AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (7) of rule 5 of the Central Sales-lax (Madras) Rules 1957 and sub-sec. (3) of Section 9 of the Central Sales-tax Act 1956,
  • (4) of Section 13, the State Government made the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules 1957, of which rule 5
  • Section 13(4) of the Central Act, sub-rule (7) of rule 5 of the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules
  • provisions of the Mysore Sales-tax Act and Sections 8(2) and 9(1) and (3) of the Central Act.
  • Section 13(3) of the Central Act to sustain sub-rule (7) But Section 13(3)
  • rules called the Madras General Sales-tax Rules 1939 of which rule 17
  • sub-rule (7). The Madras General Sales-tax Act 1939 by Section 9
  • Madras General Sales-tax Act 1939. Section 9 of this Act
  • Section 16 of the Madras General Sales-tax Act 1959
  • rule 5(7) of the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules 1957
  • Section 13(3) and (4) of the Central Salestax Act.
  • SECTION 7 CENTRAL SALES TAX ACT 1956
  • Section 13(4) of the Central Sales-tax Act
  • sub-sec. (3) of Section 9 of the Central Act
  • Section 5(3)(a) of the Mysore Salestax Act.
  • Section 9(1) of the Central Act referred
  • State Acts While sub-sec. (1) of Section 9
  • Madras General Sales Tax Act 1939
  • Madras General Sales-lax Act 1959
  • Section 16 of the Madras 1959 Act,
  • Madras General Salestax Act, 1959.
  • Section 9(3) of the Central Act
  • Section 13 of the Central Act
  • CENTRAL SALES TAX ACT 1956
  • Central Sales-lax Act 1956,
  • Central Salestax Act 1956,
  • sub-sec. (3) of Section 9
  • Section 9 and rule 17
  • Sec. 8(2). Section 9(1)
  • Section 19(2)(f)
  • Sub-rule (5)
  • Sub-rule (7)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (7) of rule 5 of the Central Sales-lax (Madras) Rules 1957 and sub-sec. (3) of Section 9 of the Central Sales-tax Act 1956,
  • (4) of Section 13, the State Government made the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules 1957, of which rule 5
  • Section 13(4) of the Central Act, sub-rule (7) of rule 5 of the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules
  • provisions of the Mysore Sales-tax Act and Sections 8(2) and 9(1) and (3) of the Central Act.
  • Section 13(3) of the Central Act to sustain sub-rule (7) But Section 13(3)
  • rules called the Madras General Sales-tax Rules 1939 of which rule 17
  • sub-rule (7). The Madras General Sales-tax Act 1939 by Section 9
  • Madras General Sales-tax Act 1939. Section 9 of this Act
  • Section 16 of the Madras General Sales-tax Act 1959
  • rule 5(7) of the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules 1957
  • Section 13(3) and (4) of the Central Salestax Act.
  • SECTION 7 CENTRAL SALES TAX ACT 1956
  • Section 13(4) of the Central Sales-tax Act
  • sub-sec. (3) of Section 9 of the Central Act
  • Section 5(3)(a) of the Mysore Salestax Act.
  • Section 9(1) of the Central Act referred
  • State Acts While sub-sec. (1) of Section 9
  • Madras General Sales Tax Act 1939
  • Madras General Sales-lax Act 1959
  • Section 16 of the Madras 1959 Act,
  • Madras General Salestax Act, 1959.
  • Section 9(3) of the Central Act
  • Section 13 of the Central Act
  • CENTRAL SALES TAX ACT 1956
  • Central Sales-lax Act 1956,
  • Central Salestax Act 1956,
  • sub-sec. (3) of Section 9
  • Section 9 and rule 17
  • Sec. 8(2). Section 9(1)
  • Section 19(2)(f)
  • Sub-rule (5)
  • Sub-rule (7)
Smart Summary

