Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants filed a claim petition before the Railway Claims Tribunal seeking compensation for the death of the deceased, who allegedly fell from a moving train near Vivek Vihar railway station and was subsequently cut by another train. The Railway Claims Tribunal dismissed the claim on 30.8.2011, holding that the appellants failed to prove that the deceased was a bona fide passenger. The present first appeal under Section 23 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 challenges that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the claimants/appellants discharged the initial burden of proving that the deceased was a bona fide passenger who died due to an untoward incident within the meaning of Section 123(c) read with Section 124-A of the Railways Act.
  2. Whether the burden of proof lies initially on the claimants to establish their case or on the Railways to prove the deceased was not a bona fide passenger.
  3. Whether the findings of the Railway Claims Tribunal dismissing the claim petition due to lack of proof of the deceased’s status as a bona fide passenger were legally sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants relied on the Division Bench judgment of the Kerala High Court in Union of India v. Leelamma (2010 ACJ 566) to argue that the onus to prove that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger lies on the Railways, not on the claimants.
  • They also cited the judgment of a Single Judge of this Court in Union of India v. Krishan Lal (1 (2010) ACC 279) to support the contention that the Railways bear the burden of disproving the deceased’s status as a bona fide passenger.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent contended that the appellants failed to prove the deceased was a bona fide passenger and that the incident occurred while the deceased was crossing the railway track, not travelling in the train.
  • They relied on documentary evidence including the police final report and inquest report which indicated the deceased died due to a train accident while crossing the track, and no journey ticket was recovered from the deceased.
  • The respondent argued that the Railway Claims Tribunal correctly applied the legal principle that the initial burden lies on the claimants to prove the deceased was a bona fide passenger.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jamirul Nisha v. Union of India, 2009 ACJ 1393 Establishing that a claimant must prove the deceased accidentally fell from the train to claim compensation under Sections 123(c) and 124-A of the Railways Act. The Court relied on this decision to affirm the necessity of proof of the untoward incident and bona fide passenger status by the claimants.
Dinesh Kumar Singh Maurya v. Union of India, FAO No. 1023 of 2010 (Allahabad High Court) Presumption that absence of a ticket indicates the deceased was not a bona fide passenger; initial burden of proof lies on claimants after Railways disproves bona fide status. The Court applied this principle to hold that the appellants failed to discharge their burden as no ticket was produced and contrary documentary evidence existed.
Union of India v. Leelamma, 2010 ACJ 566 (Kerala High Court) Onus of proving deceased was not a bona fide passenger lies on Railways. The Court rejected the applicability of this precedent, holding that the initial onus lies on claimants and not Railways.
Union of India v. Krishan Lal, 1 (2010) ACC 279 Proof of train tickets can discharge onus of bona fide passenger status. The Court distinguished this case as tickets were specifically proved there, unlike in the present case.
Pyar Singh v. Union of India, 2007 (8) AD Delhi 262 Initial onus lies on claimants to prove their case. The Court agreed with this precedent and held itself bound by it to place initial burden on the claimants.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the evidence and found that the appellants failed to prove that the deceased was a bona fide passenger who died due to an untoward incident while travelling on the train. The Railway Claims Tribunal’s reliance on documentary evidence, including the police final report and inquest report, was upheld. These documents indicated that the deceased died while crossing the railway track, not as a passenger aboard the train. The absence of a journey ticket further supported the conclusion that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger.

The Court rejected the appellants’ reliance on the Kerala High Court judgment in Leelamma, clarifying that the initial burden of proof always lies on the claimants to establish that the deceased was travelling bona fide. While the burden may shift depending on the facts, there is no general rule placing the burden initially on the Railways to prove the negative. The Court also noted the dubious nature of the appellants’ witness, who was not mentioned in the accident report or claim petition, undermining the credibility of their case.

The Court further observed that conflicting oral evidence cannot override documentary evidence prepared in the ordinary course of official duties. The factual scenario suggested the deceased was crossing the railway line and was fatally struck due to his own negligence, bringing the case within the exceptions under Section 124-A of the Railways Act.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED the appeal, affirming the dismissal of the claim petition by the Railway Claims Tribunal on the ground that the appellants failed to prove that the deceased was a bona fide passenger who died due to an untoward incident on the train.

The direct effect of this decision is that the appellants are not entitled to compensation under the Railway Claims Tribunal Act. No broader precedent was set beyond clarifying the allocation of the initial burden of proof in such claims and the importance of credible documentary evidence over unsubstantiated oral testimony.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Gurcharan Singh & Ors. v. Union Of India

    VALMIKI J. MEHTA, J (ORAL)

    1. By this first appeal under Section 23 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987, the claimants/appellants pray for setting aside of the impugned judgment of the Railway Claims Tribunal dated 30.8.2011 whereby the claim petition filed by the appellants seeking compensation was dismissed.

