Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Order 9, Rule 13, CPC.6.
  • Order 9, Rule 13, CPC.(d)
  • Order 9, Rule 13, CPC
  • Order 9, Rule 13
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Order 9, Rule 13, CPC.6.
  • Order 9, Rule 13, CPC.(d)
  • Order 9, Rule 13, CPC
  • Order 9, Rule 13
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals arise from two Civil Miscellaneous Appeals challenging decretal orders dated 23.01.2007 which dismissed petitions (I.A. Nos. 151 & 152 of 2006) filed under Order 9, Rule 13, CPC to set aside ex parte decrees entered on 18.10.2005. The respondents had filed O.S. No. 1 of 2005 and O.S. No. 2 of 2005 claiming sums of Rs. 5,41,030.88 and Rs. 45,23,815.24 respectively with 18% interest and costs. The defendants (now appellants) were absent on 18.10.2005; the suits were decreed ex parte.

To vacate the ex parte decrees the appellants filed I.A. Nos. 151 and 152 of 2005 under Order 9, Rule 13, CPC, stating in affidavits that they were bed-ridden with severe fever and diarrhoea from 16.10.2005 to 25.10.2005 and could not attend court or instruct counsel; they asserted the absence was not wilful. The respondents opposed the applications, alleging mala fides and falsehood in the affidavits.

The Trial Court, by orders dated 11.09.2006, found sufficient cause to set aside the ex parte decrees but imposed conditions: the appellants were directed to deposit costs of Rs. 44,573.25 and Rs. 3,71,175/- respectively on or before 04.10.2006, failing which the petitions would stand dismissed. The Trial Court repeatedly posted the matter and on 23.01.2007 dismissed the petitions for non-production of the High Court order and non-deposit of costs. The defendants challenged that order by filing the present Civil Miscellaneous Appeals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the discretion exercised by the Trial Court in setting aside the ex parte decrees but imposing onerous conditions (deposit of specified costs) as a pre-condition for restoration is sustainable under Order 9, Rule 13, CPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants averred by affidavit that they were laid up with severe fever and diarrhoea from 16.10.2005 to 25.10.2005 and were bed-ridden; hence they could not attend court on 18.10.2005 nor instruct their counsel. The absence was not wilful or deliberate.
  • Implicit in the appeal is a contention that the Trial Court's condition to deposit large costs as prerequisite to restoration was onerous and unjust in the circumstances of illness preventing attendance.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents/plaintiffs resisted the applications, contending that the petitions to set aside the ex parte decrees were filed with mala fide intention to delay execution of the decrees and that the reasons stated in the appellants' affidavits were false.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Krishna Rice Mills v. P. Rajagopala Konar, AIR 1958 Mad. 522 When setting aside an ex parte decree, costs may be awarded to compensate the respondent for time, money and energy wasted; suit restored for fresh disposal. This authority was cited to show that modest compensatory costs and restoration are an appropriate remedy rather than imposition of onerous conditions.
Dhanalakshmi Ammal v. Shanbagalakshmi Ammal, 1965 (1) MLJ 209 A condition imposed to deposit costs to hear application to set aside ex parte decree was held erroneous; restoration conditions must be just and reasonable. Cited to support the proposition that conditional orders for restoration must be reasonable and not arbitrary.
Nanak Chand v. Goswami Preetam Lal, AIR 1972 All. 166 (following Ahmad Hussain v. Har Dayal, AIR 1926 All. 142) An order restoring the case subject to payment of a reasonable amount of costs to the opposite party can be passed under Order 9, Rule 13, CPC. Referenced to show that reasonable costs may be imposed but the reasonableness of the amount is critical.
Foundation Overseas Ltd. v. Punjab National Bank Ltd., AIR 1977 Cal. 428 A direction to restore a suit which was dismissed for default to furnish security as a condition precedent was held not valid. Used to support the proposition that certain onerous conditional prerequisites (such as furnishing security) are invalid.
Raj Kumar Soni v. M/s. Mohan Meakin Breweries Ltd., AIR 1979 All. 370 Direction to deposit one-fifth of suit amount as condition precedent to set aside ex parte decree held illegal even where sufficient cause was found. Cited as authority that substantial monetary preconditions may be illegal despite a finding of sufficient cause.
LIC of India v. Anjan Kumar, AIR 1987 Cal. 197 While setting aside an ex parte decree, any condition imposed must be reasonable and justified by attending circumstances and not arbitrary. Supported the court's insistence that conditions must be reasonable and have justification.
Kumud Lata Das v. Indu Prasad, 1996 (7) Scale 410 (Supreme Court) The Supreme Court cancelled a direction to pay mesne profits as a condition precedent for setting aside an ex parte decree. Cited to demonstrate that the highest court has struck down onerous monetary conditions imposed as prerequisites to restoration.
State of Orissa v. Sibaram Baral, 1996 (10) SCC 93 (Supreme Court) The Supreme Court set aside a direction to deposit the entire decree amount as well as costs for restoration of the suit. Relied upon to show that orders requiring full deposit of decretal amounts as preconditions have been invalidated.
G.P. Srivastava v. R.K. Raizade and others, 2000 (3) SCC 54 (Supreme Court) Explains Order 9, Rule 13: 'sufficient cause' must be liberally construed; it must relate to the date of non-appearance; courts have wide discretion; absence can be compensated by costs; prompt approach within statutory time favors restoration. Used as a key interpretive guide for Order 9, Rule 13, emphasizing that sufficient cause is elastic and that compensation via costs is appropriate rather than harsh preconditions.
V.K. Industries v. M.P. Electricity Board, 2002 (1) CTC 703 : 2002 (3) SCC 159 (Supreme Court) Unreasonable or onerous conditions imposed to restore a suit decreed ex parte are erroneous; conditions must be reasonable having regard to all relevant factors. Applied to hold that the Trial Court's terms were onerous, harsh and unreasonable in the circumstances and therefore liable to be set aside.
Nalabala Chalamiah v. Nalabala Rubiah, AIR 1953 Mad. 464 The direction to deposit costs of the suit was upheld as not unreasonable in that case. The Court considered this precedent but distinguished it on the basis of the large amounts the Trial Court had imposed in the present matters; the opinion held the Trial Court's amounts were onerous and therefore not applicable here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first framed the core point for consideration: whether the Trial Court's exercise of discretion in setting aside ex parte decrees subject to deposit of the specified costs was sustainable under Order 9, Rule 13, CPC.

