Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 439(2) read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • provisions of Section 437 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
  • Section 439(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 437(1) or (2) or Section 439(1)
  • SECTION 8 EVIDENCE ACT
  • Section 437(5) and 439(2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 439(2) read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • provisions of Section 437 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
  • Section 439(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 437(1) or (2) or Section 439(1)
  • SECTION 8 EVIDENCE ACT
  • Section 437(5) and 439(2)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion delivered by Mr. Anil Dev Singh, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner moved this petition under Section 439(2) read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure seeking cancellation of bail granted to the respondent by an order of the learned Additional Sessions Judge dated May 12, 1993.

The prosecution's case is that on January 10, 1993 the accused (Mange Ram, Yashvinder Singh and Mohinder Singh) allegedly murdered Ravinder alias Tiger at Village Devali by inflicting injuries with hockey sticks and a "Hathi". The body was found on January 11, 1993 in an open plot at Sangam Vihar.

On January 11, 1993 statements of two persons (Sham Singh and Raj Dhan) were recorded under Section 161 CrPC claiming they saw the deceased in the company of the accused at about 7:00 p.m. The prosecution also relies on a statement of Som Pal recorded on January 11, 1993, in which Mange Ram is alleged to have made an extra-judicial confession. The accused are said to have absconded and were apprehended on January 14, 1993; on January 17, 1993 disclosure statements by two accused led to discovery of blood-stained hockey sticks in Ghaziabad. The alleged motive is a long-standing enmity arising from prolonged litigation.

The learned Additional Sessions Judge had granted bail to the respondent on May 12, 1993, noting among other things a plea regarding an inability to flex a wrist and describing the case as circumstantial. The petitioner seeks cancellation of that bail in the High Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court may cancel bail granted by a Sessions Judge under Section 439(2) CrPC in the circumstances of this case.
  2. Whether the material collected by the investigating agency (including alleged extra-judicial confession, witnesses' statements about the deceased being last seen with the accused, discovery of blood-stained weapons, CFSL report, and alleged intimidation of witnesses) establishes grounds sufficient to cancel bail.
  3. Whether cancellation of bail by the High Court is limited to situations involving a likelihood of the accused fleeing from justice or reasonable apprehension of tampering with witnesses, or whether other considerations (such as gravity of the offence and character of evidence) may justify cancellation.
  4. Whether the learned Additional Sessions Judge erred in exercising his discretion by granting bail at the pre-trial stage given the nature and gravity of the allegations and the material on record.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (Shri Singh)

  • The Additional Sessions Judge erred in granting bail in view of the nature and gravity of the offence and material collected during investigation.
  • The material included: Som Pal's statement alleging an extra‑judicial confession by Mange Ram; Sham Singh and Raj Dhan's statements that the deceased was last seen with the accused on January 10, 1993; disclosure statements leading to discovery of weapons; CFSL report linking blood on the hockey sticks to the deceased (blood group 'A'); and evidence of threats to witnesses.
  • There is reasonable apprehension that witnesses (e.g., Chandan Singh and Som Pal Singh) are being intimidated by the accused and therefore bail ought to be cancelled.
  • The accused misused the liberty granted (contention that misconduct post-release supports cancellation). The accused had motive (long-standing enmity and litigation) and absconded after the incident — conduct relevant under Section 8 of the Evidence Act.
  • The circumstantial case is complete with links: (1) deceased last seen with accused; (2) extra‑judicial confession; (3) disclosure statements to recover weapons; (4) motive; (5) CFSL report; (6) conduct of accused after crime and after release on bail — yielding a near "fool proof" case.

