AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sec. 32(b) of the Andhra Pradesh Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act hereinafter referred to as the Act.
  • provisions of the Rent Control Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sec. 32(b) of the Andhra Pradesh Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act hereinafter referred to as the Act.
  • provisions of the Rent Control Act
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Four revision petitions (C.R.P. Nos. 2658/90, 2941/90, 3122/90 and 3129/90) challenge a common judgment in R.A. Nos. 387/89, 389/89, 390/89 and 388/89 by which the orders of the Rent Controller in R.C. Nos. 291/84, 292/84, 1972/86 and 1973/86 (directing eviction of tenants) were revised.

The petitioners are the landlords and the respondents are the tenants. The landlords own two premises (referred to as "mulgies") bearing Municipal Door Nos. 3-2-840/6 and 3-2-840/7 at Kachiguda, Hyderabad. The tenants leased each mulgi under separate registered lease deeds dated 23rd September 1978, at a monthly rent of Rs. 500 each. Material lease terms included: tenancy commencing on the first of each calendar month; rent payable in advance on or before the 10th of each month; tenants to pay municipal taxes upon intimation by the landlords within one month; and a clause entitling landlords to evict on non-payment of "any two months rent" (the lease also recorded a security deposit of Rs. 10,000 to be returned at termination after deductions).

The landlords filed R.C. Nos. 291/84 and 292/84 seeking eviction on the ground of wilful default in payment of municipal taxes and rent. They also filed O.S. No. 1404/81 in the City Civil Court for eviction and recovery of municipal tax arrears for specified periods. While that suit was pending, the Supreme Court struck down Section 32(b) of the Andhra Pradesh Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act and the State issued a notification bringing certain buildings within the Act's purview; subsequently the landlords pursued rent-control petitions.

During proceedings the landlords amended their eviction petitions to plead additional defaults (including a dishonoured cheque for Rs. 1,000 towards September 1985 rent and various municipal tax arrears for later periods). The tenants filed identical counters denying wilful default and asserting that municipal tax was payable "as and when demanded" (cited at Rs. 18 per month in the lease) and that they had paid tax when demanded.

Additional eviction petitions (R.C. Nos. 1972/86 and 1973/86) were filed alleging further defaults in 1986 (late payment of January and May 1986 rents and unpaid municipal tax thereafter). The Rent Controller found wilful default in tax payments and allowed the petitions by a common order dated 12-6-1989. The tenants appealed; the Chief Judge, City Small Causes Court, Hyderabad, allowed the appeals by a common order dated 30-7-1990, treating the late rent payments as belated but not wilful defaults and refusing eviction on that ground.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the tenants committed wilful default in payment of municipal taxes (and thereby wilful default in payment of "rent" under the lease) sufficient to justify eviction under the Rent Control Act and lease terms.
  2. Whether belated payment of rent (payments made a few days after the 10th of the month) amounts to "wilful default" entitling the landlords to evict the tenants under the lease clause requiring eviction on non-payment of any two months' rent.
  3. Whether the Rent Controller's finding of wilful default and consequent eviction order was correctly revised by the Appellate Authority (Chief Judge), or whether the revision petitions should be allowed to restore the eviction orders.

Arguments of the Parties

Landlords' Arguments

  • The tenants committed wilful default in payment of municipal taxes for specified periods (initially 1-11-1979 to 30-10-1981, and for later periods up to 30-9-1984 and beyond), and in payment of rent for specified months (August 1981, October 1981, January 1986, May 1986, and notably non-payment or dishonour of payment for September 1985).
  • The tenants had sent a cheque for Rs. 1,000 towards rent for September 1985 which was dishonoured for want of funds; the landlords relied on this as an additional ground of default (landlords later amended eviction petitions to raise this point).
  • Because the tenants agreed to pay municipal taxes in the lease and defaulted in doing so despite reminders, the landlords paid the taxes and sought recovery and eviction; the landlords point to a decree in O.S. No. 1404/81 and its execution to show the tenants' liability and non-payment.

