Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 DHC 1711
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 106 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • provisions of Section 116 of T.P Act
  • Section 113 of the T.P Act.20.
  • Order 20 Rule 12 of the CPC
  • Section 106 of the T.P Act.
  • Section 107 of the T.P Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 DHC 1711
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 106 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • provisions of Section 116 of T.P Act
  • Section 113 of the T.P Act.20.
  • Order 20 Rule 12 of the CPC
  • Section 106 of the T.P Act.
  • Section 107 of the T.P Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit concerns the basement (2298 sq. ft.) of property No. 5/67, W.E.A, Padam Singh Road / Ajmal Khan Road, Karol Bagh, New Delhi. The plaintiff (the landlord) had executed a registered lease deed dated 1.12.1983 in favour of the defendant bank for a fixed term of nine years and ten months, with a monthly rent of Rs. 14,937/-. The lease expired by efflux of time on 30.9.1993.

After expiry, the parties engaged in negotiations for renewal at market rent (both orally and in writing) but no concluded agreement resulted. The plaintiff served a registered notice dated 25.2.1995 terminating the tenancy and calling upon the defendant to hand over vacant physical possession by 31.3.1995. The defendant did not vacate by that date but continued to pay the earlier agreed rent. The present suit for possession and mesne profits/damages was filed on 12.3.2001. During the pendency of the suit the property was vacated (the opinion records the vacating date variously as 25.10.2001 and 28.9.2001; the text states both dates as admitted facts).

Issues were framed on 14.8.2003. Evidence was led: plaintiff examined PW‑1 (plaintiff No.1); the defendant led two witnesses (DW‑1 and DW‑2). The Court heard arguments, considered records and proceeded to decide issue-wise.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether no valid notice under Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act was served upon the defendant? If so, to what effect?
  2. Whether the suit has not been properly valued for the purpose of Court fee and jurisdiction?
  3. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the arrears of rent/damages as prayed?
  4. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to mesne profits? If so, at what rate and for what period?
  5. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to interest? if so, at what rate and on what amount?
  6. Relief.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The registered lease deed dated 1.12.1983 expired on 30.9.1993 and was not renewed by a registered instrument; hence after expiry tenancy became month-to-month.
  • The plaintiff served a valid registered notice dated 25.2.1995 (Ex. PW‑1/3) terminating the tenancy w.e.f. 31.3.1995 and calling for vacant physical possession.
  • The defendant continued as an unauthorized occupant after termination and is liable to pay mesne profits/damages from 1.4.1995 onwards.
  • The plaintiff relied on a lease dated 30.9.1998 (Ex. PW‑1/16) for the mezzanine floor of the same property showing higher rents (Rs. 39/ sq. ft. and later Rs. 51/ sq. ft.), and pro rata reduced those rates to estimate appropriate basement rent for the contested periods.
  • Communications between the parties (letters and notices: Ex. PW‑1/4, PW‑1/5, PW‑1/6, PW‑1/8, PW‑1/9, PW‑1/10 and legal notice 10.2.2001) evidenced the plaintiff’s position on market rent and notice to quit; the defendant’s reply to the 10.2.2001 notice denied liability.
  • Relied on the decree and inquiry in a co-owner Man Mohan Singh’s suit (mesne profit fixed at Rs. 60/ sq. ft. for half the ground floor) as supporting evidence of market rates in the building.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant contended that acceptance of rent by the plaintiff up to 28.9.2001 evidenced a tenancy or at least precluded claims for mesne profits/damages (i.e., that the plaintiff’s acceptance of rent amounted to waiver).
  • DW‑1 deposed that prevailing market rates during 1998–2001 in the locality were only Rs. 20–25/ sq. ft. (basement not more than Rs. 20/ sq. ft.), and that present rates were Rs. 15–20/ sq. ft.; several specific local bank rents were listed by DW‑1 (no documentary proof was produced).
  • DW‑2 stated the defendant had paid rent up to 28.9.2001 and therefore was not liable for further use and occupation charges beyond payments made.
  • Reliance was placed on Section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act to contend that after expiry the lease became a month-to-month tenancy (the Court recorded this principle but examined its effect in light of the plaintiff’s termination).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
C. Albert Morris v. K. Chandrasekaran, 2005 (2) RCJ 148 (SC) Acceptance of rent by a landlord after a lease has been determined (by efflux of time or notice to quit) does not by itself create a new tenancy or confer upon the occupant the status/right of a tenant. The Court relied on this authority to reject the defendant's contention that the plaintiff's acceptance of rent converted the occupation into a tenancy or barred claims for mesne profits/damages.
Punjab National Bank v. Riviera Apartments Pvt. Ltd., 140 (2007) DLT 649 (DB) An acceptance of rent does not amount to a waiver of a notice under Section 113 of the Transfer of Property Act. The Court cited this coordinate-bench decision to support the conclusion that acceptance of rent did not waive the plaintiff's earlier termination notice and did not defeat the plaintiff's claim for mesne profits.
Burmah Shell Oil Distributing v. Khaja Midhat Noor, (1988) 3 SCC 44 : AIR 1988 SC 1470 In absence of a registered instrument extending a lease exceeding one year, the lease is to be treated as a month-to-month tenancy (Section 107/116 principles referenced). The Court accepted the legal proposition that the original registered lease having expired and not being extended by a registered instrument became month-to-month, but held that the plaintiff validly terminated that monthly tenancy by Ex. PW‑1/3, rendering the defendant a tenant at sufferance liable for use and occupation charges after termination.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded issue‑wise, placing onus where the evidence required and evaluating documentary and oral evidence strictly as recorded:

  1. Issue No.1 (Validity of notice under Section 106 T.P. Act): The Court found the onus on the defendant. The registered notice dated 25.2.1995 (Ex. PW‑1/3) clearly terminated tenancy w.e.f. 31.3.1995 and complied with the twin requirements of Section 106 (minimum 15 days and expiration at end of tenancy month). The notice was admitted by the defendant in the written statement and was not contradicted in cross‑examination. The notice was held valid; Issue No.1 decided for the plaintiff.
  2. Issue No.2 (Valuation for court fee/jurisdiction): The onus was on the defendant; no evidence was led by defendant to challenge the plaintiff’s stated valuation and payment of ad valorem court fee (the plaint disclosed valuation particulars and an undertaking to pay additional fees if awarded). Issue No.2 decided for the plaintiff.
  3. Issues Nos.3 & 4 (Entitlement and quantum of mesne profits/damages): The Court summarized agreed facts: lease expired 30.9.1993; no registered extension; tenancy became month-to-month by operation of law (Section 107/116 principle). The plaintiff validly terminated that monthly tenancy by Ex. PW‑1/3, so defendant became an unauthorized occupant liable for damages/use and occupation from 1.4.1995 onward.
  4. On quantum, the Court rejected the defendant’s oral claims about lower market rents for lack of documentary proof. The Court accepted comparative evidence: a lease for the mezzanine floor (Ex. PW‑1/16) showed rents of Rs. 39/ sq. ft. (1.10.1996–30.9.1999) and Rs. 51/ sq. ft. (1.10.1999–30.9.2002). Judicial notice was taken that basement rents would be lower; PW‑1 provided a pro rata reduction chart (unchallenged in cross‑examination). The Court also relied on a decree in a co-owner’s suit awarding mesne profits of Rs. 60/ sq. ft. for half the ground floor (post‑inquiry).
  5. Using the unchallenged pro rata reduction, the Court fixed mesne profits/damages for the plaintiff as follows:
    • For 18 months (period corresponding to 1.10.1996–30.9.1999 pro rata): Rs. 30/ sq. ft. per month — amounting to Rs. 12,40,920/-.
    • For next 18 months (corresponding to 1.10.1999–30.9.2002 pro rata up to the suit filing period): Rs. 40/ sq. ft. per month — amounting to Rs. 16,54,560/-.
    • For the intervening six months from 1.4.2001 to 1.10.2001 (possession handed over): Rs. 40/ sq. ft. per month — amounting to Rs. 5,51,520/-.
    • Total computed before deduction: Rs. 34,47,000/-.
    The Court directed deduction of rent already paid by the defendant (up to 1.10.2001) amounting to Rs. 7,38,634/-, leaving a net payable of Rs. 27,08,366/-.
  6. The Court rejected the defendant’s contention that plaintiff’s acceptance of rent up to 28.9.2001 precluded claims for mesne profits, relying on cited precedents (C. Albert Morris; Punjab National Bank) to hold acceptance did not create a tenancy or waive the notice.
  7. Issue No.5 (Interest): Although no contractual rate was stipulated, DW‑1 admitted liability to pay interest. The Court fixed a commercial rate of 12% p.a. as fair and ordered interest @12% p.a. from the date of filing of the suit until realization.
  8. Issue No.6/Relief: The Court decreed the suit in the calculated net amount subject to deposit of any additional court fee as directed.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Suit decreed in favour of the plaintiff for Rs. 27,08,366/-, with interest at 12% per annum from the date of filing of the suit until realization.

