Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Employees) Act No. 24 of 1971.7. Regulation 2 of Chapter III of the 1921 Act
  • Classes) Act 1994 (hereinafter referred to as the U.P Act
  • 5 Rule 6 of the Allahabad High Court Rules,
  • Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act.
  • Section 2(c)(iv) and (v) of Act.
  • provisions of U.P Act
  • Classes) Act 1994.3.
  • Education Act, 1921,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Employees) Act No. 24 of 1971.7. Regulation 2 of Chapter III of the 1921 Act
  • Classes) Act 1994 (hereinafter referred to as the U.P Act
  • 5 Rule 6 of the Allahabad High Court Rules,
  • Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act.
  • Section 2(c)(iv) and (v) of Act.
  • provisions of U.P Act
  • Classes) Act 1994.3.
  • Education Act, 1921,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This reference was made for an authoritative pronouncement on whether the rule of reservation for Scheduled Caste candidates (21% under U.P. Act No. 4 of 1994) and the operation of the roster can be applied in aided educational institutions (High School & Intermediate) for Class III (clerical grade) posts where the sanctioned cadre strength is less than five (specifically three posts).

The present proceedings arise from two writ petitions: Writ Petition No. 51617 of 2009, Heera Lal v. State of U.P., and Writ Petition No. 31716 of 2004, Satyavrat Nath v. State of U.P. In both matters the sanctioned cadre strength for clerical posts is three. Heera Lal challenged (i) appointment on a post claimed to be a promotion filled by a compassionate/direct recruitment avenue and (ii) his entitlement to benefit of reservation in promotion. Satyavrat Nath challenged the selection/approval of a candidate offered appointment as a Scheduled Caste candidate against a post that the petitioner contended could not have been reserved among the three sanctioned posts.

The Single Judge referred two questions to a larger Bench (order dated 7th October 2009 in Heera Lal) because of an apparent conflict between Division Bench decisions (Mahendra Kumar Gond on the one hand and Dr. Vishwajeet Singh / Smt. Pholpati Devi on the other) regarding applicability of the roster when cadre strength is fewer than five.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the roster in respect of reservation can be applied with regard to promotion in respect of Class III posts in Intermediate Colleges where the number of posts is less than five?
  2. Whether there is a conflict between the ratio of the two Division Bench judgments of Mahendra Kumar Gond and Dr. Vishwajeet Singh (and related decisions), and if so, which decision lays down the law correctly?

Arguments of the Parties

Arguments opposing applicability of the roster (counsel for parties opposing roster)

  • The roster and 21% reservation for Scheduled Castes can only be meaningfully applied when there are at least five posts in the cadre; with fewer than five (three posts in these cases), mathematical calculation of 21% cannot yield a reserved post.
  • Applying the roster imaginatively to create a reserved post where the statutory percentage cannot be mathematically accommodated would violate Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, and would be contrary to the Supreme Court authority in R.S. Garg v. State (2006) 6 SCC 430.
  • The ratio in Dr. Vishwajeet Singh's case was relied upon to contend that roster applicability requires a minimum of five posts; therefore roster should not be applied in the present facts.

State's / Respondent's Arguments (Sri Jaydeep Mathur, Additional Advocate General)

  • The Government Orders (notably the Government Order dated 8th March, 1973, and the Government Order dated 18th December, 1990) together with the provisions of U.P. Act No. 4 of 1994 and Section 3(7) save and permit application of reservation even where numerical strength is less than five; one of three posts must be offered to a reserved category candidate.
  • The Government Order of 8th March, 1973 explains treatment of vacancies (including carrying forward and running account) and, read with the running account formula, allows operation of the roster among three posts.
  • The decision in Mahendra Kumar Gond can be sustained by the said government order; the decision in Dr. Vishwajeet Singh concerned a different class of posts (Lecturers in Degree Colleges) and different rules, so there is no real conflict.
  • To accept the mathematical limitation urged by opponents would frustrate the object of beneficial reservation provisions, and Article 16(4-A) should be construed liberally to give effect to reservation.

