AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • INDIAN MEDICAL COUNCIL ACT 1956
  • Section 15 of the 1956 Act and Section 17 of the 1970 Act
  • Section 15(3) of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956.
  • provisions of the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945.
  • Rule 2(ee)of the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945
  • Act Tamilnadu Medical Registration Act, 1941.
  • DRUGS AND COSMETICS ACT 1940
  • Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916
  • sub-section (12)(a) of Section 20.
  • SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT
  • Section 2(f),
  • section 2(k)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • INDIAN MEDICAL COUNCIL ACT 1956
  • Section 15 of the 1956 Act and Section 17 of the 1970 Act
  • Section 15(3) of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956.
  • provisions of the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945.
  • Rule 2(ee)of the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945
  • Act Tamilnadu Medical Registration Act, 1941.
  • DRUGS AND COSMETICS ACT 1940
  • Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916
  • sub-section (12)(a) of Section 20.
  • SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT
  • Section 2(f),
  • section 2(k)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant (an association registered under the Societies Registration Act) represents members who have been practising modern medicine in clinics for more than fifteen years but who do not possess the Decree or Diploma qualifications recognized by medical universities. Relying on a Government of India circular dated 8.7.1986, which directed State Governments and Union Territories to enlist unqualified medical practitioners and introduce legislation recognizing those practising modern medicine without prescribed qualifications, the association sought relief from the High Court.

The association previously filed writ petitions: W.P. No. 16878 of 1993 (allowed due to non-filing of counter by the respondents) and later W.P. No. 7402 of 1998 etc., in which a single Judge disposed of petitions on 8.3.1992 (permitting practice subject to compliance with conditions in paragraph 8 of that order). Claiming compliance with those conditions but asserting that the Government refused to issue certificates that would secure their practice from official interference, the association filed W.P. No. 19418 of 2001 seeking a writ of mandamus directing the State to issue necessary certificates.

The learned single Judge dismissed W.P. No. 19418 of 2001 on 31.10.2001 on the basis that the Government circulars are unenforceable in the face of statutory provisions and earlier judgments. The association appealed, leading to the present Writ Appeal heard by K. Govindarajan, J.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State of Tamil Nadu is obliged to issue certificates permitting persons without prescribed medical qualifications to practise modern scientific medicine on the basis of the Government of India circular dated 8.7.1986.
  2. Whether executive circulars (such as the 8.7.1986 circular) can supplement, modify or override statutory provisions governing registration and practice of medicine (including the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, the Tamilnadu Medical Registration Act, 1941, and the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916).
  3. Whether the appellants can rely on earlier single-judge orders (e.g., W.P. No. 7402 of 1998) permitting practice subject to conditions, as a basis to require the State to issue certificates despite statutory prohibitions and contrary higher court authority.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant is an association registered under the Societies Registration Act representing members who have practised modern medicine for over 15 years.
  • Members have been practising in clinics for years despite not having formal university Decree or Diploma qualifications.
  • The association relied on the Government of India circular dated 8.7.1986, which directed States to enlist unqualified medical practitioners and consider legislation to recognise them; on that basis it sought a writ of mandamus directing the State to issue certificates enabling continued practice without official disturbance.
  • The appellant pointed to an earlier single-Judge order (W.P. No. 7402 of 1998 etc.) which permitted practice subject to compliance with conditions, and asserted compliance with those conditions.

Respondents' / State's Position (as presented in the judgment)

  • The learned Judge and the State relied on statutory provisions (Indian Medical Council Act, 1956; Tamilnadu Medical Registration Act, 1941; Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916; Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945) which require recognised qualifications for registration and practice of medicine.
  • Executive circulars cannot override or supplement statutory provisions to enable persons lacking prescribed qualifications to register or to practise modern medicine.
  • Earlier judicial orders that permitted practice subject to conditions were passed without addressing whether the Union Government had the power to issue the circular; such orders cannot be used to compel the State to implement an unenforceable circular.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Poonam Verma v. Ashwin Patel, 1996 (4) SCC 332 Holds that registration under one system of medicine entitles the practitioner to practise in that system only; a practitioner registered in one system (e.g., Homeopathy) cannot practise by drugs of another system (e.g., Allopathy) for which he has no qualification; breach may attract prosecution under Section 15(3) of the IMC Act and actionable negligence. The Court relied on this authority to emphasise that statutory registration confines practice to the system for which the qualification and registration are recognised, supporting the conclusion that unqualified persons cannot be permitted to practise modern scientific medicine.
Dr. Preeti Srivastava v. State of M.P., 1999 (7) SCC 120 Emphasises that proper medical education necessarily involves taught content, teachers, text and practical training; teacher qualifications and infrastructural facilities are essential to medical education and the production of competent practitioners. The Court used this authority to underscore the importance of regulated training and qualifications in medical education, supporting the requirement that practitioners possess prescribed qualifications and training before practising.
Dr. Mukhtiar Chand v. State of Punjab, 1998 (7) SCC 579 Harmonious reading of Section 15 of the IMC Act and Section 17 of the 1970 Act: a person enrolled on the register of Indian Medicine cannot practise modern scientific medicine unless also enrolled on a State Medical Register under the IMC Act; the right to prescribe drugs is broadly synonymous with the right to practise that system of medicine. The Court applied this principle to hold that rights to prescribe allopathic drugs or to practise modern medicine cannot be derived from notifications under Drugs Rules or executive declarations; accordingly, the Government circular could not confer such rights.
Dr. Laxman Joshi (referenced) Duty of care in medical practice; breach of statutory or professional duties can amount to actionable negligence. Referenced (via the Poonam Verma discussion) to show that practising outside one's statutory field and without requisite qualification may constitute actionable negligence and attract statutory penalties.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying and analysing the controlling statutory framework:

  • The Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 (IMC Act): Definitions (Section 2), recognition of medical qualifications (Section 11), enrolment on State Medical Registers (Section 15), and the Indian Medical Register (Section 21) make clear that only persons possessing recognised medical qualifications included in the Schedules can enrol and thereby lawfully practise "medicine" (modern scientific medicine).
  • The Tamilnadu Medical Registration Act, 1941: Provides for a State Medical Council and a register to be maintained by the Registrar (Sections 5, 10, 11) and prescribes that only those with qualifications described in the Schedules can be listed and practise; a proviso allows registration of other qualifications only after consultation with the Medical Council.
  • The Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916: Prohibits conferring or holding out degrees or titles implying qualification to practise western medical science unless issued by recognised authorities, with penalties for contravention; it also prohibits use of titles implying such qualifications unless recognised by the General Council of Medical Education.

From these provisions the Court concluded that statutory schemes require prescribed qualifications as a pre-condition to registration and lawful practice of modern medicine. Even though Article 19(1)(g) protects the right to practise a profession, that right is subject to laws prescribing professional or technical qualifications (Article 19(6)), and the regulation of such qualifications is necessary to protect patients' right to life and proper healthcare.

Turning to the Government of India circular dated 8.7.1986 (which directed States to enlist unqualified practitioners and to introduce suitable legislation), the Court observed:

  • There is no statutory provision empowering the Union Government to issue a circular that effectively supplements, modifies, or nullifies the statutory registration and qualification scheme established by Parliament and the State Legislature.
  • Executive circulars represent administrative understanding of statutory provisions but cannot compete with, override, or have the effect of modifying clear statutory provisions; such circulars are unenforceable in the face of contrary statutory law.

The Court further relied on the precedents cited (including Poonam Verma and Dr. Mukhtiar Chand) to reinforce that registration and the right to prescribe drugs are tied to statutory recognition and that a person registered under one system cannot lawfully practise another system for which he lacks qualification. The Court noted that prior decisions of this Court and the Supreme Court had held that the circulars are unenforceable vis-à-vis statutory provisions.

Addressing the earlier single‑Judge order (W.P. No. 7402 of 1998) that permitted practice subject to conditions, the Court found that that order was passed without addressing the central question of the Union Government's power to issue the circular and therefore could not be relied upon by the appellants to compel the State to issue certificates contrary to statutory provisions.

Therefore, applying the statutory provisions and the cited authorities to the facts (members lacking recognised qualifications seeking certificates based solely on the circular and past practice), the Court concluded that the writ petition lacked merit and declined to direct the State to implement the circular.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Writ Appeal dismissed.

The Court affirmed the order of the learned single Judge dismissing W.P. No. 19418 of 2001 and refused to direct the State to issue certificates to enable the appellant's members to practise modern medicine on the basis of the Government of India circular dated 8.7.1986. The Court explicitly held that the circular is unenforceable to the extent it is contrary to statutory provisions and the binding judicial authorities cited. The order concludes with "No costs."

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The association's request for mandamus to compel issuance of certificates to its members (who lack prescribed recognised qualifications) is denied; the members cannot insist that the State issue certificates enabling them to practise modern medicine based solely on the 8.7.1986 circular.
  • Broader legal consequence as stated by the Court: Executive circulars cannot be used to nullify or modify clear statutory registration and qualification schemes established by the legislature; where statutory provisions prescribe qualifications for registration and practice, those provisions govern.
  • The opinion does not set out any novel legal principle departing from the statutes and the authorities relied upon; it applies existing statutory rules and case law to the facts and declines to enforce the executive circular.

