):-
This appeal under Section 260A of the
Income Tax Act, 1961 ('the Act') by the appellant-
SNC 1/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
assessee challenging an order dated 25.02.1999 of
the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ('the Tribunal')
relating to the assessment for the block period
01.04.1985 to 26.03.1996 was admitted on
06.12.1999. Along with this appeal, we also heard
appeals by the other members of the appellants
group i.e. Appeal No. 86 of 1999 by her husband Dr.
Sohanlal Gupta, Appeal No. 91 of 1999 by her son
Dr. Arunkumar Gupta, Appeal No. 36 of 1999 by her
daughter-in-law Dr.Renu Gupta and Appeal by
Sohanlal Gupta (HUF) bearing Appeal No. 37 of 1999.
2 This appeal was admitted on the following
substantial questions of law for the consideration
of this Court:
i) Whether the Appellate
Tribunal was right in law in coming
to the conclusion that the gifts
received by the appellant from non
Resident Indians (NRI) from their Non
Resident External accounts (NRE
accounts) during the Assessment years
1993-94, 1994-95 and 1995-96 are the
'undisclosed income' of the appellant
within the meaning of clause (b) of
Section 158B of the Act even though
the said gifts were recorded in the
regular books of account of the
SNC 2/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
appellant and disclosed in the
returns of income of the appellant
filed prior to the date of the search
and no incriminating material was
found in the course of search?
ii) Whether on the facts and
in the circumstances of the case a
person well informed in law could
have come to the conclusion that the
gifts received by the appellant were
actually purchased by the appellant
when there is no evidence to that
effect on record and the appellant
has been able to prove the identify
of the donors by producing passports,
the genuineness of the transactions
by producing bank pass books of the
donors and capacity of the donors as
the gifts were received from Non
Resident External Accounts of the
donors?
iii) Whether the Appellate
Tribunal was right in law in not
considering that the appellant had
discharged the burden of proof that
lies on her by producing copies of
passports of the donors, bank pass
books of the donors, confirmatory
letters of the donors and the fact
that the gifts were given by the
donors from their respective Non
Resident External accounts and
thereafter the burden of proof had
shifted to the Assessing Officer who
has failed to discharge the same as
the Assessing Officer neither
summoned the donors nor issued any
commission nor adduced any evidence
to establish that the appellant had
not received the gifts from the
donors?
iv) Whether the Appellate
Tribunal was right in law in coming
SNC 3/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
to the conclusion that the gifts
received by the appellant are non
genuine even though there is no
evidence brought on record to derive
a legal inference to the effect that
the gifts were actually purchased by
the appellant and therefore, they are
non-genuine?
v) Whether the Appellate
Tribunal was right in law in coming
to the conclusion that the case of
the appellant is of a money-
laundering device because the copies
of passports, personal letters, gift
deeds, copies of pass book etc. were
all obtained simultaneously with the
cheques for gifts?
vi) Whether the Appellate
Tribunal was right in law in coming
to the conclusion that the gifts
received by the appellant are non
genuine because the confirmatory
letters obtained by the appellant
from different donors are identically
worded and typed on the same
typewriter even though it was
explained by the appellant that the
confirmatory letters were drafted and
prepared by the appellant herself and
sent to the donors for their
signatures for the limited purpose of
tax records?
vii) Whether the Appellate
Tribunal was right in law in not
considering the alternate argument of
the appellant to the effect that the
alleged commission receipts of
Rs.2,42,870/- cannot be separately
added in view of the addition on
account of cash seized amounting to
Rs.40,98,735/- which was sufficient
enough to cover the undisclosed
income from clinics estimated at
SNC 4/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
Rs.32,88.105/- and also commission
receipts of Rs.2,42,870/- otherwise
it would amount to taxing the same
income twice?
3 Brief facts relevant to this appeal are as
under:
(a) The appellant is running health
clinics in the name of M/s. Kayakalp
International along with her family. The
appellant's family consists of her husband
one Dr. Sohanlal Gupta (Dental Surgeon),
her son one Dr. Arunkumar Gupta (a Medical
Doctor) and her daughter-in-law one Dr.
Renu Gupta (also a Medical Doctor).
(b) The entire family of the appellant was
residing in Bhattinda, Punjab up to July
1991. However, due to terrorist activities
in Punjab, the appellant and her family
moved to Mumbai and commenced their health
clinic viz. Kayakalp International at
Borivali, Mumbai. This business expanded
and soon it had established two more
SNC 5/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
clinics in Mumbai as under:
(i) Charni Road, Mumbai- May 1995 and
(ii) Dadar, Mumbai- November 1995
(c) On 26.03.1996, a search was conducted
under Section 132 of the Act at the
three clinics and residential premises of
the appellant and her family. Consequent
thereto, assessment for block period i.e.
from 01.04.1985 to 26.03.1996 were
commenced under Chapter XIV-B of the Act
against the appellant and her said family
members.
