AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Zilla Parishads) Rules, 1995 (for short 'the Election Tribunals Rules)
  • Rule 35 of the Election Rules. Sub-rule (1) of Rule 35
  • provisions of Rule 35 of the Election Rules
  • ARTICLE 243 K CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Article 324, (c) where the Act or the Rules
  • Rule 35 of the Election Rules. RW3
  • Rule 35(1) of the Election Rules.
  • Rule 35 of the Election Rules.
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 35.
  • sub-rule (7) of Rule 34,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Zilla Parishads) Rules, 1995 (for short 'the Election Tribunals Rules)
  • Rule 35 of the Election Rules. Sub-rule (1) of Rule 35
  • provisions of Rule 35 of the Election Rules
  • ARTICLE 243 K CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Article 324, (c) where the Act or the Rules
  • Rule 35 of the Election Rules. RW3
  • Rule 35(1) of the Election Rules.
  • Rule 35 of the Election Rules.
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 35.
  • sub-rule (7) of Rule 34,
Smart Summary

Judicial Opinion Summary — D. Reddeppa Reddi, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

Election to the office of Sarpanch of Kalwal Grampanchayat was held on 3-7-1995 between Sri Y. Venkata Reddy (the petitioner in the revision petitions) and Sri V. Pratap Reddy (the contesting respondent). The Election Officer prepared result sheets (Form Nos.16 and 17) after initial counting on the same day. The initial count recorded 948 votes polled: the petitioner 428, the contesting respondent 431, and 89 votes invalid. The petitioner submitted a petition for recounting; the Election Officer recounted and found no change but could not announce results due to interim orders of this Court.

The State Election Commissioner issued a notification dated 26-7-1995 setting out grounds for recount, including a ground when the margin of victory was less than 1% of total polled votes. After the stay was vacated, a recount on 21-10-1995 was conducted (per the notification) by an officer appointed by the State Election Commissioner. That recount produced different figures: 949 polled — petitioner 430, contesting respondent 426, 93 invalid; the petitioner was then declared elected.

Two election petitions (OP Nos.7/95 and 4/95) challenged the declaration made after the recount. The Election Tribunal (District Munsif, Atmakur) set aside the petitioner's election and declared the contesting respondent elected, mainly on the ground that there was no application for recount as required by Rule 35 of the A.P. Panchayat Raj (Conduct of Elections) Rules, 1994, and by referring to a Division Bench decision that had declared the notification of 26-7-1995 illegal and void. The present two revision petitions were filed against that common order and were heard together.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Election Tribunal rested its decision solely on the basis of the Division Bench decision in Smt. S.K. Kasim Bee v. State Election Commissioner (referred to as "Khasim Bee's case")?
  2. Whether the notification dated 26-7-1995 of the State Election Commissioner is valid and/or relevant for the purpose of these cases?
  3. Whether there were justifiable grounds for recounting of votes on 21-10-1995 pursuant to the notification dated 26-7-1995 of the State Election Commissioner?
  4. Whether there are any justifiable grounds to interfere with the impugned order of the Election Tribunal?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Revisionist's) Arguments — as advanced by Sri L. Narasimha Reddy

  • The Election Tribunal relied solely on the Division Bench decision in Khasim Bee's case; that decision was subsequently reversed by the Supreme Court (order dated 12-8-1996 in the Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No.666/96), so the notification of 26-7-1995 was valid when the impugned order was passed and the recount of 21-10-1995 was therefore valid.
  • The Election Tribunal granted relief beyond the specific prayer made in the election petition: the petition specifically sought recount and declaration of the contesting respondent as elected after recount, but the Tribunal declared the contesting respondent elected without ordering a recount; if this Court finds the 21-10-1995 recount vitiated, the correct remedy would be to direct the Election Officer to order a fresh recount and then declare results.

