AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub rule (2) of Rule 10 of Order I CPC
  • Order 1 Rule 10 CPC
  • Order I Rule 10 CPC,
  • O.1 Rule 10(2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub rule (2) of Rule 10 of Order I CPC
  • Order 1 Rule 10 CPC
  • Order I Rule 10 CPC,
  • O.1 Rule 10(2)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged the trial court's rejection of its application under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC seeking impleadment as a party to a suit instituted by respondent No.1 against respondents 2 to 6. Respondent No.1's suit sought perpetual and mandatory injunction, alleging respondents 2 to 6 were its employees, were inducted into possession of premises belonging to respondent No.1 by virtue of that employment, and upon termination of employment were bound to restore possession. The petitioner claimed (in an application dated 5.2.1996) that it, and not respondent No.1, was the owner of the suit property, asserting the sale consideration in 1985 was paid from the petitioner's bank account and that the 1985 sale deed was manipulated in respondent No.1's name; it sought impleadment to avoid multiplicity of proceedings. The trial court refused impleadment as neither necessary nor proper. The present opinion disposes of the revision arising from that refusal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner should be impleaded as a party under Order I Rule 10 CPC.
  2. Whether the petitioner is a "necessary" or "proper" party to the suit as per the tests applied by the court.
  3. Whether allegations of title (ownership) justify impleadment where the plaintiff's case is limited to employment and possession matters.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner asserted it is the true owner of the suit property and the sale consideration in 1985 was paid from its bank account, with the sale deed manipulated to show respondent No.1 as owner.
  • Relying on precedents, the petitioner submitted that the phrase "questions involved in the suit" in Order I Rule 10(2) CPC should be liberally interpreted and impleadment should be allowed to avoid multiplicity of proceedings.
  • The petitioner argued non-impleadment would seriously prejudice its interests and lead to multiplicity of proceedings.

Respondent No.1's Allegations (as pleaded in the plaint)

  • Respondent No.1 alleged respondents 2 to 6 were its employees and were inducted into possession of its premises by virtue of that employment.
  • Respondent No.1 alleged that upon termination of their employment (or cessation of entitlement) respondents 2 to 6 were liable to restore possession to respondent No.1 and sought perpetual and mandatory injunction accordingly.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Satish Chand Gupta v. Sarvesh Chand Gupta, AIR 1984 DELHI 409 That the expression "questions involved in the suit" in O.1 R.10(2) CPC should be liberally interpreted and impleadment may be allowed so the real dispute is decided in presence of all interested parties; a material question common to parties and third parties should be tried once for all. The court treated this decision as distinguishable on facts and noted the principle but found it inapplicable to the present suit.
Khaja Abdul Khader v. Mahabub Saheb, AIR 1979 AP 152 That where the defendant denies the plaintiff's title, a third party claiming title sought to be impleaded must be considered a necessary and proper party for adjudication of ownership. The court held this decision distinguishable because the present suit does not raise the question of title which would necessitate impleadment.
Panne Khushali v. jcewanlal, AIR 1976 MP 148 Tests for determining a necessary party: (i) there must be a right to some relief against such party in respect of the matter involved; (ii) it should not be possible to pass an effective decree in the absence of such a party. The court relied on this Full Bench decision (and its articulation of the tests) to conclude the petitioner was neither necessary nor proper.
D.C v. Ramakrishan, AIR 1953 SC 521 Authority cited (via Panne Khushali) as part of Supreme Court jurisprudence underpinning tests for necessary parties. Referenced as part of the jurisprudential foundation for the two tests applied by the court.
Benaras Bank v. Bhagwandas, AIR 1947 All 18 Authority cited (via Panne Khushali) as part of Full Bench precedent supporting tests for necessary parties. Referenced as part of the jurisprudential foundation for the two tests applied by the court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court rejected the petitioner's broad contention that O.1 R.10(2) CPC should be applied to permit impleadment whenever multiplicity of proceedings might be avoided. It adopted the tests for a "necessary party" (there must be a right to relief against the party in respect of the matter involved; an effective decree should not be possible in the party's absence) as laid down in Panne Khushali and its authorities. Applying those tests, the court found the present suit's issues are limited to: (i) whether defendants 2–6 were in employment of respondent No.1, (ii) whether they were inducted into possession as employees, and (iii) whether they are liable to restore possession after termination of employment. The court held that title to the property is not in issue in the suit; impleading the petitioner (who claimed title) would enlarge the scope into a title suit and complicate trial. The petitioner had not disputed the plaint's averments on the three employment/possession points. The court concluded impleadment was neither necessary nor proper and observed the petitioner remained free to institute a separate suit on title.