Implications (direct effect on the parties):

  • The defendant bank is ordered to pay the plaintiff Rs. 27,08,366/- (net) representing mesne profits/damages for unauthorized use and occupation after termination of tenancy, together with interest @12% p.a. from the date of suit filing until payment.
  • The decree is to be drawn subject to the plaintiff depositing any additional court fee as directed; thereafter the file is to be consigned to the records room.
  • The decision applies the settled principles that acceptance of rent after termination does not itself create a renewed tenancy or waive a valid notice to quit, and that an expired registered lease without registered extension becomes month-to-month — but a valid subsequent termination notice can render the occupant liable as a tenant at sufferance.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal precedent; it applies existing authorities and the facts and documents before the Court to determine entitlement and quantum in this particular dispute.

Order recorded in the judgment: "Suit decreed." The decree is subject to the plaintiff depositing additional court fee as required by the Court's directions.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ravi Chadha v. Bank Of Maharashtra

    Indermeet Kaur, J.— Suit property is the basement measuring 2298 sq. ft. of property bearing No. 5/67, W.E.A, Padam Singh Road, Karol Bagh, New Delhi. Plaintiff, the landlord of the suit property had vide registered lease deed dated 1.12.1983 leased out the suit property to the defendant bank for a period of nine years and ten months. Lease was for a fixed period; monthly rent was Rs. 14,937/-. The lease expired by efflux of time on 30.9.1993

    2. After the expiry of lease, several negotiations orally as also in writing were held interse between the parties for renewal of the lease at the market rate of rent. No material decision was taken. On 25.2.1995 plaintiff terminated/determined the tenancy of the defendant and the called upon him to handover the vacant physical possession of the suit property to him on or before 31.3.1995 Defendant did not vacate the property. He, however, continued to pay the admitted rate of rent. Present suit was filed on 12.3.2001 for possession and mesne profit/damages. During the pendency of the suit on 25.10.2001 the suit property was vacated. All these facts are admitted; they are not in dispute.

    3. On 14.8.2003 the following issues were framed:

    1. Whether no valid notice under Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act was served upon the defendant? If so, to what effect?

    —(OPD)

    2. Whether the suit has not been properly valued for the purpose of Court fee and jurisdiction?

    —(OPD)

    3. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the arrears of rent/damages as prayed?

    —(OPP)

    4. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to mesne profits? If so, at what rate and for what period?

    —(OPP)

    5. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to interest? if so, at what rate and on what amount?

    —(OPP)

    6. Relief.

    4. The plaintiff in support of their case have examined plaintiff No. 1 as PW-1. The defendant in support of his case has examined two witnesses namely Anil Kumar Manikar, DW-1, Senior Manager as also Om Prakash, DW-2, Manager of the defendant company.

    5. Arguments have been heard. Record has been perused. Issue-wise findings are as follows:

    Issue No. 1:

    6. Onus to discharge this issue was on the defendant. Notice dated 25.2.1995 had been served upon the defendant by the plaintiff terminating his tenancy w.e.f 31.3.1995 asking him to hand over the vacant and physical possession of the property to the plaintiff. This document has been proved as Ex. PW-1/3. Damages @ Rs. 35/- per sq. feet for the unauthorized use and occupation of the premises w.e.f 1.10.1993 have also been claimed. This was a clear and unambiguous intention of the lessor to the lessee specifically notifying that since the tenancy had expired by efflux of time, he was liable to vacate the property and hand over the vacant and physical possession of the same to the lessor on the last date of the next calendar month i.e by 31.3.1995

    7. The twin requirements of a notice under Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act (hereinafter referred to as the T.P Act):

    (i) a minimum period of 15 days time for the tenant to vacate the premises;

    (ii) this time should expire with the end of the tenancy month; are fulfilled.

