AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 39 of the CPC and Rules 4 to 9 of Order 21
  • Article 182 (5) of the Limitation Act, 1908
  • Order 21 Rule 41 CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 39 of the CPC and Rules 4 to 9 of Order 21
  • Article 182 (5) of the Limitation Act, 1908
  • Order 21 Rule 41 CPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The High Court of Madras, exercising its Ordinary Original Civil Jurisdiction, passed a money decree dated 28th June 1991 based on a compromise. The decree directed three judgment debtors—a Company, its Managing Director, and a Director—to pay the decretal amount in instalments. The decree was not honoured, prompting the decree holder to initiate execution proceedings. The decree was transferred for execution from Madras to the Delhi High Court and subsequently to the Panjab High Court. Several applications were filed by both the decree holder and the judgment debtors during these execution proceedings, which are the subject of this order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether simultaneous execution of a decree before more than one court is permissible or constitutes an abuse of the process of court.
  2. Whether the execution application at Delhi should be dismissed or adjourned sine die due to pending execution proceedings at Chandigarh.
  3. Whether a fresh application for transfer of execution to another court is maintainable without a certificate of non-satisfaction issued under Section 41 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC).
  4. Whether the decree holder is entitled to examine judgment debtors under Order 21 Rule 41 CPC to ascertain their properties.

Arguments of the Parties

Judgment Debtors' Arguments

  • Simultaneous execution of the decree at Chandigarh and Delhi constitutes an abuse of the process of court.
  • The execution application at Delhi should be dismissed or adjourned sine die unless the decree holder withdraws the execution pending at Chandigarh.
  • Relying on Section 41 CPC, they argued that a fresh execution application seeking transfer to another court is not maintainable unless a certificate of non-satisfaction has been issued by the transferee court.
  • Heavy reliance was placed on precedents under Article 182(5) of the Limitation Act, 1908, to support their contention regarding limitation and procedural propriety.
  • Opposed the decree holder's application under Order 21 Rule 41 CPC, contending that the court cannot direct a roving enquiry without jurisdictional facts being disclosed.

Decree Holder's Arguments

  • Asserted the permissibility of simultaneous execution proceedings before more than one court.
  • Contended that the Delhi High Court has jurisdiction to execute the decree, as the decree was transferred to it and the judgment debtors reside or carry on business within its jurisdiction.
  • Maintained that the application under Order 21 Rule 41 CPC is to obtain discovery for execution purposes and not for a roving enquiry.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rulia Ram & Anr. v. Diwan Chand & Ors., AIR 1934 Lahore 728 Procedural propriety regarding execution transfer and limitation under Article 182(5) of the Limitation Act, 1908 Distinguished as not applicable to the facts of the present case concerning simultaneous execution.
Jatendrakumar Das v. Mahendrachandra Banikya, AIR 1933 Calcutta 906 Similar procedural issues under Limitation Act and execution transfer Distinguished for same reasons as above.
Jaunendra Nath Ghosh v. Kumar Jogendra Narain Sinha, AIR 1923 Patna 384 Procedural limitations on execution transfer Not directly applicable to the current matter.
Prem Lata Agarawal v. Lakshman Prasad Gupta & Ors., AIR 1970 SC 1525 Permissibility of simultaneous execution proceedings in more than one place with safeguards Followed as authoritative Supreme Court precedent permitting simultaneous execution with protections against hardship.
Radheshyam & Ors. v. Devendra, AIR 1952 Patna 213 Simultaneous execution and jurisdiction of courts in execution matters Adopted to support the permissibility of simultaneous execution and jurisdiction despite absence of certificate under Section 41 CPC.
S. Sundara Rao v. Appiah Naidu & Anr, AIR 1954 Mysore 154 Simultaneous execution Supported the permissibility of concurrent execution proceedings.
Bhagwandas v. Gomtibai, AIR 1962 All 619 Overruling earlier contrary view on simultaneous execution Followed to confirm the law allowing simultaneous execution.
Gyanchand v. Banwarilal (1964 MPLJ.SN 180) Simultaneous execution proceedings Referenced in support of permissibility.
Athivarapu Venkatarami Reddi v. Kotamreddi Rami Reddi, AIR 1950 Mad 582 Simultaneous execution Referenced in support of permissibility.
Saroda Prosaud Mullick v. Luchmeeput Singh (14 MIA 529) Execution by multiple courts simultaneously Held that no irregularity arises from simultaneous transmission to multiple courts; followed.
Manganese Ore (India) Ltd., Nagpur v. M/S. Mangilal Rungta, Calcutta, AIR 1981 Delhi 114 Scope of Order 21 Rule 41 CPC and requirement of jurisdictional facts Applied to reject claim of roving enquiry and uphold decree holder's application for discovery of judgment debtors' properties.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the objection to simultaneous execution proceedings on the basis of statutory provisions and judicial precedents. It noted that Section 38 CPC permits execution by the court that passed the decree or by the court to which it is sent for execution, indicating a permissive framework. Section 39 CPC and Rules 4 to 9 of Order 21 CPC provide for transfer and execution by transferee courts but do not expressly prohibit simultaneous execution in more than one court.

