Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 244(1) and Section 244(2) and Section 252(2)
  • SECTION 244 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Section 494 read with 109 I.P.C
  • Section 204(2) of the new Code
  • Section 244 Cr. P.C
  • Section 311 Cr. P.C
  • Section 494 I.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 244(1) and Section 244(2) and Section 252(2)
  • SECTION 244 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Section 494 read with 109 I.P.C
  • Section 204(2) of the new Code
  • Section 244 Cr. P.C
  • Section 311 Cr. P.C
  • Section 494 I.P.C
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Criminal Revision Case No. 280 of 1992 & Criminal Petition No. 1097 of 1992

Factual and Procedural Background

Two petitions were before the Court: Criminal Revision Case No. 280 of 1992 (filed against an order of discharge in C.C. No. 19 of 1990 passed by the J.F.C.M., Pathikonda dated 31 March 1992) and Criminal Petition No. 1097 of 1992 (filed against an order of dismissal in Crl. R.P. No. 11 of 1991 by the III Additional Sessions Judge, which had confirmed the order passed in Crl. M.P. No. 106/91 in C.C. No. 19/1990 by the J.F.C.M., Pathikonda).

A private complaint was filed by the complainant (the wife) against the accused (the husband) for offences under Section 494 read with Section 109 I.P.C. The sworn statement of the complainant was recorded and the complaint was filed on 26.2.1990 as C.C. 19/90; process was issued for the accused's appearance.

The brief factual background in the complaint: the parties married on 26.2.1981; after a short period of married life the complainant alleged harassment by respondents 1, 3 and 4 for dowry and that she was left at her parents' house. She obtained maintenance in M.C. 4/83. The first respondent allegedly married again on 15.7.1989 while the first marriage was subsisting. The complaint charged the husband under Section 494 IPC and respondents 2–5 under Section 494 read with Section 109 IPC.

During the magistrate's proceedings, witnesses listed in the complaint were examined, with the last listed witness examined on 5.2.1991. On that same day, before the Magistrate's discharge order was passed, the complainant filed a supplemental witness list of four persons along with an application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. The learned Magistrate registered the application as Crl. M.P. No. 106/91 and dismissed it, holding inter alia that parties lack power to request examination under Section 311 and that Section 244 Cr.P.C. did not permit a second list of witnesses at the inquiry stage; a discharge order followed. The petitioner then filed the present revision/petition challenging those orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after a complaint has been filed listing certain witnesses, the complainant can submit a further (supplemental) list of witnesses before a magistrate passes an order of discharge, and whether the Magistrate may entertain such a supplemental list.
  2. Whether an application filed citing Section 311 Cr.P.C. (instead of Section 244 Cr.P.C.) should be rejected merely because the wrong provision was cited, when the affidavit makes clear the complainant's intention to examine additional witnesses.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Somasundaram v. Gopal, AIR 1958 Madras 341 Supplemental lists under Section 204(1-A) can be added and courts have ample power under Section 244(1) to "take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution." The Court relied on this decision to interpret Section 244 as allowing supplemental lists and to support the view that the magistrate has power to examine witnesses beyond the initial list before discharge.
S. Vivekanatham v. R. Viswanathan, 1977 Crl. L.J. 425 Reiterated that Section 244 is wide enough to permit a complainant to file supplemental or additional witness lists and for the court to issue summons and record their evidence; a complainant is not irretrievably bound by the first list. The Court relied on this authority to emphasize that complainants may seek permission to examine additional witnesses where justice warrants it, and that Section 244 is broad in that respect.
State of Bombay v. Janardhan, AIR 1960 Bombay 513 Supported the view that additional names may be added to the prosecution list but added a rider that the court should refuse permission if it would prejudice the accused or not be in the interest of justice. The Court cited this case to acknowledge that while supplemental witnesses may be permitted, the magistrate retains a discretion to refuse where prejudice to the accused or injustice would result.
Nawal Kishore Shukla v. State of U.P., 1992 Crl. L.J. 1554 (Allahabad) Held that courts can permit examination of witnesses not mentioned in the original list and it is not necessary that all witnesses in the original list be examined before such permission is granted. The Court took this decision into account in interpreting "all such evidence" under Section 244(1) to include witnesses proposed in a subsequent application filed before the discharge order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a textual and precedential analysis focused on Section 244 Cr.P.C. It began by setting out Section 244(1) and (2), observing that the phrase "take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution" is broad.

