Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 34 and 35 of the Registration Act, 1908 and Rule 55 of the Registration Rules
  • Registration Act, 1908, and the Registration rules
  • Order 6, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. (b)
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act
  • Sections 41, 43, 45, 69, 75, 77, 88 and 89,
  • (2) Appearances under sub-section (1)
  • SECTION 23 CONTRACT ACT
  • REGISTRATION ACT 1908
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 34 and 35 of the Registration Act, 1908 and Rule 55 of the Registration Rules
  • Registration Act, 1908, and the Registration rules
  • Order 6, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. (b)
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act
  • Sections 41, 43, 45, 69, 75, 77, 88 and 89,
  • (2) Appearances under sub-section (1)
  • SECTION 23 CONTRACT ACT
  • REGISTRATION ACT 1908
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners filed a Writ Petition under Article 226 seeking issuance of a writ of Certiorarified Mandamus to quash an order dated 5.8.2004 (Na.Ka.A4.4068/2002) of the third respondent and Memorandum No. 433/2004 dated 8.9.2004 of the second respondent, and to direct the second respondent to register sale deeds relating to plots in S. No. 161/1, Keelkuppam Village, Arakkonam Taluk.

Key factual chronology contained in the opinion (as stated):

  • 1923: Lands (7.09 acres) in S. No. 161/1 were assigned to one Rosikhan under DKT 492/23 dated 28.12.1923 (assignment allegedly with conditions including a 10-year restriction on sale/mortgage).
  • 1951: Rosikhan sold the lands to Thaikhan by registered sale deed dated 15.2.1951 (Document No. 517).
  • 1956: Thaikhan sold the lands to Benjamin and M.I. Jacob by registered sale deed dated 7.6.1956 (Document No. 2170).
  • 1988: Benjamin released rights in favour of Mathew by release deed dated 6.5.1988; Mathew and his brother Jacob were in possession and a joint patta (No. 350) was granted; revenue records (Chitta and Adangal) recorded their names.
  • 1989: Family arrangement — Jacob settled half his share to Geetha Mathews by settlement deed dated 29.3.1989; resulting shares described for the petitioners.
  • 2002: Petitioners executed a power of attorney in favour of P. Dhanapal who prepared a layout, obtained approvals and a letter from the Block Development Officer directing gift of road/park areas to the Panchayat; a gift deed was executed on 9.5.2002 and a No Objection Certificate for sale of plots was granted by the Panchayat President on 3.7.2002. Six plots were sold between 13.3.2002 and 13.12.2002.
  • 2003: Third respondent issued a notice dated 20.10.2003 alleging the original assignment was to a Scheduled Caste person (Rosikhan) and that sales to persons of other communities violated assignment conditions; the second petitioner was called upon to show cause. A reply was submitted contesting the allegation, asserting that the sales occurred long after the 10-year period and that there was no conditional assignment in the records. The second respondent instructed the Sub-Registrar not to register the sale deeds; the Sub-Registrar reportedly insisted on production of Adi-Dravidar community certificates by purchasers. Tahsildar issued a letter on 4.3.2003 to the second respondent (copy to the third) seeking clarification and directing not to register sale deeds to non-Adi-Dravidar persons.
  • 2003 (procedural): A prior Writ Petition (W.P. No. 27702 of 2003) was dismissed by this Court on 7.10.2003 on the ground that an inter-departmental communication cannot be challenged.
  • 2004: Fifteen sale deeds were registered by the second respondent at some point; the third respondent issued a further notice on 20.3.2004 proposing an enquiry; by letter dated 5.8.2004 the third respondent stated the lands were assigned to Rosikhan (Adi-dravidar) with conditions prohibiting sale to other communities and contended agricultural lands should not be converted into layouts, indicating steps to cancel the assignment. The impugned order and memorandum (5.8.2004; 8.9.2004) effectively prevented registration of sale deeds presented on behalf of the petitioners.
  • Court hearing: Learned counsel for petitioners and respondents were heard.
  • Relief sought: Quash the impugned administrative orders and direct registration of sale deeds by the second respondent.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the refusal by the registering authorities (and the impugned administrative orders dated 5.8.2004 and memorandum dated 8.9.2004) to register the sale deeds was made in accordance with the powers and procedure prescribed under the Registration Act, 1908 and the Registration Rules.
  2. Whether registration of the documents could be refused on the ground that registration would be "opposed to public policy" (including reliance on notifications under Section 22-A of the Registration Act) or on the basis of alleged violations of conditions of the original assignment.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The property history shows assignments and subsequent sales culminating in the petitioners' possession, with pattas issued and names entered in revenue records (Chitta and Adangal).
  • The sales and development (layout) were undertaken lawfully after the relevant restriction period (petitioners emphasised that sale occurred after 27 years, so the alleged 10-year restriction had lapsed).
  • Approvals for the layout were obtained from the Block Development Officer and the President of the Panchayat; gift deed for public areas was executed as directed; a No Objection Certificate was granted; multiple plots were sold.
  • The petitioners contended there was no conditional assignment recorded in the revenue records as alleged by the respondents.
  • The petitioners placed reliance on (i) R. Ramanathan and others v. The State of Tamil Nadu and another (1997 (2) MLJ 406) — for estoppel against resumption where purchasers had developed the land and substantial time had passed; and (ii) State of Rajasthan and others v. Basant Nahata (2005 (4) CTC 606; AIR 2005 SC 3401) — on the limits of invoking public policy and the parameters for refusal to register under Section 22-A and Section 23 of the Contract Act as explained by the Supreme Court.
  • The petitioners relied on statutory provisions of the Registration Act: Sections 34 and 35, Rule 55 of the Registration Rules, and Section 22-A (on documents registration of which is opposed to public policy) to argue that the Registering Officer's powers and duties are circumscribed and that objections to registration must fall within specified grounds and procedure.