    8. These averments in the plaint have been reiterated by PW-1 on oath in Court. Nothing contrary has been elicited in his cross-examination. Notice Ex. PW-1/3 in fact is not disputed; it is a admitted document. In the written statement, the defendant has admitted these documents and the relevant extract reads as “the plaintiffs through their Counsel, vide registered AD notice dated 25.2.1995 terminated/determind the tenancy of the Defendant bank and called upon it is vacate and hand over the physical vacant possession of the suit property to the plaintiffs on or before 31.3.1995”.

    9. This was a valid notice under Section 106 of the T.P Act. Issue No. 2 is decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant.

    Issue No. 2:

    10. The onus to discharge this issue was on the defendant. No evidence has been led on this score. Plaintiff in para No. 26 of the plaint has stated that the suit has been valued for the purposes of Court fee and jurisdiction for Rs. 2,06,130.60 being the last paid rent/use and occupation charges for one year on which ad valorem Court fees of Rs. 4393.60 has been paid. For the recovery of damages valuation of suit has been fixed at Rs. 31,04,370/- on which ad valorem Court fees of Rs. 32,648.80 has been paid. Total Court fees of Rs. 37,045/- has been paid. Further the plaintiff has undertaken to pay the additional Court fee, if so, directed in terms of the mesne profits/damages if awarded at a higher rate.

    11. Issue No. 2 is decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant.

    Issue Nos. 3 & 4:

    12. These issues shall be decided by a common discussion. It is not in dispute that the property has been vacated on 28.9.2001 This finds mention in the deposition of DW-1 and has not been challenged. It is also not in dispute that the rate of rent first agreed between the parties in terms of the lease deed dated 1.12.1983 has been paid by the defendant to the plaintiff up to 30.9.1993 The lease has been determined by efflux of time on 30.9.1993 Thereafter admittedly no document has been executed between the parties renewing their lease. Tenancy has become month to month. The plaintiff vide Ex. PW-1/3 has validly terminated the tenancy of the defendant w.e.f 31.3.1995 After 1.4.1995 defendant had become became an unauthorized occupant and liable to pay mesne profit/damages for his unauthorized use and occupation.

    13. Question is what is the amount which is payable by the defendant?

    14. PW-1 on oath has placed on record a lease dated 30.9.1998 executed between the defendant bank and Gagan Sachdeva in respect of the mezzanine basement of the same property i.e the property bearing No. 5/67, Ajmal Khan Road, Karol Bagh. This document has been proved as Ex. PW-1/16 In the mezzanine floor of the same property the rate of rent was Rs. 39/- per sq. feet w.e.f 1.10.1996 to 30.9.1999 thereafter w.e.f 1.10.1999 to 30.9.2002 @ Rs. 51/- per sq. feet. The pro rata decrease in the rate of rent has also been detailed in para No. 27 of the affidavit of PW-1.

    15. Defendant to counter this evidence has on oath deposed that during the year 1998 to 2001 rate of rent in the locality where the suit property is situated was not more Rs. 20/- to Rs. 25/- sq. per feet per month. The present rate of rent is Rs. 15/- to Rs. 20/- per sq. feet per month. Witness has deposed in December 2003. He has further deposed that from inquiry it has been revealed that Bank of Baroda has been paying rent ® Rs. 55/- per sq. feet per month in respect of ground floor and at Rs. 20/- per sq. feet per month for the basement; Oriental Bank of Commerce has been paying the rent @ Rs. 40/- per sq. feet per month, South Indian Bank has been paying the rent @ Rs. 42.50/- per sq. feet per month, Andhra Bank has been paying the rent ® Rs. 21/- per sq. feet per month, Bank of Baroda (Ajmal Khan Road Branch) has been paying the rent @ Rs. 17/- per sq. feet per month, Corporation Bank has been paying the rent @ Rs. 45/- per sq. feet per month in respect of ground floor and the Indian Bank has been paying the rent @ Rs. 36/- per sq. feet per month and the rent regarding the basement in the same locality is not more than Rs. 20/- per sq. feet per month; further the rate of rent has never increased beyond Rs. 25/- per square feet per month.