Respondent's Arguments (Shri Lalit, Senior Advocate)

  • The Sessions Judge's grant of bail was a proper exercise of discretion and does not warrant interference by the High Court.
  • The chain of events relied upon by the petitioner does not sufficiently link the accused with the offence; the material does not prove guilt at this stage.
  • Mohinder allegedly could not wield a weapon because of a wrist injury (relying on a jail doctor's report dated April 27, 1993).
  • The alleged extra‑judicial confession is implausible on its facts (the circumstances described make it unlikely and Som Pal's relationship to the parties undermines reliability).
  • The timing gap between the alleged sighting at 7:00 p.m. and post‑mortem estimate of death around 11:00 p.m. weakens the connection between the sighting and the murder; the body was found in a densely populated locality where anyone could have committed the crime.
  • The panchas who witnessed recoveries are not independent (they are related to a relative of the deceased) and recovery occurred three days after the disclosure, raising suspicion of planting.
  • The CFSL report's significance is undermined if recoveries/disclosures are unreliable.
  • Allegations of threats to witnesses are concocted; respondent was not present at the time an alleged threat was made (alibi of attending a marriage in village Kanavni).
  • Cancelling bail interferes with personal liberty and is a harsh remedy; it is permissible only in exceptional cases — typically where accused flee or tamper with evidence — neither of which are made out here.
  • Relied upon Supreme Court authorities (Aslam Babalal Desai; Bhagirath Singh; State (Delhi Administration) v. Sanjay Gandhi) to support limits on cancellation and the need for careful exercise of power.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Aslam Babalal Desai v. State Of Maharashtra, (1992) 4 SCC 272 Enumerated illustrative grounds for cancellation of bail (misuse of liberty, interfering with investigation, tampering with evidence or witnesses, likelihood of fleeing, becoming unavailable, etc.); emphasised cancellation is a harsh order and should not be lightly resorted to. The Court noted these enumerated grounds are illustrative and accepted that strong grounds (not limited to the seven) may permit cancellation; used to frame acceptable bases for cancelling bail in proper cases.
Bhagirath Singh v. State of Gujarat, (1984) 1 SCC 284 Addressed cancellation of bail; the Court observed the scope of interference and the considerations relevant (but the text notes it did not lay down a general rule precluding consideration of other factors). The opinion observed that Bhagirath Singh does not displace earlier principles that gravity of offence and other facts are relevant; used to show no inflexible rule against cancellation beyond specific grounds.
State (Delhi Administration) v. Sanjay Gandhi, (1978) 2 SCC 411 Held that power to take back into custody a person enlarged on bail must be exercised with care and circumspection, but can be exercised in appropriate cases. Relied upon to emphasize that cancellation should be cautious but is permissible where justice demands; used to support exercise of power in a proper case.
State v. Jaspal Singh Gill, (1984) 3 SCC 555 : AIR 1984 S.C. 1503 Courts should consider various matters before granting bail in non-bailable offences: nature and seriousness of offence, character of evidence, peculiar circumstances of accused, likelihood of non‑attendance at trial, reasonable apprehension of tampering, public interest, etc. Applied as key authority for the proposition that the High Court may examine these considerations and cancel bail when appropriate; the Court quoted and relied on these principles.
Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Administration), (1978) 1 SCC 118 : AIR 1978 S.C. 179 At bail stage, the question is whether a prima facie case is made out on statements and materials; whether there is likelihood of tampering with witnesses; the evidence's ultimate trustworthiness is for trial. Used to support the test that the Sessions Judge and the High Court should consider if a prima facie case exists on the materials; the Court adopted this approach in evaluating whether bail should stand.
Shahzad Hasan Khan v. Ishtiaq Hasan Khan, (1987) 2 SCC 684 : AIR 1987 Supreme Court 1613 Cancelled bail granted by High Court considering gravity of offence, nature of evidence and likelihood of tampering with evidence. The Court cited this decision as an example where bail was cancelled on similar considerations and used it to justify cancelling bail in the present case where similar factors were present.
State v. Captain Jagjit Singh, AIR 1962 S.C. 253 Authority where the nature and seriousness of an offence justified interference with bail. Referred to as part of the body of authority supporting that seriousness of the offence is a relevant consideration for cancelling bail.
Shri H. C. Gaur v. Rakesh Vij & Another, 1990 (1) CC Cases 461 Held that considerations other than fears of absconding or tampering (including nature/seriousness of offence) are relevant when deciding cancellation of bail. Relied upon to reject the submission that cancellation should be restricted only to risks of absconding or tampering; used to reinforce a broader set of considerations.
Smt. Rajani Rani Kar v. Goli Pradhan, 1992 (3) Crimes 181 (Orissa High Court) Held that if bail has been granted improperly and arbitrarily, the High Court may cancel it. Cited to support the proposition that the High Court can examine propriety and legality of a Sessions Court order and cancel bail if improperly granted.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the parties' submissions and a number of Supreme Court and High Court authorities concerning the scope of a High Court's power to cancel bail under Section 439(2) CrPC. The central analytical steps in the opinion are:

  1. Legal framework: The Court explained that Section 439 confers concurrent powers on the High Court and Sessions Court to grant bail, that Section 439(2) empowers the High Court to direct arrest and commitment of a person released on bail, and that this power must be exercised with care and circumspection because it affects personal liberty.
  2. Precedent synthesis: The Court surveyed authorities (including Jaspal Singh Gill, Gurcharan Singh, Shahzad Hasan Khan, Aslam Babalal Desai and others) and distilled the guiding principles: there is no inflexible formula; the High Court may cancel bail in a proper and suitable case; considerations include nature and seriousness of the offence, character of evidence, reasonable possibility of accused not being available for trial, reasonable apprehension of tampering with witnesses, public interest, and other facts and circumstances.
  3. Rejection of narrow rule: The Court specifically addressed and rejected the respondent's contention that cancellation of bail by the High Court is limited only to situations involving likelihood of fleeing or tampering with witnesses. The Court held that those are important considerations but not exclusive; other factors (including gravity of offence and strength/nature of the material at the pre‑trial stage) may justify cancellation.
  4. Evaluation of material: The Court briefly reviewed the prosecution material it considered relevant at the pre-trial stage: (a) alleged extra‑judicial confession by Mange Ram to Som Pal; (b) statements by Sham Singh and Raj Dhan that the deceased was last seen in the company of the accused on January 10, 1993; (c) CFSL report indicating blood of group 'A' on discovered hockey sticks (alleged weapons) corresponding to the deceased's blood group; (d) disclosure statements leading to discovery of weapons; and (e) allegations of witness intimidation.
  5. Assessment of Sessions Judge's order: The Court concluded it was premature for the Additional Sessions Judge to have granted bail at that stage because the allegations were serious and a prima facie case appeared to be made out on the materials before the Court. It found that the Sessions Judge failed to sufficiently consider the gravity of the allegations before enlarging the respondent on bail.
  6. Disposition: Balancing the need to protect individual liberty with the public interest and the integrity of the criminal justice process, and having regard to the authorities and the totality of circumstances, the Court found the present case a fit and proper case for cancellation of bail.
  7. Conditional procedural direction: The Court cancelled bail but allowed the respondent an opportunity: the respondent may move a fresh application for bail after statements of material witnesses have been recorded. The cancellation order will not be operative for a period of 15 days.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is allowed and the bail of the respondent is cancelled.

Implications for the parties:

  • The direct effect is that the respondent's bail granted by the learned Additional Sessions Judge (May 12, 1993) is cancelled by the High Court.
  • The cancellation order is deferred for 15 days (i.e., it will not be operative for that period), and the respondent is permitted to move a fresh application for bail after the statements of material witnesses have been recorded by the court concerned.

The opinion does not assert that it establishes any new general precedent; it applies and synthesises existing authorities to the facts of this case and declares that on the totality of circumstances cancellation is appropriate here. The Court emphasised that cancellation is a serious interference with liberty and must be exercised in a proper case.

Petition allowed.

    Chandan Singh v. Yashvinder Chauhan .

    Mr. Anil Dev Singh, J.— By this petition moved under Section 439(2) read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the petitioner seeks cancellation of bail granted to the respondent by the order of the learned Additional Sessions Judge dated May 12, 1993.

    2. The prosecution story is that on January 10, 1993 the accused namely, Mange Ram, Yashvinder Singh and Mohinder Singh committed the murder of Ravinder @ Tiger, resident of Village Devali by inflicting injuries on his parson with hockey sticks and a Hathi.