Court Opinion Summary (Veeraswami, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitions challenge action by the Deputy Commercial Tax Officer, Mettupalayam, who in September 1965 served notices proposing to bring to tax certain turnovers of inter-State sales for the years 1960-1961 to 1964-1965 on the ground that those sales were not made on the basis of "C" declaration forms. The petitioner is a dealer in arecanuts at Mettupalayam who admittedly made sales to dealers outside Madras during the relevant years but did not register under Section 7 of the Central Sales-tax Act 1956, did not collect sales-tax from purchasers, and did not make statutory returns; he maintained accounts and invoices. The Intelligence Wing of the Sales-tax department reported his transactions and notices assessing turnover at 7% under the Central Sales-tax Act were issued. The petitioner sought prohibition of the respondent from taking further action, arguing that Sub-rule (7) of rule 5 of the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules 1957 was ultra vires Section 13(3) and (4) of the Central Act and that Section 9(3) of the Central Act was unconstitutional. The court considered these contentions and ultimately dismissed the petitions with costs and counsel's fee fixed at Rs. 250.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Sub-rule (7) of rule 5 of the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules 1957 is intra vires the power conferred by Section 13 (in particular sub-sections (3) and (4)) of the Central Sales-tax Act 1956, or whether it is ultra vires and invalid.
  2. Whether sub-section (3) of Section 9 of the Central Sales-tax Act 1956 is constitutional and, if valid, whether it supplies the assessing authority with power to assess escaped turnover by reference to the powers under the applicable State sales-tax law.
  3. Whether, in the absence of a valid Sub-rule (7), the respondent nevertheless had jurisdiction to assess the petitioner's alleged escaped turnover by relying on Section 9(3) of the Central Act and the powers of State authorities under the local sales-tax law.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Sub-rule (7) of rule 5 of the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules 1957 is ultra vires Section 13(3) and (4) of the Central Sales-tax Act 1956 because the Central Act does not specifically confer power to the State to make rules assessing escaped turnover, prescribing a period of limitation for such assessment, or to determine turnover by 'best judgment'.
  • Section 9(3) of the Central Act is unconstitutional because it attracts and adopts the provisions of the local sales-tax law as they stand and as amended over time, amounting to an improper delegation or abdication of Parliament's legislative power.
  • Factual mitigation: the petitioner asserted lack of education and ignorance of the statutory obligations, had not collected tax or made returns, though maintained accounts and invoices.

Respondent's (Revenue's) Arguments

  • The State rule-making power in Section 13(3) suffices to sustain Sub-rule (7) of rule 5; alternatively, Section 9(3) of the Central Act provides the respondent with power and jurisdiction to assess escaped turnover by invoking powers under the State's general sales-tax law.
  • The Revenue relied on the majority view in State of Madras v. Lakshminarasimiah Selly and Sons (AIR 1965 SC 1510) concerning the scope and effect of Section 9(3) to support the contention that powers under the State Act are attracted to the Central Act for assessment purposes.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Messrs. Solar Works v. Employees' State Insurance Corporation, Madras, 1964-2 Mad LJ 223; AIR 1964 Mad 376 Where an Act does not itself provide for a limitation and the delegated rule-making power does not expressly or impliedly relate to the power to prescribe time, the delegated authority cannot make a rule prescribing limitation. The court relied on this decision to support the conclusion that limitation (and the power to determine turnover by best judgment) cannot be prescribed by a rule unless there is specific enabling power in the parent Act; this supported the finding that Sub-rule (7) was beyond the rule-making power and invalid.
Commissioner of Customs and Excise v. Cure and Deeley Ltd., 1961-3 All E.R. 641 Illustrates that a turnover determined by 'best judgment' may not correspond to the actual turnover; distinguishes between actual turnover and turnover as ascertained by judgment. The court cited this authority to explain the legal significance of a turnover determined by best judgment and to underline why specific rule-making authority is required to confer power to determine turnover by best judgment.
State of Madras v. Lakshminarasimiah Selly and Sons, 16 S.T.C. 231; AIR 1965 SC 1510 Majority view on the scope and effect of Section 9(3) of the Central Sales-tax Act and its interaction with corresponding provisions of a State Act (in that case the Mysore Sales-tax Act and Sections 8(2) and 9(1) and (3) of the Central Act). The Revenue relied on this Supreme Court decision to support the contention that Section 9(3) attracts State assessment powers to the Central Act. The court observed the decision was not directly dispositive of the exact issue before it but acknowledged its relevance to the scope of Section 9(3).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the issues in two stages: first the validity of Sub-rule (7) of rule 5 of the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules 1957, and second the constitutionality and effect of sub-section (3) of Section 9 of the Central Sales-tax Act 1956.