Contesting Respondent's Arguments — as advanced by Sri D. Sudershan Reddy

  • The Election Tribunal based its decision on evidence adduced by parties and referred incidentally to Khasim Bee's case to bolster its reasoning; it did not rest solely on that decision.
  • The pleadings and evidence show that a recount was requested by the petitioner on the date of election and the Election Officer recounted then and found no change; therefore the State Election Commission's direction that recount should be held where margin was less than 1% had already been complied with and no further recount on 21-10-1995 was warranted.
  • The Election Tribunal correctly found, on the evidence, that no application was filed for recounting as required under Rule 35; absent such an application the State Election Commission's notification cannot be invoked to justify the recount of 21-10-1995.
  • Relief granted by a court should follow the evidence and statutory provisions; the Tribunal's declaration of the contesting respondent as duly elected based on the original Form No.16 (Ex.A1) is valid if the recount of 21-10-1995 is contrary to the statutory scheme and the notification.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. S.K. Kasim Bee v. State Election Commissioner, Hyderabad and others, 1996 (1) ALT 76 Decision declared the State Election Commission's notification dated 26-7-1995 illegal and void (as referenced by the Election Tribunal). The Election Tribunal had relied on this decision to sustain its conclusion that the recount of 21-10-1995 was not warranted. The High Court (this Court) found that the Tribunal referred to the decision incidentally but did not rest its decision solely on it.
Order of the Supreme Court dated 12-8-1996 in Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No.666/96 (reversing Khasim Bee's case) The Supreme Court's order effectively reversed the Division Bench decision that had declared the notification of 26-7-1995 illegal; the High Court regarded that order as relevant to the status of the notification. The High Court proceeded on the assumption that the notification was valid in view of the Supreme Court's order, and therefore considered issues without deciding the notification's validity (the State Election Commissioner was not a party and the point had not been pleaded).
A.C. Jose v. Sivan Pillai, AIR 1984 SC 921 Principles regarding the powers of an Election Commission under Article 324: (a) plenary powers where no statute/rules exist; (b) cannot override an Act or express Rules; (c) plenary power when Act/Rules silent; (d) cannot implement directions requiring Government approval without such approval. The Court relied on these principles to hold that the State Election Commissioner could not direct conduct contrary to Rule 35 of the Election Rules; recounting under the rules requires an application as per sub-rule (1) of Rule 35 and the notification could not supplant that requirement.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analysed the rival contentions by formulating four points (see Legal Issues Presented) and answered them sequentially:

  1. Point No.1 — Whether the Tribunal rested solely on Khasim Bee's case:

    The Court carefully reviewed the impugned order and concluded the Tribunal based its decision on the evidence of the respondents' witnesses and on the provisions of Rule 35 of the Election Rules. The Tribunal did refer to Khasim Bee's decision, but that reference was incidental and not the sole basis for its conclusion. Accordingly, this point was answered against the petitioner and in favour of the contesting respondent.

  2. Point No.2 — Validity/relevance of the notification of 26-7-1995:

    The Court observed that neither petition pleaded the invalidity of the notification, and the State Election Commissioner was not impleaded as a party. Therefore, it was inexpedient to decide the validity of the notification in these proceedings. The Court further stated the notification was not very relevant for the present purpose and proceeded on the assumption that it was valid in view of the Supreme Court order dated 12-8-1996. The point was accordingly answered (effectively: the Court would not decide the notification's validity here and assumed it valid for present purposes).

  3. Point No.3 — Whether justifiable grounds existed for recounting on 21-10-1995 pursuant to the notification:

    The Court accepted that the recount on 21-10-1995 was conducted pursuant to the notification clause dealing with recount where the margin of victory was less than 1% of total polled votes. However, the Court closely examined Rule 35(1) of the Election Rules, which mandates that "a candidate or, in his absence, his election agent or any of his counting agents may apply in writing to the Election Officer for recounting of the votes... stating the grounds" after announcement under Rule 34(7).

    The Court found no evidence that the petitioner filed any written application for recount as required by Rule 35(1). RW3 (the Election Officer at initial counting) and RW4 (second-stage officer) did not state that such an application was made on 3-7-1995 for recounting under Rule 35; RW3's evidence was that no disturbance occurred, ballots were counted and result sheets prepared and signed. The Court examined the notification's reasons and concluded the notification was intended to cover cases where an application for recount had been made and rejected despite a margin less than 1%. The Court rejected the petitioner's contention that the notification allowed recounts without any application under Rule 35.