Arguments / Contentions advanced by Petitioners in respective writs

  • Heera Lal: as a Class IV employee claiming promotion, contended that a compassionate appointment (a form of direct recruitment) should not have filled a post earmarked for promotion, and that he was entitled to be considered for reservation in promotion.
  • Satyavrat Nath: claimed appointment against a leave vacancy which became substantive and contended that a later appointment of a scheduled caste candidate could not have been made by applying reservation among only three sanctioned posts.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dr. Vishwajeet Singh v. State (Division Bench, 2009) The roster can be implemented only where there are five or more posts; roster inapplicable where cadre strength is less than five. The Court approved this decision as laying down the law correctly and relied on it to answer the reference; it held Mahendra Kumar Gond to be per incuriam to the extent it did not notice this line of authority.
Smt. Pholpati Devi v. Smt. Asha Jaiswal & Ors. (Division Bench, 2009) Supports the proposition that roster applicability requires a minimum number of posts (as referenced by Dr. Vishwajeet Singh). Noted by the Court as a part of the reasoning that roster should not be applied where cadre strength is less than five; decision was relied upon in approving Dr. Vishwajeet Singh.
Mahendra Kumar Gond v. D.I.O.S (2009 (6) ADJ 674) Earlier Division Bench decision relevant to Class III posts in Intermediate Colleges (interpreted by some to permit roster application). The Court held this decision to be per incuriam because it failed to notice the earlier Division Bench decisions (Dr. Vishwajeet Singh and Pholpati Devi) and did not correctly apply the law; Mahendra Kumar Gond is not approved.
R.S. Garg v. State (2006) 6 SCC 430 Where there is conflict between percentage of reservation and roster, the percentage fixed by statute prevails; reservation cannot exceed the quota fixed by law. Cited to support that imaginative application of roster to inflate reservation beyond statutory percentage would violate constitutional mandates (Articles 14 & 16); the Court relied on it to hold roster cannot be used to create reservation beyond permitted percentage.
Indira Sawhney v. Union of India (1992 Supp (3) SCC 217) Principle that overall reservation should not exceed 50% (landmark authority on reservation law). Referred to as the magnum opus on reservation; used to underscore limits on reservation and to support the proposition that reservation percentages are legally constrained.
R.K. Sabharwal v. State of Punjab (1995) 2 SCC 745 (Five-Judge Bench) Distinction between 'posts', 'vacancies' and 'cadre-strength'; percentage of reservation is worked out in relation to number of posts forming cadre-strength; vacancies are irrelevant to computation of percentage. Relied upon to explain that reservation percentage must be applied to posts (cadre strength) and not to vacancies; supported the court's mathematical/legal approach to the present problem.
Prabhash Chand Jain v. State of Haryana (1996) 8 SCC 105 Reiterates Sabharwal: reservation applies to posts/cadre strength, roster points are filled when vacancies occur; circulars operate in that sense. Cited to further elucidate that roster operation and percentage calculations must be understood in relation to posts/cadre strength and vacancies being filling events for roster points.
Rana Pratap Singh v. State of U.P (1995) ACJ 200; Official Liquidator v. Dayanand (2008) 10 SCC 1 Principles on when matters should be referred to larger Benches / precedential value of decisions. Cited to justify that the Single Judge correctly referred the question to a larger Bench for authoritative pronouncement given conflicting Division Bench decisions; these authorities supported the procedural step.
New English High School Association, Nagpur v. Baldev (2008) 5 E & S C 3110 (Bombay High Court Full Bench) Full Bench decision on reservation matters (specifics not elaborated in the opinion). The Court noted this authority but observed that in view of the Supreme Court decisions relied upon, this Bombay High Court Full Bench need not be further considered for the present reference.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by reference to the statutory and regulatory framework (U.P. Act No. 4 of 1994; Chapter III of the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921; Regulation 2 regarding sources of recruitment; Government Orders dated 8th March, 1973 and 18th December, 1990; and the Payment of Salaries Act No. 24 of 1971) and by careful consideration of relevant judicial authorities.

  1. The referring Single Judge identified an apparent conflict between Division Bench decisions: Mahendra Kumar Gond vis-à-vis Dr. Vishwajeet Singh and Pholpati Devi regarding applicability of the roster where cadre strength is less than five. The Court accepted that this created a need for authoritative clarification and that the referral to a larger Bench was appropriate (citing Rana Pratap Singh and Official Liquidator v. Dayanand).
  2. Factual-mathematical context: the sanctioned cadre strength in the institutions at issue is three posts. Regulation 2 indicates recruitment via two sources (50% promotion and 50% direct recruitment), and where fractions arise the fraction may be rounded (example given: 1.5 read as 2 promotions out of 3 posts).
  3. The Court examined the competing contentions: opponents argued that 21% reservation for Scheduled Castes cannot be mathematically applied to three posts and that attempting to do so via roster would exceed the statutory percentage and offend Articles 14 and 16; the State argued government orders and Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act permit the benefit and allow running account/roster application.
  4. The Court relied on fundamental authorities on reservation: Indira Sawhney's principle that overall reservation must not exceed 50% and R.S. Garg's ruling that where statutory percentage conflicts with roster, the percentage prevails. The Court emphasized that reservation cannot be inflated beyond the quota fixed by law.
  5. Applying R.K. Sabharwal and Prabhash Chand Jain, the Court reiterated that percentage of reservation is to be computed with reference to posts comprising the cadre-strength (and not vacancies), so that a minimum numerical threshold is material to whether a reserved post can exist within the cadre.
  6. Turning to the Government Order dated 8th March, 1973, the Court found that it does not mandate reservation of one post where total cadre strength is less than five; the Order discusses treatment of vacancies (including where there are only two vacancies in a year) but does not create a principle to override the statutory percentage or to require reservation where the statutory calculation does not permit it.
  7. Consequently, the Court held that the operation of the roster and running account to create a reserved post in cadres of fewer than five posts would amount to creating reservation rather than implementing a statutory reservation, which is impermissible. The roster is a tool to implement reservation but cannot be used to manufacture reservation beyond statutory limits.
  8. On the conflict of authorities, the Court concluded that Mahendra Kumar Gond failed to notice the earlier Division Bench decisions (Dr. Vishwajeet Singh and Pholpati Devi) and therefore was per incuriam to the extent of addressing the present question; the Court therefore did not approve Mahendra Kumar Gond and instead approved the reasoning in Dr. Vishwajeet Singh.
  9. The Court observed that Article 16(4-A) is enabling but cannot be interpreted to confer a right to reservation beyond limits laid down by legislature (U.P. Act No. 4 of 1994). Mathematical reality and legal principles together disallow applying roster to create reservation in cadres of less than five posts.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The reference was answered as follows:

  • Question No. 1: Answered in the negative — either in cases of promotion or direct recruitment, the rule of reservation providing for 21% reservation to Scheduled Castes under U.P. Act No. 4 of 1994, as applicable to aided educational institutions, cannot be pressed into service where the number of posts in the cadre is less than five.
  • Question No. 2: The Division Bench decision in Mahendra Kumar Gond v. State of U.P. (2009 (6) ADJ 674) was rendered without taking notice of the earlier Division Bench judgments in Dr. Vishwajeet Singh and Smt. Pholpati Devi and is not approved; the Court approved the decision in Dr. Vishwajeet Singh as laying down the law correctly on the issue.

Implications (direct consequences on the parties and legal application):

  • The roster and running-account operation for implementing 21% Scheduled Caste reservation may be applied only where the cadre comprises five or more posts; in cadres of fewer than five (e.g., three as in these matters), the statutory percentage cannot be implemented to reserve a post and the roster cannot be used to create reservation.
  • The Government Order dated 8th March, 1973 does not have the operation to mandate reservation of a post where the total cadre strength is less than five; the Court rejected the State's contention insofar as it sought to rely on that Order to require reservation among three posts.
  • The Mahendra Kumar Gond precedent is disapproved for the purposes of the question referred; the Court's approval of Dr. Vishwajeet Singh supplies the authoritative position that roster operation requires a minimum cadre strength of five posts for 21% reservation to be operationally meaningful and lawful.
  • No broader alteration of the principle that statutory reservation percentages prevail over roster mechanics was made; the decision confirms limitation rather than creating an expanded entitlement. The papers are to be transmitted to the concerned bench for disposal in accordance with this pronouncement.

Decision dated: 9th July, 2010. Bench: A.P. Sahi, J. (reference and reasons set out in the opinion).

    Heera Lal v. State Of U.P And Others

    A.P Sahi, J.:— This reference has been made for an authoritative pronouncement on the issue of applying the rule of reservation for schedule caste candidates in aided educational institutions (High School & Intermediate) in promotion and direct recruitment against Class III posts (clerical grade) to the extent of 21% as provided for under the statute and the application of the roster through a mathematical calculation integrated with legal implications where the number of posts in a sanctioned cadre is less than five.

    2. It entails an adjudication on the questions posed by one of us (Hon'ble A.P Sahi, J.) vide order dated 7th October, 2009 passed in Heera Lal v. State of U.P, reported in 2009 (10) ADJ Pg. 654 Paras 9 to 12, quoted below:—

    “9:…..A perusal of the said two Division Bench judgements in the case of Vishwajeet Singh (Supra) and Smt Pholpati (Supra) indicate that the applicability of the roster can be implemented wherever there are five or more than five posts to be filled up where reservation is being claimed under the Uttar Pradesh Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and other Backward Classes) Act 1994.

    3. The said decision clearly lays down : that there has to be existence of more than five posts for the purpose of applying roster otherwise it would violate the law in Indira Sahani's Case as reservation will then be in excess of 50%. Having perused the ratio of the two division Bench judgements it appears that the same has not been noticed in the decision in Mahendra Kumar Gond's case. The decision in the case of Dr. Vishwajeet was rendered on 20th April, 09 whereas decision in the case of Pholpati Devi was rendered prior to that.

    10. Both these decisions appear to have escaped the notice of the court and the applicability of the roster in the situation where there are only three posts available.