The court emphasized that simultaneous execution is not illegal or without jurisdiction, though discretion lies with the transferring court to prevent abuse or hardship. The Supreme Court's decision in Prem Lata Agarawal was cited approvingly, underscoring that simultaneous execution is permissible but should be exercised sparingly with safeguards against oppression of judgment debtors.

The court rejected the judgment debtors' reliance on cases under Article 182(5) of the Limitation Act, 1908, distinguishing those facts from the present matter. It also followed the majority view of various High Courts permitting simultaneous execution.

Regarding jurisdiction, the court held that absence of a certificate under Section 41 CPC from the transferee court does not deprive the original court of jurisdiction to entertain a fresh transfer application. The court further found no evidence of any payment or hardship suffered by the judgment debtors and concluded the objections were attempts to delay execution.

On the decree holder’s application under Order 21 Rule 41 CPC for examination of judgment debtors about their properties, the court found jurisdictional facts adequately averred. It rejected the contention that the application was a roving enquiry and allowed the application, requiring judgment debtors to appear for examination.

Holding and Implications

The court’s final decision was as follows:

The objections filed by the judgment debtors against simultaneous execution proceedings were rejected.

The application by the decree holder under Order 21 Rule 41 CPC to examine judgment debtors was allowed.

As a safeguard, the court directed that the decree holder must ensure that the total attachments at Panjab and Delhi courts do not exceed the decretal amount payable. The decision directly affects the parties by permitting concurrent execution proceedings and discovery of judgment debtor assets but does not establish any new precedent beyond affirming existing principles.

    Cholamandalam Investment & Finance Co. Ltd.Decree Holder v. Cec Ltd. & Ors.Judgment Debtor.

    R.C Lahoti, J.— This order disposes of several applications filed by the decree holder and judgment debtors during execution proceedings.

    2. The High Court of Madras in exercise of its Ordinary Original Civil Jurisdiction passed a money decree dated 28th June, 1991 based on a compromise. The three judgment debtors who are respectively a Company, its Managing Director and Director were directed to pay the decretal amount in instalments. The decree having not been honoured, the decree holder took out execution. By transfer certificate dated 24.2.92, the decree accompanied by a certificate of non-satisfaction at Madras has been transferred for execution to Delhi High Court (Original Side). Yet again the decree accompanied by transfer certificate and certificate of non-satisfaction at Madras has been transferred to Panjab High Court for execution on its Original Side.

    3. EA 282/94 and 283/94 have been filed by the Company (Judgment Debtor No. 1) raising objections to the maintainability of the execution at Delhi. The principal objection raised is that simultaneous execution of decree at Chandigarh and Delhi is an abuse of the process of Court and therefore the execution application at Delhi deserves to be dismissed or adjourned sine die unless and until the decree holder may withdraw the execution pending at Chandigarh. It is also submitted by reference to section 41 of the cpc that so long as a certificate of non-satisfaction has not been issued and sent by one transfaree court to the original executing court, a fresh application for execution seeking its transfer to another court would not lie. Heavy reliance is placed by the learned counsel for the judgment debtor on Rulia Ram & Anr. v. Diwan Chand & Ors., AIR 1934 Lahore 728; Jatendrakumar Das v. Mahendrachandra Banikya, AIR 1933 Calcutta 906 and Jaunendra Nath Ghosh v. Kumar Jogendra Narain Sinha, AIR 1923 Patna 384.

    4. I see no merit in the objection raised. No provision of Civil Procedure Code has been brought to my notice which may expressly prohibit simultaneous execution of decree before two Courts. Section 38 provides for execution of a decree either by the Court which passed it or by the Court to which it is sent for execution. The provision is permissive in nature. Section 39 of the CPC and Rules 4 to 9 of Order 21 contemplate transfer of a decree for execution to another court and the execution by transferee court.

    5. The law does not prevent simultaneous execution of decree in more courts than one, although the Court transferring the decree may in its discretion refuse such transfers as would avail the decree holder concurrent executions before more courts than one. The judgment debtor should not be put to hardship nor to opperssion. The fact remains that simultaneous transfer of decree for execution to two courts and simultaneous execution proceedings are neither illegal nor without jurisdiction.