Respondents' Position (as stated in the opinion)

  • The third respondent issued notices alleging that the lands were originally assigned to Rosikhan, a person belonging to the Adi-dravidar (Scheduled Caste) community, and that sales in favour of persons belonging to other communities violated the conditions of assignment; an enquiry was proposed and steps to cancel the assignment were indicated.
  • The second respondent issued instructions (memorandum) to the Sub-Registrar not to register sale deeds in respect of the said lands, and the Sub-Registrar reportedly required production of Adi-Dravidar community certificates from purchasers.
  • Administrative action taken by respondents rested on the contention that registration should be refused because the documents were opposed to public policy and/or violated conditions of original assignment (as reflected in the notices and instructions recited in the opinion).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R. Ramanathan and others v. The State of Tamil Nadu and another, 1997 (2) MLJ 406 Principle that proceedings for resumption/resumption-type action can be barred by estoppel where purchasers had purchased earlier, pattas issued and lands developed by investing substantial money (court in that case held the Government proceedings initiated after long delay were barred by estoppel). The petitioners' counsel relied upon this decision in support of the contention that the petitioners' development and long possession should preclude resumption; the opinion records that reliance but does not elaborate further application beyond noting the reliance.
State of Rajasthan and others v. Basant Nahata, 2005 (4) CTC 606 : AIR 2005 SC 3401 Elucidation of the doctrine of public policy as a defence (Section 23 of Indian Contract Act) and guidance on when executive action/refusal to register pursuant to public policy (including notifications under Section 22-A of the Registration Act) can be upheld; noted limits on reopening refusals to register made under Section 22-A in certain contexts. The petitioners' counsel relied on this Supreme Court decision; the opinion quotes and discusses its principles on public policy and registration, and the decision was considered in the court's assessment of whether registration could be refused as contrary to public policy.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis (as stated in the opinion) proceeded along the following lines:

  1. The court observed that the impugned administrative orders (the third respondent's order dated 5.8.2004 and the second respondent's memorandum dated 8.9.2004) had been passed without properly advertence to the powers vested in the Registering Authorities by the Registration Act, 1908 and the Registration Rules framed thereunder.
  2. The learned Government Advocate for the respondents was unable to demonstrate that the powers exercised by the Registering Authorities were exercised in accordance with the Registration Act and the Registration Rules.
  3. The court noted that it had not been shown how or for what reasons the Registering Authority had refused to register the documents presented on behalf of the petitioners. The opinion emphasised that it is for the respondents to show that registration would be contrary to public policy or would violate applicable legal provisions.
  4. Given the absence of any demonstration by the respondents that registration would be contrary to public policy or otherwise unlawful, the court held that the respondents could not refuse to register the documents submitted on behalf of the petitioners.
  5. On that basis, the court concluded that the impugned order and memorandum must be set aside and that the second respondent should be directed to register the sale deeds presented on behalf of the petitioners.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Writ Petition was allowed. The court set aside the impugned order dated 5.8.2004 passed by the third respondent in Na.Ka.A4 4068/2002 and the Memorandum No. 433/2004 dated 8.9.2004 issued by the second respondent. The second respondent was directed to register the sale deeds submitted on behalf of the petitioners in respect of S. No. 161/1, Keelkuppam Village, Arakonam Taluk, Vellore District. No costs were awarded.

