Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (6) under rule 40, sub para (2) of sub-rule (i) under rule 44 and sub-rule (3) under rule 92 of the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules 1957.
  • sub-rule (6) to Rule 40, sub-rule (1) to Rule 44 and sub-rule (3) to Rule 92. According to sub-rule (4) to Rule 40,
  • sub-rule (6) under rule 40, sub-para 2 of sub-rule (i) under rule 44 and sub-rule (3) under rule 92
  • provisions of Section 2(8) of the Tamil Nadu Public Building (Licensing) Act
  • provisions of the Public Buildings (Licensing) Act, 1965 and the Rules
  • rules 40, 44 and 92 of the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules, 1957
  • provisions of the Tamil Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules, 1966.
  • Rule 40, 44 and 92 of the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules, 1957.
  • SECTION 8 TAMIL NADU PUBLIC BUILDINGS LICENSING ACT 1965
  • provisions of the Public Buildings (Licensing) Act and Rules
  • provisions of the Public Buildings (Licensing) rules
  • provisions of the Tamil Nadu Cinema (Regulation) Act.
  • Public Buildings (Licensing) Act and the Rules.
  • provisions of the Cinema Regulation Rules
  • TAMIL NADU PUBLIC BUILDINGS LICENSING ACT 1965
  • Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules, 1966,
  • Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules
  • Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules, 1957
  • Nadu Cinema (Regulation) Rules, 1957
  • Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules
  • Public Buildings (Licensing) Act
  • Rule 11 of the amended Rules
  • Rule 11 of the Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (6) under rule 40, sub para (2) of sub-rule (i) under rule 44 and sub-rule (3) under rule 92 of the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules 1957.
  • sub-rule (6) to Rule 40, sub-rule (1) to Rule 44 and sub-rule (3) to Rule 92. According to sub-rule (4) to Rule 40,
  • sub-rule (6) under rule 40, sub-para 2 of sub-rule (i) under rule 44 and sub-rule (3) under rule 92
  • provisions of Section 2(8) of the Tamil Nadu Public Building (Licensing) Act
  • provisions of the Public Buildings (Licensing) Act, 1965 and the Rules
  • rules 40, 44 and 92 of the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules, 1957
  • provisions of the Tamil Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules, 1966.
  • Rule 40, 44 and 92 of the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules, 1957.
  • SECTION 8 TAMIL NADU PUBLIC BUILDINGS LICENSING ACT 1965
  • provisions of the Public Buildings (Licensing) Act and Rules
  • provisions of the Public Buildings (Licensing) rules
  • provisions of the Tamil Nadu Cinema (Regulation) Act.
  • Public Buildings (Licensing) Act and the Rules.
  • provisions of the Cinema Regulation Rules
  • TAMIL NADU PUBLIC BUILDINGS LICENSING ACT 1965
  • Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules, 1966,
  • Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules
  • Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules, 1957
  • Nadu Cinema (Regulation) Rules, 1957
  • Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules
  • Public Buildings (Licensing) Act
  • Rule 11 of the amended Rules
  • Rule 11 of the Rules
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitions are writ petitions seeking issuance of writs of certiorari to call for and quash Government Order G.O.Ms No. 44, Home (Cinemas-A) Department dated 7.1.1991. The facts in both writ petitions were common and a single order was passed.

The petitioners are engineering graduates whose names were included in a panel of private engineers approved by the Board of Engineers and maintained by District Collectors under the Tamil Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules, 1966. Under the Public Buildings (Licensing) Act and Rules, such panel engineers were authorised to inspect public buildings and issue Certificates of Structural Soundness.

Cinema theatres were not listed in the statutory definition of "Public Building" under Section 2(8) of the Tamil Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Act, 1965. In 1985 the Government issued G.O.Ms No. 2575 (Home dated 16.10.1985) amending the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules, 1957 so as to empower engineers included in the panel maintained under the Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules to issue structural soundness certificates for cinema theatres.

