| Sheikh Abdul Rahman v. Khan Sahib Haji Rashid Ahmed, AIR 1937 Lahore 182 |
Tests to determine whether a rural area has assumed urban character (including that inclusion within town limits is not conclusive; area may be absorbed; municipal limits important; each case on merits). |
The court applied these tests and engaged with the question whether the land had lost agricultural character and become urban; it used the principles to assess competing factual indicators of urbanisation. |
| Diwan Chand v. Nizam Din, AIR 1924 Lahore 662 |
Definition that "village" ordinarily connotes an area occupied by persons mainly dependent on agriculture; rural areas near towns may become suburbs governed by urban rules. |
Used to support the proposition that land near a town may cease to be agricultural and be governed as urban property. |
| Gopi Mal v. Muhammed Yasin, AIR 1924 Lahore 657 |
That land being fallow at time of sale does not necessarily mean it is not agricultural; however prolonged non-use and proposal as building site indicate non-agricultural status. |
Court acknowledged the rule but distinguished the instant facts where records showed abandonment for years and conversion to housing plots. |
| Shah Mohammad v. Mt. Pairi, AIR 1936 Lahore 202 |
When agricultural land is converted into a building site it ceases to be part of the estate and owner loses privileges under agricultural law. |
Cited to show that conversion to building use indicates cessation of agricultural character. |
| Uttam Chand v. Khodaya, AIR 1929 Lahore 164 |
Payment of land revenue is not conclusive that land remains agricultural as land revenue may continue after inclusion in town/village. |
Used to caution against relying solely on revenue assessment to determine agricultural character. |
| Phaggu Shah v. Khair Din, AIR 1938 Lahore 353 |
Same proposition as Uttam Chand regarding land revenue not being conclusive of agricultural character. |
Supported the court's approach to consider all facts, not revenue status alone. |
| Balwant Rai v. Dittu Ram, 1959 PLR 716 |
The nature of land for pre-emption is to be seen on the date of sale; diversion from agricultural use (e.g., to use as a bhatta) means land ceases to be agricultural. |
Reinforced the proposition that the relevant date is date of sale and that evidence of diversion supports non-agricultural character. |
| Lala Khazanchi Shah v. Haji Niaz Ali, AIR 1940 Lahore 438 |
Question whether land is agricultural is not to be determined solely from revenue papers; all facts and circumstances must be considered. |
Court relied on this authority to justify weighing documentary and other evidence (revenue entries, municipal action, sales) together. |
| Jiwa v. Buta and others, 26 Punjab record 1912 page 92 |
Principle that land occupied or let for agricultural purposes at time of sale is subject to pre-emption even if situate in a town; subsequent building by vendee does not alter pre-emption right. |
The court accepted the general principle that nature is to be determined on date of sale, but noted the decision was under an earlier statute (Pre-emption Act II of 1905) and limited its application; nevertheless the date-of-sale rule was accepted. |
| V. Ramachandra Ayyar v. Ramalingam Chettiar, AIR 1963 SC 302 |
Authority concerning the binding nature of appellate findings of fact in subsequent appeals. |
Referenced by respondent's counsel to argue the lower appellate court's factual finding was binding; the court considered this but held that where legal inference from facts is involved the second appeal may overturn the inference. |
| Madamanchi Ramappa v. Muthaluru Bojjappa, AIR 1963 SC 1633 |
Authority on limitations of review in second appeal with respect to findings of fact. |
Respondent relied on it; court treated these authorities but held the legal inference drawn by the lower appellate court was incorrect and review was warranted. |
| Gurbaksh Singh v. Nikka Singh, AIR 1963 SC 1917 |
Authority cited to show circumstances in which findings in lower courts may be reviewed on second appeal. |
Cited by the court as precedent showing the second appeal can review legal inferences and that the lower appellate court's finding was not binding where legal question arises from facts. |
| Radha Nath Seal v. Haripada Jana, AIR 1971 SC 1049 |
Authority on the scope of interference in second appeals. |
Referred to as part of the jurisprudence permitting second-appeal review of legal conclusions drawn from facts. |
| Damadilal v. Parashram, AIR 1976 SC 2229 |
Authority on interference in second appeals (scope and limits). |
Referred to by the court as illustrating the established principles on review in second appeals when legal inferences are at issue. |