Tenants' Arguments

  • The tenants denied any wilful default in payment of rent or municipal taxes. They asserted that the lease fixed property tax at Rs. 18 per month and that tax was payable "as and when demanded" by the landlord; they said they paid tax when demanded and, in any event, were not liable at an enhanced rate but paid to avoid controversy.
  • Regarding rent, the tenants contended that late payments (a few days after the 10th) were belated payments rather than wilful default; thus, such payments should not be treated as evictable defaults.
  • The tenants also argued that while their civil suit O.S. No. 1404/1981 was pending, the rent-control petitions before the Rent Controller were not maintainable (i.e., the pending suit impacted maintainability). They sought dismissal of the eviction petitions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Haji Mohamed v. Globe Theatres, AIR 1956 Mad. 216 Supports the proposition that municipal taxes (when agreed to be paid by the tenant) are included in the definition of "rent" and nonpayment of such taxes can constitute nonpayment of rent. The court relied on this decision to treat nonpayment of municipal tax (where tenant agreed to pay on intimation) as potentially amounting to wilful default in payment of rent, thus justifying eviction.
Narain Das Kasaudhan ... v. Chhotu ... (reported as AIR 1950 All. 61) Similarly supports that where a tenant agrees to pay municipal taxes, failure to pay them can be regarded as nonpayment of rent for purposes of eviction. The court cited this authority alongside Haji Mohamed to conclude that wilful default in payment of municipal taxes amounts to wilful default in payment of rent and is a ground for eviction under the Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by first examining the lease terms and the factual record of payments and demands. The relevant lease terms were (i) rent payable in advance on or before the 10th of each month, (ii) tenants to pay municipal taxes "within one month from the date of intimation by the landlords", and (iii) non-payment of any two months' rent would entitle the landlords to evict.

On the question of late rent payments, the court noted the Appellate Authority's (Chief Judge's) finding that although rents were not paid by the 10th as stipulated, the payments were in most cases only belated by a few days and thus not wilful defaults. The Chief Judge also observed the existence of the Rs. 10,000 advance deposit for each mulgi and concluded that belated payments did not amount to wilful default warranting eviction. The present court agreed with the Chief Judge's view in respect of those belated rent payments (i.e., the Chief Judge was correct in refusing eviction solely on the ground of belated rent).

The court then turned to municipal taxes. It rejected the landlords' contention that taxes were payable monthly on a pro rata basis along with rent, reasoning that the lease expressly required payment of municipal tax "within one month from the date of intimation by the landlords" after the landlord received the municipal demand notice. The lease wording, the court held, indicates a process: the Municipality serves demand notice on the landlord, the landlord intimates the tenant, and the tenant then pays within one month of that intimation.

Relying on the cited precedents (Haji Mohamed v. Globe Theatres and Narain Das Kasaudhan ... AIR 1950 All. 61), the court accepted the legal principle that where a tenant has agreed to pay municipal taxes, nonpayment of such taxes can be treated as nonpayment of rent and thus fall within the lease's eviction clause and the Act's provisions.

The court reviewed the procedural history and the civil suit O.S. No. 1404/81 (and later references in the record to O.S. No. 1404/84) in which the landlords sought recovery of rent and tax claims. The civil suit was eventually decreed for arrears of rent (decree dated 17-4-1986) and execution was taken out, properties attached and amounts realised. The court observed that the tenants in that suit had disputed liability to pay the tax arrears but did not assert that there had been no demand such that they could not pay; if the tenants' current claim (that they were not informed of demands) were true, they could have sought particulars or information during the suit. Given that the landlords obtained a decree and executed it to recover amounts, the court concluded that the evidence supports a finding that the tenants had committed wilful default in payment of municipal taxes.

The court also noted that the Appellate Authority (Chief Judge) had not taken the default in payment of taxes into account when allowing the tenants' appeals from the Rent Controller's eviction orders. Considering the additional evidence (suit, decree, execution, later defaults for subsequent periods, and documentary exhibits such as the judgment in O.S. No. 1404/81), the court concluded that there was wilful default in payment of municipal taxes which, by the authorities cited, amounts to wilful default in payment of rent and therefore justifies eviction.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The revision petitions are allowed.

