Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 33, 30, 16 and 15 of the Arbitration Act, 1940
  • Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 33, 30, 16 and 15 of the Arbitration Act, 1940
  • Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

After the arbitrators issued awards, notice of filing was served on the parties on 18th November 1987. The State of Rajasthan, respondent herein, filed objections under Sections 33, 30, 16 and 15 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 seeking to set aside or remit the majority award dated 12th September 1987 passed by Shri Chela Ram Chopra and Dr. C.P. Gupta, as well as the minority award dated 3rd October 1987 passed by Shri S.K. Gupta. The petitioner, M/s. Larsen & Toubro, contested these objections. Several issues were framed on 3rd May 1989, including jurisdiction, validity of awards, misconduct by arbitrators, necessity and consent for extension of time, and validity of a non-speaking award. Oral evidence was recorded, and the court decided the preliminary issue of jurisdiction in favor of the petitioner on 19th February 1991. Subsequent procedural steps included amendment of objections, filing of affidavits by both parties, and an application under Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure to file certain letters. The court took these letters on record after noting one was untraceable.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether this court has jurisdiction to entertain the suit?
  2. Whether the two awards given by the arbitrators are valid or liable to be set aside?
  3. Whether the arbitrators have misconducted themselves and the proceedings?
  4. Whether extension of time was necessary in the facts and circumstances of the case?
  5. Whether the parties gave their consent to the extension of time, considering the court had not been moved for extension?
  6. Whether the non-speaking award given in the instant case is valid?
  7. Whether the time taken by the arbitrators in giving the award has vitiated the award?
  8. Relief.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments

  • Argued that after conclusion of arguments on 27th February 1986, no joint deliberation took place among the three arbitrators.
  • Contended that the majority award dated 12th September 1987 and the minority award dated 3rd October 1987 were given without joint deliberation, constituting misconduct and invalidity.
  • Relied on the affidavit of arbitrator Shri S.K Gupta stating no joint deliberations occurred after the last hearing.
  • Submitted letters annexed with IA 8388/93 supported the absence of joint deliberation.
  • Contended that the awards were beyond the stipulated period and thus liable to be set aside.
  • Argued that the majority award illegally granted interest during the pendency of arbitration due to belated issuance.

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Submitted that all three arbitrators conducted proceedings together up to the last hearing and discussions were held on case facts.
  • Argued there is no legal requirement for arbitrators to meet after conclusion of proceedings to discuss the matter.
  • Stated the whereabouts of arbitrator Shri S.K Gupta were unknown from February 1986 to July 1987, causing delay.
  • Noted the respondent did not produce the letter dated 27th August 1987 referred to by Shri S.K Gupta, which could have shown avoidance of joint deliberation.
  • Contended the delay was due to non-availability of the arbitrator appointed by the respondent themselves.
  • Relied on Supreme Court precedent that arbitrators need not meet post-hearing to finalize awards.
  • Argued that the parties consented to extension of time until conclusion of proceedings, and that the proceedings conclude only upon making the award.
  • Filed an application for enlargement of time as a precautionary measure.
  • Supported the arbitrators' power to award interest pendente lite based on Supreme Court authority.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Manganlal Gangaram Tahor v. Ramaji Bondarji, AIR 1966 MP 177 Importance of joint deliberation among arbitrators Distinguished as the facts here showed delay was due to non-availability of one arbitrator and absence of joint deliberation was not proved.
Bhogilal Purshottam v. Chimanlal Amritlal, AIR 1928 BOM 49 Delay in making awards vitiates validity Held not applicable as delay was satisfactorily explained due to non-availability of arbitrator.
Reserve Bank of India v. S.S Investments, 1992 4 SCC 671 Arbitrators need not meet after conclusion of hearings to discuss the matter Followed to reject respondent’s contention that absence of joint deliberation invalidated awards.
Hari Krishna Wattal v. Vaikunth Nath Pandya, 1973 2 SCC 510 Parties can consent to extend time for making award after entering reference Applied to hold parties’ consent to extend time till conclusion of proceedings was valid.
Nagar Palika v. Mirzapur Electric Supply Co. Ltd, AIR 1990 SC 2273 Extension of time for making award by consent of parties Reinforced the principle that extension by consent is valid without court approval.
Secretary, Irrigation Department, Government of Orissa v. R.C Rai, 1992 1 SCC 508 Power of arbitrator to award interest pendente lite where agreement does not prohibit it Relied upon to uphold awarding of interest by arbitrators despite delay in award.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the affidavits and documentary evidence regarding the alleged absence of joint deliberation among the arbitrators. It found the affidavit of arbitrator Shri S.K Gupta unreliable due to lack of annexed letters and incomplete details. The court accepted that the arbitrator appointed by the respondent was unavailable from February 1986 to July 1987, which explained the delay in issuance of awards. The court noted that Supreme Court precedent establishes that arbitrators are not required to meet after hearings to finalize awards. Regarding the extension of time, the court held that the parties’ consent to extend time until conclusion of proceedings is valid, as proceedings conclude only after the award is made. The court also found that the arbitrators had the power to award interest pendente lite, relying on binding Supreme Court authority. Consequently, objections based on delay, lack of joint deliberation, and interest awarded were dismissed. The majority award was made a rule of the court with interest granted at 18% per annum from the date of the award until realization, and parties were directed to bear their own costs.