(d) During the course of the search,
it was noticed that the appellant and the
said others received substantial gifts
from certain Non Resident Indians out of
their Non Resident External Accounts
during the assessment years 1994-95, 1995-
96 and 1996-97. Besides, during the
course of search, the appellant had
SNC 6/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
offered an amount of Rs.40.98lacs for
taxation during the block period. In the
return of Income, the appellant had
disclosed an amount of Rs.39.74lacs as
unexplained cash & offered the same for
taxation. The Assessing Officer completed
the assessment for the block period
01.04.1985 to 26.03.1996 by an order dated
27.03.1997 under Section 158BA of the Act,
determining her total undisclosed income
at Rs.2.11crores. This was computed on
the basis of unexplained cash credits,
commission received on advertising,
unexplained loans, undisclosed investments
in properties, gifts from Resident Indians
and Non Resident Indians etc.
(e) Being aggrieved, the appellant
preferred an appeal against the order
dated 27.03.1997 to the Tribunal. The
Tribunal by its order dated 25.02.1999
deleted all additions made to the income
SNC 7/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
by the Assessing Officer save and except
the following two additions:
a) Gifts received from Non Resident
Indians from their NRE accounts and cash
premium paid thereon aggregating to
Rs.4.06lacs for the assessment year 1994-
1995 and 1995-1996; and
b) Commission received from M/s.
Chintamani Advertiser aggregating to
Rs.2.42 lacs for the assessment year 1993-
94 up to 1996-1997.
4 The appellant is in appeal, on the
aforesaid two additions, which has been sustained
by the order dated 25.02.1999 of the Tribunal.
5 Mr. B. V. Jhaveri, learned Counsel
appearing for the appellant submitted that seven
questions of law, as framed by the appellant, at
the time of admission of the appeal could be
suitably classified into two questions of law
namely question no. (i) and question no.(vii).
SNC 8/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
According to him, questions nos. (ii) to (vi) are
mere facets of the issue arising in question no.
(i). Therefore, he is not pressing question nos.
(ii) to (vi) and seeks to raise and press only
question nos. (i) & (vii) at the time of final
hearing.
6 With regard to the first question namely
gifts received from Non Resident Indians through
their NRE accounts being brought to tax as
undisclosed income under Chapter XIV-B of the said
Act is concerned, Mr. Jhaveri made the following
submissions:
a) Gifts received by the appellant
cannot be subjected to tax in a block
assessment under Chapter XIV-B of the Act,
as the same would not fall within the
meaning of undisclosed income as given
under Section 158B(b) of the Act. This
was for the reason that the gifts which
were received by the appellant had been
declared to the Income Tax Authorities in
SNC 9/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
the form of capital gain account filed
along with her return of income. In
support, he invited our attention to the
return of income filed by the appellant
during the assessment years 1994-95 and
1995-96. So far as, assessment year 1993-
94 is concerned, he invited our attention
to an order dated 28.09.1995 of the
Assessing Officer under Section 143(3) of
the Act, wherein the gifts received from
NRI's was subject matter of inquiry and
duly considered while passing the
assessment order.
b) A block assessment can only be
carried out on the basis of documents
found during the search and not on the
basis of other documents/evidence obtained
otherwise than during the course of a
search. According to him, the entire
basis of the block assessment was with
regard to the gifts, were statements made
by the appellant's husband and son to the
SNC 10/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
FERA (Foreign Exchange Regulation Act)
Authorities on 06.11.1996 and 07.11.1996
respectively; and
c) On merits, the documents found
during the search were in the form of
copies of the passport of the donors,
copies of their NRE accounts and also
confirmatory letters from the donors
regarding the fact that the gifts have
been made to the appellant. According to
him none of the aforesaid documents either
singly or together could lead to the
conclusion that the gifts are fake. This
conclusion by the authorities is based
merely on suspicion. Suspicion howsoever
strong, cannot take a place of proof. In
view of the above, Mr. Jhaveri submits
that the additions of amounts received as
gifts to the appellant's income as
unexplained credits and/or fake gifts is
not sustainable.