The court reviewed prior decisions from the Madras, Bombay and Allahabad High Courts which had addressed whether a complainant may add or seek examination of witnesses beyond the initial list. The Madras decisions (Somasundaram and S. Vivekanatham) were taken to establish that supplemental lists can be permitted and that Section 244 empowers the magistrate to receive evidence produced in support of the prosecution beyond the original list. The Bombay authority (State of Bombay v. Janardhan) qualified that discretion must be exercised so as not to prejudice the accused or subvert the interests of justice. The Allahabad decision (Nawal Kishore Shukla) supported permitting examination of witnesses not originally listed and observed it is not necessary to have exhausted the original list before granting permission.

Applying these authorities and the plain language of Section 244, the Court concluded that "all such evidence" is not limited to the witnesses named in the complaint's initial list, but also encompasses witnesses proposed in a subsequent application filed before the magistrate's discharge order. Consequently, a complainant has the right to produce additional witnesses in support of the charge at any time before discharge, subject to the court's discretion to prevent prejudice or injustice.

The Court also addressed the procedural point that the supplemental application had been framed under Section 311 Cr.P.C. rather than Section 244 Cr.P.C. The Court held that mere citation of an incorrect provision does not mandate automatic dismissal where the affidavit clearly indicates the complainant's intention to examine additional witnesses and where the averments disclose a prima facie case. On that basis the Court set aside the magistrate's order rejecting the application and the consequential order of discharge.

Finally, the Court directed that the lower court proceed from the stage of the supplementary application and dispose of the matter in accordance with law.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Both the Criminal Petition No. 1097 of 1992 and Criminal Revision Case No. 280 of 1992 are allowed.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The order dismissing the application for examination of supplementary witnesses (Crl. M.P. No. 106/91) is set aside.
  • The consequential order of discharge in C.C. No. 19/90 is set aside.
  • The lower court (magistrate) is directed to proceed from the stage of the complainant's application to examine the witnesses named in the supplementary list and to dispose of the case in accordance with law.

Broader implications (as reflected in the opinion): The Court interpreted Section 244 Cr.P.C. to permit the examination of additional witnesses proposed by a complainant before the discharge order is passed, consistent with prior High Court authorities; however, the magistrate retains discretion to refuse if allowing additional witnesses would prejudice the accused or be otherwise contrary to the interests of justice. The opinion did not purport to lay down a novel precedent beyond applying and following the cited High Court authorities.

    Jamuna Rani v. S. Krishna Kumar & Others

    1. The Criminal Revision Case No. 280 of 1992 is filed by the petitioner against the order of discharge passed in C.C No. 19 of 1990 on the file of the J.F.C.M Pathikonda, Dt. the 31st of March, 1992. The Criminal Petition on, Crl. P. No. 1097/1992 is filed by the petitioner against the order of dismissal passed in Crl. R.P No. 11 of 1991 by the III Additional Sessions Judge, confirming the order passed in Crl. M.P No. 106/91 in C.C No. 19/1990 passed by the J.F.C.M Pathikonda. The facts in brief are as follows:

    2. A private complaint was filed by the complainant (wife) against the accused (husband) in the court of the J.F.C.M Pathikonda, for the offence under Section 494 read with 109 I.P.C A sworn statement of the Complainant was recorded on the date of the complaint, i.e on 26.2.90 and on the same day the complaint has been taken on file as C.C 19/90 and process was issued for the appearance of the accused.