Direct consequence: The respondent-tenants are directed to vacate the premises and hand over vacant possession to the landlords within three months from the date of the order. The court ordered "No costs."

Implications: The court's decision restores the Rent Controller's eviction orders (which had been revised by the Appellate Authority) on the ground that tenants committed wilful default in payment of municipal taxes and that such default amounts to wilful default in payment of rent under the lease and the cited authorities. The opinion does not announce any novel legal principle beyond applying the cited precedents to the facts; the immediate effect is the eviction direction and execution against the respondents as ordered.

All statements in this summary are drawn exclusively from the provided opinion text. No external facts or interpretations have been added.

    Smt. Kanta Bai Asawa And Others v. Kranti Swaroop Machine Tools, Pvt., Ltd & Another

    1. The above four Revisions petitions i.e, C.R.P Nos. 2658/90, 2941/90, 3122/90 and 3129/90 are directed against the common Judgment in R.A Nos. 387/89, 389/89, 390/89 and 388/89 respectively by which the orders of the Rent Controller made in R.C Nos. 291/84, 292/84, 1972/86 and 1973/86 directing eviction of the tenant was revised.

    2. The Revision petitioners are the landlords and the respondents are the tenants.

    3. The Revision petitioners are the owners of two mulgies bearing Municipal Door Nos. 3-2-840/6 and 3-2-840/7 situatedat Kachiguda, Hyderabad. The respondents took the mulgies on a monthly rent of Rs. 500/- each and executed registered lease deeds separately in respect of each mulgi. They are Exs. A-1 and A-2 dated 23rd September, 1978. As per the terms of lease deed the tenancy commences on first of every calendar month and that the rent is payable in advance on or before 10th of every month. The tenants had also agreed to pay the municipal taxes. It was further stipulated that non-payment of any two months rent as agreed to will entitle the landlords to eject the tenants on the ground of wilful default. The, tenants deposited a sum of Rs. 10,000/-. This deposit has to be returned to the tenants at the time of termination of tenancy after deducting the arrears of rents, electricity charges etc., if any. The rental deed further stipulates that the tenants should pay municipal taxes within one month from the date of intimation by the landlords. These are the conditions of the lease relevant for disposal of the Revision petitions.

    4. The petitioners-Landlords filed R.C No. 291/84 and R.C No. 292/84 for eviction of the tenants from the mulgies 840/6 and 840/7 respectively on the ground that the tenants have committed wilful default in payment of property tax as well as monthly rent. The tenants did not pay the tax due to the Municipality for the period from 1-11-1979 to 30-10-1981 in respect of both the mulgies. So, the landlords filed a suit in O.S No. 1404/81 on the file of II Addl. Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad seeking eviction of the tenants and also for realisation of the arrears of municipal taxes for the said years. While the suit was pending, the Supreme Court struck down Sec. 32(b) of the Andhra Pradesh Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act hereinafter referred to as the ‘Act’. The Government of Andhra Pradesh issued a notification bringing all the buildings which are ten years old and whose rent does not exceed Rs. 1000/- per month within the purview of the Act. In the meanwhile according to the landlords the tenants committed wilful default in payment of rent in respect of both the mulgies for the months of August, 1981 and October, 1981 within the stipulated time. The rent payable for August, 1981 was paid on 10th September, 1981 and the rent for the month of October, 1981 was paid on 12th of November, 1981. The landlords therefore filed R.C Nos. 291/84 and 292/84 for eviction.