The court reviewed the facts: the appellants had sworn to being ill and bed-ridden from 16.10.2005 to 25.10.2005, being unable to attend court on 18.10.2005. The Trial Judge had found sufficient cause and yet imposed the condition to deposit substantial costs by 04.10.2006 as a term for restoration.

The court reiterated the well-established legal position under Order 9, Rule 13, CPC that a court setting aside an ex parte decree has discretion to allow the petition on terms, but such conditions must be just and reasonable in the circumstances. The opinion surveyed multiple precedents which collectively establish that:

  • “Sufficient cause” is an elastic concept to be liberally construed and must relate to the date of non-appearance (G.P. Srivastava).
  • Courts may impose conditions such as costs or security but those conditions must be reasonable, not arbitrary, onerous or excessive (V.K. Industries; LIC of India v. Anjan Kumar; Nanak Chand; Ahmad Hussain).
  • Supreme Court authorities have struck down particularly harsh monetary prerequisites (State of Orissa v. Sibaram Baral; Kumud Lata Das; Raj Kumar Soni).
  • Some cases upheld modest costs when reasonable in context (Krishna Rice Mills; Nalabala Chalamiah), but the amounts imposed must be proportionate to the circumstances.

Applying these principles, the court concluded that although the Trial Court had found sufficient cause for the appellants' absence, the monetary conditions imposed by the Trial Court (Rs. 44,573.25 and Rs. 3,71,175/-) were excessive and onerous in the facts of these cases. The court distinguished Nalabala Chalamiah (where deposit of costs was upheld) on the ground that the amounts here were large and thus unreasonable.