    16. However, no document has been produced to substantiate these averments. In his cross-examination, DW-1 has admitted that he has no documents to show what was the prevailing rate of rent as has been deposed by him in his examination-in-chief. DW-2 has deposed that the defendant is not liable to pay any use and occupation charges as defendant has paid up to date rent up to 28.9.2001

    17. Defendant has submitted that the plaintiff has without any demur or protest admittedly accepted this rent up to 28.9.2001 This does not now entitle hint for any claim of damages or mesne profit.

    18. In C. Albert Morris v. K. Chandrasekaran, 2005 (2) RCJ 148 (SC), the Supreme Court has held:

    “We are, therefore, of the opinion that a mere acceptance of rent by the landlord-1st respondent herein from the tenant in possession after the lease has been determined either by efflux of time or by notice to quit would not create a tenancy so as to confer the erstwhile tenant the status of a tenant or a right to be in possession.”

    19. In Punjab National Bank… v. Riviera Apartments Pvt. Ltd.…., 140 (2007) DLT 649 (DB), it has been held by a coordinate Bench of this Court that a acceptance of rent would not amount to a waiver of the notice under Section 113 of the T.P Act.

    20. This argument of the learned defence Counsel is thus negatived.

    21. Reliance has also been placed on the provisions of Section 116 of T.P Act to advance the submission that after the expiry of the lease deed defendant has become a tenant on month to month basis. Reliance has been placed upon Burmah Shell Oil Distributing v. Khaja Midhat Noor, (1988) 3 SCC 44 : AIR 1988 SC 1470. There is no doubt to this proposition. The registered lease deed has admittedly expired by efflux of time. There has been no extension of the same; a lease for a period of exceeding one year could have been extended only by a registered instrument. In the absence of such a registered instrument a lease should be deemed to be a lease from month to month. In terms of Section 107 of the T.P Act a lease in the absence of registered instrument becomes a monthly lease. This proposition is not disputed. However, the subsequent termination of the tenancy in terms of Ex. PW-1/3 is a valid termination and the monthly lease has been terminated by the plaintiff w.e.f 31.3.1995 after which the defendant has become a tenant at sufferance and liable to pay charges for his unauthorized use and occupation.

    22. Attention has been drawn to the inter se communications between the parties. On 6.7.1997 vide Ex. PW-1/4 defendants wrote to the plaintiff conveying to them that they have received a sanction for renewal of the lease deed of the 50% of the ground floor portion let out to them by the plaintiff. In terms of this letter the enhanced rent would be Rs. 18/- per sq. feet per month which would be effective from 1.4.1997 with a revision of 25% after five years; this lease period would be 10 years commencing from 1.10.1993 On 15.7.1997 vide Ex. PW-1/5 the plaintiff making a reference to the letter Ex. PW-1/4 wrote to the defendant that the prevailing market rent is Rs. 35/- per sq. feet per month and they are willing to accept the rate of Rs. 32/- per sq. feet per month but the offer of Rs. 18/- per sq. feet per month is not acceptable. On 9.10.1997 vide Ex. PW-1/6 the plaintiff wrote to the defendant bank enclosing a letter of the Indian Overseas Bank indicating the prevailing market rent. This was reiterated by the plaintiff in his letter dated 5.3.1998 Ex. PW1/8. This was again reiterated in the subsequent letters dated 3.12.1998 Ex. PW1/9 and 25.1.1999 Ex. PW1/10 with a warning that in case the offers of the plaintiff are not accepted, legal recourse would have to be taken.

    23. Legal notice dated 10.2.2001 had been served upon the defendants by the plaintiff making a demand of Rs. 45/- per sq. feet per month as damages w.e.f 1.10.1993, receipt of this legal notice is not disputed. On 28.2.2001 vide Ex. PW-1/14 the defendant had replied to the legal notice of the plaintiff. It was stated that the plea of the plaintiff to enhance the rent was only a harassment on the defendant. He denied his liability to pay the enhanced rent.

    24. It is not in dispute that 50% of the remaining portion of the ground floor of the suit property had also been let out to the bank by its co-owner namely Man Mohan Singh. The said Man Mohan Singh had filed a suit for possession for recovery of mesne profits. The said suit had been decreed on 29.4.2000; mesne profit/damages for use and occupation had been awarded @ Rs. 90/- per sq. feet per month which had been modified in appeal to Rs. 60/- per sq. feet per month with direction to the trial Court to conduct inquiry. Trial Court on inquiry had concluded that the rate of Rs. 60/- per sq. feet per month for use and occupation was just and fair. This was for the half portion of the ground floor of the suit property.