    Applying A.C. Jose v. Sivan Pillai, the Court reiterated that the State Election Commissioner cannot direct action contrary to a statutory rule and that the statutory requirement of an application under Rule 35(1) could not be bypassed by the notification. On the evidence, the Court held there were no justifiable grounds for recounting on 21-10-1995 under the notification. This point was answered against the petitioner and in favour of the contesting respondent.

  4. Point No.4 — Whether there are justifiable grounds to interfere with the impugned order:

    The Court observed that the election petitions prayed for recount and declaration after recount; the contesting respondent's pleadings and evidence stated that a recount on the date of election had been requested by the petitioner and carried out by the Election Officer with no change, and the petitioner's counter admitted the paragraph describing that recount (except for disagreement on the number of valid votes). The Court found no rebuttal evidence that no on-the-spot recount request had been made or that the Election Officer had refused to recount on the date of counting.

    In light of the conclusions on the prior points (particularly that the 21-10-1995 recount was not justifiable under Rule 35 and the notification), the Court concluded the Election Officer had no option but to declare results based on the original Form No.16 (Ex.A1). Consequently, there were no justifiable grounds to interfere with the Tribunal's order given the evidence and statutory interpretation. The Court therefore dismissed the revision petitions.

Holding and Implications

Holding: THE REVISION PETITIONS ARE DISMISSED.

Immediate consequences and directions imposed by the Court (as stated in the opinion):

  • The Court held there were no justifiable grounds for the recount conducted on 21-10-1995 pursuant to the State Election Commissioner notification, because the statutory requirement of a written application under Rule 35(1) was not shown to have been complied with.
  • The Election Officer was directed to declare the results on the basis of the votes entered in Ex.A1 (Form No.16) — i.e., the results of the original counting on the date of election.
  • The revision petitions were dismissed as devoid of substance; the Court made no order as to costs.

Broader implications: The Court refrained from deciding the general validity of the notification dated 26-7-1995 (because the State Election Commissioner was not party and the point was not pleaded). The opinion applied established principles limiting an election authority's power to override statutory rules (drawing on A.C. Jose v. Sivan Pillai) but did not purport to lay down any novel legal precedent beyond the application of Rule 35 and those principles to the facts of these petitions.

    Y. Venkat Reddy v. Court Of The District Munsif, Atmakur

    D. Reddeppa Reddi, J

    1. These two revision petitions are directed against the common order dated 1-9-1997 of the Election Tribunal (District Munsif) Atmakur, Mahaboobnagar District, constituted under the A.P. Panchayat Raj (Election Tribunals in respect of Grampanchayats, Mandal Parishads and Zilla Parishads) Rules, 1995 (for short 'the Election Tribunals Rules) made in OP Nos.7 and 4 of 1995 setting aside the election of one Sri Y. Venkata Reddy as Sarpanch of Kalwal Grampanchayat of Narva Mandal and declaring one Sri V. Pratap Reddy as duly elected Sarpanch of the said Grampanchayat.

