(Order of the Court was delivered by
M.M.SUNDRESH,J.)
Facts in brief:
1.1 The government of India has undertaken the project of providing a Bye
pass to Trichy with a view to improve the infrastructure for agricultural,
industrial, educational, health and socio-economic advancement in and around
Trichy. The project of Tiruchirappalli - Karaikudi section of NH-210 from
Km.10/000 to Km.94/000 including Trichy Bye pass on NH-67 from Km.110/016 to
Km.135/930 was designed and restructured as two-lane with paved shoulders.
1.2 For the above said purpose an alignment is required for Trichy Bye
pass which starts near Thuvakudi village at Km.110/016 of NH-67 and intersects
at Panchapur village at Km.135/930 at NH-45B. The said Bye pass road passes
through Thuvakudi, Palanganakudi, Ilandaipatti, Kandalur, Sooriyur and Kumbakudi
- Velayuthangudi, Olaiyur, K.Sathanur South and K. Sathanur North villages of
Tiruchirappalli District. The alignment also passes through Mathur,
Signathakurichi and Kumaramangalam villages of Pudukottai District. Apart from
the same, the alignment also passes through the Periyakulam and Kanakkankulam
tanks of Sathanur village.
1.3 The Bye pass road after completion would facilitate to connect the
following important National Highways roads:
1.Thanjavur - Trichy - NH-67.
2.Trichy - Madurai - NH-45B.
3.Trichy - Karur - NH-67.
4.Trichy - Karaikudi; Karaikudi - Ramanathapuram - NH-210.
5.Trichy - Dindigul - NH-45.
1.4 The respondent No.7, who is the authority to complete the project has
obtained an expert opinion from one R.Sivasamy, who is a former Chief Engineer
and Administrator, who retired from the services of the Union Ministry of
Surface Transport. This opinion has been obtained for the alignment at
Kanakkankulam Tank. Similarly, insofar as Sathanur Periyakulam Tank is
concerned, another opinion has been obtained from the said person. Apart from
the said opinion, the 7th respondent has obtained one another opinion from
Dr.P.Kasinatha Pandian, who has done his Doctorate degree in water resources.
1.5 The report submitted by Shri.R.Sivasamy is as follows:
"The proposed alignment across the tank on the southern end of the tank is in
the shallow region. The outflow from the tank is through three sluices are on
western side of tank. Hence the alignment does not prevent the flow of water to
the ayacut. The surplus water is let out at the southern side by the surplus
weir. With a view to facilitate free flow of surplus water from northern side to
southern side balancing culverts are required. The site plan of the tank sluices
inlet flow and outlet flow of tank are enclosed. Further, to take case of the
rain water from catchment area, the vent way of the culvert should be designed.
Accordingly, it is necessary to provide 3 Nos. of Box Culvert, with a vent way
of 3m width and depth of 2m above Full Tank (or) Balancing Bridge of 1 x 9 span
with clear vent way.
It is worth to mention that the water from the New Kattalai Canal is let
into the tank for four months in a year for irrigation purpose. The tank was dry
during remaining 8 months. However, the NHAI is requested to improve the surplus
weir so as to have free flow of water to avoid the breach of tank.
The formation of road reduces the storage capacity of tank by 10,000 cubic
meter as per Cross Section, the NHAI should deepen the tank in such a way that
the full storage capacity is restored.
...
The K. Sathanur tank was dry when I visited the site. The Trichy Bye pass
alignment passes across the tank on the north eastern part of the tank. The
inflow of the tank is in the order of 55 cusecs and outflow in order of 780
cusecs. The inflow to the tank is from south-eastern side and three sluices are
located on the western side and one on the northern side as shown in the sketch
enclosed. The surplus water from the tank is let out by the surplus weir located
on the north-east corner of the tank. There is no obstruction of flow of water
to the three sluices located on the western side of the tank. With regard to the
one sluice on northern side, free flow of water is ensured by proposing
Balancing Bridges / Culverts. The reach from Ch:134+400 to Ch:134+600 is deeper
hence Balancing Bridge of 1 x 20m of span shall be provided. The other reaches
from Ch:133+800 to Ch:134+400 at every 200 m interval one Box Culvert of 3m
width and 2m depth above the Full Tank Level (FTL) shall be provided."
1.6 The report submitted by Dr.P.Kasinatha Pandian, concerning the above
mentioned Tank is as follows:
"1. A minor bridge of at least 25 m span should be constructed in the
chainage between 134.400 to 134.600m to maintain the free flow of water on both
sides.
