AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sections 147, 148, 149 and 302 of Indian Penal Code.18. Sections 34 and 149 of the Indian Penal Code
  • sections 147, 148, 149 and 302 read with 34 of Indian Penal Code.
  • section 147,148 read with section 149 of Indian Penal Code
  • charges.10. Section 213 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • charged.9. Section 212 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • section 395 read with section 397 of Indian Penal Code.
  • section 302 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code.7.
  • section 302 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code
  • section 324 read with 34 of Indian Penal Code,
  • Section 211 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • section 34 or 149 of the Indian Penal Code
  • provisions or section of Indian Penal Code.
  • sections 458 and 323 of Indian Penal Code
  • SECTION 313 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • section 324 of the Indian Penal Code
  • section 395 of Indian Penal Code.22.
  • section 395 read with section 397
  • section 323 of Indian Penal Code
  • section 324 of Indian Penal Code
  • section 323, Indian Penal Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sections 147, 148, 149 and 302 of Indian Penal Code.18. Sections 34 and 149 of the Indian Penal Code
  • sections 147, 148, 149 and 302 read with 34 of Indian Penal Code.
  • section 147,148 read with section 149 of Indian Penal Code
  • charges.10. Section 213 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • charged.9. Section 212 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • section 395 read with section 397 of Indian Penal Code.
  • section 302 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code.7.
  • section 302 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code
  • section 324 read with 34 of Indian Penal Code,
  • Section 211 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • section 34 or 149 of the Indian Penal Code
  • provisions or section of Indian Penal Code.
  • sections 458 and 323 of Indian Penal Code
  • SECTION 313 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • section 324 of the Indian Penal Code
  • section 395 of Indian Penal Code.22.
  • section 395 read with section 397
  • section 323 of Indian Penal Code
  • section 324 of Indian Penal Code
  • section 323, Indian Penal Code
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants, Samadhan Baburao Khakre and Govinda Jagadeo Gaikwad (original accused Nos. 1 and 12), challenged their conviction and sentence imposed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Buldana by Judgment and Order dated 28 January 1992. They were convicted for an offence punishable under section 324 read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code for causing injuries to Dharma Sitaram Dode (P.W.12) and Tukaram Totaram, and each was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year and to pay a fine of Rs. 200/-, in default 7 days' further imprisonment.

The complainant, Ukharda s/o Chandrabhan Dode, filed Revision Application No. 61/92 being aggrieved by the trial Court's judgment and order of acquittal of certain accused and seeking enhancement of sentence. The Criminal Appeal (by the accused) and the Revision Application (by the complainant) arose out of the same common judgment and were decided together by the Court issuing the opinion summarized herein.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial Court could lawfully convict the appellants under section 324 IPC read with section 34 when no substantive charge under section 324 (or a charge incorporating section 324 with section 34 or 149) was framed against them.
  2. Whether the manner in which charges were framed (and the particulars given) complied with the requirements of sections 211–213 of the Code of Criminal Procedure so as to avoid prejudicing the accused.
  3. Whether the trial Court complied with the obligation under section 313 Cr.P.C. to put to the accused the incriminating materials and points relied upon for conviction.
  4. Whether there was evidence on record specifically implicating the appellants in causing injuries to Dharma Sitaram Dode (P.W.12) and Tukaram Totaram sufficient to sustain the conviction.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (as recorded)

  • The principal contention raised by the appellants (through their counsel Shri Mardikar) was that the conviction and sentence were illegal because the trial Court never framed a substantive charge under section 324 IPC (nor a charge incorporating section 324 with section 34 or 149) against them; hence they were not apprised of the case they had to meet.
  • It was asserted that because no specific charge under section 324 was framed, there was no need to go into the merits of evidence — the conviction was vitiated by this charge defect which went to the root of the case.
  • The appellants also relied on the insufficiency of the s.313 Cr.P.C. questioning — incriminating circumstances relied upon for conviction were not specifically put to them, depriving them of the opportunity to explain those matters.

