AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (Act of 1966 for short).
  • provisions of Act of 1966 and the Land Acquisition Act, 1984.
  • MRTP Act, 1966 or the Land Acquisition Act
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (Act of 1966 for short).
  • provisions of Act of 1966 and the Land Acquisition Act, 1984.
  • MRTP Act, 1966 or the Land Acquisition Act
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners sought a direction to the respondents to release land bearing Gat No. 370, Hissa No. 1, situated at taluka Pen, district Raigad, from Reservation No. 7 (Garden) in the final development plan. The land is within the limits of the Pen Municipal Council and measures 0-42-07 + 0-04-0 R. The development plan came into force on 3 March 1989 and reserved the land for a garden (Reservation No. 7).

The petitioners state that they served a notice dated 2 February 2009 under section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 ("Act of 1966") (said notice was received by respondent No. 3) and later a further notice to respondent No. 1 dated 11 March 2010 requesting issuance of notification under section 127(2). The petitioners alleged that respondents did not take steps to purchase the land in response to the notices and therefore the reservation should be deemed to have lapsed.

The municipal council/respondents placed on record earlier correspondence and internal resolutions indicating attempts or proposals to purchase the land by paying market compensation and a later resolution (23 January 2008) to acquire the land through the Collector. The Collector's office communicated that the proposal submitted was incomplete. The petitioners filed the present writ petition; the court heard submissions and disposed of the petition by dismissing it and discharging the rule.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the notice(s) served by the petitioners qualify as a valid notice under section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966.
  2. If a valid notice under section 127 is served, whether failure by the planning/appropriate authority to take steps within the prescribed time results in lapse of the reservation and release of the land from the reservation.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners contend they are the owners of the subject land reserved as Garden (Reservation No. 7) in the 1989 development plan and that they served a notice under section 127 (dated 2 February 2009) which was received by respondent No. 3.
  • They submitted that, in view of settled law, if after receipt of a notice under section 127 the State/authority fails to take proper action within the statutory time, the reservation stands lapsed and the land is released from the reservation.
  • The petitioners argued that a technical approach should not be taken that would frustrate the object of their claim and that the respondents ought to have acted on the notice.

Respondent No. 3 (Municipal Council) Arguments

  • Respondent No. 3 contended that a proper and valid notice under section 127 is an essential precondition to claim lapsing of reservation; the notice in the present case did not conform to the basic requirements of section 127 and therefore could not be the basis for claiming lapse.
  • The municipal council relied on earlier communications and meetings showing negotiations between the council and the landowners, including the petitioners' earlier correspondence indicating willingness to accept market-rate compensation and subsequent refusal to transfer the land; a valuation was determined (Rs. 34,69,695) and requests were made to the Collector for acquisition, with the Collector indicating the proposal was incomplete.
  • Respondent No. 3 relied on the affidavit of its Chief Officer and other records to show that the matter was not one where a mechanically effective section 127 notice had been ignored, but that there had been communications and steps inconsistent with an immediate claim that the reservation had lapsed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gimar Traders v. State of Maharashtra, (2007) 7 SCC 555 The opinion quotes para 56: section 127's underlying principle is that land should be utilized for its reserved purpose within a given time or the owner should be permitted to utilize it; steps under section 127 must be steps "towards acquisition" (not mere applications which may or may not culminate). The court relied on the quoted principle to emphasize that mere applications or tentative steps that may or may not result in acquisition cannot be treated as steps under section 127 that prevent lapse of reservation.
Beohar Rajendra Sinha v. State of M.P., (1969) 1 SCC 796 (reported also as 1970 Mh.L.J (S.C) 195) Not specified in the provided opinion; listed among judgments relied upon by the petitioners. The opinion records that the petitioners relied upon this judgment; the text does not detail how the court applied it.
Mohinder Gupta v. Frontier Construction Company, (2010) 15 SCC 551 Not specified in the provided opinion; listed among judgments relied upon by the petitioners. The opinion records that the petitioners relied upon this judgment; the text does not detail further application by the court.
Nagpur Cable Operators Association v. Commissioner of Police Nagpur, 1995 (2) Mh.L.J 753 Not specified in the provided opinion; listed among judgments relied upon by the petitioners. The opinion records that the petitioners relied upon this judgment; the court did not elaborate its application in the text.
C.V. Shah and A.V. Bhat v. State of Maharashtra, 2006 (3) Bom.C.R 216 The Division Bench observed (para 17) that the notice under section 127 need not set out all facts; the form is not prescribed; sufficient compliance requires the notice to describe the land with sufficient clarity and require the relevant authority to acquire the land. The court treated this decision as squarely covering the issue: it applied the C.V. Shah/A.V. Bhat test to conclude the petitioners' notice did not meet the requirements of section 127 and therefore the petition lacked merit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first stated the settled legal position regarding section 127 of the Act of 1966: (a) the notice contemplated by section 127 is to be given by the owner or person having interest in land reserved/allotted/designated in the final development plan when the land has not been acquired by agreement or acquisition proceedings within 10 years of the plan coming into force; (b) the object of the notice is to inform the appropriate authority to acquire the land; (c) the form of the notice is not prescribed but it must describe the land with sufficient clarity and clearly require acquisition or compulsory purchase; and (d) if such a proper notice is served and no steps are taken within six months from service, the reservation is deemed to have lapsed and the land is deemed released from the reservation.

