Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as the Act),
  • section 2(24)(viii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961,
  • INCOME TAX ACT
  • provisions of section 280(d).
  • Finance Act of 1962,
  • section 280(d)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as the Act),
  • section 2(24)(viii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961,
  • INCOME TAX ACT
  • provisions of section 280(d).
  • Finance Act of 1962,
  • section 280(d)
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Ramaprasada Rao, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This reference arose at the instance of the revenue under section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 challenging the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Madras decision which held that a part payment of a refund of an annuity deposit (Rs. 1,509) for the assessment year 1967–68 was not income in the hands of each of two minor nominees. Two appeals before the Tribunal involved the same question and were consolidated for the reference.

The underlying facts, as set out in the opinion, are: Shri Murugappa Chettiar made annuity deposits (Rs. 2,000 on 29-10-1964 and Rs. 11,070 on 2-3-1965) under Chapter XII-A of the Act and nominated two minors (M.M. Murugappan and M.M. Venkatachalam) to receive repayments in the event of his death. Shri Murugappa Chettiar died on 1-1-1965. Each nominee received Rs. 1,509 in the year under consideration. The Income-tax Officer and the Appellate Assistant Commissioner had assessed these receipts as income in the hands of each minor. The assessees contended that the receipts were not their income because the annuity was not created by them but derived from the acts of a third party (the depositor), whereas the revenue contended the receipts retained the character of income and should be taxed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal was correct in holding that the part payment of refund of annuity deposit in the sum of Rs. 1,509 (referable to the assessment year 1967–68) was not income liable to tax within the meaning of section 2(24)(viii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, in the hands of each of the assessees (the nominees)?

Arguments of the Parties

Assessees' Arguments

  • The amounts received by each minor were not income in their hands because the annuity (and the deposit) was not created by them; the receipts resulted from the depositor's act and nomination.
  • Because the annuity repayments arose from the depositor's action, the receipts lacked the characteristic of "income" as arising from their own exertion or activity.

Revenue's (Applicant's) Arguments

  • Even though the receipts were by reason of the act of a third party, they retained the badge of income and should be taxed in the hands of the recipients.
  • Because the depositor took a deduction when making the annuity deposit, it would be equitable to tax the sums received in repayment even if receipted by the depositor's nominees.
  • Reliance was placed on the definition of "income" in section 2(24)(viii) which includes any annuity due or commuted value paid under section 280(d), arguing that this supports taxation of such instalments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner of Income-tax v. Hukumchand Mohanlal, [1971] 82 ITR 624 (SC) Principle that where the Act contains no provision making a successor or legal representative liable in respect of the subject-matter under discussion, there is no liability on such successor/representative to pay tax. The court applied this principle analogously to hold that in the absence of a specific provision in the Act or the Annuity Deposit Scheme taxing repayments made to nominees, those nominees cannot be treated as taxable on such receipts.
Commissioner of Income-tax v. Narottamdas K. Nawab, [1976] 102 ITR 455 (Guj) Held that instalments received by a nominee retain the character of income and are taxable in the nominee's hands (broader proposition adopted by that High Court). The court considered and rejected the broad proposition in this Gujarat High Court decision, distinguishing it and declining to follow its ratio on the facts and on principles of statutory construction and taxing power.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded along statutory construction and principle-based lines, focusing on the precise language of the taxing provisions and the limited scope of a taxing statute:

  1. Statutory framework: Chapter XII-A (effective 1-4-1964) defined "annuity deposit" and section 280(d) contemplated an Annuity Deposit Scheme under which the Central Government would repay annuity deposits to the depositor in ten annual equated instalments. The Scheme also provided for nomination by a depositor so that repayments could be made to nominated persons upon the depositor's death.
  2. Nature of section 2(24)(viii): The court observed that section 2(24)(viii) of the Act includes any annuity due or commuted value of any annuity paid under section 280(d). The court treated this as a statutory fiction that renders the annually repaid instalments income in the hands of the depositor (i.e., the fiction applies to the depositor for the purpose of taxing those instalments).
  3. Absence of a charging provision for nominees: The court emphasized that a taxing statute must be explicit and cannot be extended by intendment or equitable considerations. There was, in the court's view, no charging section in the Act that would bring to tax the instalments when received by the nominees instead of the depositor. The statutory fiction in s.2(24)(viii) operates to treat the repayment as income of the depositor, but it does not, by itself, create a charge on the nominee.
  4. Principle of strict construction in taxation: The court reiterated the fundamental principle that taxation provisions must be construed strictly in favour of the assessee when there is doubt. The court rejected the revenue's plea that equity required taxing the nominees merely because the depositor previously obtained a deduction.
  5. Reliance on precedent: The court invoked the Supreme Court's decision in Commissioner of Income-tax v. Hukumchand Mohanlal to support the proposition that liability does not arise where the statute does not provide for it. By contrast, the court examined the Gujarat High Court's decision in Narottamdas K. Nawab and declined to follow its broader proposition that the instalments retain their original character as income in the hands of nominees.
  6. Practical illustration and policy consideration: The court used a practical example to underscore the difficulty of accepting the revenue's position — showing that taxing nominees irrespective of their individual taxable capacity or lack of a charging provision would create anomalous results and could not be justified absent explicit statutory authority.
  7. Conclusion of reasoning: Because the instalments were paid to the nominees by virtue of nomination and no specific provision in the Act or the Scheme charged such receipts to tax in the nominees' hands, the amounts were not "income" of the nominees within the meaning of the Act.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The reference question is answered against the applicant (the revenue) and in favour of the assessees (the nominees). The court ordered costs in favour of the assessees and fixed the assessees' counsel's fee at Rs. 250.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the installments of the annuity refund (Rs. 1,509 each) received by the two minor nominees were held not to be taxable income in their hands for the assessment year in question.
  • The court relied on principles of strict statutory construction of taxing provisions and on the absence of any express charging provision making nominees taxable for such repayments. Accordingly, the decision limits the revenue's ability to tax amounts received by nominees in lieu of a depositor absent clear statutory authority.
  • The opinion does not purport to create a new broad principle beyond the application of established rules of statutory construction to the facts; the court expressly refused to follow the broader view taken by the Gujarat High Court in the Narottamdas case. The decision therefore addresses the specific statutory and factual context rather than establishing a generalized new tax principle.

Costs ordered: the assessee shall have his counsel's fee fixed at Rs. 250 (Rupees two hundred and fifty only).

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Madras-Ii v. M.M Muthiah.

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Ramaprasada Rao, J.:— At the instance of the revenue, the following question of law has been referred to us to give an answer thereto:

    “Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was right in holding that the part payment of refund of annuity deposit in the sum of Rs. 1,509 referable to the assessment year 1967–68 was not an income liable to tax within the meaning of section 2(24)(viii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, in the hands of each of the assessees?”

    2. Two appeals were disposed of by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Madras, in which the appellant was Shri M.M Muthiah, as father and guardian of the minors, and the respondent in the present reference is also Shri M.M Muthiah, as father and guardian of the two minors.

    3. A common question arose in both the appeals. Hence the two applications filed by the Commissioner of Income-tax, Madras-II, under section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”), were consolidated.

    4. Shri Murugappa Chettiar paid a sum of Rs. 2,000 on October 29, 1964, as annuity deposit referable to the assessment year 1964-65. Another sum of Rs. 11,070 under the same head was paid on March 2, 1965, in respect of the assessment year 1965-66. He nominated two minors, M.M Murug-appan and M.M Venkatachalam, jointly as his nominees to receive the refunds, in case he dies which nomination he could do under the provisions of the Annuity Deposit Scheme of 1964. On the death of Murugappa Chettiar on January 1, 1965, the above nominees became entitled to receive by way of repayment of the instalments which were payable under the Annuity Deposit Scheme to the assessee, but in the instant case to the nominees by virtue of the nomination. Each of the minors, who is hereinafter referred to as the “assessee”, received a sum of Rs. 1,509 in the year under consideration. Both the Income-tax Officer and the Appellate Assistant Commissioner assessed the said receipt in the hands of each of the assessees as their income. The assessees' contention throughout was that it is not income in their hands as the annuity was not created by them and that the receipt in the instant case is the result of an overt act on the part of Shri Murugappa Chettiar and it would not have the characteristic of income in their hands. The department, on the other hand, would maintain that notwithstanding the fact that the receipt in the hands of the assessee of the refund is by reason of the act of a third party, yet it would retain the badge of income in their hands. It was also contended that as annuity deposit when made by the depositor, was taken as a deduction in computing the taxable income of the depositor, it is equitable to bring to tax the sums received in repayment even though they are receipted only by the nominees of the depositor. The Tribunal, after appreciating the contentions of the parties, was of the view that the said receipt by the assessees would not be income. Hence the reference on the question at the instance of the department.