By G.O.Ms No. 44, Home (Cinemas-A) Department dated 7.1.1991 the Government deleted the provisions in the Cinema (Regulation) Rules which had empowered panel engineers maintained under the Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules to issue structural soundness certificates for cinema theatres, effectively reserving that function to the Executive Engineers of the Public Works Department (PWD). The petitioners challenged that Government Order as arbitrary and illegal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether G.O.Ms No. 44, Home (Cinemas-A) Department dated 7.1.1991, which deleted provisions empowering panel engineers (maintained under the Tamil Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules) to issue structural soundness certificates for cinema theatres, is arbitrary or illegal and therefore liable to be quashed.
  2. Whether the Government had adequate material and justification to delete the provisions empowering the panel of private engineers and to revert the power exclusively to Executive Engineers of the PWD, particularly in light of public safety concerns and the absence of expert inquiry.
  3. Whether the impugned Government Order unduly affected the petitioners' legitimate professional entitlement (their ability to issue structural soundness certificates under the previously amended rules).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners are qualified engineers whose names appear on the panel of registered engineers drawn and maintained by District Collectors under the Tamil Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules, 1966, and are therefore empowered to inspect and issue Certificates of Structural Soundness for public buildings.
  • Although cinema theatres were not originally included in the statutory definition of "Public Building," the 1985 amendment (G.O.Ms No. 2575 dated 16.10.1985) to the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules empowered panel engineers to issue structural soundness certificates for cinema theatres, and the petitioners relied on that amendment to inspect and certify cinema theatres.
  • G.O.Ms No. 44 (7.1.1991) arbitrarily deleted those provisions and thereby deprived the petitioners of their right to issue structural soundness certificates for cinema theatres, affecting their profession and interests without proper justification.
  • Insofar as the public buildings legislation and rules are concerned, the Cinema (Regulation) Rules could not be read to conflict with the Public Buildings (Licensing) Act and Rules; therefore the Government Order removing panel engineers' competence was not permissible without adequate grounds.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Government relied on instances where the Executive Engineer, PWD had reported certain theatres as unfit to run shows while an engineer from the panel certified them as structurally sound; such conflicting certifications raised public-safety concerns.
  • To avoid the problem of "twin authorities" issuing inconsistent certificates and in the interest of public safety, the Government decided to eliminate the empowerment of the panel engineers for cinema theatres and revert to the original system where Executive Engineers of PWD alone issue structural soundness certificates.
  • The Government also pointed out that there are about 2,600 theatres in the State and PWD engineers are more numerous and better able to perform the certification function without delay; the amendment to Rules 40, 44 and 92 of the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules, 1957 was therefore justified.
  • On this basis the Government Advocate submitted that G.O.Ms No. 44 was valid and should not be interfered with.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the official records to ascertain the basis for the amendment effected by G.O.Ms No. 44 (7.1.1991). The documents showed that the solitary basis for the amendment was a government letter (Letter No. MS.1610 Home (Cinemas-A) Department dated 10.7.1990) reporting that instances had occurred where Executive Engineers, PWD certified that certain theatres should not be permitted to run shows because they were in bad shape, while an engineer from the panel certified those same theatres as structurally sound.

The court noted that this concern about inconsistent certifications and public safety was the lone reason recorded by the Government for amending Rules 40, 44 and 92 of the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules, 1957. The records did not reveal any other material relied upon by the Government to conclude that certificates issued by the panel engineers were unreliable.

The court observed that the Government made no attempt to appoint a committee or seek expert opinion to investigate the genuineness or scope of the allegations (i.e., to determine whether the panel engineers' certifications were systematically unreliable). Given that there are nearly 2,600 cinema theatres and that many theatres were reported to be in poor condition, the court held that the Government should have sought expert advice before removing the panel engineers' competence.

Because the records contained no other supporting material and no independent investigation was undertaken, the court concluded that the Government acted arbitrarily in deleting the provisions (specifically, the identified sub-rules in Rules 40, 44 and 92) by promulgating G.O.Ms No. 44 dated 7.1.1991.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court held that G.O.Ms No. 44, Home (Cinemas-A) Department dated 7.1.1991 is illegal and arbitrary and therefore struck it down. The writ petitions were allowed.