    3. On January 11, 1993, body of the deceased Ravinder alias Tiger was found in an open plot located in Sangam Vihar. On the same day the statements of two persons, namely, Sham Singh and Raj Dhan, were recorded by the police under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, according to which they allegedly saw the deceased in the company of the accused on January 10, 1993 at about 7.00 p.m Besides the statements of Sham Singh and Raj Dhan, it is claimed that the statement of one Som Pal, was also recorded by the police on January 11, 1993, itself. According to this statement Mange Ram is alleged to have made an extra judicial coafessioa before Som Pal, admitting the commission of the offence by all the three accused persons. The accused are said to have absconded after the incident and on being apprehended on January 14, 1993 Yashvinder and Mohinder made disclosure statements leading to the discovery of blood stained hockey sticks on January 17, 1993 from the fields located in Ghaziabad. The alleged motive for the murder of the deceased is said to be a, long standing enmity between the parties, nurtured by prolonged litigation between them.

    4. On being moved under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure by the respondent, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, granted bail to him. While so doing the learned Additional Sessions Judge took note of the plea of the co-accused that he was unable to flex his wrist because of an injury sustained by him six months back and for this reason it would not be possible for him to wield a hockey stick. He also noted that it was a case of circumstantial evidence.

    5. Shri Singh, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the learned Additional Sessions Judge was not right in releasing the accused on bail in view of the nature and gravity of the offence alleged to have been committed by them, the material collected by the investigating agency and reasonable apprehension of the witnesses being tempered with by the accused. According to him, the material collected during the investigation, including the statement of Sompal regarding the extra judicial confession of the accused Mange Ram and the statements of Sham Singh and Rajdhan regarding the fact that the deceased was last seen alive in the company of the accused, was enough to throw out the bail application of the respondent. While drawing my attention to the CFSL report it is asserted by the learned Counsel that the report unmistakably connects accused with the crime as both the hockey sticks, the alleged weapons of offence, discovered at the instance of the accused persons namely, Mahinder and Yashvinder, were found smeared with human blood of group ‘A’ which corresponded to the blood of the deceased. It is the contention of the learned Counsel that the witnesses namely, Chandan Singh and Som Pal Singh have been threatened by the accused persons and therefore they do not deserve the freedom granted to them by the learned Additional Sessions Judge. Learned Counsel further submits that when the accused has misutilised the liberty granted to him, his bail should be cancelled, Shri Singh asserts that litigation was going on between the parties and the accused had a very strong motive to commit the crime. Learned Counsel also points out that after the incident the accused absconded and could not be apprehended until January 14, 1993. This conduct according to the learned Counsel is relevant under Section 8 of the Evidence Act. Learned Counsel contends that the circumstantial evidence is complete with all the links firmly in position and is incompatible with the innocence of the accused. In nutshell his submission is that the following material would indicate that the case against the accused, is a fool proof one; (!) the deceased was last seen alive in the company of the accused; (2) extra judicial confession of Mange Ram, admitting the murder of Ravinder by all the three accused; (3) disclosure statements made by accused persons leading to the discovery of the weapons of offence: (4) motive; (5) report of the CFSL; (6) conduct of the accused persons after the crime and on their release on bail.

    6. On the other hand Shri Lalit, learned Senior Advocate, appearing for the respondent submits:

    7. That the order of the learned Additional Sessions Judge granting bail to the respondent does not call for any interference as the exercise of discretion was based on sound and proper principles of law; that the chain of events relied upon by the petitioner does not link the accused with the offence and that they do not point to their guilt; that Mohinder accused at the time of the incident was not able to wield the weapon of offence according to the report of the jail doctor dated April 27, 1993 and that the alleged extra judicial confession and the story that the deceased was last seen alive in the company of the accused on January 10, 1993 does not inspire any confidence.

