AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion challenges an award of the Fourth Labour Court under the Industrial Disputes Act. The petitioner-workman had been employed as a miller by the first respondent company for about six to seven years. He worked until 2 April 1980. On 3 April 1980, when he reported for duty, he was told not to resume and that he would be informed later when to return. The workman attempted to obtain work on two or three subsequent occasions but received no response from the employer. On 8 May 1980 he approached the Government Labour Officer. Conciliation failed and the dispute was referred to the Labour Court. The Labour Court held that the workman had abandoned his service rather than being terminated, and it rejected the reference by an award. The present petition challenges that award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Labour Court was correct in holding that the petitioner-workman had abandoned his service rather than having been terminated.
  2. Whether the employer discharged the burden of proof required to establish abandonment of service, including compliance with procedural requirements (notice to resume work and inquiry) before terminating or treating the employment as abandoned.
  3. Whether the Labour Court properly relied on the Government Labour Officer's report and the evidence of two employee-witnesses without verifying the report or confronting the workman with its contents.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner-workman's Arguments (as advanced by Sri Kochar)

  • The Labour Court relied primarily on a report attributed to the Government Labour Officer (dated 27 May 1980) which purportedly recorded company statements that there had been a quarrel and that the company was willing to take the workman back without back-wages; the report also recorded that the workman was not willing to rejoin and would take legal dues because he feared being "troubled." This report was signed by the workman.
  • These papers were called for by the company; the Government Labour Officer was not examined and the workman was not asked to explain the circumstances in which the report recorded that he was not prepared to resume duty. The report was not shown to the workman, and he was not confronted with it.
  • The Labour Court also relied on testimony of two company workmen (Ramesh and Sunil) which, the petitioner contends, is unreliable because they had no direct knowledge of the stoppage and of the partner Anand's alleged role in preventing the petitioner from resuming work. Anand, who the petitioner alleges prevented him from returning, was not examined by the company.
  • The offer to reinstate recorded in the Government Labour Officer's report was conditional (without back-wages); the petitioner was drawing about Rs. 33 per day and was legitimately entitled to back-wages, so refusal of such a conditional offer was justified.
  • The company failed to attend conciliation proceedings; the conciliator’s failure report recorded their absence. Given the petitioner's repeated attempts to obtain work and his approach to the Government Labour Officer, it is difficult to accept that he abandoned service voluntarily.

Respondent 1 Company’s Position (as represented in the record)

  • The company maintained that there was no termination of service; their case was that the petitioner had abandoned his service by refusing to come and resume work.
  • It is admitted on record that the company did not give any notice to the workman calling upon him to resume duty, nor did it ask him to show cause why his services should not be terminated; no inquiry was held prior to the alleged termination.
  • To prove abandonment the company relied on the Government Labour Officer’s report and the evidence of the two company workmen (Ramesh and Sunil) who stated they witnessed events on 2–3 April 1980 and that the petitioner told Anand he would not work.
  • In the opinion record, counsel for the company submitted to the orders of the Court (i.e., did not resist the challenge in this proceeding in the manner recorded by the Court).

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by examining both the evidential basis relied upon by the Labour Court and the applicable procedural requirement that an employer must satisfy before treating employment as abandoned or terminating service.

  1. Burden of proof: The court emphasised that where an employer pleads abandonment of service it is for the employer to prove such abandonment. This is a central legal principle applied by the court to evaluate the Labour Court's finding.
  2. Deficiencies in proof: The Labour Court had relied largely on (a) a report attributed to the Government Labour Officer and (b) testimony of two company workmen. The High Court found both sources insufficient:
    • The Government Labour Officer's report (dated 27 May 1980) was not proved in evidence because the Government Labour Officer was not examined. The report was ambiguous about what transpired and recorded only the company's statements; it did not contain a recorded statement of the workman. The report was not shown to the workman, and no explanation was elicited from him regarding the contents.
    • The offer recorded in that report was conditional (the company was allegedly willing to take the workman back but without back-wages). The Court noted that the offer without back-wages was inadequate because back-wages were legitimately due to the petitioner, who earned about Rs. 33 per day.
    • The two company witnesses (Ramesh and Sunil) testified to events involving the petitioner's brother and to assertions that the petitioner refused to work; however, these witnesses had limited or indirect connection to the stoppage, and the partner alleged by the petitioner to have prevented his return (Anand) was not examined by the company. The same evidence in a related case involving the brother had led the Labour Court to conclude termination, not abandonment.
  3. Procedural requirements: The court observed that the company had not given any notice to the workman to resume work or asked him to show cause, nor had it held any inquiry before terminating his service. The court stressed that even where abandonment is alleged, the employer should give notice and hold an inquiry before treating the employment as terminated.
  4. Misplaced reasoning by the Labour Court: The Labour Court had reasoned that the absence of any notice from the workman after the alleged removal meant the workman had refused to join service and had no intention to work. The High Court rejected this approach as legally unsound and held that the Labour Court's finding was prima facie bad in law.
  5. Conclusion of analysis: Given the failure of the employer to properly prove abandonment and to comply with procedural safeguards, and the unreliability/unverified nature of the evidence relied upon, the High Court concluded that the Labour Court's finding in favour of abandonment was unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is allowed; the impugned order of the Labour Court is set aside and the petitioner-workman is to be reinstated with full back-wages and continuity of service.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The first respondent-company is directed to reinstate the petitioner-workman in service with full back-wages from 3 April 1980 until reinstatement, with continuity of service and all attendant benefits accruing from that continuity.
  • The rule was made absolute and the petitioner was awarded costs.
  • The opinion does not purport to set out or explain any new legal precedent beyond applying the established principle that an employer must prove abandonment and should observe procedural safeguards (notice and inquiry) before terminating service; the decision's practical effect is to reverse the Labour Court's award and order reinstatement and back-wages for the petitioner in this specific dispute.