Complainant / State (as recorded)

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments advanced on behalf of the complainant or the State. The record states that Smt. Sirpurkar, counsel for the applicant, was heard but nothing was shown to impugn the trial Court's acquittals or to establish a case for retrial.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Yusuf Sardar Niyamatulla Momin v. State of Maharashtra, 1979 BCR 125 Conviction under one provision (section 323 IPC) is illegal where charges were framed under a different provision (section 395 read with 397 IPC) so that the accused are not properly apprised of the offence for which they are convicted; a charge based on different ingredients prejudices the accused. The Court relied on this precedent to support the principle that a conviction without a specific charge (or on an offence different in character from the charged offence) is unsustainable; by parity of reasoning the present conviction under section 324 where no such charge was framed is unlawful.
Makkhan v. Emperor, AIR (32) 1945 All. 81 Conviction under sections different from the charge (convictions under sections 458 and 323 IPC while charged under section 395 IPC) is illegal because the accused were not charged with the offences for which they were convicted. The Court cited this decision analogously to demonstrate that convictions based on offences different from those framed in the charge-sheet cannot be sustained; applied to hold the present conviction unsupported by the framing of charge under section 324 IPC.
Nanak Chand v. State of Punjab, (1955) 1 SCR 1201 : AIR 1955 SC 274 A substantive charge for an offence must be framed by quoting the relevant provisions/sections of the Indian Penal Code so that the accused knows the offence charged against him. The Court invoked this authority to emphasize that no substantive or independent charge alleging causing injuries (i.e., under section 324 IPC) was framed here; hence the conviction was procedurally defective and illegal.
Bhupesh Deb Gupta (Dead) By Lrs. v. State of Tripura, (1979) 1 SCC 87 : AIR 1978 SC 1672 Where the basis of the charge differs substantially from what is sought to be proved (e.g., gratification paid to influence a public servant vs. the charge framed), the accused is prejudiced by the defect in the charge and has no opportunity to meet the real case against him. The Court relied on this principle to find that the appellants were prejudiced by the failure to frame the proper charge and thus had no opportunity to meet the case ultimately relied upon for conviction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded from the foundational requirement that charges must state the offence and particulars with sufficient clarity so as to enable the accused to prepare his defence (citing the statutory scheme in Chapter XVII of the Code of Criminal Procedure and sections 211–213 Cr.P.C.). The opinion explains the purpose of framing charges: to inform the accused of the case he has to meet and to set out the necessary ingredients of the offence.

The trial Court had framed charges against 14 accused under sections 147, 148, 149 and 302 read with section 34 IPC. The framed charge (set out in the record) accused all 14 of committing murder (section 302). However, the appellants were ultimately convicted only for an offence under section 324 read with section 34 IPC for causing injuries to two persons. The Court found that no substantive charge under section 324 (either independently or read with section 34 or 149) was ever framed against the appellants.

Applying the principles in the cited precedents, the Court held that conviction for an offence which was not the subject-matter of a specific charge (or a charge that apprised the accused of that offence) is unsustainable because it deprives the accused of the opportunity to defend himself on the true case. The Court emphasized that while conviction on a lesser or cognate offence is permissible in some circumstances, the "major/minor" distinction requires the offences to be cognate and to share the essential ingredients; where the offence proved is entirely different in nature from the offence charged, conviction cannot stand.

The Court then turned to the facts: the trial Court in its own findings had acquitted on the charges of 147, 148, 149 and 302 IPC, yet recorded a finding that offence under section 324 was committed by the two appellants. The instant opinion found that:

  • No substantive charge under section 324 IPC was framed against the appellants;
  • The prosecution evidence did not contain any direct evidence that the appellants caused injuries to Dharma Sitaram Dode (P.W.12) or Tukaram Totaram — P.W.12 did not state that the appellants caused his injuries, and Tukaram Totaram was not examined;
  • The trial Court failed to put specific incriminating circumstances to the appellants under section 313 Cr.P.C.; the questions put were stereotyped and did not ask the accused to explain the specific acts relied upon for conviction (for example, no question asked that the appellants had caused injuries to Dharma Sitaram and Tukaram by means of an axe);
  • Consequently, prejudice was occasioned to the appellants because they had no adequate notice of the precise nature of the offence they were ultimately convicted of and were not given an opportunity to explain those particular incriminating facts.

In view of the statutory requirements for framing of charges, the authorities cited and the factual record showing both the absence of a specific charge and an absence of evidence directly implicating the appellants, the Court concluded that the conviction and sentence were ipso facto illegal and unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Criminal Appeal No. 70/92 by the accused is allowed; the conviction and sentence dated 28-01-1992 in Sessions Case No. 33/86 are quashed and set aside.

