Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 39 Rule 2A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) read with Section 151 CPC
  • Order 39 Rules 1 & 2 CPC read with Section 151 CPC
  • Order 39 Rule 2A CPC
  • Order 39 Rule 4 CPC
  • Order 7 Rule 11 CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 39 Rule 2A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) read with Section 151 CPC
  • Order 39 Rules 1 & 2 CPC read with Section 151 CPC
  • Order 39 Rule 2A CPC
  • Order 39 Rule 4 CPC
  • Order 7 Rule 11 CPC
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

A suit for partition in respect of property bearing no. 42-44, Sunder Nagar, New Delhi was filed by minor Plaintiffs through their next friend, Mrs. Asha Aggarwal. Alongside the suit the Plaintiffs sought interim relief under Order 39 Rules 1 & 2 CPC read with Section 151 CPC; the court directed all parties to maintain status quo in respect of the property by order dated 07.05.1997.

The status quo order of 07.05.1997 was modified by the court on 16.09.2005 to the extent that Defendant No.12 was permitted to exercise and deal with his undivided share without parting with possession. Later Defendant No.8 applied under Order 39 Rule 4 CPC for a similar modification; by order dated 24.11.2009 the court recorded that Defendant No.8 shall be entitled to exercise her rights and deal with her undivided one-third share in the property.

Plaintiffs alleged that despite these orders there remained an absolute restriction on transfer of possession; they contend that Defendant No.8, her sons (Defendants No.4–7) and Defendant No.14 (Caravan Commercial Company Ltd.) violated the status quo by delivering vacant and peaceful possession of the ground floor to Defendant No.14 pursuant to an Agreement to Sell. The Plaintiffs moved an application under Order 39 Rule 2A CPC (contempt) seeking detention of persons, attachment of the ground floor and other reliefs.

Defendants filed replies and rejoinders. It was not disputed by Defendant No.8 or Defendant No.14 that vacant and peaceful possession of the ground floor had been handed over to Defendant No.14; the Agreement to Sell records delivery of vacant and physical possession of the ground floor to the vendee. Defendants No.4–7 were not served with notice of the contempt application and thus the court held that the application could not proceed against them.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there was disobedience of the status quo order dated 07.05.1997, as subsequently modified by orders dated 16.09.2005 and 24.11.2009, so as to constitute contempt of court punishable under Order 39 Rule 2A CPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The orders dated 16.09.2005 and 24.11.2009 allowed Defendants to deal with their undivided shares but did not permit any transfer of possession; status quo as to possession remained intact.
  • Defendant No.8, her sons (Defendants No.4–7) and Defendant No.14 delivered possession of the ground floor to Defendant No.14 in breach of the status quo and therefore are liable for contempt.
  • They sought civil imprisonment of persons concerned under Order 39 Rule 2A CPC and attachment of the ground floor.

Defendants' Arguments (summary as stated in the opinion)