the learned Counsel for the Revenue-respondent
submits as under:
a) The disclosure made by the
appellant while filing its return of
income was not a subject matter of inquiry
in the assessment year 1994-95 and 1995-96
as the same was not declared as her
income. So far as, assessment year 1993-
1994 is concerned, the Non Resident
Indians gifts received from NRE account
had not been brought to tax as undisclosed
income in view of the fact that the same
was the subject of inquiry in an order
passed under Section 143(3) of the Act on
28.09.1995. Therefore, the reliance upon
the aforesaid order by the appellant to
establish that the gifts have been
disclosed as income is not relevant for
the present proceedings;
b) It was only on search that the
documents found established that what had
SNC 12/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
been disclosed as gifts were in fact not
gifts but merely purchase of entries at a
premium, so as to convert her undisclosed
income into regular income. Therefore the
amounts shown as gifts were in fact
undisclosed income and therefore within
the scope of Chapter XIV-B of the Act;
c) The amount taxed as undisclosed
income under Chapter XIV-B of the Act were
on the basis of material found during the
search. The material found during the
search indicated that the gifts were not
genuine; and
d) In matter such as these, one can
never have conclusive evidence and one
would have to take into account the
surrounding circumstances particularly the
fact that gifts aggregating to Rs.35.47
lacs were received by the appellant and
her family. This fact and the surrounding
circumstances would be tested on the
probability of human behaviour to arrive
SNC 13/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
at conclusion whether the gifts are
genuine or not. In considering such
probabilities, it cannot be said that the
conclusion was reached on the basis of
conjectures, surmise, inferences and/or
suspicions.
8 The second issue is that the commission
of Rs.2.42 lacs received from M/s.Chintamani
Advertiser should not be separately subjected to
tax in view of the fact that out of Rs.40.98 lacs
cash seized the respondents had estimated an amount
of Rs.32.88 lacs as undisclosed income leaving a
sufficient balance to cover the commission receipts
of Rs.2.42 lacs was not raised before the Assessing
Officer or the Tribunal. In the circumstances, the
question no.(vii) would not arise for consideration
by us. Our court in the matter of CIT v. Tata
Chemicals, reported in 256 ITR page 395 has held
that an appeal to the High Court under Section 260A
of the Act can only be on a question raised before
the Tribunal. In this case, admittedly, the
SNC 14/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
question as formulated for our consideration was
not raised before the Tribunal. Therefore there is
no occasion for us to consider and answer the same.
9 Therefore in this appeal we are concerned
only with the alleged gifts received by the
appellant from Non Resident Indians out of their
NRE accounts. Before, dealing with the respective
submission for the purposes of considering the
issue raised in this appeal, we may usefully
reproduce the relevant provisions of Chapter XIV-B
of the said Act as under:
158B. In this Chapter, unless the
context otherwise requires.-
(a).....
(b) "undisclosed income" includes
any money, bullion, jewellery or
other valuable article or thing or
any income based on any entry in the
books of account or other documents
or transactions, where such money,
bullion, jewellery, valuable
articles, thing, entry in the books
of account or other document or
transaction represents wholly or
partly income or property which has
not been or would not have been
disclosed for the purposes of this
Act [,or any expense, deduction or
allowance claimed under this Act
SNC 15/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
which is found to be false].
Assessment of undisclosed income as a
result of search
158BA(1)....
Computation of undisclosed income of
the block period
158BB(1) The undisclosed income of
the block period shall be the
aggregate of the total income of the
previous years falling within the
block period computed, [in accordance
with the provisions of this Act, on
the basis of evidence found as a
result of search or requisition of
books of account or other documents
and such other materials or
information as are available with the
Assessing Officer and relatable to
such evidence],
(a) ...
(b) ...
(c) ...
(d) ...
(e) ...
(f) ...
Explanation-......
(2) In computing the undisclosed
income of the block period, the
provisions of sections 68,69,69a, 69b
and 69C shall, so far as may be,
apply and references to "financial
year" in those sections shall be
construed as references to the
relevant previous year falling in the
block period including the previous
year ending with the date of search
or of the requisition.
(3) The burden of providing to
the satisfaction of the Assessing
Officer that any undisclosed income
had already been disclosed in any
return of income filed by the
SNC 16/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
assessee before the commencement of
search or of the requisition, as the
case may be, shall be on the
assessee.
(4) ....
10 Mr. Jhaveri submits that the sine-qua-non
for application of Chapter XIV-B of the Act is that
the income should be undisclosed income.
Undisclosed Income has been defined under Section
158B(b) of the said Act as any income or property
which has not been or would not have been disclosed
for the purposes of this Act. Mr. Jhaveri in
support of his submission that all the alleged
gifts had been disclosed to the respondent, relies
upon the return of income filed by the appellant
for the assessment years 1993-94, 1994-95 and 1995-
96 where along with the return of income, the
appellant had filed her Capital Account which
disclosed the receipt of gifts. However, we are not
really concerned with the disclosure made in the
assessment year 1993-94 for the reason that the
gift received during that year have not been made
part of undisclosed gifts before the Tribunal.
