Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a company manufacturing and selling Kayaks and Canoes, submitted an offer in response to a quotation invitation by the Department of Tourism, Government of Uttar Pradesh. The petitioner’s offer included specific terms regarding prices, advance payment, delivery schedule, and freight charges. The respondent issued a counter offer with differing terms, including inspection requirements and delivery deadlines. The petitioner supplied some goods and raised bills, but the respondent cancelled some requirements and maintained their terms. A dispute arose over payment of Rs. 2,43,887.70 along with interest, which the petitioner claimed was wrongfully withheld by the respondent. The petitioner sought to have the suit tried under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) as a suit for a liquidated demand arising from a written contract. The learned Additional District Judge declined this prayer and directed the suit to be registered as an ordinary suit. The petitioner filed this civil revision petition challenging that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the correspondence between the parties constituted a written contract sufficient to maintain a suit under Order XXXVII CPC for a liquidated demand.
  2. Whether a suit for price of goods under Section 55 of the Sale of Goods Act can be treated as a suit for a liquidated demand arising on an enactment under Order XXXVII(ii) CPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The correspondence exchanged between the parties amounted to a written concluded contract.
  • The suit was based on a liquidated demand arising under the written contract and hence maintainable under Order XXXVII CPC.
  • Alternatively, the suit was based on a debt or liquidated demand arising under Section 55 of the Sale of Goods Act, which also permits trial under Order XXXVII CPC.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The petitioner’s offer and respondent’s counter offer did not result in a concluded agreement as there was no consensus on significant terms like delivery, advance payment, and freight.
  • Though the petitioner supplied some goods, the contract was not finalized and therefore the suit could not be treated as arising from a written contract.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M/S. Panjab Pen House v. M/S. Samrat Bicycle Ltd. (AIR 1992 Delhi 1) Suit under Order XXXVII CPC maintainable based on an invoice embodying all terms and conditions of contract. Distinguished on facts; in the instant case the invoice did not contain all terms and conditions and no concluded contract was found.
West Bengal Decorating Co. v. Damodar Das Daga (AIR 1982 Calcutta 386) Cause of action arises under an enactment only if the right to recover depends on the enactment itself. Applied to reject the contention that claim under Section 55 of the Sale of Goods Act arises "on an enactment" for the purpose of Order XXXVII(ii) CPC.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the correspondence exchanged between the parties and concluded that there was no consensus of mind on essential terms such as delivery, advance payment, and freight charges. The presence of an offer and counter offer with differing terms meant no concluded written contract existed. The petitioner’s reliance on the precedent of Panjab Pen House was rejected since that case involved an invoice containing all terms, unlike the present facts. The court also examined the petitioner’s alternative argument that the suit was maintainable under Order XXXVII(ii) CPC as a debt or liquidated demand arising under Section 55 of the Sale of Goods Act. The court held this contention to be misconceived because the claim for price under Section 55 arises from the terms of a contract, not directly from the enactment itself. The court relied on the West Bengal Decorating Co. case to emphasize that a cause of action arises under an enactment only if the right to recover depends on the enactment, which was not the case here. Therefore, the trial court’s direction to try the suit as an ordinary suit was found to be free of any jurisdictional error or irregularity.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is that the suit filed by the petitioner must be tried as an ordinary suit and not under Order XXXVII CPC for summary trial of liquidated demands. No new precedent was established by this ruling; it reaffirms that a suit under Order XXXVII requires a concluded written contract or a liquidated demand arising directly from an enactment, neither of which was present here.

    Simba F.R.P (P) Ltd v. Department Of Tourism, Lucknow, U.P.

    Manmohan Sarin, J.— The petitioner by this civil revision petition is assailing the order dated 27.1.1994, by which the learned Additional District Judge directed the suit to be registered as an ordinary suit and declined the prayer of the petitioner for trial of the suit under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure. The revision petition had been admitted to hearing on 20.3.1995 The facts in brief are as under:

    (i) The petitioner is a company engaged in the business of manufacturing and selling of Kayaks and Canoes. The respondent i.e the Department of Tourism, Government of Uttar Pradesh, had invited quotations for the supply of Kayaks and Canoes vide its notification dated 31.12.1990 The petitioner submitted its offer vide letter dated 3.1.1991 The petitioner quoted the prices and stated the terms and conditions in the offer. Some of the terms and conditions that may be noticed are:—

    All prices are Ex-works, Sikandrabad (U.P).

    Prices prevailing at the time of receipt of written order would be charged.

    Advance of 40% of the order value alongwith the firm, clear and acceptable order was required to be paid.

    Balance 60% payment to be made within 15 days of delivery.

    Delivery to commence within 15 days of the receipt of firm, clear and acceptable order accompanied with advance.

    Packing, freight and Insurance to be on the purchaser's account.