  • Defendants No.8 and No.14 contended that the orders (particularly the order of 24.11.2009) did not specifically prohibit transfer of possession and were reasonably capable of more than one interpretation; where an order is ambiguous, contempt proceedings should not be entertained.
  • It was argued that even accepting the Plaintiffs' case, the Plaintiffs and certain other defendants were entitled only to one-third share and were in possession of the entire first floor (approximately 50% of built-up area). Therefore transfer of the ground floor to Defendant No.14 did not necessarily violate entitlement and did not amount to contempt.
  • Defendant No.14 relied on pending objections to maintain that the main suit and other proceedings (including an Order 7 Rule 11 application) might affect entitlement; counsel relied on case law that ambiguities defeat contempt proceedings.
  • Defendants No.4–7 were not properly served and thus the contempt application could not proceed against them.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Tamilnad Merchantile Bank Shareholders Welfare Association v. Tamilnad Merchantile Bank Ltd., (2008) 15 SCC 529 Principle that when an order of the Court is ambiguous and reasonably capable of more than one interpretation, proceedings for contempt should not be entertained. The court noted the principle relied upon by Defendants but held that the orders in the instant matter were not ambiguous; therefore this precedent did not assist the Defendants.
Sushila Raje Holkar v. Anil Kak (Retired), (2008) 14 SCC 392 Principle concerning ambiguity of orders and maintainability of contempt proceedings when orders are reasonably capable of more than one meaning. The court observed the precedent was relied upon but concluded the impugned orders were clear and unambiguous, so the precedent did not relieve the Defendants of contempt liability.
K.K. Puri petitioner v. M.K. Industries, 1997 (40) DRJ 797 Authority cited by Defendants concerning ambiguity and contempt proceedings (as relied upon by defense counsel). The court noted reliance but held K.K. Puri would not assist because the court found no ambiguity in the relevant orders.
State of Bihar v. Rajendra Singh, AIR 2004 SC 4419 Principle that in proceedings under Order 39 Rule 2A CPC the court's role is to see whether there is disobedience of the order and it is not permissible to examine the correctness of the earlier decision alleged to be violated. The court applied this principle to frame the scope of the contempt inquiry: it focused on disobedience rather than re‑examining prior orders.
Union of India v. Subedar Devassy PV, AIR 2006 SC 909 Similar principle limiting the scope of contempt proceedings to disobedience and not the correctness of the underlying decision. The court relied on this authority to reinforce that the contempt application must be confined to determining disobedience of the court's order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court identified the narrow question for determination as whether there was disobedience of the status quo order dated 07.05.1997 as subsequently modified by orders dated 16.09.2005 and 24.11.2009. The court proceeded as follows:

  1. The court compared the earlier orders: the order of 16.09.2005 expressly modified the 07.05.1997 order to permit Defendant No.12 to exercise and deal with his undivided share without parting with possession, while maintaining status quo in respect of possession. The 24.11.2009 order granted Defendant No.8 a concession similar to that given to Defendant No.12.
  2. The court rejected the Defendants' contention that the 24.11.2009 order was ambiguous. It held that the concession given to Defendant No.8 was clearly similar to that given to Defendant No.12 and that status quo as to possession was to be preserved.
  3. The court emphasized that in Order 39 Rule 2A CPC proceedings the court is limited to determining whether there has been disobedience of a court order and is not permitted to re-examine the correctness of the earlier decision alleged to have been violated. The court cited State of Bihar v. Rajendra Singh and Union of India v. Subedar Devassy PV in support of this limitation on scope.
  4. The court considered the factual material (including the Agreement to Sell and the Local Commissioner's earlier report) and the admission by Defendant No.8 and Defendant No.14 that vacant and peaceful possession of the ground floor had been delivered to Defendant No.14.
  5. The court addressed the argument that Plaintiffs' entitlement was only to one-third and that they and certain other defendants occupied roughly 50% of the built-up area (first floor). The court rejected this as twofold:
    • First, the modified orders were clear that possession was not to be disturbed.
    • Second, even on the Defendants' own showing, Defendant No.8 was in possession of the entire ground floor, which the court found to be more than one-third of the property; thus delivering the entire ground floor to Defendant No.14 could not be justified as dealing only with the 1/3 share.
  6. The court also recorded that Defendants No.4–7 had not been properly served with notice of the contempt application and therefore the application could not proceed against them.
  7. Having found disobedience of the possession-related status quo, the court concluded that Defendants No.8 and No.14 were guilty of contempt under Order 39 Rule 2A CPC.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The court held that Defendant No.8 and Defendant No.14 had disobeyed the status quo order dated 07.05.1997 as modified by orders dated 16.09.2005 and 24.11.2009, and were guilty of contempt of court under Order 39 Rule 2A CPC.

Consequential directions and immediate effect on the parties (as ordered in the opinion):

  • Defendant No.14 is directed to deliver vacant possession of the entire ground floor as received from Defendant No.8 under the Agreement to Sell dated 25.05.2011 within eight weeks.
  • Defendant No.8 is directed to obtain physical possession of the entire ground floor delivered by her to Defendant No.14 within eight weeks.
  • The question of imposing punishment for contempt was made dependent on compliance with the above directions.
  • The contempt application could not proceed against Defendants No.4–7 due to lack of service.
  • The matter was listed for compliance on 15.10.2014.

