1 Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith and heard
finally by consent of learned Counsel for respective parties.
2 The petitioners are challenging order dated 09.12.2011,
passed by Divisional Commissioner, Aurangabad, in Appeal No.
104/2011, whereby the appellate authority allowed the appeal
presented by Respondent No.4 herein and quashed and set aside
the decision of village panchayat expressing no confidence against
Respondent No.4, in a meeting dated 26.08.2011.
{3}
wp226712.odt
3 Respondent No.4 is the Sarpanch of village panchayat
Futana. A motion of no confidence was moved against the
Sarpanch by six members out of total strength of seven members,
by presenting a requisition in that behalf on 20.08.2011 to the
Tahsildar, Kalamnuri. The Tahsildar directed issuance of notice to
the Sarpanch and convened a meeting for consideration of no
confidence motion on 26.08.2011 at the office of village panchayat.
The meeting was attended by six members, whereas, Respondent
No.4 - Sarpanch of village panchayat remained absent. The motion
of no confidence was passed against Respondent No.4 by all the six
members of village panchayat casting their vote in favour of the
motion.
4 The Resolution adopted in the meeting expressing no
confidence against the Sarpanch was subjected to challenge in an
appeal presented to the Additional Collector, Hingoli. It is
contended in the memorandum of appeal by Respondent No.4 that
he has not been served with the notice of meeting and the alleged
service of notice on the mother of Respondent No.4, who is a
female member of the family, is not in consonance with Rule 7 of
the Bombay Village Panchayats (Meetings) Rules, 1959 and as
such, the motion of no confidence passed against him deserves to
be quashed and set aside. The Additional Collector, Hingoli, was
not convinced by the arguments and referring to sub-rule (2-B) of
{4}
wp226712.odt
Rule 2 of the Bombay Village Panchayats Sarpanch and Up-
Sarpanch (No Confidence Motion) Rules, 1975, it is recorded that
the notice shall have to be construed as validly served if it is
handed over to the adult member of the family.
5 The decision rendered by the Additional Collector,
Hingoli, was subject matter of appeal at the instance of
Respondent No.4 before the Divisional Commissioner, Aurangabad,
who accepted the argument advanced by appellant - Respondent
No.4 herein in respect of invalid service of notice and proceeded to
quash and set aside the proceedings of meeting dated 26.08.2011,
including the Resolution of no confidence passed against
Respondent No.4.
6 I have heard arguments advanced by learned Counsel
for respective parties. It is contended by learned Counsel for the
petitioners that provisions of sub-rule (2-B) of Rule 2 of the
Bombay Village Panchayats Sarpanch and Up-Sarpanch (No
Confidence Motion) Rules, 1975, would govern the aspect of service
of notice and once it is established that the notice is served on the
adult member of the family, it is sufficient compliance of the
requirement. It is contended that even if it is held that Rule 7 of
the Bombay Village Panchayats (Meetings) Rules, 1959, is
applicable, the condition requiring tendering of notice on the adult
male member of the family shall have to be construed as directory
{5}
wp226712.odt
since it is merely a procedural part. It is contended that by
construing the condition prescribed in the Rules as directory, the
object of provisions of the enactment would be achieved in stead of
holding the same as mandatory. It is contended that the object of
enactment would be defeated if the rule governing service of notice
on the adult male member, as contemplated by Rule 7, is
construed as mandatory.
7 Learned Counsel appearing for Respondent No.4
contended that in view of decision of the Full Bench in the matter
of Viswas Pandurang Mokal Vs. Group Gram Panchayat, Shihu
and others, reported in 2011 (3) Mh.L.J. 500, the provisions of
Bombay Village Panchayats (Meeting) Rules, 1959, are applicable
for conduct of business of a special meeting of panchayat for
consideration of motion of no confidence moved under Section 35
of the Bombay Village Panchayats Act. Reliance is placed on
paragraph no.17 of the judgment, which reads thus:
"17 Thus, Rule 17 provides that the person
who has submitted notice of the motion shall
move the motion in the meeting. Rule 20 deals
with how amendments to the motion can be
proposed. Rule 21 deals with how a person
who wants to speak on a motion has to
address. What should be the duration of the
speech and what is the decorum to be following
in speaking at the meeting. Thus, in these
Rules provisions in detail have been made for
the conduct of the meeting both ordinary and
{6}
wp226712.odt
special of the village panchayat. Perusal of the
No Confidence Motion Rules shows that they do
not contain any provision in relation to the
conduct of the meeting. Provisions for conduct
of the meeting of the village panchayat are to be
found in the Meeting Rules. The manner of
submitting a requisition for convening a special
meeting of the village panchayat to consider
motion of no confidence against the Sarpanch
or Up-Sarpanch is to be found in sub-sections
(1) and (2) of section 35 and the No Confidence
Motion Rules. But neither in section 35 nor in
the No Confidence Motion Rules we find
provisions made as how many days notice
should be given to the members of the Special
meeting to be convened under section 35.