    2. The facts that led to the filing of these petitions as set out in the pleadings and borne out by evidence on record may be stated thus : Election to the office of Sarpanch of Kalwal Grampanchayat was held on 3-7-1995. There was contest for the same between Sri Y. Venkata Reddy (hereinafter referred to as "the petitioner'') and Sri V. Pratap Reddy (hereinafter referred to as "the contesting respondent"). Sri Venkata Swamy, Teacher, M.P. Narva Mandal was the Election Officer. Polling was held from 7a.m. to 1 p.m. On the same day counting was taken up from 2p.m. onwards and concluded by 4p.m. During the counting, it was found that 948 votes were polled. Of them, Sri Venkata Reddy secured 428 votes and Sri Prathap Reddy 431 votes. 89 votes were declared as invalid votes. The Election Officer prepared Form Nos.16 and 17. The petitioner submitted a petition for recounting of votes. The Election Officer recounted the votes, but found no change. However, he could not announce the results in view of the orders of this Court staying the declaration of election results. Meanwhile, the State Election Commissioner appointed under Article 243(k) of the Constitution of India issued a notification No.531/SEC/B/95-3 dated 26-7-1995 setting out grounds for recount. One of the grounds stipulates that recounting should be done when the margin of victory was less than 1% of the total polled votes. Sometime thereafter orders staying the results were vacated and the State Election Commissioner was permitted to declare the results of all elections to the offices of Sarpanch etc., Thereupon, as per the guidelines issued by the State Election Commissioner in the notification dated 26-7-1995 one Sri D. Basava Raj, Mandal Educational Officer, Narva Mandal, conducted recounting. Li the course of recounting, it was found that 949 votes were polled. The petitioner secured 430 votes and the contesting respondent 426 votes. 93 votes were rejected as invalid votes. Thereupon, the petitioners was declared elected as Sarpanch of Kalwal Grampanchayat. Questioning the said election, OP Nos.7/95 and 4/95 were filed, the former by the contesting respondent who contested the election and the latter by Sri K. Laxman Rao, a voter of Kalwal Grampanchayat. These petitions were resisted by the petitioner by filing a detailed counter separately in each petition. There was an order of this Court in CRP No.75/97 to club both the petitions and dispose of them together. Accordingly, they were clubbed. Evidence was recorded in OP No.7/95 and the same was treated as evidence in OP No.4/95. The petitioner in OP No.7/95 examined himself as PW1. One Sri Maheswara Reddy was examined as PW2. Exs.A1 and A2 were marked through them. The petitioner, who was elected during recount was examined as RW1. Also RWs.2 to 6 were examined and Exs.B1 and B2 were marked on behalf of RW1. The Election Tribunal, though failed to frame issues with reference to the pleadings, formulated the following point for consideration:

    Whether the recounting of votes conducted on 21-10-1995 was in accordance with the A.P. Panchayat Raj (Conduct of Elections) Rules, 1994 (for short the Election Rules)?

    It answered the point in fevour of the contesting respondent mainly on the ground that there was no application by or on behalf of the petitioner for recounting of votes as contemplated under Rule 35 of the Election Rules. It also referred to the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in Smt. S.K. Kasim Bee v. State Election Commissioner, Hyderabad and others, 1996 (1) ALT 76 declaring the notification dated 26-7-1995 of the State Election Commissioner as illegal and void to sustain its conclusion that the recounting done on 21-10-1995 is not warranted. In consequence, it set-aside the election of the petitioner and declared the contesting respondent, the petitioner in OP No.7/95 as Sarpanch of Kalwal Grampanchayat Hence, these two revision petitions.

