Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 397 I.P.C read with Ss. 39 and 44(c) of the Indian Electricity Act.
  • Ss. 39 and 44(c) of the Indian Electricity Act read with S. 379, I.P.C
  • S. 36(a) of the Tamil Nadu Forest Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 397 I.P.C read with Ss. 39 and 44(c) of the Indian Electricity Act.
  • Ss. 39 and 44(c) of the Indian Electricity Act read with S. 379, I.P.C
  • S. 36(a) of the Tamil Nadu Forest Act,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Quashing Petition — C.C. No. 173 of 1986)

Factual and Procedural Background

The accused in C.C. No. 173 of 1986 (Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Dindigul) filed an application under Section 482 Cr.P.C. seeking quashing of the proceedings against him. The factual sequence in the opinion is as follows:

  • On 27-8-1984 the Assistant Divisional Engineer, T.N.E.B., Palani, complained that during inspection of a three-phase meter (S.C. 160 Neikkarapatti) belonging to the petitioner, M.R.T. seals were missing and recorded units had been reduced, amounting to alleged electricity theft.
  • Police registered Cr. No. 435 of 1984 (Palani Taluk Police Station) under S. 397 I.P.C. read with Ss. 39 and 44(c) of the Indian Electricity Act and Muthuswami, Sub-Inspector, investigated, examining ten witnesses.
  • On 7-5-1985 the investigating Sub-Inspector submitted a final report under S. 173 Cr.P.C. concluding that no case was made out and referring the matter as a “mistake of fact.” A refer notice under S. 169 Cr.P.C. was served on the petitioner on 18-5-1985.
  • The Sub-Divisional Magistrate, on 12-6-1985, after perusal, accepted the final report and recorded the matter as “mistake of fact.” The referred charge-sheet was numbered 104 of 1985.
  • On 27-9-1985 the Inspector of Police, following directions of the Superintendent of Police and on advice of the Public Prosecutor, reopened the investigation and on 22-1-1986 filed a charge-sheet under Ss. 39 and 44(c) of the Indian Electricity Act read with S. 379 I.P.C. in the same crime number.
  • The Magistrate returned the charge-sheet on 14-2-1986 querying whether permission had been obtained to reopen; the police resubmitted on 15-2-1986 seeking permission and stating circumstances. On 19-2-1986 the Magistrate granted permission to investigate, took cognizance, numbered the case C.C. 173 of 1986 and issued summons to the accused.
  • Upon receipt of the summons the accused filed the present quashing petition under S. 482 Cr.P.C.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after a Sub-Inspector has submitted a final report under S. 173 Cr.P.C. referring the matter as a “mistake of fact” and the Magistrate has accepted that report and recorded the matter accordingly, a subsequent investigation by the Inspector of Police and filing of a fresh charge-sheet (without the prior order of the Magistrate being set aside by a competent forum) is legal and proper.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The order passed by the Magistrate recording the police report as “mistake of fact” is a judicial order rendered by the Magistrate in his judicial capacity and has attained finality unless reversed by a competent forum.
  • Because that earlier judicial order has not been reversed, the subsequent proceedings (reopening of investigation and filing of a fresh charge-sheet) are vitiated by illegality and should be quashed.
  • When the charge-sheet was filed the earlier police report was not pending before the Magistrate and the Magistrate had not taken cognizance on that earlier report; therefore a superior officer cannot reinvestigate or file a fresh charge-sheet in those circumstances.

Respondent's (State/Government Advocate) Arguments

  • Relying on Section 173(8) Cr.P.C., the State contends that the police may conduct further investigation after forwarding a report under sub-section (2) and may forward a further report if further evidence is obtained; thus filing a fresh charge-sheet on reinvestigation is permissible even if the matter was earlier referred as “mistake of fact.”