On Sub-rule (7):

  • The court identified that Sub-rule (7) creates three features: (1) power to assess escaped turnover, (2) a five-year limitation period for applying that power, and (3) a power to determine escaped turnover by 'best judgment'.
  • The Central Act (specifically Section 13(4)) did not specifically empower the State Government to make rules enabling assessment of escaped turnover, prescribing limitation or providing for determination by best judgment; in contrast, the earlier Madras General Sales-tax Act 1939 and subsequently the Madras General Sales-tax Act 1959 expressly contained provisions authorising such rule-making or set out the power themselves.
  • The court emphasized that although limitation may be procedural in character, it is also substantive; therefore limitation and substantive features of assessment cannot be supplied by a mere rule unless there is an express enabling provision in the parent statute.
  • The Solar Works decision was applied to hold that where the parent Act did not provide the limitation and the delegation did not cover the power to prescribe time, the rule-making authority could not validly prescribe such limitation.
  • Consequently, Sub-rule (7), insofar as it provided for limitation and the determination of escaped turnover by best judgment, exceeded the State's rule-making power and was struck down as invalid (the sub-rule "as a whole, should be struck down as invalid").

On Section 9(3) of the Central Act:

  • The court examined Section 9(3), which directs that authorities empowered under the general sales-tax law of the appropriate State shall, on behalf of the Government of India and subject to rules made under the Central Act, assess, collect and enforce payment of the Central tax "in the same manner as the tax ... under the General sales-tax law of the State is assessed, paid and collected", and may exercise the powers they have under the State law.
  • The court construed "in the same manner" to mean that State sales-tax authorities shall assess, collect and enforce Central tax in exactly the same way as under the local law and that while so acting they have the same powers as under the local law.
  • The court traced the relevant local law history: when the Central Act was enacted the Madras General Sales-tax Act 1939 was in force; that Act (and its rules) provided expressly for assessment of escaped turnover and limitation (five years). The Madras General Sales-tax Act 1959 (Section 16) substantially re-enacted those provisions.
  • The court then assessed the petitioner's constitutional challenge to Section 9(3) as amounting to an objection to the Parliament adopting local law provisions by reference. The court accepted the principle that Parliament cannot adopt by reference provisions that did not exist when the Central law was made, but found that here Section 16 of the Madras 1959 Act substantially re-enacted the provisions in force when the Central Act had been framed, and that the subject matter was one the Parliament had applied its mind to when enacting Section 9(3).
  • On that basis the court held Section 9(3) constitutional and capable of attracting the operative machinery and powers of the State sales-tax law for assessment of Central tax; as such the respondent could invoke the powers available under the appropriate State law to assess escaped turnover despite the invalidity of Sub-rule (7).

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Petitions dismissed.

More precisely, the court made these core rulings:

  • Sub-rule (7) of rule 5 of the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules 1957 is ultra vires and invalid insofar as it purports to prescribe a limitation period and to permit determination of escaped turnover by 'best judgment' without specific enabling power in the Central Act's rule-making provisions (Section 13).
  • Sub-section (3) of Section 9 of the Central Sales-tax Act 1956 is constitutional and valid; it attracts for the purposes of assessment and collection the powers of the State sales-tax authorities and their procedural machinery "in the same manner" as under the local law, and therefore the respondent retains jurisdiction to proceed by reference to State law powers to assess escaped turnover.