    25. Mesne profits have been claimed for the preceding three years i.e from 1.3.1998 to 28.2.2001, however entitlement of the plaintiff company is three years prior to the filing of the suit which would be from 11.3.1998 to 12.3.2001

    26. Property had been vacated on 28.9.2001 On record, it has been proved that the adjoining property i.e 50% of the share which is co-owned by Man Mohan Singh had been decreed for mesne profits/damages @ Rs. 60/- per sq. feet per month w.e.f 20.11.1997 up to 30.9.2001 Order of District Judge dated 29.4.2000 on the application under Order 20 Rule 12 of the CPC in the said suit is on record. In the present case there is a further positive evidence to substantiate the averment of the plaintiff that rent of the same property i.e for the mezzanine floor in the same building was @ Rs. 39/- per sq. feet per month from the October 1996 up to September 1999 and thereafter at Rs. 51/- per sq. feet per month from October 1999 to September 2002. These are the relevant periods for which the plaintiff is entitled to make his claim. Admittedly, this rate of rent is for the mezzanine floor. Judicial notice is taken of the fact that the rent of the basement will be lower in comparison to the rent being paid for the mezzanine floor. A pro rata decrease in the rental of the mezzanine floor qua the basement has been tabulated in a chart and finds mention in para No. 27 of the evidence by way of affidavit of PW-1. The rate of Rs. 39/- for the mezzanine floor would pro rata decrease to Rs. 32.90 for the period 1.10.996 to 30.9.1999 and for the period 1.10.1999 to 30.9.2002 corresponding rate of Rs. 51/- would be decreased to Rs. 42.80/- for the basement. This pro rata reduction has not been challenged in the cross-examination of PW-1. The rental of the basement would by and large be 1/3rd less than the rental of the mezzanine floor. This calculation is accepted.

    27. Plaintiff is thus entitled to damages/mesne profits for 18 months @ 30/- per sq. feet per month (less then Rs. 39/- per sq. feet per month for the mezzanine floor) and from the period 12.9.1999 up to the date of filing of suit i.e 12.3.2001 for the balance 18 months @ Rs. 40/- per sq. feet per month (less than Rs. 51/- per sq. feet per month for the mezzanine floor). Plaintiff would accordingly be entitled to damages/mesne profits for 18 months ® Rs. 30/- per sq. feet per month and for the next 18 months @ Rs. 40/- per sq. feet per month; this amount would be minus the “rental” which had already been paid by the defendant to the plaintiff i.e up to 1.10.2001 The amount calculated for the first 18 months @ Rs. 30/- per sq. feet per month would be Rs. 12,40,920/- and for the next 18 months @ Rs. 40/- per sq. feet per month would be Rs. 16,54,560/- i.e a total sum of Rs. 28,95,480/-.

    28. For the period from 1.4.2001 up to 1.10.2001 i.e the six months intervening period when the possession was finally handed over by the defendant to the plaintiff, plaintiff is entitled to damages/mesne profits @ Rs. 40/- per month which is calculated in the sum of Rs. 5,51,520/-. Total amount thus due and payable is Rs. 34,47,000/-. The “rental” as paid by the defendant to the plaintiff has to be deducted which is calculated Rs. 7,38,634/-; balance amount due and payable to the plaintiff is Rs. 27,08,366/-.

    29. Issue Nos. 4 and 5 are decided accordingly in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant.

    Issue No. 6:

    30. Although there is no stipulated rate of interest which has been carved out and there is no document to the said effect yet DW-1 as admitted that the defendant bank is liable to pay interest. Being a commercial transaction; rate of interest @ 12% per annum is fair and just. Decree will carry interest @ 12% per annum which will be calculated from the date of filing of the suit till realization.

    Issue No. 7: Relief:

    31. Suit is decreed in the sum of Rs. 27,08,366/- with interest @ 12% per annum to be paid from the date of filing of the suit till realization. Subject to the plaintiff depositing the additional Court fee, decree sheet be drawn. File be consigned to record room.

    Suit decreed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ravi Chadha v. Bank Of Maharashtra
    (Mar 23, 2010)