Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sections 498-A and 304-B and section 113-B of the Evidence Act
  • provisions of sections 304-B and 498-A of IPC,
  • provisions of section 304-B of the IPC
  • provisions of section 154(1) of Cr. P.C,
  • provisions of section 304-B of IPC
  • section 304-B or 498-A, IPC.and
  • sections 498-A and 304-B, IPC.
  • provisions of section 157(1)
  • provisions of section 304-B
  • section 304-B of the IPC,
  • section 174 of Cr. P.C
  • section 304-B of IPC,
  • section 304-B
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sections 498-A and 304-B and section 113-B of the Evidence Act
  • provisions of sections 304-B and 498-A of IPC,
  • provisions of section 304-B of the IPC
  • provisions of section 154(1) of Cr. P.C,
  • provisions of section 304-B of IPC
  • section 304-B or 498-A, IPC.and
  • sections 498-A and 304-B, IPC.
  • provisions of section 157(1)
  • provisions of section 304-B
  • section 304-B of the IPC,
  • section 174 of Cr. P.C
  • section 304-B of IPC,
  • section 304-B
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (L.C. Bhadoo, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The accused/applicant Mohitram applied under section 439 Cr.P.C. for bail during trial. The prosecution case as stated in the opinion is that the deceased, Mati Bai, had married the accused about one year before the incident. On 12.2.2003, at about 11 a.m., Mati Bai and her 25-day-old son Manish died by consuming a poisonous substance. The accused gave a "merge intimation" to the Jarhagaon Police Station reporting the matter; the police performed a post-mortem and took viscera, which were later found to contain pesticides. Inquiry under section 174 Cr.P.C. was conducted and statements of the deceased's parents, sister-in-law and other witnesses were recorded; these statements alleged cruelty and repeated demand for Rs. 50,000/- by the accused. On 14.9.2003 Sub-Inspector, P.S. Mahila Thana registered a case under section 304-B of the IPC. The accused sought bail; the State opposed the application. The court heard counsel for both sides and delivered the order rejecting the bail application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the ingredients of section 304-B IPC are made out on the facts alleged (i.e., death otherwise than under normal circumstances within seven years of marriage, and proof of cruelty or harassment soon before death in connection with a demand for dowry).
  2. Whether section 304-B IPC applies where the deceased was a second wife or where the marriage's legality is disputed (i.e., whether a legally wedded wife is required for 304-B to apply).
  3. Whether the delay between the date of death (12.2.2003) and registration of the case (14.9.2003) is fatal to the prosecution or weakens the case such that bail should be granted.
  4. Whether, in view of the nature and seriousness of the offence, the accused is entitled to bail under section 439 Cr.P.C.

Arguments of the Parties

Accused / Applicant (Mohitram) — Arguments

  • The deceased was the accused's second wife and not a "legally wedded wife"; therefore, section 304-B IPC is not attracted.
  • There was a significant delay between the incident (12.2.2003) and registration of the case (14.9.2003). The parents of the deceased participated in the funeral and did not immediately report the matter, which, it was argued, undermines the allegation of harassment and cruelties leading to dowry death.

State / Panel Lawyer

  • The Panel Lawyer opposed the bail application.
  • No further detailed particulars of the State's arguments appear in the provided opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Reema Aggarwal v. Anupam, 2004 AIR SCW 344 The Apex Court held that for the limited purposes of sections 498-A and 304-B IPC (and related provisions such as section 113-B of the Evidence Act), a purposive construction should be adopted so that persons who enter into a marital relationship and cohabit as husband and wife are covered even if the marriage's legal validity is disputed. The Court stated that the term "woman" (and the legislative intent) should be interpreted to protect women who enter into marital relationships from harassment related to dowry demands, and that "husband" may be construed to include those who contract marriages ostensibly or cohabit and then subject the woman to cruelty. The court relied on this decision to reject the argument that section 304-B applies only to a "legally wedded wife." The court applied the Reema Aggarwal principle to hold that Mati Bai, though described as a second wife, was living as a wife of the accused and therefore covered by section 304-B IPC. The court also noted that a High Court judgment holding the contrary view had been overruled by the Apex Court in Reema Aggarwal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded step-by-step and tied the statutory ingredients of section 304-B IPC to the facts recorded in the investigation and the witnesses' statements:

  1. The court first set out the statutory ingredients of section 304-B IPC as required to attract the provision:
    • Death of a woman caused by burns or bodily injury or occurring otherwise than under normal circumstances;
    • Within seven years of her marriage;
    • It is shown that soon before her death she was subjected to cruelty or harassment by her husband or any relative of her husband;
    • Such cruelty or harassment was for, or in connection with, any demand for dowry.
  2. Applying these ingredients to the facts before it, the court observed that:
    • Mati Bai died within one and a half years of marriage and by consuming poison (therefore "otherwise than under normal circumstances");
    • Statements recorded during the inquiry (from the deceased's mother, father and sister-in-law) averred that the accused demanded Rs. 50,000/-, beat the deceased, threatened to bring his earlier wife and to throw her out of the house — facts that, on the face of it, indicate harassment/cruelty for dowry demands;
    • The father corroborated that the accused demanded money twice and that the accused physically assaulted the deceased;
    • Post-mortem/forensic material showed pesticides in the viscera, consistent with death by poisoning as reported.
    On this basis the court concluded that the ingredients of section 304-B appeared to be satisfied on the materials collected so far.
  3. Addressing the contention that the deceased was not a "legally wedded wife," the court examined the language of section 304-B and noted that the statute speaks of a "woman" and does not require the woman to be a legally wedded wife. The court relied on the Apex Court's decision in Reema Aggarwal to adopt a purposive construction: where a woman and a man live as husband and wife, the protective statute should apply for the limited purposes of sections 498-A and 304-B, even if the formal validity of the marriage is disputed. Therefore, the alleged second-wife status did not exclude application of section 304-B.
  4. Concerning the delay in registering the case, the court recounted that:
    • A "merge intimation" was given by the accused on the same day as the deaths and the police began enquiry under section 174 Cr.P.C.;
    • Viscera were seized and found to contain pesticides;
    • Statements recorded during the enquiry contained allegations of dowry demand.
    The court held that the delay between the incident and registering the case (about seven months) was not fatal. It noted statutory provisions (section 154(1) and section 157(1) Cr.P.C.) showing the police's duty and power to investigate on information received or on suspicion, even if not first reported by close relatives, and observed that parents being poor and shocked might explain their failure to immediately report. The court declined to draw a conclusion adverse to the prosecution based solely on the delay, since the matter was under investigation and the police had taken steps from the outset.
  5. Finally, the court balanced the nature of the allegations (serious offence under section 304-B) against the accused's application for bail under section 439 Cr.P.C., and reasoned that because of the gravity of the charge and the materials on record, the accused was not entitled to bail at this stage.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The application for bail is rejected.

Implications:

  • The accused (Mohitram) is not granted bail during trial and remains subject to continued investigation and prosecution for an offence registered under section 304-B IPC.
  • The court applied existing Supreme Court authority (Reema Aggarwal v. Anupam) to hold that section 304-B may be invoked where a woman and a man live as husband and wife, even if the formal legality of the marriage is disputed; thus the opinion follows and applies existing precedent rather than announcing a new legal principle.
  • No broader new precedent was created by this order; the decision applies established legal tests and cited authority to refuse bail in light of the seriousness of the allegations and the evidence recorded during inquiry.

Disposition

Application rejected.

    Mohitram v. State Of Chhattisgarh

    L.C Bhadoo, J.:— The accused/applicant namely Mohitram has preferred this application under section 439 of the Cr. P.C for releasing him on bail during trial.

    2. The prosecution case, in brief, necessary for the disposal of this application is that deceased Mati Bai was married to the accused/applicant one year before the incident. On 12.2.2003 at about 11 a.m Mati Bai committed suicide along with her 25 days son Manish by consuming poisonous substance. The accused/applicant gave merg intimation to the Police Station Jarhagaon that today in the morning at about 7 a.m he went to his agriculture field. His mother and father also went to the agriculture field. Only Mati Bai and his 25 days old son were at the residence. At about 11 a.m his nephew Phulesh came to the field and informed him that his wife was not well and froth was coming out from her mouth. On hearing this he immediately rushed to the village where he found his wife dead and lying on the cot. On receiving this report Police registered the merg intimation and started enquiry under section 174 of the Cr. P.C The statements of the witnesses namely, father of deceased Chamruram, mother Mantora Bai, sister-in-law Kamlabai and other witnesses were recorded by the police during the enquiry. The above witnesses in their case diary statements have stated that after the marriage of Mati Bai with the accused/applicant when she came to her parents house, she disclosed to her sister-in-law Kamlabai that her husband has illicit relations with the sister-in-law and he was regularly demanding Rs. 50,000/- and he used to say that her parents are beggars they had not given anything in the dowry. If she would not bring Rs. 50,000/- then she would not be allowed to reside with him and he would bring his earlier wife and for bringing Rs. 50,000/- her husband used to beat her. The father of the deceased has also corroborated the above statement of Kamalabai and even he has stated that the applicant demanded that money twice from him also and he replied that he was a poor man, therefore, he was not in a position to pay that much of amount. Ultimately she committed suicide by consuming poison. Ultimately on 14.9.2003 Sub-Inspector, P.S Mahila Thana registered the case against the accused/applicant under section 304-B of the I.P.C

