceded by the respondent's counsel.

Regarding the substantive offences, the court found merit in the appellant’s contention that a partner cannot be accused of criminal breach of trust under Section 406 IPC in respect of partnership property. The respondent admitted this point. As to the offence of cheating under Section 420 IPC, the court held that the complaint did not disclose any clear criminal intention to cheat or deceive the complainant. Instead, the facts revealed a civil dispute over partnership and property rights.

Consequently, the court concluded that the matter was essentially civil in nature and that the orders passed by the learned ADC were illegal.

Holding and Implications

The court allowed the petition and quashed the criminal proceedings initiated against the accused-petitioner Ratish Rai. The direct effect is that the criminal case under Sections 406 and 420 IPC stands dismissed. The complainant is advised to pursue any grievances through civil proceedings. No new precedent was established by this decision.

    Ratish Rai v. Mohesh Singh Opposite Party.

    1. Heard learned counsel Mr. J.K Barua on behalf of the accused-petitioner and learned counsel Mr. S.N Medhi for the opposite party.

    2. The opposite party submitted a complaint petition before the Addl. Deputy Commissioner, Tuensang against the present petitioner Ratish Rai to the effect that both the complainant and the accused jointly purchased from the Army at Gauhati a truck (Nissan) at a cost of Rs. 23,000/- and that the truck was repaired at Jorhat at a cost of Rs. 7090/- and that the complainant paid half of the money involved in purchasing the truck and in repairing it. The vehicle was registered in the name of Raju Rai son of the accused and was numbered NIL-524. It is alleged that the accused Ratish Rai executed a deed/agreement in presence of respectable persons at Tuensang on 4-7-82 to the effect that both the complainant and the accused formed a partnership in the vehicle. On 1-9-82 as the complainant approached the accused and wanted to know about the profit and loss of the truck, the accused flatly denied the complainant having anything to do with the vehicle. It is also alleged that on 1-9-82 in presence of respectable witnesses the accused denied having executed any document of partnership. The complaint had been lodged against the accused person for having cheated the complainant and having committed criminal breach of trust with respect to the vehicle. The relief sought by the complainant is “to take suitable action to transfer the vehicle in my name on payment of his share as agreed upon”.

    3. The learned ADC on perusal of the petition took cognizance of the offences under Ss. 406 and 420 IPC and issued summons to the accused fixing 14-10-82 as the next date. Thereafter, the complainant on 22-9-82 submitted a petition supported by an affidavit to the learned ADC praying for attachment before Judgment of the vehicle concerned. Thereon the learned ADC got satisfied and issued non-bailable warrant of arrest against the accused and order of attachment of the vehicle on 22-9-82. The accused surrendered before the court on 22-9-82 and he was enlarged on bail of Rs. 30,000/-. This order was conditional upon production of the vehicle by the accused before the Police for attachment within 20 days. This revision petition has been filed for quashing of the proceeding.

    4. Learned counsel Mr. Barua for the petitioner submitted that the learned ADC did not examine the complainant under S. 200 Cr. PC and (hat this is an incurable invalidity for which the entire proceeding should be quashed. In support he relied on Dulichand Bolhra v. State, AIR 1971 Assam 14 : (1971 Cri LJ 35) in which for non-observance of the provisions of S. 190(1)(c) the entire proceeding was quashed. Mr. Medhi on the other side, however submitted that only the spirit of Cr. P.C has to be followed in those areas including Tuensang where the Administration of Justice and Police Regulation is in force. Mr. Barua pointed out that 1970 Assam LR 122 : (1971 Cri LJ 35) (supra) came to the aforesaid decision while discussing Rule 22 of the Administration of Justice and Police Regulation. The examination of the complainant under S. 200 Cr. PC is a procedure which adds to the credibility of the complaint at the initial stage. The complain is the foundation of the entire proceeding. So, it should have a test of credibility by examining the complainant on oath as regards the facts of the complaint. In this sense it can be said that the spirit of the Cr. PC has not been followed in the present case. Mr. Barua stressed on the illegality the order passed under S. 83 Cr. PC. The provisions of S. 83 Cr. PC follow the provisions of S. 82 Cr. PC and without having issued any proclamation as envisaged under S. 82 Cr. PC attachment of the property of the accused is not permissible. In the instant case also there has not been any proof or material to show that the accused was absconding. So, the order passed under S. 83 Cr. PC has been illegal. This is frankly conceded by Shri Medhi, learned counsel for the other side. Then Mr. Barua referred to the offences under S. 406 IPC. According to him no partner of a partnership can be accused of having committed criminal breach of trust with regard to the asset of the partnership. In support he referred to AIR 1964 Raj 267 : (1964 (2) Cri LJ 730) and AIR 1958 Andh Pra 555 : (1958 Cri LJ 1114). Sri Medhi also frankly admitted that there might not be ingredients of the offences under S. 406 IPC in the present case. What Mr. Medhi stresses is that there are ingredients of the offence under S. 420 IPC inasmuch as facts are there which show that the accused had the intention of deceiving or cheating the complainant while purchasing the truck/entering into partnership business. But a reading of the complaint does not disclose this. Mr. Barua relied on 1976 AIR ??? 169 (sic) in respect of his argument that there must have been a clear statement saying that the criminal intention of cheating was there on behalf of the accused while the alleged transaction was entered into.

    5. He argues that there is no statement of this nature in the complaint. In my view, the totality of the facts stated in the complaint discloses a dispute of civil nature and the complainant may take recourse to a proceeding of civil nature to gel redressal of his grievances. Mr. Barua also pointed out in this connection that the trial is admittedly in the name of the son of the accused-petitioner. It is not there that the son Raju Rai is a party to the proceeding. Mr. Medhi, on the other hand, pointed out that as per statement in the complaint, the complainant bore 50% cost of the purchase and repair of the vehicle.

    6. Any way, I find that the matter is of civil nature and as said before, the order passed by the learned ADC have been illegal. In this view of the matter, the petition has to be allowed. The complainant, however, may bring any civil proceeding against the accused-petitioner, if he has any grievance.

    7. In the result, the petition is allowed and the proceeding is quashed.

    8. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ratish Rai v. Mohesh Singh Opposite Party.
    (Feb 20, 1984)