AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was employed by the respondent-federation, appointed as a sales assistant in September 1965 and later promoted to manager (fertilisers). By proceedings dated 2 August 1984 (effective 1 December 1982), the respondent terminated the petitioner’s services on the ground of unauthorised absence. Terminal benefits (gratuity, provident fund and return of security deposit) were not paid. The petitioner served a lawyer's notice (5 June 1985) and the respondent replied that payment of gratuity was withheld because a general enquiry into pesticides distribution (relevant to the period when the petitioner worked as manager (pesticides)) was pending. The petitioner filed a writ petition seeking a writ of mandamus to direct settlement/payment of gratuity, provident fund, return of security bond and other amounts payable under various statutes.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent was justified in withholding the petitioner’s gratuity by invoking Sub‑section (6) of Section 4 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that termination (effective 1 December 1982) had not led to payment of gratuity and other terminal benefits; this withholding was arbitrary and oppressive.
  • The petitioner sought a writ directing payment of gratuity, provident fund and return of security deposit.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent admitted applicability of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, but submitted that the petitioner’s services were terminated for wilful absence/neglect amounting to misconduct and relied on Section 4(6) of the Act to justify forfeiture of gratuity.
  • The respondent also stated that provident fund could be withheld and that the petitioner allegedly owed the federation Rs. 17,378.77 (particulars first disclosed in the counter‑affidavit), which could be adjusted against amounts payable to him.
  • The respondent relied on the existence of a pending general enquiry (pesticides distribution) covering the petitioner’s period of employment as a reason to withhold gratuity.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court’s analysis centers on the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, and the specific operation of Section 4 (particularly Sub‑section (6)), Section 7 and related rules and provisions referenced in the opinion:

  1. Statutory framework and obligations:
    • The Act is described as beneficial legislation applicable to the respondent’s employees under its regulations.
    • Section 4(1) makes gratuity payable on termination where the employee has rendered continuous service of not less than five years; the term “retirement” (S.2(q)) includes termination otherwise than on superannuation.
    • Section 7 (and rules) places an obligation on the employer to determine the amount of gratuity and give written notice specifying the amount both to the person entitled and to the controlling authority as soon as it becomes payable; rules require action within prescribed time limits (Rule 8: employer must, within 15 days of receipt, issue notice and fix a date not later than 30 days after receipt for payment if claim admitted).
    • Section 8 provides for recovery by the Collector and compound interest at 9% per annum from expiry of prescribed time if unpaid.
  2. Application to facts:
    • The petitioner had continuous service since 1965 and was terminated effective 1 December 1982, thus meeting the five‑year service requirement for gratuity.
    • Termination for unauthorised absence constitutes “retirement” under the Act; thus the petitioner was prima facie entitled to gratuity payable on the date of termination.
    • The respondent did not determine and pay the gratuity within the statutory time. The petitioner applied for payment on 25 October 1984 (received 26 October 1984); under Rule 8 the gratuity should have been paid within 30 days, i.e., by 25 November 1984.
  3. Interpretation of Section 4(6) — forfeiture conditions:
    • Section 4(6) permits forfeiture of gratuity either partially (to the extent of damage or loss caused by an act, wilful omission or negligence causing damage to employer’s property) or wholly where termination is for riotous/disorderly conduct, acts of violence, or offences involving moral turpitude committed in the course of employment.
    • The court emphasised that Sub‑section (6) does not authorise indiscriminate withholding of gratuity; it prescribes specific situations under which forfeiture (partial or whole) can lawfully occur.
    • The court examined the respondent’s termination order (2 August 1984) and found it did not state grounds that fall within the fetters of Sub‑section (6)(a) or (6)(b) (i.e., the specified categories that permit forfeiture). Accordingly, the respondent could not lawfully withhold the gratuity on the basis of the pending enquiry or merely on account of alleged negligence/unauthorised absence.
  4. Provident fund and security deposit:
    • The court held the petitioner was also entitled to the provident fund as the respondent gave no specific lawful reason to withhold it.
    • As to the security deposit (Rs. 1,500), the court recognised the respondent’s right to recover amounts due. However, particulars of the claimed dues (totalling Rs. 17,378.77) were first raised in the respondent’s counter‑affidavit and had not been previously communicated; therefore the respondent could not retain the security deposit indefinitely without issuing notice and giving the petitioner an opportunity to be heard. If after such process amounts are found due, the respondent may adjust/recover them from the deposit.
  5. Remedies and timing:
    • Because the respondent failed to pay gratuity within the statutory period, the petitioner was entitled to compound interest at 9% per annum from 25 November 1984 until payment (the court directed payment of gratuity with interest compounded at 9% p.a. from that date).
    • The court directed the respondent to settle the provident fund within ten days from receipt of the order and to pay the gratuity with compound interest forthwith (interest computed from the statutory due date).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The court held that the respondent was not justified in withholding the petitioner’s gratuity under Section 4(6) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, and ordered payment of gratuity together with compound interest at 9% per annum from 25 November 1984 until payment. The respondent was directed to settle the provident fund within ten days. The respondent may recover any legitimately due amounts after issuing notice and giving the petitioner an opportunity to be heard, and may then adjust such amounts against the security deposit if properly determined. Costs were awarded (advocate's fee Rs. 500).