    8. Continuing his arguments Shri Lalit submits that in so far as the matter of alleged extra judicial confession is concerned, the circumstances in which the same is said to have been made by the accused Mange Ram before Som Pal shows that the allegation is a far fetched one. He further submits that Mange Ram is alleged to have told Som Pal that he wanted to sell his jeep because he required money for engaging a Counsel to defend him in connection with the murder of Ravinder, which all the three accused had committed. It is the contention of the learned Counsel that it was unlikely that Mange Ram would have made such a statement as the object was to sell the jeep to secure the maximum price for the same. He also urges that it was not likely that any person, who commits a murder would confess his guilt to a mere acquaintance and that too when the latter happens to work for a close relative of the deceased. As regards the allegation that the deceased was seen alive in the company of the accused is concerned, the learned Counsel points out that the death of Ravinder, according to the post mortem report must have taken place around 11 p.m on January 10, 1993 while the deceased was allegedly seen in the company of the accused at 7.00 p.m in the evening. It is the submission of learned Counsel that the gap between the time of death of Ravinder and the time when Sham Singh and Raj Dhan allegedly saw the deceased in the company of the accused is considerable and this circumstance does not connect the accused with the murder of the deceased. He submits that the locality where the body of the deceased was found is densely populated and anybody could have murdered the deceased. In so far as the disclosure statements leading to the discovery of the weapons of offence are concerned, learned Counsel argues that the witnesses to the same are not independent. Braham Parkash and Ramesh, the two so called independent Panchs are related to Chandan Singh, a close relative of the deceased. In this regard he has drawn my attention to the genelogical table which has been placed on record by the respondent. Learned Counsel submits that while disclosure statements are said to have been made on January 14, 1993 by Yashvinder and Mahinder the recovery of the weapons of offence at the instance of the two accused has been made after three days i.e, on January 17, 1993. Learned Counsel suggests that in the circumstances weapons of offence were planted by some one at the places from where they were allegedly discovered. With regard to the CFSL report, it is asserted that since the disclosure statements and the discovery pursuant thereto do not inspire any confidence, the CFSL report is of no consequence whatsoever. Regarding the threats which have been allegedly extended to the witnesses by the accused persons is concerned learned Counsel says that these allegations have been coined to create prejudice against the respondents and to manufacture grounds for seeking cancellation of their bails. He maintains that on May 6, 1993 at 9 a.m, when Mahinder is alleged to have extended the threat to Chandan Singh, his client was not in Delhi and was attending a marriage ceremony of a close relative at village Kanavni. Finally learned Counsel submits that the rejection of bail stands on one footing while the cancellation of bail stands on another, as the latter interferes with the liberty of an individual and cannot be resorted to except in exceptional cases. He submits that the considerations in both the situations are different. According to the learned Counsel bail once granted can be cancelled only if the accused try to flee from justice or if they tamper with evidence. The learned Counsel urges that both the conditions for cancellation of bail in the present case are absent. In support of his arguments, he has cited decisions of the Supreme Court in Aslam Babalal Desai v. State Of Maharashtra., (1992) 4 SCC 272, Bhagirath Singh v. State of Gujarat, (1984) 1 SCC 284 and State (Delhi Administration) v. Sanjay Gandhi, (1978) 2 SCC 411.

    9. I have considered the respective submission of learned Counsel for the parties.

    10. I will first take up the submission of the learned Counsel for the respondent that bail once granted by the Court of Session can be cancelled by the High Court only on fulfilment of at least one of the two conditions, namely, that there should be a likelihood of the accused fleeing from justice and reasonable apprehension of the accused witnesses being tempered with. Recently I had an occasion to deal with the same proposition in Jayanti Prasad Goel. v. Smt. Sumitra Jain & Ors.) 1300 of 1992 decided on September 10, 1993 where the accused had been granted bail by the Additional Sessions Judge and the complainant moved for its cancellation. This was a case where a young bride, six months pregnant, had died of burn injuries in the matrimonial home and it was alleged that she was the second victim of the gory crime, the first one whose place she came to fill as a bride had also died of burn injuries. This is how the matter was dealt with to find an answer to the aforesaid proposition:—