This is evident from paragraph 6 internal page 8 of
SNC 17/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
the impugned order dated 25.02.1999.
11 So far as, the assessment years 1994-95
and 1995-96 are concerned, it is an admitted
position that no assessment under Section 143(3) of
the Act had been done for the above two years till
the initiation of block assessment proceedings
under Chapter XIV-B of the Act. Mr. Jhaveri
submits that there is difference between a block
assessment and regular assessment. According to
him, in a block assessment only that income can be
subjected to tax which has not been disclosed but
found as a result of search under the Act. The
assessment as block assessment under Chapter XIV-B
of the Act is an assessment of undisclosed income
unearthed, as a result of a search. However, the
same would not affect the regular assessment
covering the previous year falling in the block
period. It is therefore, his submission that in
case the Assessing Officer was of the view that the
gifts were not genuine, then the same having been
disclosed in the regular assessment could be a
SNC 18/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
subject matter of proceedings for reopening of
assessment etc. but to subject such disclosed
income as a part block assessment is not available
to the department/respondent. In support of
aforesaid submission, he relies upon the decision
of the Supreme Court in the matter of Asst.
Commissioner of Income Tax v. Hotel Bluemoon
reported in 321 ITR page 362.
There can be no quarrel with the above
proposition. However, where the income has not
been disclosed and the same has been reveled during
the search proceedings then block assessment as
provided under Chapter XIV-B of the Act would
certainly apply. The meaning of undisclosed income
as spelt out under Section 158B(b) is that
undisclosed income is that income which has not
been or would not have been disclosed for the
purpose of this Act. In the present case, the
appellant had not disclosed its income but had
incorrectly disclosed the same as gifts received.
This is for the reason that gifts are not income,
SNC 19/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
they are received on capital account and can never
be subjected to tax. However, during the course of
search, it was found that the appellant had
incorrectly declared large amounts as gifts, when
in fact no such gifts were received from Non
Resident Indians. Therefore, where the gifts are
found to be not genuine, then the amounts
represented by those gifts certainly become
undisclosed income. Further, the burden of proof is
on the assessee in terms of Section 158BB(3) of the
Act to satisfy the Assessing Officer that the so
called undisclosed income has already been
disclosed in the return of income filed by the
assessee. To our mind, mere mentioning of an
amount as capital receipt in the Capital Account
would not amount to a disclosure of income. This
is so, as a capital receipt is not income and
consequently not subject to tax.
13 Mr. Jhaveri in support of his contention
that the slleged gifts were disclosed income to
which Chapter XIVB of the Act would not apply
SNC 20/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
firstly relied upon the decision of Delhi High
Court in the matter of L.R.Gupta v. Union of India
reported in 194 ITR page 32 where the court held
that in terms of Section 132 (1)(c) of the Act
"income which has not been disclosed" would mean
income which the assessee has not returned in his
income tax return. Mr. Jhaveri states that in the
present facts the gift has been shown along with
her return of income filed for the assessment years
1994-95 and 1995-96. However, as held in L. R.
Gupta (supra) at page 48
The words 'undisclosed
income' must mean income which is liable to be
taxed under the provisions of the Income Tax Act
but which has not been disclosed by an assessee in
an effort to escape assessment. 'Not disclosed'
must mean the intention of the assessee to hide the
existence of the income or the assets from the
Income Tax Department, while being aware that the
same is rightly taxable.
Therefore in the present
facts, the appellant-assessee had disclosed a
receipt as gifts only with an intention to hide the
existence of its income which was otherwise
SNC 21/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
taxable. In view of the above, this would be non
disclosed income for the purpose of Chapter XIV-B
of the Act;
14 He then relied upon the decision of the
Delhi High Court in the matter of CIT v. Ashok Dua
reported in 177 Taxman page 494. In the above
case, the assessee had disclosed receipts of gifts
in his return of income. However, during the
course of search, gift deeds and affidavits
relating to the same were discovered. The Assessing
Officer added the amount disclosed as gifts to the
income on the ground that the gifts were bogus.
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) and the
Tribunal on consideration of the facts involved
therein, came to the conclusion that no
incriminating material was found during the course
of search to indicate that the gifts were not
genuine. This concurrent finding of fact led the
Delhi High Court to refuse to interfere with the
orders of authorities under the Act.
In the present facts, the confirmatory
SNC 22/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
letters addressed by the donors to the assessee
were identically worded, typed on the same
typewriter, the donors seemed were not related to
the assessee, the aggregate gifts received by the
family of the appellant was over Rs.35 lacs and all
gifts were made allegedly out of love and affection
for the appellant and/or her family members.