    11. In this view of the ratio laid down in the two judgements of Dr Vishwajeet Singh and Smt. Pholpati Devi (Supra) there appears to be a contradictory position indicated in Mahendra Kumar Gond's case and as such the same deserves to be resolved by reference to a larger Bench.

    12. Accordingly, in exercise of the powers conferred under Chapter 5 Rule 6 of the Allahabad High Court Rules, the following questions deserve to be referred to a larger Bench, in view of the position indicated above.

    1. Whether the roster in respect of reservation can be applied with regard to the promotion in respect of class class III posts in Intermediate College, where the number of posts is less than five?

    2. Whether there is a conflict between the ratio of the two Division Bench judgements of Mahendra Kumar Gond (Supra) and Dr. Vishwajeet Singh (Supra) as referred to herein above, and if so, then which of the decisions lay down the law correctly?

    4. The reference has to be answered in the context of the provisions contained in U.P Act No. 4 of 1994 read with the Government Orders dealt with hereinafter and Chapter III of the Regulations framed under the U.P Intermediate Education Act, 1921, in order to specify as to how and in what circumstances, the roster for implementing the rule of reservation has to be applied.

    5. It is undisputed that Uttar Pradesh Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and other Backward Classes) Act 1994 (hereinafter referred to as the U.P Act No. 4 of 1994) applies in relation to appointment on posts in Institution recognized and governed by the 1921 Act receiving grant-in-aid from State funds. The admitted position in the case at hand is in relation to such a post for which aid is admissible and is under receipt of such grant as defined in Section 2(c)(iv) and (v) of Act. Members of the Schedule Caste are entitled for the benefit of reservation against 21% of the posts.

    6. The specific case which has given rise to the reference in both the cases that are before us, namely Writ Petition No. 51617 of 2009, Heera Lal v. State of U.P and Writ Petition No. 31716 of 2004, Satyavrat Nath v. State of U.P, is that the sanctioned strength of the post of clerks (Class III posts) are three, and in such a situation whether one of the posts could be offered to a candidate of the Scheduled Caste Category by way of reservation. The said three sanctioned posts form the total cadre strength in both the Institutions which are governed by the provisions of the 1921 Act and the Regulations framed thereunder. The Institutions where the claim is staked are privately managed and receiving grant-in-aid from State funds. The financial approval and sanction of the post in question and disbursement of salary to the employees is governed by the statutory provisions of Uttar Pradesh High School and Intermediate Colleges (Payment of Salaries of Teachers and other Employees) Act No. 24 of 1971.

    7. Regulation 2 of Chapter III of the 1921 Act makes a provision through two sources of recruitment to the said cadre, fifty per cent by way of promotion and the rest by direct recruitment. The provision further clarifies that if the fraction is either exactly half or more than half in calculation of the percentage, then the same shall be read as one complete unit, and as in the instant cases where there are three posts, the fraction of 1.5 will be read as two and therefore two posts have to be filled up by way of promotion.

    8. In the case of Heera Lal the claim is by way of promotion. Heera Lal being a Class IV employee has set up a challenge to the compassionate appointment of the respondent no. 6 in Writ Petition No. 51617 of 2009 on two grounds. Firstly that the post to filled by promotion could not be filled by appointing a dependant of a deceased employee under the compassionate appointment Rules which is a source of direct recruitment, and secondly the petitioner was entitled to be given the benefit of reservation while considering promotion. The petition was entertained and the reference has been made keeping in view the ratio of the decision in the case of Mahendra Kumar Gond v. D.I.O.S reported in 2009 (6) ADJ 674 and the view expressed by another Division Bench in relation to the applicability of the roster in the case of Dr. Vishwajit Singh v. State reported in 2009 U.P.L.B.E.C (2) 1443 which in turn refers to another bench judgment in the case of Smt. Pholpati Devi v. Smt. Asha Jaiswal & Ors., reported in 2009 ADJ (2) Pg. 90.

    9. The second case which is before us, Satyvrat Nath v. State, Writ Petition No. 31716 of 2004 is a matter where the petitioner claims to have been appointed against a leave vacancy of one of the clerks of the Institution in the year 1999. His further claim is that the vacancy subsequently became substantively vacant, with the retirement of the incumbent who was on leave, in the year 2005 and therefore, he should be granted approval on the said post as he had been selected by a duly constituted Selection Committee. During the pendency of the writ petition an amendment application has been moved challenging the fresh selection and appointment of the respondent no. 6 Sachin Kumar who has been offered appointment as a scheduled caste candidate. It is contended that he could not have been given the said benefit as no reservation could have been applied amongst the three posts sanctioned in the Institution.

