Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Companies Act or the Co-operative Societies Act.
  • SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT
  • Bombay Cooperative Societies Act, 1925.
  • Nadu Co-operative Societies Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Companies Act or the Co-operative Societies Act.
  • SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT
  • Bombay Cooperative Societies Act, 1925.
  • Nadu Co-operative Societies Act.

    T. Vijaya Rajan v. State Of Tamil Nadu, Rep. By The Commissioner And Secretary To Govt. Cooperation Dept., Madras.

    1. These two writ petitions are preferred by the same petitioner who was an employee of the third respondent Co-operative Stores. The first writ petition is directed against an order of the second respondent, namely, Registrar of Co-operative Societies dismissing the petitioner's revision application against the order of suspension pending' enquiry into the charges framed against him. The second writ petition is directed against the final order of dismissal from service.

    2. The petitioner appeared in person and argued the matter. He fairly stated that in view of the final order of dismissal, the writ petition challenging the order of suspension has become infructuous. Accordingly, W.P 7978 of 1986 is dismissed as infructuous and without going into the merits. No costs.

    3. Regarding W.P 13070 of 1986, Mr. Ibrahim Kalifullah, learned counsel appearing for the 3rd respondent raised a preliminary objection as to the maintainability of the writ petition. According to the learned counsel, the relief prayed for is only against the 3rd respondent and the respondents 1 and 2 are impleaded as parties just to make it appear that some relief is also asked for against them.

    4. As I am inclined to accept the preliminary objection raised by the learned counsel for the third respondent, I do not consider that I should set out the facts in detail or discuss the points raised by the petitioner in challenging the order of dismissal passed by tne third respondent.

    5. According to the learned counsel for the third respondent, the relationship between the Co-operative Society and its employees is that of a master and servant and therefore, even if there is a wrongful dismissal of, the employee, the court cannot interfere in exercise of the powers, under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India. He further submitted that it is open to the petitioner to raise an industrial dispute or to avail himself of the alternative remedy available under the provi-, sions of the Tamil Nadu Co-operative Societies Act. In support of his contention, he, relied on two unreported Division Bench', judgments of this Court in Ranhiappa v. Sriperumbudur Taluk Co-op. Marketing Society Ltd, W.P 677 of 1977, order, dt. 27-9-1979., and Balakrishnan v. Special Offlcer and Mg. Director, Tamil Nadu State Coop. Bank Ltd. W.Ps 1042 and 1043 of 1977, order, dt. 22-10-79. He also placed before me the judgment of Nainar Sundaram, J., who has followed the above referred Division Bench judgments in the case Baskaran and others v. State Bank of India Staff Co-op. Society Ltd., rep. by its Secretary, Madras, and others. The learned counsel also relied on a judgment of the Supreme Court in S.S Dhanoa v. Municipal Corporation, Delhi and others. This judgment of the Supreme Court has also been noticed and relied on by Nainar Sundaram, J., in the judgment referred to above.

    6. The principle laid down in the Division Bench judgment referred to above is to the following effect—

    “Notwithstanding the wide amplitude of Art. 226 of the Constitution when compared with Art. 12 of the Constitution, a writ can issue only against the State or authority contemplated under Art. 12 and not to a company registered under the Companies Act or the Co-operative Societies Act. The relationship between: the Co-operative Society and its employees is that of master and servant and that, therefore, even if there is a wrongful dismissal of the employee the Court cannot issue a writ of mandamus directing, reinstatement or a declaration that the termination of service is wrongful”.