    5. Subsequent to the filing of these two petitions for eviction, the landlords filed separate I.As in each petition for eviction and got the petitions amended. By that amendment the landlords pleaded that the tenants sent a cheque for Rs. 1,000/- towards rent for September, 1985 for both the mulgies and when the cheque was presented for encashment it was dishonoured for non-availability of funds. Apart from that it is contended that the tenants committed wilful default in payment of municipal taxes for the period 1-11-1981 to 30-9-1984 amounting to Rs. 3,572-10 Ps. for each mulgi. The landlords paid the municipal tax as tenants did not pay the same in spite of repeated reminders. Municipal tax for the period 1-11-1981 to 31-3-1984 for both the mulgies amounting to Rs. 5,919-48 was paid by the tenants by way of Demand Draft along with a covering letter dated 28-7-1984 and the same was received by the landlords on 1-8-1984. Similarly the tenants sent another Demand Draft for Rs. 1,224-72 along with a covering letter dated 26-10-1984 towards the municipal tax for the period from 1-4-1984 to 30-9-84 and the same was received by the landlords on 6-11-1984. The tenants again sent a Demand Draft for Rs. 1,224-72 with a covering letter dated 5-1-1985 towards municipal tax for the period from 1-10-1984 to 31-3-1985 and the landlords received the same on 11-1-1985. The tenants have not paid the tax for the subsequent period from 1-4-1985 to 30-9-1985. Thus, according to the landlords there was default in payment of rent as well as taxes even during the pendency of the petitions for eviction and the landlords therefore pray for eviction of the tenants and for vacant possession.

    6. The tenants filed counters in R.C Nos. 291/84 and 292/84 with identical averments. In those counters they contended that they have not committed any wilful default either in payment of rent or municipal tax. In the lease deed, it is mentioned that the property tax is Rs. 18/- per month and the same is payable as and when-demanded. The tenants have been paying property tax as when demanded. Eventhough the tenants are not liable to pay tax at the enhanced rate, yet in order to avoid controversy the tenants have been paying tax at the enhanced rate.

    7. The landlords filed O.P No. 1404/1981 on the file of II Additional Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad seeking relief of eviction and recovery of arrears of tax. When that matter is pending the petitions filed for eviction before the Rent Controller are not maintainable. The tenants had not committed any wilful default in payment of rent for the months of August and October, 1981. Generally Municipal tax was levied once in every half year and the demand notice was served on the landlord. The tenants are liable to pay the tax as per the terms of the lease deed within one month from the date of intimation by the landlord. The tenants therefore request for dismissal of the petitions filed for eviction.

    8. While the above two Rent Control petitions were pending the landlords filed two other petitions in R.C No. 1972/86 and 1973/86 for eviction in respect of the premises bearing Nos. 840/6 and 840/7 reiterating what they had stated in the earlier petitions for eviction. It was further contended in those eviction petitions that the tenants committed default in payment of rent for the month of January, 1986. According to the landlord the rent which was payable by 10-1-1986 was paid to him by way of draft on 17-1-1986. Similarly there was default in payment of rent for the month of May, 1986. The tenants sent the rent for the month of June which was payable on 10-6-1986 on 24-7-1986. It is further alleged that the tenants had also committed default in payment of municipal tax for the period subsequent to 1-4-1985. The landlords therefore prayed for eviction of the tenants. In these two petitions also the tenants have filed counters denying the alleged wilful default.

    9. The learned Rent Controllor on consideration of the evidence adduced found that the tenants had committed wilful default in payment of taxes and that they are liable for eviction and consequently allowed the petitions by a common order dated 12-6-89. Aggrieved by that order the tenants have filed appeals before the Chief Judge, City Small Causes Court, Hyderabad. The learned Chief Judge allowed those appeals by a common order dated 30th July, 1990. He observed that though there was default in payment of rent in the sense that it was not paid by 10th of every month in advance as stipulated in the agreement, yet they cannot be deemed as wilful defaults as would entitle the landlords to evict the tenants inasmuch as they were only belated payments. The learned Chief Judge, refused to treat them as wilful defaults warranting an order of eviction. In the rental deed it is stipulated that the rents are payable on 10th of every month in advance. Except in respect of the rent payable for September, 1985 the tenants had paid rent either by cheque or draft within the few days after 10th. The Chief Judge observed that the landlords have with them anadvance of Rs. 10,000/- in respect of each mulgi and that therefore it would not be proper to treat these belated payments as amounting to wilful default. It is true that the landlords received a cheque for Rs. 1,000/- towards payment of rent for both the mulgies. But when the cheque was presented it was dishonoured and that payment was made in December, 1986. The learned Chief Judge observed that this dishonour of the cheque was not intimated to the tenants. But it could be seen from the record that the landlords filed an application for amendment of the petition raising the plea regarding non-payment of rent for September, 1985. The same was allowed. In that application the tenants had also, filed a counter. So, it cannot be said that the tenant had no knowledge of dishonour of the cheque. The rent for the month of September, 1985 was paid only in December, 1986 as admitted by the tenants themselves. But according to the recitals in the lease deed the landlords would be entitled to ask for eviction if there is default in payment of rent for any two months (not two consecutive months as observed by the learned Chief Judge). Under the circumstances, I find that the learned Chief Judge was right in refusing to order eviction on the ground of wilful default in payment of rent.