Direct consequences on the parties:

  • The conviction and sentence of the appellants for section 324 read with section 34 IPC are set aside.
  • Any fine paid by the appellants shall be refunded to them.
  • Their bail bonds shall stand cancelled (as recorded in the order).
  • The complainant's Revision Application No. 61/92 (seeking to challenge acquittals or enhance sentence) is dismissed as the State had not shown any error in the trial Court's acquittals and had not preferred an appeal.

Implications for broader law: The opinion applies existing authorities and statutory provisions concerning the framing of charges and the duty to put incriminating materials to an accused. The Court did not purport to lay down new legal principles; it applied established law to the facts and found the conviction vitiated by procedural defects and by absence of evidence specifically implicating the appellants.

Appeal by accused allowed.
Revision of complainant against acquittal dismissed.

    Samadhan Baburao Khakare And Another v. State Of Maharashtra .

    1. The appellants Samadhan Baburao Khakre and Govinda Jagadeo Gaikwad (original accused No. 1 and 12 respectively) challenged their conviction and sentence passed by the Addl. Sessions Judge, Buldana vide Judgment and Order dated 28th January, 1992, for the offence punishable under section 324 read with 34 of Indian Penal Code, for causing injuries to Dharma Sitaram Dode (P.W 12) and Tukaram Totaram, sentencing both the appellants to suffer R.I for one year and to pay a fine of Rs. 200/- each i/d to suffer further R.I for 7 days.

    2. Ukharda s/o Chandrabhan Dode — the complainant being aggrieved by the judgment and order of acquittal of the appellants/accused as also other accused in other offences and for enhancement of sentence of the appellants/accused, preferred the Revision Application No. 61/92.

    3. The instant Criminal Appeal and the Revision Application being arising out of the common judgment, both are decided by the common judgment.

    4. Shri Mardikar, the learned counsel for the appellants/accused raised the legal objection to the conviction and sentence which goes to the root of the case and thus maintained there is no need to go to the merits of the case.

    5. The question raised is that the Addl. Sessions Judge, Buldana, vide Exh. 43 framed charges against the 14 accused persons under sections 147, 148, 149 and 302 read with 34 of Indian Penal Code. As per the charge, all the 14 accused persons along with deceased Baburao Dattu Khakare and deceased accused Amruta Dipa Khakare, on 30th October, 1985 at about 8.30 a.m at village Talkhed, in furtherance of their common intention formed unlawful assembly in prosecution of their common object to beat the complainant Rawaji Bimbaji Dode and the witnesses Ukharda Chandrabhan, Suresh Rawaji, Namdeo Ninaji, Dharma Sitaram, Prabhakar Ukharda and others.

    6. Charge framed under section 302 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code reads as under:

    “Fourthly, on the same date, time and place you accused Nos. 1 to 14 along with the deceased Baburao Dattu Khakare and deceased Amruta Dipa Khakare, in furtherance of common intention, did commit murder by intentionally or knowingly causing the death of Prabhakar Ukharda Dode, and thereby committed an offence punishable under section 302 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code”.

    7. It is not disputed that the appellants/accused are convicted for the offence punishable under section 324 read with 34 of Indian Penal Code. However, the learned Addl. Sessions Judge, neither framed the substantive charge under section 324 of Indian Penal Code against the appellants nor any substantive offence, if any read with section 34 or 149 of the Indian Penal Code is framed. Therefore, Shri Mardikar, the learned counsel for the appellants/accused very vehemently contended that no substantive charge having been framed under section 324 of the Indian Penal Code, the conviction and sentence awarded by the learned trial Court is illegal.

    8. Chapter XVII of the Code of Criminal Procedure deals with the framing of charge/charges. Section 211 of the Code of Criminal Procedure contemplates that:

    “Every charge under this Code shall state the offence with which the accused is charged”.

    9. Section 212 of the Code of Criminal Procedure contemplates that:

    “Particulars as to time, place and person, of the alleged offence (if any) against whom, of the thing (if any) in respect of which, it was committed, the reasonable notice of the matter be given by incorporating all the charges”.

    10. Section 213 of the Code of Criminal Procedure contemplates that:

    “In the charge, the particulars of the manner in which the alleged offence was committed should be apprised to the accused”.