    2. The claim petition was dismissed as the Railway Claims Tribunal held that the claimants/appellants failed to prove that the deceased was a bona fide passenger. The relevant findings and observations of the Railway Claims Tribunal read as under:

    “After perusal of record, I observe that in the documents i.e AW1/6 to AW1/9, placed on record by the applicants, it is no where mentioned that (deceased) fell down from the train and died. The burden of proof rests entirely upon the applicants to prove the untoward incident, within the meaning of section 123(c) read with section 124-A of the Railways Act. In this connection, a reference may be made to a decision of Hon'ble Delhi High Court titled as Jamirul Nisha v. Union of India, 2009 ACJ 1393, wherein it is held in para no. 34 & 35 of the decision as under:

    “34. From the perusal of section 123 c 92) & 124 A, it is clear that “sine qua non” for claiming compensation, on account of death or injury sustained in a train accident is that the victim of a train accident, or his dependents as the case may be, must first establish that the victim or the deceased had accidentally fallen from the train.”

    “35. In the instant case, applicants have failed to establish that the deceased had accidentally fallen from the train, therefore, the question of the proof by the Railways that the death of the deceased was not the result of untoward incident does not arise.”

    Hence, it is clear that the applicants miserably failed to prove the untoward incident by way of documents placed on record by them & it is also relevant to mention that in the police final report i.e R5 (based on inquest report & other documents), submitted by the respondent, it is clearly mentioned by Sh. Zile Singh SHO/ODRS dt.24.05.2008 in his report as under:-

    “On 20.03.2008, on receipt of information, IO reached the place of occurrence i.e KM pole no. 9/01-9/03 Vivek Vihar railway line & there he found lying one male dead body of an old man, who was identified as Gurumukh Singh S/o Sardar Mohan Singh R/o H. No. 20/97, Kalyanpuri Delhi. Statements of the witnesses were recorded, who told that the deceased met with train accident, while he was crossing the railway line. Post Mortem was got conducted, cause of death was train accident. No foul play suspected, inquest may please be filed.”

    Sd/-

    Zile Singh SHO/ODRS

    24.05.2008

    Filed.

    Sd/-

    Mahendra Kumar

    Sub Divisional Magistrate

    Kotwali

    The aforesaid report was sent to Sub Divisional Magistrate Sh. Mahendra Kumar, who endorsed & accepted it. The evidence of witness AW2 Sh. Rajeev is also not convincing, because he did not submit any positive proof that he was travelling with Sh. Gurmukh Singh as there was no reference of AW2 in the claim application & so the story put forth by the applicants, is an after thought & not well convincing. The copy of document R5(based on inquest report & other documents), submitted by the respondent, was given to the applicants through their Counsel, but nothing was adduced in rebuttal on behalf of the applicants. Hence, adverse inference goes against the applicants. It is also relevant to mention that the documents i.e AW 1/6 to AW1/9 submitted by the applicants & R5 submitted by the respondent, were prepared in the ordinary course of duties by the Govt. officials and the veracity of the documents, cannot be doubted.

    Hence, it is clear that the incident occurred, while Sh. Gurmukh Singh (deceased) was crossing the railway track on 20.03.2008 at KM pole no. 9/01-9/03 Vivek Vihar railway line & met with the train accident, due to his own negligence & for that Railway Administration is not responsible as the present case falls under the exceptions of section 124-A of the Railway Act. I also observe that no journey ticket was recovered either from the possession of the deceased or from the site of the incident and in this regard, I find momentum of force, when the Ld. Counsel for the respondent states that the story put forth by the applicants, is a mere concoction only to get false compensation and now a days, it is a simple tendency of some people by adopting other means by quoting that the deceased was travelling, on the strength of valid railway journey ticket and the ticket lost in the incident. However, the legal position of law is very much clear as it has been held in Dinesh Kumar Singh Maurya v. Union of India, vide FAO no. 1023 of 2010, decided on 28.8.2010 by the Hon'ble Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench), wherein it is observed as under:-

    “True, may be in certain cases the ticket of bonafide passenger is list, snatched or taken away by some criminal and unscrupulous persons but there cannot be a presumption that the ticket of every deceased necessarily is taken out or it is lost or mutilated. In case ticket is not found from the body of the deceased or from its vicinity, the presumption would be that such a person was not a bonafide traveler, of course, evidence can be led to prove otherwise. If any untoward incident takes place within the meaning of Section 124-A of the Railways Act, initial burden lies on the Railways to prove that the passenger was not a bonafide passenger, but the same having been discharged, onus shifts on the person claiming compensation, to establish by some believable evidence, that such a passenger was a bonafide passenger, more so when contrary admissible evidence is produced by the Railways.”

    The authority titled (supra) is applicable in the present case. I find momentum of force in the submissions of Ld. Counsel for the respondent and there is no modicum of merit in the submissions of Ld. Counsel for the applicants. The authorities submitted by Ld. Counsel for the applicants, is not applicable in the present case as the facts are to some extent different. It is also relevant to mention that when there is a conflict between oral evidence and documentary evidence, in such circumstances, the documentary evidence will prevail.

    Hence, I record my findings on Issue no. 1 & 2 against the applicants and in the favour of respondent.”

