Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion (H.R. Khanna, C.J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

These two appeals — S.A.O. 110-D of 1962 and R.S.A. 105 of 1967 — were brought by M/s. Kanhiya Lal Balkishan Das (the appellants). The respondent in S.A.O. 110-D of 1962 is Labhu Ram; the respondent in R.S.A. 105 of 1967 is the firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath through partner Jagan Nath. The appeals were heard together because common questions of law and fact arose.

The subject matter is shop No. 3659, Pahari Dhiraj, Saddar Bazar, Delhi. The premises were let to the firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath on 1-1-1957 at a monthly rent of Rs. 29.00. The firm was dissolved on 13-4-1959 and the lessee rights in the premises were said to have fallen to Labhu Ram.

Labhu Ram filed an application under section 9 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 for fixation of standard rent alleging the agreed rent was excessive. The landlords admitted letting to the firm but alleged no landlord–tenant relationship with Labhu Ram and contended that the shop had been sublet to Labhu Ram without written permission, rendering the application not maintainable. The Additional Controller held that Labhu Ram was a partner and became a tenant by operation of law; that decision was affirmed by the Rent Control Tribunal, and S.A.O. 110-D of 1962 was brought against the Tribunal's order.

R.S.A. 105 of 1967 arises from a suit by the landlords for recovery of Rs. 1,134 (rent for three years prior to 30-4-1964). The defendant firm pleaded that on dissolution the premises were allotted to Labhu Ram and that liability to pay rent was Labhu Ram's alone; notice of dissolution was said to have been served on the landlords. The trial court framed issues including whether Labhu Ram was a necessary party, whether the defendant was a subsisting tenant, and the amount due. The trial court and the Additional District Judge found that there was no landlord–tenant relationship with the defendant firm after dissolution and dismissed the landlords' suit; R.S.A. 105 of 1967 challenges that decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the allotment of leased premises to a partner of the original tenant partnership (on dissolution) amounts to subletting such that the application under section 9 of the Delhi Rent Control Act by that partner is not maintainable.
  2. Whether Labhu Ram (an individual who purportedly received the premises upon dissolution) was a proper/necessary party and entitled to apply for fixation of standard rent under section 9 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958.
  3. Whether, after dissolution of the partnership, the former partners (other than the partner to whom the premises were allotted) remain liable to the landlord for rent due for the period prior to surrender of possession.
  4. Whether the courts below were correct in holding that there was no subsisting landlord–tenant relationship between the appellants and the defendant firm after dissolution of the firm and allotment of the premises to Labhu Ram.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • In S.A.O. 110-D: It was contended that, even if Labhu Ram was a partner, he might have been inducted into the partnership after 1-1-1957 (the date of commencement of the tenancy) and before dissolution on 13-4-1959 — a factual point which, appellants argued, makes the Tribunal's finding vulnerable.
  • In S.A.O. 110-D: The allotment of the premises to Labhu Ram on dissolution should be treated as subletting, invalidating his application under section 9.
  • In S.A.O. 110-D: Labhu Ram alone could not maintain an application for fixation of standard rent; all persons who took the premises on rent should join in an application under section 9.
  • In R.S.A. 105 of 1967: The appellants argued that all partners who were parties to the tenancy on 1-1-1957 remained liable for rent until possession was surrendered to the landlords; dissolution and an internal allotment among partners did not absolve them vis-à-vis the landlord.