Implications:

  • The direct consequences are: (a) immediate payment of gratuity with compound interest at 9% p.a. from the statutory due date; (b) settlement of provident fund within ten days; and (c) procedural requirement on the respondent to issue notice and give a hearing before recovering alleged dues from the security deposit.
  • The opinion stresses that forfeiture under Section 4(6) is limited to the specific situations enumerated in the statute and cannot be used as a general ground to withhold gratuity (e.g., pending internal enquiries alone do not justify withholding).
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond its application of the statute to the facts; it addresses the parties' rights and obligations in the present case rather than announcing broader principle beyond statutory interpretation and application to these facts.

Costs awarded: Advocate's fee Rs. 500.

    B. Mohan Reddy v. Andhra Pradesh State Co-Operative Marketing Federation, Ltd.

    1. The petitioner was an employee of the respondent-federation. He was appointed as a sales assistant in September 1965. Later, he got promotion and in 1982, when he was working as manager (fertilisers) his services were terminated as he is said to have abstained from duty. By proceedings Rc. No. ME2.SM/2/84, dated 2 August 1984, the respondent terminated the services of the petitioner with effect from 1 December 1982, on the ground of unauthorised absence. As the terminal benefits like gratuity, provident fund and other fringe benefits were not paid to the petitioner, he sent a lawyer's notice on 5 June 1985, to the respondent. The respondent replied that an enquiry into pesticides affairs relating to the period when he worked as manager (fertilisers) was pending and hence his gratuity could not be released. In the circumstances, the petitioner filed this writ petition praying for a writ of mandamus to direct the respondent to settle his claim regarding payment of gratuity, provident fund, return of security bond and all other amounts payable to him under various statutes.

    2. The respondent has filed its counter-affidavit admitting that under the regulations of the MARKFED, the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (for short the Act), is made applicable to its employees, but it is stated that the amounts were not paid to the petitioner since his services were terminated on account of negligence and unauthorised absence amounting to misconduct and that he is not entitled to claim any gratuity under S. 4(6) of the Act. It is stated that the provident fund consists of the contributions of the employer and the employee. It is also admitted that in the security deposit account, the petitioner is having a sum of Rs. 1,500 to his credit. It is added that pursuant to the report of the accounts section of the federation, the following amounts are due from the petitioner:

    Rs. P. 1. Fertiliser Wing 265 00 2. Procurement and Marketing Division 2,681 90 3. General Division 14,431 87 Total 17,378 77

    3. It is further submitted that the general enquiry ordered in the matter of pesticides distribution relevant to the period in which the petitioner was the manager is pending for the exact determination of the liability; as such, the amounts under any of the heads cannot be paid to him. In the circumstances, it is prayed that the writ petition may be dismissed.

    4. Sri E.V Bhagiratha Rao, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the services of the petitioner were terminated in the year 1984, with effect from 1 December 1982, but the gratuity and other terminal benefits are not paid so far by the respondent which is arbitrary and oppressive and, therefore, the petitioner is entitled to an appropriate writ directing payment of these amounts. Sri Vilas V. Afzalpurkar, the learned counsel for the respondent-federation, submits that the services of the petitioner were terminated for wilful absence from duty and in view of S. 4(6) of the Act, the respondent is entitled to forfeit the amount of gratuity. He further submits that pursuant to the report of the accounts section of the federation, the petitioner is due to the respondent a sum of Rs. 17,378.77 which is liable to be deducted from any amounts payable to him. Therefore, the writ prayed for cannot be issued.

    5. The only question that requires consideration is whether the respondent is justified in withholding the gratuity under Sub-sec. (6) of S. 4 of the Act.