Holding and Implications

The court dismissed the respondent's objections and upheld the validity of both the majority and minority awards.

The majority award dated 12th September 1987 was made a rule of the court, with interest at 18% per annum granted in favor of the petitioner from the date of the award until realization. The decision confirms that delay caused by non-availability of an arbitrator appointed by a party does not vitiate an award, and that arbitrators need not necessarily engage in joint deliberation post-hearing. The court also affirmed the arbitrators' authority to award interest pendente lite. No new precedent was set; the ruling primarily applied existing law to the facts, resulting in a final decree in favor of the petitioner. Parties were ordered to bear their own costs.

    Larsen & Toubro Ltd. v. State Of Rajasthan .

    Sat Pal, J.:— In this case after the awards were received from the arbitrators, notice of filing of the awards was issued to the parties on I8th November, 1987. On receipt of notice, the State of Rajasthan, respondent herein, filed objections under Sections 33, 30, 16 and 15 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 for setting aside/remitting the majority award date 2th September, 1987 pasted by Shri Chela Ram Chopra and Shri (Dr.) C.P Gupta arbitrators and also the minority award dated 3rd October, 1987 passed by Shri S.K Gupta arbitrator. The averments made in the objections were controverted by M/s. Larsen & Toubro, petitioner herein in their reply dated 12th December, 1988. Thereafter the respondent filed rejoinder on 26th April, 1989. The following issues were framed an 3rd May, 1989:

    (1) Whether this court has jurisdiction to entertain the suit ?

    (2) Whether the two awards given by the arbitrators, are not valid, and liable to be set aside ?

    (3) Whether the arbitrators have misconducted themselves and the proceedings ?

    (4) Whether extension of time was necessary in the facts and circumstances of the case ?

    (5) Whether the parties gave their consent to the extension of inadequate, inasmuch as the court had not been moved for extension of time ?

    (6) Whether the non-speaking award given in the instant case, is valid ?

    (7) Whether the time taken by the arbitrators in giving the award, in the facts and circumstances of the case, has vitiated the award ?.

    (8) Relief.

    2. On the same date the parties were directed to lead oral evidence in the court. Thereafter statement of Shri Jagdish Cband and Sbri Sudarshan Singh (PW 1 and PW 2) was recorded on 1st August, 1989 and 8th September, 1989. Vide order dated 14th December, 1990 it was directed that issue No. I which pertains to the jurisdiction of this court to entertain the suit, be heard as a preliminary issue. Vide order dated 19th February, 1991 the said preliminary issue was decided in favour of the petitioner and it was held that this court has jurisdiction to entertain the present suit.

