Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.The
  • Section 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.
  • SECTION 30 ARBITRATION ACT 1940
  • Section 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act,
  • Section 30 of the Arbitrator Act, 1940.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.The
  • Section 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.
  • SECTION 30 ARBITRATION ACT 1940
  • Section 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act,
  • Section 30 of the Arbitrator Act, 1940.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (K. Ramamoorthy, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, M/s Atree Associates (the Contractor), and the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) entered into a contract for providing water supply, sanitary installations and internal development in Pocket-BD, Block-B, Janakpuri, New Delhi. Disputes between the parties were referred to Shri S.C. Kaushal, SE (Arbitration)-II. The Arbitrator passed an award on 20 September 1994 allowing certain claims and rejecting others; the award included pendentelite interest at 12% per annum from 3 June 1993 to 30 May 1994.

The DDA filed objections by IA No. 1440/95. The court record notes relevant commercial and timeline particulars recorded in the opinion:

  • Estimated cost: Rs. 57,00,006/-
  • Tender cost: Rs. 84,64,509/-
  • Tender percentage: 45% above DSR 1981
  • Date of start: 6.4.1985
  • Date of completion (contract): 5.7.1986
  • Actual date of completion: 3.5.1989
  • Payments were made only in 1992.

The court considered the DDA's objections, counsel submissions (notably by Mr. V.K. Sharma for the DDA), the Arbitrator's award and the material placed before the Arbitrator, and heard responses by the Contractor before deciding whether to interfere with the arbitral award under the Arbitration Act, 1940.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Arbitrator's awards on the various identified claims suffer from an error apparent on the face of the record or misconduct such that the court should interfere under Sections 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.
  2. Whether the specific monetary awards made by the Arbitrator on Claims 1, 2 (sub-claims i, iii, xi), 3, 9, 17, 18, and 19 should be set aside, modified or confirmed in the light of the objections raised by the DDA.

Arguments of the Parties

Delhi Development Authority (DDA) — Principal Objections and Contentions

  • General contention: the Arbitrator did not give adequate reasons for various awards; absence of reasons vitiates the award and prevents intelligible scrutiny of the Arbitrator's mind and process.
  • Specific contention as to Claim No. 1: argued that no reasons were given for allowing the Contractor's claim for rebates recovered from running/final bills.
  • Specific contention as to Claim No. 2 (multiple sub-items): contended that the Arbitrator arrived at conclusions without reasons or intelligible working of mind for items 2(i), 2(iii) and 2(xi).
  • Similar objections were raised in respect of Claims 3, 9, 17 and 18 — asserting absence of reasons and challenging the rational basis of the Arbitrator's decisions.

Contractor (M/s Atree Associates) — Principal Responses

  • Asserted that material placed before the Arbitrator (documents such as Ex.R-III, R-IV, R-IVA, R-1, Annexures to the final bill and other documentary evidence) supported the claims and explained the Arbitrator's conclusions.
  • For Claim No. 1: relied on documentary evidence to show the DDA had not fulfilled contractual obligations for rebate conditions.
  • For Claim No. 2(i): pointed out admissions and absence of rate submissions by the Respondent; argued the Arbitrator correctly distinguished lintel bends from ordinary beams.
  • For other sub-claims (2(iii), 2(xi), Claim 3, 9, 17, 18): asserted that the Arbitrator considered the relevant agreement clauses and material, and that findings were supported by evidence and hence permissible under Sections 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a claim-by-claim review of the Arbitrator's award limited to the material before the Arbitrator and the objections advanced under the Arbitration Act, 1940. The analysis repeatedly applies two central principles stated or relied upon in the opinion:

  • Findings of fact by the Arbitrator, particularly technical or evidentiary findings, are not generally amenable to review by the court under Sections 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 unless there is an error apparent on the face of the record or misconduct.
  • The sufficiency of reasons: the court examined whether the Arbitrator had provided sufficient reasons or intelligible findings to demonstrate consideration of the material and to show no misconduct or arbitrariness in reaching the conclusions challenged by the DDA.