Implications and direct effects:

  • Direct effect on the parties: Although Sub-rule (7) was struck down, the respondent's power to assess the petitioner's alleged escaped turnover was upheld by virtue of Section 9(3) of the Central Act and the powers conferred on State authorities by the local sales-tax law; accordingly, the petitioner's request to prohibit further action was denied and the petitions were dismissed.
  • Costs: The petitions were dismissed with costs (one set) and counsel's fee was fixed at Rs. 250.
  • Precedential impact noted in the opinion: The court clarified the limits of rule-making delegated powers (limitations and substantive assessment powers cannot be supplied by rules absent express statutory authority) and confirmed that Section 9(3) may validly import the assessment machinery and powers of the State sales-tax law where those provisions are substantially what existed when the Central law was enacted; however the opinion does not purport to lay down a novel, broad doctrine beyond these applications to the facts before it.

End of summary based exclusively on the provided opinion.

    Haji J.A Kareem Sait v. The Deputy Commercial Tax Officer, Mettupalayam .

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Veeraswami, J.:— The validity of Sub-rule (7) of rule 5 of the Central Sales-lax (Madras) Rules 1957 and sub-sec. (3) of Section 9 of the Central Sales-tax Act 1956, is questioned in these petitions for prohibiting the respondent, the Deputy Commercial Tax Officer, Mettupalayam from taking further action against the petitioner under the Central Sales-lax Act 1956, in pursuance of his notices in September 1965, proposing to bring to tax certain turnovers of inter State sales for the years 1960-1961 to 1964-1965 on the ground that such sales were not made on the basis of “C” declaration forms of dealers of other States. The petitioner states that he has been carrying on business as dealer in arecanuts in Mettupalayam town. During these years, he admittedly effected sales of arecanuts to dealers outside the State of Madras. He did not register himself as a dealer as required by Section 7 of the Central Sales-tax Act 1956. According to him being uneducated he was not aware of the provisions of this Act and had failed to collect even one naya paisa as sales-tax from any one of the purchasers and to make returns of his transactions. He was however, as he has said, maintaining correct accounts as well as invoices and keeping records relating to each transaction effected by him. The Intelligence Wing of the Salestax department reported to the respondent about the petitioner's transactions during I he said years and action was taken by the respondent to assess the transactions by serving notices on the petitioner to show cause why he should not be assessed as proposed. The notices set oui the circumstances under which action was taken and the turnover for each year to be assessed at 7 per cent under the Central Sales-lax Act as the petitioner had not sold on C declaration forms of the dealers of other States.

    2. The contention for the petitioner is that the action taken by the respondent to assess his alleged escaped turnover is wholly without jurisdiction and that rule 5(7) of the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules 1957 is ultra vires Section 13(3) and (4) of the Central Salestax Act. Reliance being placed for the respondent on Section 9(3) of the Act. The sub-section, according to the petitioner's submission, is unconstitutional. We are of the view that the petitioner's first contention is well founded but not the second. Section 13 of the Central Act provides for power to make rules. Sub-sec. (1) authorises the Central Government to make rules providing for certain mailers specifically mentioned and the rules made by the Central Government are required by Sub-sec. (2) to be placed before both Houses of Parliament under Sub-sec. (3). The State Government is given the power to make rules to ram out the purposes of the Act but the rules so made should not be inconsistent with the provisions of the Act and the rules made under sub-sec. (1). The next Sub-section enumerates certain purposes in respect of which the State Government will have power to make rules and this power is given without prejudice to the powers conferred by sub-sec. (3). In purported exercise of the powers conferred by sub-sees. (3) and (4) of Section 13, the State Government made the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules 1957, of which rule 5 provides for submissions of returns and the procedure to assess them. Sub-rule (5) says that after the close of the year, the assessing authority shall, after such scrutiny of the accounts and after such enquiry as he considers necessary, satisfy himself that the return or returns filed are correct and complete and finally assess under a single order the tax of taxes payable under the Act for the preceding year or for the year to which the return submitted relates as the case may be. The sub-rule further provides that if the assessing authority finds that the returns are incorrect or incomplete, he shall assess the turnover to the best of his judgment after giving the dealer an opportunity to prove the correctness and completeness of his returns. Sub-rule (7) is as follows;

    “If, for any reason, the whole or any part of the turnover of business of a dealer has escaped assessment to tax in any year, the assessing authority may, at any time within five years next succeeding that to which the lax relates, determine as to the best of his judgment the turnover which has escaped assessment and assess the tax payable on such turnover after issuing a notice to the dealer and after making such enquires as he considers necessary.”