    “Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure confers concurrent powers on the High Court and the Court of Session for granting bail. The power however, has to be exercised in the light of the provisions of Section 437 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Besides, both the High Court and the Court of Session under Section 439(2) have been conferred with power to direct any person, who has been released on bail, to be arrested and committed to custody. This power to commit a person to custody after being enlarged on bail has to be exercised with care and circumspection as it involves the liberty of a person. But this does not mean that even in appropriate cases the power cannot be exercised. Rather the power must be exercised if the ends of justice demand exercise of the same. In a case where a Court of Session has granted bail, the State can straightaway move the High Court for cancellation of the bail without approaching the Court of Session in this regard. This follows the superior position of the High Court vis-a-vis the Court of Session. The exercise of power by the High Court under Section 439(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, however, will depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case and there cannot be a strait jacket formula in regard to the considerations, which prevail with the High Court for cancellation of bail granted by a Court of Session.

    11. In The State v. Jaspal Singh Gill, (1984) 3 SCC 555 : AIR 1984 S.C 1503, the order of the High Court granting bail was set aside by the Supreme Court having regard to the gravity of the offence with which the accused was charged. While cancelling the bail of the accused granted by the High Court, the Supreme Court observed as follows:—

    “On a consideration of the above three decisions, I am of the view that the Court before granting bail in cases involving non-bailable offences particularly where the trial has not yet commenced should take into consideration various matters such as the nature and seriousness of the offence, the character of the evidence, circumstances which are peculiar to the accused, a reasonable possibility of the presence of the accused not being secured at the trial, reasonable apprehension of witnesses being tampered with, the larger interests of the public of the State and similar other considerations.

    On going through the order passed by the High Court, I feel that its decision that the material collected by the prosecution and the evidence to be adduced at the trial would not be sufficient to sustain a conviction appears to be premature one in the circumstances of this case. Since the trial is yet to begin, I do not propose to say anything more at this stage lest it should prejudice either the accused or the prosecution than observing that on a perusal of the complaint and the other material available in the case, it cannot reasonably be stated that the prosecution case against the respondent is such that it can be thrown out at the threshold. It appears that a prima facie case is made out against the respondent. The gravity of the offences is quite obvious.”

    12. In Shri H. C. Gaur…Petitioner v. Shri Rakesh Vij & Another…S, 1990 (1) CC Cases 461, this Court while dealing with a similar proposition held as follows:—

    “The contention canvassed by Mr. Sood that unless there are such considerations as apprehension about accused not remaining available for trial, or his tampering with evidence or intimidating the witnesses; the Court should not entertain petition for cancellation of bail, particularly when moved by the complainant apparently out of vendetta, than as a matter of genuine grievance, cannot be wholly accepted for it has been held in the case of Gurcharan Singh (supra) that nature and seriousness of the offence is also one of the relevant considerations. There are other cases, namely, (1) State v. Captain Jagjit Singh, AIR 1962 S.C 253, and (2) State v. Jaspal Singh Gill, (1984) 3 SCC 555 : AIR 1984 S.C 1503, where orders of the High Court granting bail to the accused were set aside, considering the gravity of the offence with which the accused therein were charged.

    The decision relied upon by Mr. Sood, Bhagirath Singh Judeja v. State of Gujarat, 1984 Cr.L.J 160 with all respects, does not lay down any general principles as it is manifest that their Lordships of the Supreme Court did not approve the order passed by the High Court in cancelling bail, in view of the observations made in that order taking into consideration status of the victim of the incident, and such extraneous factors as place of incident being inside premises of a hospital and other allied circumstances. This judgment does not take note of the judgment in the case of Gurcharan Singh (supra) to the effect that in suitable cases, the superior Court can examine the propriety of an order of granting bail and interfere accordingly and that the nature and seriousness of the offence, as also other facts and circumstances of the case are relevant factors for consideration, nor that of the earlier decision in the case of Captain Jagjit Singh (supra).”