    10. The tenants had further agreed to pay the municipal taxes. According to the terms of the lease deed this tax should be paid by the tenants within one month from the date of intimation by the landlord. The Municipality would serve demand notice on the landlord and the landlord is expected to inform the same to the tenants and on such information the tenants have to pay taxes within one month from the date of intimation. It is contended by the tenants that the landlord had not intimated them of the tax payable and that therefore the non-payment of tax even if true cannot be construed as wilful default. The landlord has contended that the tax is payable every month pro-rata along with the rent. But I am unable to agree with this contention, as the recitals in the lease deed would not warrant such interpretation. If what the landlords contend were to be true, it would not have been mentioned in the lease deed that the tenant has to pay the tax on being informed by the landlord within one month from the date of intimation. The recitals in the lease deed would indicate that the landlord on service of the demand notice in respect of tax is bound to intimate the tenant and on such intimation the tenant has to pay tax within one month. In cases where the tenant has agreed to pay the municipal tax, any nonpayment of tax would amount to non-payment of rent. Thus, the tax is also included in the definition of rent as reported in Haji Mohamed v. Globe Theatres . AIR 1956 Mad. 216. and Narain Das Kasaudhan…Defendant Applicant; v. Chhotu…Plaintiff Opposite Party. . AIR 1950 All. 61.. As per the decisions cited above, even if the tenants have committed wilful default in payment of municipal tax as agreed upon and if such default is wilful, the landlords are entitled to evict the tenant under the provisions of the Act. In the instant case the landlords has filed O.S No. 1404/81 on the file of II Addl. Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad for recovery of rents for the period from 1-10-1979 to 30-10-1981 and for eviction of the tenants. As the building was constructed subsequent to 1957 the provisions of the Rent Control Act were not applicable as per the provisions of Sec. 32(b) of the Act. While that suit was pending the Supreme Court struck down Sec. 32(b) as unconstitutional. The Government issued notification by which all the buildings constructed more than ten years back and fetching a rent not exceeding Rs. 1000/- were brought within the purview of the provisions of the Act. In view of the above notification the landlords filed Rent Control Petitions in R.C Nos. 291/84 and 292/84. Subsequently the suit in O.S No. 1404/84 filed by the landlords was decreed only for arrears of rent on 17-4-1986. In that suit the tenants disputed their liability to pay the tax arrears as claimed by the landlords. It was not their case that they could pay the amount but there was no demand. If what they say now in the eviction petitions were to be true they should have asked for information regarding the amount that has to be paid towards tax and then paid the amount. But, on the other hand, the tenants contested the suit and it was disposed of five years after the institution. That suit was decreed and the landlords filed execution petition, got the properties attached and men realised the amounts. So, under the circumstances, it cannot be said that the tenants had not committed any wilful default in payment of municipal faxes. This was one of the grounds urged by the landlords in their application for eviction in R.C Nos. 291/84 and 292/84. But, it appears that the Appellate Authority had not taken into consideration this default in payment of taxes. Even for the subsequent periods also there was default and the landlords had to file suit for recovery of taxes. Ex. P-9 is the copy of judgment in O.S No. 1404/81. The evidence of the landlords shows that they had executed the decree for realisation of the amount. So, under the circumstances, I find that the tenants have committed wilful default in payment of tax and the same amounts to wilful default in payment of rent as would entitle the landlords to evict the tenants. Hence, the revision petitions are allowed and the respondent-tenants are directed to vacate the premises and handover vacant possession of the same to the landlords within three months from the date of this order. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Kanta Bai Asawa And Others v. Kranti Swaroop Machine Tools, Pvt., Ltd & Another
    (Jun 29, 1993)