Applying those principles, the court's step-by-step assessment of the challenged claims is summarized below (the court's own characterizations and quoted formulations are preserved):

  • Claim No. 1 (rebates illegally recovered) — The Arbitrator recorded that the "letter of Award contains four conditions of rebate" and found the Respondent(s) had not fulfilled contractual obligations for availing rebates; he awarded Rs. 1,23,487.30. The judge accepted that the Arbitrator (an engineer) considered the documents and reached a factual conclusion; the court found no error apparent or misconduct warranting interference.
  • Claim No. 2(i) (lintel bends) — The Arbitrator awarded Rs. 12,808.50, concluding that "lintel bends are different than ordinary lintel beams" and Respondents had "wrongly measured and paid". The court found the Award contained sufficient reasons based on evidence/admissions and not open to interference under Section 30/33.
  • Claim No. 2(iii) (butt hinges, welding, lugs) — Arbitrator awarded Rs. 6,660.50 and explained that some elements were included in nomenclature of agreement items (No. 5.1 and 6.1), but others (base tie/sill tie) were partly justified; the court held there was no error warranting interference.
  • Claim No. 2(xi) (earth disposal/lead) — Arbitrator awarded Rs. 23,461/-, relying on Item No. 1.4 of the Agreement and admissions that payment for item 1.4 had not been made though work executed. The court accepted the Arbitrator's reasoning and confirmed the award.
  • Claim No. 3 (withheld sums) — Arbitrator awarded Rs. 6,703/-, noting that the Respondent had released a portion but still withheld Rs. 6,703/- without justification; the court found the award contained sufficient reasons and confirmed it.
  • Claims No. 4 to 8 and 10 to 16 — These claims were rejected by the Arbitrator; the court confirmed those rejections without detailed separate analysis.
  • Claim No. 9 (cartage of C.I. pipes) — Arbitrator awarded Rs. 1,500/- relying on rates worked out by Respondent(s) (Annexure-V). Although the judge observed the sum was small, he considered the DDA's objection and found no error on the face of the record; award confirmed.
  • Claim No. 17 (penal recovery for excess issue) — Arbitrator awarded Rs. 1,258.70, concluding Respondent(s) did not establish that excess materials were available on site or that loss was sustained; award confirmed as not vitiated by the objections.
  • Claim No. 18 (recovery for work at risk and cost) — Arbitrator awarded Rs. 6,406/- after considering the final bill, completion certificate and the absence of material showing the item was not executed; the court found no merit in DDA's objection and confirmed the award.
  • Claim No. 19 (interest) — Contractor sought interest at 24% under various heads; Arbitrator awarded pendentelite interest at 12% p.a. from 3.6.1993 to 30.5.1994. The court found the Arbitrator had exercised his discretion reasonably and declined to interfere.

Throughout the analysis, the court emphasized that the Arbitrator's technical findings and fact-finding (as an engineer arbitrator) were supported by documents, admissions and the agreement's terms; in the absence of an identifiable error apparent on the face of the record or misconduct in the Arbitrator's approach, interference under Sections 30 and 33 was not justified.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court confirmed the Arbitrator's awards on the specified claims and made the award rule of the court. Specifically, the court directed that the DDA pay the Contractor the amounts and interest as determined by the Arbitrator.

Direct consequences and orders set out in the opinion:

  • The court confirmed and directed payment of the aggregate principal sums awarded on the confirmed claims, totaling Rs. 1,82,285.00, broken down in the opinion as:
    • Claim 1: Rs. 1,23,487.30
    • Claim 2(i): Rs. 12,808.50
    • Claim 2(iii): Rs. 6,660.50
    • Claim 2(xi): Rs. 23,461.00
    • Claim 3: Rs. 6,703.00
    • Claim 9: Rs. 1,500.00
    • Claim 17: Rs. 1,258.70
    • Claim 18: Rs. 6,406.00
  • Interest of Rs. 15,147.50 (calculated on Rs. 1,82,285.00 at 12% per annum from 3.6.1993 to 30.5.1994) is to be paid by the DDA.
  • The DDA is also ordered to pay interest at 12% per annum from 20.9.1994 up to the date of realisation on the principal awarded amounts.
  • There shall be no order as to costs.

Implications for precedent and future cases: The opinion does not announce any new legal principle or bind future courts; rather, it applies established standards concerning the limited scope for judicial interference with arbitral findings of fact and the requirement that an arbitral award not be vitiated by an error apparent on the face of the record or arbitrator misconduct. The direct effect is to enforce the Arbitrator's monetary awards and interest as a decree against the DDA.

Note: This summary is strictly confined to the facts, findings, reasoning and orders contained in the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.

    Atree Associates v. Delhi Development Authority

    K. Ramamoorthy, J.:— The Petitioner M/s Atree Associates and the Delhi Development Authority entered into a contract with reference to the work of providing water supply, sanitary installations and internal development in Pocket-BD, Block-B, Janakpuri, New Delhi.