    3. Sri L. Narasimha Reddy, learned Counsel for the petitioner raised two principal contentions : First: The Election Tribunal set-aside the petitioner's election solely on the basis of the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in Khasim Bee's case (supra) and since said decision was reversed by the Supreme Court by order dated 12-8-1996 in Civil Appeal No..../96 arising out of SLP (C) No.666/96, even by the time the impugned order dated 1-9-97 was passed the notification dated 26-7-95 of the State Election Commissioner holds the field and therefore the election petitions should have been dismissed holding that the recounting done on 21-10-1995 is perfectly valid. Second, the specific prayer in the election petition is for recounting of votes and declare the contesting respondent as duly elected Sarpanch of Kalwal Grampanchayat. But, the Election Tribunal declared the contesting respondent as duly elected Sarpanch without ordering for recount of votes. Thus, the relief granted in the impugned order is far in excess of the relief sought for. Hence, even in case this Court comes to the conclusion that recounting done on 21 -10-1995 is vitiated for any reason there should be a direction to the Election Officer to declare the results only after ordering for recount of votes afresh. Sri D. Sudershan Reddy, learned Counsel for the contesting respondent, counters the first submission on three counts : First, the Election Tribunal rested its order on the basis of the evidence adduced by both the parties, but incidentally referred to the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in Khasim Bee's case (supra) only to lend assurance to its conclusion that the recounting done on 21-10-1995 pursuant to the notification dated 26-7-1995 of the State Election Commissioner is not warranted. Second, the specific pleading and evidence adduced on behalf of the contesting respondent and Sri K. Laxman Rao, the petitioners in OP Nos.7 and 4 of 1995 respectively that the petitioner, who secured 428 votes, submitted a petition for recounting of votes and the Election Officer recounted the votes as sought for by him, but found no change, is not denied by the petitioner. Thus, the direction given by the State Election Commissioner in the notification dated 26-7-1995 that recounting should be done when the margin of victory was less than 1% of the total votes polled was already complied with by the Election Officer. Therefore, there should not have been a further recounting on 21-10-1995. Third, it has been found by the Election Tribunal on the basis of evidence that no application was filed by the petitioner for recounting of votes as contemplated under Rule 35 of the Election Rules. The question of recounting of votes even as per the grounds set out in the notification dated 26-7-1995 of the State Election Commissioner would arise only when there is an application for recounting as contemplated under Rule 35 of the Election Rules. In the absence of any such application, the recounting done on 21-10-1995 is totally unwarranted. Regarding the second submission, it is his plea that it is for the Court to grant appropriate relief basing on the evidence and also the relevant statutory provisions. The recounting done on 21-10-1995 is contrary to the relevant statutory provisions and also the notification dated 26-7-1995 of the State Election Commissioner and therefore the impugned order declaring the contesting respondent as duly elected Sarpanch on the basis of votes secured by him in the counting done on the date of election ie., 3-7-1995 and as entered in Form No.16marked as Ex.A1 is perfectly valid.

    4. In view of these rival contentions, the points for our consideration may be formulated as under:

    1. Whether the Election Tribunal rested its decision solely on the basis of the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in Khasim Bee 's case (supra) ?

    2. Whether the notification dated 26-7-95 of the State Election Commissioner is valid and/or relevant for the purpose of the present cases ?

    3. Whether there were justifiable grounds for recounting of votes on 21-10-1995 pursuant to the notification dated 26-7-1995 of the State Election Commissioner ?

    4. Whether there are any justifiable grounds to interfere with the impugned order ?

    Point No.1 : In order to appreciate this point, we have carefully gone through the entire impugned order. It is clear therefrom that the Election Tribunal on consideration of the evidence of RWs. 1 to 4 and the provisions of Rule 35 of the Election Rules came to the conclusion that the recounting done on 21-10-1995 was not in accordance with Rule 35. True, incidentally, the Election Tribunal also referred to the decision in Khasim Bee's case (supra). But, that by itself, in our considered view, is not sufficient to hold that the Election Tribunal rested its conclusion solely on the basis of the decision in Khasim Bee's case. The point is accordingly answered against the petitioner and in favour of the contesting respondent.

    Point No. 2 : It is not pleaded in cither of the petitions that the notification dated 26-7-95 of the State Election Commissioner is invalid and inoperative. That apart, the State Election Commissioner has not been impleaded as a respondent in either of the petitions. No steps have been taken even before this Court to bring on record the State Election Commissioner as a party to the present proceedings. In this view of the matter, we consider it inexpedient to decide the validity of the said notification. Also, we are of the view that the said notification is not very much relevant for our purpose. Moreover, we have to proceed on the assumption that it is valid in view of the order dated 12-8-1996 of the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.../96 arising out of SLP (C) No.666/96. This point is accordingly answered.

    Point No. 3 : It is not disputed before us that the recounting was conducted by RW4 on 21-10-95 pursuant to the following instruction contained in the notification dated 26-7-1995 of the State Election Commissioner :

    "Where recounting was not done even though the margin of victory was less than 1% of the total polled votes."

    It may be stated here that RW3 was the Election Officer and RW4 was the second stage Election Officer for the purpose of recounting of votes on 21 -10-1995 in the office of Mandal Praja Parishad, Atmakur. RW3, the Election Officer, did not state in his evidence that the petitioner made any application for recounting of votes as contemplated under Rule 35(1) of the Election Rules, which reads as under :

    "35 Recount of votes :-(1) After such announcement has been made under sub-rule (7) of Rule 34, a candidate or, in his absence, his election agent or any of his counting agents may apply in writing to the Election Officer for recounting of the votes either wholly or in part stating the grounds on which, he demands such recount."