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Namassivayam v. State, 1981 Mad LW (Cri) 151 : 1982 Cri LJ 707 When a Magistrate, after perusing a police report, passes an order recording “no case” or “mistake of law/fact,” that order is judicial in nature; reinvestigation and filing a charge-sheet on the same complaint by the police (without privilege of fresh complaint, Magistrate's permission, or agitating the order) is illegal. The court relied on this decision to hold that a Magistrate's order recording “mistake of fact” is judicial and that reinvestigation by police without challenging such an order is impermissible in the present facts.
State of Bihar v. J.A.C. Saldanha (Supreme Court decision cited in Namassivayam) Referenced as an earlier Supreme Court authority relevant to the principle discussed in Namassivayam (specific principle not quoted in the provided text). Used as background authority in Namassivayam which the court relied upon; the opinion cites Namassivayam's consideration of this Supreme Court decision in support of the judicial nature of the Magistrate's order.
Kamalapati Trivedi v. State of West Bengal, 1979 Mad LW (Cri) 48 (SN) : 1979 Cri LJ 679 Orders passed by a Magistrate under sub-section (3) of S. 173 Cr.P.C. and similar judicial orders form part of the judicial process and cannot be viewed in isolation from the judicial function; such orders are made after applying judicial mind. The court cited this decision to reinforce that a Magistrate's acceptance of a police report (discharging an accused or recording “mistake of fact”) is a judicial order and part of the judicial process.
Nagalingam v. State, 1985 Mad LW (Cri) 99 An order passed by a Magistrate after perusing records and the final police report is a judicial order. The court cited this decision for the same proposition that the Magistrate's order is judicial in nature.
Periasami v. Inspector of Police, Ponnagaram Police Station, Dharmapuri, 1984 Mad LW (Cri) 36 : 1984 Cri LJ 239 S. 173(8) Cr.P.C. expressly permits further investigation after a police report has been forwarded to the Magistrate, and empowers the investigating officer to file further reports where additional evidence is obtained (useful where the first report is incomplete or requires correction). The court acknowledged this authority to explain the proper scope of S. 173(8) — namely, that it permits further/revised reports after an original charge-sheet has been filed or where the first report is incomplete — and then distinguished it from the present facts.
Raman Narayanan (in re), 1973 Mad LJ (Cri) 16 : 1973 Cri LJ 1288 Police has the right to reopen investigation and file a supplementary charge-sheet after a final report under S. 173 Cr.P.C. if fresh facts come to light; Magistrate's permission is not necessary for further investigation in such circumstances (as stated in the quoted passage). The court considered this decision and its quoted passage to demonstrate circumstances where S. 173 late-stage or supplemental investigation is allowable, and then distinguished those circumstances from the present case where the Magistrate had recorded “mistake of fact.”

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by (i) setting out the facts and the sequence of police reports and magistrate action, (ii) identifying the single pivotal legal question—whether subsequent police reinvestigation and filing of a charge-sheet was permissible after the Magistrate had accepted a police report recording the matter as “mistake of fact”—and (iii) analysing applicable statutory and judicial authorities.

Key points in the court's step-by-step analysis (as presented in the opinion):

  1. The court observed that earlier decisions of this Court and the Supreme Court (notably Namassivayam and Kamalapati Trivedi) treat an order passed by a Magistrate, after perusing the police final report and recording “mistake of fact” or “mistake of law,” as a judicial order rendered in the Magistrate's judicial capacity.
  2. The court emphasized that where the Magistrate has passed such an order after applying his mind, it assumes the character of a judicial order and cannot be lightly set aside by the prosecution or re-opened by a different police officer without appropriate challenge or judicial reversal.
  3. The court contrasted two different factual patterns addressed in precedent:
    • Cases where an original charge-sheet was filed and later, on the basis of newly discovered or additional evidence, the police filed a supplementary or revised charge-sheet (instances where S.173(8) and decisions like Periasami and Raman Narayanan apply).
    • Cases (like the present one) where the investigating officer submitted a final report treating the matter as a “mistake of fact,” the Magistrate accepted it and recorded the same — creating a judicial order discharging the matter.
  4. The court accepted the respondent's statutory submission that S.173(8) Cr.P.C. permits further investigation and forwarding of further reports when additional evidence is obtained, but held that the scope of S.173(8) must be read in context: it is principally directed at situations where a charge-sheet/report has been filed and later supplemented or revised, not at cases where the Magistrate has already passed a judicial order recording the matter as a “mistake of fact.”
  5. Relying on the ratio in Namassivayam (and related authority), the court held that if the prosecution was aggrieved by the Magistrate's order recording “mistake of fact,” the proper course was to challenge that order before a higher forum and obtain reversal before reinvestigating; unilateral reinvestigation and refiling of a charge-sheet in the same matter without such challenge would be illegal.
  6. The court concluded that the present case falls into the second factual pattern (Magistrate accepted the “mistake of fact” report): consequently the later prosecution action (reinvestigation and filing of charge-sheet leading to C.C. 173 of 1986) could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is allowed and the proceedings against the petitioner are quashed.