    3. The facts which lead to the filling of the above complaint was that on 26.2.1981 the first respondent married the complainant according to Hindu rites and rituals at Arya Vysya Choultry in Kurabalakota, Madanapally taluk.

    4. They lead married life for a short period. Thereafter, she was harrased by respondents 1, 3 and 4 for not bringing dowry of Rs. 25,000/- and she was forcibly left in her parents house. As she had no means to maintain herself, she filed M.C 4/83 on the file of J.F.C.M Kuppam and she was awarded maintenance. The first respondent also filed a petition for divorce against the complainant which is pending. Taking advantage of the official position of respondent No. 3 the first respondent married the second respondent on 15.7.89 while the first marriage was still subsisting. Therefore, the complainant filed the above complaint against the husband for the offence under Section 494 I.P.C and against respondents 2 to 5 for the offence punishable under Sections 494 read with 109 I.P.C

    5. After the process was issued for the appearance of the accused, all the witnesses who were mentioned in the list appended to the complaint were examined and the last witness appended to the list was examined on 5.2.91 On the same day, i.e on 5.2.91 before the order of discharge has been passed by the Magistrate, a supplemental list of witnesses consisting of four persons, with an application under Section 311 Crl. P.C was filed to issue summons to those witnesses also. The learned Magistrate registered the same as Crl. M.P No. 106/91 and he held that either the complainant or the accused have no power or right to request the court to examine witnesses under Section 311 Cr. P.C He further held that the power to summon witnesses under this Section is a special one and it is quite different from the power under other Sections of the Code, on the application of the parties who have a right to process. The parties to a case cannot dictate to a Court over the summoning of the witnesses under this Section and that the discretion to summon vests solely in the court alone and no compulsion can be placed upon any court to summon a witness particularly in a case where the court has come to the conclusion that the evidence of the witness concerned would not be necessary. He further held while considering the scope and ambit of Section 244 Crl. P.C that there is no provision under Section 244 Crl. P.C to file a second list of witnesses at the stage of enquiry before framing the charge instituted otherwise than on a police report. For the above reasons, he dismissed the petition holding that the same is not maintainable. Consequent on passing of this order a discharge order has been passed against which the petitioner filed Crl. R.C 280/92 in this Court.

    6. Now the main point that has to be decided in this case is, when a complaint has been filed listing out certain number of witnesses, whether the complainant can be permitted to submit a further list of witnesses before the order of discharge is passed and whether the same can be entertained by the Magistrate. The language that has been adopted in Section 244 Crl. P.C is very clear. Section 244 of the Criminal Procedure Code reads thus:

    “244. Evidence for Prosecution: (1) When, in any warrant-case instituted otherwise than on a police report, the accused, appears or is brought before a Magistrate, the Magistrate shall proceed to hear the prosecution and take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution.

    (2) The Magistrate may, on the application of the prosecution, issue a summon to any of its witnesses directing him to attend or to produce any document or other thing.”

    7. On an identical point when it had come up for consideration before the Madras High Court, the learned Judges held in Somasundaram v. Gopal, (1) AIR 1958 Madras 341 that the list filed under Section 204(1-A) can be added to by supplemental lists accompanied by applications to the Court to summon those new witnesses. Such supplemental lists can be in addition to all the witnesses in the primary list filed by the private complainant under Section 204(1) Crl. P.C or in addition only to such of the witnesses in the primary list whom he decides to examine. The phrase “take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution” in Section 244(1) and Section 244(2) and Section 252(2) Crl. P.C shows the ample powers of the Court in this respect.