    13. Again in Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Administration), (1978) 1 SCC 118 : AIR 1978 S. C. 179 the Supreme Court held as follows:—

    “The only question which the Sessions Judge was required to consider at that stage was whether there was prima facie case made out, as alleged, on the statements of the witnesses and on other materials. There appeared at least nothing at that stage against the statement of A.S.I Gopal Das who had made no earlier contradictory statement. “The taint of unreliability” could not be attached to his statement even for the reason given by the learned Sessions Judge. Whether his evidence will ultimately be held to be trustworthy will be an issue at the stage of trial. In considering the question of bail of an accused in a non-bailable offence punishable with death or imprisonment for life, it is necessary for the Court to consider whether the evidence discloses a prima facie case to warrant his detention in jail besides the other relevant factors referred to above.”

    14. At another place the Court observed that there cannot be an inexorable formula in the matter of granting bail and the facts & circumstances of each case will govern the exercise of judicial discretion in granting or cancelling bail. In Bhagirath Singh (supra) the Supreme Court, with respect, cannot be said to have departed from the principle laid down in State v. Jaspal Singh Gill, (supra). As pointed out in the case of Gurcharan Singh (supra), the facts and circumstances of each case will govern the exercise of judicial discretion in matters of granting or cancelling bail, therefore no inflexible rule was intended to be laid down by the Supreme Court in of Bhagirath Singh (supra).

    15. Again in State (Delhi Administration) v. Sanjay Gandhi, (1978) 2 SCC 411, the Supreme Court observed that the power to take back in custody one who has been enlarged on bail has to be exercised with care and circumspection. But at the same time it held that in an appropriate case such a power can be exercised. While so holding the Supreme Court noticed the case of Gurcharan Singh (supra) and observed as under:—

    “In Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Administration), while confirming the order of the High Court cancelling the bail of the accused, this Court observed that the only question which the Court had to consider at that stage was whether “there was prima facie case made out, as alleged, on the statements of the witnesses and on other materials”, that “there was a likelihood of the appellants tampering with the prosecution witnesses”. It is by the application of this test that we have come to the conclusion that the respondent's bail ought to be cancelled.”

    16. In Shahzad Hasan Khan v. Ishtiaq Hasan Khan, (1987) 2 SCC 684 : AIR 1987 Supreme Court 1613, the Supreme Court cancelled the bail of the accused, which was granted by the High Court, having regard to the gravity of the offence, the nature of the evidence available and the likelihood of the accused tampering with evidence. The Supreme Court in this regard observed as follows:—

    “Having regard to the facts and circumstances of this case we are of the opinion that the learned Judge committed serious error in recalling his order dated June 3, 1986 and enlarging the respondent on bail. The occurrence took place, in the broad day light, in a busy market place and there are a number of eye witnesses to support the case against the respondent who was named as an assailant in the First Information Report. Immediately after the occurrence he could not be traced (it was alleged that he had absconded) for more than a month, attempts were made on his behalf to tamper with evidence. In view of these facts and circumstances the respondent No. 1 was not entitled to bail if the seriousness of the matter was realised and a judicious approach was made. We had accordingly set aside the order of the High Court and directed that respondent No. 1 Ishtiaq Hasan Khan shall be taken into custody forthwith and the trial shall proceed in accordance with law expeditiously.”

    17. There is no doubt that the liberty of the accused has to be safeguarded in accordance with law but while keeping in mind the interests of the accused, the collective interest of the community cannot be lost sight of so that the parties do not lose faith in the administration of justice and take law into their own hands to wreak vengenance by private retribution.

    18. The High Court while considering the question of cancellation of bail can also examine the propriety and legality of the order passed by the Court of Session.

    19. In Smt. Rajani Rani Kar v. Goli Pradhan, 1992 (3) Crimes 181, Orissa High Court, held inter alia, that if it is found that bail to the accused has been granted improperly and arbitrarily, the same can be cancelled by the High Court.”

