Writ Petition is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for the issuance of a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus to call for records relating to the (1) transfer order dated issued by the first respondent in Ref. No. B2/3220/2010 dated 21.01.2010 transferring and allotting petitioner to Forestry ExtensionWing and consequential orders issued by (2) the second respondent in S.O No. 4/2010E dated 25.01.2010 and (3) third respondent in Na.Ka No. Pa1/916/2010 dated 03.02.2010 to quash the same and issue consequential direction to the respondents to allow the petitioner to work at the same place of Sirumalai Range, Dindigul Division.
ORDER
Challenging the orders of transfer and the consequential orders, the petitioner has filed this Writ Petition to quash the same and a further direction to the respondent to allow the petitioner to work at the same place of Sirumalai Range Dindigul Division.
2. The orders, which are under challenge is that the petitioner was transferred from Sirumalai Range, Dindigul Division to forest Extension Wing in the existing vacancy. Secondly, the consequential order of the second respondent, dated 25.01.2010, wherein the petitioner was allotted to Forest Extension Wing and posted him to Ooty Forestry Extension Range of Forestry Extension Division, Krishnagiri. Lastly, the order of the third respondent District Forest Officer, Dindigul, an order relieving the petitioner from the post of Forest Range, Sirumalai Region Dindigul District.
3. According to the petitioner, he was recruited through Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission as Forest Ranger in the year 1984 and posted at Arasu Rubber corporation, Nagercoil from 28.08.1985 Thereafter, he served as Forest Ranger at various ranges and in all wings, i.e Territorial, Plantation, Corporation etc and finally joined at the present place of Sirumalai Range on 15.07.2006 He claims that he is a qualified person to be considered for the post of Assistant Conservator of Forest.
4. While that being the position, he was served with a charge memo under Rule 17(b) of the Tamil Nadu Civil Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules by the Conservator of Forests, Madurai Circle in his letter No. B2/12628/2006 dated 24.07.2009 He challenged the above said charge memo by way of a Writ Petition before this Court in W.P No. 7828 of 2009 and this Court, by an order, dated 23.12.2009, quashed the charge memo issued by the Conservator of Forest, Madurai Circle. Thereafter, the first respondent has issued an order of transfer, transferring the petitioner from Sirumalai Range and posted him to Forest Extension Wing on administrative grounds in the proceedings stated supra.
5. It is his case of the petitioner that the transfer order and other consequential orders were passed with an ulterior motive to cause trouble to him and there is no administrative exigencies as alleged in the impugned order and the order is also passed in the middle of the academic year contrary to the guidelines and orders issued in G.O.Ms No. 10, P & AR Department, dated 07.01.1994, wherein the policy of the Government is that all transfers due shall be effected during the transfer period, namely, the first of April and 30th June, every year. Therefore, he challenged the above orders on the ground that the impugned orders have been passed in the middle of the academic year affecting the promotional opportunity of the petitioner as Assistant Conservator of Forest and also the education of his children and without any administrative exigencies. Therefore, the same have to be quashed.
6. On the above background pleadings, the learned counsel for the petitioner would contend that the children of the petitioner are studying in Kendriya Vidyalaya, Madurai. The petitioner's daughter is doing her eleventh standard and his son is studying in eighth standard respectively. Therefore, the order of transfer made during the middle of the academic year will affect their education. He would also submit that there is no administrative exigencies for making such transfer and in the absence of any complaint against the petitioner, the respondent has issued the order of transfer, which is unsustainable. Therefore, the impugned transfers orders are contrary to the guidelines issued by the government in G.o.Ms No. 10.
7. Per contra, the learned Special Government Pleader appearing for the respondents, on instruction, would submit that there are lot of felling of trees during the period of the petitioner's tenure. Therefore, it is necessitated that the petitioner is to be transferred to some other place on administrative grounds. In the absence of any malafide reasons, this Court would normally interfere in the order of transfer, even if it is made during the academic year.
8. I have heard the submissions made by the learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned Special Government Pleader and perused the materials available on record.
9. In this case, it is seen that the petitioner has been recruited through Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission in the year 1984 and after serving in various places, posted at the present station of Sirumalai range on 15.07.2006 It appears that there was a charge memo and the petitioner challenged the same by way of a Writ Petition in W.P No. 7828 of 2009 and this Court by an order, dated 23.12.2009, quashed the charge memo and thereafter, the first respondent has issued the impugned order of transfer, transferring him to Forest Extension Wing on administrative grounds and subsequently the second respondent issued an order, on 25.01.2010, by allotting the petitioner to Ooty Forest Extension Wing of Forest Extension Division, Krishnagiri. Thereafter, the third respondent passed the relieving order on 03.02.2010
10. It is the cardinal principle that the Court should not interfere with the transfer order is made in public interest and for administrative reasons and unless the transfer orders are made in violation of any mandatory, statutory rule or on the ground of malafide. A Government servant holding a transferable post have no vested right to remain posted at one place or the other, he is liable to be transferred from one place to the other and transfer orders issued by the competent authority do not violate any of his legal rights. Even if a transfer is passed in violation of executive instructions or orders, the Courts ordinarily should not interfere with the order instead affected party should approach the higher authorities in the department. If the courts continue to interfere with day-to-day transfer orders issued by the government and its subordinate authorities, there will be a complete chaos in the administration which would not be possible to public interest.
11. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Director of School Education, Madras and others v. O. Karuppa Thevan and another reported in 1994 Supp (2) SCC 666, held that as and when the matters have come before this Court, normally, this Court hesitant to interfere in the matters of transfer on administrative ground. It is also the settled principle, no law requires an employee to be heard before his transfer when authorities make the transfer for the exigencies of administration. However, when the petitioner's children are studying in school, the transfer should not have been effected during the mid-academic term. Although there is no such rule, in view of the fact that in effecting transfer, the children of an employee studying should be given due weightage, if the exigencies of the service are not urgent.
12. The petitioner also filed an affidavit of undertaking before this Court stating that
“I submit that I undertake to obey the transfer order issued by the first respondent and the other consequential orders issued by the second and third respondents if it is given effect at the end of the academic year i.e, June 2010, in the event if I am not promoted as Assistant Conservator of Forest or my representation to the first respondent does not evoke any favourable orders for my nearby postings”
13. In addition to that the petitioner also filed the certificate showing that his children are studying in Kendriya Vidyalaya, Madurai.
14. In the light of the above undertaking and considering the facts and circumstances of the case and also looking into the balance of convenience, this Writ Petition is disposed of with the following directions:
(i) The first respondent is directed to retain the petitioner till the academic year, namely, 31.05.2010 and thereafter, the order of transfer will be given effect from 01.06.2010
(ii) The petitioner is also directed to join the transferred place with effect from 01.06.2010, except in case of promotion of the petitioner, otherwise he has to adhere to the order of this Court by giving effect to the order of transfer with effect from 01.06.2010
No costs. Consequently connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.
RR
Home