Further, no circumstances have been indicated by
the appellant before the authorities or during the
hearing before us as to what was the occasion for
apparent strangers to advance an amount aggregating
Rs.35 lacs to the Gupta family as gifts. Therefore
the decision of Delhi High Court in the matter of
Ashok Dua (Supra) is completely distinguishable
from the facts arising in the present case.
15 Mr. Jhaveri then relied upon the
unreported decision of the Punjab & Hariyana High
Court in the matter of CIT v. V. P. Singh in Income
Tax Appeal No. 194 of 2002 dated 16.04.2012. In
the above case also, there was a finding of fact by
the Tribunal that the gifts received by the
SNC 23/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
assessee were genuine and mere non filing of a
return of income would not result in making the
gifts an undisclosed income, so as to attract
Chapter XIV-B of the Act. In the case at hand,
there is a finding of fact by the Assessing Officer
as well as the Tribunal that the gifts are not
genuine and the appellant has not been able to show
that the aforesaid conclusion of the Tribunal is
arbitrary or perverse.
16 The unreported decision of this court in
the matter of CIT v. Bombay Trading and Marketing
Co. in Income Tax Appeal No.2234 of 2009 dated
04.01.2010, wherein this court dismissed an appeal
by the revenue on the ground that the Commissioner
of Income Tax (Appeals) and the Tribunal held that
where sundry creditors had been disclosed in the
regular return of income and accepted by the
Department, it would not be open to the Department
to allege that the amounts which were reflected as
sundry creditor could not be added as a part of
income in a block assessment under Chapter XIV-B of
SNC 24/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
the Act. In the above case also the Commissioner
of Income Tax (Appeals) and the Tribunal had come
to a finding of fact that the income had been
disclosed in the regular return of income filed by
the assessee and that the credit balances shown
were not genuine. In the present facts it was as a
result of search that the revenue came across
documents which led it to the conclusion that
whatever was shown as gifts were in fact not gifts,
but undisclosed income which was shown as gifts.
Therefore, the aforesaid decision also is
inapplicable to the present fact.
17 In Bhagvati Prasad Kedia v. CIT, reported
in 248 ITR page 562(Cal), the department sought to
consider the genuineness of loan under a block
assessment even though the same had been duly
accounted for in the regular books of account as
found during the search. In the above case the
court held that Assessing Officer and the Tribunal
were incorrect in holding that the loan could be
taxed as undisclosed income inter alia on the
SNC 25/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
ground that the loan was genuine as the loan
creditor was an assessee in whose assessment the
loan advanced had been accepted by the Revenue. As
against the above, in the present case no evidence
has been led by the appellant to establish the
genuineness of the gifts such as producing the
donors before the authorities etc. Therefore in our
view the present case is a clear case of the gifts
being undisclosed income which is subject to
Chapter XIV-B of the said Act.
18 In CIT v. Vikram Doshi reported in 256
ITR page 129 (Bom) the Tribunal had as a matter of
fact come to the conclusion that if the income
concerned had been disclosed and was the subject
matter of regular assessment then the same cannot
be a part of block assessment. The aforesaid
finding of the Tribunal being a finding of fact was
not interfered with by this court. The facts in the
present case are completely distinguishable as
there are concurrent findings of fact by the
Assessing Officer and the Tribunal that the so
SNC 26/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
called gifts were in fact not gifts, but
undisclosed income to which Section 68 of the Act
would clearly apply.
19 We therefore find that none of the
decisions which were relied upon by the appellant
during the course of the hearing would have any
application to the facts of the present case. In
this case, there is a concurrent finding of fact by
the Assessing Officer and the Tribunal that the
amounts shown as gifts were not genuine gifts, but
were mere credits taken so as to evade payment of
income tax. Further, as gifts are not income being
a capital receipt and not subject to income tax its
disclosure or non disclosure is of no consequence
for the purpose of the Act. The Assessing Officer
would normally accept an assessee's return of
income along with the accounts showing an amount
received as gifts in its capital account. However,
it is only on account of search that documents were
unearthed / found which showed that the gifts were
not genuine, but only a method to convert the
SNC 27/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
appellant's unaccounted money into regular income.
Therefore, we hold that the non genuine gifts to
the appellant was undisclosed income and covered by
the definition provided in Section 158B(b) of the
Act.
20 The second contention of the appellant is
that a block assessment can only be carried out in
respect of documents found during the search and it
is not open to the Assessing Officer to rely upon
the documents and/or evidence other than those
found during the course of the search for the
purposes of assessment under Chapter XIVB of the
Act. The submission is that the evidence found
during the search can alone be a basis for block
assessment. According to Mr. Jhaveri the
authorities under the Act have been influenced by
the confessional statement made by the Appellant's
son and husband to the FERA authorities on
06.11.1996 & 07.11.1996 respectively to the effect
that the gifts were not genuine and they paid a
premium of 8% to receive the gifts from Non
SNC 28/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
Resident Indians. However, the statement made
before the FERA authorities were withdrawn /
retracted on the next day have not been relied
upon. In any event, it is his contention that the
statements made under FERA were made after over 6
months from the date of the search and therefore,
was not evidence which was found during the course
of search and therefore could not be relied upon
for block assessment under Chapter XIVB of the Act.