    In the judgment of the Supreme Court referred to above, it is held as follows—

    “There is a distinction between a corporation established by or under an Act and a body incorporated under an Act. The distinction was brought out by this Court in Sukhdev Singh v. Bhogataran Sardar Singh Raghavanshi 1975-3 S.C.R 619=A.I.R 1975 S.C 1331.. It is observed:—

    A company incorporated under the Companies Act is not created by the Companies Act but comes into existence in accordance with the provisions of the Act. Tnere is thus a well-marked distinction between a body which, after coming into existence, is governed in accordance with the provisions of a statute, In Sabhjit Tewary v. Union of India 1975-3 S.C.R 619=A.I.R 1975 S.C 1329., the question arose whether the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research which was a society registered under the Societies Registration. Act, was a statutory body. It was urged that because the Council of. Scientific and Industrial Research had Government nominees as the President of the body and derived guidance and financial aid from the Government, it was a statutory body, Repelling the contention, the court observed (at page 1330 of A.I.R)—‘The Society does not have a statutory character like the Oil and Natural Gas Commission, or the Life Insurance Corporation or Industrial Finance Corporation. It is a society incorporated in accordance with the provisions of the Societies Registration Act. The fact that the Prime Minister is the President or that the Government appoints nominees to the Governing Body or that the Government may terminate the membership will not establish anything more than the fact that the Government takes, special care that the promotion, guidance, and co-operation of scientific and industrial research, the institution and financing of specific researches, establishment or development and assistance to special institution or department of the existing institutions for scientific study or problems affecting particular industry in a trade, the utilisation of the result of the research conducted under the auspices of the Council towaids the development of industries in the country are carried out in a responsible manner.

    Whatever has been said with regard to the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research which was a society registered under the Societies Registration Act equally applies to the Co-operative Store Ltd., which is a society registered under the Bombay Cooperative Societies Act, 1925. It is not a statutory body because it is not created by a statute. It is a body created by an act of a group of individuals in accordance with the provisions of a statute.”

    Nainar Sundaram, J. in the judgment cited above, after noticing all these cases, has ruled as follows—

    “It is true that a writ under Art. 226 may lie against a body, though not a ‘State’ within Art. 12, The, words'any person'in Art. 226 would only mean any person to whom, according to the well established principles, a writ could issue. This Court cannot grant reliefs against purely private bodies or individuals under Art. 226 to enforce private rights such as the one arising from a contract of employment. A writ will issue under Art. 226 not only against the State and its officials who seek to enforce the law made by the State, but also against private bodies or individuals who claim against the petitioner under, that law. In such a contingency, the petitioners would be entitled to relief not only against the State and its officials, but also against private bodies or individuals, for, otherwise, the reliefs against the State and the officials would be infructuous. But, here in the present case, the grievances expressed by the petitioners are with reference to non-employment and orders of dismissal, based on the elationship of master and servant. As on date, we have two pronouncements of a Bench of this Court, which are squarely applicable to the facts of the present cases and I am bound by them and the attempt made by the learned counsel for the petitioners to get out of the ratio of the Bench could not fructify. Accordingly, these writ petitions are dismissed, I make no order as to costs.”

    As against this, a judgment of mine reported in Varadarajan v. Special Officer, T.V.C.S Ltd. 98 L.W 428., has been brought to my notice wherein I have held that writ against Special Officer, T.U.C.S Ltd., Madras is maintainable. In that judgment, I have specifically stated that T.U.C.S Ltd., stands on a different footing as it is controlled by Government and 85 per cent of the shares are held by the Government. Further, I have also pointed out that a Division Bench of this Court in W.A 74 of 1970 (judgment, dt. 18.11.1973) has rejected a similar preliminary objection as to the maintainability of the writ petition against T.U.C.S In the light of the later pronouncements and particularly in the light of the view expressed by the Supreme Court noted above, I do not think that my decision reported in S. Varadarajan v. Special officer, T.U.C.S Ltd., can be pressed into service to the facts of this case.

    7. In the light of the consistent rulings of this Court, I uphold the preliminary objection raised by the learned counsel for the 3rd respondent. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed as not maintainable. It is however made clear that it is open to the petitioner to seek other alternative remedy. There will be no order as to costs.

    VCS/RR

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    T. Vijaya Rajan v. State Of Tamil Nadu,...
    (Jul 6, 1987)