    2. Disputes arose between them and they were referred to Shri S.C Kaushal, SE (Arbitration)-II, for adjudication. The Arbitrator passed the award on 20th September 1994 allowing a few claims and rejecting the rest and awarded interest @ 12% per annum with effect from 3rd June 1993 to 30th May 1994 towards the pendentelite interest.

    3. The DDA filed objection vide IA No. 1440/95. Mr. V.K Sharma learned counsel for the DDA rendering real assistance to the court made submission with reference to Claims Nos 1, 2, 3, 9, 17, 18 and 19. Mr. Sharma was very thorough in his preparation and he could easily make me to appreciate the real controversy in the matter.

    4. The brief facts of the case are as follows:

    Estimated cost Rs.57,00,006/-

    Tender costRs. 84,64,509/-

    Tender percentage 45% above DSR 1981

    Date of start6.4.1985

    Date of completion5.7.1986

    Actual date of completion 3.5.1989

    5. The payments were made only in 1992.

    6. On Claim No. 1

    The Contractor claimed a sum of Rs. 1,37,240/- on account of various rebates illegally recovered from various running bills/final bill without fulfilling contingent conditions. The Arbitrator awarded a sum of Rs. 1,23,487.30. Mr. V.K Sharma learned counsel for the DDA contended that no reason has been given by the Arbitrator and that vitiates the award. The objection in this regard is stated in para (a) at page 2 of the objection. The Contractor in reply stated that the material placed by the Contractor on record would prove the case of the Contractor. The Contractor has also referred to Ex.R-III, R-IV, R-IVA and R-1 in volume IV of the record of the Arbitrator. The learned counsel for the DDA relied on these documents and also Annexure I, Annaexure III to the final bill and also showed me the dates relating to the payment and also the rebates recovered from the Contractor. Though I am dealing with the petition under Section 30 I wanted to satisfy myself whether the award could be sustained on the material placed on record. The Arbitrator has stated “The letter of Award contains four conditions of rebate. Respondent(s) have not fulfilled the contractual obligations, for availing the rebate as per agreed terms of contract. The claim of the Claimant(s) is justified for Rs. 1,23,487.30 (Rs. one lakh twenty three thousand four hundred eighty seven and paise thirty) only, and I decide that the Respondent(s) do pay this amount to the Claimant(s).” The Arbitrator is an Engineer and he has come to the conclusion after considering the documents. Therefore, I do not find any error apparent on the face of the record and it cannot be said that the Arbitrator has misconducted himself in not giving the judgement as it were as contended for by the DDA. The finding given by the Arbitrator that the DDA had not fulfilled the contractual obligation cannot be challenged in the light of the material placed before the Arbitrator.

    7. On Claim No. 2

    In this claim a sum of Rs. 4,90,000/- is claimed by the Contractor for the work done but not paid by the Department.

    The Arbitrator had allowed partly claim Nos 2(i) and 2(iii) and 2(xi) rest of the claims shown in the sub-head were rejected by the Arbitrator.

    claim No. 2(i)

    The arbitrator had awarded a sum of Rs. 12,808.50. Here also the contention that the award is not valid as the Arbitrator has not given any reasons for decision. In reply the Contractor stated:

    Against the said Claim No. 2(i) a sum of Rs. 12,808.50 was awarded the Respondent during the arbitration proceedings admitted the execution of work as to 73.24 .3 however it did not deny the rate claimed by the Petitioner nor the Respondent furnished any rate analysis in respect of the item in question it contended only that there is no difference between the lintel bends and ordinary beams.

    After giving full opportunity to the parties to make their submissions and after taking into consideration the learned Arbitrator held that “lintel bends are different than ordinary beams, therefore the Respondents have wrongly measured and paid”. Hence, the said sum of Rs. 12,808.50 was rightly awarded by the learned Arbitrator. The Award contains the sufficient reasons. The above findings of fact are not amenable to review and or the Court can go into the reasonableness of the reasons recorded in the Award under Section 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940. The said findings of fact are based on evidence.

    The Arbitrator has said:

    “Claimant(s) claim for extra payment on account of lintel bends. As, the lintel bends are different than ordinary lintel beams, therefore the Respondents) have wrongly measured and paid. I, decide that the claim of the Claimant(s) is justified upto Rs. 12,808.50 (Rs. twelve thousand eight hundred eight and paise fifty) only which the Respondent(s) do pay.”