    3. This sub-rule, therefore, provides for (1) assessment of escaped turnover (2) period of limitation for applying the power to assess such turnover, namely, five years and (3) determination by best judgment of the escaped turnover. The provisions of the Central Act do not themselves provide for any of these mailers and certainly Section 13(4) does not specifically confer power on the State Government to make a rule like Sub-rule (7). The Madras General Sales-tax Act 1939 by Section 9 provided power for the assessing authority to assess the turnover on the basis of the ??? and where it does not accept the correctness or completeness of the return, to assess it to the best of his judgment and by Section 19(1) authorised the State Government to make rules to carry out the purposes of the Act, and by sub-sec. (2) certain matters were particularised without prejudice to general power to make rules for the purposes of the Act in respect of which the State Government could make rules. One of such mailers specifically mentioned is the assessment to tax under this Act of any turnover which has escaped assessment and the period within which such assessment may be made not exceeding five years' Section 13(4) of the Central Sales-tax Act does not contain any such specific enabling provision, though the Act was made when the Madras General Sales Tax Act 1939 was still in force which the Parliament should have been aware of. The Madras General Sales-lax Act 1959 has not left to the rule making authority the power to make rules relating to the assessment of escaped turnover but Section 16 of the Act itself provides for power to assess escaped turn over and prescribes also the procedure and period of limitation for the exercise of that power as well as the power to assesss such turnover by best judgment. In the absence of an enabling power provided for by Section 13(4) of the Central Act, Sub-rule (7) of rule 5 of the Central Sales-tax (Madras) Rules is unauthorised and is ultra vires the power of the State Government.

    4. Power to assess escaped turnover is an original power, whether it is applied to a case of failure to make returns or reopening of an order of assessment already made in order to bring to tax what has escaped assessment. In either case, the power is part of and included in the power to make assessments but it does follow ??? it that by reason of the existence of such a power, the State Government could provide for limitation for exercise of power to assess escaped turnovers by best judgment. No doubt limitation is procedural but it is also substantive. A rule covering those matters cannot, therefore, be made unless it be in exercise of specific conferment of enabling rule-making power. This Court in Messrs. Solar Works v. Employees' State Insurance Corporation, Madras, 1964-2 Mad LJ 223 : (AIR 1964 Mad 376) took the view that where an Act itself did not provide for limitation with reference to a particular matter and the delegation of power to make rules was conferred by a section of the Act which did not express or impliedly relate to the power to prescribe time, the authority to which the power was delegated, namely, the State in that case, would not make a rule prescribing limitation. We have already pointed out that the legislative practice at least so far as this State is concerned, appears to be that in the Salestax law, express and specific conferment of power is made to make a rule providing for assessment of escaped turnover, limitation for exercise of the power and the manner in which the assessment Should be made, including by best judgment. The charge under the Central Act as well as the State Acts is on the turnover which means the actual turnover. A turnover determined by best judgment is what the authority, which determined it, had taken to be the turnover which need not necessarily be the actual turnover. Vide Commr. of Customs and Excise v. Cure and Deeley Ltd. 1961-3 All E.R 641.

    5. A rule providing for determination of turnover by best judgment could only be valid if there is specific conferment of the enabling power upon the rule making authority. The Revenue, however, relies upon Section 13(3) of the Central Act to sustain Sub-rule (7) But Section 13(3) is in general terms and confers power to make rules only to carry out the purposes of the Act. Nowhere in the Central Act is there am indication that one of its purposes is to provide for limitation for the exercise of the power to assess escaped turnover ??? to determine such turnover by best judgment. We hold that by Sub-rule (7) at least in so far as it provided for limitation and determination of escaped turnover by best judgment is in excess of the rule making power and the sub-rule, as a whole, should be struck down as invalid.