2. Box culverts with suitable size should be provided at every 200m in the
remaining part of the road falls within the tank.
3. Deepening of tank in the shallower parts is a must to ensure the
storage capacity to the original level.
4. Side slopes of the proposed bypass road should be provided with
revetment with lining to control erosion and to avoid silting."
1.7 The respondent No.7 has also obtained one another report from the
Director, Centre for Water Resources, Anna University, Chennai for the formation
of road in Kannakkankulam and Periyakulam Tanks of K.Sathanoor.
1.8 Since for the proposed alignments, lands were to be acquired, as they
belong to private persons, a notification was published by the Central
Government under Section 3-A of the National Highways Act, 1956. After
considering the objections, which are two in numbers, that too regarding
compensation, orders have been passed under Section 3C (2) of the National
Highways Act, 1956. A declaration under Section 3(D) was also passed on
12.05.2011.
1.9 At that stage, the petitioner has come forward to file this Writ
Petition, seeking a writ of mandamus, to direct the respondents not to put up
the ring road (NH-67) in the middle of K. Sathanoor Periakulam and Kannakkan
Kulam, including the agricultural nanja lands and form an alternative alignment.
2. The grievance of the petitioner is that by the proposed alignment, the
small farmers, who are depending upon the agricultural operations would be
affected and by laying roads over the two tanks, the water source would be very
much affected. When the developmental activities are pitted against the
consideration of natural resources, the latter will have to be given primacy.
The petitioner has also relied upon the judgments rendered by this Hon'ble Court
in Selvakumar v. Union of India, 2011 (1) CWC 23 and Krishnan, L. v. State of
Tamil Nadu, 2005 (4) CTC 1 in support of its case.
3. A counter affidavit and an additional counter affidavit have been filed
by the respondent No.7. It has been stated therein that the Writ Petition is not
maintainable in law and facts as it is nothing but a private interest
litigation. The President of the petitioner association is personally affected
and without even giving an objection to the acquisition he has formed the
association and filed the Writ Petition. The entire procedure contemplated under
the National High Ways Act, 1956 has been followed resulting in the acquisition
of lands and the lands have become vested with the Government. The respondent
No.7 is an expert body in the construction of roads and the entire project has
been conceived after getting opinion of two experts, after conducting the
environment impact study. Apart from the opinion of the experts an opinion has
been obtained from the Director of Water Resources, Anna University, Chennai.
The subsequent opinion given by the said authority by discussing the opinion
given by the Chief Engineer, Public Works Department will also be implemented
and hence, the 7th respondent prays that suitable order may be passed
considering the huge public interest involved.
4. Locus Standi:
Even though the respondent No.7 has filed a counter affidavit stating that
there is no public interest involved, as the President of the petitioner
association is a person affected by the acquisition, we are not willing to go
into the said issue. Even assuming that there is a private interest, when the
issue involved is of public importance, this Court will have to look into the
same and decide it on its own merits. Merely because the President of the
petitioner association has got some private interest, the same cannot be applied
to the petitioner, particularly in view of the public interest involved in
preserving the water bodies. Hence, we reject the contentions of the respondent
No.7 on the locus-standi of the petitioner to file this Writ Petition.
5. Reports of the Experts:
Considering the issues involved, particularly with regards to the possible
impact on the water sources, namely K.Sathanoor Periakulam and Kannakkan Kulam
tanks, this Court by order dated 08.08.2011, directed the Chief Engineer of
Public Works Department, Water Resources Organisation, Trichy to appear before
this Court on 16.08.2011. On his appearance, the said authority was directed to
file a report. A report was filed by the Chief Engineer, Public Works Department
on 25.08.2011. The said report is extracted hereunder:
"1. The highway should not pass through the tank.
2. The new alignment should at best be aligned along the boundaries of the
tanks without affecting the inflow and outflow from the tanks.
3. If it is inevitable to align the Highway in the tank, then the Highway
should be constructed over the bridges after proper hydraulic and hydrologic
analysis so that there is no obstruction to the inflow and outflow from the
tanks.