Implications: The direct practical effect of the decision is that the administrative obstacles (the impugned order and memorandum) preventing registration of the petitioners' sale deeds were removed, and the registering authority was ordered to effect registration of the sale deeds. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond its application to the facts of this case; it primarily enforces the requirement that refusal to register must be shown to be in accordance with the Registration Act, the Registration Rules, or validly justified as being opposed to public policy.

    M.L. Mathews v. Inspector General Of Registration

    The Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying to issue a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus as stated therein.

    JUDGMENT

    1. The Writ Petition has been filed praying for the issuance of a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus to call for the records relating to the order, dated 5.8.2004, Na.Ka.A4.4068/2002 of the third respondent and the memorandum No. 433/2004, dated 8.9.2004, of the second respondent and quash the same and consequently direct the second respondent to register the sale deeds in respect of the plots in S. No. 161/1, Keelkuppam Village, Arakonam Taluk.

    2. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners as well as for the respondents.

    3. It is submitted on behalf of the petitioners that the lands of an extent of 7.09 acres situated at S. No. 161/1 in Keelkuppam Village, Arakkonam Taluk, was assigned in favour of one Rosikhan, son of Sivaramulu, in the year 1923, under DKT 492/23, dated 28.12.1923 The said lands were assigned to him as he was a landless poor person under Dharkast rules with certain terms and conditions including that he should not sell or mortgage the said lands for a period of 10 years from the date of assignment. Following the assignment, the lands were being cultivated by Rosikhan, who was in possession and enjoyment of the same. In the year 1951, he had sold the lands to one Thaikhan under a registered Sale Deed, dated 15.2.1951, under Document No. 517. Subsequently, Thaikhan had sold the lands to Benjamin son of Maran and M.I Jacob son of Mallath, by a registered Sale Deed, dated 7.6.1956, under Document No. 2170. The said Benjamin had released his rights over the lands in favour of Mathew under a release deed, dated 6.5.1988, and from the date of the release deed, the said Mathew has been in possession and enjoyment of the lands along with his brother Jacob. It has been further submitted that a joint patta had been granted in favour of Mathew and Jacob under patta No. 350. The names were also entered in all the revenue records, including the Chitta and Adangal. Subsequently, a family arrangement had taken place by which Jacob had settled half of his share in the property to his brother's daughter Geetha Mathews, by a settlement deed, dated 29.3.1989 Thus, the first Petitioner became entitled to half share and the second and third Petitioners were entitled to one fourth share each in the property in S. No. 161/3, to an extent of 7.09 acres.

    4. The petitioners, who are the owners of the above mentioned lands, had executed a power of attorney in favour of one P. Dhanapal, son of Poongavanam, who has filed the affidavit in support of the present Writ Petition on behalf of the petitioners. The said P. Dhanapal, with an intention to develop the lands, had formed a lay out and submitted the plan for approval to the Block Development Officer, Arakonam, on 2.5.2002 The Block Development Officer, Arakonam, by a letter, dated 7.5.2002, had directed P. Dhanapal to approach the President of the concerned Panchayat and he was also directed to execute a gift deed in favour of the Panchayat for the areas earmarked as road, park and public places, etc. Accordingly, P. Dhanapal had executed the gift deed in favour of the Panchayat, on 9.5.2002 Thereafter, the layout was approved and a ‘No Objection Certificate’ was also granted, for the sale of the plots by the President of the Panchayat, on 3.7.2002 Thereafter, six plots were sold to several persons, from 13.03.2002 to 13.12.2002 While so, the third respondent had issued a notice, dated 20.10.2003, alleging that the lands S. No. 161/1 were assigned to a Schedule Caste person by name Rosikhan and the sale in favour of persons belonging to the other communities was against the conditions under which the original assignment had been made. Hence, the second petitioner was called upon to show cause as to why her sale deed should not be canceled. The second petitioner was given 15 days time to show cause stating that if she failed to do so, a final order would be passed. On receipt of the said notice, a detailed reply was sent narrating all the facts and pointing out that the sale was made only after a period of 27 years and therefore, there was no violation of the conditions of the assignment, as alleged in the notice. It was also stated that the lay out was approved and transactions were also made in respect of the said lands and there was no dispute in that regard. Further, on a perusal of the records, it was clear that there was no conditional assignment of the lands in S. No. 161/1 said to have been made in favour of Rosikhan. Even though there were no further communications from the third respondent, the second respondent had issued instructions to the Sub-Registrar, Arakonam, not to register the sale deeds in respect of the said lands. Therefore, the Sub-Registrar, Arakonam, had refused to register the Sale Deed and he had insisted that those who were purchasing house plots in S. No. 161/1 should produce Adi-Dravidar Community Certificates with the intention of avoiding persons belonging to other communities from purchasing the house sites. Accordingly, the Tahsildar, Arakonam, had issued a letter, dated 4.3.2003, to the second respondent marking a copy to the third respondent, directing them not to register any sale deed to any person not belonging to Adi-dravidar community and had called for further clarifications in that regard.