    3. The facts of the case show that as per the case of the claimants/appellants, the deceased was travelling by train to the Old Delhi Railway Station from Meerut and he died on account of fall from the Ambala Passenger Train bearing No. 306 near the flyover of Vivek Vihar station at Delhi. The death took place as per the appellants/claimants on account of falling from the train around Vivek Vihar railway station under the fly over and the deceased got cut from another train which came from the opposite side and which is pleaded to be an untoward incident as per Section 123(c) and Section 124A of the Railways Act, 1989 for the appellants/applicants to be entitled to the compensation.

    4(i) Learned counsel for appellants/claimants impugns the findings of the Railway Claims Tribunal by placing reliance upon the Division Bench judgment of the Kerala High Court in the case of Union of India v. Leelamma, 2010 ACJ 566 to argue that onus of proof that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger of the train inasmuch as the deceased had no ticket is on the railways and not on the appellants/claimants. Reliance is also placed for the same purpose upon the judgment of the learned Single Judge of this Court reported as Union of India v. Krishan Lal, 1 (2010) ACC 279.

    (ii) In my opinion, the contention of the learned counsel for the appellants/claimants is totally misconceived. The initial onus in my opinion always lies with the appellants/claimants to show that there is a death due to untoward incident of a bona fide passenger. Of course, by filing of the affidavit and depending on the facts of a particular case that initial onus can be a light onus which can shift on the Railways, however, it is not the law that even the initial onus of proof which has to be discharged is always on the railways and not on the claimants. I cannot agree to this proposition of law that the Railways have the onus to prove that a deceased was not a bonafide passenger because no such negative onus is placed upon the Railways either under the railways act or the railway claims tribunal act & rules or as per any judgment of the Supreme Court. No doubt, in the facts of the particular case, onus can be easily discharged such as in a case where deceased may have died at a place where he could not have otherwise been unless he was travelling in the train and in such circumstances depending on the facts of a particular case it may not be necessary to prove the factum of the deceased having a ticket because ticket as per the type of incident of death can easily be lost in an accident. I at this stage take note of a judgment of a leaned Single Judge of this Court in the case reported as Pyar Singh v. Union of India2007 (8) AD Delhi 262 which holds that it is the claimant upon whom the initial onus lies to prove his case. I agree to this view and I am bound by this judgment and not by the ratio of the case of Leelamma (supra).

    5. In the case before the Kerala High Court the deceased died at Trichy Railway Station on a journey from Chennai to Trichy and, therefore, onus upon the claimants was held to be discharged in that case.

    6. In the case of Union of India v. Krishan Lal (supra) it is noted that the train tickets were specifically proved as Exh. AW-1/3 to Exh. AW-1/8. In such circumstances, the onus of proof with respect to the deceased person being bona fide passenger was discharged. There is no specific ratio laid down in the case of Krishan Lal (supra) that claimants do not have initial onus to prove their case and onus is on Railways to disprove that a deceased is not a bonafide passenger. Therefore, the ratio of the case of Union of India v. Krishan Lal (supra) does not apply to the present case.

    7. In the present case, the deceased was a resident of Kalyan Puri in Delhi and which is just about few kilomenters from the Vivek Vihar Railway Station. In my opinion, just because there is a report of a death on account of person being found badly cut up on account of train cannot mean that Courts have to necessarily hold that the deceased was in fact travelling in the train. Trial court has exhaustively dealt with this aspect and referred to the documents of the railway authorities to hold that the deceased cannot be said to have been a bona fide passenger of the train and therefore appellants/claimants are not entitled to compensation.

    8. I may note that there exists certain grave/peculiar facts in the present case, and which possibly show the fraudulent nature of the claim. The first is that the witness Sh. Rajeev who appeared on behalf of the appellants as AW-2, his existence was not known till the affidavit by way of evidence was filed. The name of this witness is not mentioned in the report of the accident. There is no mention of the name of this witness even in the claim petition. This witness is thus not a genuine witness and has been rightly so held by the Railway Claims Tribunal. Another aspect to be also noted is that this witness AW-2 Sh. Rajeev has not filed and proved any ticket to show that he was travelling with the deceased on the date of the alleged death of the deceased.

    9. There is another aspect which shows that the case set up by the appellants is not correct inasmuch as even as per the appellants/claimants the deceased got cut up by another train with which he came into contact, however, railway authorities have not been given a report by the train driver of the so called other train about occurrence of any such accident and which reporting ordinarily takes place by a driver of a train if a man is crushed under the train which that driver was commandeering.

    10. This Court is of the opinion that really the deceased, who was not living not too far away from the place of the incident, was in fact trying to cross the railway track on that fateful day and he unfortunately was run over by a train.

    11. In view of the above, I do not find that the Railway Claims Tribunal, in any manner committed an error in denying the claim of the appellants/claimants. Deceased has rightly been held not to be a bona fide passenger who was travelling by the train.

    12. The appeal is therefore dismissed. Though the present is a fit case for imposition of costs, however, I am not imposing any costs because the husband/father of the appellants/claimants had died in the accident.

    13. Let the copy of this judgment be sent to the Chairman Railway Claims Tribunal for being circulated so that the legal position of the onus of proof is known.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gurcharan Singh & Ors. v. Union Of India
    (Jan 8, 2014)