    10. In the aforesaid background the reference focuses on the issue relating to the mathematics and calculation of the applicability of the rule of reservation for extending benefit to scheduled caste candidates by applying the roster. The two cases therefore are confined to the applicability of the rule of reservation for scheduled castes and the roster to be applied in an Institution where the sanctioned strength of the cadre is three. The first in relation to promotion, whereas the second is of direct recruitment.

    11. It has been pointed out by the learned counsel at the bar that a Special Leave Petition against the decision in the case of Dr. Vishwajeet Singh is pending before the apex Court. It is also stated that no interim orders have been passed therein so far. Accordingly, we have proceeded to hear the matter noticing the same.

    12. We have been assisted by Sri R.C Dwivedi and Sri Lalji Pandey for the private parties and Sri Jaydeep Mathur learned Additional Advocate General assisted by Sri M.C Chaturvedi learned Chief Standing Counsel at Allahabad and Sri L.P Gupta learned Chief Standing Counsel at Lucknow for the State.

    13. The main plank of the argument on behalf of those opposing the application of the roster, rests on the ratio of the Division Bench decision in the case of Dr. Vishwajeet Singh (supra), contending that there is no occasion for the applicability of the rule of reservation with the help of any roster for scheduled caste candidates, as the percentage of reservation for scheduled castes which is 21%, envisages the existence of a minimum of total number of five posts in the cadre strength for calculating and applying the said percentage. It is urged by them that 21% can be calculated only if there are a minimum number of five posts for offering 21% reservation as it is only then that one post can be reserved for scheduled castes. It is submitted that if the posts are less than five, as in the present case which is three, the mathematical percentage as prescribed i.e 21% is beyond calculation and there cannot be a fraction available amongst three posts for applying the said percentage.

    14. Further, in view of the decision of the apex court in the case of R.S Garg v. State, reported in (2006) 6 SCC 430, any such calculation by imaginatively applying the roster would be contrary to the constitutional mandate of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. It is submitted that whether the post is to be filled by promotion or by direct recruitment, being the two sources of recruitment, the aforesaid rule of reservation for offering 21 per cent of the posts cannot be pressed into service as the posts are less than five. Certain other judgments have also been cited which shall be discussed herein after.

    15. Replying to the aforesaid submissions Sri Jaydeep Mathur learned Additional Advocate General placed before the Court, the Government Order dated 8th March, 1973, the Government Order dated 18th December, 1990 and the provisions of U.P Act No. 4 of 1994 and contended that one of the posts, out of three, has to be offered to a reserved category candidate, and bereft of the percentage of reservation as prescribed, the Government Order dated 8th March, 1973 by its own operation extends the said benefit and is also saved under Section 3(7) of the 1994 Act. He submits that the provisions of the said Government Order are in relation to reservation and are saved by virtue of provisions aforesaid being in addition to the reservation provided under the Act. He submits that keeping in view the running account formula the roster can be applied even amongst three posts and the benefit of promotion in reservation is available under the Government Order dated 18th December, 1990. Sri Mathur contends that in view of the aforesaid position there is apparently no conflict between the decisions in the case of Mahendra Kumar Gond and Dr. Vishwajeet Singh (supra). He submits that the ratio in the case of Mahendra Kumar Gond can be saved by applying the aforesaid Government Order of 8th March, 1973 and which was not the issue in the case of Dr. Vishwajeet Singh. He submits that in Dr. Vishwajeet Singh's case the matter related to appointment on the post of Lecturers in Degree Colleges and the calculation made therein was in accordance with the rules that were applicable for the purpose of appointment of such Lecturers and therefore, in the absence of any such real conflict no such dispute requires to be resolved. He submits that as a matter of fact it is the rule of per incuriam which can be said to be at best attracted inasmuch as the referring order indicates that the decision in the cases of Dr. Vishwajeet Singh and Smt. Pholpati Devi escaped the notice of the Court while proceeding to decide the case of Mahendra Kumar Gaur.

    16. While advancing his submission in respect of question no. 1, Sri Mathur took us through the details of the clauses contained in the Government Order dated 8th March, 1973 and submitted that even where the posts are less than five the rule of reservation for giving benefit of reservation to a scheduled caste candidate is available. He therefore submits that the reference be answered accordingly keeping in view the constitutional mandate for the benefit of reservation. The contention is that the very object of a beneficial piece of legislation would be frustrated if the mathematical calculation as suggested is accepted. He submits that the enabling mandate of the Constitution under Article 16(4-A) in particular cannot be bound or circumscribed by any tool of interpretation, and that the provisions of U.P Act No. 4 of 1994 do not prohibit the benefit of reservation even if the numerical figure is less than five.