    11. The whole purpose and object of framing charges is to enable the defence to concentrate its attention on the case that he has to meet, and if the charge is framed in such a vague manner that the necessary ingredients of the offence with which the accused is convicted is not brought out in the charge then the charge is not only defective but illegal. It is no doubt that when the accused is charged with a major offence, he can be convicted of a minor offence. It is true that what is major offence and what is minor offence is not defined. The gravity of offence must depend upon the severity of the punishment that can be inflicted, but the major and the minor offences must be cognate offences which have the main ingredients in common, and a man charged with one offence which is entirely of a different nature from the offence which is proved to have been committed by him, cannot in the absence of a proper charge be convicted of that offence, merely on the ground that the facts proved constitute a minor offence. For example, a man charged with an offence of murder cannot be convicted for forgery or misappropriation of funds, or such offences which do not constitute offences against person, the reason being that the accused had no opportunity in such a case to make defence, which may have been open to him, if he had been charged with the offence for which he is to be convicted.

    12. Admittedly, in the instant case, no charge is framed against the appellants/accused as an independent charge or with the aid of either section 34 or 149 of the Indian Penal Code alleging that they caused injuries to Dharma s/o Sitaram Dode (P.W 12) and Tukaram Totaram (not examined). It is, thus, apparent that no opportunity was accorded to the appellants/accused to meet the charge and, therefore, prejudice is caused to the appellants/accused.

    13. In a case of Yusuf Sardar Niyamatulla Momin… v. The State Of Maharashtra…., 1979 BCR 125, brother Kotwal, J., held the conviction under section 323 of Indian Penal Code illegal as the charges were framed under section 395 read with section 397 of Indian Penal Code. In that case the charge was framed under section 395 read with section 397 and the ingredients of the said charge is robbery and dacoity. The learned Judge disbelieved prosecution evidence. Therefore, from out of five accused, four were acquitted holding that no such incident occurred and, therefore, the charge for vicarious liability cannot be sustained. In other words, alleged act attributed to the present appellant, cannot be of any assistance. Therefore, application of section 395 read with section 397 by necessary implication, the implication of vicarious liability is ruled out. The conviction under section 323, Indian Penal Code without specific charge is unsustainable in law.

    14. In the instant case, the para 9 of the judgment deals with the points for consideration. The point No. 4 reads as follows:

    “Whether the prosecution has proved that the accused Nos. 1 to 14, in furtherance of common intention, committed murder by intentionally or knowingly causing the death of Prabhakar Ukharda Dode?”

    15. Para 10 of the judgment deals with the findings. In respect of point No. 4, the findings are as under:

    “Offence under section 324 of the Indian Penal Code is committed by the accused No. 1 Samadhan Baburao Khakre and accused No. 12 Govind s/o Jagdeo Gaikwad only”.

    16. In para No. 18 of the Judgment, the learned trial Court held that:

    “All these facts shows that the accused were not at all the members of an unlawful assembly, but they had gathered at the spot later on. Under such circumstances, if at all any criminal act committed by any of the accused is in their individual capacity and not in prosecution of the common object of unlawful assembly. The accused party not being the aggressors no case either under section 147,148 read with section 149 of Indian Penal Code is maintainable against them. Hence, I answer points Nos. 1 to 3 in the negative”.

    17. The learned trial Court after considering the evidence concluded in para 43 of the judgment that:

    “The prosecution has failed to prove its case under sections 147, 148, 149 and 302 of Indian Penal Code.”

    18. Sections 34 and 149 of the Indian Penal Code are merely explanatory. Both do not create any specific offence. Under section 34, there needs to be more than one but below five persons actuated by common intention and when in furtherance of that common intention a criminal act is done by them, each of them is liable for that act as if the act had been done by him alone. Similarly, to attract the provisions of section 149, an offence may be committed by a member of an unlawful assembly and the other members will be liable for that offence although there was no common intention between that person and the other members of the unlawful assembly to commit that offence provided the conditions laid down in section are fulfilled. Thus, if the offence committed by that person is in prosecution of the common object of the unlawful assembly or such as the members of that assembly knew to be likely to be committed in prosecution of the common object, every member of the unlawful assembly would be guilty of that offence, although there may have been no common intention and no participation by the other members in the actual commission of that offence.

    19. A charge for a substantive offence needs to be framed quoting the provisions or section of Indian Penal Code. This aspect has been dealt with in a case of Nanak Chand v. The State of Punjab, (1955) 1 SCR 1201 : AIR 1955 SC 274.