    It is not there even in the evidence of RW4 that there was an application for recounting of votes as contemplated under Rule 35. It is also not the case of the petitioner deposing as RW1 that he made any application before the Election Officer-RW3, for recounting of votes as contemplated under Rule 35. On the other hand, his evidence is that he secured one vote more than the votes secured by the contesting respondent and RW3 succumbed to the pressure of PW2, the election agent of PW1 and counted 3 votes in favour of the contesting respondent, PW1. But this version of his is belied by the evidence of RW3, the Election Officer. He admitted in the course of cross-examination that there was no disturbance whatsoever at the time of counting and nobody raised any objection as to the counting of votes done by him. Yet, the learned Counsel for the petitioner tries to justify the recounting done by RW4 on 21-10-1995 on the ground that it was in consonance with the instructions contained in the notification dated 26-7-1995 of the State Election Commissioner. He maintains that as per the said notification recounting should be held whenever the margin of votes \vas less than 1 % of the total votes polled irrespective of the fact whether an application was filed as contemplated under Rule 35 or not. Therefore, it has to be seen whether the notification dated 26-7-1995 of the State Election Commissioner contemplated or provided for recounting of votes without there being any application as contemplated under 35 and/or where recounting was already done either on the basis of the application filed under Rule 35 or as per the oral request made by the aggrieved candidate or his election agent. In this context, it would be useful to refer to the reasons and circumstances that led to the issuance of notification dated 26-7-1995 by the State Election Commissioner. They read as under:

    "The State Election Commission has received numerous petitions seeking recount of the votes polled during recent elections to the Gram Panchayat. Several writ petitions also have been filed in the High Court seeking directions to the State Election Commission to order recount. The High Court through our Counsel desired to know what action the State Election Commission is intending to take on various representations before it for recounting of the votes polled in Gram Panchayats.

    The State Election Commission has initially taken the view that once result sheets in Form No. 17 have been signed no request for recounting shall be entertained. However, a sample verification of the complaints received has shown that in many cases the Election Officers appear to have violated instructions of the Election Commission and signed result sheets in Form No. 17 without giving an opportunity for recount."

    It is clear from the above that recounting shall be done only in cases where there was an application or request for recount and the same was rejected even though the margin of victory was less than 1% of the total votes polled. At any rate, we are unable to interpret the notification in question in the manner it is sought to be interpreted by the learned Counsel for the petitioner.

    5. The powers of the Election Commission in the matter of superintendence, direction and control of elections have been succinctly set out by the Supreme Court in A.C. Jose v. Sivan Pillai, AIR 1984 SC 921 in the following terms :

    "(a)when there is no Parliamentary legislation or rule made under the said legislation, the Commission is free to pass any orders in respect of the conduct of elections,

    (b) where there is an Act and express Rules made thereunder, it is not open to the Commission to override the Act or the Rules and pass orders in direct disobedience to the mandate contained in the Act or the Rules. In other words, the powers of the Commission are meant to supplement rather than supplant the law (both statute and Rules) in the matter of superintendence, direction and control as provided by Article 324,

    (c) where the Act or the Rules are silent, the Commission has no doubt plenary powers under Article 324 to give any direction in respect of the conduct of election, and

    (d) where a particular direction by the Commission is submitted to the Government for approval, as required by the Rules, it is not open to the Commission to go ahead with implementation of it at its own sweet will even if the approval of the Government is not given."