Respondents' / Defendant's Arguments

  • In S.A.O. 110-D: The position taken at earlier stages (Additional Controller and Tribunal) was that Labhu Ram was a partner and became a tenant by operation of law; that conclusion was maintained before the Court.
  • In R.S.A. 105 of 1967: The defendant firm contended that after dissolution the premises were allotted to Labhu Ram and that liability to pay rent rested with Labhu Ram alone; notice of dissolution had been served on the landlords, supporting their contention that the firm was no longer liable.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shrimati Saraswati Devi v. L. Gian Chand, 1970 R.C.R 874 Where premises are let to a partnership firm, the entry/exit of a partner (one partner leaving and a new partner entering) does not amount to subletting. The Court relied on this decision to support the conclusion that allotment of the shop to one of the existing partners on dissolution did not constitute subletting.
Murli Dhar v. Chuni Lal and others, 1970 R.C.J 922 The firm name is a compendious description of the partners; occupation by the firm is the same as occupation by its partners; where old and new firms share a common partner, occupation by the new firm is to be treated as occupation by the old tenant. Used to reinforce that one partner's occupation or continuation in possession does not amount to subletting and that the partnership name is merely a collective description of individual partners.
Ram Vichar & another v. Daulat Ram Mohan Das & others, 1967 D.L.T 223 Where a later firm in possession consists of partners who were also partners of the earlier firm, that change does not amount to subletting. Cited to illustrate that change in the composition of firms or continuation of possession by common partners does not create a subletting situation.
K. Devarajulu Naidu v. C. Ethirajavathi Thayaramma & others, A.I.R. 1950 Madras 25 An assignment by one partner to the other of the partnership's interest in leased premises upon dissolution did not constitute a breach of a covenant prohibiting assignment without lessor's consent; landlord was not entitled to eviction on that ground. Invoked to support the proposition that transfer/assignment among partners on dissolution does not per se breach lease covenants or amount to subletting enforceable against the landlord.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed the matters in a structured way, applying statutory provisions and precedents to the concrete factual and procedural record before it.

  1. On the appellants' factual contention that Labhu Ram might have been inducted into the partnership after the tenancy began (a submission that would affect the tenure question), the Court declined to entertain this factual plea for the first time in a second appeal because the point had not been raised before the Additional Controller or the Rent Control Tribunal. The Court treated this as a pure question of fact not open for the first time on second appeal.
  2. On whether allotment of the premises to Labhu Ram amounted to subletting, the Court analyzed the character of a firm and the legal status of partners. It relied on Section 4 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932 (as quoted in the opinion) to explain that a "firm" is a compendious name for its partners; when a firm takes premises, each partner is a tenant. Subletting, the Court observed, requires introduction of a third person into the premises. Allotting the premises to one of the firm's partners (on dissolution) therefore is not subletting because the partner is not a third person but was effectively part of the tenant entity. The Court fortified this conclusion by referring to cited precedents that apply the compendious-firm principle in similar contexts.
  3. On standing to apply under section 9 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958, the Court noted that section 9 permits either the landlord or the tenant to apply for fixation of standard rent. Since Labhu Ram had become a tenant when the firm leased the premises, he was entitled to make the application in his own right. The Court found nothing requiring all original tenants to join an application under section 9.
  4. Regarding R.S.A. 105 of 1967 (the rent recovery suit), the Court considered the appellants' argument that partners who were parties to the tenancy remained liable for rent until surrender of possession, despite internal arrangements on dissolution. The Court accepted this position: dissolution and internal allotment to Labhu Ram without landlord assent did not extinguish the landlords' rights to claim rent from the former partners. The Court invoked Section 43 of the Indian Contract Act to the effect that joint promisors may be compelled to perform the whole promise and relied on authoritative text (Lindley on Partnership) to show that changes in firm composition do not affect rights against third parties unless those third parties accede to the change.
  5. On the consequence of the incorrect finding by the lower courts on issue No. (2) (that there was no subsisting liability), the Court held that the lower courts were wrong and that R.S.A. 105 of 1967 must be allowed. Because issue No. (3) (quantification) had not been decided below in view of issue No. (2), the matter was remanded for determination in accordance with law.