    6. I am fortified in taking the above view by the decision of the Supreme Court in Prem Lata Agarawal v. Lakshman Prasad Gupta & Ors., (AIR 1970 SC 1525):—

    “Simultaneous execution proceeding in more places than one is possible but the power is used sparingly in exceptional cases by imposing proper terms so that hardship does not occur to judgment-debtors by allowing several attachments to be proceeded with at the same time.”

    7. Simultaneous execution is permissible, is the view taken by Full Bench of Patna High Court in Radheshyam & Ors. v. Devendra, AIR 1952 Patna 213, Full Bench of Mysore High Court in S. Sundara Rao v. Appiah Naidu & Anr. AIR 1954 Mysore 154, Division Bench of Allahabad High Court in Bhagwandas v. Gomtibai, AIR 1962 All 619 (overruling its earlier view to the Contrary), Madhya Pradesh High Court in Gyanchand v. Banwarilal (1964 MPLJ.SN 180), Madras High Court in Athivarapu Venkatarami Reddi v. Kotamreddi Rami Reddi (AIR 1950 Mad 582). In the earliest and leading authority of Saroda Prosaud Mullick v. Luchmeeput Singh (14 MIA 529) it was held that there was no irregularilty in a Zillah Judge transmitting the record to three Zillah Courts at the same time for execution.

    8. All the decisions relied on by the learned counsel for the Judgment debtors are under Article 182 (5) of the Limitation Act, 1908 holding in the facts of each case that any application made by the decree holder to the transferring court after the decree has been transferred to another court for execution does not amount to step in aid of execution so as to save limitation. Those cases do not interms apply to the case at hand. In any case, I am bound to follow the law laid down by the Supreme Court. I would also prefer to adopt the view taken by the majority of High Courts referred to in para 7 above.

    9. The Full Bench of Patna High Court in Radheshyam's case (supra) has clearly held that the Court passing the decree has the jurisdiction to execute the decree In certain circumstances inspite of absence of any certificate under Section 41 from the transferee court. It is clear that merely because the Madras Court had not received certificate under Section 41 CPC from Delhi Court it was not deprived of jurisdiction to entertain a fresh prayer for transfer of decree for execution to another court.

    10. I have asked the learned counsel for the Judgment debtors, if the judgment debtors have paid a single penny in satisfaction of decree eversince 28.6.1991, the date of the decree? The answer has been in the negative. Nothing has been pleaded much less suggested to hold if at all and how the judgment debtors are suffering hardship or oppotression by such simultaneous execution. The objections preferred by the JDs are wholly devoid of any merit. It is merely an affort at delaying the execution proceedings by unwilling judgment debtors. The objections are rejected, however, with a view to safeguard the interest of the JDs, it is directed that the decree holder shall not secure such attachment the total whereof taken together at Panjab and Delhi may exceed the amount payable under the decree.

    11. EA 199/94 is an application under Order 21 Rule 41 CPC filed by the decree holder seeking examination of the judgment debtor Nos. 2 and 3 as to their properties. The application is opposed by the judgment debtors submitting that this Court cannot direct a roving enquiry to be made unless the decree holder had disclosed facts conferring this Court with jurisdiction to execute the decree. This Court has jurisdiction to execute the decree, the same having been transferred to it and the JDs actually and voluntarily residing or carrying on business or personally working for gain within the jurisdiction of this Court within the meaning of section 39 (1) (a) of the cpc. This is alleged in the execution application. The company-Judgment debtor No. 1 has its principal office in Delhi is not denied.

    12. Manganese Ore (India) Ltd., Nagpur… v. M/S. Mangilal Rungta, Calcutta…., AIR 1981 Delhi 114, relied on by learned counsel for judgment debtor does not help him. This Court has held that jurisdictional facts have to be averred by decree holder and cannot be left to be determined by indulging into a roving enquiry resorting to Order 21 Rule 41 CPC. The object of Order 21 Rule 41 CPC is to obtain discovery for the purpose of execution in cases where there is any difficulty or delay in obtaining particulars of the judgment debtros' property. This is what the decree holder has done in the present case. The jurisdictional facts are all averred in execution application. By application under Order 21 Rule 41 CPC, the decree Holder is seeking ascertainment of judgment debtor's property. The prayer of decree holder cannot be rejected by branding it one seeking a roving enquiry. The application is allowed. The judgment debtors No. 2 and 3 shall be bound to appear before the Court for recording their statements.

    13. The upshort of the above discussion is EA No. 282-283/94 filed by the JDs are rejected. EA No. 199/94 filed by the decree holder is allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Cholamandalam Investment & Finance Co. Ltd.Decree Holder v. Cec Ltd. & Ors.Judgment Debtor.
    (Mar 20, 1995)