    17. Before proceeding to delve into the substantive issue of the mathematical calculation in relation to the applicability of the roster, it would be appropriate to clarify the position in relation to the submission made by Sri Mathur on the second question regarding the conflict between the two Division Bench judgments in the case of Mahendra Kumar Gond and the decision in the case of Dr. Vishwajeet Singh which has approved the reasoning given in the case of Pholpati Devi.

    18. The conflict which was pointed out in the referring order was in effect to resolve the method of calculation for applying the rule of reservation where the cadre strength of the post in question is less than five. The referring order clearly recites that there is a contradictory position presumed in Mahendra Kumar Gond's case without noticing the judgment in the case of Dr. Vishwajeet Singh (supra) and the case of Pholpati Devi v. Asha Jaiswal (supra). In essence this court noticed the aforesaid anomaly and therefore it is in the aforesaid sense that the reference was made to resolve the said “conflict”. The same has arisen on account of the position as indicated above and Sri Mathur is therefore right in his submission that the decision in the case of Mahendra Kumar Gond to that extent is per incuriam.

    19. In our opinion, it was therefore necessary for the learned Single Judge to have referred the matter to a larger bench for an authoritative pronouncement as to the correct position of law. This was also necessary as the learned Single Judge was bound by the Division Bench judgment in the case of Mahendra Kumar Gond (supra) which was directly in issue in relation to a Class III post of an Intermediate College governed by the 1921 Act and also arose out of a claim against one post out of the total cadre strength of three posts in the Institution. The learned Single Judge, therefore, faced with the aforesaid Division Bench judgment in the present cases as well, was obliged to refer the matter after noticing the two earlier Division Bench judgments in the case of Dr. Vishwajeet Singh (supra) and Smt. Pholpati Devi. This is in consonance with the law enunciated by our Full Bench in the case of Rana Pratap Singh v. State of U.P, reported in (1995) Allahabad Civil Journal 200 and also in view of the latest Supreme Court decision in the case of Official Liquidator v. Dayanand, reported in (2008) 10 SCC 1. Without delving on this any further, we may add that the answer to the first question would either way resolve the issue, and as such question no. 2 stands answered accordingly.

    20. Coming to the substantive part of the issue as referred to in question no. 1, Bertrand Russel (1872-1970) in his work Mysticism and Logic (1918) opined that mathematics could be defined as the subject in which we never know what we are talking about, nor whether what we are saying is true. This impression about the subject should not disillusion us for we have to specify the calculation, and clarify the discrepancy in the logic, or the absence of consideration of such logic in the case of Mahendra Kumar Gond in the light of the decisions of the earlier Division Benches. This is necessary in order to clarify the law which would help in deciding a large number of such pending matters on this issue and also for future guidance in relation to such appointments. This will obviously reduce litigation, the consequence would be what Stephen Hawkins has said in “A brief History of Time (1988)” that “someone told me that each equation included in the book would halve the sales”.

    21. The magnum opus on the issue of reservation by our courts is the case of Indira Sawhney v. Union of India, reported in 1992 Supplement (3) SCC Pg. 217. It has been categorically laid down that overall reservation should not be allowed to exceed 50%.

    22. In the present case, the rule of reservation as contained in U.P Act No. 4 of 1994 if applied then out of three posts, if one of the posts is given to the scheduled caste category, the reservation would exceed 21% and reach 33%. It would, therefore, violate the maximum permissible limit as contained in the statutory provision. The Government Order dated 8th March, 1973 can be saved only to the extent of its applicability which in our opinion does not mandate the reservation of one post even if the total number of posts is less than five. Clause (2) of the said Government order is in relation to the availability of vacancies to be filled up by way of promotion, where it is provided that if in the year of recruitment, the number of vacancies available under the reserved category or the category of carry forward vacancies is only two, then in that event one of the vacancies can be treated to be of the reserved category. If only one vacancy is available in the year of recruitment in the said category then the same shall be treated as unreserved. The relevant clause is quoted below:—

    23. Having carefully examined the said Government Order dated 8th March, 1973 we do not find any such provision for applying the rule of reservation for schedule caste in cases where the total cadre strength is less than five. The Government Order does not enunciate any such principle which can be treated to be in addition to the prescription of the outer limit of percentage of reservation for scheduled castes as provided for in the 1994 Act.

    24. The said Government Order only explains the status of the vacancies if the number of vacancies is only two.

    25. The issue relating to the distinction between the words post, vacancy and cadre strength has been clearly explained in the decision of R.K Sabharwal v. State of Punjab, reported in (1995) 2 SCC 745. Paragraph 6 is quoted herein below:

    “The expressions ‘posts’ and ‘vacancies’, often used in the executive instructions providing for reservations, are rather problematical. The word ‘post’ means an appointment, job, office or employment. A position to which a person is appointed. ‘Vacancy’ means an unoccupied post or office. The plain meaning of the two expressions make it clear that there must be a ‘post’ in existence to enable the ‘vacancy’ to occur. The cadre-strength is always measured by the number of posts comprising the cadre. Right to be considered for appointment can only be claimed in respect of a post in a cadre. As a consequence the percentage of reservation has to be worked out in relation to the number of posts which form the cadre-strength. The concept of ‘vacancy’ has no relevance in operating the percentage of reservation.”