Holding and Implications

Core Holdings

  • S.A.O. 110-D of 1962: DISMISSED. The Court concluded there was no merit in the appellants' contentions in that appeal: (a) it would not entertain the late factual contention about induction of a partner on second appeal; (b) allotment to a partner on dissolution did not amount to subletting; and (c) Labhu Ram, as a tenant by virtue of the firm's tenancy, could maintain an application under section 9 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 for fixation of standard rent.
  • R.S.A. 105 of 1967: ACCEPTED (allowed). The Court held that the partners of the firm who were parties to the tenancy remained liable for rent until possession was surrendered to the landlords, and that the lower courts were incorrect in holding otherwise. The case was remanded to the trial court for decision on the remaining issue(s), notably issue No. (3), in accordance with law.

Immediate Consequences for the Parties

  • R.S.A. 105 of 1967 is allowed and remitted to the trial court for determination of the amount and period (issue No. (3)) in accordance with the Court's legal findings.
  • S.A.O. 110-D of 1962 is dismissed, confirming that Labhu Ram may pursue fixation of standard rent under section 9 in his own name.
  • The Court directed that the parties appear in the trial court on 27th February, 1971, and ordered that each party shall bear its own costs in both appeals.

The Court's decision applies existing statutory provisions (Section 4, Indian Partnership Act; Section 43, Indian Contract Act; Section 9, Delhi Rent Control Act) and prior case law to the facts; the opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond those applications.

    M/S. Kanhiya Lal Balkishan Dass v. Labhu Ram

    H.R Khanna, C.J:— This judgment would dispose of S.A.O 110-D of 1962 and R.S.A 105 of 1967. Both the appeals have been filed by M/s. Kanhiya Lal Balkishan Das. The respondent in S.A.O 110-D of 1962 is Labhu Ram while that in R.S.A 105 of 1967 is firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath through Jagan Nath partner. The two appeals are being decided by a common judgment as the submission of the learned counsel for the parties is that common questions of law and fact arise in the two cases and the decision in one is bound to impunge upon the decision in the other.