    5. Chapter XII-A, which became effective from April 1, 1964, defined annuity deposit as meaning “a deposit of money required to be made under the provisions of this Chapter”. It is not in dispute that Shri Murugappa Chettiar was a person who was obliged to make the annuity deposit. section 280(d) of the Act contemplates the framing of an annuity deposit scheme. It also says that the Central Government shall repay to the depositor the annuity deposit made or recovered in any year in ten annual equated instalments of principal and interest at such rate as may be notified by the Central Government in the Official Gazette. There is also a provision for the computation of the annuity at the prescribed computed value. Section 280 of the Act amplifies the provision for the framing of the annuity deposit scheme. This scheme shall be notified in the official Gazette and it relates to the deposits made under Chapter XII-A. One of the provisions in the scheme, which refers to the entitlement of the depositor, provides for the nomination of any person to receive the annuity or any other sum due under this Chapter to any depositor in the event of his death There is also a contemporaneous provision for the cancellation of such nomination or a change in it.

    6. The argument of the learned counsel for the applicant is that the refund of the instalment to the nominee under an annuity deposit scheme would be income in the receipter's hands. Reliance is placed upon the definition of “income” in section 2(24) of the Act. “Income” under section 2(24)(viii) of the Act includes any annuity due or commuted value of any annuity paid under the provisions of section 280(d). This fictional inclusion of the annuity referred to in section 280(d) is significant. section 280(d) refers to the repayment to the depositor of the annuity deposit-in ten annual equated instalments. Therefore, it is only in such circumstances and by a statutory fiction that the annually repaid instalment is treated as income in the hands of the depositor.

    7. While interpreting a taxing statute, there is no scope for intendment or assumption. Unless the charging section is expressive and clear, it is not possible to include all amounts received by an assessee as his income on the only contention that it would be equitable to do so. It is fundamental that there is no equity in a tax. If a slight doubt arises whether the money in the hands of an assessee is assessable at all as income, then it is also equally rational to interpret such a provision in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. It, therefore, follows that the contention of the revenue that the refunds received by the nominees of the depositor should in equity be assessed to such income as if it is their income is fallacious. In our view, there is, as at present, no charging section which would bring to tax the instalments received by a nominee of a depositor under the charging head “income” within the meaning of section 2(24)(viii) of the Act. It may be of interest to note that the above sub-clause in section 2(24) has been inserted by the Finance Act of 1962, and notwithstanding the fact that the annuity deposit scheme is said to have been framed subsequently, no change in the definition of “income” has been made so far. As it is not possible for the revenue to extend the area of taxation without express authority for the purpose derived from one or the other of the charging sections in the Act, we are of the view that the contention of the applicant that it would be equitable to do so is unsound.