    6. That does not however, conclude the matter in favour of the assessee. As we indicated, the Revenue relies on Section 9(3) of the Central Act and contends that even in the absence of Sub-rule (7), the respondent will have the power and jurisdiction to take action, as he has, against the petitioner. Support is sought to be derived for this contention from the majority view in State of Madras v. Lakshminarasimiah Selly and Sons 16 S.T.C 231 : (AIR 1965 SC 1510), on the scope and effect of Section 9(3). In that case the Supreme Court decided with reference to the provisions of the Mysore Sales-tax Act and Sections 8(2) and 9(1) and (3) of the Central Act. Though the sales, there, were of inter-State character, they were nevertheless not liable to tax under the Central Sales-lax Act, as they were not first sales within the Mysore State which alone were made liable to tax at a single point at that stage under the Mysore Act. This decision was reached on the majority of the view that whatever ambiguity existed in relation to the expression “in the same manner” in Sec. 8(2). Section 9(1) dispelled it and made it clear that Section 8(2) dealt with not only the calculation of the rates but also the manner of levy of the lax. The Supreme Court held that “levied” in Section 9(1) of the Central Act referred to the expression “levied” in Section 5(3)(a) of the Mysore Salestax Act. We do not, therefore, think that this decision is directly in point for the Revenue, because, the question we have to decide now is somewhat different, namely, whether sub-sec. (3) of Section 9 attracts to the working of the Central Act, the powers of assessing authorities under the State Act to assess escaped turnover.

    7. As we mentioned earlier, the Central Act itself does not contain provisions relating to the machinery and powers of assessment and collection of Central Salestax. But the scheme of the Central Act shows that instead it assimilates and attracts for its purpose, by reference to the relative provisions of the Salestax law in force under the State Acts as to machinery for and powers of assessment and collection of tax. We do not think it necessary to reproduce the circumstances in which Article 286 of the Constitution came to be amended and the Central Salestax Act 1956, was enacted the preamble to this Act sets out its purpose quite clearly and accordingly the Act contains definition of when a sale or purchase of goods shall be deemed to take place in the course of inter-State trade or commerce, prescribes the locale of such sale and declares its liability to the Central tax. The rate of lax is fixed by Section 8 which has in certain circumstances, ??? to the rate of tax obtaining under the State Acts. The next section provides for levy and collection of tax and penalties. Sub-sec. (1) says that the inter-State salestax shall be levied and collected by the Government of India in the manner provided in sub-sec. (3) in the State from which the movement of the goods commenced. Sub-sec. (1) has a proviso which we need not refer lo. Sub-sec. (2) deals with the collection of penalties imposed on a dealer under Section 10A Sub-sec. (3) reads:

    “The authorities for the time being empowered to assess, collect and enforce payment of any tax under the general sales tax law of the appropriate State shall, on behalf of the Government of India, and subject to any rules made under this Act, assess, collect and enforce payment of any tax including any penalty, payable by a dealer under this Act in the same manner as the tax on the sale or purchase of goods under the General sales-tax law of the State is assessed, paid and collected; and for this purpose they may exercise all or any of the powers they have under the general sales lax law of the State; and the provisions of such law including provisions relating to returns, appeals, reviews revisions., references, penalties and compounding of offences, shall apply accordingly;

    Provided that if in any State or part thereof there is no general salestax in force, the Central Government may, by rules made in this behalf, make necessary provision for all or any of the matters specified in this sub-section, and such rules may provide that a breach of any rule shall be punishable with fine which may extend to five hundred rupees: and where the offence is a continuing offence, with a daily fine which may extend to fifty rupees for every day during which the offence continues”.