    In view of the above, there can be no direction by the State Election Commissioner to the Election Officers or any other concerned authorities to act contrary to Rule 35 of the Election Rules. Sub-rule (1) of Rule 35 mandates that there shall be an application in writing to the Election Officer for recounting of votes either wholly or in part stating the grounds for such recount. It follows, recounting cannot be resorted to unless there is an application for the same as contemplated under sub-rule (1) of Rule 35. In the case on hand, the plea of the contesting respondent and the evidence adduced on his behalf that there was recounting of votes on the date of election itself on the application/request made by and on behalf of the petitioner stands unrebutted. Also, it is not the case of the petitioner that he made an application for recounting of votes as contemplated under Rule 35(1) of the Election Rules. Further, as rightly held by the Election Tribunal, there is no iota of evidence to establish that the petitioner made an application for recounting of votes. In such view of the matter, we arc fully satisfied that there were absolutely no justifiable grounds for recounting votes on 21-10-95 pursuant to the notification dated 26-7-1995 of the State Election Commissioner. This point is accordingly answered against the petitioner and in favour of the contesting respondent.

    Point No. 4 : True, as urged by the learned Counsel for the petitioner, the prayer in OP No.7/95 filed by the contesting respondent reads as under:

    "It is therefore prayed that the Hon'ble Court may be pleased to allow the election petition setting aside the election of 1st respondent as Sarpanch of Kalwal Grampanchayat and declare this petitioner as elected Sarpanch of Grampanchayat Kalwal by recounting votes in the election held on 3-7-98 for the post of Sarpanch Grampanchayat Kalwal."

    The prayer in OP No.4/95 filed by a voter of Kalwal Grampanchayat is also to the same effect. The contesting respondent deposing as PW1 also prayed for recounting of votes and to declare him elected as Sarpanch of Kalwal Gram Panchayat. But, the following plea in para 1 of the election petition :

    It is submitted that 1st respondent herein submitted a petition for recount after the announcement of particulars from the result sheet filled up in Form No.17. The 2nd respondent counted all the votes again at the instance of 1st respondent, but there was no change in the number of votes got by the petitioner and the first respondent. The 2nd respondent also obtained the signatures of petitioners and as well as 1st respondent in the result sheet

    is not denied in the counter filed by the petitioner. To be more specific, the counter filed by the petitioner in this regard reads as under:

    "In reply to para No.1 of the petition are admitted by the respondent. Except the number of valid votes polled in favour of the respondent."

    On this aspect, the evidence of the contesting respondent, who has been examined as PW1, is as follows:

    ' 'At the time of counting of votes myself, Respondent No.1 and our agents were present there. The total votes polled in the election were of 948 and I got 431 and the Respondent No. 1 has got 428 and 89 were declared as invalid. Then the election officer prepared Form No.16 and 17 entered the results of counting. Thereafter the Respondent No.1 requested the Election Officer to recount the votes since the difference is only of 3 votes. Accordingly the votes were again counted but there was no any change to previous counting. The Election Officer obtained the signatures of election agents on Form No.16 and 17. As per the counting I got majority votes than Respondent No.1. The results were withheld as there was stay not to declare the results."

    In the cross-examination, it is not even suggested to him that there was no request by the petitioner to the Election Officer for recounting votes and the votes were not recounted by the Election Officer. It is significant to note that it is not even elicited from RW3, who has been examined on behalf of the petitioner himself that he made an application for recounting, but he failed to do so. It is also not elicited from RW4, who has also been examined on behalf of the petitioner, that there was an application of the petitioner for recounting of votes as contemplated under Rule 35 of the Election Rules. RW3 is specific in his evidence that after counting of votes he prepared the result sheet under Ex.A1, Form No.16.

    6. In the light of the pleadings and the evidence referred to supra and our conclusion on point No.3 that there were no justifiable grounds for recounting of votes on 21-10-1995, the Election Officer has no option but to declare the results on the basis of votes secured by the candidates as entered in Ex.A1, Form No. 16, Ex.A1, Form No.16, reads as under:

    Form No-16 Part II Result of Counting S.No.

    Name of the candidate Number of valid votes cast

    1.

    7. In the light of the above discussion and for the reasons recorded by us on points 1 to 4, we have no option but to hold that these revision petitions are devoid of substance. They are, accordingly, dismissed. However, we make no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Y. Venkat Reddy v. Court Of The District Munsif, Atmakur
    (Jul 3, 1998)