    8. The principle laid down by the Supreme Court in Commissioner of Income-tax v. Hukumchand Mohanlal, [1971] 82 ITR 624 (SC) is that if the Act did not contain any provision making a successor in business or the legal representative of an assessee liable in the subject-matter under discussion— in that case thus it was, because of lack of a legal provision-there was no liability on the legal representative of the original assessee to pay taxi on the deemed profits of the original assessee. Here also we are confronted with a similar situation. When the instalments are refunded after the depositor makes the annuity deposit in accordance with the provisions of the Act and the Scheme, then such instalments are added on to his income and he is liable to pay income-tax on it as if it is income earned during the year of receipt. But in the absence of a specific provision in the Annuity Deposit Scheme or in the Act (which contemplates a nomination on the part of the depositor), to tax refund of annuity deposit in instalments to nominees then we are in vain to find a charging section which could bring to tax such annual instalments received by the assessee not by virtue of any commercial activity of their own, not even by any deeming provision under the Act or under the Scheme, but by a fortuitous circumstance in that they were the nominees entitled to receive such instalments which nomination was made by the deceased depositor. We are, therefore, unable to accept the second contention that it would be equitable to bring to assessment the sums received by the assessees even though they received it only as nominees of the depositor. The other contention is that the amount in-the hands of the assessees which they received as nominees of the depositor retains the characteristic of income. We are of the view that neither in the popular sense nor in the sense the Act defines “income”, the amount received by the assessees in the instant case would be income. In the popular sense “income” would mean the resultant of exertion or activity. In the statutory sense, it might take into its fold such monies, though not popularly or commercially understood as income, but deemed to be income under the provisions of the Act. The instalment repayable under the Annuity Deposit Scheme undoubtedly is the income in the hands of the depositor. Bat the depositor nominated the assessees to receive the same. It is in effect a gift of an annuity made by the depositor. Such monies received by the depositor cannot still retain the badge of income which is liable to tax under the Act. We have already expressed the view that there is no specific provision to bring to tax such receipts in the hands of the nominees. On first principles, it appears to be so clear that the amount received by the nominees, in the circumstances above stated, would not be “income”. Strong reliance, however, was placed by Mr. Rangaswamy, learned counsel, on a decision of the Gujarat High Court reported in Commissioner of Income-tax v. Narottamdas K. Nawab, [1976] 102 ITR 455 (Guj). There the learned judges were of the view that from a broader point of view, the instalments received by the nominee would retain its characteristic as income. The learned judges put it on the ground that the annuity deposit scheme being one of the measures to curb inflation and it was in that broad sense they were of the view that the character of the receipt, namely, income, which was originally received by him, does not change by reason of the fact that instead of being received in a particular year, it is received in ten equal instalments and that too by his nominees. Mr. Rangaswamy appearing for the applicant did not urge before us that the amount in the hands of the assessee would be an annuity as known to the general law. But he would rely squarely on the ratio of the Gujarat case. If the intendment of the Act and its provisions were such that the receipt of money in the hands of the nominee would be income, then certain inconvenient situations are likely to arise. According to the revenue, it is the refunded money that is taxable income because it was originally liable to tax. Supposing it is receipted by a person who is not liable to tax at all under the provisions of the Income-tax Act, then the question is whether he would be assessed on the receipted instalments, notwithstanding the fact that such amounts so received by him annually fall short of the minimum income which could be brought to tax in any financial year. To expatiate, supposing an assessee receives an income of five thousand rupees per year and he receives one thousand rupees by way of refund of an annual instalment in the capacity as nominee of a depositor, both the amounts put together will still fall short of the assessable income under the present provisions of law. Is it possible, therefore, to assess that portion of the amount receipted by the nominee irrespective of the taxable level on the only ground that the depositor was liable to pay the tax and, therefore, the nominee cannot escape the tax? We are unable to see any justification in it as the contention of the revenue, if accepted, should apply to all situations uniformly and as it cannot apply in the illustration given by us, it makes us think that the amount received by a nominee of a depositor under the annuity deposit scheme would not be his income and it is not exigible to tax under the provisions of the Act. With great respect, we are unable to accept the broad proposition set down by the Gujarat High Court in [1976] 102 ITR 455, (Commissioner of Income-tax v. Narottamdas K. Nawab).

    9. The question is, therefore, answered against the applicant and in favour of the assessee with costs. The assessee shall have his counsel's fee fixed at Rs. 250 (Rupees two hundred and fifty only).

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Madras-Ii v. M.M Muthiah.
    (Jan 4, 1977)