Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2012 BHC 3233
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2012 BHC 3233
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This suit was filed by the plaintiff for recovery of Rs. 1,60,40,822/- based on an Agreement for Sale of TDR dated 18 August 2006, an Affidavit cum Declaration and Undertaking dated 18 August 2006, and certain post-dated cheques that were dishonoured. Earlier, by an agreement dated 3 August 2006 between Shiv-Shahi Punarvasan Prakalp Limited and the defendant, 3,000 sq. metres of TDR were to be sold for Rs. 7,55,63,280/-. The defendant paid Rs. 42,30,300/- to the transferor and then entered into the 18 August 2006 agreement with the plaintiff, under which the plaintiff agreed to pay the balance consideration to the transferor and the defendant agreed to pay the plaintiff Rs. 1,19,15,700/- within 30 days.

The defendant issued three post-dated cheques for Rs. 70,00,000/-, Rs. 34,00,000/- and Rs. 9,00,000/-; only the Rs. 9,00,000/- cheque was ever honoured, and the others were dishonoured when presented. The defendant sent a letter on 21 March 2007 claiming an oral booking of a flat in an alleged project of the plaintiff and asked for return of the cheques; the plaintiff denied this by letter dated 26 March 2007. The plaintiff issued statutory notices under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and ultimately issued a demand notice on 7 September 2009 for Rs. 1,60,40,822/- with interest at 18% p.a.; there was no response to that notice, and the present suit was filed. Summons for Judgment No. 516 of 2009 was taken out; the defendant was served but was absent. The court heard the plaintiff's counsel and perused the defendant's affidavit in reply.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit is barred by limitation (i.e., whether it was filed after the expiry of the applicable limitation period).
  2. Whether the cheques were issued towards an alleged oral booking of a flat in the plaintiff's project (as the defendant contends) and whether that defence required return/cancellation proceedings.
  3. Whether any alleged oral modification of the written agreement would render the plaintiff's summary suit based on the (original or modified) agreement non-maintainable.
  4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to interest at the rate of 18% per annum as provided in the 18 August 2006 writing.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The agreement of 18 August 2006 required the defendant to pay within 30 days; the 30-day period expired on 17 September 2006 and the suit filed on 15 September 2009 is within three years from the expiry (plaintiff's counsel relied on the agreement date and payment schedule).
  • Part payments by cheques dated 25 March 2007, 5 April 2007 and 30 April 2007 were dishonoured; these dishonoured payments extended the cause of action and thus the limitation period.
  • The plaintiff denied having any construction project at Ghatkopar and pointed out that the defendant had not instituted any proceedings for return of the cheques.
  • For acceptance of a lesser consideration, fresh writing was not necessary; moreover, the suit is founded not only on the agreement but also on the affidavit cum declaration and the dishonoured cheques.
  • The plaintiff claimed interest at 18% per annum as provided in the writing dated 18 August 2006.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The suit is barred by limitation because the agreement is dated 18 August 2006 and the suit was filed on 15 September 2009 (alleged expiry of three years).
  • The cheques were issued towards an oral booking of a flat in an under-construction project of the plaintiff at Ghatkopar; when the defendant cancelled the booking, the plaintiff was liable to return the cheques and the payments were not under the suit agreement.
  • Any modification of the 18 August 2006 agreement was oral; therefore, a summary suit based on an orally modified agreement is not maintainable.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

On limitation: The court held that the cause of action to file the suit commenced only after the 30-day period from the 18 August 2006 agreement had expired (i.e., after 17 September 2006). The court accepted the plaintiff's position that dishonoured cheques dated 25 March 2007, 5 April 2007 and 30 April 2007 constituted part payments and thereby extended the cause of action until 30 April 2007. On this basis the court concluded there was no substance in the defence that the suit was barred by limitation.