    3. I have heard Shri R.R Sinha, learned Counsel for the applicant and Shri Praveen Das, Panel Lawyer for the State.

    4. Learned Counsel for the accused/applicant argued that deceased Mati Bai was the second wife of the accused/applicant and she was not legally wedded wife, therefore, offence under section 304-B of the IPC is not made out. He further argued that the incident took place on 12.2.2003 The parents of the deceased participated in the funeral ceremony but they had not reported the matter and the case was registered only after seven months from the date of the incident which itself shows that the harassment and subjecting the deceased to cruelty is even not prima-facie made out.

    5. On the other hand, learned Panel Lawyer opposed the bail application.

    6. As far as first question raised by the learned Counsel for the applicant is concerned, section 304-B of the IPC envisages that “where the death of a woman is caused by any burns or bodily injury or occurs otherwise than under normal circumstances within seven years of her marriage and it is shown that soon before her death she was subjected to cruelty or harassment by her husband or any relative of her husband for, or in connection with, any demand for dowry, such death shall be called “dowry death”, and such husband or relative shall be deemed to have caused her death”. Therefore, in order to bring the particular act in the mischief of section 304-B of the IPC the requirement is:

    (i) the death of a woman is caused by burns or bodily injury or occurs otherwise than under normal circumstances;

    (ii) within seven years of her marriage;

    (iii) it is shown that soon before her death she was subjected to cruelty or harassment by her husband or any relative of her husband; and

    (iv) that too in connection with any demand for dowry.

    7. As far as first Part is concerned, the death of Mati Bai occurred within one and half year of her marriage and that too by consuming poison i.e, otherwise than under normal circumstances. As far as the question of subjecting her to cruelty or harassment in connection with the demand of dowry is concerned, the mother, father and sister-in-law of the deceased have categorically stated that the accused/applicant used to torture and harass the deceased for demand of Rs. 50,000/- and he used to say that nothing has been given in the dowry at the time of the marriage and the parents of the deceased are beggars. Even the father of the deceased has said that the accused demanded Rs. 50,000/- twice from him. The applicant even used to beat her, he used to say that he would throw her out of the house and he would bring his first wife. Therefore, the ingredients of the offence under section 304-B are satisfied with the above facts of the case.

    8. Now, coming to the question that Mati Bai was not legally wedded wife, as per the prosecution case, she was the second wife. If we look into the language of the section nowhere it has been mentioned that a woman should be legally wedded wife. The word even ‘wife’ has not been used. The word which has been used by the legislature is a “woman”. Moreover, it is admitted position that Mati Bai was married to the accused/applicant and out of the wedlock she delivered a male child who was of 25 days on the date of the incident. Therefore, it is established that deceased Mati Bai and the accused/applicant used to live as husband and wife and they were leading their lives as husband and wife. Even the mother, father and the sister-in-law of the deceased have categorically stated that Mati Bai was married to the accused/applicant. Therefore, in my opinion, the case is squarely covered under the provisions of section 304-B of the I.P.C In this connection recent judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the matter of Reema Aggarwal v. Anupam . 2004 AIR SCW 344, similar points were raised before the Hon'ble Apex Court and in this case also Reema Aggarwal was the second wife of Anupam. The Hon'ble Apex Court held that:

    “The concept of “dowry” is intermittently linked with a marriage and the provisions of the Dowry Act apply in relation to marriage. If the legality of the marriage itself is an issue further legalistic problems do arise. If the validity of the marriage itself is under legal scrutiny, the demand of dowry in respect of an invalid marriage would be legally not recognizable. Even then the purpose for which sections 498-A and 304-B and section 113-B of the Evidence Act were introduced cannot be lost sight of. Legislation enacted with some policy to curb and alleviate some public evil rampant in society and effectuate a definite public purpose or benefit positively requires to be interpreted with certain element of realism too and not merely pedantically or hyper technically. The obvious objective was to prevent harassment to a woman who enters into a marital relationship with a person and later on becomes a victim of the greed for money. Can a person who enters into a marital arrangement be allowed to take a shelter behind a smoke screen to contend that since there was no valid marriage the question of dowry does not arise? Such legalistic niceties would destroy the purpose of the provisions. Such hairsplitting legalistic approach would encourage harassment to a woman over demand of money. The nomenclature “dowry” does not have any magic charm written over it. It is just a label given to demand of money in relation to marital relationship. The legislative intent is clear from the fact that it is not only the husband but also his relations who are covered by section 498-A. it would be appropriate to construe the expression “husband” to cover a person who enters into marital relationship and under the colour of such proclaimed or feigned status of husband subjects the woman concerned to cruelty or coerce her in any manner or for any of the purposes enumerated in the relevant provisions—Sections 304-B/498-A, whatever be the legitimacy of the marriage itself for the limited purpose of sections 498-A and 304-B, IPC. Such an interpretation, known and recognized as purposive construction has to come into play in a case of this nature. The absence of a definition of “husband” to specifically include such persons who contract marriages ostensibly and cohabitate with such woman, in the purported exercise of his role and status as “husband” is not ground to exclude them from the purview of section 304-B or 498-A, IPC.”

    and the judgment of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh has been overruled in which it was held that the provisions of section 304-B of the IPC are attracted in the case of legally wedded wife.

    9. Therefore, in view of the above judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court, the intention of the Legislature behind inserting the provisions of section 304-B of IPC was that the husband and his relations who are responsible for the dowry death of a woman should be brought into the mischief of dowry death whether the marriage in question was valid or not. In order to attract the provisions of sections 304-B and 498-A of IPC, it is sufficient to show that the victim woman and the accused husband were residing as husband and wife at the relevant point of time. Therefore, I do not find any substance in the arguments of the learned Counsel for the accused/applicant.

    10. Now, coming to the second argument that the death took place on 12.2.2003 and the case was registered on 14.9.2003 The merge intimation was given to the police on the same day and after postmortem examination viscera were taken and the same were found to contain pesticides and during the enquiry under section 174 of Cr. P.C the parents and relatives of the deceased gave statements about the demand of dowry by the accused, thereafter the case was registered under section 304-B of IPC, therefore, the delay in registration of the case is not fatal in this case. It is not the case that the parents of the deceased have falsely implicated the accused. They are very poor persons and even if they participated in the last rites and if they have not reported the matter that does not absolve the accused/applicant from the heinous crime. If a cognizable offence is committed and that is brought to the notice of the police by anyone as per the provisions of section 154(1) of Cr. P.C, the police is bound to register the case and investigate the same.

    11. As per the provisions of section 157(1) of the Cr. P.C “if, from information received or otherwise, an officer in charge of a police station has “reason to suspect the commission” of an offence which he is empowered under section 156 to investigate, he shall forthwith send a report of the same to a Magistrate empowered to take cognizance of such offence upon a police report and shall proceed in person, or shall depute one of his subordinate officers not being below such rank as the State Government may, by general or special order, prescribe in this behalf, to proceed, to the spot, to investigate the facts and circumstances of the case, and, if necessary, to take measures for the discovery and arrest of the offender”. Therefore, under this provision on receiving the information if the police suspect the commission of a cognizable offence, the S.H.O can take up investigation, even if it is not reported by the parents of the deceased as in the present case the merge intimation was already given by the accused/applicant, the police is not debarred from investigating into the matter. If the matter is not reported by the close relatives of the deceased and after investigation and collection of the evidence if police reaches to the conclusion that a particular offence has been committed by any person then police certainly can take up the matter, register the case and file the charge sheet.

    12. Therefore, merely by not reporting the matter by the parents of the deceased does not make the case weak at all if it is otherwise genuine and established. Moreover, at this stage, neither it is required nor necessary to give any opinion or finding on this aspect of the matter because the matter is under investigation. Police has to collect evidence and material and to ultimately reach to the final conclusion after completion of the evidence. There is a Hon'ble Apex Court's judgment that at the time of death of a woman the parents are under shock and grief, therefore if they had not reported the matter to the Police on an urgent basis that can not make the case doubtful or weak. Moreover, in the present case, the husband already reported the matter to the police and police registered the merge intimation on the same day and started the enquiry. When police already started the enquiry that might have given the impression to the parents that when the police is already enquiring into the matter they are not required to report, as has come on record that they are very poor persons.

    13. Therefore, in view of the above, the accused/applicant is involved in a very serious offence punishable under section 304-B of the IPC, I am of the opinion that looking to the seriousness of the crime the accused/applicant is not entitled for the benefits of section 439 of the Cr. P.C for releasing him on bail during trial. Accordingly, the application is rejected.

    14. Application Rejected.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohitram v. State Of Chhattisgarh
    (Feb 17, 2004)