Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • (b), (c) and (f) of s. 65 and cl. (b) of s. 66 of the Bombay Prohibition Act.
  • CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE AMENDMENT ACT
  • Sub-section (1) of s. 262, Criminal Procedure Code,
  • Section 116 of the Bombay Prohibition Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • (b), (c) and (f) of s. 65 and cl. (b) of s. 66 of the Bombay Prohibition Act.
  • CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE AMENDMENT ACT
  • Sub-section (1) of s. 262, Criminal Procedure Code,
  • Section 116 of the Bombay Prohibition Act

    Bandulal Balaprashad v. The State Of Maharashtra

    Chainani, C.J:— This is an application in revision by the accused, who has been convicted under cls. (b), (c) and (f) of s. 65 and cl. (b) of s. 66 of the Bombay Prohibition Act. The offences under s. 65 of the Act are punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years. The case was, therefore, a warrant case and not a summons case. Section 116 of the Bombay Prohibition Act provides that in all trials for offences under this Act, the Magistrate shall follow the procedure prescribed in the Code of Criminal Procedure for the trial of summary cases in which an appeal lies. Sub-section (1) of s. 262, Criminal Procedure Code, provides that in summary trials the procedure prescribed for summons eases shall be followed in summons cases and the procedure prescribed for warrant cases shall be followed in warrant cases, except as mentioned in the following sections in Chapter XXII. The trial Magistrate should, therefore, have followed the procedure prescribed for warrant cases. He, however, tried the ease as a summons case. It has, therefore, been urged on behalf of the accused that the trial was vitiated by the Magistrate's following a wrong procedure and that, consequently, the conviction of the accused is illegal. On the other hand, it has been urged on behalf of the State that the irregularity is one, which is curable under s. 537, Criminal Procedure Code, unless it is shown that prejudice has been caused to the accused.

    2. We have been referred to several discisions on this point, but we do not think it is necessary to refer to most of them. The law on the subject has been summed up by the Privy Council in Pulukuri Kotayya v. King-Emperor . 1946 L.R 74 I.A 65, at p. 75, S.C 49 Bom. L.R 508., in these words:

    “…When a trial is conducted in a manner different from that prescribed by the Code (as in N.A Subramania Iyer v. King-Emperor . 1901 L.R 28 I.A 257, S.C 3 Bom. L.R 540.), the trial is bad, and no question of curing an irregularity arises; but if the trial is conducted substantially in the manner prescribed by the Code, but some irregularity occurs in the course of such conduct, the irregularity can be cured under s. 537, and none the less so because the irregularity involves, as must nearly always be the case, a breach of one or more of the very comprehensive provisions of the Code.”

    3. These observations have been quoted with approval by the Supreme Court it Narayan Rao v. The State of Andhra Pradesh . [1958] S.C.R 283., and Chhadami Lal Jain v. The State of Uttar Pradesh . [1960] 1 S.C.R 736, at p. 747., and in Payare Lal v. State Of Punjab . 1960 Supreme Court Criminal Appeal. No. 240 of 1960, decided on August 30, 1961 [Unrep.. The Criminal Procedure Code classifies the offences triable by a Magistrate into two broad categories, summons cases and warrant cases. Chapter XX contains provisions laying down the procedure to be observed in the trial of summons cases. Chapter XXI lays down the procedure prescribed for the trial of warrant cases. The Code, therefore, prescribes two different procedures for the trial of the two classes of cases.

    4. The differences between the two procedures have been considerably reduced after the amendment of the Code by the Code of Criminal Procedure (Amendment) Act (XXVI of 1955). But there are still substantial differences between the two procedures. Consequently, when a warrant case is tried according to the procedure prescribed for summons eases, it would be difficult to hold that the trial is conducted in the manner prescribed by the Code. The case would fall within the first category mentioned in the above passage from the judgment of the Privy Council in Pulukuri Kotayya's case. The trial would, therefore, be bad. It is necessary to add that where the Magistrate follows substantially the provisions laid down in Chap. XXI in regard to the trial of warrant cases, but commits some irregularity in following those provisions, the irregularity would be curable under s. 537, unless prejudice is shown to have been caused to the accused.

    5. The failure of the trial Magistrate in this ease to follow the procedure prescribed for warrant eases, therefore, vitiates the trial. The conviction of, and the sentence passed upon, the accused are, therefore, set aside and the case will be sent back to the trial Court for retrial of the accused. Under sub-ss. (2) and (3) of s. 251A, Criminal Procedure Code, in the trial of a warrant case the Magistrate has first to examine the accused and after giving the prosecution and the accused an opportunity of being heard he has to frame a charge against the accused, unless he comes to the conclusion that the charge is groundless. The irregularity in this case, therefore, occurred when the Magistrate failed to frame a charge and proceeded to record the evidence without framing a charge. The retrial of the accused should commence from the stage at which the irregularity occurred. The examination of the accused already made should be deemed to have been made under sub-s. (2) of s. 251A. The Magistrate should proceed further from this stage and after hearing the prosecution and the accused decide on the basis of the evidence already recorded and the examination of the accused already made, for what offences a charge should be framed. He should then frame a charge and thereafter proceed to try the accused in accordance with the procedure prescribed in ss. 262 and 264. The accused to continue on bail for a fortnight in the meantime he should apply to the trial Court for bail.

    6. The trouble and expense involved in the retrial of the accused and the time of the Court, which is likely to be taken in trying the ease again, would have been saved, if greater care had been exercised at the commencement of the proceedings. It is also the duty of both the Police Prosecutor and the defence advocate to bring such defects to the notice of the Court at a very early stage of the trial.

    7. Re-trial ordered.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bandulal Balaprashad v. The State Of Maharashtra
    (Jan 31, 1962)