    6. The Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, is a beneficial legislation enacted with a view to provide payment of gratuity to employees engaged in factories, mines, oilfields, plantations, ports, railway companies, shops and other establishments. Under the regulations of the respondent-federation, the Act is applicable to the employees of the respondent. Now we may notice briefly the relevant provisions of the Act. Section 3 of the Act provides for the appointment of a controlling authority for the administration of the Act. Section 4 is the main stay of the Act. It contains six sub-sections. Sub-section (1) provides that gratuity shall be payable to an employee on the termination of his employment if he has rendered continuous service for not less than five years. The amount of gratuity is payable to an employee on his superannuation, or retirement or resignation, or on his death or disablement due to accident or disease. The first proviso prescribes that completion of continuous service of 5 years shall not be necessary where the termination of employment of an employee is due to death or disablement. The second proviso says that in case of death of an employee, the gratuity payable to him shall be paid to his nominee or, if no nomination has been made, the amount should be paid to his heirs; Sub-Sees. (2) and (4) prescribe method of computation of gratuity and Sub-sec. (3) mentions the ceiling on the amount of gratuity payable to an employee. However, Sub-sec. (5) says that nothing in S. 4 shall affect the right of an employee to receive better terms of gratuity under any award or agreement or contract with the employer. Sub-Section (6) empowers the employer to forfeit the gratuity. We shall revert to this sub-section presently. Section 6 enjoins that each employee who has completed one year of service should make nomination for the purpose of second proviso to Sub-sec. (1) of S. 4 and also deals with matters allied to it. Section 7(1) of the Act provides for the determination of the amount of gratuity by the employer on the application of an eligible person. The Act regards the right of the employee so inviolable that even without any application under S. 7(1), the employer is obliged to determine the amount of gratuity and to give a notice in writing to the person to whom the gratuity is payable and also to the controlling authority specifying the amount of gratuity so determined as soon as it becomes payable. The employer is also under an obligation to pay the amount of gratuity within such time as may be prescribed. In case of dispute regarding the amount of gratuity, the controlling authority is required to determine the amount payable under Sub-sec. (4) of S. 7 of the Act. The provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure in respect of specified' matters are made applicable to an enquiry under Sub-sec. (4) and the orders passed by the controlling authority is made, appealable. Section 8 requires the Collector to recover the amount of gratuity on a certificate issued to him by the controlling authority together with compound interest thereon at 9 per cent per annum from the date of expiry of the prescribed time as arrears of land revenue and pay the same to the person entitled thereto.

    7. Admittedly, in this case, the petitioner was appointed in September 1965, and his services were terminated in December 1982, as such he had put in more than five years of service. Under S. 4 of the Act, gratuity is payable on superannuation of the employee or on his retirement or resignation or on his death or disablement in any accident. The term “retirement” has been defined in S. 2(q) of the Act to mean termination of services of an employee otherwise than on superannuation. Therefore, termination of the services of the petitioner by the respondent for the alleged misconduct of unauthorised absence from duty amounts to retirement within the meaning of the Act and he is entitled to gratuity which is payable on the date of termination. As noticed above, Sub-sec. (2) of S. 7 has placed an obligation on the employer to give notice in writing duly specifying the amount of gratuity to the employee and the controlling authority, whether or not the employee applied for gratuity under Sub-sec. (1) of S. 7. In this case, the petitioner did apply to the respondent for settlement of gratuity, provident fund and for return of security deposit on 25 October 1984. His advocate, by notice, dated 5 June 1985, called upon the respondent to pay the gratuity amount payable to the petitioner within one week on receipt of notice. Instead of determining the amount of gratuity payable and paying the same, the respondent in his reply, dated 22 June 1985, took the stand that there was an enquiry into pesticides affairs relating to the period during which the petitioner worked as manager (pesticides) and so his gratuity could not be released till the completion of the same enquiry. Thereafter, on 28 June 1985, the petitioner's advocate sent another notice to the respondent stating that the plea was set up in its reply of 22 June 1985, with the mala fide intention to deliberately delay the payment of amounts to which the petitioner is entitled legally and at no point of time any notice was issued to him about any irregularity while he was the manager (pesticides) or subsequently.

    8. Before me, the stand of the respondent is sought to be justified under S. 4(6) of the Act. Sub-section (6) of S. 4 incorporates two situations in which the amount of gratuity can be forfeited either wholly or to the extent of the loss caused to the employer by the employee. It would be useful to extract here Sub-sec. (6) of S. 4 of the Act.