    5. A Writ Petition filed before this Court, in W.P No. 27702 of 2003, was dismissed by an order, dated 7.10.2003, wherein it was stated that an inter-departmental communication cannot be challenged. Thereafter, a detailed representation was sent to the first respondent requesting him to issue necessary instructions to the third respondent not to insist on the production of community certificates by the intending purchasers. It was also requested that the third respondent should be directed to register the sale deeds relating to the said lands. Thereafter, 15 sale deeds were registered by the second respondent. While so, on 20.3.2004, the third respondent had issued a notice referring to the earlier notice, dated 20.10.2003, and without referring to the reply issued to the said notice, stating that the enjoyment of the lands in S. No. 161/1 assigned in favour of Rosikhan is in violation of the conditions of assignment. By the said notice, an enquiry was proposed to be held. By a letter, dated 5.8.2004, the third respondent had stated that the lands were assigned in favour of the Rosikhan belonging to Adi-dravidar Community with certain conditions. As per the said conditions, it should not be sold to persons belonging to other communities. Further, as per Government Orders, agricultural lands should not be converted into lay outs. Due to the violations of the conditions, steps were being taken to cancel the assignment. Further, due to the impugned order, dated 5.8.2004, passed by the third respondent in Na.Ka.A4 4068 of 2002 and the Memorandum No. 433/2004, dated 8.9.2004, issued by the second respondent, the petitioners were not able to register any sale deeds through their power of attorney-P. Dhanapal.

    6. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioners has placed reliance on an order of this Court in R. Ramanathan and others v. The State of Tamil Nadu and another, 1997 (2) MLJ 406, wherein it was held that the petitioners therein had purchased the lands in the year 1973, and the pattas were also issued with regard to the said lands and the lands were developed by investing substantial money. Therefore, the proceedings by the Government initiated in the year 1987, for resumption of the lands, were held to be barred by estoppel.

    7. The learned counsel appearing for the Petitioners had relied on the decision of the Supreme Court in State of Rajasthan and others v. Basant Nahata, 2005 (4) CTC 606: AIR 2005 SC 3401, where in it has been held as follows:

    “Public policy is not capable of being given a precise definition. What is ‘opposed to public policy’ would be a matter depending upon the nature of the transaction. The pleadings of the parties and the materials brought on record would be relevant so as to enable the Court to judge the concept as to what is for public good or in the public interest or what would be injurious or harmful to the public good or the public interest at the relevant point of time as contra-distinguished from the policy of a particular Govt. A law dealing with the rights of a citizen is required to be clear and unambiguous. Doctrine of public policy is contained in a branch of common law, it is governed by precedents. The principles have been crystallized under different heads and though it may be possible for the Courts to expound and apply them to different situations but it is trite that the said doctrine should not be taken recourse to in ‘clear and incontestable cases of harm to the public though the heads are not closed and though theoretically it may be permissible to evolve a new head under exceptional circumstances of a changing world.’

    A contract being ‘opposed to public policy’ is a defence under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act and the Courts while deciding the validity of a contract has to consider: (a) Pleadings in terms of Order 6, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. (b) Statute governing the case (c) Provisions of Parts III and IV of the Constitution of India (d) Expert evidence, if any (e) The materials brought on record of the case (f) Other relevant factors, if any. It becomes amply clear that it is not possible to define public policy with precision at any point of time. It is not for the executive to fill these grey areas as the said power rests with judiciary. Whenever interpretation of the concept ‘public policy’ is required to be considered it is for the judiciary to do so and in doing so even the power of the judiciary is very limited. Even for the said purpose, the part dealing with public policy in Section 23 of the Contract Act is required to be construed in conjunction with other parts thereof.”

    However, after discussing all the relevant aspects of the case the Supreme Court had finally stated.

    “so far as amendments made by other States are concerned, we are of the opinion that any order passed by a Sub-Registrar or Registrar refusing to register a document pursuant to any notification issued under Section 22-A of the Act would not be re-opened.”