No broader legal precedent was announced by this order; the court confined itself to determining disobedience of the relevant interlocutory orders and directing restoration of possession, noting that established authority limits contempt inquiries to disobedience rather than re‑examination of the merits of earlier orders.

    Yashaswi Aggarwal v. Rakesh Aggarwal

    1. By virtue of this order, I propose to dispose of the application under Order 39 Rule 2A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) read with Section 151 CPC preferred by the Plaintiffs (applicants) for initiating action of contempt against Defendant No. 8, her sons Defendants No. 4 to 7 and Defendant No. 14, Caravan Commercial Company Ltd. for violating the order dated 24.11.2009

    2. A suit for partition in respect of property bearing no. 42-44, Sunder Nagar, New Delhi was preferred by the minor Plaintiffs, through their next friend Mrs. Asha Aggarwal. Along with the suit, an application I.A No. 4108/1997 under order 39 rules 1 & 2 cpc read with section 151 cpc was also filed by the Plaintiffs for restraining the Defendants from transferring, alienating, encumbering or disturbing the status quo of the property as it was existing on the date of filing of the suit and the application. By an order dated 07.05.1997, the parties (to the suit) were directed to maintain status quo in respect of the property bearing no. 42-44, Sunder Nagar, New Delhi.

    3. I.A No. 4696/2005 was preferred by Defendant No. 12 for modification of the order dated 07.05.1997 The order was modified by the Court by an order dated 16.09.2005 Since this order will be relevant for reference a little later, the same is extracted hereunder:

    “The counsel for the Plaintiffs states that his clients will have no objection in case the Defendant No. 12 exercises his rights and deals with his undivided share without parting with the possession of any portion of the property.

    In view of the statement made by the counsel for the plaintiffs, the order dated 07.05.1997 is modified to the extent that the status quo will be maintained in respect of possession of the parties to property no. 42-44, Sunder Nagar, New Delhi. However, Defendant No. 12 shall be entitled to exercise his rights and deal with his undivided share in the property.”

    4. It is the case of the Plaintiffs (applicants) that thereafter I.A No. 3084/2006 was filed by Defendants No. 9 to 11 and 13 for vacation of the status quo order dated 07.05.1997 The said application was dismissed by this Court by an order dated 22.08.2007 Thereafter, another application I.A No. 12948/2008 was preferred by Defendant No. 8 under Order 39 Rule 4 CPC for discharging the status quo order dated 07.05.1997 The application came to be disposed of by an order dated 24.11.2009, whereby Defendant No. 8 was also permitted to deal with her undivided ⅓rd share in the property. It is this order which is alleged to have been violated by Defendant No. 8, her sons Defendants No. 4 to 7 and Defendant No. 14, Caravan Commercial Company Ltd. Therefore, it will be apposite to extract the order dated 24.11.2009 hereunder for ready reference:

    “This application has been made under Order 39 Rule 4 CPC on behalf of Defendant No. 8 with a prayer that the court should modify the status quo order dated 7th May, 1997 which was earlier modified on 16 September, 2005.

    It is submitted by learned counsel for Defendant No. 8 that Defendant No. 8 was entitled to undivided ⅓ share in the property. This court vide order dated 16 September, 2005 had given liberty to Defendant No. 12, who was similarly placed that Defendant No. 12 shall be entitled to exercise his rights and deal with his undivided share in his property. He states that Defendant No. 8 is also entitled for the same liberty.

    Learned counsel for the plaintiffs states that as far as Defendant No. 8 is concerned, her ⅓ share in the property is not disputed and counsel for the plaintiffs has no objection in case the similar order as in respect of Defendant No. 12 has been passed is also passed in favour of Defendant No. 8.

    In view of this submission, the application for modifying the status quo order dated 16 September, 2005 is allowed and it is observed that Defendant No. 8 shall be entitled to exercise her rights and deal with her undivided ⅓ share in the property.

    The application stands disposed of.”