    “4(6) … (a) the gratuity of an employee, whose services have been terminated for any act, wilful omission or negligence causing any damage or loss to, or destruction of, property belonging to the employer, shall be forfeited to the extent of the damage or loss so caused;

    (b) the gratuity payable to an employee shall be wholly forfeited;

    (i) if the services of such employee have been terminated for his riotous or disorderly conduct or any other act of violence on his part; or

    (ii) if the services of such employee have been terminated for any act which constitutes an offence involving moral turpitude, provided that such offence is committed by him in the course of his employment.”

    9. From a plain reading of Sub-sec. (6) of S. 4, it is obvious that it does not authorise an employer to withhold the amount of gratuity for any reason. It provides for forfeiture of gratuity either partially or wholly, as the case may be, in the following situations:

    (i) where the services of an employee are terminated for any act, wilful omission or negligence which caused any damage or loss or destruction of property belonging to the employer, then only the employer can forfeit the amount of gratuity to the extent of the damage or loss so caused. In such a case the employer will have to specify the amount forfeited for the loss or damage caused by the employee from out of the amount determined under Sub-sec. (2) of S. 7.

    (ii) Where the services of an employee are terminated for riotous or disorderly conduct or any other act of violence on his part.

    (iii) Where the services of an employee are terminated for any act which constitutes an offence involving moral turpitude provided that such offence is committed by him in the course of his employment.

    10. It is only when an employee's services are terminated for any of the reasons mentioned in (ii) and (iii) above stated that the gratuity payable to him can be wholly forfeited.

    11. In this case, from a persual of the order of the respondent of 2 August 1984, terminating the services of the petitioner, it is clear that his services are not terminated for any of the reasons stated in (i) to (iii) (specified in Sub-secs. (6)(a) and (6)(b) of S. 4).

    12. From the above discussion, it follows that the respondent is not entitled to withhold the amount of gratuity either on the ground of pendency of alleged enquiry into the pesticides affair or for any other reason. The petitioner is, therefore, entitled to the amount of gratuity due to him under the Act.

    13. In so far as the amount of provident fund is concerned, the petitioner is also entitled to the same as no specific reason is given by the respondent for withholding the same amount.

    14. Regarding the security deposit of Rs. 1,500, it cannot be disputed that the respondent is entitled to recover any amounts due to it by the petitioner. In Para. 5 of the counter-affidavit, an amount of Rs. 17,378.77 is said to be due under different heads which are extracted above. Since the particulars of the amounts are mentioned for the first time in the counter-affidavit and were not stated earlier either in reply to the notice sent by the lawyer of the petitioner or otherwise, the respondent is not entitled to withhold the same for an indefinite period. However, it would be open to the respondent to issue notice to the petitioner for recovery of any amount due to it by him and after giving him an opportunity of being heard, determine the amount due adjust or recover the same from out of the security deposit.

    15. The respondent is not entitled to withhold either gratuity or provident fund amount of the petitioner either on the ground of pendency of enquiry or for recovery of some amounts said to be due by the petitioner. It has been noticed above that S. 8 of the Act ordains the Collector to recover the amount of gratuity with compound interest thereon at 9 per cent per annum from the date of expiry of the prescribed time. Rule 8 of the rules require that within 15 days of receipt of application for payment of gratuity, the employer shall issue a notice to the employee specifying the amount of gratuity payable, if the claim is found admissible, by fixing a date not being later than the thirtieth day after the date of receipt of the application for payment thereof. The petitioner sent the application for payment of gratuity on 25 October 1984, which was received by the respondent on 26 October 1984. Under Rule 8 of the rules, the gratuity should have been paid within 30 days of the receipt of the application, that is, on or before 25 November 1984. The petitioner has been deprived of the amount of gratuity for unjustifiable reasons. The petitioner is, therefore, entitled to compound interest on the amount of gratuity at the rate of 9 per cent per annum till the date of payment. Therefore, the respondent is directed to pay the amount of gratuity together with compound interest thereon at the rate of 9 per cent per annum from 25 November 1984, till the date of payment, and to settle the provident fund within a period of ten days from the date of receipt of this order.

    16. In the result, the writ petition is allowed with costs as indicated above. Advocate's fee Rs. 500.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    B. Mohan Reddy v. Andhra Pradesh State Co-Operative Marketing Federation, Ltd.
    (Jan 18, 1989)