4. The flow in the Kannakkankulam supply channel (Distributory No.14 of
NKHLC) is affected by the proposed NH67 alignment in Kanakkankulam tank. Hence,
it is recommended that the Highway alignment may be realigned to safeguard the
Existing supply channel. (OPTION A)
(or)
It it is inevitable to align the Highway in supply channel, then the High
way should be constructed over the bridges after proper Hydraulic and Hydrologic
analysis so that there is no obstruction to the inflow and outflow to the supply
channel. (Option B as per enclosed sketch)"
6. In order to get more clarification, we permitted the respondent No.7 to
refer the said report to the Director, Centre for Water Resources, Anna
University, Chennai. Accordingly, the said authority has also filed a report
dated 18.09.2011, which is also extracted hereunder:
"3.0 Conclusions and Recommendations
# Based on the Hydraulic and Hydrologic analysis, it is concluded that
both the options proposed by the Chief Engineer, PWD (Option A and Option B are
technically feasible propositions.
# However, if Option A (i.e., realignment of the highway) is opted, it
affects the storage capacity of Kanakkankulam Tank, and it will not disturb the
existing alignment of the supply channel.
# If Option B (i.e., providing bridge over the supply channel for a length
of 166 m) is exercised, then both the existing alignment of the proposed highway
and supply channel are not affected."
7. This Court is concerned with the proposed laying of road over the two
tanks, namely K.Sathanoor Periakulam and Kannakkan Kulam tanks. While dealing
with the same, this Court is also concerned with the alignment over the said
channel. In other words, the primary concern of this Court is regarding the
maintenance of the water supply to the existing tanks while permitting the
respondent No.7 to complete the project.
8. Concept of Development:
This Court is quite conscious of the role to be played by a Court of law
while dealing with the question of preservation of ecology viz-a-viz the
development. A Court of law will have to strike a balance between the
developmental activities by following the principle of sustainable development
as against maintaining the environmental balance. A mere economic criteria or
commercial venture by itself cannot be termed as a sustainable development. A
development will have to satisfy the whole spectrum of civil, cultural,
economic, political and social process for the overall improvement of the
general public. Considering the above definition, we have no doubt in mind that
the project envisaged by the respondent No.7 would certainly amount to a
developmental activity involving sustainable development.
9. Considering the very same issue, it has been held in N.D. Jayal v.
Union of India, (2004) 9 Supreme Court Cases 362 by the Hon'ble Apex Court in
the following manner:
"ASPECTS RELATED TO CONDITIONAL CLEARANCE
22. Before adverting to other issues, certain aspects pertaining to the
preservation of ecology and development have to be noticed. In Vellore Citizens'
Welfare Forum v. Union of India, (1996) 5 SCC 647 and in M.C. Mehta v. Union of
India, (2002) 4 SCC 356 it was observed that the balance between environmental
protection and developmental activities could only be maintained by strictly
following the principle of "sustainable development". This is a development
strategy that caters to the needs of the present without negotiating the ability
of upcoming generations to satisfy their needs. The strict observance of
sustainable development will put us on a path that ensures development while
protecting the environment, a path that works for all peoples and for all
generations. It is a guarantee to the present and a bequeath to the future. All
environment-related developmental activities should benefit more people while
maintaining the environmental balance. This could be ensured only by strict
adherence to sustainable development without which life of the coming
generations will be in jeopardy.
23. In a catena of cases we have reiterated that right to clean environment is a
guaranteed fundamental right. Maybe, in a different context, the right to
development is also declared as a component of Article 21 in cases like Samatha
v. State of A.P. (1997) 8 SCC 191 and in Madhu Kishwar v. State of Bihar, (1996)
5 SCC 125.
24. The right to development cannot be treated as a mere right to economic
betterment or cannot be limited as a misnomer to simple construction activities.
The right to development encompasses much more than economic well-being, and
includes within its definition the guarantee of fundamental human rights. The
"development" is not related only to the growth of GNP. In the classic work,
Development As Freedom, the Nobel prize winner Amartya Sen pointed out that "the
issue of development cannot be separated from the conceptual framework of human
right". This idea is also part of the UN Declaration on the Right to
Development. The right to development includes the whole spectrum of civil,
cultural, economic, political and social process, for the improvement of
peoples' well-being and realization of their full potential. It is an integral
part of human rights. Of course, construction of a dam or a mega project is
definitely an attempt to achieve the goal of wholesome development. Such works
could very well be treated as integral component for development.
25. Therefore, the adherence to sustainable development principle is a sine qua
non for the maintenance of the symbiotic balance between the rights to
environment and development. Right to environment is a fundamental right. On the
other hand, right to development is also one. Here the right to "sustainable
development" cannot be singled out. Therefore, the concept of "sustainable
development" is to be treated as an integral part of "life" under Article 21.