Holding and Implications

Revision dismissed.

Direct effects on the parties: the petitioner's application for impleadment was refused; the petitioner's revision was dismissed without any order as to costs; associated CMs (2799, 4263/96) stand rejected. The opinion confines its decision to the parties and facts before the court and does not purport to establish any new broader precedent beyond applying established tests for necessary and proper parties.

    Evangelical Church Of Indiapetitioner v. North India Outreach Society.S

    R.C Lahoti, J.— The petitioner is aggrieved by the rejection of its application under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC seeking impleadment as a party to the suit filed by respondent No. 1 against respondents 2 to 6.

    2. Respondent No. 1 has filed a suit for issuance of perpetual and mandatory injunction against respondents 2 to 6 alleging that respondent No. 2 to 6 were employees of respondent No. 1 and in their capacity as employees were inducted into possession of the premises belonging to the society respondent No. 1, which employment having come to an end, the respondent No. 2 to 6 were bound to restore possession to respondent No. 1.

    3. According to the petitioner, as per the averments made in the application dated 5.2.1996, under Order I Rule 10 CPC, it is the petitioner and not the plaintiff-respondent No. 1, who is the owner of the suit property. The sale consideration at the time of acquisition of the property in the year 1985 was paid out of the bank account of the petitioner but the sale deed which was executed in 1985 was so manipulated as to be executed in the name of the plaintiff-respondent No. 1. It was further submitted that if the petitioner was not allowed to be impleaded as a party to the suit, there will be multiplicity of the proceedings and the interest of the applicant-petitioner would be seriously prejudiced.

    4. The learned trial court has rejected the application filed by the petitioner forming an opinion that the petitioner was neither a necessary nor a proper party to the suit. The impleadment would enlarge the scope of controversy in the suit which could not be allowed.

    5. The learned counsel for the petitioner has placed forceful reliance on Satish Chand Gupta v. Sarvesh Chand Gupta, AIR 1984 DELHI 409 and Khaja Abdul Khader v. Mahabub Saheb, AIR 1979 AP 152 to submit that the expression : ‘questions involved in the suit’ as occurring in sub rule (2) of Rule 10 of Order I CPC has to be liberally interpreted. To attract the applicability of the provision, it is not necessary that the party sought to be impleaded should be one whose presence may be required for deciding the questions already arising in the suit. If the impleadment would avoid multiplicity of the proceedings touching the same property then it should be allowed.

    6. In the opinion of this court the proposition canvassed by the learned counsel for the petitioner is too wide and cannot be accepted. I may straightaway refer to a Full Bench decision of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in Panne Khushali v. jcewanlal, AIR 1976 MP 148. Placing reliance on the Supreme Court decision in D.C v. Ramakrishan, AIR 1953 SC 521 and Full Bench decision of Allahabad High Court in Benaras Bank v. Bhagwandas, AIR 1947 All 18, the following tests have been laid down for determining who is necessary party to a suit.

    “(i) There must be a right to some relief against such party in respect of the matter involved in the proceedings in question.

    (ii) It should not be possible to pass an effective decree in the absence of such a party.”