21 This submission ignores the fact that
under Section 158BB(1) of the Act, an Assessing
Officer has to compute the undisclosed income for
the block period in accordance with the provision
of the Act on the basis of evidence found, as a
result of a search or other documents or materials
available with the Assessing Officer and relatable
to such evidence. In the present case, the evidence
in the form of confirmatory letters, deed of gifts
etc. were found during the course of search. The
authorities on examination of the confirmatory
letters and surrounding circumstances reached a
SNC 29/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
prima facie view that the gifts were not genuine. A
notice dated 27.06.1996 under Section 158BC of the
Act was accordingly issued. Thereafter, before the
assessment for the block period could be completed,
the Assessing Officer came across the confessional
statement made by the appellant's husband and son
under FERA stating that the gifts were not
genuine. Therefore, the statements made under the
FERA and its retractions are relatable to the
confirmatory letters given by the donors of the
gifts found during the search of the appellant's
premises. The confessional statement is certainly
relatable to the evidence found during the course
of the search.
22 Mr. Jhaveri in support of his submission
that the block assessment has to be done only on
the basis of the documents found during the course
of the search, relied upon the decision of the
Madras High Court in CIT v. S. Ajitkumar, reported
in 300 ITR page 152.
The High court upheld the finding of the
SNC 30/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
Tribunal that in case of block assessment only
documents found during the course of search could
be a basis for block amount. In the above case
information was gathered during the course of
survey operation at the premises of a third party
and that information/material was not relatable to
any material found during the course search
operation. On the aforesaid finding of fact, the
High Court refused to interfere. In the present
case, the Tribunal has essentially relied upon the
documents found during the course of the search
such as identical confirmatory letters typed on the
same typewriter not from relatives but from
strangers (most were seamen) and the confessional
statement as well as retraction made to FERA
authorities which were relatable to the material
found during the course of the search. Besides it
seems that the amendment made to Section 158BB(1)
of the Act in 2002 with retrospective effect from
1995 was not brought to the notice of the court.
The section as amended permits assessment on the
basis of any material with the Assessing officer
SNC 31/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
relatable to the evidence found during the search.
Therefore the above decision is distinguishable
from the present facts.
23 In CIT v. K. Bhuvanendran & Ors. Reported
in [2008]303 ITR page 235(Mad) a statement made
during the course of the search that certain
undisclosed income had been paid was retracted.
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) as well as
the Tribunal held that the retracted statement
could not be relied upon as there was no evidence
or material found during the course of search
operation to which such statement could be related.
The aforesaid findings of fact were not interfered
with by Madras High Court. This above case is
completely distinguishable as in the present facts,
there was material found during the course of
search which gave rise to a finding that the gifts
shown by the appellant were not genuine and the
statement and the retraction thereof to the FERA
authorities were certainly relatable to the
evidence found during the course of the search.
(2009) 308 ITR page 124, the decision in S.
Ajitkumar's case (Supra) were relied upon to
conclude that only material found during the search
could be relied upon for the purpose of block
assessment. In the aforesaid case, the fixed
deposits in fictitious names were found not during
the course of search, but during the course of
investigation which followed the search. On the
aforesaid facts, the Madras High Court held that
since the information relating to fixed deposits in
fictitious names was not found during the course of
search, it could not be used to arrive at the
undisclosed income for the block period. As
pointed out above, in the present case, the gifts
were found not to be genuine on the basis of the
evidence found in the form of confirmatory letters
during the course of the search.
25 In CIT v. Ravikant Jain, 250 ITR page 141
the Delhi High Court held that undisclosed income
for the block period can only be determined on the
SNC 33/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
basis of evidence found as a result of search. The
court held that in case any evidence is found de
hors the search, the same could be brought to tax
in regular assessment and not as a part of the
block assessment. In the aforesaid case, the
Tribunal had come to a finding that the undisclosed
income was not on the basis of any material found
during the course of the search, but on the basis
of a change of opinion i.e. the auditors report on
the existing facts which had already been disclosed
in the regular course of assessment. Besides, it
must be borne-in-mind that the aforesaid decision
was rendered prior to 2002 when the words
"relatable to such evidence" was introduced in
Section 158BB(1) of the Act with retrospective
effect from 1995.