    The brief facts of the case are that the appellants are the owner-landlords of the premises in dispute comprising shop No. 3659, Pahari Dhiraj, Saddar Bazar, Delhi. The premises were let out by the appellants to firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath through Jagan Nath on 1-1-1957 at a monthly rent of Rs. 29.00 The firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath was subsequently dissolved on 13-4-1959 and the lessee rights of the premises in dispute fell to the share of Labhu Ram respondent. Labhu Ram filed an application under section 9 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958, for fixation of standard rent on the allegation that the agreed rent was excessive. The appellant-landlords admitted that the shop in dispute had been let out to firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath, but alleged that there was no relationship of landlord and tenant between the parties. Plea was also taken that the shop had been sublet to Labhu Ram without the written permission of the appellant-landlords and as such the application of Labhu Ram was not maintainable.
    The Additional Controller after hearing the parties came to the conclusion that Labhu Ram was a partner of firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath and on dissolution of that firm he became a tenant by operation of law. The application for fixation of standard rent as such was held to be maintainable. The appellants went up in appeal, but the decision of the Additional Controller was affirmed by learned Rent Control Tribunal. S.A.O 110-D of 1962 is directed against the order of the Rent Control Tribunal. When the appeal came up for hearing before Dua, C.J, the learned Chief Justice directed that it be disposed of by a larger Bench.
    R.S.A 105 of 1967 arises out of a suit for recovery of rent of Rs. 1,134.00 brought by the landlord-appellants for the period prior to 30-4-1964 for the premises in dispute. The rent for the period which was beyond the period of limitation was given up and the amount of Rs. 1,134.00 as representing rent for three years only was claimed.
    The above suit was contested by the defendant firm. It was pleaded on its behalf that though there came into existence tenancy in respect of the premises in dispute on 1-1-1957, the defendant firm had thereafter been dissolved on 13-4-1959. According to the defendant firm, as a result of dissolution of the partnership the premises in dispute were allotted to Labhu Ram and as such the liability to pay rent was that of Labhu Ram alone. Notice regarding dissolution of partnership was also stated to have been served upon the landlord-plaintiffs. The following issues were framed in the case: —
    “ (1) Whether Shri Labhu Ram is a necessary party to the suit ?
    (2) Whether the defendant is not a subsisting tenant of the plaintiff ? If so, to what effect ?
    (3) To what amount and from when the plaintiff is entitled.
    The trial court decided issue No. (1) against the defendant firm. Issue No. (2) was decided against the plaintiffs and it was held that there was no relationship of landlord and tenant between the plaintiffs and the defendant firm in view of the dissolution of the partnership and the allotment of the premises in dispute to Labhu Ram. Issue No. 3 was held to be redundant in view of the finding on issue No. (2). In the result the plaintiffs' suit was dismissed. On appeal the learned Additional District Judge affirmed the finding of the trial Court on issue No. (2) and dismissed the appeal. R.S.A 105 of 1967 is directed against the judgment and decree of the Additional District Judge. At the time this appeal was admitted it was directed that it should be heard with S.A.O 110-D of 1962.
    We have heard Mr. Radhey Mohan Lal on behalf of the appellants and Mr. Jaggi on behalf of the respondent in S.A.O 110-D of 1962 as well as Mr. Jagdish Kumar on behalf of the respondent firm in R.S.A 105 of 1967, and are of the opinion that there is no substance in the contention advanced on behalf of the appellant's in S.A.O 110-D while there is force in the submissions made on appellants' behalf in R.S.A 105. So far as S.A.O 110-D of 1962 is concerned, the first contention of Mr. Radhey Mohan Lal is that assuming that Labhu Ram was a partner of firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath, he might have been inducted as such in that firm after 1-1-1957, the date of the commencement of the tenancy, and before 13-4-1959, the date of the dissolution of the firm. This submission essentially involves questions of fact and the order of the Rent Control Tribunal or even that of the Additional Controller shows that no such point was raised before them. As such we are not prepared to entertain this plea involving questions of fact for the first time in second appeal.
    Mr. Radhey Mohan Lal argues that even if Labhu Ram was a partner of firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath, the allotment of the premises in dispute to him on the dissolution of the firm should be held to amount to subletting. The learned counsel in this context has emphasised the fact that the original tenant of the premises was firm Gokal Jagan Nath. There is no force in the above contention. A firm, it is well-known, is a compendious name of the partners constituting the firm. According to Section 4 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, persons who have entered into partnership with one another are called individually ‘partners and collectively ‘a firm’. It would, therefore, follow that when firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath took the premises in dispute on rent from the appellants, Labhu Ram who was one of the partners of the firm became, along with the other partners a tenant in the premises. Subletting essentially entails the induction of a third person into the premises. The allotment of the shop to one of the partners of the firm, which was the tenant of the premises, upon its dissolution cannot amount to subletting. We are fortified in this conclusion by a Bench