    All India Assn. Of Private Medical Practitioners v. State Of T.N.

    K. Govindarajan, J.

    1. The above Writ Appeal is directed against the order of the learned Judge passed in W.P No. 19418 of 2001, dated 31.10.2001, under which the learned Judge has dismissed the writ petition filed by the appellant, seeking to issue a Writ of mandamus, directing the State of Tamil Nadu to issue necessary certificate on complying with the conditions imposed by the learned Judge in the order dated 8.6.1998 in W.P No. 7402 of 1998 etc., on the basis of the data furnished already by the members of the petitioner-association and acknowledged by the respective Collectors of the Districts.

    2. The appellant claiming that it is an association registered under the Societies Registration Act, filed the above writ petition on the basis that its members are practicing in modern medicine in the respective clinics for more than 15 years. Though they have not secured any Decree or Diploma prescribed by various Universities for qualifying them as Registered Medical Practitioners in various disciplines, relying on the circular issued by the Government of India dated 8.7.1986, directing the State Governments and the Union Territories to enlist the unqualified medical practitioners and to introduce suitable legislation for recognising those practicing in modern medicine without acquiring prescribed Degree or Diploma, the petitioner-Association approached the High Court ? by filing writ petition in W.P No. 16878 of 1993 for issue of a Writ of mandamus against the respondents therein forbearing them from interfering with their practice in modern medicine. Due to non filing of the counter by the respondents the said writ petition was allowed. Subsequently, the petitioner-association approached the High Court by filing another writ petition in W.P No. 7402 of 1998 etc., seeking to issue a Writ of mandamus to the State of Tamil Nadu to regularise the practice of unqualified medical practitioners in modern medicine as per the circular issued by the Central Government dated 8.7.1986 The learned Judge in the order dated 8.3.1992 disposed of the writ petitions permitting them to practise in modern medicine in the field in which they have been rendering services to the public, on their compliance of the conditions mentioned in paragraph 8 of the said order.

    3. Stating that though they have complied with such conditions, the Government is not issuing any certificates so as to enable them to continue their practice in modern medicine without any disturbance from the officials, the petitioner-association filed the present writ petition in W.P No. 19418 of 2001.

    4. The learned Judge relying on the provisions of various Acts relating to the subject and also the earlier judgments of this court and the Apex Court, observed that in the earlier proceedings, this court has held that the said circulars are unenforceable in the face of the statutory provisions and so the writ petition filed by the appellant herein cannot be sustained, as there are no merits in the writ petition. Hence this Writ Appeal.

    5. We heard both the learned counsel for the appellant and Mr. V. Raghupathi, learned Government Pleader appearing for the respondents.

    6. Before dealing with the facts, we are inclined to deal with the relevant provisions of law on the subject. The Indian Medical Council Act,1956 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) was enacted to provide for the reconstitution of the Medical Council of India, and the maintenance of a Medical Register for India and for matters connected therewith. In view of definition under Section 2(f), modern scientific medicine in all its branches shall mean as “medicine”. Under Section 2(h) “recognised medical qualification” has been defined as any of the medical qualification included in the Schedules. “State Medical Register” has been defined under section 2(k) as a register maintained under any law for the time being in force in any State regulating the registration of practitioners of medicine. Section-11 of the Act deals with the recognition of Medical Qualifications granted by Universities or Medical Institutions in India for the purposes of the Act. As contemplated under Section-15 of the Act, only the persons who are having sufficient qualification which has been included in the Schedules to the Act can enrol themselves on any State Medical Register. Under Section-21, Medical Council shall cause to be maintained in the prescribed manner a register of medical practitioners to be known as the Indian Medical Register, which shall contain the names of all the persons who are for the time being enrolled on any State Medical Register and who possess any of the recognised medical qualifications.

    7. From the above said provisions it is clear that the persons who are possessing recognised medical qualification alone can register their names as contemplated under the Act and they alone can practise “medicines”.

    8. To provide for the registration of Medical Practitioners in the State of Tamil Nadu, the State Legislature had enacted an Act “Tamilnadu Medical Registration Act, 1941”. Under Section-5 of the said Act of 1914, a Medical Council shall be established for the State of Tamilnadu and the said council as contemplated under Section-10 shall contain a Registrar, who shall act as the Secretary of the Council and the said Registrar has an obligation as contemplated under Section-11 of the said Act 1914 should keep a register of medical practitioners and only the persons who have possessed of any of the qualification described in the Schedules shall be entitled to be listed their names so as to enable them to practise Allopathy or any other system of medicine. In the proviso to Section-13 the Legislature has given power to the State Government permitting the registration of any person who shall furnish to the Registrar proof that he is possessed of a medical degree, diploma or certificate of any University, medical college or school approved by the Council, other than those described in the Schedule after consulting the Medical Council.