Therefore, in our opinion, for that purpose one
will have to follow the provisions of the Meeting
Rules because they lay down as to how many
days notice of special meeting is to be given to
the members. Section 35 provides that the
Sarpanch or Up-Sarpanch against whom the
motion is to be moved is entitled to attend and
participate in the meeting, and he is entitled to
speak at the meeting. But there is no provision
to be found made in section 35 or in the No
Confidence Motion Rules as to the manner in
which the Sarpanch or Up-Sarpanch can
exercise his right to participate and speak at
that meeting. Provisions for that purpose are to
be found in the Meeting Rules. Neither section
35 nor No Confidence Motion Rules lay down as
to what is to be done if the requisite quorum is
not present at such meeting. But the meeting
Rules contain provisions in that regard.
Neither Section 35 nor No Confidence Motion
Rules makes provision dealing with the
situation when the members present in the
{7}
wp226712.odt
meeting disregard the authority of the presiding
officer. Those provisions are to be found in the
Meeting Rules. In our opinion, therefore, there
is no reason why the provisions of the Meeting
Rules to the extent that no contrary provision
is made either in the Act itself or in the No
Confidence Motion Rules should not apply to a
meeting called under section 35. In our
opinion, if the provisions of the Meeting Rules
are held to be applicable to a meeting called
under section 35, it will facilitate holding of
meeting under section 35 effectively. Therefore,
in our opinion, it can be safely said that the
provisions of the Meeting Rules generally apply
to a special meeting convened under section 35.
However, such provisions of the Meeting Rules
which are found to be contrary to the
provisions contained either in the Act in
relation to the holding of the special meeting for
consideration of motion of no confidence
against Sarpanch or Up-Sarpanch or in the No
Confidence Motion Rules would not apply to a
meeting called under section 35. Now taking
up the question whether specifically provisions
of Rule 17 of the Meeting Rules apply to a
meeting called under section 35 is concerned,
in our opinion, the provisions of section 17 will
apply in a meeting called under section 35. As
observed above section 35 contains a provision
for submission of requisition by members to the
Tahsildar for calling a special meeting of the
village panchayat to consider the motion of no
confidence against Sarpanch or Up-Sarpanch.
It casts a duty on the Tahsildar to call a
meeting for that purpose within seven days of
the receipt of the requisition. But section 35
does not contain any provision as to how that
meeting is to be conducted, save and except to
{8}
wp226712.odt
provide that the Sarpanch or Up-Sarpanch
concerned shall have a right to attend and
participate in that meeting. We have already
observed above that perusal of No Confidence
Motion Rules and the Form of the requisition
shows that when the members of the village
panchayat submit the requisition to the
Tahsildar, what they actually do is that they
request the Tahsildar to convene a special
meeting of the village panchayat so that in that
meeting they can move a motion of no
confidence against Sarpanch or Up-Sarpanch.
It is, thus, clear that moving of the motion of no
confidence is not by submission of requisition
to the Tahsildar. The requisition is only for
calling a special meeting to facilitate moving of
motion of no confidence. The motion of no
confidence is actually moved in the meeting of
the village panchayat and as there is no
contrary provision to be found either in the Act
or in the No Confidence Motion Rules, in
relation to moving of a motion in a meeting of
the village panchayat, Rule 17 of the Meeting
Rules which makes such a provision will apply.
In the Meeting Rules there is a provision made
for calling a special meeting of village panchayat
because a requisition is received from
members. Therefore, concept of convening a
special meeting of the village panchayat as a
consequence of requisition received from the
members is to be found in the Meeting Rules
itself and therefore, all those provisions
contained in the Meeting Rules in relation to
convening and holding of a special meeting of
the village panchayat will apply to the special
meeting convened under section 35, subject to
there being any specific contrary provision in
the Act or in the No Confidence Motion Rules."