    5. The Plaintiffs grievance is that a bare reading of the orders dated 16.09.2005 and 24.11.2009 will make it abundantly clear that though Defendants No. 8 and 12 were given liberty to deal with their undivided share in the suit property, but there was an absolute restriction so far as transfer of property and possession was concerned and the status quo order dated 07.05.1997 in respect of possession of the suit property was never varied. It is averred that the order dated 24.11.2009 was passed in presence of the counsel for Defendant No. 14, who had been impleaded as a Defendant in the suit. It is stated that Smt. Pushpa Devi and her sons, i.e Defendant No. 8 and Defendants No. 4 to 7 were residing on the ground floor of the suit property. At the time of entering into an Agreement to Sell, they (Defendants No. 4 to 8) parted with possession of the ground floor of the suit property in favour of Defendant No. 14, which was in violation of the status quo order dated 07.05.1997 read with orders dated 16.09.2005 and 24.11.2009 The Plaintiffs, thus, pray for punishing Defendants No. 4 to 8 and Defendant No. 14 with the following prayers:

    “a) Initiate action against Defendant No. 8, her sons i.e Defendants No. 4 to 7 and Defendant No. 14, Caravan Commercial Company Limited, through its Directors/Principal Officers under Order 39 Rule 2A CPC by ordering the detention of Defendants No. 4 to 8 and Directors/Principal Officers of Defendant No. 14 in Civil Prison.

    b) Attach the ground floor of the suit property bearing no. 42-44, Sunder Nagar, New Delhi.

    c) Pass such other and appropriate orders as this Hon'ble Court deems fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.”

    6. Replies and rejoinders to the application have been filed by the Defendants and the Plaintiffs respectively. It has not been disputed by Defendant No. 8 as also by Defendant No. 14 that vacant and peaceful possession of the ground floor of the property bearing no. 42-44, Sunder Nagar, New Delhi has been handed over to Defendant No. 14. Para 3 (on page 12 of the Agreement to Sell) specifically records that vacant and physical possession of the ground floor and constructed areas of the super structures have been offered by the vendor which includes Defendants No. 4 to 8 and has been occupied by the vendee i.e Defendant No. 14.

    7. It may be mentioned that Defendants No. 4 to 7 have been impleaded as a party to this contempt application as they were the confirming parties to the Agreement to Sell dated 15.11.1991 A perusal of record shows that Defendants No. 4 to 7 were ordered to be proceeded ex parte in the main suit. Initially, Mr. Deepak Sahni, Advocate appeared on behalf of Defendants No. 4 to 7 in addition to Defendant No. 8 on 28.02.2013 However, on the next date, Mr. Deepak Sahni, Advocate appeared only on behalf of Defendant No. 8. A letter was also placed on record that Mr. Deepak Sahni, Advocate had been representing only Defendant No. 8 and, therefore, the court notice of the application could not have been served upon him on behalf of Defendants No. 4 to 7. The counsel for the Plaintiffs sought time to file fresh address of Defendants No. 4 to 7, but that too was not done. Since Defendants No. 4 to 7 were not served with the notice of this application and since Defendant No. 8 was the vendor, this application cannot proceed against Defendants No. 4 to 7.

    8. The short question for disposal of the application under Order 39 Rule 2A CPC is whether there is disobedience of the status quo order dated 07.05.1997, which was subsequently modified by an order dated 24.11.2009?

    9. I have heard Mr. Jeevesh Nagrath, Advocate for the Plaintiffs (applicants) and Mr. Sandeep Sindhwani, learned Sr. Counsel for Defendant (Respondent) No. 8 and Mr. Ravi Gupta, learned Sr. Counsel for Defendant (Respondent) No. 14. The learned Sr. Counsel for Defendant No. 8 and Defendant No. 14 have vehemently argued that although the entitlement of the Plaintiffs in respect of ⅓ share in property no. 42-44, Sunder Nagar is in dispute, but even if the case of the Plaintiffs is accepted as it is, they (Plaintiffs and Defendants No. 1 to 3) were entitled only to ⅓ share in the property bearing no. 42-44, Sunder Nagar. They were in possession of the entire first floor which was approximately 50% of the built-up area in these properties. Thus, the undivided shares of the Plaintiffs and Defendants No. 1 to 3 would be much less than the entire area of the first floor and thus, if possession of the ground floor of the suit property was transferred by Defendants No. 4 to 8 in favour of Defendant No. 14, there cannot be any violation of the status quo order dated 07.05.1997, modified by subsequent order dated 24.11.2009 as the Plaintiffs will be entitled to seek their share out of only ⅓ share of the properties. The learned Sr. Counsel for the Defendants urge that although there was specific mention to maintain status quo with regard to possession and transfer of the properties by the parties in the order dated 07.05.1997 while permission was granted to Defendant No. 12 to deal with his share, there was no such restriction imposed on Defendant No. 8 while her application for discharge of the status quo order was disposed of by the order dated 24.11.2009