    9. Even under this Act, unless the persons have prescribed qualification, cannot register their names and legally practise medicine.

    10. Under the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916 enacted to regulate the grant of titles implying qualifications in western medical science, and the assumption and use by unqualified persons of such titles. According to Section-3 of the Act no person in the States shall confer, grant, or issue, or hold himself out as entitled to confer, grant, or issue any degree, diploma, licence, certificate or other document stating or implying that the holder, grantee or recipient is qualified to practise western medical science. According to Section-5, any contravention of the same shall be punishable with a fine. According to Section-6A, no person shall have any title to his name, description, letters or abbreviations which imply that he holds a degree, diploma, licence or certificate as his qualification to practise any system of medicine unless such a degree, diploma, licence or certificate was issued by an authority and has been recognised by the General Council of Medical Education.

    11. As stated above, sufficient enactments have been made to prevent the persons from practising “medicine” without having necessary qualifications and also for registration as contemplated under the above said Act.

    12. In the present case, it is not in dispute that the members of the Association are not having any such qualification. They are trying to get a certificate only on the basis of their experience in practising “medicine” without any such qualification. The right to practise any profession or to carry on any occupation, trade or business is no doubt a fundamental right guaranteed under Article 19(1)(g) of The Constitution of India. But, that right is subject to any law relating to the professional or technical qualifications necessary for practising any profession or carrying on any occupation or trade or business indicated in Clause-6 of Article 19 of the Constitution. The regulatory measures on the exercise of this right both with regard to standard of professional qualification and professional conduct have been applied keeping in view not only the right of medical practitioners, but also the right to life and proper health care of persons who need medical care and treatment. The need of the hour is better doctors than more doctors, better health education than more education, better health care than more health care delivery.

    13. In the decision reported in Poonam Verma v. Ashwin Patel, 1996 (4) SCC 332 it has been held by the Supreme Court as follows while considering the issue whether a person holding Diploma in Homeopathy Medicine and Surgery can administer Allopathic medicine without having any qualification in the same: “30. The scheme of the Act, therefore, indicates that a person gets the right to practise in Homeopathy on being registered as a medical practitioner. The certificate of registration issued to such practitioner requires him to practise in Homeopathy Only as is clear from the words “And Shall Practise Homeopathy Only” used in sub-section (12)(a) of Section 20. Apart from the right to practice, other rights which become immediately available to a person on registration of his name are indicated in Section 28 which, inter alia, includes right to treat patients according to the Homeopathic system of medicine.

    31. Right to practise in Allopathic system of medicine as also the right to practise in Ayurvedic or Unani system of medicine is regulated by separate independent Central and local Acts. Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 deals, inter alia, with the registration of persons possessing requisite qualifications as medical practitioner in Allopathic system as also recognition of medical qualifications and examinations by Universities or Medical Institutions in India.

    38. But merely because the anatomy and Physiology are similar, it does not mean that a person having studied one system of medicine can claim to treat the patient by drugs of another system which he might not have studied at any stage. No doubt, study of Physiology and Anatomy is common in all systems of medicines and the students belonging to different systems of medicines may be taught Physiology and Anatomy together, but so far as the study of drugs is concerned, the Pharmacology of all systems is entirely different.

    41. Since the law, under which respondent-1 was registered as a medical practitioner, required him to practise in Homeopathy Only, he was under a statutory duty not to enter the field of any other system of medicines as, admittedly,he was not qualified in the other system, Allopathy, to be precise. He trespassed into a prohibited field and was liable to be prosecuted under Section 15(3) of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956. His conduct amounted to an actionable negligence particularly as the duty of care indicated by this Court in Dr. Laxman Joshi case Was Breached By Him On All The Three Counts Indicated Therein.”

    14. While deciding the correctness of the Act of the State Government prescribing different admission criteria by contemplating different minimum qualifying marks for special category candidates seeking admission under the reserved category in medical courses, the Constitutional Bench of the Apex Court in Dr. Preeti Srivastava v. State of M.P, 1999 (7) SCC 120 observed that for proper education it would necessarily have in its fold (i)the taught, (ii)the teacher, (iii)the text and also (iv)training as practical training is required to be imparted to students pursuing the course of postgraduate medical education. The qualification of the teachers is determined by the Medical Council of India by prescribing the basic qualifications for admission of the students. While considering the importance of training, it is further observed that training to be imparted to the students has a direct nexus with the infrastructural facilities like the number of beds of patients to be attended to by postgraduate medical students, providing appropriate infrastructure for surgical training etc., also would form part of education and such facilities for giving such practical training to the taught also would be an important part of medical education. It is of course true that not only the eligibility of students for admission to medical courses but also the quality of students seeking to get medical education especially postgraduate medical education with a view to turning out efficient medical practitioners for serving the suffering humanity would all be covered by the term “education”.