Applying those principles, the court examined the petitioners' notice dated 2 February 2009. The notice stated the land was reserved under Reservation No. 7 with effect from 3 March 1989, asserted that no steps had been taken under the provisions of the Act of 1966 and the Land Acquisition Act within ten years, and requested cancellation of the reservation. The court held that, on its face, this notice did not amount to the notice contemplated by section 127 because it lacked requisite details and did not meet the sufficiency requirements explained in C.V. Shah and A.V. Bhat.

The court further considered documentary records placed by respondent No. 3, which showed prior communications between the landowners and the municipal council regarding private negotiations, an offer/valuation and a request to hand over possession in return for market-rate compensation, and later municipal resolutions and communications to the Deputy Director of Town Planning and to the Collector seeking acquisition. The Collector's office had communicated that the proposal was incomplete. The court observed that these documents revealed the parties' conduct and that the petitioners had engaged in correspondence and negotiations inconsistent with a straightforward, proper section 127 notice being ignored.

On the combined assessment of the legal requirements for a section 127 notice and the factual record, the court concluded that the notice in the present case did not meet the statutory requirements and therefore could not support the claim that the reservation had lapsed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Petition dismissed. The writ petition was dismissed and the rule stood discharged.

Implications: The direct effect is that the petitioners' request for a direction to release the subject land from Reservation No. 7 was denied. The court held that the petitioners' notice did not satisfy the statutory requirements of section 127 and therefore could not be treated as effecting lapse of the reservation. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal principle beyond applying existing precedent (notably Gimar Traders and C.V. Shah & A.V. Bhat) to the facts of this case; consequently, no new precedent is declared in this decision.

Rule discharged. Petition dismissed.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ramchandra Shankar Joshi And Others v. State Of Maharashtra And Others

    Naresh H. Patil, J.:— The petitioners seek direction to the respondents to forthwith release the land bearing Gat No., 370, Hissa No. 1 situated at taluka-Pen, district-Raigad from reservation No. 7 (Garden).

    2. It is the contention of the petitioners that they are owners of the land situated within the limits of the Pea Municipal Council. The said land admeasures 0-42-07 + 0-04-0 R. In the development plan, which came into force on 3rd March, 1989, the said land was reserved by the municipal council for the purpose of garden as reservation No. 7. The petitioners contend that on 2nd February, 2009, a notice was issued under section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (“Act of 1966” for short). It is stated that the said notice was received by respondent No. 3. In spite of receipt of notice, no steps were taken by respondent No. 2. The petitioners claimed to have issued another notice to respondent No. 1 on 11th March, 2010 and requested for issuance of notification under section 127(2) of the Act of 1966. The petitioners state that the respondents did not take any action for purchasing the petitioners' land in terms of notice issued under section 127 of the Act of 1966.

    3. The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that in view of settled position of law, after receipt of notice under section 127 of the Act of 1966 if the State fails to take proper action then the subject reservation would stand lapsed. The learned counsel submits that in the affidavit-in-reply filed by respondent No. 3-Council a stand is taken that the said notice is not in compliance with the provisions of section 127 of the said Act. Learned counsel submits that a technical view need not be taken which would frustrate the cause of the petitioner.

