Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Thangavelu, was convicted under Section 500 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to pay a fine of Rs. 200. Out of that fine, if realised, Rs. 100 was ordered to be paid to the complainant (P.W.1, Ponnammal) as compensation under Section 545(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code. The defamatory material arose from a plaint (S.C. No. 349 of 1963) filed in the District Munsif Court, Tirukoilur, in which the petitioner described the complainant, Ponnammal, as the concubine of P.W.2, Namasivaya Odayar. The trial and appellate courts considered the matter; the courts below found that Ponnammal was an unmarried Brahmin woman of about thirty years and that the petitioner's statement was defamatory and unsupported by reasonable grounds of belief. The petitioner sought revision, raising several grounds including reliance on exceptions to Section 499 IPC and an argument that there was no publication of the alleged defamatory matter.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the statement in the plaint that P.W.1 (Ponnammal) was the concubine of P.W.2 amounted to defamation punishable under Section 500 IPC.
  2. Whether there was publication of the alleged defamatory matter (i.e., whether filing the plaint in court and serving a copy constituted publication).
  3. Whether the petitioner had reasonable grounds to believe the allegation true (as relevant to Exception 1 to Section 499 IPC).
  4. Whether the petitioner could successfully invoke Exception 9 to Section 499 IPC (good faith) and, relatedly, the burden of proof for such a plea under Section 105 of the Evidence Act.
  5. Whether there was any justification to interfere with the appellate court's reduction of the fine from Rs. 500 to Rs. 200 and with the sentence imposed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner argued that there was no publication of the defamatory allegation because a copy of the plaint (Ex. P.1) was sent only to P.W.1 (the complainant).
  • The petitioner relied on factual circumstances set out in ground No. 7 of the revision to show he had reason to believe the allegation (invoking Exception 1 to Section 499 IPC).
  • The petitioner also relied on Exception 9 to Section 499 IPC (good faith) and the factual circumstances referred to in the revision grounds to claim the benefit of that exception.

Respondent / Court Position (as represented in the opinion)

  • The courts below found P.W.1 to be an unmarried Brahmin woman and concluded that the statement in the plaint was defamatory and false.
  • The appellate court found that the petitioner had no reasonable grounds to believe that P.W.1 was the concubine of P.W.2, rejecting the reliance on Exception 1.
  • The trial and appellate courts treated the filing of the plaint (prepared and filed by P.W.3 on behalf of the petitioner and bearing the court seal) as constituting publication of the defamatory matter.
  • The courts held that the petitioner had failed to demonstrate good faith (Exception 9), and that the circumstances asserted did not reasonably support the petitioner's belief in the truth of the allegation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
G.G. Jeramiah v. F.S. Vas, ILR 36 Mad 457 Authority concerning proof of publication where a paper appears to be printed/published by a person — i.e., that appearance is not in itself proof of publication by that person. The court held the precedent was inapplicable on the facts: that decision concerned publication in a paper and proof that the accused was responsible for it. Here the defamatory matter was signed and filed by the petitioner in a plaint; the court found that filing the plaint constituted publication and that the petitioner was responsible.
Harbhajan Singh v. State of Punjab (Crl. App. 53 of 1961): AIR 1966 SC 97 Discussion in paragraph 21 of the considerations relevant to establishing good faith for the purposes of invoking an exception to defamation provisions (Exception 9 to Section 499 IPC). The court cited this authority to note that good faith is a question dependent on the facts and circumstances of each case. Applying that principle, the court found the facts did not establish good faith for the petitioner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by applying the elements of the offence and the relevant exceptions to the facts found by the courts below:

  1. Defamatory character: The court accepted the factual finding that the statement in the plaint describing P.W.1 as the concubine of P.W.2 was defamatory; P.W.1 was found to be an unmarried Brahmin woman and the assertion was false.
  2. Publication: The court rejected the petitioner's contention that there was no publication because only a copy of the plaint was sent to P.W.1. The opinion emphasised that the plaint was prepared and filed into court by P.W.3 on the petitioner's behalf and bore the court seal, and that filing the plaint in court constituted publication of its contents. Therefore publication was established despite the petitioner's argument.
  3. Reasonable belief (Exception 1 to S.499 IPC): The courts below and the appellate court considered the factual circumstances relied on by the petitioner (ground No.7) and found they did not amount to reasonable grounds for believing the imputations to be true. The appellate court explicitly held that the petitioner had no reasonable ground to hold the belief he asserted.
  4. Good faith (Exception 9 to S.499 IPC) and burden of proof: The petitioner also relied on Exception 9. The court noted that this plea was not urged in the courts below and that under Section 105 of the Evidence Act the burden of proving circumstances bringing the case within Exception 9 lies on the accused. The court cited Section 52 IPC to define "good faith" (acts done or believed without due care and attention are not in good faith) and relied on the Supreme Court authority in Harbhajan Singh to observe that the question of good faith is fact-specific. After reviewing the circumstances (which the appellate judge had already considered), the court concluded the facts did not demonstrate good faith — the allegation was unnecessary in a suit for recovery of money and showed lack of good faith.
  5. Sentence and revision: On these analyses, the court concluded the conviction under Section 500 IPC was fully justified. The opinion also criticised the appellate court's reduction of the fine from Rs. 500 to Rs. 200 as unjustified, but overall found no ground to interfere in the revision and dismissed the criminal revision petition.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The conviction of the petitioner under Section 500 IPC was upheld and the criminal revision petition was dismissed; the petition is dismissed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner's conviction and the sentence imposed (including the fine of Rs. 200 with Rs. 100, if realised, ordered to be paid to P.W.1 under Section 545(1) CrPC) stand; the criminal revision was dismissed.
  • On exceptions to defamation: The court reaffirmed that claims of reasonable belief and good faith under the exceptions to Section 499 IPC must be supported by facts and carry the onus on the accused (Section 105, Evidence Act). The court applied established definitions of good faith (Section 52 IPC) and treated the question of good faith as fact-specific in line with the cited Supreme Court authority.
  • Precedential impact: The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal principle beyond applying existing law to the facts; it does not indicate the setting of a new binding precedent.
CJ/VGW/D.V.C

    Thangavelu Chettiar v. Ponnammal .

    1. Petitioner Thangavelu has been convicted under S. 500 I.P.C and sentenced to a fine of Rs. 200 and out of the fine amount if realised Rs. 100 has been ordered to be paid to P.W 1 as compensation under Section 545(1) of the Cr PC

    2. The petitioner described the complainant Ponnammal as (concubine) of P.W 2, Namasivaya Odayar in a plaint filed by him in S.C No. 349 of 1963 on the file of the District Munsif Court, Tirukoilur. P.W 1 (Ponnammal), complainant in this case, is an unmarried Brahmin woman aged thirty years and the statement of the petitioner in his plaint that she is the concubine of P.W 2 is clearly defamatory. This is not disputed.

    3. The facts mentioned in ground No. 7 as reasonable grounds for the belief of the petitioner that P.W 1 (Ponnammal) was the concubine of P.W 2 Namasivaya Odayar were considered by the courts below which negatived the contention of the petitioner. They found that P.W 1 was an unmarried Brahmin girl and not a concubine of P.W 2 (Namasivaya Odayar). It appears from the judgment of the Courts below that the petitioner relied on Exception 1 to Sec. 499 I.P.C In fact, paragraph 12 of the appellate court's judgment snows that it was urged on behalf of the appellant (petitioner here) that it was sufficient if the accused had reason to believe that P.W 1 was the concubine of P.W 2. At the end of the paragraph, the appellate court has found that the appellant (petitioner here) had no reasonable reason to believe that P.W 1 was the concubine of P.W 2.