    3. By order dated 25th September, 1992 passed in IA 3097/92 the application filed on behalf of the petitioner was allowed and the petitioner was permitted to amend its objections filed with regard to pendente lite interest as awarded by the arbitrator. Vide order dated 15th February, 1993, the respondent/objeetor was given liberty to file its evidence by way of affidavits within six weeks and the petitioner was given liberty to file counter affidavit within three weeks thereafter. Pursuant to this order on 29th March, 1993 the respondent/objector filed affidavit of Shri Shyam Lai Mathur, Executive Engineer and Shri S.K Gupta, who was one of the arbitrators appointed by the respondent in terms of the arbitration clause. On 7th August, 1993, the petitioner filed the affidavit of Shri Sudarshan Singh, who was the sales manager of the petitioner at the relevant time.

    4. During the pendency of the case the petitioner served a notice on the respondent asking them to file the copies of the letters referred to by Sbri S.K Gupta in his affidavit. Thereafter the respondent/objeetor filed IA 8388/93 under Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking permission of the court to file copies of the letters mentioned in the affidavit of Shri S.K Gupta are for which the respondent had received a notice from the petitioner to produce the same in the court. In this application it was, however, stated that the respondent had contacted Shri S.K Gupta, the learned arbitrator, and he had informed them that the copy of the letter dated 27th August, 1987 which was referred to by him in his affidavit, was not traceable. This application was not opposed by the learned counsel for the petitioner. Accordingly, by my order dated 6th Jahuary, 1994 1 allowed this application and the copies of the letters annexed with this application were taken on record.

    5. New I proceed to deal with the various issues framed in this case. As stated hereinabove issue No. 1 has already been disposed of vide order dated 19th February, 1992,

    Issue No. 2 & 3

    6. Mr. Purobit, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent/objeetor submitted that in the present case the arguments were concluded on 27th February, 1986 and thereafter joint deliberation did not take place amongst three arbitrtors. He further submitted that after the lapse of more than one and a half years the learned arbitrator, namely, Shri C.R Chopra and Dr. C.P Gupta without holding the deliberation with the third arbitrator Shri S.K, Gupta gave their award on 12th September, 1987 at New Delhi and Shri S.K Gupta, the third arbitrator, gave his award on 3rd October, 1987 at Bikaner. The learned counsel, therefore, contended that the arbitrators have misconducted themselves and the proceedings and the awards given by the learned arbitrators were not valid and were liable to be set aside. In this connection he drew my attention to the affidavit of Shri S.K Gupta, who was one of tbe arbitrators, and submitted that in this affidavit it has clearly been stated that the last hearing in this case was held on 27th February, 1986 and thereafter no joint deliberations amongst the three arbitrators ever took place. He also draw my attention to tbe copies of the letters annexed with IA 8388/93 and submitted that these letters also showed that there had been no joint deliberations and application of mind by the learned arbitrators. He, therefore, contended that the absence of joint deliberation has the effect of rendering the awards invalid. In support of his contention the learned counsel has placed reliance on a judgment of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in Manganlal Gangaram Tahor v. Ramaji Bondarji . AIR 1966 MP 177., and a judgment of Bombay High Court in Bhogilal Purshottam v. Chimanlal Amritlal . AIR 1928 BOM 49..

    7. Mr. Watel, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner submitted that upto the last date of hearing all the three arbitrators had been conducting the proceedings together and during the course of proceedings all kinds of discussion used to take place on the facts of the case. He further submitteed that there was no requirement of law that after the conclusion of the proceedings all the arbitrators must meet to discuss the matter. Learned counsel also drew my attention to the affidavit of Shri Sudarshan Singh filed on behalf of the petitioner wherein he has stated that from February 1986 to July 1987, whereabouts of one of the arbitrator, namely, Shri S.K Gupta were not known due to change of place of posting/leave or absence from duty and this fact had not been controverted by the respondent/objeetor. He also submitted that the respondent/objcctor had not produced the letter dated 27th August, 1987 referred to by Shri S.K Gupta in his affidavit and this letter could have shown that the said arbitrator was avoiding to have a joint deliberation with the other two arbitrators though admittedly the other two arbitrators had been writing to him to ascertain his availability in New Delhi for joint deliberation. The learned counsel submitted that the delay in making the award was also due to the non-availability of Shri S.K Gupta who was appointed as an arbitrator by the respondent/objeetor themselves. In support of his contention the learned counsel placed reliance on a recent judgment of the Supreme Court in Reserve Bank of India v. S.S Investments . 1992 4 SCC 671