    4. Learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 3 submits that for claiming relief of lapsing of reservation, a proper and valid notice issued under section 127 is essential requirement of law. In the present case, the said notice does not conform to the basic requirements. Hence such a notice cannot be a basis for claiming relief of lapsing of reservation. Learned counsel further submits that in the development plan of 1989 the petitioners' land was reserved for garden. In a meeting, dated 4th January, 1997, it was resolved to develop the said plot by entering into agreement with the owner of the said land. The petitioners by their application dated 10th May, 2000 informed respondent No. 3 that they are willing to accept the compensation at the market rate and hand over the possession of the said land or they be provided alternate plot within the municipal council area. It is submitted that vide letter dated 21st July, 2000, respondent No. 3 requested the petitioners to hand over possession of the said land as the petitioners had agreed to accept the compensation at the market rate. The total amount towards valuation was determined at Rs. 34,69,695/-. The municipal council requested the petitioners to transfer the said land at the market rate. However, the petitioners refused to transfer the said land. In a general body meeting held on 23rd January, 2008 it was resolved to acquire the said land through the Collector, Raigad. Accordingly, intimation was given to Deputy Director, Town Planning, Kokan Division by a letter dated 24th January, 2001. By letter dated 16th July, 2008 a request was also made to the Collector, Raigad for acquiring the said land. By communication dated 11th August, 2008, the office of the Collector informed respondent No. 3 that the proposal submitted was incomplete and further informed to submit the proposal after complying with various compliances referred to in the said letter. Learned counsel relied upon the affidavit sworn by the Chief Officer of respondent No. 3-Council on 24th August, 2011.

    5. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners has relied upon judgments of Supreme Court in the cases of Gimar Traders v. State of Maharashtra, (2007) 7 SCC 555; Beohar Rajendra Sinha v. State of M.P, 1970 Mh.L.J (S.C) 195 : (1969) 1 SCC 796; Mohinder Gupta v. Frontier Construction Company, (2010) 15 SCC 551 and judgment of this Court in the case of Nagpur Cable Operators Association v. Commissioner of Police Nagpur, 1995 (2) Mh.L.J 753.

    The Apex Court in the case of Gimar Traders (supra) has observed as under:

    “56. The underlying principle envisaged in section 127 of the mrtp act is either to utilize the land for the purpose it is reserved in the plan in a given time or let the owner utilize the land for the purpose it is permissible under the town planning scheme. The step taken under the section within the time stipulated should be towards acquisition of land. It is a step of acquisition of land and not step for acquisition of land. It is trite that failure of authorities to take steps which result in actual commencement of acquisition of land cannot be permitted to defeat the purpose and object of the scheme of acquisition under the MRTP Act by merely moving an application requesting the Government to acquire the land, which Government may or may not accept. Any step which may or may not culminate in the step for acquisition cannot be said to be a step towards acquisition.”

    6. The learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 3 placed reliance on the judgment of this Court in the case of C.V Shah and A.V Bhat v. State of Maharashtra, 2006 (3) Bom.C.R 216, wherein the Division Bench of this Court has observed in para 17 as under:

    “17. The notice contemplated in section 127 is a notice requiring the Planning Authority or the Development Authority or the Appropriate Authority, as the case may be, to acquire the land which is reserved, allotted or designated for public purpose in the final development plan. The notice is given by the owner or the person having interest in the land that is reserved, allotted or designated for the particular purpose in the development plan because such land has not been acquired by consent or no proceedings for acquisition have commenced under the MRTP Act, 1966 or the Land Acquisition Act within 10 years of the coming into force of final development plan or final regional plan. The very fact that notice is given for acquisition or in other words for compulsory purchase by the owner or the person interested in such land would lead to show that the land is reserved, allotted or designated in the final development plan/final regional plan and that in respect of which no acquisition has taken place by agreement within 10 years from the date of coming into force of the final development plan or final regional plan or in respect of which the acquisition proceedings have not commenced either under the MRTP Act or under the Land Acquisition Act. The expression “serve notice………to that effect” cannot be construed to mean that in the notice it is mandatorily required to be stated that the subject land is reserved/designated/allotted in the development plan and that the land has not been acquired within 10 years from the date on which the final regional plan or final development plan came into force or that no proceedings in relation to that land for acquisition has commenced either under the MRTP Act or under the Land Acquisition Act within 10 years. The object of the notice under section 127 is to inform the Authority mentioned therein to acquire the land which is designated, reserved or allotted in the final development plan. The notice need not set out all the facts and details of the reservation/designation or that the said land has not been acquired within 10 years of the coming into force of the final development plan. The word ‘Notice’ denotes an intimation to the party concerned of a particular fact. Notice may take several forms. Form of notice under section 127 is not prescribed. In our view, therefore, the notice under section 127 shall meet the sufficient compliance if notice describes the land in sufficient clarity and requires the Planning Authority or the Development Authority or the appropriate authority, as the case may be to acquire or compulsorily purchase the land so reserved, allotted or designated in the development plan.”

    7. It is a settled position of law that notice contemplated under section 127 of the Act of 1966 is to be given by the owner or the person having interest in the land which is reserved, allotted or designated for the particular purpose in the development plan. The object of the notice under section 127 is to inform the Authority mentioned therein to acquire the land which is designated, reserved or allotted in the final development plan. It is further settled position in law that form of notice under section 127 is not prescribed. Therefore such notice shall meet sufficient requirement in describing the land in clear terms and require the planning authority or development authority or the appropriate authority, as the case may be, to acquire or compulsorily purchase the land so reserved, allotted or designated in the development plan. In case such a notice in a proper form is served on the concerned authority and no steps are taken within six months from the date of service of such notice, the reservation/allotment/designation shall be deemed to have lapsed and the land shall be deemed to have been released from the said reservation.

    8. Therefore, the precondition for the land owner or the person interested to claim benefit under the provisions of section 127 of the Act, 1966 would be to give proper notice describing the land in sufficient clarity and intimating the concerned authority in clear terms.

    9. In the present case, we have perused the contents of the notice. It states that the subject land which is described in the notice was reserved under reservation No. 7 in the development plan with effect from 3rd March, 1989. In the next paragraph, it is mentioned that for a period of 10 years no steps have been taken in accordance with the provisions of Act of 1966 and the Land Acquisition Act, 1984. The petitioners further stated in the said notice that in these circumstances, the reservation concerning the subject land gets lapsed. In the last paragraph, it is stated that necessary steps be taken for cancellation of reservation and note be taken accordingly. The said notice is dated 2nd February, 2009. Reading of this notice makes it very clear that it cannot be termed as notice contemplated under section 127 of the Act of 1966. On the other hand, the record placed before us by respondent No. 3 shows that certain communications were exchanged between the land owners and the appropriate authority for purchasing the said land by paying compensation at market rate. One of such communication is dated 10th June, 2000 addressed by the petitioners to the Chief Officer of respondent No. 3 and another dated 21st July, 2000 addressed by the Chief Officer to the petitioners. By communication dated 1st March, 2005, the petitioners informed the Chief Officer that the subject land is owned by them and is a tenanted property which is to be acquired by the municipal council by private negotiations. On 23rd January, 2008, the municipal council adopted resolution in respect of the subject land wherein it was decided that as Special Economic Zone was to be created in Pen taluka there was lot of demand to the properties which are situated in the municipal area. Therefore the land owners i.e the petitioners herein were not inclined to hand over the land to the municipal council by private negotiations. This correspondence further shows intention of the parties in respect of the subject land. Shri A.G Girkar, the Assistant Director of Town Planning, Alibaug has filed affidavit-in-reply on behalf of respondent No. 1 and requested that the writ petition be dismissed.

    10. In the facts, we are of the view that the subject notice does not meet the requirements of the provisions of section 127 of the Act of 1966. It suffers from want of requisite details. The issue raised herein is squarely covered by the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in the case of C.V Shah and A.V Bhat (supra). There is no merit in the petition.

    11. Petition is dismissed. Rule stands discharged.

    Petition dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramchandra Shankar Joshi And Others v. State Of Maharashtra And Others
    (Aug 24, 2015)