    10. The three co-owners, i.e Defendants No. 3, 8 and 9 had entered into an Agreement to Sell on 15.11.1991 with Defendant No. 14 for a sum of Rs. 1.90 crores and Rs. 30 lakhs was paid to the co-owners through cheque as part payment. Thereafter, another registered Agreement to Sell dated 16.11.1992 was executed by all the co-owners in favour of Defendant No. 14 and they received a further sum of Rs. 36 lakhs by cheques. It is urged that these agreements and the payments are not in dispute. It is urged that Defendant No. 14 also instituted a suit for specific performance of contract against Defendants No. 3, 8 and 9 being CS (OS) 2443/1993 in which an order of status quo dated 27.10.1993 was passed. Upon tenants vacating the suit property, despite status quo, Plaintiffs and Defendants No. 1, 3 and 8 occupied separate portions of the suit property. Local Commissioner appointed by the Court gave report dated 18.04.1994 that the Plaintiffs and Defendants No. 1 to 3 were in possession of the entire first floor, whereas Defendant No. 8 was in possession of the entire ground floor. It is urged that CCP 70/1994 filed by Defendant No. 14 in CS (OS) 2443/1993 is pending adjudication. It is the case of Defendant No. 14 that in order to frustrate the decree of specific performance to be passed in favour of Defendant No. 14, Defendant No. 3, through her grandsons, instituted the present suit on the frivolous plea of HUF Funds/coparcenaries without filing even a single document. It is urged that after 20 years of litigation, Defendants No. 8, 9 to 13 and Defendant No. 14 amicably settled their disputes which was intimated to this Court on 02.06.2011 in CS (OS) 2443/1993. The prayer of the Plaintiffs in that suit for possession was not granted. Defendant No. 14 had already undertaken not to create any third party interest. It is stated that no violation of any order was ever done by Defendant No. 14. The learned Sr. Counsel for Defendant No. 8 and Defendant No. 14 urge that when an order is ambiguous and is reasonably capable of more than one interpretation, proceedings for contempt would not be maintainable. In support of their contention, the learned Sr. Counsel for Defendant No. 14 placed reliance on Tamilnad Merchantile Bank Shareholders Welfare Association v. Tamilnad Merchantile Bank Ltd., (2008) 15 SCC 529 and Sushila Raje Holkar v. Anil Kak (Retired)., (2008) 14 SCC 392. It is urged that the main suit of the Plaintiffs is not maintainable and the application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC preferred by Defendant No. 14 is pending which could not be heard and therefore also, Defendant No. 14 cannot be held guilty of contempt. Learned Sr. Counsel for Defendants No. 8 in support of his proposition has placed reliance on K.K Puripetitioner v. M.K Industries., 1997 (40) DRJ 797.

    11. It may be mentioned that subsequently, another application on mentioning was moved on behalf of the Defendant No. 14 for addressing further arguments urging that Defendant No. 14 in the absence of fair and sufficient opportunity would be prejudiced. The application I.A No. 13644/2014 was dismissed by the Court with the observation that full opportunity was granted to Mr. Ravi Gupta, Senior Advocate, who not only addressed oral arguments, but was also permitted to place on record written submissions in the afternoon which were subsequently filed and placed on record.