{9}
wp226712.odt
8 On perusal of the judgment of the Full Bench in
Viswas's case, it would be clear that the Full Bench has expressed
an opinion that the provisions of Meeting Rules to the extent that
no contrary provision either in the Act itself or in the No
Confidence Motion Rules, 1975, would apply to a meeting called
under Section 35. It is reiterated by the Full Bench that although
provisions contained in Meeting Rules in relation to convening and
holding of a special meeting of village panchayat will apply to a
special meeting convened under Section 35, subject to there being
any contrary provision in the Act or in the No Confidence Motion
Rules. It would be, thus, clear that the provisions contained in the
Meetings Rules in relation to convening and holding of a special
meeting of village panchayat will apply to the special meeting. The
objection raised in the instant matter by Respondent No.4 to the
validity of the meeting is on the ground of non observance of Rule
7 of the Meeting Rules in its strict sense. Since there is a specific
provision contained in sub-rule (2-B) of Rule 2 the Bombay Village
Panchayats Sarpanch and Up-Sarpanch (No Confidence Motion)
Rules, 1975, in respect of service of notice on the adult member of
the family, it cannot be insisted upon by Respondent No.4 that the
notice shall be served only on the adult male member of the family,
as mandated by Rule 7 of the Meeting Rules of 1959. Sub-rule (2-
B) of Rule 2 of the Bombay Village Panchayats Sarpanch and Up-
Sarpanch (No Confidence Motion) Rules, 1975, provides thus:
{10}
wp226712.odt
2-B Every notice under sub-rule (1), wherever
it may be practicable, be served by delivering or
tendering it to the Sarpanch or Upa-Sarpanch
to whom it is addressed or, where such person
cannot be found, by delivery or tendering it to
any adult member of his family residing with
him; and if no such adult member can be found
or, where the Sarpanch, Upa-Sarpanch or sult
adult member, as the case may be, refuses to
accept the notice, it shall be served by affixing
it, in the presence of two witnesses, on the
outer door or some other conspicuous part of
the house in which such Sarpanch or Upa-
Sarpanch ordinarily dwells. The notice served
in this manner shall be deemed to be served or
tendered or delivered to the concerned
Sarpanch or Upa Sarpanch.
9 In the instant matter, there is evidence that the notice
of no confidence has been served on the mother of Respondent No.
4. There is proper compliance of the requirement of sub-rule (2-B)
of Rule 2 of the Rules. As such, it cannot be permitted to be
contended by Respondent No.4 that notice has not been properly
served upon him. Considering the observations made by the Full
Bench in paragraph no.17 of the judgment, quoted above, once
there is observance of provisions of Sub-rule (2-B) of Rule 2 the
No Confidence Motion Rules, 1975, in respect of service of notice,
Respondent No.4 cannot be permitted to insist upon compliance of
Rule 7 of the Meeting Rules, 1959 and also cannot be permitted to
contend that service of notice on the female member of the family
{11}
wp226712.odt
is bad. The insistence made by Respondent No.4 for strict
compliance of Rule 7 of the Meeting Rules, 1959, inasmuch as
service of notice on male adult member of the family, also cannot
be said to be a mandatory requirement. The provisions of sub-rule
(2-B) of Rule 2 the No Confidence Motion Rules, 1975, permit
service of notice on the adult member of the family and as such,
compliance of said sub-rule is sufficient to draw an inference in
respect of validity of service of notice. The requirement of service
of notice only on the male member of the family, as contemplated
by Rule 7 of the Meeting Rules, 1959, cannot be construed as a
mandatory requirement. The question, as to whether a Statute is
mandatory or directory depends upon the intent of legislature and
not upon the language in which the intent is clothed. The meaning
and intention of the legislature must govern and those are to be
ascertained not only from the phraseology of the provision, but
also by considering its nature, its design and the consequences
which would follow from construing it, the one way or the other.
The object of the provisions of section 35 is to ensure democratic
functioning of the local institutions and removal of office bearers
who does not command confidence of majority. The decision taken
by the majority cannot be permitted to be defeated for technical
reasons.
10 In this context, reference can be made to the judgment
in the matter of Smt.Annapurnabai Ajabrao Vs. Annapurnabai
{12}
wp226712.odt
Anandrao, reported in 1967 Mh.L.J. NOC 36, wherein, Division
Bench of this Court, in para 16 has observed thus:
"Even if it were to be assumed that there
was some technical flaw in the proceedings of
the meeting or in transmission of the results of
the meeting to the Panchayat Samiti, we do not
see how that could entitle the petitioner to
claim to continue as Sarpanch of the Gram
Panchayat. A Gram Panchayat is essentially a
democratic institution which must be run on
democratic principles. When the majority of
the members have clearly expressed that they
do not desire the petitioner to be their leader
and Sarpanch, appropriate attitude of the
petitioner as a person working for democracy
whatever have been to tender her registration
straightway. At any rate, it does not behave of
democratic spirit to challenge the decision of
the majority who unmistakably declared their
want of confidence in their erstwhile leader."
11 In the instant matter, Respondent No.4 has lost
confidence of the majority since all the six members out of total
strength of seven members of the panchayat, have expressed their
no confidence against him. Respondent No.4 is, therefore,
expected to respect will of the majority and make way for election
of leader who holds confidence of majority. The decision rendered
by Divisional Commissioner, Aurangabad, allowing the appeal
presented by Respondent No.4, is erroneous and, therefore, liable
to be quashed.
{13}
wp226712.odt
12 In the result, order dated 09.12.2011, passed by
Divisional Commissioner, Aurangabad, in Appeal No.104/2011, is
quashed and set aside.
13 Rule is accordingly made absolute. There shall be no
order as to costs.