Balancing the respondents' entitlement to compensation for expenses caused by default and the appellants' entitlement to have the matter tried on merits given their illness, the court exercised its own discretion to impose modest compensatory costs: Rs. 2,000/- in C.M.A. No. 1656 of 2007 and Rs. 3,000/- in C.M.A. No. 1657 of 2007, payable within two weeks. Upon filing a memo of compliance, the Trial Court was directed to restore the suits and dispose of them within two months from restoration.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Civil Miscellaneous Appeals are allowed. The Trial Court's orders imposing onerous conditions for restoration (large deposits of costs) were set aside insofar as they required those large amounts; instead modest compensatory costs were ordered and the suits were to be restored on compliance.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The appellants must pay Rs. 2,000/- in C.M.A. No. 1656 of 2007 and Rs. 3,000/- in C.M.A. No. 1657 of 2007 to the respondents as compensatory costs within two weeks from receipt of the High Court order.
  • Upon payment and filing of a memo of compliance before the Trial Court, the Trial Court is directed to restore the suits.
  • The Trial Court is directed to dispose of the restored suits within two months from the date of restoration. The appeals were allowed and "No costs" was recorded (as to the appeals themselves).

No broader change to legal doctrine was asserted by the court; the decision applied existing principles restricting imposition of onerous preconditions for setting aside ex parte decrees under Order 9, Rule 13, CPC and tailored relief on the facts.

    D.K Bhaskaran And Another v. Barton Trust, A Registered Partnership Firm, Rep. By Its Partner, Mr. M.A Chacko, Fair House, Porter Avenue, Coonoor, The Nilgris And Another S

    1. The above Civil Miscellaneous Appeals are filed against the fair and decretal orders dated 23.1.2007 made in I.A Nos. 151 of 2006 in O.S No. 1 of 2005 and I.A No. 152 of 2006 in O.S No. 2 of 2005 respectively, Petitions filed under Order 9, Rule 13, CPC to set aside the ex parte decrees passed in the respective Suits on 18.10.2005

    2. The respondents herein filed O.S No. 1 of 2005 and 2 of 2005 claiming a sum of Rs. 5,41,030.88 and Rs. 45,23,815.24 respectively with 18% interest per annum and for costs. As the defendants/appellants herein remained absent on 18.10.2005, they were set ex parte and the Suits were allowed as prayed for.

    3. To set aside the ex parte decrees, the appellants herein filed I.A Nos. 151 of 2005 and 152 of 2005 respectively under Order 9, Rule 13, CPC stating that the appellants were laid up with severe fever and diarrhoea from 16.10.2005 to 25.10.2005 and when the Suits were posted for cross examination of the plaintiffs on 18.10.2005, the appellants/defendants could not attend the Court nor instruct their counsel and that the absence was not willful nor deliberate. The said Applications were resisted by the respondents/plaintiffs herein contending that the Applications were filed with mala fide intention to delay the execution of the decrees and the reasons stated in the affidavit are false.

    4. The Trial Court, by separate orders dated 11.9.2006, directed the appellants/respondents to deposit costs of Rs. 44,573.25 and Rs. 3,71,175/- respectively on or before 4.10.2006 and in case of failure to comply with the said direction, ordered that the Petitions shall stand dismissed. The Trial Court posted the matter on 5.10.2006 for reporting compliance of the direction. The case was posted before the Trial Court on several dates from 5.10.2006 to 23.1.2007 and on 23.1.2007 the Trial Court passed the following order:

    “For production of High Court order. High Court order copy not produced. Costs not deposited. Petition is dismissed.”

    It is against the said order, the defendants in the Suits filed the present Civil Miscellaneous Appeals.

    5. I have heard the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants as well as the learned counsel appearing for the respondents in the light of the provisions contained in Order 9, Rule 13, CPC.

    6. The point for consideration in these Appeals is whether the discretion exercised by the Trial Court while setting aside the ex parte decrees ordering deposit of costs of the Suits, is sustainable.