Implications (as expressed in the opinion):

  • Direct effect: The criminal proceedings that had been initiated by the later charge-sheet (leading to C.C. No. 173 of 1986) were quashed and the petition for quashing was allowed.
  • Scope and guidance: The court clarified that where a Magistrate, after perusal of the police final report, records the matter as “mistake of fact” (or otherwise acts judicially to record no case), that order is judicial in nature; if the prosecution wishes to challenge that outcome it must do so by agitating the Magistrate's order before a higher forum rather than resorting to unilateral reinvestigation and refiling in the same proceedings. The court distinguished that situation from cases where S.173(8) Cr.P.C. permits supplemental reports after an initial charge-sheet — the latter principle does not permit reopening once the Magistrate has judicially recorded a “mistake of fact” without the Magistrate's order being set aside.

Result stated in the opinion: "Petition allowed."

    K. Ramasubbu v. The State And Another

    1. The accused in C.C No. 173 of 1986 on the file of the Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Dindigul, has filed this application under S. 482 Cr. P.C to quash the said proceedings against him. The said petition came to be filed in the following circumstances. The Assistant Divisional Engineer T.N.E.B Palani, gave a compiaint on 27-8-1984 alleging that during the inspection of S.C 160 Neikkarapatti distribution, belonging to the petitioner, he noticed M.R.T seals provided in three phase meter in the service missing and that the petitioner has committed theft of electricity, by opening the cover of the meter and reduced the recorded units thereunder. On the basis of the said complaint a case was registered against the petitioner in Cr. No. 435 of 1984 Palani Taluk, Police station, under S. 397 I.P.C read with Ss. 39 and 44(c) of the Indian Electricity Act. The said complaint was investigated by one Muthuswami, Sub Inspector, and he examined as many as ten witnesses and after obtaining opinion of the Assistant Public Prosecutors (Grade I and Grade II) sent the final report dt. 7-5-1985 under S. 173 Cr. P.C to the Court, to the effect that no case was made out against the petitioner, and the case was referred as ‘mistake of fact’. Refer notice under S. 169, Cr. P.C was also served on the petitioner on 18-5-1985 and his acknowledgment was obtained. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Dindigul also on receipt of the final report and after perusing the connected records accepted the final report sent by the said Muthuswami and passed an order on 12-6-1985 as follows-Recorded as “mistake of fact”. The referred charge-sheet has been numbered as 104 of 1985.

    2. The Inspector of Police, Palani, as per the directions of the Superintendent of Police, Madurai, and on the advice of the Public Prosecutor, Madurai Dt. reopened the investigation on 27-9-1985 and filed charge-sheet under Ss. 39 and 44(c) of the Indian Electricity Act read with S. 379, I.P.C in the same crime number, on 22-1-1986. When the charge-sheet was returned by the Magistrate on 14-2-1986, whether permission has been obtained to reopen, the respondent resubmitted the same on 15-2-1986 stating the circumstances under which it was reopened and seeking permission to investigate the same. The Magistrate passed an order on 19-2-1986 to the effect that permission is granted to investigate the case. He took cognisance of the case and numbered the same as C.C 173 of 1986 and issued summons to the accused. On receipt of the said summons the accused has filed this application.

    3. According to the petitioner, the earlier order passed by the Magistrate on the police report, as mistake of fact, is a judicial order passed by him in his capacity as court and it has become final. Further, the same has not been reversed by a competent forum at the instance of the respondents. Hence, the entire proceedings are vitiated with illegality and have to be quashed. It is further submitted that on the date when the charge-sheet was filed no police report was pending since the Magistrate has not taken cognisance on the basis of the earlier report submitted by the Sub Inspector, and as such, the respondent, though a superior officer cannot reinvestigate or reopen the case and file a fresh charge-sheet.

    4. The only point that arises for consideration in this quash proceedings is whether, in view of the fact that the Sub Inspector who investigated the case submitted a report under S. 173 Cr. P.C to the Magistrate that the matter has been referred as ‘mistake of fact’ and on the basis of the report the Magistrate accepted the finding and passed orders to the effect ‘Recorded as mistake of fact’ the subsequent investigation by the Inspector of Police and filing the charge-sheet is legal and proper. Already a similar question came up for consideration before this Court and the Supreme Court. In Namassivayam v. State, 1981 Mad LW (Cri) 151 : (1982 Cri LJ 707), Sathar Sayeed, J. after considering the earlier decisions of the Supreme Court reported in State of Bihar v. J.A.C Saldanha, 1980 Mad LW (Cri) 8 (SN) : 1980 Cri LJ 98 at p. 109 and Kamalapati Trivedi v. State of West Bengal, 1979 Mad LW (Cri) 48 (SN) : 1979 Cri LJ 679 at P. 698 held—