Core Ruling: G.O.Ms No. 44 dated 7.1.1991 is struck down as illegal and arbitrary.

Direct consequences and immediate implications:

  • The writ petitions seeking certiorari to quash G.O.Ms No. 44 were allowed.
  • No costs were awarded.
  • In view of the disposal of the main writ petitions, the connected W.M.P. Nos. 11258 and 19196 of 1991 were closed.

Broader implications: The opinion does not discuss setting any new precedent beyond the facts of the challenge to G.O.Ms No. 44. The decision's stated basis is the insufficiency of governmental material and absence of expert inquiry supporting the amendment; the court did not articulate a generalized rule beyond this finding.

    P. Perumal And 8 Others Petitioners v. State Of Tamil Nadu Rep. By Secretary To Government Home (Cinemas-A) Department, Fort St. George, Madras- 9

    1. The writ petitions are for the issue of writ of certiorari to call for the records of the respondent made in G.O.Ms No. 44, Home (Cinemas-A) Department dated 7.1.1991 and quash the same.

    2. As the facts in both the writ petitions are one and the same, the following common order is passed.

    3. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has argued that the petitioners are graduates in Engineering who are included in the panel of Engineers approved by the Board of Engineers and maintained by the District Collectors under the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules, 1966. The petitioners were involved in the construction of cinema theatres and they have constructed many theatres. Learned Senior Counsel has argued that “Public Buildings” are defined under Section 2(8) of the Tamil Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Act, 1965 which did not include ‘cinema theatres’ as the class of buildings constituting cinema theatres were to be approved under the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Cinema (Regulation) Act. Learned Senior Counsel has further argued that as per the provisions of the above Act, the owner of a public building who intends to use any building as a public building is required to make an application to the competent authority for a licence which is to be accompanied by a Certificate of Structural Soundness in the prescribed form obtained from an Engineer. “Engineer” is defined under Section 2(3) of the Act to mean any person possessing such Engineering qualifications as may be prescribed. Learned Senior Counsel submitted that in terms of Section 25 of the Act, the Tamil Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules, 1966 were framed which specified the details of the Engineering qualification for the purpose of the Act. According to the petitioners the said Rules were amended in the year 1970 to provide for a panel of registered Engineers to be drawn for each District by the Collector of the said District with the concurrence of the Superintending Engineer of the Public Works Department. The said panel of private Engineers possessing the qualifications specified in the Table to Rule 11 of the amended Rules were to be registered under four classes for each District depending upon which was related to the class of buildings. Hence as per the amended Rules, Structural Soundness Certificate is to be issued only by an Engineer whose name found a place in the panel of registered Engineers approved by the Board of Engineers and maintained by the District Collectors under the provisions of the Act and the Rules. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners submitted that the petitioners are private Engineers possessing the qualifications specified in the Table to Rule 11 of the Rules whose names have been included in the panel of registered Engineers for the District concerned which had been drawn and maintained by the Collector of the District with the concurrence of the Superintending Engineer of the Public Words Department. The petitioners have been empowered to inspect and issue a Certificate of Structural Soundness as required under the Tamil Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Act, 1965 so as to enable public buildings to be licensed for the use of the public. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has brought to the notice of this court the provisions of Section 2(8) of the Tamil Nadu Public Building (Licensing) Act which defines ‘Public Building’. Public Building means any building—

    (a) used as a —

    (i) school (including a tutorial school) or college (including a tutorial college) or University or other educational institution;

    (ii) hostel;

    (iii) library;

    (iv) hospital, nursing home, dispensary, clinic or maternity centre;

    (v) club;

    (vi) lodging house, boarding house or hotel; or

    (vii) choultry;

    (b) ordinarily used for public meeting or for celebrating marriage functions or for holding parties.

