Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — C. Nagappan, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The first respondent (plaintiff) filed O.S. No. 221 of 1994 seeking a decree directing the defendants to pay Rs. 1,83,400/- with interest at 12% per annum and costs. The plaintiff alleged that on 6.6.1992 the second defendant, acting as the power of attorney for the first defendant, entered into a sale agreement to sell the suit property for Rs. 3,50,000/-, received an advance of Rs. 1,50,000/- and agreed to complete the sale within three months (with specified consequences on default). The plaintiff claimed subsequent efforts to get the sale deed registered were fruitless and later learned the property belonged to one Kokilambal, who had executed a prior settlement deed (dated 5.11.1979), and that the defendants (first and second) had no right over the suit property. The plaintiff issued a lawyer's notice dated 28.2.1994; the defendants received it but did not reply or repay the advance.

In the trial, the first defendant remained absent and was set ex parte. The second defendant admitted executing the sale agreement as power of attorney but denied receiving the advance personally, denied the plaintiff's allegations of fraudulent misrepresentation, and contended he acted only within the authority conferred by the power deed. The Trial Court, after framing eight issues and hearing evidence (plaintiff as P.W.1; second defendant as D.W.1), held that the second defendant was liable along with the first defendant and decreed joint and several payment with interest and costs. The second defendant appealed against that judgment and decree.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant (second defendant), being the power agent (agent) of the first defendant (principal), is personally liable to pay the suit claim.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (second defendant)

  • The appellant/agent does not incur personal liability for contracts entered into on behalf of his principal under the principles of contract law, absent any contract to the contrary making him personally liable.
  • There was no specific plea or proof of fraud in the plaint; fraud requires specific pleading and clear proof. In the absence of such, the Trial Court's conclusion that the agent was personally liable is erroneous and unsustainable.
  • Reliance was placed on the Division Bench decision in Pudukottah Textiles Ltd. v. B.R. Adityan, AIR 1976 Mad 341, and on Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act as establishing that an agent is not personally bound or entitled to enforce contracts entered into on behalf of his principal unless there is a contract to the contrary.

Respondent's Arguments (plaintiff / first respondent)

  • The plaintiff dealt directly with the second defendant and had not seen the first defendant; the sale agreement was entered into with the second defendant, and on that basis the Trial Court's finding of liability against the defendants was argued to be just and proper.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pudukottah Textiles Ltd. v. B.R. Adityan, AIR 1976 Mad 341 That, following Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act, an agent is not personally bound by contracts entered into on behalf of his principal and cannot be personally held liable (or enforce) such contracts in the absence of any contract to the contrary or personal benefit/interest; an agent who acted for the principal and did not secure any benefit is not personally liable. The court applied the principle from this decision to the facts: finding that the second defendant acted for and on behalf of the first defendant, received money for and on behalf of the principal, had no personal interest or secured benefit, and that there was no pleading/evidence of fraud or any contract making the agent personally liable. Consequently, the court modified the Trial Court's decree by dismissing the suit as against the second defendant.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by examining the pleadings, the documents and the testimony that were actually before the Trial Court:

  1. Documentary foundation: Exhibit A-1 (sale agreement dated 6.6.1992) showed the sale agreement executed between the plaintiff and the second defendant “as power agent of the first defendant” and acknowledged receipt of Rs. 1,50,000/- as advance. Exhibit A-2 was the registered power deed (dated 13.2.1991) executed by the first defendant in favour of the second defendant empowering sale, mortgage and lease of the suit property.
  2. Evidence and pleadings: The plaintiff's pleadings and oral evidence did not specifically allege misrepresentation or fraud by the defendants; the plaint averred that the defendants' act “amounts to cheat the plaintiff,” but there was neither a clear pleaded case of fraud nor oral testimony establishing fraud. The plaintiff's testimony confirmed that the second defendant acted as power of attorney for the first defendant and that the plaintiff later discovered the property's title issues and sought return of the advance (via Exhibit A-3 notice and Exhibit A-4 acknowledgement).
  3. Second defendant's stance: The second defendant admitted acting as agent, denied receiving the amount personally, and denied any personal liability. He asserted he acted only within the scope of the power deed.
  4. Legal principle: The court relied on the established principle (citing the Division Bench decision and Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act) that an agent is not personally liable for acts done on behalf of his principal where there is no contract making the agent personally liable and where the agent has no personal interest or secured benefit from the transaction.
  5. Application to facts: The recitals in Exhibit A-1 indicated the advance was received for and on behalf of the first defendant. There was no plea or evidence that the second defendant had personal interest or benefit. Because there was no specific pleadings or proof of fraud and no contract making the agent personally liable, the Trial Court's finding that the agent hatched a plan to cheat and was personally liable was not warranted on facts or law.
  6. Conclusion: Applying the precedent and statutory principle, the court concluded the Trial Court erred in decreeing the suit against the agent; the second defendant could not be personally made liable for the suit claim.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appeal is allowed; the judgment and decree of the Trial Court is modified so that the suit as against the second defendant (the agent) is dismissed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The decree against the second defendant is set aside and the suit is dismissed insofar as it was filed against him. The Trial Court's decree stands only as against the first defendant (the principal) as applicable from the Trial Court decision (the opinion modifies the trial decree to dismiss against the agent).
  • Costs: There shall be no order as to costs in the appeal.
  • Precedential effect: The court applied existing law (including the cited Division Bench decision and Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act) to the facts. The opinion does not indicate that it is creating any new legal principle beyond applying settled law; it modifies the Trial Court's decree consistent with that existing principle.

This summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.

    P. Appasamy v. Samy Lourde Joseph & Anr.

    C. Nagappan, J.:— This appeal is preferred against the judgment and decree dated 23.8.1995 made in O.S No. 221 of 1994 on the file of I Additional Subordinate Judge, Pondicherry. The second defendant is the appellant.

    2. The first respondent herein filed the suit seeking for a judgment and decree directing the defendants to pay a sum of Rs. 1,83,400/- to the plaintiff with subsequent interest at the rate of 12% per annum and for costs of the suit.

    3. The case of the plaintiff is that the second defendant, as a power of attorney of first defendant, has entered into a sale agreement with the plaintiff on 6.6.1992 to sell the suit property for a sum of Rs. 3,50,000/- and on the date of the sale agreement, the second defendant received advance amount of Rs. 1,50,000/- and further agreed to complete the sale within three months, failing which, he agreed to repay the advance amount in double and the plaintiff has to lose the advance amount if the default is on his part. It is further stated by the plaintiff that he made several efforts by approaching the second defendant to register the sale deed and that efforts became fruitless and the plaintiff came to know that the suit property belonged to one Kokilambal and she had executed a settlement deed on 5.11.1979 in favour of S.P Poyyathappan alias Appan and Manoranjithammal and the defendants 1 and 2 have no right over the suit property. According to the plaintiff, the first defendant, without any title or right over the suit property, executed a power deed in favour of second defendant in respect of the suit property and, in turn, the second defendant executed the sale agreement in favour of the plaintiff and the act of the defendants amounts to cheat the plaintiff and the plaintiff issued lawyer's notice on 28.2.1994 and though the defendants received the notice, they did not send any reply or repaid the advance amount and hence the suit.

    4. The first defendant remained absent and was set ex parte.

    5. The second defendant, in his written statement, has admitted that he, as power of attorney of the first defendant, entered into a sale agreement with the plaintiff on 6.6.1992 and agreed to sell the suit property for a sum of Rs. 3,50,000/-, but has denied that he received advance amount of Rs. 1,50,000/- and agreed to complete the sale agreement within three months and he has further denied the plaint averment that the plaintiff has made several efforts to get the sale deed registered and they became fruitless. The second defendant has also denied the plaint averment that the suit property belonged to one Kokilambal who had executed a settlement deed in favour of two persons and the defendants have no right over the suit property. According to the second defendant, the first defendant executed the power deed in favour of the second defendant in respect of the suit property and, in turn, he executed the sale agreement in favour of the plaintiff and according to him, he never personally received a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- as advance and he acted only on the direction of the first defendant and within the scope of the power deed executed by the first defendant. The second defendant has further denied that the act of the defendants amounts to cheat the plaintiff. It is further stated by the second defendant that the sale agreement was entered into by him only on behalf of the first defendant and not in any of his personal capacity and he has not received any consideration from the plaintiff and therefore he is not having any personal liability in the sale agreement and it will not bind the second defendant personally.

    6. The Trial Court framed eight issues and the plaintiff examined himself as P.W.1 and marked Exhibits A1 to A4 on his side and the second defendant examined himself as D.W 1 and no document was marked on their side. On a consideration of oral and documentary evidence, the Trial Court held that the second defendant is also liable along with the first defendant for the suit claim and granted a decree directing the defendants to pay jointly and severally the suit amount with interest at 12% per annum and costs. Aggrieved by the same, the second defendant has preferred the present appeal.

    7. The second respondent/first defendant, though served in the appeal, does not appear in person or through Counsel and her name is printed in the cause list. For the sake of convenience, in this judgment, the parties are referred to as arrayed in the suit.

    8. The point for determination in the appeal is as to whether the appellant, being the power agent of the first defendant, is not liable to pay the suit claim.

    Point:

    9. The learned Counsel for the appellant submits that the Trial Court has failed to note that under the principles of contract law, the appellant/agent does not carry any personal liability for the transaction entered into by him for his principal and in the absence of any plea of fraud, which requires specific pleading and clear proof, the conclusion of the Trial Court that the second defendant, as a power agent, is also personally liable to return the advance amount paid by the plaintiff, is erroneous and unsustainable in law and in support of his submission, he relies on a decision of the Division Bench of this Court in Pudukottah Textiles Ltd. v. B.R Adityan, AIR 1976 Mad 341.

    10. Per contra, the learned Counsel for the first respondent submits that the plaintiff has not seen the first defendant and has entered into the sale agreement only with the second defendant, who is the appellant herein and the conclusion of the Trial Court that the defendants are liable for the suit claim, is just and proper.