    “In this case, the police had once put up a detailed report after complete investigation and on the basis of the report filed by the respondent before the Magistrate against the petitioner, the Magistrate passes an order, which is judicial in nature, to the effect that there is no case and the complaint is recorded as ‘mistake of law’. The Magistrate, while passing the order, exercised his judicial power and discretion and it is an ‘order’ and unless that order is set aside, reinvestigation of the case on the same complaint not by the Superintendent of Police, but at the instance of the Inspector of Police, for the same offence, is an illegality. I can understand if the respondent agitates the earlier order passed by the Magistrate on 16th July, 1977 which was recorded as ‘mistake of law’ at a higher forum and at the same time, startes reinvestigation of the case at the instance of the Superintendent of Police or the Magistrate, and a charge-sheet is filed against the petitioner, then there is some substance in it. But, that is not the case here. In this case, the Magistrate has not taken cognisance at all on the earlier police report submitted by the respondent under S. 173, Cr. P.C Had there been the police report against the petitioner pending before the Magistrate, and if no order is passed on the police report by the Magistrate and if the respondent, while the report is pending before the Magistrate, holds a further detailed inquiry and collects several other particulars of the offence committed by the petitioner and submits a further report, then it can be said that the further investigation by the respondent is not barred when the cognisance of the offence has yet to be taken by the Magistrate. But, the case before us is, that there is no cognisance at all of the earlier enquiry report, and when once the Magistrate passes an order as ‘mistake of law’ on the earlier enquiry report, submitted by the police, it is a judicial order, for the Magistrate has passed the said order after applying his mind on the report submitted by the police, and taking cognisance of the same offence by the Magistrate on a reinvestigation of the case by the police without any fresh complaint by the complainant and without obtaining any permission from Court, is illegal, perverse and contrary to law and should not be allowed to sustain and has, therefore to be set aside.”

    5. In Nagalingam v. State, 1985 Mad LW (Cri) 99, S.A Kader, J. also was of the opinion that an order passed by a Magistrate on perusing the records and the final report of the police is a judicial order in his capacity as court.

    6. On the other hand, it was contended by the learned Government Advocate that in view of S. 173(8), Cr. P.C the police can file’ a fresh charge-sheet on the reinvestigation and there is no bar in filing charge-sheet even though originally it was referred as ‘mistake of fact’. Sec. 173(8), Cr. P.C reads as follows—

    “Nothing in this section shall be deemed to preclude further investigation in respect of an offence after a report under sub-sec. (2) has been forwarded to the Magistrate, and, whereupon such investigation, the officer in charge of the police station obtains further evidence, oral or documentary, he shall forward to the Magistrate a further report or reports regarding such evidence in the form prescribed; and the provisions of sub-secs. (2) to (6) shall, as far as may be, apply in relation to such report or reports as they apply in relation to a report forwarded under sub-sec. (2)”.

    7. Sub-section (2) refers to the ‘report’ to be submitted in the form prescribed by the State Government to the court by the investigating officer as soon as it is completed. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner, Sec. 173(2), Cr. P.C refers to a case where the offence is made out. Natarajan J. (as he then was) in Periasami v. Inspector of Police Ponnagaram Police Station, Dharmapuri, 1984 Mad LW (Cri) 36 : (1984 Cri LJ 239) held -

    “Sec. 173(8), Cr. P.C has been newly added in order to make it expressly clear that merely because an investigating officer has sent a police report to the magistrate, he will not stand precluded from making further investigation in the case and submitting to a further report or reports to the Magistrate regarding the additional evidence gathered by him in the further investigation. Because of this express provision, it should not be taken that if a police officer had committed an error in giving full and proper particulars regarding the names of parties, the nature of information, the names of witnesses, etc. in his first report, he cannot correct the mistake by filing a second report. When the Code provides for even further investigation being done after a report is filed before a Magistrate, there can be no bar whatever for the Police filing a second or revised report on the materials already gathered during the investigation especially when the second report is intended to set right certain mistakes or omissions in the first report. The matter should, therefore, be viewed in its proper perspective.”