    After considering the materials and the arguments, I am of the view that the Arbitrator is not guilty of any misconduct and there is no error apparent on the face of the record. Therefore, the award on this claim is confirmed.

    8. On Claim No. 2(iii)

    The Arbitrator had awarded Rs. 6,660.50 towards costs of butt hinges and welding to the frame and cost of lugs etc. In the objection petition the DDA has stated that the Arbitrator had come to the conclusion without giving any reasons one is not able to find the intelligible working of the mind, therefore, the Award is vitiated. The contractor in reply thereto has stated that the Arbitrator had considered the claim in the light of Provisions being Items No. 5.1 and 6.1 of the Agreement and the Arbitrator has only said that the claim is partly justified and, therefore, that cannot be challenged by the DDA under Section 30 of the Arbitrator Act, 1940. The Arbitrator has said:

    “The cost of butt hinges and welding to the frame and cost of lugs have been included in the frame item, as per nomenclature of item No. 5.1 of Agreement and under item No. 6.1, hence, extra for cost of provision of lugs and hinges is not justified. The Claimant(s) claim is partly justified for payament of extra cost for base tie/sill tie, I, hold that the claim is partly justified to Rs. 6,660.50 (Rs. six thousand six hundred sixty & paise fifty) only, which the Respondent(s) do pay to the Claimant(s)”.

    Here also I do not find any error warranting interference under Section 30 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.

    9. On Claim No. 2(xi)

    The Arbitrator had passed the Award for Rs. 23,461/-. The DDA in its objection petition has stated that the Arbitrator has not given any reasons for arriving at this decision. It is not known how his mind was working in coming to the conclusion. In reply the Contractor states:

    “Against the said Claim No. 2(xi) a sum of Rs. 23,461/- was awarded. It is submitted that the quantity of earth disposedd was not disputed by Respondents. However the Respondent contended that the rates for such quantity are payable in accordance with the itme No. 1.4 of the Agreement for the disposal of earth within one KM and in that only disputed the lead of 5 KM as claimed by the Petitioner.

    The learned Arbitrator considered the relevant Item No. 1.4 of the Agreementg and in terms of the submissions/admissions of the Respondent the learned Arbitrator awarded a sum of Rs. 23,461/-.

    No reason exist to challenge the Award of Rs. 23,461/- in respect of Claim No. 2(xi).

    It is submitted that the Award contains the sufficient reasons, that “the claim of the Claimants is partly justified as also admitted by the Respondents) during the hearing that no payment have been made for item No. 1.4 of the Agreement though executed”.

    The above findings of fact are not amenable to review and or the court cannot go into the reasonableness of the reasons recorded in the Award under Sections 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940”.

    The Arbitrator has relied upon Clause 1.4 of the agreement and also stated that the DDA had admitted no payment had been made for item No. 1.4 of the agreement even though the work was done and therefore, the arbitrator has said that the DDA shall pay a sum of Rs. 23,461/-. I am unable agree that with the learned counsel for the DDA that there is any error apparent on the face of the record. Accordingly, this part of the award is confirmed.

    10. On Claim No. 3

    The Arbitrator had awarded Rs. 6,703/- as against the claim of Rs. 85,000/- on the ground that certain amount was illegally held by the DDA. In the objection petition the DDA has taken a point that the Arbitrator has not given any reasons. In reply thereto the contractor states:

    “Against the said Claim No. 3, a sum of Rs. 6703/- was awarded the Respondent withhold only a sum of Rs. 6703/- and released the remaining withheld amount during the arbitration proceedings, that is out of Rs. 70,000/- illegally withheld by the Respondent it had released only a sum of Rs. 63,297/-. It was substantiated and justified and even evident that Rs. 6703/- was admittedly still remained withehdl by the Respondents without any reasons and justifications and in fact none exist. Moreover no reasons was furnished by the Respondent as to hwy and what purpose it had withheld the said sum of Rs. 6703/-

    Hence, after considering the submissions of the parties the learned Arbitrator has rightly awarded the balance withheld sum of Rs. 6703/- in favour of the Petitioner, the award contains the sufficient reasons.

    The above findings of fact based on evidence are not amenable to review under Section 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.”

    Here also I do not find any error in the award passed by the Arbitrator.

    11. On Claim Nos 4 to 8:

    These claims have been rejected by the Arbitrator and it is confirmed.