decision (Andley & Tatachari JJ.) of this Court in Shrimati Saraswati Devi v. L. Gian Chand, 1970 R.C.R 874 (1). It was held in that case that where premises were out to a partnership firm and one of the partners left the firm and a new partner entered the firm, it did not amount to subletting. In Murli Dhar v. Chuni Lal and others, 1970 R.C.J 922, (2) it was held by their Lordships of the Supreme Court that the firm name was only a compendious way of describing the partners of the firm and the occupation of premises by a firm was the same as occupation by its partners. The Court held that where the old and new firms had a common partner, the occupation by the new firm of a premises shall be taken to be the occupation by the old tenant as the common partner will be considered to be in possession all through in his individual capacity. In Ram Vichar and another v. Daulat Ram Mohan Das & others, 1967 D.L.T 223 (3), a Division Bench of the Punjab High Court, (Mahajan and Kapur JJ.), held that there would be no subletting of the premises if the firm consisting of 6 to 10 partners was no longer in possession of the premises and a firm consisting of 4 partners, who were also partners of the first firm, was in possession. In K. Devarajulu Naidu v. C. Ethirajavathi Thayaramma and others, A.I.R 1950 Madras 25, (4) one of the two partners after dissolution of the firm assigned to the other partner the interest of the partnership in the premises which had been taken on lease by the firm. It was held by Rajamannar C.J and Mack J. that the above assignment did not amount to breach of the covenant prohibiting an assignment of the lease without the consent of the lessor and as such the landlord was not entitled to eviction on that ground.
    Lastly it has been argued in S.A.O 110-D of 1962 that Labhu Ram alone could not maintain an application for fixation of standard rent. In this respect we find that according to section 9 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958, the Controller shall, on an application made to him in this behalf either by the landlord or by the tenant in the prescribed manner, fix standard rent of the premises. Labhu Ram, as stated above, became a tenant of the premises when firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath took the same on rent. As such Labhu Ram was entitled to apply for fixation of standard rent. Nothing has been brought to our notice as makes it imperative that all the persons who took the premises on rent should join as petitioners in an application under section 9 of the said Act. S.A.O 110-D of 1962 is consequently liable to be dismissed.
    So far as R.S.A 105 of 1967 is concerned, Mr. Radhey Mohan Lal submits that the appellants let out the premises to firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath. All the partners of that firm consequently became liable for the rent of the premises till such time as the possession of the premises was surrendered back to the landlords. The dissolution of the firm, according to Mr. Radhey Mohan Lal, would not affect the right of the appellants to claim rent of the premises from the persons who were partners of the firm before its dissolution. The above stand has been controverted by Mr. Jagdish Kumar, but in our opinion there is considerable force in the submissions of the appellants in this respect. The appellants on 1-1-1957 let out the premises to firm Gokal Chand Jagan Nath. As such the liability to pay rent of the premises was that of all the partners of the firm. The fact that the partners mutually decided to dissolve the firm and to allot the premises to Labhu Ram alone would not absolve them of their liability for rent vis a vis the landlords. There is nothing to show that the landlords gave their assent to the arrangement by which the premises in dispute were allotted to Labhu Ram. It may be that if the rent of the premises is realised by the landlords from a partner other than Labhu Ram, he may have a claim against Labhu Ram for being reimbursed in view of the terms of dissolution, but that fact would not affect the right of the landlords to recover the rent from the partners of the firm. According to Section 43 of the Indian Contract Act, when two or more persons make a joint promise, the promise may, in the absence of express agreement to the contrary, compel any one or more of such joint promisors to perform the whole of the promise. What is the effect of a change in a firm on its liabilities qua the third party has been discussed on pages 44 and 324 of Law of Partnership by Lindley, Twelfth Edition. It is stated on page 44: —
    “Another most important consequence of the principle, that on any change amongst the persons composing a partnership there is in fact a new partnership, and not a mere continuation of the old one, is that although, upon a change in a firm, it may be agreed between the members of the old and new partnerships, the rights and obligations of the old shall devolve upon the new partners, this has no effect upon third parties unless they accede to it.”
    Again on page 324 the learned author has observed: —
    “So as regards changes occasioned by the retirement of a partner. It has been already shown that the retirement of a partner in no way affects his rights against or obligations to strangers in respect of past transactions.”
    We are, therefore, of the view that the finding of the Courts below on issue No. (2) was not correct. R.S.A 105 of 1967 must consequently be allowed.
    In the result, S.A.O 110-D of 1962 is dismissed, but R.S.A 105 of 1967 is accepted. As in the latter appeal the Courts below did not decide issue No. (3) in view of the finding on issue No. (2), the case is remanded to the trial Court for decision in accordance with law. Keeping in view all the circumstances, we leave the patties to bear their own costs in both the appeals. The parties are directed to appear in the trial Court on 27th February, 1971.
    Order accordingly.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S. Kanhiya Lal Balkishan Dass v. Labhu Ram
    (Jan 20, 1971)