    Gaurishankar Vishwakarma v. Eagle Spring Industries (Private), Ltd., And Others

    Sawant, J.:— The decision under challenge is of the Fourth Labour Court under the Industrial Disputes Act. Briefly stated the facts are that the petitioner-workman was working as a miller in the first respondent company's factory for about 6 to 7 years prior to the refusal of work to him on and from 3 April, 1980. It appears that the workman worked up to 2 April, 1980, and when he went to report for duty as usual on 3 April, 1980, he was asked not to resume the duties and was told that he would be intimated later as to when be should resume the duty. The workman approached for work on two or three occasions thereafter, but having failed to get any response from the employer, ultimately, on 8 May, 1980, approached the Government Labour Officer. The matter having not been settled at that stage, it was taken in conciliation. The conciliator made his failure report and hence there was a reference of the dispute to the Labour Court. The Labour Court, by its impugned order, held that it was the workman who had abandoned the service and that it was not a case of termination of service as alleged by him. With this finding the Labour Court rejected the reference by its impugned award. Hence the present petition.

    2. Sri Kochar, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner-workman, pointed out that the Labour Court had relied solely on the so-called report of the Government Labour Officer (not the Conciliation Officer) in which it is stated by him that on 27 May, 1980, the company had stated before him that as there was a quarrel of the petitioner-workman with his co-workman, the workman did not come for work. The company was ready to take him back on work without back-wages. The Government Labour Officer has also stated that the workman was not ready to join the work and he was ready to accept his legal dues rather than join the work because he was apprehending that he would be “troubled.” This report is signed by the petitioner-workman. Sri Kochar attacked this finding, and according to us rightly, on the ground that these papers of the Government Labour Officer were called for by the company. The Government Labour Officer himself was not examined nor was the workman asked to explain as to in what circumstances the Government Labour Officer had mentioned in his report that he was not prepared to resume his duty although the company was ready to take him back without back-wages. In fact, Sri Kochar complained that this report was not even shown to the workman at any time. He also pointed out that the Labour Court had relied also on the evidence of two workmen examined by the company to show that it was the petitioner-workman who bad abandoned his service which evidence is totally unreliable. It is the allegation of the workman that it was one Sri Anand, a partner of respondent 1 company, who had prevented the petitioner-workman from resuming the duty. Anand is not examined by the company. Instead, the workmen who had no connection with the stoppage of the work were examined to depose to the facts which were not to their knowledge.