Weighty concepts like intergenerational equity (State of H.P. v. Ganesh Wood
Products, (1995) 6 SCC 363), public trust doctrine (M.C. Mehta v. Kamal Nath,
(1997) 1 SCC 388) and precautionary principle (Vellore Citizens, (1996) 5 SCC
647), which we declared as inseparable ingredients of our environmental
jurisprudence, could only be nurtured by ensuring sustainable development."
Hence, we are of the considered view that the project undertaken by the
respondent No.7 would satisfy the definition of development.
10. Preservation of environment vis-a-vis development:
It is rather settled proposition of law that when a development activity
is pitted against the preservation of environment, the latter would get primacy.
However, efforts should be taken to synchronize both the factors including the
question as to whether the same is likely to have adverse effects on ecology or
not. While doing so, the Courts are duty bound to take into consideration the
relevant materials including the view of the experts. It has been held in Bombay
Dyeing & Mfg. Co. Ltd. (3) v. Bombay Environmental Action Group, (2006) 3 SCC
434 as follows:
"Reduction in green areas vis-.-vis environmental impact assessment
277. While considering the environmental aspect, we must not forget that before
constructions are allowed to be commenced and completed, the exercise for
environmental impact assessment is mandatorily required to be done by the
competent authority. An expert body, albeit within the four corners of the
regulatory provisions, would be entitled to consider the entire question from
the environmental aspect of the matter which would undoubtedly take into
consideration all relevant factors including the question as to whether the same
is likely to have adverse effects on ecology or not. Consideration of ecological
aspects from the court's point of view cannot be one-sided. It depends on the
fact situation in each case. Whereas the court would take a very strict view as
regards setting up of an industry which is of a hazardous nature but such a
strict construction may not be resorted to in the case of town planning. The
counsel before us referred to the decision in Padma v. Hiralal Motilal Desarda,
(2002) 7 SCC 564 wherein it was stated: (SCC p. 586, para 32)
'32. The significance of a development planning cannot therefore be denied.
Planned development is the crucial zone that strikes a balance between the needs
of large-scale urbanisation and individual building. It is the science and
aesthetics of urbanisation as it saves the development from chaos and
uglification. A departure from planning may result in disfiguration of the
beauty of an upcoming city and may pose a threat for the ecological balance and
environmental safeguards.'"
Therefore, the project undertaken by the respondent No.7 being a developmental
project to be implemented by taking note of the environment aspect it cannot be
said that it is totally detrimental to ecology, more so, when an affidavit has
been filed by it accepting to follow the guidelines and opinion provided by the
experts.
11. The effect of Expert Opinion:
In the present case on hand, apart from the opinions relied upon by the
respondent No.7, other opinions have been given by the Chief Engineer, Public
Works Department and the Director, Centre for Water Resource, Anna University,
Chennai. This Court cannot act like an appellate authority to go beyond the said
opinions given by the experts. Further, there is nothing on record to establish
that the said opinion given by the experts are demonstratively wrong. In this
connection it is apposite to refer to the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in
Akhil Bharat Goseva Sangh (3) v. State of A.P., (2006) 4 Supreme Court Cases
162, which is extracted hereunder:
59. The appellant sought to challenge the veracity and correctness of the
figures given in the report of the Central Government as well as in the
quinquennial census. In our view, this submission is devoid of merit. It is now
well settled by various decisions of this Court that the findings of expert
bodies in technical and scientific matters would not ordinarily be interfered
with by the courts in exercise of their power under Article 226 of the
Constitution or by this Court under Article 136 or 32 of the Constitution. For
this proposition, reliance can be placed on the decision of this Court in
Systopic Laboratories (P) Ltd. v. Dr. Prem Gupta, 1994 Supp (1) SCC 160. Paras
19 and 20 of this decision clearly give the answer on the question whether the
findings of the expert body in technical and scientific matters can be
interfered with by the Court either under Article 226 or by this Court under
Article 32 or 136 of the Constitution.
Hence, in view of the said pronouncements of the Hon'ble Apex Court, while
exercising the power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, this Court
cannot ignore or substitute the opinion given by the experts based upon relevant
materials placed before them.
12. Exclusion of lands:
The learned counsel for the petitioner would also contend that in as much
as the proposed alignment crosses through the agricultural lands, the same shall
not be permitted and therefore, suitable direction will have to be given to
respondent No.7 for realignment.