26 The Gauhati High Court in CIT v. Bimal
Auto Agency, 314 ITR page 151 refused to interfere
with a finding of the Tribunal that no material was
found during the course of the search for purpose
of block assessment. The court also held that the
SNC 34/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
valuation of the property by the Department
Valuation officer post the search was not material
found during the course of search. The Tribunal on
facts in the above case had come to the conclusion
that no material or evidence was found during the
course of the search and therefore any material
obtained thereafter cannot be related to the search
even post the 2002 amendment of Section 158BB of
the Act. In the above facts the court refused to
interfere. The facts of the present case are
completely different as in this case
material/evidence of the gifts not being genuine
were found during the course of search which led to
the issuing of notice for block assessment.
27 We therefore find that none of the
decisions which were relied upon by the appellant
during the course of the hearing would have any
application to the facts of the present case. It is
very clear that consequent to the amendment in 2002
to Section 158BB of the Act documents and/or
information available with the assessing officer
SNC 35/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
and relatable to evidence found during the search
is certainly evidence which can be used to compute
the undisclosed income for the block period.
28 Infact while introducing the amendment by
Finance Act, 2002 the CBDT issued a circular dated
27.08.2002 explaining the need for the amendment as
under :
"61.3 The existing provisions of
section 158BB specify the manner of
computation of undisclosed income of the
block period. According to sub-section
(1) of the said section, the first step is
to compute the aggregate of the total
income, including undisclosed income, of
the previous year falling within the block
period on the basis of evidence found as a
result of search or requisition and such
other materials or information as are
available with the Assessing Officer.
Such aggregate income is, thereafter, to
be adjusted for the income or loss which
has already been assessed or declared, to
arrive at the undisclosed income of the
block period.
61.3.1 Some appellate authorities have
held that income which can be included in
the block assessment is only such income
which is directly evidenced by material
found during the search and does not
include income which has been discovered
on the basis of post-search inquiries made
during the block assessment proceedings.
This is contrary to the intention that nay
undisclosed income discovered as a result
SNC 36/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
of search is to be included in the block
assessment as long as such income has been
detected as a result of evidence gathered
during the search.
61.3.2 The Finance Act, 2002, has amended
section 158BB to clarify that the block
assessment of undisclosed income is to be
based on the evidence found in the search
and material or information gathered in
post-search inquiries made on the basis of
evidence found in the search."
(emphasis supplied)
29 In this case the statement and the
retraction thereof to the FERA authorities is
certainly relatable to evidence found during the
search and could be considered to compute the
undisclosed income.
30 Lastly, it was submitted on merits that
the evidence found during the course of the search
viz. copies of confirmatory letters from the donors
of the gifts, copies of passport of the Non
Resident Indian's donors of the gifts and their NRE
account singly or together do not indicate reason
enough to record the conclusion that the gifts were
not genuine. Mr. Jhaveri submits that the entire
case against the appellant is as on the basis of
SNC 37/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
suspicion, conjectures and unwarranted inferences.
31 At this stage it may be relevant to
reproduce two confirmatory letters from the donors
to members of Gupta family as an illustration of
identical language from donors situated in
different countries, which are as follows:
Letter 1) "From: Darshan Singh Raina,
Starship Management Ltd,
801, Brickel Avenue,
ig Suit - 1002, Miami,
Florida 33131, U.S.A.
Date : 21.09.1995
To,
Mr. Sohanlal Gupta,
201-A, Lancelot,
S.V.Road, Borivali (W),
Mumbai - 400 092.
My Dear Sohanlalji,
By the grace of God, I trust this letter
will find you and your family in the best of health
and spirits. Likewise I am also keeping fine.
I am enclosing herewith a cheque no.
001437 dt. 21.9.95, for Rs.4,00,000/- (Rs. Four
Lakhs only), drawn on Bank of Baroda, N.R.E.
Branch, Veena Nagar, Mulund (W), Bombay - 400 080,
India, issued out of my N.R.E. Account No. 75016,
the same has been accepted by you as per our oral
talk.
I have made this gift to the amount of Rs.
4,00,000/- to you out of natural love and affection
and the high esteem and regards the I have for you.
Henceforward you are the sole owner of the proceeds
SNC 38/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
of this gift and can enjoy the same as you may deem
fit and proper. I have made this gift without any
past, present or future consideration of any kind
whatsoever and declare that I have not got any type
of right, title, control or interest on the amount
gifted to you as mentioned hereinabove.
Please convey my regards to BHABHIJI, ARUN
& Renu, Love to Baby Aakansha.
By the Grace of God, I trust this letter
will find you and your family in the best of health
and spirits. Likewise I am also keeping fine.