    8. The last sub-section assigns the proceeds of any lax levied and collected under the Central Act in any State to that Stale, which shall retain the same. It is manifest from Section 9 that though the Central tax is levied and collected for and on behalf of the Government of India, it is appropriated eventually by the particular State entitled to it and the administration of the provisions of the Central Salestax Act is left to the authorities functioning under the State Acts While sub-sec. (1) of Section 9 directs that the Central Salestax shall be levied and collected in the manner provided in Sub-sec. (3). The latter makes available the authorities under the State Acts and their powers under those Acts to assess, collect and enforce payment of any local tax, to assessment, collection and enforcement of Central Salestax in other words, Sub-sec. (3) provides for two matters (1) the authorities empowered to assess, collect and enforce payment of local tax under the State law are authorised to assess, collect and enforce payment of the Central tax on behalf of the Government of India and subject to the rules made under the Act in the same manner as the lax on the sale of purchase of goods under the State law is assessed, paid and collected and (2) while acting under that authority, the authorities concerned will exercise all or any of the powers they have under the general salestax law of the State. The State Salestax authorities are thus charged with the duty to assess, collect and enforce payment of central salestax and in discharging this duty they have all the powers which they possess under the State Salestax law. The words “in the same manner” in sub-sec. (3) of Section 9 of the Central Act clearly show, In our opinion, the true scope and effect of that sub-section, to wit the State Tax Salestax authorities shall assess, collect and enforce payment of the Central tax in exactly the same way as under the local Salestax law and for that purpose the authorities will have same powers as they possess under such law to assess, collect and enforce local salestax.

    9. That being the effect of sub-sec. (3) of Section 9, one has to turn to the provisions of the appropriate local salestax law to see what powers the sales tax authorities possess thereafter. When the Central Sales-tax Act 1956 was enacted, there was in force in the State of Madras, the Madras General Sales-tax Act 1939. Section 9 of this Act prescribed the procedure for assessment of tax and conferred power to assess returns and compute tax and, where the returns are incorrect or incomplete, to assess turnover by best judgment. Section 19(2)(f) conferred on the State Government power to make rules for assessment of escaped turnover and the period during which such assessment should be made not exceeding five years. In exercise of this rule making power, the State Government made rules called the Madras General Sales-tax Rules 1939 of which rule 17 provided for the procedure to assess escaped turnover and prescribed the period in this regard, namely five years. The power and procedure in relation to assessment of escaped turnover including limitation provided by Section 9 and rule 17 are now substantially to be found in Section 16 of the Madras General Salestax Act, 1959, It follows, therefore, that sub-sec. (3) of Section 9 of the Central Act would enable the respondent to invoke those powers which he has under the local Salestax law in assessing turnover which has escaped assessment in any year.

    10. The contention for the petitioner is, that sub-sec. (3) is unconstitutional because it attracts for its purpose, for assessment, collection and enforcement of tax the provisions of the local Salestax for the time being in force and such legislation by reference amounts to abdication by the Parliament of its legislative powers. It is not disputed by the petitioner that where the Parliament intends to adopt, for purposes of Central legislation, any particular provisions of a State law, it can do so by reference to those provisions instead of reiterating them verbatim. That precisely is the case in relation to Sub-sec. (3) of S. 9. But the Madras General Salestax Act 1939 was repealed and was substituted by the Madras General Salestax Act, 1959. The argument for the petitioner is that the Parliament cannot with propriety make a law adopting by reference, the provisions of the State Law, as they stand amended by the local Legislature from time to time. The principle of the contention is certainly unexceptionable, for, while it is competent for the Parliament to adopt the existing provisions of a local law as part of the Central legislation without repeating those provisions in the Central Act, it cannot make a law adopting the provisions of a local law which did not exist at the time. Is this principle offended in this case? In answering this question, we are inclined to think that we should look at the substance and not the form of the matter. Section 16 of the Madras General Sales-tax Act 1959 substantially re-enacted, as we already mentioned, the provisions under the Madras General Sales-tax Act, 1939, relating to assessment of escaped turnover and the period of limitation for exercising that power. This is not, therefore, a case where the law, as re-enacted by the local Legislature, is substantially different from what it was when the Central legislature enacted by reference to it. The crux of the matter is that the subject matter of Section 16 of the Madras 1959 Act, is not something which the Parliament had not applied its mind to when it enacted Section 9(3). On that view, we are not persuaded to hold that sub-sec. (3) of Section 9 is unconstitutional. The petitions are dismissed with costs One set. Counsel's fee Rs. 250.

    KJ/AKJ/D.V.C

    11. Petitions dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Haji J.A Kareem Sait v. The Deputy Commercial Tax Officer, Mettupalayam .
    (Jun 24, 1966)