    4. The main ground urged by the learned advocate for the petitioner is that there was no publication as the copy of the plaint Ex. P. 1 was sent only to P.W 1, Ponnammal. I am unable to accept this contention. It was not argued in either of the courts below or mentioned in the grounds of revision that there was no publication in this case. The learned advocate for the petitioner relied upon paragraph 14 of the appellate court's judgment in support of his contention that the plea had been taken, but a reading of that paragraph would show that the plea taken was that the allegation would not amount to defamation. It is clear from paragraph 4 of the complaint filed in this case that the defamation complained of in this case was with regard to the allegation in the plaint in S.C 349 of 1963 on the file of the District Munsif Court, Tirukoilur, and in the same paragraph the complainant has referred to her having received a copy of the plaint Ex. P. 1. The filing of the plaint in the court has been spoken to by P.W 3, Sri P.R Subramaniam, who filed the plaint on behalf of the petitioner. Thus there can be no doubt that the defamation contained in the plaint was published by the I plaint being filed in the court. Further even assuming that the complainant referred to the allegation in Ex. P. 1, still there is publication. It is clear from a scrutiny of the copy of the plaint Ex. P. 1, that it was prepared by P.W 3, and filed into court, and it bears the seal of the District Munsif's Court, Tirukoilur. The copy of the plaint should be compared with the original by the court before it is served on the defendant by registered post. The learned advocate for the petitioner relied on the decision in G.G Jeramiah v. F.S Vas, ILR 36 Mad 457, in support of his contention that there should be publication and that the fact that a certain copy of a paper appears to be printed and published by A is not proof of publication by him. It is clear from what I have stated that the decision is hardly applicable to the facts of the present case. The decision refers to a publication in a paper and it should be proved that the accused was responsible for the publication. But in this case, the defamatory matter contained in the plaint was admittedly signed and filed by the petitioner. There can be no doubt that there was publication of the defamatory matter.

    5. The learned advocate for the petitioner relied on exception 9 to S. 499 I.P.C It is clear from the judgments of the courts below that this was not urged in the courts below. Under Section 105 of the Evidence Act, the burden of proving the circumstances to show that the case of the accused comes within exception 9 to S. 499 I.P.C is upon the petitioner and in the absence of such plea, it is open to a court to presume the absence of such circumstances. Good faith is defined in S. 52 of the Penal Code. Nothing, says S. 52 I.P.C, is said to be done or believed in good faith which is done or believed without due care and attention. In Harbhajan Singh v. State of Punjab, (Crl. App. 53 of 1961): (AIR 1966 SC 97) the Supreme Court in paragraph 21 of its judgment has dealt with the relevant considerations to support the plea of good faith to invoke the benefit of Exception 9. It is clear from the said judgment that the plea of good faith would be a question to be considered on the facts and circumstances of each case.

    6. It is true that if the facts and circumstances proved in this case support the plea if good faith and other requirements of Exception 9 to S. 499 I.P.C it is open to the accused to rely on the same and claim the benefit of the said Exception in spite of his not having pleaded it. The learned act vocate for the petitioner relied on the several circumstances mentioned in ground No. 7 of the grounds of revision. I have already referred to the fact that the appellate Judge has considered these facts and found that there was no reason for the petitioner to believe that P.W 1 was the concubine of P.W 2. There can be no doubt that the petitioner has unnecessarily made the defamatory allegation in a suit for recovery of money and it shows lack of good faith.

    7. The conviction of the petitioner under S. 500, I.P.C is fully Justified on the facts of this case and there is absolutely no ground to interfere in revision. I do not find any justification of the appellate court to have reduced the fine from Rs. 500 to Rs. 200. There is no ground also to interfere with the sentence of Hue. The criminal revision case is dismissed.

    CJ/VGW/D.V.C

    8. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Thangavelu Chettiar v. Ponnammal .
    (Nov 1, 1965)