    20. In the instant case, no substantive or independent charge was framed against either of the accused for causing any injuries by means of sharp pointed weapon to Dharma Sitaram Dode (P.W 12) and Tukaram Totaram (not examined).

    21. In a case of Makkhan v. Emperor reported in AIR (32) 1945 All. 81, the Court held that:

    “Conviction under sections 458 and 323 of Indian Penal Code is illegal, as the accused were charged for the offence under section 395 of Indian Penal Code.”

    22. In a case of Bhupesh Deb Gupta (Dead) By Lrs. v. State Of Tripura., (1979) 1 SCC 87 : AIR 1978 SC 1672, in para 12, Their Lordships observed that:

    “As the basis of the charge is entirely different from what is sought to be made out now i.e the gratification was paid to the accused for influencing a public servant, it cannot be said that the accused was not prejudiced by the frame of the charge. On a careful scrutiny of the facts of the case, the accused was prejudiced by the defect in the charge and that he had no opportunity to meet the case that is put forward against him”.

    23. Giving conscious thought to the facts and circumstances of this case as well in view of the mandatory provisions of apprising the accused of the case which he has to meet in the defence, not being followed in the instant case, the conviction and sentence passed by the learned trial Court is ipso facto illegal.

    24. Besides this legal provision, there is no iota of evidence against the appellants/accused that they caused injuries on the person of Dharma Sitaram Dode (P.W 12) and Tukaram Totaram. Dharma Sitaram Dode (P.W 12) did not state that the appellants/accused have caused injuries on his person. He simply stated that accused No. 2 Bhimrao had caught hold of him. There is no whisper against the appellant/accused No. 12 Govinda Gaikwad that he had played any role. Another injured Tukaram Totaram not being examined, there is no evidence. It is, thus, clear that there is no evidence at all against the appellants/accused that these two appellants had caused any injury on the person of Dharma Sitaram Dode (P.W 12) and Tukaram Totaram.

    25. The learned Trial Court has also committed glaring mistake in not putting incriminating circumstances found which he has considered for conviction while putting questions under section 313 of Criminal Procedure Code. The questions and answers are stereotype. The questions Nos. 16, 17 and 18 put up to appellant/accused No. 1 and the appellant No. 2.original accused No. 12 are similar. No question was put to either of the accused to the effect that they caused injuries on the persons of Dharma Dode (P.W 12) and Tukaram Totaram by means of axe. A question is to the effect that the accused Samadhan i.e the appellant No. 1 had given blows on the head of Urkuda Chandrabhan with an axe and others beat Dharma Sitaram, Tukaram Namdeo and Suresh Savaji. Another question is to the effect that accused Samadhan and Bhimrao had caught hold of Dharma Sitaram and accused No. 11 Kawadu had dealt an axe blow on his head. The question No. 18 is to the effect that accused No. 15 Balu Amruta had given blow with the stick on the back of Dharma Sitaram.

    26. The object and purpose of illustrating the explanation under section 313 of Criminal Procedure Code is that the materials or points brought out in the prosecution evidence against accused be put to the accused, so that to accord him an opportunity to give his explanation. It is clear from the above discussion, the accused had no notice of the offence of which he was going to be convicted and was not asked to explain the points on which their conviction is based. On this aspect too, the conviction and sentence passed by the learned trial Court is liable to be set aside.

    27. In the result, the Criminal Appeal No. 70/92 is allowed. The conviction and sentence passed by the learned trial Court on 28-1-1992 in Sessions Case No. 33/86 is quashed and set aside. The fine paid, if any, by the appellants/accused, be refunded to them. Bail bonds shall stand cancelled.

    28. Smt. Sirpurkar, the learned counsel for the applicant was heard. During her submissions, nothing has been brought to my notice that can be construed as the learned trial Court has committed any error in acquittal of other accused and thereby prejudice is caused to the complainant and thereby the case is made out for re-trial. The State has not preferred appeal against the acquittal as also for enhancement of the sentence. There being no substance in the Criminal Revision Application No. 61/92, the same is dismissed.

    Appeal by accused allowed.
    Revision of complainant against acquittal dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Samadhan Baburao Khakare And Another v. State Of Maharashtra .
    (Mar 3, 1995)