I have given cheque no.031029 dtd.13-12-
95, for Rs.1,00,000/- and cheque no. 031031 dtd.
02.02.96 for Rs.75,000/- Both cheques drawn on Hong
Kong & Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited,
Payable at Madras, issued out of my N.R.E. Account
No.141 120023-006. The same has been accepted by
you as per our oral talk.
I have made this gift of the amount of Rs.
1,75,000/- to your out of natural love and
affection and the high esteem and regards that I
have for you. Henceforward you are the sole owner
SNC 39/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
of the proceeds of this gift and can enjoy the same
as you may deem fit and proper. I have made this
gift without any past, present or future
consideration of any kind whatsoever and declare
that I have not got any type of right, title,
control or interest on the amount gifted to you as
mentioned hereinabove.
Please convey my regards to Bhabhiji. How
is Arun, Renu & Aakansha.
With best wishes,
Yours lovingly,
(A.T. DIANOLD)
32 Mr. Jhaveri submits that these letters
were prepared by the appellant and her family for
production before the Income Tax Authorities when
called upon to substantiate the genuineness of
gifts. Therefore, they were all typed on the same
typewriter and are identically worded.
33 However, as pointed out by the Tribunal,
this was a position taken by the appellant for the
first time only in rejoinder before it to meet the
objections of the department. One more fact which
must be borne-in-mind is that most of the donors
are seamen and none of them was produced before the
Assessing Authority at the time of assessment to
establish the genuineness of the gifts. In matters
SNC 40/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
such as these all facts are within the knowledge of
the appellant and therefore the department is not
expected to prove its case with mathematical
precision but a degree of probability of a prudent
man taking into account the probable behavior of a
reasonable man along with surrounding
circumstances. In fact Parliament realizing the
difficulty for the Revenue to prove its case to the
hilt provided under Section 158BB(3) of the Act
that the burden of proving to the satisfaction of
the Assessing Officer that any income had already
been disclosed is on the assessee. Further, sub
section (2) of section 158BB in terms provided that
section 68 of the Act relating to cash credits
would apply to block assessment and in such cases
also it is for the assessee to satisfactorily
explain to the Assessing Officer, the source of the
credit found in the books of an assessee. In
matter such as these where all the facts are within
the knowledge of the assessee alone it is
impossible for the revenue to prove the breach of
law on the part of the assessee beyond reasonable
SNC 41/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
doubts. The Apex Court in the matter of Sumati Dayal v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Bangalore., reported in 214 IR page 801 had
observed with regard to an assessee claiming to
have received a large sum of money by winning in
horse racing as under :
" There is no dispute that
the amounts were received by the
appellant from various race clubs on
the basis of winning tickets presented
by her. What is disputed is that were
they really the winnings of the
appellant from the races. This raises
the question whether the apparent can
be considered as the real. As laid
down by this court the apparent must
be considered the real until it is
shown that there are reasons to
believe that the apparent is not the
real and that the taxing authorities
are entitled to look into the
surrounding circumstances to find that
the reality and the matter has to be
considered by applying the test of
human probabilities."
The court further observed in conclusion
as under :
"In our opinion, the majority
opinion after considering the
surrounding circumstances and applying
the test of human probabilities has
rightly concluded that the appellant's
claim about the amount being her
winnings from races is not genuine."
which appeared to be real are infact not real,
particularly, if one takes into account the
surrounding circumstances and applies the test of
human probabilities. It is most unlikely in the
normal course of human conduct for a family to
receive gifts in excess of over Rs.35 lacs from
persons who are not related in any manner to the
assessee or her family. Similarly, while
considering the order of the Tribunal, one is not
required to examine the same through a microscope
so as to discover a minor lapse here or there so as
to use it as a peg on which one can raise a
question of law. The Apex Court in the matter of
Homi Jehangir Gheesta v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Bombay, reported in 60 ITR
page 135 observed that where the circumstances are
such that the only proper inference one can draw is
that receipt has to be treated as a income in the
hands of the assessee such inferences are one of
fact and not of law. In the present case, if all
the circumstances are taken together it certainly
establishes that the alleged gifts received by the
SNC 43/44 ITXA 38-99.doc
appellant-assessee were nothing but a modes
operandi to convert her cash income into regular
income. In such circumstances, no fault can be
found with the order of the Tribunal while
considering the material found during the course of
the search and particularly the identical letters
written by the donors.
35 In view of the above question (i) which
also covers questions (ii) to (iv) are answered in
the affirmative i.e. in favour of the revenue-
respondent and against the appellant-assessee. So
far as, question no. (vii) is concerned as pointed
out above the same does not arise from the order of
the Tribunal and is therefore dismissed as not
maintainable.
36 The appeal is dismissed. No order as to
costs.