    7. The reason given by the appellants for their absence on 18.10.2005 as stated in the affidavit filed in support of the Petition to set aside the ex parte decree is that the appellant was laid up with severe fever and diarrhoea from 16.10.2005 to 25.10.2005 and he was bed-ridden and hence he could not move out. The learned Trial Judge, after holding that the sufficient cause is shown to set aside the ex parte decrees, by order dated 11.9.2006 imposed a onerous condition to deposit the costs referred above on or before 4.10.2006

    8. It is true that the Court, which passes order in set aside Petitions, is vested with the discretion to allow the Petition on terms. It has to be ascertained whether in this case, the course adopted by the Trial Court is just and proper, in the circumstances of the case, wherein the petitioner failed to appear before the Court due to his illness.

    9. Sufficient cause having been made out even as per the order of the Trial Court, onerous condition for restoration cannot be imposed while setting aside the ex parte orders under Order 9, Rule 13, CPC. The above issue is considered in a number of decisions.

    (a) In the decision reported in Krishna Rice Mills v. P. Rajagopala Konar, AIR 1958 Mad. 522, while setting aside an ex parte decree, this Court awarded cost of Rs. 75/- to compensate the respondent for the waste of time, money and energy caused to him and the Suit was restored for fresh disposal.

    (b) In Dhanalakshmi Ammal v. Shanbagalakshmi Ammal, 1965 (1) MLJ 209, a condition imposed to deposit the cost to hear the application to set aside the ex parte decree was found erroneous and set aside and it is held that the conditional order can be passed for restoration of the Suit which must be just and reasonable.

    (c) In Nanak Chand v. Goswami Preetam Lal, AIR 1972 All. 166, a learned Judge of the Allahabad High Court, following a Division Bench decision of that Court reported in Ahmad Hussain v. Har Dayal, AIR 1926 All. 142, held that an order restoring the case for default of condition of payment of a reasonable amount of the cost to the opposite party can be passed under Order 9, Rule 13, CPC.

    (d) A Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court in the decision reported in Foundation Overseas Ltd. v. Punjab National Bank Ltd., AIR 1977 Cal. 428, considered a direction to restore the Suit, which was dismissed for default to furnish security as condition precedent, was held not valid.

    (e) The Allahabad High Court in Raj Kumar Soni…Applicant; v. M/S. Mohan Meakin Breweries Ltd.…Opposite Party., AIR 1979 All. 370, held that the direction to deposit 1/5th of the Suit amount as condition precedent to set aside ex parte decree even after giving a clear finding that there had been sufficient cause for being absent on the date when ex parte decree was passed was held illegal.

    (f) In LIC of India v. Anjan Kumar, AIR 1987 Cal. 197, the Calcutta High Court held that while setting aside the ex parte decree imposing of condition must be reasonable and must have some justification having regard to the attending circumstances and the same cannot be imposed arbitrarily.

    (g) A Direction to pay mesne profit as condition precedent for setting aside the ex parte decree was cancelled by the Honourable Supreme Court in the decision reported in Kumud Lata Das v. Indu Prasad., 1996 (7) Scale 410.

    (h) A direction to deposit the entire decree amount as well as cost for restoration of the Suit was set aside by the Honourable Supreme Court in the decision reported in State of Orissa v. Sibaram Baral, 1996 (10) SCC 93.

    (i) Sufficient cause for non-appearance to be proved on the date of hearing alone and not anterior or posterior to the said date was considered by the Honourable Supreme Court in the decision reported in G.P Srivastava v. R.K Raizade and others, 2000 (3) SCC 54. In paragraph 7 of the Judgment the Supreme Court held thus:

    “7. Under Order 9, Rule 13, CPC an ex parte decree passed against a defendant can be set aside upon satisfaction of the Court that either the summons were not duly served upon the defendant or he was prevented by any “sufficient cause” from appearing when the Suit was called on for hearing. Unless “sufficient cause” is shown for non-appearance of the defendant in the case on the date of hearing, the Court has no power to set aside an ex parte decree. The words “was prevented by any sufficient cause from appearing” must be liberally construed to enable the Court to do complete justice between the parties particularly when no negligence or inaction is imputable to the erring party. Sufficient cause for the purpose of Order 9, Rule 13 has to be construed as an elastic expression for which no hard and fast guidelines can be prescribed. The Courts have a wide discretion in deciding the sufficient cause keeping in view the peculiar facts and circumstances of each case. The “sufficient cause” for non-appearance refers to the date on which the absence was made a ground for proceeding ex parte and cannot be stretched to rely upon other circumstances anterior in time. If “sufficient cause” is made out for non-appearance of the defendant on the date fixed for hearing when ex parte proceedings were initiated against him, he cannot be penalised for his previous negligence which had been overlooked and thereby condoned earlier. In a case where the defendant approaches the Court immediately and within the statutory time specified, the discretion is normally exercised in his favour, provided the absence was not mala fide or intentional. For the absence of a party in the case the other side can be compensated by adequate costs and the lis decided on merits.” (Emphasis Supplied)

    (j) An unreasonable condition imposed to restore the Suit which was decreed ex parte was found erroneous by the Honourable Supreme Court in the decision reported in V.K Industries v. M.P Electricity Board, 2002 (1) CTC 703: 2002 (3) SCC 159, wherein in paragraphs 4 to 6 it is held thus,—

    “4. The only grievance of the appellants is that the terms, upon which ex parte decree is set aside, are onerous and not reasonable. On behalf of the respondents submission was made supporting the said terms as justified.

    5. Ordinarily, a money decree is not stayed unconditionally and the judgment-debtor would be put on terms. Even so, such conditions must be reasonable having regard to all relevant factors. Although ex parte decree was passed against the appellants, once it is set aside on the ground of non-service of Suit summons the money decree did not exist for execution. It is no doubt true that in restoring a case the Court may impose conditions to deposit costs or the decretal amount or some portion thereof or to ask the defendant to give security but such conditions should be reasonable and not harshly excessive. In the impugned order the appellants are put on terms to deposit a sum of Rs. 2,00,000 and to furnish a bank guarantee for the remaining suit claim within a period of two months. In our view these terms are onerous, harsh and unreasonable in the facts and circumstances of the case and that too even before the trial of the Suit on merits.

    6. On 29.10.2001, the learned counsel for the appellants stated that within two weeks, a sum of Rs. 50,000 shall be deposited in the Trial Court and notice was issued on that day. During the course of hearing the learned counsel informed that a sum of Rs. 50,000 is already deposited in the Trial Court.”

    10. In the decision cited by the learned counsel for the respondent reported in Nalabala Chalamiah v. Nalabala Rubiah, AIR 1953 Mad. 464, this Court upheld the direction to deposit cost of the Suit was not found unreasonable and the same cannot be applied to the facts of this case since cost of the Suit in C.M.A No. 1656 of 2007 is Rs. 3,39,287/- and in C.M.A No. 1657 of 2007, the cost imposed was Rs. 44,573.25. The said amounts having been huge amounts, I am of the view that the condition imposed is onerous and the same is liable to be set aside. However, taking note of the expenses incurred by the respondent due to the absence of the appellants in these Appeals, cost of Rs. 2,000/- is ordered to be paid to the respondents in C.M.A No. 1656 of 2007 and Rs. 3,000/- is ordered to be paid to the respondents in C.M.A No. 1657 of 2007 as compensatory costs. The said amount shall be paid by the appellants within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this order and file a memo to that effect before the Trial Court. On such memo being filed, the Trial Court is directed to restore the Suits. The Suits having been filed in the year 2005 and being money Suits, the Trial Court is directed to dispose of the Suits within a period of two months from the date of restoration of the Suits.

    The Civil Miscellaneous Appeals are allowed with the above directions. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    D.K Bhaskaran And An... v. Barton Trust, A Regi...
    (Jul 27, 2007)