    26. The position was further explained in the case of Prabhash Chand Jain v. State of Haryana, reported in (1996) 8 SCC 105. Paragraph 8 is quoted herein below:

    “The last submission made by the learned counsel for the appellants and the respondent-State was that the recent judgment dated 10.2.1995 of the Constitution Bench in R.K Sabharwal v. State of Punjab supports their contention, inasmuch as, according to them, as per the said circular, the reservation policy is to be applied to the posts and not to the vacancies. We find no such observation made in the said judgment. In fact, in the very beginning, the Court has stated that the expressions ‘posts’ and ‘vacancies’ are often used in the executive instructions providing for reservation, problematically. The Court has then gone on to explain that the word ‘post’ means the position to which the person is to be appointed. The vacancy means a non-occupied post or office. The plain meaning of the two expressions makes it clear that there must be posts to enable the vacancies to occur. The cadre strength is always measured by the number of posts comprising the cadre and the right to be considered for appointment can only be claimed in respect of a post in a cadre. As a consequence, the percentage of reservation has to be worked out in relation to the number of posts which form the cadre strength. The concept of vacancy has no relevance in operating the percentage of reservation. The Court has then explained that when all the roster points in the cadre are filled, the required percentage of reservation in post is achieved. The roster point in a cadre can be filled in only when the vacancies occur and not otherwise. Hence the observations made in the said judgment relating to the percentage of reservation in posts has to be understood in that sense. It is not the contention of the respondent-employees belonging to the reserved category that the percentage of reservation is to be calculated dehors the number of posts. However, while filling the posts, it is the vacancies which have to be taken into consideration and these vacancies have to be filled in, according to the roster points. That is precisely what is sought to be done in the present case by the circular of 9.2.1979”.

    27. The decision in R.K Sabharwal's case is a five judges pronouncement which still holds the field. The question of giving the benefit of reservation in excess of the percentage of quota of reservation has been put to rest by the decision in the case of R.S Garg v. State of U.P, reported in (2006) 6 SCC 430. Paragraph 40 which is quoted herein below:

    “We are not concerned with the reasonableness or otherwise of the percentage of reservation. 21% of the posts have been reserved for the Scheduled Tribe (sic Caste) candidates by the State itself. It, thus, cannot exceed the quota. If is not disputed that in the event of any conflict between the percentage of reservation and the roster, the former shall prevail. Thus, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case, the roster to fill up the posts by reserved category candidates, after every four posts, in our considered opinion, does not meet the constitutional requirements”.

    28. The decision of the Full Bench of the Bombay High Court in the case of New English High School Association, Nagpur v. Baldev, reported in (2008) 5 Education and Service Cases 3110 need not be gone into as in view of the decisions of the Apex Court referred to herein above, the rule of reservation, in our opinion, cannot be pressed into service on the facts of the present reference.

    29. However, even assuming that one such post can exist by applying the rule of necessity and the principle of rounding off, the rule of reservation of 21% in less than five posts cannot be implemented. Law is also acknowledged as a technical dress. The prescription of law therefore cannot be designed through an interpretive tool to make it look upside down. Neither the Government Order dated 8th March, 1973 or the subsequent orders nor the provisions of U.P Act No. 4 of 1994 project and support any such proposition as advanced on behalf of the State. The mathematical calculation prohibits anything further, and so do the legal principles as noticed above. The game of digits and numbers cannot be taken further even by employing the intuitive mind of the great mathematician Ramanujam nor can such a view be made possible through the best of forensic legacy of law.

    30. The rule of roster and the concept of a running account of the roster therefore would commence only if there are five or more posts for extending the benefit of 21% reservation in favour of the scheduled caste category. A numerically less strength figure, below the required number, would therefore not allow the roster to be operated, as a roster is there to implement the rule of reservation and not a tool to create reservation. As noticed in the judgments of the Apex Court that in the event of any any conflict between the percentage of reservation and the applicability of the roster, the former would prevail. Thus, in no event can the percentage of reservation be inflated or enhanced by the illusionary or imaginative application of the rule of roster. If such interpretation as suggested by the State is given then the same would amount to a non-constructive existence of a miscalculated proof in the words of the famous German Mathematician Leopold Kronecker (1823-91). In legal terms this would violate the mandate of the constitution and in cases of promotion it would not be in conformity with the same.