    15. The Government of Punjab State issued notifications under Clause(iii)of Rule 2(ee)of the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945 which defines “registered medical practitioner”. Under such notification notified vaids/hakims claim right to prescribe allopathic drugs covered by the Indian Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940. A Division Bench of Punjab & Haryana High Court held that such a notification was ultra vires of the said provisions. While considering the said issue, in the decisions reported in Dr. Mukhtiar Chand v. State of Punjab, 1998 (7) SCC 579 the Apex Court held as follows:

    “47. A harmonious reading of Section 15 of the 1956 Act and Section 17 of the 1970 Act leads to the conclusion that there is no scope for a person enrolled on the State Register of Indian Medicine or the Central Register of Indian Medicine to practise modern scientific medicine in any of its branches unless that person is also enrolled on a State Medical Register within the meaning of the 1956 Act.

    48. The right to practise modern or Indian system of medicine cannot be based on the provisions of the Drugs Rules and declaration made thereunder by State Governments. Indeed, Ms. Indira Jaising has also submitted that the right to practise a system of medicine is derived from the Act under which a medical practitioner is registered. But she has strenuously argued that the right which the holders of a degree in integrated courses of Indian medicine are claiming is to have their prescription of allopathic medicine honoured by a pharmacist or a chemist under the Pharmacy Act and the Drugs Act. This argument is too technical to be acceded to because prescribing a drug is a concomitant of the right to practise a system of medicine. Therefore, in a broader sense, the right to prescribe drugs of a system of medicine would be synonymous with the right to practise that system of medicine. In that sense, the right to prescribe an allopathic drug cannot be wholly divorced from the claim to practise allopathic medicine.”

    16. Moreover, similar writ petitions were filed in this court in W.P No. 18186 of 1991 etc., batch were dismissed on 31.12.1996 In another W.P No. 14042 of 91, the Private Medical Practitioners Association of India, Tamil Nadu Branch sought to issue a Writ of mandamus directing the State of Tamil Nadu to forthwith implement the directions of the Government of India issued in the proceedings dated 8.7.1986 which is also the subject matter in this writ petition. The said Writ Petition was dismissed on 6.11.1995 and the same was confirmed by the Division Bench in W.A No. 1384 of 1995 in the order dated 21.8.1998 For the same relief 17 individuals filed another Writ Petition in W.P No. 522 of 2000 and the same learned Judge dismissed the said writ petitions in an elaborate order dated 21.1.2000 The Modern Medical Practitioners Association of India initiated another Writ Petition in W.P No. 2572 of 2000 seeking to issue a writ of mandamus directing the State Government to register the names of the members of the petitioner association in the State Medical Register maintained by the State as per the provisions of the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945. The learned Judge rejected the said contention.

    17. We are not able to understand in spite of specific statutory provisions, as to how the Union of India had issued such directions contrary to the statutory provisions and the judgments of the Apex Court. No provision is pointed out to show that the Government is empowered to issue such circular and so it is not open to the Government to supplement the provisions of the Act and Rules made thereunder by executive orders which has the effect of nullifying or modifying the statutory provisions. So far as circulars issued by the Government are concerned, they represent merely their understanding of the statutory provisions and they are not binding upon the courts as such circulars cannot compete with statutory provisions.

    18. The circular which is sought to be implemented cannot have any legal force and this court is not inclined to direct the Government to implement such circulars as it is unenforceable in law. But for the said circular, the members of the association cannot insist the State Government to issue certificate to enable them to practise “Medicine”. Though the appellant had relied on the judgment of the learned single Judge made in W.P No. 7402 of 98 etc., batch dated 15.6.98 the said order was passed by the learned single Judge without even going into the question regarding the power of the Union Government to issue such a circular contrary to law on the issue and so the appellant cannot take advantage of the said judgment to claim that the State Government should permit the members of the appellant association to practise in medicine though they are not having any qualification to do so.

    19. In view of the above discussion, we do not find any reason to interfere with the order of the learned single Judge. Hence, the Writ Appeal is dismissed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    All India Assn. Of Private Medical Practitioners v. State Of T.N.
    (Nov 12, 2002)