    8. That was a case where originally the charge-sheet was filed against four persons under S. 36(a) of the Tamil Nadu Forest Act, and subsequently a revised charge-sheet was filed to the effect that two other persons along with four others entered into a criminal conspiracy in committing theft of sandalwood from the patta land. There the question arose whether, in view of S. 173(1), Cr. P.C on the evidence available, the subsequent charge-sheet can be filed. On a perusal of S. 173(8), Cr. P.C the investigating officer is certainly empowered to forward a further report or reports on the basis of the further evidence available subsequent to the filing of the original charge-sheet. The same question was also considered in Namasivayam v. State, 1981 Mad LW (Cri) 151 : (1982 Cri LJ 707) and Sathar Sayeed, J. held in para 13, as follows—

    “I may at this stage state that if a police officer after he lays a charge-sheet gets information or additional information, he can still investigate and lay further charge-sheet. Where the first report made by the police to the Magistrate, though was incomplete, contained all the particulars and a supplementary report containing all the particulars is filed sub-sequently giving the particulars and details of the witnesses, who are merely formal witnesses, the first report is in fact a complete report as required by S. 173(2)(i), Cr. P.C and it is not vitiated by the mere fact that the supplementary report is filed subsequently. But, that is not the case here.”

    9. The same question was considered by a Division bench of the Kerala High Court in Raman Narayanan in re, 1973 Mad LJ (Cri) 16 : (1973 Cri LJ 1288) wherein it was held—

    “Law is well-settled that the police has the right to reopen the investigation even after the submission of the charges under S. 173 Cr. P.C if such facts come to light. The Police has the right to file a supplementary charge-sheet after a final report under S. 173 Cr. P.C was filed. If a police officer after laying charge gets further information, he can still investigate and lay further charge-sheet. If fresh facts come to light after a final report, Magistrate's permission is not necessary for further investigation. So in this case the police officer was right in bringing to the notice of the Sub Magistrate that the charge was laid against a wrong person.”

    10. All these cases only deal with cases where originally charge-sheet was filed against accused and subsequently revised charge-sheet was filed on getting fresh materials. But, that is not the case here. In the instant case, the investigating officer after making investigation by examining as many as ten witnesses referred the case as ‘mistake of fact’ and submitted a report to this effect to the court and the Magistrate has also accepted the same and ordered ‘Recorded as mistake of fact’. As held by this court and the Supreme Court in the earlier cases referred to, the said order is a judicial order. If really the prosecution was aggrieved by the said order and wants to reopen the case, they should have agitated the matter and challenged the said order passed by the Magistrate and then after obtaining necessary order from the higher forum, reinvestigated the case. It was observed by Sathar Sayeed, J. in the above quoted decision—

    “There must be a limit for investigation of the complaint by the Police. The police cannot at the instance of one officer after enquiry, say that there is no case against the petitioner and that report having been accepted by the Magistrate, subsequently at the instance of another police officer, as in this case the Inspector of Police says that there is a case against the petitioner.”

    11. It is needless to say that under S. 173(3), Cr. P.C it is open to the Magistrate either to agree with the police report or not to agree with the same and he can direct further inquiry and give suitable directions. Even in cases when the report was filed charging the accused, it is open to the Magistrate either to take cognisance of the offence under S. 190(1)(b), Cr. P.C or take the view that the facts disclosed do not make out an offence and decline to take cognisance. In Kamalapati Trivedi v. State of West Bengal, 1979 Mad LW (Cri) 48 (SN) : 1979 Cri LJ 679 it was held—

    “Thus in the case of an order passed by a Magistrate under sub-sec. (3) of S. 173 of the Code in agreement with the police report does not call for any hearing or the production of any evidence on the part of the accused, as it goes in his favour. If the Magistrate, on the other hand, disagrees with the report submitted by the police and takes cognisance of the offence, the accused comes into the picture and thereafter shall have the right to be heard and to adduce evidence in support of his innocence. Viewed in this context, all orders passed by a Magistrate acting judicially such as orders of bail and those passed under sub-sec. (3) of S. 173 of the Code discharging an accused or orders taking cognisance of the offence complained of are parts of an integral whole which may end with a definite judgment after an inquiry of a trial, or earlier according to the exigencies of the situation obtaining at a particular stage, and which involves, if need be, the adducing of evidence and the decision of the Magistrate on an appreciation thereof. They cannot be viewed in isolation and given a character different from the entire judicial process of which they are intended to form a part.”

    12. Thus, in view of the ratio laid down in the above decision, it is clear that the order passed by the Magistrate on the basis of the first report submitted by the Sub Inspector is a judicial order. The second revised report contemplated under S. 173(8) of the Code is only in case where the charge-sheet is filed and subsequently revised or additional charge-sheet is contemplated on the further materials available, and not in a case where the case was already referred as mistake of fact and accepted by court. For all these reasons, I am of the view that the proceeding against the petitioner is liable to be quashed and consequently it is quashed. The petition is allowed.

    13. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K. Ramasubbu v. The State And Another
    (Nov 11, 1986)