    31. It is to be remembered that Article 16(4-A) is an enabling provision and in view of the said interpretation the same cannot be construed to confer an absolute right of reservation even beyond the limits prescribed under the law framed by the legislature, namely U.P Act No. 4 of 1994. We may clarify that the roster loses its capability of application where the rule of reservation itself cannot be pressed into service keeping in view the numerical strength of the cadre in such matters as in the present case which is less than five. To do so would be a miscalculation in raw mathematics and the fine tenets of law. The argument of the State if accepted would result in unconstitutionality and an illogical acceptance of the rule of reservation. This would also satisfy the test of reasonableness as arithmetical calculations are also one of the logical foundations for reason. The calculation cannot be violated as explained above and if that is done then it would be unreasonable as well as unconstitutional.

    32. The statutory position as contained in U.P Act No. 4 of 1994 completely takes care of the situation and the impact of the maximum reservation percentage provided for therein cannot be nullified through an interpretation which is neither supported by any Government Order, Rule or judicial pronouncement. The case of Mahendra Kumar Gond (supra) did not decide the question which has been raised in relation to the calculation of the minimum number of posts to be available for applying the rule of reservation.

    33. In view of the aforesaid conclusions, we find ourselves in full agreement with the view taken in Dr. Vishwajeet Singh's case and we hold that the decision in the case of Mahendra Kumar Gond (supra) is per incuriam and even otherwise does not apply the law correctly. We further reject the contention of the State in relation to the issue involved and the submissions raised for the applicability of the Government Order dated 8th March, 1973.

    34. There may be cases where there is a rule making provision for different sources of recruitment within the same cadre, then reservation has to be applied to the posts available for being filled up in accordance with the source of recruitment. This issue may arise in the context where a candidate is not available for filling up the post by way of promotion and the same has to be diverted to be filled up by direct recruitment. Such a situation will arrive in cases where the number of posts may be five or more so as to make the rule of reservation applicable. Taking for instance were there are say 8 posts in a cadre and the rule is, as presently involved, namely that 50% posts have to be filled up by way of promotion, in that event four posts have to be filled up by promotion and four by direct recruitment. The rule of reservation for appointment by way of promotion is availably only to scheduled castes in the State of U.P and no such rule is available for other backward categories. They are entitled to the benefit of reservation only in the process of direct recruitment. In the example given above where four posts out of eight are to be filled up by direct recruitment one post will have to be given to the other backward category keeping in view the 27% mandate of reservation in favour of such category under the 1994 Act. Against four posts of promotion quota, reservation to a scheduled caste category cannot be granted as there as to be a minimum of five posts for applying the 21% reservation for promotion. In a given situation where no other candidate of any category is available for promotion against the four posts, then such a vacancy to be filled up by promotion may have to be carried over for direct recruitment. This would bring about a change of strength in the source of recruitment thus fluctuating the strength of the post available by direct recruitment. A scheduled caste candidate would therefore, get the benefit of reservation if the cadre strength is increased to five for direct recruitment, even though the same candidate would not get the benefit of reservation if the promotion quota of 50% is adhered to. It would be appropriate to point out that taking a case where there are five posts for being filled up by promotion and five by direct recruitment in the cadre then in such an event the rule of reservation to the extent of 21% in both the sources can be conveniently made applicable without disturbing the ratio in either of the sources.

    35. In such a situation wherever the issue of reservation arises one will have to keep in mind the strength of the cadre as also the source of recruitment which is governed by a statutory rule. The rule providing for the source of recruitment therefore will have to be balanced in such situations. The fluctuating strength of a cadre will therefore have to be kept in mind for applying the rule of reservation.

    36. In view of the reasons in support of the conclusions drawn herein above our answer to the questions posed are as follows:—

    1. Question No. 1 is answered in the negative holding that either in cases of promotion or direct recruitment, the rule of reservation providing for 21% reservation to scheduled castes under U.P Act No. 4 of 1994 as applicable to aided educational institutions cannot be pressed into service where the number of posts in the cadre is less than five.

    2. The decision in the case of Mahendra Kumar Gond v. State of U.P reported in 2009 (6) ADJ Pg. 674 having been rendered without taking notice of the two Division Bench judgments in the case of Dr. Vishwajeet Singh (supra) and Smt. Pholpati Devi (supra) is not approved. The Judgments of Dr. Vishwajeet Singh is hereby approved as laying down the law correctly on the issue raised herein.

    37. Let the papers be now transmitted before the concerned bench for proceeding to decide the matter in accordance with the pronouncement made herein above.

    38. 9th July, 2010

    39. Sahu

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Heera Lal v. State Of U.P And Others
    (Jul 9, 2010)