    (ii) The respondent in response to the petitioner's offer of 3.1.1991 vide its letter of 21.1.1991 set out its terms and conditions for supply. It prescribed inspection by the Indian Canoeing Association and furnishing of test certificate before despatch. Payment was to be subject to the test certificate being furnished. Prices F.O.R Ballia with no freight being payable upto Ballia. Delivery to be completed by 24.1.1991

    (iii) The petitioner on 22.1.1991 wrote to the respondent for withdrawal of the conditions with regard to delivery and reiterated the condition of its offer that the petitioner would commence delivery within 15 days of the receipt of firm, clear and acceptable order.

    (iv) The petitioner in the meanwhile supplied 10 kakays to meet the urgent requirements and raised its bill bearing No. SKD/0233/91 dated 22.1.1991 for Rs. 53,054/-. The respondent vide letter dated 28.1.1991 cancelled the requirement for some of the items which had earlier been intimated as being required vide its letter of 21.1.1991 The respondent further reiterated that the terms and conditions specified earlier in the order would be applicable.

    (v) The petitioner claims to have supplied the remaining balance of Kayaks and Canoes that had been ordered aprat from the Kayaks and Paddles, the requirement for which had been deleted in the respondent's letter of 28.1.1991 The petitioner raised his bill bearing No. SKD/0276/90-91 dated 23.3.1991

    2. It is the petitioner's case that the defendant has wrongfully and illegally failed and neglected to pay the sum of Rs. 2,43,887.70 being the price of the goods sold. The petitioner further claimed a sum of Rs. 1,39,765.00 being the interest claiming at the rate of 21% per annum, in all amounting to Rs. 3,83,652.70.

    3. The petitioner on the basis of the above correspondence claimed that the correspondence with the petitioner constituted the written contract and the suit seeking to a liquidated demand/debt arising under a written contracts as above was liable to be tried under Order XXXVII C.P.C

    4. Counsel for the petitioner during the hearing, firstly submitted that the correspondence in the instant case amounted a written concluded contract and the suit being based on it was, therefore, for a liquidated demand in money payablee by the respondent arising arising out of the written contract. Counsel for the petitioner submitted in the alternative that the suit was for the sum of a debt or liquidated demand based on an enactment, viz.; Section 55 of the Sale of Goods Act.

    5. Counsel for the respondent on the other hand asserted that the petitioner had submitted an offer and in response the respondent had given their counter offer which was responded to by the petitioner. However, there was no agreement reached with regard to important and significant terms, such as delivery, advance payment of price, freight and other charges. It could not be said that there was a concluded written contract. Counsel for the respondent, further, admitted that the plaintiff had supplied the Kayaks and Kanoes that had been received by the defendant.

    6. From a perusal of the correspondence it cannot be said that the same constitutes a written contract which could be made the basis of a suit under Order XXXVII C.P.C It cannot be said that there was “consensus of mind which led to a contract”. In the instant case, there was an offer, counter offer in which different terms and conditions were specified and agreement had not been reached on all the terms such as feight, advance, delivery, etc.

    Counsel for the petitioner had relied on AIR 1992 Delhi 1 titled M/S. Panjab Pen House…Plaintiff v. M/S. Samrat Bicycle Ltd.…Defendant in support of the contention that written contract could be on the basis of correspondence exchanged. In the case cited a suit under Order XXXVII C.P.C was held to be maintainable based on an invoice since the invoice embodied all the terms and conditions of the contract It was the admitted position between the parties that the supply of the goods had been under the terms and conditions as per the invoice. In the case before us the invoice does not contain the terms and conditions of the contract and it cannot be said that all the terms and conditions of supply had been agreed to between the parties in the correspondence exchanged.

    7. The second contention of the defendant is that the suit falls within the ambit Order XXXVII C.P.C as it claims a price of goods under Section 55 of the Sale of Goods Act and therefore the same falls within the ambit of Order XXXVII(ii) being a debt or liquidated demand arising on an enactment where the sum sought to be recovered is a fixed sum of money or in the nature of a debt other than a penalty.” I am afraid this contention of the counsel of the defendant is misconceived. Section 55 of the Sale of Goods Act provides “where under a contract of sale the property in the goods has passed to the buyer and the buyer wrongfully neglects or refuses to pay for the goods according to the terms of the contract, the seller may sue him for the price of the goods”. It would be evident from reading of the Section that the claim for the price of the goods arises from the terms of the contract of sale. Simply because the Act enables the seller to sue the buyer for price, the claim cannot be said to arise on an enactment. Reference may be made in this connection to AIR 1982 Caluctta 386 titled West Bengal Decorating Co. v. Damodar Das Daga, wherein while dealing with a similar plea the Court observed” a cause of action does not arise under or on an enactment unless it arises out of and depends upon the enactment so that the plaintiff must show both in stating and improving his case that his right to recover stands on the enactment.” This is not the situation in the instant case. No other point is pressed or urged before me.

    8. In view of the foregoing discussions, the order of the trial court directing the trial of the suit in an ordinary manner does not suffer from any infirmity, jurisdictional error or material irregularity. The petition, therefore, fails and is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Simba F.R.P (P) Ltd v. Department Of Tourism, Lucknow, U.P.
    (Jul 1, 1995)