    8. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties and have perused the record. In the present case, in terms of the arbitration clause, the petitioner had appointed Shri Chela Ram Chopra as its arbitrator while the respondent/objeetor appointed Shri S.K Gupta, the then Additional Chief Engineer as their arbitrator and the Institution of Engineers of India appointed Dr. C.P Gupta, who was a professor Civil Engineering, University of Roorkee as their arbitrator. Shri S.K Gupta one of the arbitrators has filed his affidavit as respondent/objector's evidence. As a matter of principle the arbitrator should not have filed his affidavit in support of the case of one of the parties but if at all he had chosen to file such an affidavit, the arbitrator ought to have annexed the copies of various letters referred to in his affidavit. In para 4 of the affidavit of Shri S.K Gupta it has been stated that, “I once wrote to Dr. C:P. Gupta suggesting him to hold a meeting at Delhi of all the three arbitrators to discuss the case and finalize the award in mid July. 1987.” Shri S.K Gupta has not even mentioned the date of the letter written by him to Dr. C.P Gupta. Again in paras of the affidavit it has been mentioned by Shri S.K Gupta that he received a letter dated 22nd August, 1987 asking him to intimate as to when he would be in Delhi so that a meeting of the arbitrators could be held at Delhi to finalize and this letter was duly replied by him on 27th August, 1987. But it has not been mentioned in the affidavit as to whether by letter dated 27th August, 1987 Shri S.K Gupta had suggested any date when he would be in Delhi, nor a copy of this letter was annexed with the affidavit. Even in IA 8388/93 it has been admitted by the respondent/objeetor that a notice was received from the learned counsel for the petitioner to produce various letters referred to by Shri S.K Gupta in his affidavit and in this application it has been stated that the copy of the letter dated 27th August, 1987 was not traceable with Shri S.K Gupta. Further in his affidavit Shri S.K Gupta had admitted the receipt of the copy of the letter dated 11th July, 1987 addressed by Dr. C.P Gupta to Shri C.R Chopra and copy endorsed to him but it is not mentioned as to whether he had sent any reply to Dr. C.P Gupta as to whether be would be available in Delhi during the period 10th August, to 21st August, 1987. It may also be pointed out here that after the copy of the joint award dated 12th September, 1987 passed by Dr. C.P Gupta and Shri C.R Chopra was sent to Shri S.K Gupta, he passed his own separate award on 3rd October, 1987 and in his separate award he awarded in favour of the petitioner a sum of Rs. 3,15,000 against a sum of Rs. 4,95,900 awarded by the other two arbitrators. But he had not mentioned anything that there had been no joint deliberations. In view of these facts I am of the view the affidavit filed by Shri S.K Gupta does not inspire any confidence. Besides it has been held by the Supreme Court in the case of S.S Investment (supra) that it is not imperative that arbitrators should meet upon the conclusion of the hearings to discuss the matter.

    9. As regards the delay in passing the award, Shri Sudarshan Singh in his affidavit has stated that the whereabouts of Shri S.K Gupta, one of the arbitrators were not known during the period February 1986 to July 1987 and this fact has not been controverted by the respondent/objeetor. The letter dated 11th July, 1987 written by Dr. C.P Gupta to Shri C.R Chopra, copy of which was also endorsed to Shri S.K Gupta, also shows that Shri S.K Gupta for tbe first time had suggested that a meeting to finalise the award should be held at Delhi in mid July 1987. The letter dated 22nd August, 1987 written by Shri C.R Chopra to Shri S.K Gupta further shows that Shri C.R Chopra was not even aware of the telephone number of Shri S.K Gupta at Jaipur. Further letter dated 14th July, 1987 written by Shri C.R Chopra to Dr. C.P Gupta, copy of which was also endorsed to Shri S.K Gupta, also shows that it was not possible for Shri C.R Chopra to contact Shri S.K Gupta. As stated hereinabove Shri S.K Gupta in his affidvit has not mentioned anything as to whether he had suggested any date of August 1987 when he could be available in Delhi for joint deliberations. From these facts it is clear that the delay in making the award was also because of the non-availability of Shri S.K Gupta, who was appointed by the respondent/objeetor as their arbitrator. As the delay has been satisfactorily explained, the ratio of the judgment in the case of Bhogilal (supra) is not applicable to the present case.