    It has been pointed out by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioners that Section 34 and 35 of the Registration Act, 1908 and Rule 55 of the Registration Rules are relevant for the present case. They read as follows:

    Section 34. Enquiry before registration by registering officer — (1) Subject to the provisions contained in this Part and in Sections 41, 43, 45, 69, 75, 77, 88 and 89, no document shall be registered under this Act, unless the persons executing such document, [and in the case of document for sale of property, the persons claiming under that document] or their representatives, assigns or agents authorised as aforesaid, appear before the registering officer within the time, allowed for presentation under Sections 23, 24, 25 and 26:

    Provided that, if owing to urgent necessity or unavoidable accident all such persons do not so appear, the Registrar, in cases where the delay in appearing does not exceed four months, may direct that no payment of a fine not exceeding ten times the amount of the proper registration fee, in addition to the fine, if any, payable under Section 25, the document may be registered.

    (2) Appearances under sub-section (1) may be simultaneous or at different times.

    (3) The registering officer shall thereupon —

    (a) enquire whether or not such document was executed by the persons by whom it purports to have been executed;

    (b) satisfy himself as to the identity of the persons appearing before him and alleging that they have executed the document [or they are claiming under the document]; and

    (c) in the case of any person appearing as a representative, assign or agent, satisfy himself of the right of such person so to appear.

    (4) Any Application for a direction under the Proviso to sub-section (1) may be lodged with a Sub-Registrar, who shall forthwith forward it to the Registrar to whom he is subordinate.

    (5) Nothing in this Section applies to copies of decrees or orders.

    Section 35. Procedure on admission and denial of execution respectively.— (1)

    (a) If all the persons executing the document appear personally before the Registering Officer and are personally known to him, or if he be otherwise satisfied that they are the person they represent themselves to be, and if they all admit the execution of the document, or

    (b) if in the case of any person appearing by, a representative, assign or agent, such representative, assign or agent admits the execution, or

    (c) if the person executing the document is dead, and his representative or assign appears before The Registering Officers and admits the execution, the Registering Officer shall register the document as directed in sections 58 to 61, inclusive.

    (2) The Registering Officer may, in order to satisfy himself that the persons appearing before him are the persons they represent themselves to be, or for any other purpose contemplated by this Act, examine any one present in his office.

    (3) (a) If any person by whom the document purports to be executed denies its execution, or

    (b) If any such person appears to the Registering Officer to be a minor, an idiot or a lunatic, or

    (c) If any person by whom the document purports to be executed is dead, and his representative or assign denies its execution,

    the registering officer shall refuse to register the document as to the persons so denying, appearing or dead; Provided that, where such officer is a Registrar, he shall follow the procedure prescribed in Part XII:

    [Provided further that the State Government may by notification in the Official Gazette, declare that any Sub-Registrar named in the notification shall, in respect of documents the execution of which is denied, be deemed to be a Registrar for the purpose of this sub-section and of Part XII.]

    Rule 55. It forms no part of a registering officer's duty to enquire into the validity of a document brought to him for registration or to attend to any written or verbal protest against the registration of a document based on the ground that the executing party had no right to execute the document; but he is bound to consider objections raised on any of the grounds stated below:

    “(a) that the parties appearing or about to appear before him are not the persons they profess to be;

    (b) that the document is forged;

    (c) that the person appearing as a representative, assign or agent, has no right to appear in that capacity;

    (d) that the executing party is not really dead, as alleged by the party applying for registration; or

    (e) that the executing party is a minor or an idiot or a lunatic.”

    “Section 22-A. Documents registration of which is opposed to public policy. — (1) The State Government may, by notification in the Tamil Nadu Government Gazette, declare that the registration of any document or class of documents is opposed to public policy.

    (2) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, the Registering Officer shall refuse to register any document to which a notification issued under sub-section (1) is applicable.

    8. It is seen that the impugned orders have been passed without adverting to the powers vested in the Registering Authorities under the Registration Act, 1908. The learned Government Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondents is not in a position to show that the powers have been exercised by the Registering Authorities only in accordance with the Registration Act, 1908, and the Registration rules framed thereunder. Further it has also not been shown as to how or for what reasons the Registering Authority has refused to register the documents submitted on behalf of the petitioners. It is for the respondents to show that such registration would be contrary to public policy and would be in violation of the provisions of law applicable to the case. In the absence of such violation, the respondents cannot refuse to register the documents submitted on behalf of the petitioners. Therefore, the Writ Petition is allowed, setting aside the impugned order, dated 5.8.2004, passed by the third respondent in Na.Ka.A4 4068/2002 and the memorandum No. 433/2004, dated 8.9.2004, issued by the second respondent. Consequently, the second respondent is directed to register the sale deeds submitted on behalf of the petitioners in respect of S. No. 161/1, Keelkuppam Village, Arakonam Taluk, Vellore District. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M.L. Mathews v. Inspector General Of Registration
    (Jan 29, 2007)