Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • s. 74 of the Contract Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • s. 74 of the Contract Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The defendant, a forest contractor and timber merchant at Yeotmal, had a branch at Murtizapur where Gopikisan (P.W.2) worked. The plaintiff alleged that on 29 August 1948 Gopikisan, as manager, contracted to supply 2,000 bags of saw dust at Re. 1 per bag within four months; the plaintiff paid Rs. 250 advance, received only 423 bags, and claimed Rs. 1,000 as liquidated damages plus Rs. 102 excess paid. The defendant admitted employing Gopikisan and keeping stock at Murtizapur but denied that Gopikisan had authority to make forward contracts or to be manager/agent with such authority. The trial Court dismissed the suit; the lower appellate Court awarded Rs. 102 refund and damages of Rs. 394-4-0 (total Rs. 496-4-0). The defendant appealed and the plaintiff filed a cross-objection seeking enhancement of damages.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Gopikisan had authority (express or implied) to enter into a contract for the future sale of saw dust on behalf of the defendant.
  2. Whether the plaintiff proved that he suffered damage as a result of the breach.
  3. Whether the clause fixing Rs. 1,000 as payable on breach is a valid pre-estimate of damages under s. 74 of the Contract Act or an in terrorem penalty, and consequently whether the plaintiff is entitled to that sum or to reasonable damages without proof of actual loss.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Defendant's) Arguments

  • Gopikisan was a servant but had no authority to act as manager, agent, or to enter into forward contracts for sale.
  • The damages claimed were not admissible as Gopikisan lacked authority and the defendant therefore was not liable for the alleged contract.

Respondent's (Plaintiff's) Arguments

  • Gopikisan was appointed manager of the Murtizapur branch and entered into the contract on 29 August 1948 for 2,000 bags at Re. 1 per bag.
  • The plaintiff paid Rs. 250 advance, received only 423 bags, and claimed Rs. 1,000 as liquidated damages plus Rs. 102 excess paid.
  • Relied in part on the defendant's evidence that P.W.2 was authorised to sell saw dust at specified rates to support alleged authority.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analysed the matter in two principal steps.

  1. Authority of Agent: The Court found that although Gopikisan did contract as alleged, the plaintiff failed to allege or prove that Gopikisan had authority to make contracts for future goods. The Court drew a clear distinction between authority to sell goods in stock and authority to enter contracts to sell future goods; the defendant's admission that P.W.2 was authorised to effect sales did not establish authority to make forward contracts. On this short ground the claim for damages could not succeed.
  2. Proof of Damage and s. 74: The Court held that the plaintiff led no evidence of actual damage and that such damage could not be inferred from the defendant's admission about authorised sale rates. The Court examined the clause fixing Rs. 1,000 as payable on breach in light of s. 74 of the Contract Act and concluded the sum was in terrorem (a penalty), not a bona fide pre-estimate of loss—because it could be grossly disproportionate to any conceivable loss (example: failure to deliver one bag would still attract Rs. 1,000). Since the clause was penal, the plaintiff could not recover that sum or reasonable damages without proof that some loss had actually been sustained. The plaintiff also failed to prove that saw dust was used as manure or that any loss resulted from non-delivery. Therefore no damages could be awarded on this basis.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed; the cross-objection is dismissed; the decree of the lower appellate Court is modified by reducing it from Rs. 496-4-0 to Rs. 102. Costs are allocated: the plaintiff is entitled to costs on Rs. 102 in all Courts; the defendant is entitled to costs on the remainder in all Courts; costs of the cross-objection are borne by the plaintiff-respondent. The final order: Appeal allowed.

Implications: The decision directly affects only the parties by reducing the decree and allocating costs. The opinion applies s. 74 of the Contract Act to distinguish between a genuine pre-estimate and a penalty clause; no broader precedent beyond the case facts is stated.

    Satyanarayan Amolakchand Bhat v. Vithal Narayan Jamdar

    Mudholkar, J.:— This is an appeal by the defendant from a decree for damages to the extent of Rs. 394-4-0 for an alleged breach of a contract for the sale of saw dust. The plaintiff has filed a cross-objection in which he has claimed enhancement of the damages by Rs. 394-4-0.

    2. The relevant facts are as follows: The defendant who is a forest contractor and a timber merchant at Yeotmal had opened a branch office at Murtizapur for the sale of timber and saw dust. According to the plaintiff, he had appointed Gopikisan (P.W 2) as the manager of the shop and that Gopikisan entered into a contract with the plaintiff on August 29, 1948, for the supply of 2,000 bags of saw dust within four months at the rate of Re. 1 per bag. The plaintiff alleges that he paid Rs. 250 as an advance to Gopikisan, that Gopikisan delivered to him only 423 bags of saw dust and that neither he nor the defendant delivered to him the balance. It may be mentioned that in the contract it is stated that if a breach were committed, the defendant would be liable to pay Rs. 1,000 by way of damages. The plaintiff, therefore, claimed this amount together with a sum of Rs. 102 which was in excess of the amount which he had paid to Gopikisan over and above the price of 423 bags supplied by him from time to time. The defendant denied the claim. While he admitted that he kept a stock of amber at Murtizapur and also that Gopikisan was his servant who was working at Murtizapur, he denied that Gopikisan was either a manager of the shop, for a diwanji or an agent of the defendant, or that he had any authority to make any forward contracts for the purchase or sale of goods. He also denied the damages claimed by the plaintiff.

    3. The trial Court dismissed the suit. The lower appellate Court, however, granted a decree to the plaintiff for the refund of Rs. 102 and damages to the extent of Rs. 394-4-0.