    3. The learned counsel appearing for respondent 1 company submitted to the orders of the Court. Admittedly, the first respondent company has not given any notice to the workman either calling upon him to resume the duty or asking him to show cause as to why his services should not be terminated for his failure to resume his duties. No wonder, therefore, that there was no inquiry held before the termination of his service. In fact, according to respondent 1 company, there was no termination of service. Their case is that the petitioner-workman had abandoned the service by refusing to come and to resume the work. It is difficult to accept this case. It is now well settled that even in the case of the abandonment of service, the employer has to give a notice to the workman calling upon him to resume his duty and also to hold an enquiry, before terminating his service on that ground. In the present case the employer has done neither. It was for the employer to prove that the workman had abandoned the service. To prove it, the employer relied solely on two pieces of evidence—one is the so-called report of the Government Labour Officer to which we have made a reference. The report is not proved by examining the Government Labour Officer. It was not even shown to the workman, much less, was he confronted with it. Thus, no explanation was called for from the workman with regard to the statements made by the Government Labour Officer in his so-called report. Secondly, the report itself is ambiguous with regard to what exactly transpired before the Government Labour Officer and in what circumstances the events stated there took place, if at all they had occurred as stated therein. It appears from the judgment of the Labour Court that the report is of 27 May, 1980 and it states that it was the company which had stated before him (i.e, the Government Labour Officer) that since there was a quarrel of the petitioner-workman with his co-workman, the workman did not want to join the duty. It is also stated there that the company was ready to take the workman back but without back-wages. No statement of the workman is recorded by the Government Labour Officer. It is on the basis of this so-called statement of the company, that the Government Labour Officer had noted that it was the petitioner who was not ready to come and join his duties. It may also be pointed out here that even according to the report the offer of the company was to take the workman back but without back-wages. It must be noted that the petitioner-workman at the relevant time was drawing daily wages of about Rs. 33. It is admitted by the respondent-company that nothing had happened before 3 April, 1980 to create any apprehension in the mind of the workman that he would be “troubled” or that he would be in danger if he joined duty from 3 April, 1980. It is, therefore, difficult to believe that the workman who had worked continuously for six to seven years, would abandon his service for no rhyme or reason. It has also to be remembered that it was the workman who had approached the Government Labour Officer with a specific grievance that he was not allowed to join his duty. It was also his grievance that although he had approached the company for work from time to time, and the company's partner Anand had kept on promising him that he would be taken in service he was not given work and hence he was forced to approach the Government Labour Officer. In the circumstances, it is difficult to believe that he would refuse the offer of work when it was given to him before the Labour Officer. What is further, the matter had gone in conciliation and the first respondent-company had not even cared to attend the conciliation proceedings. The failure report of the conciliation mentions the said absence. Even if we accept the Government Labour Officer's report, the workman was justified in refusing th??? offer of work since the offer was made without back-wages, which were legitimately his dues. It is unfortunate that the Labour Court which was expected to follow judicial procedure, chose to depend upon unverified statements made in the report and came to the conclusion that it was the workman who had refused to resume the work. The Court also failed to grasp that the offer was conditional.

    4. As regards the evidence of the two workmen who are even now supervisors in the company, viz., Ramesh and Sunil, all that they have stated is that they were present at the time of the so-called incident of 2 April, 1980, in which the petitioner-workman's brother one Amoldhar Sharma was involved. The witness Ramesh had asked Amoldhar to repair a machine and according to him, although he had supplied oil to Amoldhar, Amoldhar had failed to repair it. It is also the case of these two witnesses that the petitioner-workman had asked his brother Amoldhar not to work at 5 P.M and that both of them had gone away. It is further their case that on 3 April, 1980, both of them, i.e, petitioner and his brother Amoldhar had attended the factory but did not change their clothes and the petitioner-workman told Anand that he would not work. It was not only the petitioner-workman who had stopped attending work, it was also his brother Amoldhar who had similarly stopped attending the factory. These very witnesses were examined in the case involving Amoldhar. In that case, the very same Judge of the; Labour Court has come to the conclusion that it was not a case of abandonment of service but of the termination of service considering similar evidence of the two witnesses. Oh the same evidence, the Labour Court, has, however, found no difficulty in the present case to come to the conclusion that the petitioner-workman had abandoned the service Although, further, the case of the petitioner-workman was that it was Anand who bad stopped him from coming to work and who had kept on promising him that he would be taken in service, Anand has not been examined by the company. Reliance is, however, placed on the evidence of these two witnesses to make out the case of the abandonment of service.

    5. What strikes us more is the reasoning of the Labour Court. Since it is the case of respondent 1 company that the workman had abandoned the service, it was for the company to prove that there was such abandonment. However, the Labour Court has argued that since the workman had not given any notice to the company after his alleged removal, it should be held that it was he who had refused to join the service, and that he bad no intention to work in the factory. We have, therefore, no hesitation in holding that the finding recorded by the Labour Court is prima facie bad in law, and the order of the Labour Court should be set aside.

    6. Accordingly, we allow the petition, set aside the impugned order of the Labour Court and direct the first respondent-company to reinstate the petitioner-workman in service with full back-wages from 3 April, 1980 till he is reinstated in service with continuity of service and all benefits accruing to him on that account. Rule is made absolute accordingly with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gaurishankar Vishwakarma v. Eagle Spring Industries (Private), Ltd., And Others
    (Sep 3, 1987)