    12. On Claim No. 9

    The Contractor has claimed a sum of Rs. 1500/- on account of cartage of C.I Pipes. Though I am inclined to say it is not worth considering but because Mr. Sharma pressed his objection, I am adverting to the same. The learned Counsel for the DDA states that in the objection petition it is stated that Rs. 1500/- has been awarded on the basis of Annexure V filed by the defendant but according to the objection annexure V filed only a sum of Rs. 472/- being due.

    In reply the Contractor has stated that at the time of hearing before the Arbitrator the DDA had admitted a sum of Rs. 472/- is due but it was substantiated before the Arbitrator that a sum of Rs. 1500/- liable to be awarded in terms of the principle set out by the Respondents in Annexure V. According to the Contractor after considering the submissions made by the parties, the arbitrator awarded a sum of Rs. 1500/-. the Arbitrator has said:

    “As per rates for cartage of pipe worked out by Respondent(s) (Annexure-V), the claim of the Claimant(s) justified for Rs. 1500/- (Rs. One Thousand Five Hundred) only, which Respondent(s) do pay to the claimant(s).”

    I do not find any error apparent on the face of the record. I confirm the award on this claim.

    13. On Claims 10 to 16:

    Claims 10 to 16 were rejected by the Arbitrator.

    14. Claim No. 17

    As against Claim of Rs. 5744/- a sum of Rs. 1258.70 has been awarded by the Arbitrator. The Arbitrator has stated:

    “The Respondent(s) have proposed a penal rate recovery of Rs. 1,258.70 in the final bill for excess issue of cement and S.C.I pipes to claimant(s). The Respondent(s) have not produced any evidence of such material available at site which means the material even though found in excess as per theoretical consumption statement, but, have been used for bonafide use of work. Moreover, no loss sustained have been established by the Respondent(s) on this account. The claim of the claimant(s) is, therefore, justified and the Respondent(s) do pay Rs. 1258.70 to the Claimant(s).”

    I do not find any error apparent on the face of the record and no valid material has been produced by the DDA for taking a different view in the matter.

    14. On Claim No. 18

    A sum of Rs. 6406/- has been claimed on account of illegal recovery made for so called work done at risk and cost.

    The DDA in the objection petition alleges that no reasons have been given by the Arbitrator and therefore, it is vitiated. In reply to this the Contractor has submitted that the Arbitrator had given full opportunity to the parties to make their submissions and on the material placed by the parties on record, the Arbitrator has come to the conclusion the Arbitrator has stated:

    “The Respondent(s) have recorded completion certificate subject to certain work to be done. The provision of A.C sheet on expansion Joint does not appear in the said list. Also, as per final bill, the item appears to be executed paid for. The claim of the Claimant(s) is justified and I decide that the Respondent(s) do pay Rs. 6406/- (Rupees Six thousand four hundred, six) only to the Claimant(s).”

    I do not find any merit in the objection taken by the DDA on this. Therefore, the Award on this claim is confirmed.

    15. On Claim No. 19

    This claim relates to the rate of interest. The Contractor had claimed interest @ 24% per annum on all under three heads:

    a) Pre-reference interest.

    b) Pendentelite interest.

    c) Future interest.

    The Arbitrator had awarded pendentelite interest @ 12% per annum from 3.6.1993 to 30.5.1994 only.

    As I had noticed above, the Arbitrator has exercised his discretion reasonably and 1 do not find any reason to interfere with the award on this claim. Accordingly, the award is made rule of the court.

    The amount payable by the DDA to the Petitioner/Contractor is as follows:

    1. Claim 1 Rs. 1,23,487.30

    2. Claim 2(i) Rs. 12,808.50

    3. Claim 2 (iii) Rs. 6,660.50

    4. Claim 2 (xi) Rs. 23,461.00

    5. Claim 3 Rs. 6,703.00

    6. Claim 9 Rs. 1,500.00

    7. Claim 17 Rs. 1,258.70

    8. Claim 18 Rs. 6,406.00

    Total Rs. 1,82,285.00

    There shall be a decree directing the D.D.A to pay to the Petitioner/Contractor the following amounts:

    a) A sum of Rs. 1,82,285.00;

    b) Interest of Rs. 15147.50 (on a sum of 1,82,285.00 @ 12% per annum from 3.6.1993 to 30.5.1994)

    c) to pay interest @ 12% per annum from 20.9.1994 upto the date of realisation.

    There shall no no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Atree Associates v. Delhi Development Authority
    (May 22, 1996)