    4. The first point urged on behalf of the defendant is that Gopikisan had no authority to enter into the alleged contract. There is no doubt that Gopikisa did enter into a contract of the kind alleged by the plaintiff. But it would appear that Gopikisan had no authority to enter into such a contract. It is one thing for a person to authorise his servant to sell goods which are in stock with him, it is another to authorise him to enter into a contract to sell goods at a future date. The plaintiff has led no evidence to prove Gopikisan's authority to do the latter. Indeed, he has not even alleged in his plaint that Gopikisan had any authority to enter into a contract of this kind. He was content to say that Gopikisan was the manager of the branch opened by the defendant at Murtizapur. That allegation is not sufficient. It was necessary for the plaintiff to allege further that by reason of the position which Gopikisan held he had either express or implied authority to enter into such a contract. Reliance is, however, placed upon the following statement in the evidence of the defendant himself in support of the contention that Gopikisan had authority to enter into this contract:

    “In Murtizapur the P.W 2 was ordered to sell Saw Dust between annas -/12/- to Rs. ¼/- … not below annas -12/-. …P.W 2 had authority to sell Saw Dust in Akola also at annas -/14/- per bag (Yeotmal delivery). It is a fact that I had also empowered P.W 2 to sell Saw Dust in Akola and also in Murtizapur.”

    5. This part of the evidence of the defendant only shows that Gopikisan was authorised to effect sales. It does not show that he had any authority to enter into contracts. There is a real difference between a power to sell goods and power to enter into a contract to sell goods at a future date. It is clear from the contract on which the plaintiff relies that the transaction related to future goods and not to goods then in existence. It cannot he implied that a person who has a power to sell ready goods must also of necessity have a power to enter into a contract for the sale of future goods. On this short ground, therefore, the plaintiff's claim for damages must fail.

    6. There is, however, another reason why, in my opinion, the plaintiff's claim for damages must fail. It is that the plaintiff has led no evidence to show that he had suffered any damage at all; nor can it be inferred that the plaintiff must have suffered any damage. The learned Judge of the lower appellate Court when faced with this difficulty placed reliance upon the statement or the admission made by the defendant which is already quoted and came to the conclusion that the plaintiff is entitled to damages on the basis of the difference between the contract price and the maximum price at which the defendant had authorised Gopikisan to sell saw dust at Murtizapur. In the first place, this evidence does not show that any damage was sustained by the plaintiff. In the next place, this evidence is not sufficient to enable the Court to ascertain what was the rate of saw dust at the date of the breach. It may well be that the rate was Re. 1, 0-14-0 or even 0-12-0, in which case the plaintiff would certainly not be entitled to damages.

    7. It is, however, said that the contract having specified a sum of Rs. 1,000 a damages for its breach, the plaintiff was entitled to this amount or to a reason able amount irrespective of the question whether the plaintiff had proved the actual loss. If the sum mentioned in the contract as damages payable by the defendant to the plaintiff is a pre-estimate by the parties, s. 74 of the Contract Act would apply and would entitle the plaintiff to reasonable damages nor exceeding the amount so named in case there was a breach of the contract by the defendant. If, however, this amount has been mentioned in terrorem, it would be by way of penalty and the plaintiff would not be entitled to claim this amount or any reasonable amount unless it is shown that he has actually sustained damages. In the instant case, it would appear that the amount of Rs. 1,000 mentioned in the contract is not a pre-estimate by the parties of the damage that would have been sustained by the plaintiff by reason of the breach. Bearing in mind that the rate of one bag of saw dust was Re. 1, the total price that would have been payable by the plaintiff to the defendant for the entire quantity of 2,000 bags would be Rs. 2,000. If the defendant supplied 1999 bags but failed to supply one bag there would undoubtedly be a breach of the contract on the part of the defendant and under the contract, as it stands, the defendant would be liable to pay Rs. 1,000 as compensation to the plaintiff. This would be entirely disproportionate to the injury sustained by the plaintiff. It would, therefore, follow that the figure specified in the contract was fixed not as a pre-estimate by the parties of the damage which the plaintiff would suffer by reason of the breach, but in terrorem. Where such is the case, it cannot be presumed that the plaintiff must have suffered some damage. Therefore, the plaintiff must prove that he did in fact suffer some damages, though he need not prove the actual extent of the damages. Here the allegation is that the saw dust was to be used for manuring the fields of the plaintiff and that the failure of the defendant to supply the full quantity of saw dust contracted for resulted in damages to the plaintiff. There is no evidence to show that saw dust is used as a manure nor has one word been said by any one in this case that the use of saw dust gives a better yield of crops than otherwise. It would, therefore, follow that the plaintiff has not shown that he had suffered any damage at all. No doubt s. 74 says that where a sum is stated in the contract as payable to a party if a breach thereof is caused by the other party, the Court has power to grant compensation to the party even though actual loss or damage is not proved. But that does not mean that compensation can be awarded even though no loss whatsoever has been caused. For the very concept of award of compensation is bound up with loss or damage that results from a breach of contract. All that s. 74 permits is award of compensation even where the extent of the actual loss or damage is not proved and gives discretion to the Court to fix the amount. Where, as here, no loss or damage has ensued, there can be no question of awarding compensation. In my opinion, therefore, the plaintiff is not entitled to claim any damages.

    8. For these reasons, I allow the appeal, dismiss the cross-objection and modify the decree of the dower appellate Court by reducing it from Rs. 496-4-0 to Rs. 102. The plaintiff will be entitled to his costs on Rs. 102 in all the Courts and the defendant will be entitled to his costs on the remainder in all the Courts.

    9. Costs of the cross-objection will be borne by the plain tiff-respondent.

    10. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Satyanarayan Amolakchand Bhat v. Vithal Narayan Jamdar
    (Mar 25, 1957)