    12. There is no dispute about the proposition of law as has been urged by the learned Sr. Counsel for Defendants No. 4 to 8 and Defendant No. 14 that when an order of the Court is ambiguous and is reasonably capable of more than one interpretation, proceedings for contempt should not be entertained. Can it be said that the order dated 07.05.1997 read with subsequent orders dated 16.09.2005 and 24.11.2009 was capable of two interpretations? The learned Sr. Counsel for Defendants No. 8 and Defendant No. 14 have stressed that there is no specific mention in the order dated 24.11.2009 that Defendant No. 8 will not be entitled to transfer possession of the suit property while dealing with the property and thus, even if order dated 16.09.2005 is taken into consideration, at the most, it will show that the order dated 24.11.2009 was capable of two interpretations and thus, no action of contempt can be taken against Defendants No. 8 and 14.

    13. I have already extracted earlier the orders dated 16.09.2005 and 24.11.2009 Order dated 16.09.2005 categorically records no objection of the Plaintiffs in respect of the right of Defendant No. 12 to deal with his undivided share without parting with the possession of any portion of the property. The order dated 07.05.1997 was modified by order dated 16.09.2005 to the extent that Defendant No. 12 may deal in his share but status quo was to be maintained in respect of possession of property bearing no. 42-44, Sunder Nagar by the parties. By a subsequent application I.A No. 12948/2008, Defendant No. 8 wanted discharge of the status quo order dated 07.05.1997, which was granted to Defendant No. 8 recording that ⅓ share of Defendant No. 8 is not disputed and the counsel for the Plaintiffs has no objection in case the order as passed in respect of Defendant No. 12 is passed in respect of Defendant No. 8. Thus, everybody was aware that concession which had been given to Defendant No. 8 was similar to the one granted to Defendant No. 12 by the order dated 16.09.2005 Hence, the contention raised on behalf of Defendant No. 8 and Defendant No. 14 that the order dated 24.11.2009 with regard to dealing with the property with or without possession was ambiguous and capable of two interpretations is unfounded. It may be mentioned that in the proceedings under Order 39 Rule 2A CPC, the Court is simply to see whether there is disobedience of the order passed by the Court. It is not permissible for the Court to examine the correctness of the earlier decision which is stated to be violated. (See State of Bihar v. Rajendra Singh, AIR 2004 SC 4419 and Union of India v. Subedar Devassy PV, AIR 2006 SC 909). The judgments in Tamilnad Merchantile Bank and Sushila Raje Holkar (supra) and K.K Puri (supra) relied upon by the learned Sr. Counsel for Defendant No. 14 and Defendant No. 8 will not come to the rescue of the Defendants as there was no ambiguity in the order. The contention that Defendant No. 8 was in possession of only ground floor of which possession was delivered to Defendant No. 14 and the Plaintiffs and Defendants No. 1 to 3 were in possession of more than ⅓ share in the property and thus, there will not be any contempt is noted to be rejected for two reasons. First, as stated earlier, the order as modified by the subsequent orders was clear that possession of the property is not to be disturbed. Second, even if it is assumed that Plaintiffs and Defendants No. 1 to 3 were in possession of about 50% of the built-up portion, Defendant No. 8 was also in possession of the entire ground floor which must be more than ⅓ share of Defendant No. 8. Thus, even if Defendant No. 8 had been permitted to part with the possession of the ⅓ portion of the property belonging to him (though it was not done), she could not have delivered the possession of entire ground floor to Defendant No. 14 which as per own showing of Defendant No. 8 about 50% of the property.

    14. Thus, I have no hesitation to hold that Defendant No. 8 and Defendant No. 14 have disobeyed the status quo order dated 07.05.1997, subsequently modified by orders dated 16.09.2005 and 24.11.2009 They are guilty of committing contempt of court under Order 39 Rule 2A CPC. In order to purge themselves of contempt, Defendant No. 14 is directed to deliver vacant possession of the entire ground floor as received by it from Defendant No. 8 by virtue of Agreement to Sell dated 25.05.2011 within 8 weeks; similarly, Defendant No. 8 is directed to obtain physical possession of the entire ground floor delivered by her to Defendant No. 14 by earlier said agreement within 8 weeks. The matter of awarding punishment will be dependent on the compliance of this order.

    15. List for compliance on 15.10.2014

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Yashaswi Aggarwal v. Rakesh Aggarwal
    (Aug 4, 2014)