    11. Exhibit A-1 is the sale agreement, dated 6.6.1992, entered into between the plaintiff and the second defendant as power agent of the first defendant with regard to the suit property agreeing to sell the same for a consideration of Rs. 3,50,000/- and acknowledging the receipt of a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- as advance from the plaintiff. Exhibit A-2 is the registration certificate of power deed, dated 13.2.1991, executed by the first defendant in favour of the second defendant empowering the second defendant to sell, mortgage and lease the suit property. It is not in dispute that the second defendant executed Exhibit A-1 sale agreement as power of attorney of the first defendant in favour of the plaintiff. The specific case of the plaintiff is that his efforts to obtain a sale deed for the suit property from the defendants became fruitless and he has sought for return of the advance amount paid together with interest in the suit.

    12. The first defendant remained absent and was set ex parte in the suit.

    13. The second defendant contended that Exhibit A-1 sale agreement was entered into by him with the plaintiff only on behalf of the first defendant and he has not received any amount personally and he is not having any personal liability for the suit claim. There is no allegation of fraud made by the plaintiff in the plaint and he has only stated that the act of the defendants amounts to cheat the plaintiff. The plaintiff examined himself as P.W.1 and in his testimony, he has only stated that the second defendant has entered into Exhibit A-1 sale agreement with him as power of attorney of the first defendant and the plaintiff came to know that the suit property does not belong to first defendant and it is originally owned by one, Kokilambal and he asked for return of the advance amount from the defendants and that was not given, pursuant to which, he issued Exhibit A-3 Advocate's notice dated 28.2.1994 and the same was received by the defendants as evidenced by Exhibit A-4 postal acknowledgement. There is no allegation of any misrepresentation made by the defendants in the plaint averments and the plaintiff in his oral testimony also does not say so. In such circumstances, the finding of the Trial Court that the first defendant, as principal and the second defendant, as agent, hatched a plan to cheat the plaintiff, is not warranted either on facts or in law and cannot be sustained.

    14. The second defendant, when he acted as agent, obviously had the implied authority to act for the first defendant in the matter of the sale of the suit property. It is not the case of the plaintiff that there was any contract making the second defendant, as agent, personally liable for honouring the sale agreement and executing the sale deed. As per the recitals in Exhibit A-1 sale agreement, the second defendant has received the advance amount for and on behalf of the first defendant. There is neither plea nor evidence that the second defendant had any personal interest or secured a benefit under the sale agreement. In such circumstances, the contention of the learned Counsel for the appellant that the plaintiff could only obtain the relief as against the first defendant, who is the principal and not against the second defendant, who is an agent of the first defendant/principal, is well founded. The Division Bench, in the decision referred above, has laid down the law in clear terms and the same is extracted below for better appreciation:

    “7……….It is a well established principle of law that qui facit per alium facitper se, he who acts through another, acts for himself. In the instant case, the company acted through its director-in-charge. Virtually, therefore it was the incorporated company, who was facting for itself, though in the garb of its Agent or Director-in-charge, namely the second defendant. In such circumstances, Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act makes it clear that in the absence of any contract to that effect an agent cannot personally enforce contracts entered into by him on behalf of his principal, nor is he personally bound by them. The learned Counsel for the respondents was unable to refer to us any contract to the contrary in the instant case whereby the second defendant took over for himself the personal responsibility of honouring or executing the so-called contract in the suit. In the absence of any such contract, an agent cannot be personally bound by all such acts done by him for and on behalf of his principal. In the case under consideration, the second defendant received the advance, for and on behalf of the first defendant, but mistakenly encashed it prematurely without adverting to the fact whether a contract has been fully forged or concluded as between the parties. It is common ground, that the cheque was issued in the name of the Pudukkottah Textiles Limited. The moneys went to the benefit of the first defendant. The second defendant obviously acted for and on behalf of the first defendant and did not receive any benefit from the so-called contract. In these circumstances, we agree with the learned Counsel for the appellant that the plaintiff could only obtain relief as against the first defendant who is the principal in the bargain and not as against the second defendant, who is an agent to such a principal. Following the well known principle laid down in Section 230 of the Contract Act as also the accepted law that an agent is not personally liable for the acts done by him for and on behalf of his principal and in which he had no interest or secured a benefit, we are of the view that the learned trial Judge was wrong in having decreed the suit against both the dafendants. In these circumstances, we modify the decree of the trial Court and decree the suit as against the first defendant with costs. Insofar as the suit against the second defendant is concerned, it is dismissed, but there will be no order as to costs.”

    15. The above decision applies in all fours to the facts of the present case. The second defendant obviously acted for and on behalf of the first defendant and he cannot be personally made liable for the suit claim as per the principle laid down in Section 230 of the Contract Act. The conclusion of the Trial Court that the second defendant is also liable for the suit claim, is erroneous in law and liable to be set aside. The Point is determined accordingly.

    16. The appeal is allowed and the judgment and decree of the Trial Court is modified to the effect that the suit as against the second defendant shall stand dismissed. However, there shall be no order as to costs in the appeal.

    17. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P. Appasamy v. Samy Lourde Joseph & Anr.
    (Feb 8, 2008)