13. We are afraid that the said contention of the learned counsel for the
petitioner cannot be countenanced for more than one reason. The Government of
India while acquiring the lands followed the procedure contemplated under the
National Highways Act, 1956 by calling for objections. Except two objections,
which are pertaining to compensation, no other objections have been raised
inclusive of the objection of the President of the petitioner association. The
lands have been acquired by respondent No.7 and the project has become final.
The petitioner cannot espouse the cause of the individual farmers in a public
interest litigation. Admittedly, the farmers whose lands have been acquired have
not challenged the proceedings. Further, the question of realignment shall not
be ordered by this Court as it is for the 7th respondent to make arrangement
after taking note of the various factors placed before it. The viability and
feasibility of the project done in larger public interest does not warrant any
interference. While considering the issue of public interest and public
importance the Court will have to give preference to it a lesser interest or a
private interest.
14. We have also perused the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court
in Selvakumar v. Union of India, 2011(1) CWC 23. The facts involved therein are
totally different. The Hon'ble Division Bench did not have the reports of the
experts as we have before us. Further, a judgment cannot be read like a statute
as it has to be applied to the facts of the case. Moreover, the issue involved
therein was the preservation of tank, which have been adequately addressed in
the case by the reports furnished by the experts. Therefore, the relief sought
for by the petitioner insofar as realignment over the lands belonged to the
private persons are concerned is liable to be rejected and is accordingly,
rejected.
15. Analysis of the opinions of the Expert:
An affidavit has been filed by the respondent No.7 that the opinion given
by the Chief Engineer, Public Works Department together with the opinion given
by the Director of Centre for Water Resources, Anna University, Chennai would be
applied in letter and spirit. In the opinion given by the Chief Engineer, Public
Works Department, insofar as the alignment of the highway in the tank is
concerned, it has been stated that the said highway should be constructed over
the bridges after providing hydraulic and hydrologic analysis so as to prevent
any obstruction to the inflow and outflow of the tank. Similarly, insofar as the
flow in the supply channel to Kannakkankulam tank is concerned, two options have
been given by the Chief Engineer, Public Works Department. Option 'B' provides
for construction of bridges over the channel after Hydraulic and Hydrologic
analysis to enable the free flow of water. Considering the same, the Director,
Centre for Water Resources, Anna University has also stated that Option 'B' is a
technically feasible proposition. As the respondent No.7 has stated that they
are ready and willing to follow Option 'B' as suggested by the experts and they
would also follow the design of culvert protection provided by the Centre for
Water Resources, Anna University, Chennai, we find no reason to reject the said
statement.
16. Conclusion:
Accordingly, the following directions are issued:
(i) The respondent No.7 is directed to align the highway in the tanks,
namely K.Sathanoor Periakulam and Kannakkankulam by constructing over bridges
after providing appropriate Hydraulic and Hydrologic analysis, so as to prevent
any obstruction to the inflow and outflow of the tanks.
(ii) The respondent No.7 is permitted to follow Option 'B' as suggested by
the Chief Engineer, Public Works Department and the Director, Centre for Water
Resources, Anna University, Chennai by aligning the highway in the supply
channel of Kannakkankulam tank by constructing over bridges after following
appropriate Hydraulic and Hydrologic analysis so as to prevent the obstruction
of inflow and outflow of water.
(iii) The 7th respondent shall comply with the suggestions made by the
Director, Centre for Water Resources, Anna University, Chennai, insofar as the
construction of the over bridges by undertaking appropriate Hydraulic and
Hydrologic analysis.
(iv) The 7th respondent shall not at any cost involve in any activity that
would obstruct the inflow and outflow of water supply in the supply channel or
in the tanks, namely K. Sathanoor Periakulam and Kannakkan Kulam Tanks.
17. With the above directions, the Writ Petition is disposed of. No costs.
Consequently, connected M.P.(MD) No.1 of 2011 is closed.
sj
To
1.Union of India,
Rep. by the Secretary to the Central Government,
Environment Department,
New Delhi.
2.The National High Ways Authority of India,
Rep. by its Chief General Manager,
G-6, 6th Chief General Manager,
New Delhi.
3.The District Collector,
Cantonment,
Trichy - 1,
Tamil Nadu.
4.The District Collector,
Collector Office, Pudukottai.
5.The Chief Engineer,
PWD, Water Resources and Organisation,
Subramaniapuram, Trichy -1,
Tamil Nadu.
6.The Special District Revenue Officer,
Competent Authority of NHAI,
Pudukottai.
7.National Highways Authority of India (NH-67),
Rep. by its Project Director,
No.1, 2nd Floor, Subramaniapuram 3rd Street,
Karaikudi.