    7. As to who is a proper party it has been held vide para 13 in the case of Panne ( supra):

    “The governing expression for deciding the question of proper party is whose presence before the Court may be necessary in order to enable the Court effectually and completely to adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved in the suit. Thus, the question of proper parties has also to be decided, bearing in mind the scope of the suit. The question involved in the suit is the enforceability of the contract entered into between the parties. If these applicants are introduced as party in the suit, the scope of the suit, as already observed hereinabove would be enlarged and it would be turned into a suit for title., For effectually and completely adjudicating upon the rights between the non-applicants Nos. 1 and 2 on the contract, the presence of these applicants is not at all necessary. We cannot be oblivious of the legal position also that the judgment in the suit would be a judgment inter parties and not a judgment in rem and as such, it would be operative only between the parties. Therefore, the expression “all the questions involved in the suit” can very well be said to mean the questions as between the parties to the litigation. The scope of the suit cannot be widened. The judgment in this suit is not going to affect the title of the applicants, if any. The plaintiff is the dominus litus and cannot be forced to add parties against whom he does not want to fight unless it is a compulsion of the rule of law and, as already discussed hereinabove, these applicants are not necessary parties and as such, the plaintiff cannot be forced upon to join them as parties.”

    8. So far as the suit filed by respondent no.1 is concerned, the question of title to the suit property does not arise for decision. All that the plaintiff-respondent No.1 would be required to prove is: (i) that the defendant No.2 to 6 were in the employment of the plaintiff; (ii) that they were inducted into possession of the premises by the plaintiff on account of their being in its employment and (iii) that the defendants are liable to restore possession to the plaintiff consequent to their employment having been terminated or they having ceased to be entitled to continue in possession of the premises. To decide any of these questions, impleadment of the petitioner is neither necessary nor proper. This impleadment would complicate the trial and call upon the court to embark upon adjudication of such issues as are not germane to the trial of the suit before it. It is pertinent to note that the petitioner has not in his application disputed the correctness of the averments made in the plaint by the respondent NO.1 touching the three points stated hereinabove. By the rejection of the petitioner's application no prejudice is caused to it inasmuch as the petitioner is still at liberty to file its own suit seeking adjudication of title qua the plaintiff-respondent No.1 (impleading the other respondents too if so advised.)

    9. The two decisions relied on by the learned counsel for the petitioner are clearly distinguishable. 9.1In Satish Chand Gupta ( supra) the plaintiff claimed an injunction against the defendant-tenants restraining them from parting with possession. The intervener was co-owner of the premises who had obtained possession during pendency of the suit. In such circumstances the impleadment was allowed and upheld by the High Court. In this context it was observed:

    “The object of O.1 Rule 10(2) is that the real dispute raised in the suit should be decided in the presence of all the parties interested in the suit. It is not limited to questions which are involved in the suit as between the parties originally impleaded.”

    9.2 However, the High Court has further proceeded to say :

    “A material question common to the parties and to third parties should be tried once for all. To secure this result the court has a discretion to add parties which it should exercise, unless by the addition of new parties either of the parties already on the record would be prejudiced of their remedies.”

    9.3 In Khaja's case (supra), the suit was for ejectment of the defendants based on the title of the plaintiff which was denied by the defendant. The intervener had sought for the impleadment setting up his title by heirship. The trial court had held the intervener to be a proper party and permitted impleadment. The High Court of Andhra Pradesh has observed :—

    “When the defendants denied the title of the plaintiffs, the plaintiffs will have to establish their title to the suit property. The court has to determine the question of title of the plaintiffs. In order to decide the question relating to the ownership of the land, the 1st respondent who is sought to be impleaded in the suit as a defendant and who claims to be the owner of the land in question, must be considered to be a necessary and proper party without whose presence the question cannot be finally and effectually adjudicated upon.” [pr 7]

    10. It was this finding recorded by the court which had allowed the impleadment ordered by the trial court being maintained by the High Court.Such is not the case here.

    11. For the foregoing reasons therevision is held devoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed. It is dismissed without any order as to costs.

    12. With the dismissal of the CR, CMs 2799, 4263/96 also stand rejected.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Evangelical Church Of Indiapetitioner v. North India Outreach Society.S
    (Jan 9, 1997)