    20. I have referred to the aforesaid decision and quoted the same in extenso as the argument advanced and two of the authorities relied upon by Shri Lalit in the present case we are also advanced and relied upon in that case too. From the decision in Jayanti Prasad Goel (supra) it clearly follows that once an accused has been enlarged on bail, his liberation from custody cannot be lightly interfered with, but this does not mean that even in a proper case where ends of justice would be defeated unless the accused is committed to custody, power of the High Court to cancel the bail cannot be exercised. Shri Lalit relied upon the following observations of the Supreme Court in Aslant Babalal Desai (supra):

    “Bail granted under Section 437(1) or (2) or Section 439(1) can be cancelled under Section 437(5) and 439(2) where (1) the accused misuses his liberty by indulging in similar criminal activity, (ii) interferes with the course of investigation, (ii) attempts to tamper with evidence or witness, (iv) threatens witnesses or indulges in similar activities which would hamper smoother investigation, (v) there is likelihood of his fleeing to another country, (vi) attempts to make himself scarce by going underground or becoming unavailable to the investigating agency, (vii) attempts to place himself beyond the reach of his surety, etc. These grounds are illustrative and not exhaustive. Rejection of bail stands on one footing but cancellation of bail is a harsh order because it interferes with the liberty of the individual and hence it must not be lightly resorted to.”

    21. Though in the above decision the Supreme Court indicated seven grounds, mostly based upon the activities of an accused after the grant of bail to him, at the same time it observed that these grounds were illustrative and not exhaustive and where there are strong grounds, cancellation of bail can be ordered in a proper case.

    22. Thus the Supreme Court did not depart from the principles laid down in its earlier decisions including. The State v. Captain Jagjit Singh, AIR 1962 SC 253, The State v. Jaspal Singh Gill (supra) and Shahzad Hasan Khan v. Ishtiaq Hasan Khan, (supra) etc. where the Supreme Court cancelled the bails having regard to the gravity of the offence, nature of the evidence available, the likelihood of the accused running away from justice, the likelihood of the accused misutllising his liberty by intimidating the witnesses and tampering with evidence, the larger interests of the State and community including the consideration that parties do not lose faith in the system and take law into their own hands to wreak vengenance by private retribution. Although it may not be possible for a Court hierarchically subordinate to the High Court, which granted bail to the accused, to consider cancellation thereof without the intervention of a supervening circumstance, it is competent in law for the High Court to cancel bail in a proper and suitable case as a superior Court, while examining the propriety and legality of the order granting bail and interfere accordingly.

    23. The principles which flow from the decisions of the Courts in the matters of grant or cancellation of bail cannot be put in a strait jacket and facts of each case would govern the matter.

    24. As regards the submission of learned Counsel for the respondent that on merits the learned Additional Sessions Judge was justified in granting bail to the petitioner is concerned, I am of the opinion that it was not the right stage for the learned Additional Sessions Judge to have exercised his discretion in granting bail to the respondent. The learned Additional Sessions Judge failed to take into consideration that the allegations against the accused are very serious. The learned Additional Sessions Judge granted bail to the respondent in view of his order in Mahender Singh's case.

    25. At this stage a detailed discussion of the material placed on record by the State is not warranted. It would be sufficient to point out that the material consists of the alleged extra judicial confession made by Mange Ram before Som Pal, Statement of Sham Singh and Raj Dhan regarding the alleged fact that the deceased was last seen alive in the company of the accused persons on January 10, 1993 only a couple of hours before his death, CFSL report according to which blood detected on the weapons of offence, namely, hockey sticks, which were allegedly discovered at the instance of the accused, was found to be of “A” Group, which allegedly tallies with the blood group of the deceased and the allegation that accused are trying to intimidate the witnesses.

    26. Having regard to the totality of the circumstances of the case and keeping in view the guidelines laid down in the aforesaid judgments of the Supreme Court I consider it to be a fit and proper case for cancellation of of bail of the respondent. Accordingly, the bail of the respondent is cancelled. It will, however, be open to the respondent to move a fresh application for bail after the statements of material witnesses have been recorded by the Court concerned, if so advised. This order of cancellation of bail, however, will not be operative for a period of 15 days.

    Petition allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chandan Singh v. Yashvinder Chauhan .
    (Sep 17, 1993)