On the alleged oral booking: The court found no material on record to show that the defendant had ever booked a flat in an alleged construction project of the plaintiff at Ghatkopar. The court noted that the defendants had not instituted any proceedings for return/cancellation of the cheques and described the defence that payments of large sums (Rs. 49 lacs) were made for an oral booking without any writing as "sham, bogus and illusory." Accordingly the court rejected that defence.

On oral modification: The court held there was no substance in the defence that fresh writing was required to accept a lesser consideration. Further, the court observed that the suit was founded not only on the written agreement dated 18 August 2006 but also on the affidavit cum declaration and the dishonoured cheques. Therefore, the defence based on alleged oral modification failed.

Overall conclusion of analysis: The court found each defence raised by the defendant to be sham and illusory, and therefore concluded the plaintiff was entitled to relief in terms of prayer (a) of the Summons for Judgment. The court also accepted the plaintiffs' claim to interest at 18% per annum as provided in the writing dated 18 August 2006.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Summons for Judgment is made absolute in terms of prayer clause (a).

Other directives: A decree is to be drawn up accordingly. The court allowed interest at the rate of 18% per annum as provided in the 18 August 2006 writing.

Consequences: The direct effect is that the plaintiff has obtained an absolute order on the Summons for Judgment and a decree will be prepared in accordance with the judgment. The opinion does not discuss any broader legal implications or the setting of a new precedent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Runwal Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. Yogesh Mehta

    1. This suit has been filed for recovery of sum of Rs. 1,60,40,822/- based on a written contract being the Agreement for Sale of TDR dated 18th August, 2006 read with the Affidavit cum Declaration and Undertaking dated 18th August, 2006 and the dishonoured cheques. Some of the relevant facts are set out hereunder:—

    2. By an agreement dated 3rd August, 2006 between Shiv-Shahi Punarvasan Prakalp Limited and the defendant herein, the said Shiv-Shahi Punarvasan Prakalp Limited agreed to sale and transfer to the defendant herein 3000 sq.mtrs of TDR under DRC No. SRA/622.Constn. dated 18th July, 2006 for the total consideration of Rs. 7,55,63,280/-. It appears that out of the consideration amount agreed under the said agreement, defendant could pay only Rs. 42,30,300/- to the said transferor Shiv-Shahi Punarvasan Prakalp Limited. It is the case of the plaintiff that defendant thereafter approached the plaintiff for financial help. Pursuant to the negotiations held between plaintiff and defendant, on 18th August, 2006, the Agreement for Sale/transfer TDR came to be arrived at between plaintiff and defendant. Under the said Agreement, the defendant herein agreed to sale TDR of 3000 sq.mtrs to the plaintiff and in view thereof, the plaintiff agreed to pay balance consideration of Rs. 7,13,32,980/- to the said Shiv-Shahi Punarvasan Prakalp Limited. It is agreed to adjust the sum of Rs. 5,94,17,280/- against the said amount agreed to be paid by the plaintiff to the said transferor. Defendant herein agreed to pay Rs. 1,19,15,700/- to the plaintiff within 30 days. If addition to the said agreement entered into between the plaintiff and defendant, the defendant has also executed an Agreement cum Declaration and Undertaking on 18th August, 2006. It is the case of the plaintiff that the defendant issued three postdated cheques of Rs. 70 lacs, Rs. 34 lacs and Rs. 9 lacs respectively in favour of the plaintiff. Out of three cheques, only a cheque of Rs. 9 lacs came to be honoured. It is the case of the plaintiff that even those cheques, when deposited, were dishonoured.