    8. The same point has again been considered by the Madras High Court in S. Vivekanatham v. R. Viswanathan, (2) 1977 Crl. L.J 425 and the learned Judges reiterated the same. In that case also the Complainant furnished a list of 4 witnesses. He gave up the examination of two witnesses in that list and later he requested the court to summon ten witnesses and have them examined under Section 311 Crl. P.C Realising that the Court may not be interested to summon those persons and examine them as Court witnesses, the petitioner withdrew that petition and filed another petition praying for permission to cite those ten witnesses as additional witnesses on the complainant's side and to have them examined. The learned Judges held that Section 244 is wide enough to give power to a Court to accept a supplemental or additional list of witnesses given by a complainant and to issue summons to them and record their evidence. They further held as follows:

    “Though Section 204(2) of the new Code prescribes that no summons or Warrant shall be issued against the accused under Sub-section (1) until a list of the prosecution witnesses has been filed, that cannot be taken to mean that a complainant is irretrievably chained to the first list of witnesses filed by him and he cannot seek the permission of the Court to examine additional witnesses even where circumstances or interests of justice warrant such examination. To hold otherswise would actually lead to grave injustice and hardships to complainants.”

    9. The same is the view taken by the Bombay High Court in State of Bombay v. Janardhan, (3) AIR 1960 Bombay 513. But the learned Judges went further and put a rider saying that the Court should not, however, give permission to add names to the list if it is going to prejudice the case of the accused or if it is not in the interest of justice. But what is contemplated under Section 204(1) is only giving out a list of prosecution witnesses by the complainant and if in the opinion of the Magistrate taking cognizance of an offence, there is sufficient ground for proceeding, he shall issue summons or warrants as the case may be. But Section 244(1) says that the Magistrate shall take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution to substantiate the charge, which means that it does not confine only to the list of witnesses mentioned at the earliest point of time. The Court has got ample power, before the order of discharge is passed, to entertain the application of the complainant with regard to the examination of the witnesses sought to be examine in support of the charge. Not only the persons listed in the complaint but also any other person who has got knowledge or who has got something to say about the complaint alleged therein, can be examined if such an application is made by the complainant before the order of discharge is passed. So, the Magistrate at the earliest point of time has no discretion to dismiss the application to examine some more witnesses other than the persons mentioned in the list. To make it more clear the complainant has got absolute right to produce the evidence in support of the charge at any time before the discharge order is passed, and for that purpose he can make an application to examine some more witnesses apart from the witnesses mentioned in the list appended to the complaint. While considering Section 244 Cr. P.C the Allahabad High Court in Nawal Kishore Shukla v. State of U.P, (4) 1992 Crl. L.J 1554 held that the Court can permit examination of the witnesses not mentioned in the list and that it is not necessary that all the witnesses named in the list of witnesses should have been examined before such a permission is granted. Taking into account the views expressed by the Madras, Bombay and Allahabad High Courts and on interpreting ‘all such evidence’ in Section 244(1), I feel that it does not limit to the witnesses mentioned in the list appended to the complaint but it refers to any other witness mentioned in a subsequent application filed before the discharge order is passed by the Magistrate.

    10. The other ground for rejection is that the application has been filed under Section 311 Cr. P.C and that it ought to have been filed under Section 244 Cr. P.C Mere quoting of a wrong provision of law does not mean automatic dismissal, particularly, when it is made clear in the affidavit that the complainant wants to examine some more witnesses other than those mentioned in the list and also when the averments in the affidavit discloses that a prima facie case is there. So, the order of rejection that has been passed on the application for examination of the witnesses mentioned in the supplementary list is set aside. As this Court found that the petitioner has got a right to examine some more witnesses other than those mentioned in the list appended to the complaint and the court is bound to summon the witnesses, the order of discharge which is a consequential order has to be set aside and it is accordingly set aside. The Lower court is directed to proceed from the stage of the application made by the complainant for examining the witnesses mentioned in the supplementary list and dispose of the case in accordance with law.

    11. In the result, both the criminal petition, Crl. P. No. 1097 of 1992 and the Criminal revision case, Crl. R.C No. 280 of 1992, are allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jamuna Rani v. S. Krishna Kumar & Others
    (Sep 18, 1992)