    10. For the foregoing reasons I do not find any merit in the objections raised by the respondent/objeetor and accordingly Issues No. 2 and 3 are decided in favour of the petitioner and against the respondent.

    Issues No. 4 & 5

    11. As regards Issues No. 4 and 5, Mr. Purohit, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent/objeetor, submitted that the parties had given their consent for extension of time “till the conclusion of proceedings”. He further submitted that the proceedings in the present case were concluded on 27th February, 1986 and the majority award was made on 12th September, 1987 and the award by the third arbitrator was made on 3rd October, 1987. He, therefore, contended that the awards have not been made within the stipulated period and as such the awards were liable to be set aside.

    12. Mr. Watel, learned Senior Counsel, appearing on behalf of the petitioner, however, submitted that the proceedings shall conclude only when the award is made. He, therefore, contended that since the parties had extended the time by consent till the conclusion of the proceedings, the petitioner was not required to approach this court for extension of time though by way of caution, the petitioner has filed an application IA No. 5367/89 for enlargement of time in making the award till 3rd October, 1989. In support of his contention the learned counsel placed reliance on two judgments of the Supreme Court Hari Krishna Wattal v. Vaikunth Nath Pandya . 1973 2 SCC 510 and Nagar Palika v. Mirzapur Electric Supply Co. Ltd . AIR 1990 SC 2273.

    13. As held by the Supreme Court in the case of Hari Karishna Wattal (supra), the arbitrator is entitled to enlarge the time if after entering upon the reference the parties to the arbitration consent to such enlargement. In the present case admittedly the parties had agreed for extension of time till the conclusion of the proceedings. Tbe proceedings shall stand concluded only after the award has been made by the learned arbitrators. In view of this I do not find any merit in the objection raised on behalf of the respondent/objeetor on this aspect of tbe matter. Accordingly, Issues No. 4 and 5 are decided in favour of the petitioner and against the respondent.

    Issue No. 6

    14. The learned counsel for the respondent/opjector did not press this issue. Accordingly, Issue No. 6 is decided in favour of the petitioner and against the respondent.

    Issue No. 7

    15. In view of my findings given on Issues No. 2 and 3. I hold that the time taken by the arbitrators in giving the award has not vitiated the award.

    16. Lastly, Mr. Purohit, the [earned counsel for the respondent/objector submitted that the learned arbitrators who rendered majority award have illegally awarded interest on the sum awarded by them during the pendency of the arbitration proceedings. Learned counsel submitted that the arguments before the arbitrators were concluded on 27th February, 1986 and the majority award was rendered on 12th September, 1987 i.e, after more than one and a half years from the date the arguments were heard. He, therefors, contended that no interest could be awarded in such a belated award. Mr. Watel, learned Senior Counsel on the other hand drew my attention to a judgment rendered by a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Secretary, Irrigation Department, Government of Orissa v. R.C Rai . 1992 1 SCC 508., In this judgment it was held that where the agreement between the parties does not prehibit grant of interest and where a party claims interest and that dispute is referred to the arbitrator, he shall have the power to award interest pendente lite.

    17. Having given my anxious consideration to the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties, I am of the view that the arbitrators had the power to award interest pendente lite in view of the law laid down by the Supreme Court in Secretary, Irregation Department, Government of Orissa (supra).

    18. As regards the delay in making the award. I have already held that the delay was mainly on the ground that the arbitrator appointed by the respondent/objector was not available from February, 1986 to July 1987. In view of this the respondent/objector is not entitled to any relief against awarding of interest on the ground that the majority award is belated one. In view of the above discussion the objections against the award are dismissed and the majority award dated 12th September, 1987 is made a rule of the court. Let a decree be drawn in terms of the award. The award will form part of the decree, I further grant interest at the rate of 18% per annum in favour of the petitioner and against the respondent from the date of award till realisation. The parties are, however, left to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Larsen & Toubro Ltd. v. State Of Rajasthan .
    (Jan 18, 1994)