    3. By letter dated 21st March, 2007, addressed to the plaintiff, the defendant alleged that the defendant had booked a premises orally in the under construction project of the plaintiff and since the defendant wanted ready possession of the premises, the defendant thereafter requested the plaintiff to cancel the booking of the premises. He requested the plaintiffs to return the cheques issued by the defendant. Plaintiff by their letter dated 26th March, 20.07 denied the said allegations and refused to return the cheques. The Learned Counsel for the plaintiffs states that the defendants have not filed any proceedings for return of the said cheques. The plaintiff thereafter issued various notices demanding payment under various dishonoured cheques under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. Though the defendant replied to the notice, it was contended that the cheques issued were in respect of the booking of flats orally made by the defendant for booking of the flat for in under construction project of the plaintiffs. Finally, the plaintiff issued notice on 7th September, 2009 calling upon the defendant to pay a sum of Rs. 1,60,40,822/- with interest at the rate of 18% per annum. There is no reply to the said notice. The plaintiff thereafter filed the present suit and took out Summons for Judgment No. 516 of 2009. Defendant is absent though served. I have heard the learned Counsel appearing for the plaintiff and I have also perused the affidavit in reply filed by the defendant.

    4. The first defence raised by the defendant's is that suit is barred by the law of limitation contending that as the Agreement is dated 18th August, 2006, whereas the suit is filed on 15th September, 2009, i.e after expiry of the three years. The learned Counsel appearing for the plaintiff pointed out that under the said agreement dated 18th August, 2006, the defendant had agreed to pay the amount within 30 days from the date of the said agreement. The period of 30 days expired on 17th September, 2006, the suit was filed on 15th September, 2009. The learned Counsel also placed reliance on the fact that cheques issued on 25th March, 2007, 5th April, 2007 and 30th April, 2007 towards part payment, came to be dishonoured. According to the learned Counsel, period of limitation thus extended and suit as filed by the plaintiff is within time. In my view cause of action to file a suit would have commenced only after period of 30 days, from the date of the execution of the said agreement. Eyen otherwise, in view of the part payment made by the defendant, cause of action was extended till 30th April, 2007. In my view, there is no substance in the defence that the suit is barred by law of limitation.

    5. The next plea raised by the defendant is that cheques issued by the defendant were towards oral booking made by the defendant of the flat in the proposed construction project at Ghatkopar of the plaintiff and since these bookings were cancelled by the defendant, plaintiff was liable to return the said cheques. Defendant has alleged that the said payments were not made towards any consideration under the suit agreement. The Learned Counsel appearing for the plaintiff pointed out that at no point of time the plaintiff had any construction project at Ghatkopar as alleged by the defendant. Defendants have not filed any proceedings for return and/or cancellation of those cheques. In my view, the defendant never placed on record any material that at any point of time that it had booked any flat in the alleged construction project of the plaintiff at Ghatkopar It is very difficult to believe such plea raised by the defendant that huge amount of Rs. 49 lacs would be paid against oral booking of flat without insisting for any writing. I, therefore, reject this defence raised by the defendant as the same is sham, bogus and illusory.

    6. The next defence raised by the defendant is that even if suit agreement dated 18th August, 2006 is modified, it has been modified orally and therefore summary suit based on such modified agreement orally is not maintainable. The learned Counsel appearing for the plaintiff pointed out that for accepting lessor consideration, fresh writing was not necessary. In my view, there is no substance raised by the defendant that fresh writing was required to be executed between the parties for accepting lessor amount. In any event, since the plaintiff have filed the present suit not only on the basis of the agreement for sale of TDR, dated 18th August, 2006 but also on the basis of affidavit cum declaration and undertaking and also dishonoured cheques. Therefore there is no substance in this defence raised by the defendant.

    7. In my view each and every defence raised by the defendant is sham and illusory The plaintiff is, therefore, entitled to order in terms of prayer (a) of Summons for Judgment. In view of the provisions in the writing dated 18th August, 2006 for interest @ 18% per annum, the plaintiffs have rightly claimed interest @ 18% per annum.

    8. I accordingly pass the following order:—

    (1) Summons for Judgment is made absolute in terms of prayer clause (a).

    (2) Decree to be drawn up accordingly.

    Order accordingly.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Runwal Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. Yogesh Mehta
    (Mar 7, 2012)