    The cinema theatres are not included in the above definition. In view of the fact that the Cinema (Regulation) Rules did not provide for the inspection and issue of certificates by the panel of Engineers maintained under the Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules, 1966, there was a lot of delay in the inspection and issue of certificates regarding the Structural Soundness of Cinema theatres in the Sate due to the dearth of Executive Engineers in the State. Learned Senior Counsel has argued that in view of the above position, the Tamil Nadu Exhibitors Association had therefore made representations that it was necessary to amend the Rules so as to empower the Engineers included in the panel of Engineers maintained by the District Collectors under the Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules to issue Structural Soundness Certificates for Cinema theatres under the Tamil Nadu Cinema (Regulation) Rules also. The Government by G.O.Ms No. 2575, Home dated 16.10.1985 amended the Tamil Nadu Cinema (Regulation) Rules, 1957 so as to empower any Engineer included in the panel of Engineers approved by the Board of Engineers and maintained by the District Collectors under the Tamil Nadu Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules to be competent to issue Structural Soundness Certificates under the Cinema (Regulation) Rules. In view of the abovesaid Government Order the Petitioners were empowered to inspect and issue structural soundness certificates in respect of cinema theatres. The petitioners were inspecting and issuing structural soundness certificates to all public buildings including cinema theatres for the purpose of enabling such buildings to be licensed for the use of the public. Suddenly, the respondent has issued an order in G.O.Ms No. 44 Home (Cinemas-A) Department dated 7.1.1991 amending the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulations) Rules deleting the provisions which empowered engineers included in the panel of engineers and maintained by the District Collectors under the provisions of the Public Buildings (Licensing) Rules from being competent to issue the structural soundness certificates to cinema theatres. The said Government Order is arbitrary and illegal and liable to be struckdown.

    Learned senior counsel for the petitioners has argued that the definition of “Public Buildings” is an inclusive definition which includes a cinema theatre to which public or section of the public have access. The word ‘Engineer’ has been defined for the purpose of the Act to mean a person possessing such Engineering qualifications as may be prescribed. Rule 11 as amended empowers such of those Engineers possessing the qualifications prescribed in the Rules and who are included in a panel maintained by the District Collectors with the concurrence of the Superintending Engineer, PWD to be competent to issue a Structural Soundness Certificate of any Public building. In the year 1985 the Cinema (Regulation) Rules were amended to include sub-rule (6) to Rule 40, sub-rule (1) to Rule 44 and sub-rule (3) to Rule 92. According to sub-rule (4) to Rule 40, the Executive Engineers shall issue a Certificate of structural soundness of the building in Form “N” along with a report in Form “O” which shall be valid for a period of three years. Learned senior counsel for the petitioners has argued that but for the said amendment, it would have been open to the persons like the petitioners or the owners of Cinema theatres to complain that they are entitled to apply for a licence with the Structural Soundness Certificate issued by the panel Engineers in view of the Public Buildings (Licensing) Act and the rules made thereunder and that the Cinema (Regulation) Rules cannot be construed to be in conflict with the Public Buildings (Licensing) Act and the Rules. By virtue of G.O.Ms No. 44 Home (Cinema-A) Department dated 7.1.1991 the provisions of the Public Buildings (Licensing) Act, 1965 and the Rules made thereunder are in conflict with the provisions of the Cinema Regulation Rules for the reason that the Structural Soundness Certificate has to be issued by the Executive Engineer under the Tamil Nadu Cinema Regulation Rules. Learned senior counsel for the petitioners has argued that by the impugned Government Order, the petitioners who have been included in the panel of Engineers approved by the Board of Engineers and maintained by the District Collectors under the provisions of the Public Buildings (Licensing) Act and Rules made thereunder, are deprived of their right to issue Structural Soundness Certificate to cinema theatres. Learned senior counsel for the petitioners has argued that the said Government Order is arbitrary and illegal as it affects the profession of the petitioners.

    4. The respondent has filed a counter stating that G.O.Ms No. 2575 Home (Cinemas-A) Department dated 16.10.1985 has been issued so as to empower any Engineer included in the panel of Engineers approved by the Board of Engineers and maintained by the District Collectors under the Tamil Nadu Buildings License Rules to be competent to issue structural soundness certificate under the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules, 1957 also. As instances have come to the notice of the Government wherein when the Executive Engineer, Public Works Department had advised in the structural soundness certificate that certain theatres should not be allowed to run shows because the theatre buildings were in bad shape, an Engineer in the panel had certified that they were structurally sound. In order to curtail such things and keeping in view the public safety, the Government has decided to eliminate the system of empowering twin authorities to issue structural soundness certificate in respect of cinema buildings and also to revert to the original system of allowing the Executive Engineers, Public Works Department alone to issue such certificates. The Government had also decided to delete the relevant provisions of rule pertaining to the issue of structural soundness certificate by the panel of engineers. Accordingly the Government amended the rules 40, 44 and 92 of the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules, 1957 withdrawing the powers conferred on the panel of approved Engineers for the issue of structural soundness certificate for cinema theatres. In the counter it is also stated that there are about 2600 theatres in the State. The Engineers of the Public Works Department are more in number who are able to perform the functions of issue of structural soundness certificate for cinema building without delay. Keeping in view, the Government has brought in G.O.Ms No. 44, Home (Cinemas-A) Department dated 7.1.1991

    5. Basing on the above, learned Government Advocate has argued that the abovesaid Government Order is perfectly valid and it should not be interfered with.

    6. In this case, the records have been called for for knowing the reason to bring in the amendment to the Tamil Nadu Cinema (Regulation) Rules by G.O.Ms No. 44, dated 7.1.1991 The records reveal that the basis for the amendment is the letter from the Secretary to Government to the Commissioner of Land Administration, Madras-5 by Letter No. MS. 1610 Home (Cinemas-A) Department dated 10.7.1990 In the said letter it is stated that it has come to the notice of the Government wherein when the Executive Engineer, Public Works Department has advised in the structural soundness certificate that certain theatres should not be allowed to run shows because the theatre buildings are in bad shape, an Engineer in the panel has issued certificate stating that the above theatres are structurally sound. It affects the public safety and the licensing authorities are not in a position either to allow or to deny such theatres to run shows. It was therefore felt that in the interest of public safety it will be advisable to eliminate the system of empowering twin authorities to issue structural soundness certificates in respect of cinema theatre buildings and also to revert to the original system of allowing the Executive Engineer Public Works Department alone to issue such certificates. This is the lone reason given by the Government for bringing amendment to Rule 40, 44 and 92 of the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules, 1957. But the records show that the Government did not have any other material to come to the conclusion that the structural soundness certificates issued by the panel of Engineers approved and maintained by the District Collectors should not be relied upon. The records also reveal that the respondent did not make any attempt to appoint a Committee to go into the genuineness of the allegation made by the said Executive Engineer. The records reveal that there are nearly 2600 cinema theatres in the State and instances have come to the notice of the Government that the conditions of most of the cinema theatres are bad. Before issuing the amendment to Rules 40, 44 and 92 of the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules 1957, the Government should have sought expert opinion in this regard whether they can act upon the structural soundness certificates issued by the panel of Engineers. The records do not reveal any other material on which the Government relied on to delete the provisions under sub-rule (6) under rule 40, sub para (2) of sub-rule (i) under rule 44 and sub-rule (3) under rule 92 of the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation) Rules 1957. Under the circumstances, it has to be held that the Government has acted in an arbitrary manner in deleting the provisions under sub-rule (6) under rule 40, sub-para 2 of sub-rule (i) under rule 44 and sub-rule (3) under rule 92 while promulgating G.O.Ms No. 44 Home (Cinemas-A) Department dated 7.1.1991 As the records do not reveal any other material in support of the deletion, the abovesaid G.O.Ms No. 44 dated 7.1.1991 is struck down as illegal and arbitrary. For the reasons stated above, the writ petitions are allowed. No costs. In view of the disposal of the main writ petitions, W.M.P Nos. 11258 and 19196 of 1991 are closed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P. Perumal And 8 Oth... v. State Of Tamil Nadu ...
    (Apr 28, 1999)